A practitioner’s guide · 43 methods · 180 situations

The Coaching Methods Field Guide

A practical map of the moves a coach can make and the situations that call for them: what to notice, what to ask, what to avoid, and how to turn a good conversation into real change.

5families
43methods
180situations
9situation groups
5coach inner-game practices
The topic is a door. These are keys. Use the one that opens more awareness, not the one that makes the coach look clever. Follow the energy in the room, not the toolkit.

Start here

Coaching is a conversation that helps a person see their situation more clearly and choose what to do about it. The coach doesn’t supply the answers. Instead, they use well-chosen questions, careful listening and a few structured techniques to help the client find answers they will actually act on.

This guide collects 43 coaching methods and 180 situations that come up again and again in professional coaching. It is written for anyone who coaches: new coaches learning the craft, managers who coach their teams, HR and learning professionals, and experienced coaches who want a sharper map of what they already do.

The central idea is simple. First notice what is happening in the room, then choose the move that fits it. Most coaching goes wrong not because the coach asked a bad question, but because they asked a good question at the wrong moment.

What you’ll find

  • 5 families that follow the shape of a coaching conversation
  • 43 methods, each explained the same way, in ten parts
  • 180 situations in 9 groups, each on a full card
  • 5 practices for the coach’s own inner game

Three ways to use this guide

To learn

Read “How the pieces relate” and “The spine of the hour” first. Then learn the ten starter methods below, one or two a week, trying each in real conversations before adding more.

Before a session

Think about the client you’re about to see. Find the situation that sounds most like them in the Situation Atlas and read its card: what’s underneath, what to avoid, and questions to have ready.

After a session

Look up the method you used. Read “Where it gets stuck”, “Coach mistakes” and “Client traps”. Ask yourself what you’d do differently. This works well in supervision too.

Ten methods to learn first

  1. 1 Contract the topic firstAgree what the session is for before going anywhere.
  2. 2 Expand the topicTurn a polished story into real material.
  3. 3 And what else?Keep asking until the obvious list runs out.
  4. 4 Scale the topicTurn a vague feeling into a number you can move by one.
  5. 7 Slow down: reflect, pause, follow heatReflect, pause and follow the energy. Presence is the intervention.
  6. 12 ReframeOffer a different meaning for the same facts.
  7. 21 Imagine a preferred futurePicture the wanted future before generating options.
  8. 36 Generate options then one experimentWiden the choices, then commit to one small test.
  9. 38 Harvest a just-landed insightStop and anchor an insight instead of asking more.
  10. 40 Sort controlSort what is theirs, shared, or not theirs to move.

How to read a page

A method page

Starts with a short definition and a quick card (when to reach for it, the move, a watch-out and four questions). Then come ten parts: what it is, the client’s context, the coach’s options, how it works, where it gets stuck and how to move it forward, questions, the situations it fits, coach mistakes and client traps, plus three worked problems.

A situation card

Shows what is happening and the recommended move at a glance. Open it for what you’ll see in the room, what the client might say, what’s underneath, questions to ask, what to avoid, examples, a short sample exchange, signs it’s working, a look-alike situation not to confuse it with, and the methods that handle it.

Codes

Methods are numbered 1 to 43. Situations use S-codes: S3.9 is situation 9 in group 3 (The mind’s frame).

Key terms

Coaching
A conversation that helps someone think, decide and act on their own goals. The coach asks more than tells; the client owns the answers.
Client
The person being coached.
Sponsor
The person or organisation paying for or requesting the coaching, often the client’s manager or HR.
Contracting
Agreeing what the coaching (or a single session) is for, how it will work and what is confidential. Done at the start and revisited often.
Session / engagement
A session is one conversation. An engagement is the whole series, from first meeting to ending.
Three-way meeting
A meeting between client, sponsor and coach to agree goals and review progress.
Reframe
Offering a different, equally true meaning for the same facts.
Externalizing
Talking about a pattern as something the client has, not something they are.
Ambivalence
Wanting and not wanting a change at the same time. Normal, not a sign of weakness.
Change talk
The client’s own words in favour of change. Coaches listen for it and draw more of it out.
Polarity
An ongoing tension between two goods (for example stability and change) that is managed over time rather than solved once.
Altitude
The level a conversation is working at: story, feeling, belief, identity, system or experiment.
Experiment
A small, dated action the client chooses to test something in real life.
Holding space
Staying present, calm and unhurried so the client can think and feel without being rushed.
Supervision
Regular reflective conversations where a coach reviews their own practice with an experienced supervisor.
Referral
Pointing a client to another professional (therapist, doctor, HR, legal) when a topic is beyond coaching.
A note on scope. This is a guide for ordinary professional coaching. It is not a diagnostic manual and not therapy. If a client is in crisis, at risk, or describing a clinical problem, their safety and a referral to the right professional come first. Always follow your professional body’s code of ethics and any safeguarding rules that apply to you.

The conversation arc: five families

The 43 methods sit inside five families. The grouping tells you when in a conversation each tool belongs. Each family is triggered by one diagnostic question. Click a family to jump to it.

The conversation arcOpenMethods 1–9Start of a topicHas this topic only been seenfrom one angle?Shift the FrameMethods 10–20When meaning is stuckIs the meaning of undisputedfacts locked?Move in TimeMethods 21–27When today is all they seeIs the client standing onlyinside today’s problem?Precise InquiryMethods 28–34When questions go flatHas an ordinary open questionstopped producing anything new?Land ItMethods 35–43Make it lastHas enough opened that it mustbecome durable?
More on choosing and sequencing methods

Every experienced coach recognizes this problem: a client says a sentence, and in that instant a dozen possible directions open up. Ask about feeling, and you might miss the pattern. Ask about the pattern, and you might miss the body. Push toward action, and you might cut off grief that needed a minute more. Wait too long, and momentum drains from the hour. This guide exists to make that split-second judgment easier to see, name, and practise — not by handing over a script, but by mapping the terrain a session actually moves through, and the cues that tell you where you are standing on it.

A method is a key, not a script — it is a family of moves organized around one underlying intention, not a fixed sentence to memorize. They are collected here because in practice they cover the great majority of what a skilled coach actually does with their mouth open: they open a topic, they question the frame around it, they move the client through time to find a destination, or they close the loop into something the client will actually do. Every method’s quick card names the situation the method is built for, the single-sentence coach move that captures its intent, four sample questions that tend to open that particular door, and a caution about the way it can be misused.

Sequencing matters more than any individual method's cleverness. Contract before diving, because a beautifully explored topic that was never the client's real concern is wasted craft. Expand before challenging, because a reframe offered before the client feels fully heard lands as correction rather than insight — the client experiences it as being talked over, not seen further. Feel before reframing, for the same reason: cognition that arrives ahead of felt experience gets rejected by the nervous system even when it is technically accurate. If the client is trapped in the problem — turning it over and over without a picture of what "solved" would look like — move them in time (preferred future, miracle question, future-self) before generating options, because options generated against a fog of not-wanting rather than a clear picture of wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. And if the client is already leaning forward with new language and real energy, land an experiment instead of exploring further; continued exploration at that point is often the coach's need for thoroughness getting in the way of the client's readiness to move.

The methods sit in five families, each answering a different question about what the topic currently needs:

Seven methods — clean language, the question cube, the pre-mortem, the third entity, temporal reframe, positive intent reframe, and systemic reframe — are more structured than the rest of the set. They earn their place here precisely because they are more demanding to use well: each borrows a discipline (linguistics, risk planning, family-systems work, narrative therapy) that has its own internal logic, and each can tip into a parlour trick if used as a gimmick rather than a genuine architecture for inquiry. Reach for them once the simpler moves in this part have been tried and the topic is still flat, not as a first move to sound clever.

In the room, the discipline is simple to state and hard to practise: ask one question drawn from the family that fits what you are hearing, then wait. If nothing opens after a real pause, change family — reach for a different kind of move entirely — rather than simply asking a louder or cleverer version of the same question.

The spine of the hour

Every entry in this guide sits somewhere on the same underlying sequence — the shape a well-run coaching hour tends to take, whether the topic is a boardroom conflict or a quiet crisis of meaning. Contract sets the destination. Explore surfaces the real material. Widen stretches the frame so the client is not choosing from only the two options they walked in with. Focus narrows back down to the actual point of leverage. Forward turns insight into something the client will do, notice, or say differently by next week.

Naming this arc matters because most of what goes wrong in a session is not a bad question — it is the right question asked at the wrong stage.

Skipping contract looks efficient and wastes the hour: the coach and client end up solving two different problems without realizing it. Skipping explore looks respectful of time and instead recycles the client's first, most rehearsed account of events — the version that has already been told to a partner, a friend, and a mirror, and that rarely contains the new information the session needs. Skipping widen keeps the client inside the same two doors they arrived with, so the "choice" the coach helps them make was never really a choice. Skipping focus turns a rich exploration into a diffuse conversation with no single thread to pull. And skipping forward is the most common failure of all: a genuinely good fifty minutes of insight, with nothing built to carry it out of the room, so next week starts from zero again.

The stage a client is in is rarely announced. It shows up in how they are speaking — the tense of their verbs, the specificity of their language, whether their body has caught up with their words. Reading that stage, more than knowing any individual technique, is the actual skill this guide is trying to build.

01

Contract

What is the topic, and what would make this hour useful? If several topics arrive, choose one.

Skipping it: coach and client solve two different problems without realising it.
02

Explore

Expand, feel, find the pattern, question the frame. New language should appear, not only the rehearsed account.

Skipping it: the first, most rehearsed account gets recycled.
03

Widen

Preferred future, other chairs, opposite belief, exceptions. The topic becomes larger than the first story.

Skipping it: the client chooses between the same two doors they walked in with.
04

Focus

What is the real work now: person, role, or system; feeling, belief, or a next act?

Skipping it: a rich exploration with no single thread to pull.
05

Forward

One insight the client owns, one experiment sized to the state in the room, one way to know it happened.

Skipping it: fifty good minutes with nothing built to carry it out of the room.

How to use this in a live session

Notice how the topic is being held — polished, stuck, certain, vague, overloaded, in the head, or ready to move. That noticing is the actual diagnostic step; everything after it is just retrieval. Choose one method family that matches what you are hearing. Open the Situation Atlas only if you need exact wording for the situation in front of you — this guide is meant to be consulted between sentences, not read like a script during them. Ask one question. Then wait; the silence after a well-placed question is doing as much work as the question itself, and coaches who rush to fill it are usually managing their own discomfort, not the client's. If nothing opens after a genuine pause, do not simply ask a different question at the same level — change level instead: story → feeling → belief → identity → system → experiment. A stuck conversation is very often not a hard problem; it is the right kind of question aimed at the wrong altitude.

If nothing opens, change altitude, not wording · explained below
1Story
2Feeling
3Belief
4Identity
5System
6Experiment
A stuck conversation is often the right kind of question aimed at the wrong altitude.
Noticehow the topic is being held
Chooseone method family
Askone question
Waitlet the silence work
Shiftchange level if stuck

Changing level: the six altitudes

The same topic can be discussed at six different levels. When a conversation stalls, the problem is usually the level, not the question. Asking a cleverer question at the same level rarely helps. Moving up or down a level often does. The example below follows one client who says, “My boss keeps overriding my decisions.”

1

Story

What happened

The events, the plot, who said what.

Ask“What happened in Tuesday’s meeting?”
Client“He changed my decision in front of the team again.”
Go here whenThe client keeps adding detail and the story sounds the same as last week.
2

Feeling

What it’s like

The emotional and physical experience of the story.

Ask“What do you feel when he overrides you?”
Client“Small. Humiliated.”
Go here whenThe story is fluent but flat. New feeling words usually mean real material is surfacing.
3

Belief

What they assume

The interpretation or rule underneath the feeling.

Ask“What do you take it to mean when he does that?”
Client“That he doesn’t trust me.”
Go here whenThe feeling is clear but locked in by one certain reading of events.
4

Identity

Who they are in it

How the situation connects to their sense of self.

Ask“Who do you become in those moments?”
Client“The junior again. The one who has to ask.”
Go here whenThe same pattern shows up with many different people, so it’s about the client, not this one relationship.
5

System

What surrounds it

The structures, roles, culture and incentives around the problem.

Ask“What in how decisions are made here keeps this happening?”
Client“Nobody ever agreed who owns which decisions.”
Go here whenThe client is carrying personally something that is partly a design flaw.
6

Experiment

What they’ll try

A small, real, dated action that tests something.

Ask“What’s one decision you could agree ownership of with him this week?”
Client“I’ll ask to own the supplier choice, starting Monday.”
Go here whenA rich conversation is about to end with nothing built to carry it out of the room.
When nothing opens, change level. If the client keeps re-telling the story, go down to feeling or across to belief. If they are deep in feeling and going round in circles, move to system or experiment.
The order isn’t fixed. The ladder runs from surface to depth to action, but you can jump. A flooded client may need to go straight from feeling to one tiny experiment. A client blaming themselves may need system before identity.
End at experiment. Most good sessions touch at least two levels and finish with a small action. The most common failure is a rich conversation at feeling, belief or identity that never reaches experiment, so nothing changes by next week.
Listen for what’s new. If the client hasn’t said anything new for a few minutes, you are probably on the right topic but at the wrong altitude.

How the pieces relate

Families, methods, situations5FamiliesWhen in the conversation?43MethodsWhich move do I make?180SituationsWhat am I seeing?containsone-to-manyanswers / is diagnosed bymany-to-many“A method is a move; a situation is the diagnosis that tells you the move is needed.”

Family

Where are we in the conversation? A container that tells you which kind of tool fits this stage. Each method belongs to exactly one family.

Method

What move do I make? The technique itself, explained with the same ten parts every time.

Situation

What am I seeing? A recognizable pattern in the client: what you see and hear, what’s underneath, what to avoid, and an example.

Why situations sit inside the methods. A method is a move; a situation is the diagnosis that tells you the move is needed. So each method lists the situations it fits, and each situation in the Situation Atlas lists the methods that handle it. Whichever end you start from, recognising the situation and reaching for the tool happen in the same glance.

The methods sit inside five families because the family tells you when in the arc of a conversation each tool belongs.

Anatomy of every method

Every method follows the same template. The document runs the parts in order 1–10. This diagram groups them by what they’re for, and each method page has a coloured strip linking to its own parts.

Anatomy of a methodEvery one of the 43 methodsUnderstand it1What it really is2Client’s context3Coach’s options4How it worksTroubleshoot it5Where it gets stuck6Move it forwardUse it7Questions to use8SituationsGuard it9Coach mistakes10Client traps+Worked problems
  1. What it really is: the method without jargon, made concrete.
  2. The client’s context: what the client is doing, saying and experiencing that signals this method is needed. This answers “why would I reach for this tool?”
  3. The coach’s options: the real decision menu: the variants a coach can choose between.
  4. How it works, deeply: the underlying mechanism: why the move works, not just what to say.
  5. Where it gets stuck: the specific way this method fails in the room.
  6. How to move it forward: the recovery move when it stalls.
  7. Questions to use: core questions, plus further questions to extend the toolkit.
  8. Situations from the field: the recognisable situations that call for this method, so diagnosis and move live in one place.
  9. Coach mistakes and watch-outs: what the coach does wrong.
  10. Client traps: what the client does, often unconsciously, to avoid the method’s benefit, plus three worked problems.

Situation map: which method handles which kind of situation

This counts the situations filed under each method, by situation group (S1–S9). Darker cells mean the method is a heavier-used tool for that kind of situation. Click any method name to jump to it.

A session, start to finish

Maya leads a product team of eight. She asked for this session saying “my team won’t take ownership.” Follow the hour stage by stage. On the right of each step you can see what the coach noticed, which situation it matched, which method they used, and the level the conversation was working at.

ConversationWhat the coach noticed · situation · level · method used
Contract
Client

There’s loads going on. The roadmap, a hire, my review, and honestly the team just won’t take ownership of anything.

Coach

That’s a lot. If only one of those changed by the end of today, which would make the biggest difference?

Several topics at once, delivered quickly. The real work is choosing one.

Client

The ownership thing. It affects everything else.

Coach

And if this hour were really useful, what would you leave with?

Topic chosen. Now the destination.

Level: Story
Client

A way to get them to step up without me checking everything.

Coach

Good. Let’s start there.

Contract set: ownership, without constant checking.

Level: Story
Explore
Client

So last week, the release notes. I asked Sam to do them. He sent a draft, I rewrote half of it, and then on Friday…

Coach

(after listening) You’ve clearly told this one before. What’s true about it that you haven’t said yet?

Fluent, detailed, slightly bored. A rehearsed story. More plot won’t help.

Client

(pause) That I’m tired. And a bit embarrassed I keep rewriting things.

Coach

Tired and embarrassed. What’s that like?

New feeling words. The level has shifted.

Level: Feeling
Client

Like I can’t stop. If it goes out with mistakes, it’s on me.

Coach

What do you take it to mean, if something goes out with mistakes?

A belief is showing under the feeling. Move up one level.

Level: Belief
Widen
Client

That I’m not a good enough leader. That my boss will think I’ve lost control.

Coach

So your rewriting protects something. What would someone you respect say about this pattern?

The rescuing has a protective job. Widen with another perspective rather than challenging it.

Client

My old manager would say I’m robbing them of the chance to learn.

Coach

And a year from now, if this were going really well, what would we see?

Perspective has opened. Now give her somewhere to stand other than inside the problem.

Level: Identity
Client

Me in fewer meetings. Sam presenting the release himself. Me coaching, not fixing.

Coach

Who are you, in that picture?

Concrete, observable future. A shift in identity is in the air.

Level: Identity
Focus
Client

Someone who trusts people. Who sets the standard and lets them meet it.

Coach

What’s yours to change here, and what isn’t?

Time to narrow to the real lever. Sort control.

Level: System
Client

I can’t control whether Sam gets it right first time. I can control how clear the standard is, and whether I jump in.

Coach

(pause) Say that again, slower.

A real insight has landed. Don’t ask another clever question. Anchor it.

Forward
Client

I control the standard and whether I jump in.

Coach

What’s one small experiment you could run this week?

Energy is forward. Land it, sized to how she is.

S1.7 Ready to moveLevel: Experiment
Client

Next release, I’ll agree the standard with Sam up front, then not touch his draft. Just give one round of feedback.

Coach

When will that be, and how will you know it happened?

Specific, dated, owned by her.

Level: Experiment
Client

Thursday. I’ll know if I didn’t open the doc after he sends it.

Coach

What might get in the way?

Quick pre-mortem on the experiment, not on her.

Level: Experiment
Client

Panic at 5pm on Wednesday. I’ll text you a thumbs-up instead of opening it.

Coach

Thank you. What do you want to remember from today?

Close by harvesting her words, not the coach’s summary.

Level: Experiment

What to take from it

  • The coach spent the first three minutes only on contracting. Without it, this hour could easily have been about the roadmap.
  • The rehearsed story was heard once, then the coach went under it, not around it.
  • The level moved from story to feeling to belief to identity to system to experiment. No single question was clever; the movement did the work.
  • The reframe (her rewriting protects something) came only after the feeling had been heard.
  • When insight landed, the coach stopped asking and anchored it.
  • The experiment was small, dated and designed by the client, with one obstacle planned for.
Family 1 of 5 · Methods 1–9

Open

Has this topic only been seen from one angle?

The Open family exists for the first minutes of almost any topic. Its job is to stop the coach and client from moving forward with only the first, thinnest version of the story. Nothing gets “solved” here — the point is to make sure the topic has actually been seen, not just narrated.

1
Open family

Contract the Topic First

Core move: Agree the destination before diving in
5 options10 questions37 situations

1What it really is

Before any exploration begins, coach and client explicitly agree on what is being worked on and why it matters today. This is not a formality or an administrative checkbox — it is a diagnostic move. Skipping it is the single most common reason a coaching hour fails: the coach and client quietly agree to work on two different problems and never notice.

In practice, contracting answers three plain questions out loud: what do you want to work on, what would you like to have by the end of this conversation, and how will we both know we got there? The first answer a client gives is often a topic (“my team”), not an outcome, so the coach gently keeps going until there is something specific enough to aim at. A useful contract is small enough to make real progress on in one session, owned by the client rather than by their manager or the coach, and stated in the client’s own words.

It sounds like: “Before we go anywhere, what would make this hour worth it for you?” or “If we did good work today, what would you walk out with?” It is not a fixed agenda, and it can be renegotiated mid-session if something more important surfaces, as long as the change is named rather than drifted into. You know it has worked when the client can say in one sentence what today is for, and when both of you could tell a third person the same thing without checking with each other first.

4How it works, deeply

Contracting works because it converts an implicit assumption (“we both know what we’re doing here”) into an explicit, checkable agreement. Most miscommunication in coaching is not a bad answer to a good question — it’s a good answer to the wrong question, because nobody named the destination first. The contract also functions as a compass the coach can return to later in the hour when things get diffuse: “is this still in service of what we agreed?”

Underneath this is a basic feature of attention: people find what they are looking for. When the destination is named, both coach and client start filtering the conversation for what is relevant to it, and side-stories naturally fall away. NLP’s well-formed outcome criteria add useful precision here. The outcome is stated in positive terms, within the client’s own control, described in sensory terms, sized for the time available, and checked for side effects on the rest of the client’s life.

Contracting also changes the relationship. By asking what the client wants rather than assuming, the coach signals that the client leads the agenda, which builds ownership from the first minute. It quietly tests readiness too: a client who cannot name any outcome may need the session to be about finding one, and that is a valid contract in itself. Finally, a clear contract makes the ending honest, because coach and client can check together whether they got what they came for rather than ending on a vague sense of “that was useful.”

Quick card

Reach for it when
Any new topic; start of session; client dumps several issues
The move
Agree what you are exploring and why it matters today before diving
Watch
Without a contract the hour becomes storytelling with no destination.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What about this is most important to work on today?
  2. If this session were a complete success, what would you leave with?
  3. Is this the real issue, or is something underneath it?
  4. What do you need from me on this today?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Overwhelmed and undifferentiated — they arrive with a flood of topics (“my reorg, my report, the board pack, a stalled hire, and honestly I’m dreading Sundays”) and no way to prioritize among them.
  • Carrying someone else’s agenda — the topic was assigned (“my boss said I need to work on executive presence”) rather than chosen, and the client hasn’t yet located their own stake in it.
  • Vague about the destination — “I just want to talk” is not a contract; it’s an absence of one.
  • Protecting a “safe” topic — a quieter, more painful issue sits underneath a socially acceptable one, and the client is testing whether it’s safe to go there.
  • Mid-session drift — thirty minutes into a contracted topic, the client’s energy visibly moves toward something else entirely.

3The coach’s options

The coach is choosing among five distinct moves depending on which client state above is present:

1Force a ranking when there are multiple live topics (“If only one could change this week, which one?”).
2Ask for a success criterion when the topic is vague (“What would make this hour useful to leave with?”).
3Negotiate a slice when the client can’t choose (“Twenty minutes on X, then we check in.”).
4Name the mismatch when the assigned topic and the client’s energy don’t match, and hand the choice back to them.
5Re-contract live, mid-session, the instant the energy visibly moves elsewhere — asking permission before following it.
Variation from NLPWell-formed outcomes

A short check that a goal, for the session or the engagement, is one the client can actually work on.

  • Stated in the positive — What do you want, rather than what you want to stop?
  • In the client’s control — What part of this can you start and keep going yourself?
  • Sensory-specific — When you have it, what will you see, hear and feel?
  • Context — Where, when and with whom do you want this?
  • Resources — What do you already have that will help, and what do you need?
  • Ecology — What might it cost you, and who else is affected? Is it still worth it?

Watch: Use it as a light check, not a form to fill in. One or two criteria are often enough to sharpen the contract.

A standard NLP goal-setting frame. NLP tools are widely used in coaching, but research support for NLP’s core claims is limited. Treat this as a practical tool to test, not proven science. See also Other NLP techniques.

5Where it gets stuck

The hour turns into storytelling with no destination. Coach and client are, without realizing it, solving two different problems. Insight lands — but on a topic the client didn’t actually come in wanting to change.

6How to move it forward

Name the fork explicitly. If the client can’t choose between competing topics, don’t force a full decision — contract a small, time-boxed slice instead, then re-check. If the assigned topic and the visible energy don’t match, say so as a neutral observation and let the client decide which to follow.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What about this is most important to work on today?
  • If this session were a complete success, what would you leave with?
  • Is this the real issue, or is something underneath it?
  • What do you need from me on this today?
  • Which item has the most heat?
Going further
  • If you could only bring one sentence into this room today, what would it be?
  • What would make today’s hour a waste of your time — so we can avoid that?
  • Whose problem is this, really — yours, or one you inherited?
  • What have you already tried to solve this on your own, before bringing it here?
  • If we don’t talk about this today, what happens to it?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.5Overwhelmed Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to …
What is happening Too much at once, pressure, no footholdCoach move Exceptions, resources, +1 on the scale
In the room
Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to outrun the body.
What’s underneath
An overloaded system cannot use a big plan. Load reduction and resource-finding are regulation, not soft extras. +1 and exceptions restore a sense of authorship without pretending the load is imaginary.
Avoid here
Giant homework. Preferred-future montage. Pre-mortem (more future weight). Who-would-you-need-to-be as a heroic identity.
Example
Six workstreams plus a sick parent. Exception: last Thursday when they declined two meetings. +1: decline the standing Thursday review that produces no decisions. Not a life-redesign.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods145740
S1.9Skimming / staying on the surface Short answers. “It’s fine.” Jumps topics. Jokes away. No dwell time.
What is happening Short answers, “it’s fine”, jumps topics, jokes awayCoach move Slow down. One thread. Reflect + silence. Invite the unsaid
In the room
Short answers. “It’s fine.” Jumps topics. Jokes away. No dwell time.
What’s underneath
Surface is often safety, not shallowness. Chasing every new topic they offer as escape trains the dodge. One thread + silence is the intervention.
Avoid here
And-what-else as a machine gun. Deep identity work before safety. Challenge.
Example
Client hopscotches from team to school to a podcast they heard. Coach returns to “it’s fine.” Under it: they were copied off a thread. Two minutes there is the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods127
S1.10Dumping everything at once / multiple topics Long list. Urgency. No priority. Breathless. They watch to see which fire you will pick.
What is happening Long list, urgency, no priority, breathlessCoach move Contract. Choose the thread with the most energy
In the room
Long list. Urgency. No priority. Breathless. They watch to see which fire you will pick.
What’s underneath
The list is data. The session still needs one focus. Several topics at once usually means the real work is choosing, not answering all of them.
Avoid here
Trying to land six micro-plans. Expanding every item. Being the project manager.
Example
Reorg, hire, board pack, leave-question. Heat is on the leave-question when they say it. Contract twenty minutes there; the rest becomes context for whether they stay.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods140
S1.12Bringing someone else’s agenda “My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.
What is happening “My boss said I should…”, partner booked them, HR sent themCoach move Separate assigned topic from their topic. Restore ownership
In the room
“My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.
What’s underneath
Coaching requires authorship. You can work the overlap between organizational want and client want. You cannot become the organization’s enforcer and still be their coach.
Avoid here
Running the company’s curriculum. Ignoring the assigned topic entirely without naming the fork (can blow up sponsorship). Advice on how to “perform presence.”
Example
Assigned: executive presence. Owned: credit stolen by a peer. Overlap: one visible moment Thursday. Both agendas honored; neither colonizes the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods163540
S1.13Avoiding the real topic Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.
What is happening Safe issue up front, energy elsewhere, late-session revealCoach move Follow energy, not the official title. Name the mismatch
In the room
Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.
What’s underneath
Avoidance is information about cost and safety, not a character flaw. Name the mismatch; do not ambush. They choose.
Avoid here
Clever “gotcha.” Deep dive with eight minutes left. Reframe of the safe topic as if it were the work.
Example
Official: calendar. Heat: “my partner booked this.” Offer the observation. They choose the authorship topic. Calendar was the costume.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12714
S1.14First time saying it out loud Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What is happening Hesitation, “this may sound silly”, long pause before the sentenceCoach move Safety first. Witness. Do not rush to fix or reframe
In the room
Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What’s underneath
Being heard is the intervention. Insight can wait. A reframe here is a small violence: it teaches them that this room, too, will rush to tidy what they just risked.
Avoid here
Immediate reframe, options, miracle, challenge.
Example
“I think I want to leave the field.” Coach does not build an exit plan. First work: they hear themselves. Then they choose hold vs move.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17133538
S1.16Talking very fast / flooding with words No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.
What is happening No pauses, stacked clauses, little breathCoach move Pace down. Reflect one piece. Ask for the headline
In the room
No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.
What’s underneath
Speed is often anesthesia or an attempt to get it all in before they are interrupted (history of not being given the floor). Pacing down is regulation. Headline restores choice.
Avoid here
Matching speed. And-what-else rapid fire. Complexifying.
Example
Seven-minute sentence about a reorg. Coach: one sentence. “I don’t know if I have a job.” That is the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods173132
S1.19Jumping straight to solutions Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What is happening Action list before the topic is understoodCoach move Pause action. Check if the problem is the real problem
In the room
Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What’s underneath
Premature plans recycle the old frame. Sometimes action-hunger is anxiety management. Distinguish a planning hour from an understanding hour — and let them choose if both are live.
Avoid here
Helping them polish the premature plan. More options on an unexamined problem.
Example
Client arrives with a 9-point script for a fight with their peer. “If it worked, what would it give you?” “I want to stop being erased.” Understanding hour: erasure pattern. Then a shorter request, not a 9-point prosecution.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17102126
S2.12Lonely in the role / “no one gets it” Isolation. Peer gap. Cannot talk at home or work.
What is happening Isolation, peer gap, can’t talk at home or workCoach move Name the isolation. Build a support design, not only inner work
In the room
Isolation. Peer gap. Cannot talk at home or work.
What’s underneath
Insight without a place to belong often fades. This is not only inner work. Design support. The coach is not their only peer.
Avoid here
More self-reliance identity. Only inner resilience.
Example
New country manager. Coaching holds the weekly sense-making. Also: one external peer and one in-country ally. Belonging design, not just “hold the loneliness better.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods116
S2.13Resentful / bitter Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.
What is happening Kept score, “after all I did”, tightnessCoach move Find the unmet contract. Turn resentment into a request or a boundary
In the room
Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.
What’s underneath
Resentment is often an unmet contract that was never spoken. Venting without a request keeps them stuck. Turn into a request or a boundary — or a clean decision to stop waiting.
Avoid here
More venting as the whole method. Moral lecture about gratitude.
Example
Covered a peer’s region for a year. Never agreed; never asked. Clean ask or stop covering. Bitterness was unpaid invoice plus silence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1243740
S2.15Over-excited / manic planning Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.
What is happening Huge vision, no sleep, ten projectsCoach move Channel the energy. Sequence. Risk-check without killing it
In the room
Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.
What’s underneath
Do not match the high. Be the ballast. Channel, sequence, risk-check without killing life.
Avoid here
Matching with more vision. Shame about the high.
Example
Ten-project founder week. Keep the customer-evidence project 30 days. Pre-mortem on scope only. Energy stays; pile shrinks.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1122526
S3.5Should / must / have-to language Duty voice. Little want-language.
What is happening Duty voice, little want-languageCoach move Translate should → want / value / fear / someone else’s voice
In the room
Duty voice. Little want-language.
What’s underneath
Don’t smash duty. Find the living value, fear, or borrowed voice under it. Then they can choose.
Avoid here
Adolescent rebellion coaching. Ignoring real duties (care, visa, safety).
Example
“I have to take the global role.” Whose: father’s immigrant script + a sponsor. Want-language: “I want work that uses my languages and a life with my kids.” Both/and experiment becomes speakable.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods114
S3.7Complexifying / adding layers to stay safe More frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decision.
What is happening More frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decisionCoach move Simplify to the real choice. Time-box complexity
In the room
More frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decision.
What’s underneath
Complexity can be highly intelligent avoidance. Time-box. 70% information. Actual Friday choice.
Avoid here
Question cube used as more layers. More stakeholder maps.
Example
Nine-stakeholder model for a hire. Friday choice: A or B, 30-day review. Fear under complexity: being seen to pick wrong. Named; then picked.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods129
S4.9Outsourcing judgment to the coach “Just tell me what you would do.”
What is happening “Just tell me what you would do”Coach move Refuse the expert trap. Offer a perspective only if contracted, without attachment
In the room
“Just tell me what you would do.”
What’s underneath
Flattering trap. Advice creates dependency and weakens their muscle. Occasional contracted perspective is fine; a habit is not coaching.
Avoid here
Answering as the main move.
Example
Stay or go. They already know they are leaving. My answer would spare them disappointing their sponsor. Work that, not my hypothetical career.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1
S5.2Action without insight / busywork Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.
What is happening Lots of doing, no learning, hamster wheelCoach move Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs motion
In the room
Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.
What’s underneath
Do not applaud motion that is avoidance. Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs anxiety-motion.
Avoid here
More productivity systems.
Example
14 status meetings. 50% less might reveal no decision owner. Stillness would show the missing contract, not a need for a 15th meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods172140
S5.13Impatient for a quick fix Wants the trick, the script, this week.
What is happening Wants the trick, the script, this weekCoach move Honor urgency. Distinguish technique vs identity work. Offer a 7-day test
In the room
Wants the trick, the script, this week.
What’s underneath
Honor urgency. Distinguish technique vs identity work. Give a real near move without pretending deep change is a hack.
Avoid here
Fake hack. Or a sermon about patience with no near move.
Example
“Give me the script for executive presence.” Near move: one scene Thursday. Longer: identity that can be seen. Both named; only one is this week.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1
S6.5Old identity dying (expert → leader, founder → CEO) Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What is happening Grief + incompetence of the new skinCoach move Name the identity funeral and the apprenticeship
In the room
Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What’s underneath
They need rites of passage, not only skills. Name the funeral and the apprenticeship. Newness is not incompetence.
Avoid here
Tool-only manager training.
Example
Founder still in every product thread. Funeral: “I am no longer the best doer in the room.” Apprenticeship: one thread they sponsor only. Old identity contributes taste, not keystrokes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods116233435
S7.17New leader / first-time manager Still doing the old job. Conflict-shy.
What is happening Still doing the old job, conflict-shyCoach move Role contract, let-go list, first conversations
In the room
Still doing the old job. Conflict-shy.
What’s underneath
Do not only teach tools. Shift identity. Role contract. Let-go list. First conversations.
Avoid here
Toolkits without identity funeral.
Example
Still the best analyst on the team. Stop-doing: last-pass on every model. First conversation: who owns the last-pass now.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13435
S7.33Disclosure of bullying, harassment or discrimination Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What is happening Client describes treatment that may be bullying, harassment or discriminationCoach move Listen and believe; map options and support; refer to formal channels
In the room
Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What’s underneath
This is not only a coaching topic. It may need HR, legal, union or other formal support. The coach listens, believes, helps the client understand their options and supports their choice. The coach does not investigate, judge or decide for them, and does not promise confidentiality they can’t keep.
Avoid here
Coaching their “resilience” to tolerate it. Telling them what to do. Investigating or confronting anyone. Minimising.
Example
A junior employee describes repeated comments about her accent from a manager. The coach listens, acknowledges how hard it is, and helps her map formal and informal options and who could support her.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17163740
S8.1Testing the coach / “impress me” Wry, evaluative. “Other coaches said…”
What is happening Wry, evaluative, “other coaches said…”Coach move Stay unhooked. Presence. Contract what would make this useful
In the room
Wry, evaluative. “Other coaches said…”
What’s underneath
Can look hostile; often checking for safety. Stay unhooked. Usefulness, not performance.
Avoid here
Question-cube-as-audition. Clever reframe to win.
Example
“My last coach used clean language.” Coach does not demonstrate it. Contracts usefulness. Test softens when they are not being auditioned back.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1
S8.2Wants the coach to be the expert / mentor / parent Advice hunger. “What would you do?”
What is happening Advice hunger, “what would you do?”Coach move Name the pull. Offer choice: coaching vs a contracted opinion
In the room
Advice hunger. “What would you do?”
What’s underneath
Name the pull. Offer choice: coaching vs a contracted opinion. A habit of answering is not coaching.
Avoid here
Becoming the parent who says yes.
Example
They lose the muscle and the blame if you answer. Named. They already know they will not take the role. Work that.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1
S8.11Session energy drops / both get sleepy Fog. Circles.
What is happening Fog, going in circlesCoach move Call it. Stand, breathe, pick a sharper question or close this thread
In the room
Fog. Circles.
What’s underneath
Polite persistence in a dead thread wastes the hour. Call it. Stand, breathe, sharper slice or park.
Avoid here
One more question at the same altitude.
Example
Fog on a stakeholder map. Real topic was the leave-question they stepped around. Naming the drop finds it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods129
S8.13Wants therapy from coaching — or vice versa Trauma unfolding, diagnosis talk — or only tactics when grief is here.
What is happening Trauma unfolding, diagnosis talk, or only tactics when grief is hereCoach move Re-contract scope. Refer when needed. Stay in present-and-forward if coaching
In the room
Trauma unfolding, diagnosis talk — or only tactics when grief is here.
What’s underneath
Re-contract scope. Refer when needed. Stay present-and-forward if this is coaching. Know your edge. Referring is competence.
Avoid here
Amateur trauma work. Or skipping grief that belongs in the room for a beat.
Example
Trauma material unfolding. Coaching part: how they want to walk into Thursday’s review. Referral named without dumping them. Both are care.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1
S8.14Time pressure in the session Big topic at minute 45.
What is happening Big topic at minute 45Coach move Don’t open surgery. Contract a slice or park it well
In the room
Big topic at minute 45.
What’s underneath
A messy deep-dive into the last 8 minutes is not bravery. Don’t open surgery. Clean slice or strong setup for next time.
Avoid here
Opening the real topic at minute 52.
Example
Leave-question at minute 48. Setup for next time + one sentence they want remembered. No amateur exit plan in 8 minutes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1
S8.16Suicidal thoughts or risk disclosed Hopelessness. “What’s the point?” Talking about not being here, being a burden, or having a plan. May be hint…
What is happening Client hints at or states thoughts of ending their lifeCoach move Stop the coaching agenda; ask directly; listen; connect them to professional help
In the room
Hopelessness. “What’s the point?” Talking about not being here, being a burden, or having a plan. May be hinted rather than stated.
What’s underneath
Safety comes before coaching. Asking directly and calmly about suicidal thoughts does not plant the idea; it often brings relief. The coach stays calm, listens, takes it seriously, and helps the client connect with professional help: their GP, a mental health professional, or crisis services. The coach follows their contract and any safeguarding procedures, and gets supervision afterwards.
Avoid here
Carrying on with the coaching agenda. Panic or lecturing. Promising complete confidentiality. Ending the session without a plan for support.
Example
A client says, “Sometimes I think everyone would be better off without me.” The coach pauses the session, asks directly, listens, and stays with the client while they agree who they will contact for help that day.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1732
S8.18Client far more senior or powerful than the coach The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.
What is happening Large status gap; coach tempted to defer or impressCoach move Contract for challenge; stay curious and independent
In the room
The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.
What’s underneath
Seniority and status are part of the room. If the coach defers, the client loses the challenge they need. The coach’s value is in their questions and their independence, not in matching the client’s status.
Avoid here
Deference. Performing expertise. Avoiding challenge.
Example
A new coach working with a CEO keeps agreeing. In supervision, the coach realises this. Next session they contract openly for challenge.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13728
S8.19Cultural or identity gap between coach and client Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.
What is happening Coach and client differ in culture, identity or experienceCoach move Name the gap; use the client’s own words; ask, don’t assume
In the room
Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.
What’s underneath
Culture, identity and lived experience shape what problems mean and what solutions are possible. The coach doesn’t need to share them, but does need curiosity, humility and willingness to name the gap and ask.
Avoid here
Assuming your own cultural norms are neutral. Avoiding the topic. Over-apologising.
Example
A coach from a low-hierarchy culture coaches a client from a high-hierarchy culture about “speaking up to the boss.” The coach asks what speaking up would look like in the client’s context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods171128
S8.20Attraction, over-familiarity or boundary pull Personal messages outside sessions. Requests to meet socially. Compliments that feel personal. The coach may …
What is happening Relationship drifting beyond the professional; personal pull on either sideCoach move Restate boundaries kindly and clearly; take it to supervision
In the room
Personal messages outside sessions. Requests to meet socially. Compliments that feel personal. The coach may feel flattered or uncomfortable.
What’s underneath
Coaching needs clear boundaries to stay safe and useful. The coach is responsible for holding them, kindly and clearly, whatever the client does. Supervision is important.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Encouraging it. Shaming the client.
Example
A client begins sending friendly late-night messages. The coach thanks them, restates how and when they communicate, and discusses it in supervision.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17
S8.21Confidentiality clashes with safety or legal duty The client shares something that may put them or others at risk, or that may be illegal. The coach feels torn…
What is happening Information shared may require action beyond the coaching relationshipCoach move Revisit the agreed limits; explore the client acting first; seek advice
In the room
The client shares something that may put them or others at risk, or that may be illegal. The coach feels torn.
What’s underneath
Confidentiality has limits, which should be agreed in the contract at the start. When serious risk to someone or legal duties are involved, the coach may need to act. Being honest with the client about those limits keeps trust.
Avoid here
Promising total confidentiality. Acting without telling the client. Ignoring the risk.
Example
A client reveals they are covering up a safety risk at work. The coach reminds them of the agreed limits of confidentiality and explores how the client can report it themselves.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods140
S9.1First session or chemistry meeting Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What is happening First meeting; deciding whether to work together and howCoach move Show how you work; clarify expectations, confidentiality and fit
In the room
Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What’s underneath
The chemistry session is about fit and expectations, not proving brilliance. The coach should show how they work, clarify what coaching is and isn’t, and help the client decide.
Avoid here
Over-selling. Starting deep work before the contract is agreed. Being vague about logistics and confidentiality.
Example
A client asks how coaching will help. The coach does a short taste of coaching on a real topic, then explains confidentiality, sponsor involvement and how they would work together.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods136821
S9.2Sponsor asks what the client said A manager or HR contact asks for updates or details from sessions.
What is happening Sponsor wants information about sessionsCoach move Restate the agreement; redirect to client-owned progress updates
In the room
A manager or HR contact asks for updates or details from sessions.
What’s underneath
The sponsor has a legitimate interest in progress, but not in session content. Confidentiality and reporting should be agreed upfront in a three-way contract. The client, not the coach, should own the progress updates.
Avoid here
Sharing session content. Being evasive without explaining why.
Example
An HR manager asks how sessions are going and what the client said about their boss. The coach explains the agreement and suggests the client gives a progress update in the next three-way meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14042
S9.3Three-way meeting with client and sponsor Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What is happening Formal alignment or review meeting with sponsor presentCoach move Prepare the client to lead; facilitate goals and observable signs of change
In the room
Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What’s underneath
Three-way meetings align goals and show progress. The client should lead, the coach facilitates, and the sponsor gives perspective. Preparation matters.
Avoid here
Coach speaking for the client. Revealing session content. Letting the sponsor dominate.
Example
Before the meeting, the coach helps the client rehearse what to share. In the meeting, the client presents goals, and the boss shares what they would notice changing.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16263742
S9.4Coaching isn’t working Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What is happening Sessions repeat without progress; frustration on one or both sidesCoach move Name it openly; review goals, fit and approach together
In the room
Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What’s underneath
Lack of progress is information. The topic, the fit, the timing or the method may be wrong. Naming it openly is better than carrying on politely.
Avoid here
Blaming the client. Pretending it’s fine. Trying harder with the same approach.
Example
After six sessions, nothing has changed. The coach names it and asks what isn’t working. The client admits the real topic is leaving, not leadership.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293439
S9.5Client wants to stop early Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.
What is happening Client asks to end the engagement before plannedCoach move Respect the choice; reflect on what led to it; harvest the learning
In the room
Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.
What’s underneath
Stopping early can be the right choice or an avoidance. The coach respects the decision while inviting reflection on what led to it and what the client has gained.
Avoid here
Persuading them to stay. Taking it personally. Ending without reflection.
Example
A client wants to stop after three sessions. The coach asks what led to it. The client admits the topic got too close. They agree a final session to harvest learning.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17838
S9.7Repeated cancellations or no-shows Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.
What is happening Sessions keep being cancelled or missedCoach move Name the pattern without blame; re-contract
In the room
Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.
What’s underneath
Repeated cancellations are information: about priority, avoidance, workload, or fit. Naming the pattern, without blame, helps the client decide what they want.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Getting annoyed. Making assumptions.
Example
A client cancels three times. The coach names the pattern kindly. The client admits the sessions feel like another obligation. They change frequency and focus.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14839
S9.8Remote session: camera off, distracted or multitasking Camera off, typing sounds, delayed answers. Short replies.
What is happening Client distracted or unseen in remote sessionsCoach move Name it; agree remote norms; help them arrive
In the room
Camera off, typing sounds, delayed answers. Short replies.
What’s underneath
Remote coaching needs agreed norms. Distraction may be workload, avoidance or connection problems. Naming it and agreeing what works helps the session be useful.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Getting irritated. Assuming bad faith.
Example
A client keeps checking email during sessions. The coach names it and asks what would help them be present. They agree to start each session with two minutes of settling.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1732
S9.12New or re-formed team with unclear roles Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.
What is happening Team is new or changed; roles and agreements are unclearCoach move Contract at team level: purpose, roles, decision rights, ways of working
In the room
Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.
What’s underneath
New teams need explicit agreements about purpose, roles and ways of working. Without them, people fill gaps based on old habits, and friction appears as personal conflict. Contracting at team level is the work.
Avoid here
Jumping to team-building games. Letting the leader define everything alone. Treating role confusion as a personality problem.
Example
After a merger, two teams become one. The coach runs a session where each person maps what they think they own. Gaps and overlaps become visible, and the team writes a one-page charter.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods163342

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Skipping contract to appear efficient.
  • Choosing the topic for the client because it’s more interesting to the coach.
  • Contracting so tightly that live, emerging material has no room to surface.
  • Becoming the enforcer of someone else’s (boss/HR/partner’s) assigned agenda.

10Client traps

  • Listing everything so that nothing specific can be finished.
  • Offering the “safe” topic instead of the real one.
  • Wanting the coach to pick the topic, then resenting the choice.

Three worked problems

1

Director with six fires. Client arrives with a reorg, a difficult report, a board pack, a stalled hire, Sunday dread, and “I think I might leave.” Coach contracts: “If this hour could resolve only one thing enough that the rest gets quieter, which?” Client chooses Sunday dread. Underneath it sits the leave question. The other five become context, not the agenda. Forward move: one conversation with the sponsor this week, not a six-item plan.

2

HR-sent “presence” client. Official topic is executive presence. After contract questions, the client admits the real heat is a peer who took credit for their work. Coach names both agendas and finds the overlap: one visible moment in Thursday’s leadership meeting. Presence work becomes a specific scene, not a vague personality project.

3

Mid-session drift. Thirty minutes in, the contracted topic is a hiring decision, but the client’s body lights up when they mention their father retiring. Coach re-contracts live: “The energy just moved. Stay with the hire, or spend the remaining time on what just arrived?” Client takes fifteen minutes on the new material, then returns to one decision criterion for the hire. Both threads land.

Where it comes from

Contracting is a foundation of professional coaching and is part of the core competencies of the major coaching bodies. Session-level contracting is also central to transactional analysis (Eric Berne).

My notes

2
Open family

Expand the Topic

Core move: Pull impact, pattern, feeling — not more plot
5 options10 questions6 situations

1What it really is

This method pulls out context, impact, pattern, feeling, and the unsaid — not more plot. It is the antidote to a client who tells a fluent, well-rehearsed story that has already been told, word for word, to a partner, a friend, and a mirror.

Expanding means asking for the dimensions of the topic the client hasn’t already put into words: how long it has been going on, what it costs them and others, where else it shows up in their life, how it feels in the moment, and what they haven’t said yet. The coach is not collecting more events or more characters; more plot only makes the story longer, not deeper. Each question invites the client to look at the same situation from a slightly different side.

It sounds like: “What does this cost you, week to week?”, “Where else does this pattern show up?”, or “What haven’t you said about this yet?” It is not an investigation, and the coach doesn’t need to understand every detail to be useful. The goal is for the client to see more of their own topic, not for the coach to become an expert in it. The best signs that it is working are that the client slows down, reaches for new words, pauses before answering, or says something like “I hadn’t thought about it that way.”

4How it works, deeply

A rehearsed story is stable precisely because it has been repeated — repetition is a social technology that keeps an experience at arm’s length so the teller doesn’t have to feel it again. Expanding works by refusing the plot (“then what happened”) and instead asking for dimensions the rehearsed version has never been asked to supply: duration, impact, pattern, feeling. New language is the signal that the expansion has worked — if the client’s phrasing doesn’t change, the method hasn’t landed yet.

There is a memory mechanism behind this. Each time a story is retold, the brain retrieves the most recent version rather than the original experience, so the story becomes smoother and thinner with every telling. Questions about impact, pattern and feeling send the client back to the experience itself, where details that never made it into the story are still available. That is why expansion often brings back memories, sensations or connections the client hadn’t thought about in years.

Expansion also tests the size and shape of the topic before the coach commits to a direction. A topic that sounds like a conflict with one colleague may turn out, once the pattern is explored, to be a recurring theme across several relationships. The coach is not being thorough for its own sake: they are making sure the session works on the real topic rather than the most recently rehearsed one. Done well, it also helps the client feel deeply heard, which builds the trust that later, more challenging methods depend on.

Quick card

Reach for it when
First version sounds rehearsed, thin, or only the official plot
The move
Pull context, impact, pattern, feeling, the unsaid
Watch
Expand to create new language, not to collect more plot.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What else is there about this?
  2. How long have you been carrying this?
  3. What pattern do you recognize here?
  4. What part is in your control, and what part is not?

2The client’s context

The client is giving a “press release” version of events: competent, low-emotion, and identical to how they’ve described it elsewhere. They may sound articulate and even insightful, but nothing new is arriving in the room — the coach is simply the fourth audience for a fixed script. Sometimes the story is thin because it’s a slogan (“I need more balance”) rather than an account. Sometimes it’s narrated as if by an outside observer, with no body in it at all.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses which dimension to pull on:

1Impact — “how does this affect your day-to-day, not the plot?”
2Duration — “how long have you been carrying this?”
3Pattern — “what do you recognize here that has happened before?”
4Control split — “what part is yours to move, and what part isn’t?”
5The unsaid word — “if you said this for the first time, what word would you actually use?”

5Where it gets stuck

The coach collects more inbox-level detail. The client feels heard the way a reporter is heard — accurately, but not met. No new language appears, because the questions are still asking for more plot.

6How to move it forward

Stop asking “what happened next.” Explicitly change altitude — ask about feeling or body sensation instead of narrative. Ask directly: “If you said this for the first time, what word would you use?”

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What else is there about this?
  • How long have you been carrying this?
  • What pattern do you recognize here?
  • What part is in your control, and what part is not?
  • How does this affect you in your day-to-day — not the story, the impact?
Going further
  • If a close friend who knew nothing about this heard only the feeling behind it, what would they hear?
  • What are you leaving out of the version you usually tell?
  • Whose version of this story have you been repeating — yours, or someone else’s framing of it?
  • What does this cost you that doesn’t show up in the retelling?
  • If this story had a soundtrack, what would it sound like right now?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.1Telling a rehearsed story Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Lo…
What is happening Fluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotionCoach move Expand: “What else?” / impact / feeling
In the room
Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Low emotion. They sound competent and slightly bored by their own plot.
What’s underneath
The first version is almost never wrong; it is rarely complete. Rehearsal is a social technology: it keeps the story stable so the teller does not have to feel it again. Professional coaching needs the unstable layer — impact, pattern, the word they are not using.
Avoid here
Preferred future too early (they have not arrived in the present). Reframe before they feel heard (lands as “you did not listen to my official version”). Generating options (there is no new material to option from). Pre-mortem (there is no plan; there is a performance).
Example
A VP tells a smooth story of a “difficult stakeholder.” Dates, emails, tone. Coach hears it once, then asks for impact. New sentence: “I rewrite every message three times and I hate who I am at 11pm.” That sentence is the topic. The stakeholder is context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods235673139
S1.9Skimming / staying on the surface Short answers. “It’s fine.” Jumps topics. Jokes away. No dwell time.
What is happening Short answers, “it’s fine”, jumps topics, jokes awayCoach move Slow down. One thread. Reflect + silence. Invite the unsaid
In the room
Short answers. “It’s fine.” Jumps topics. Jokes away. No dwell time.
What’s underneath
Surface is often safety, not shallowness. Chasing every new topic they offer as escape trains the dodge. One thread + silence is the intervention.
Avoid here
And-what-else as a machine gun. Deep identity work before safety. Challenge.
Example
Client hopscotches from team to school to a podcast they heard. Coach returns to “it’s fine.” Under it: they were copied off a thread. Two minutes there is the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods127
S1.11Over-specific / lost in detail Names, dates, emails, who said what. Inbox as the room.
What is happening Names, dates, emails, who said whatCoach move Zoom out to pattern, purpose, and what they want instead
In the room
Names, dates, emails, who said what. Inbox as the room.
What’s underneath
Detail can be a hiding place — from feeling, from pattern, from a decision. Harvest one pattern, then leave the inbox.
Avoid here
Following each email. Clean language on every proper noun.
Example
Twelve-message CC war. Chapter title: “I will not ask directly.” Pattern, then one request. Inbox closed.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2639
S1.13Avoiding the real topic Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.
What is happening Safe issue up front, energy elsewhere, late-session revealCoach move Follow energy, not the official title. Name the mismatch
In the room
Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.
What’s underneath
Avoidance is information about cost and safety, not a character flaw. Name the mismatch; do not ambush. They choose.
Avoid here
Clever “gotcha.” Deep dive with eight minutes left. Reframe of the safe topic as if it were the work.
Example
Official: calendar. Heat: “my partner booked this.” Offer the observation. They choose the authorship topic. Calendar was the costume.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12714
S2.2Numb / flat / shutdown Monotone. “Whatever.” Low energy. No charge.
What is happening Monotone, “whatever”, low energy, no chargeCoach move Gentle sensory/body, tiny scales, exception, warmth without pressure
In the room
Monotone. “Whatever.” Low energy. No charge.
What’s underneath
Shutdown is not the absence of a topic; it is a nervous-system setting. Turning enthusiasm to ten usually deepens it. Raise volume one notch: tiny scale, flicker, safe sliver.
Avoid here
Rally speeches. Who-you-need-to-be as a trumpet. Preferred-future cinema.
Example
“Career is fine I guess.” 5% care: they still notice ugly slide design. Tiny act: one craft conversation. Aliveness returns without a purpose workshop.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2531
S7.37Role reshaped or threatened by AI and automation Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What is happening Work changing because of AI or automation; uncertainty about the futureCoach move Separate tasks from value; picture two futures; run small experiments
In the room
Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What’s underneath
Some tasks will change; the client’s value is rarely only the tasks. Coaching helps separate fact from fear, find which strengths become more valuable, and run experiments with the new tools rather than waiting.
Avoid here
Reassuring that nothing will change. Predicting the future. Pure technical advice.
Example
A copywriter fears AI will replace her. Coach separates tasks from value. She experiments with AI tools for drafts and repositions as a brand strategist.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods29242636

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Expanding purely to seem thorough.
  • Interrupting the first telling just to appear clever.
  • Expanding indefinitely and never converging on a focus.

10Client traps

  • Offering more plot as proof of effort (“I’m really working on this, see how much detail I have”).
  • Staying inside the version already told to three other people because it’s safer.

Three worked problems

1

“My stakeholder is difficult.” Rehearsed story of missed emails and tone. Expanding to impact reveals the client is pre-writing every message three times and not sleeping before the Tuesday forum. New language: “I am managing their mood instead of the work.” That sentence becomes the real topic.

2

“I need better work-life balance.” A slogan. Expanding with “how long have you been carrying this?” surfaces eight years. Pattern: every promotion buys six months of chaos, then a promise to reset. New language: “I keep selling future-me a life current-me will not live.”

3

Conflict story with no feeling. Client can quote exact dates but no emotion. Expanding into the room (“what are you feeling as you tell this right now?”) reveals a tight jaw: “Protecting a team that doesn’t know I’m protecting them.” Work moves from the email chain to the unspoken protector role.

Where it comes from

Draws on person-centred listening (Carl Rogers) and the exploratory questioning common to most coaching models.

My notes

3
Open family

And What Else?

Core move: Repeat until the known list is exhausted
5 options10 questions7 situations

1What it really is

A simple, repeated prompt used to exhaust the known list until something unrehearsed appears. It is deceptively minimal — the power is entirely in the repetition and the willingness to sit past the point of discomfort where most conversations stop.

The coach asks one short question, “And what else?”, then waits, and asks again, often three, four or five times. The first answers come quickly because they are stored and ready. Later answers come slowly, because the client has to look for them rather than fetch them, and that is where the useful material tends to be. The coach’s job is to keep the tone curious and light, so that the repetition feels like an invitation rather than pressure.

It sounds like: “And what else?”, “What else might be in the way?”, or “Is there anything else, even something small?” It is not a technique for filling silence, and it shouldn’t be fired off like a reflex; each repetition needs real space after it. It also has a natural end: when the client genuinely says “that’s it” after a pause, the coach stops and works with what has emerged. A good marker that it has worked is an answer that surprises the client themselves, often introduced with “Actually…” or “This might sound silly, but…”

4How it works, deeply

Most people’s first three answers to any hard question are the ones they’ve already rehearsed defending — to a boss, a partner, or themselves. The fourth or fifth answer is usually the first one that hasn’t been pressure-tested, which is exactly why it’s more honest and more uncomfortable. The method works because the pause after “and what else?” is where the client has to generate something new instead of retrieving something stored.

The question is effective partly because it is so plain. It carries no hypothesis, no suggestion and no direction, so the client cannot pick up from it what the coach thinks the answer should be. Every answer has to come from the client. Its repetition also communicates something important without saying it: that the coach has time, is not satisfied with the first easy answers, and believes there is more the client knows than they have yet said.

The method also works on the coach. Asking “and what else?” instead of jumping in with an observation or an idea holds back the coach’s natural urge to advise, which Michael Bungay Stanier has called the “advice monster.” This keeps the conversation exploratory for longer and stops the coach from fixing the wrong problem too early. It is especially valuable at the start of a session, when the first topic offered is often not the most important one, and at the end, when the most useful action may be the one that hasn’t been mentioned yet.

Quick card

Reach for it when
First answer is the known data-dump; need the unknown
The move
Repeat until the known is exhausted and something new appears
Watch
Stop when energy shifts or they say “that’s all” and mean it. Then work that last piece.
Four questions that often open it
  1. And what else?
  2. What else matters about this?
  3. What else are you not saying?
  4. What else do you want from this?

2The client’s context

The client gives a tidy, data-dump-style first answer — often exactly three items, the “official” reasons. A competent client will often stop right where the socially acceptable answer ends. Something unsaid is usually sitting just behind that tidy list, and it rarely appears on the first pass.

3The coach’s options

The coach can direct the repetition at different targets:

1Exhaust the known list — keep asking until the client runs out of the obvious.
2Exhaust the polite version — explicitly invite the unwise, embarrassing, or “shouldn’t say this out loud” answer.
3Exhaust options before choosing — useful in a decision-making moment, not just a feelings moment.
4Exhaust stakeholders — “who else is affected, and what else?”
5Trust that the last item is often the real item.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach becomes a tape recorder — repeating “and what else” without warmth turns it into interrogation. Alternatively, the coach stops one item too early (missing the real one) or continues past the point where the energy already shifted (grinding a dead well).

6How to move it forward

Stop the moment energy visibly shifts, or the client says “that’s all” and clearly means it — then work that last piece. If the client keeps looping the same three items, name the loop directly and ask what they’re not saying.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • And what else?
  • What else matters about this?
  • What else are you not saying?
  • What else do you want from this?
  • If there were one more thing you almost didn’t mention?
Going further
  • What’s the version of this you’d only say if I promised not to react?
  • If your answer had to surprise even you, what would it be?
  • What’s on the list that you’ve decided doesn’t count?
  • If you had to add one more reason that makes you slightly uncomfortable, what is it?
  • What would the fifth reason be, if there had to be a fifth?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.1Telling a rehearsed story Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Lo…
What is happening Fluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotionCoach move Expand: “What else?” / impact / feeling
In the room
Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Low emotion. They sound competent and slightly bored by their own plot.
What’s underneath
The first version is almost never wrong; it is rarely complete. Rehearsal is a social technology: it keeps the story stable so the teller does not have to feel it again. Professional coaching needs the unstable layer — impact, pattern, the word they are not using.
Avoid here
Preferred future too early (they have not arrived in the present). Reframe before they feel heard (lands as “you did not listen to my official version”). Generating options (there is no new material to option from). Pre-mortem (there is no plan; there is a performance).
Example
A VP tells a smooth story of a “difficult stakeholder.” Dates, emails, tone. Coach hears it once, then asks for impact. New sentence: “I rewrite every message three times and I hate who I am at 11pm.” That sentence is the topic. The stakeholder is context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods235673139
S5.4No options they can see “There is no way.” Frozen imagination.
What is happening “There is no way”Coach move Invent 8 ideas including bad ones. Constraint-busting. Borrow others’ moves
In the room
“There is no way.” Frozen imagination.
What’s underneath
First “no options” is usually freeze, not physics. Invent eight including unwise. Constraint-busting.
Avoid here
Picking from their empty list. Premature experiment.
Example
“Cannot move the date.” Eight options include lying, cutting 40%, pairing, public tradeoff. Option 9: cut scope and say the tradeoff sentence. Imagination thaws.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods32122
S7.32Job search / in-between identity Lost title. Narrative wobble.
What is happening Lost title, narrative wobbleCoach move Story of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications
In the room
Lost title. Narrative wobble.
What’s underneath
The search is a meaning project as well as a market project. Story of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications.
Avoid here
Only job-search tactics. Only identity fog with no market move.
Example
Ex-title wobble. Alive story: they design conditions for teams to decide. Experiment: two conversations in that language, not 40 generic applications. Chapter change, not apology.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3935
S8.4Agrees with everything (false harmony) Nodding. No friction. No energy.
What is happening Nodding, no friction, no energyCoach move Invite disagreement. Look for the place they don’t buy it
In the room
Nodding. No friction. No energy.
What’s underneath
Harmony can be a way not to be known. Invite disagreement. Look for the place they don’t buy it.
Avoid here
Taking nods as success.
Example
Nods through a reframe. “Where am I off?” “This isn’t about presence.” Real topic appears once disagreement is legal.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3
S8.18Client far more senior or powerful than the coach The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.
What is happening Large status gap; coach tempted to defer or impressCoach move Contract for challenge; stay curious and independent
In the room
The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.
What’s underneath
Seniority and status are part of the room. If the coach defers, the client loses the challenge they need. The coach’s value is in their questions and their independence, not in matching the client’s status.
Avoid here
Deference. Performing expertise. Avoiding challenge.
Example
A new coach working with a CEO keeps agreeing. In supervision, the coach realises this. Next session they contract openly for challenge.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13728
S9.1First session or chemistry meeting Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What is happening First meeting; deciding whether to work together and howCoach move Show how you work; clarify expectations, confidentiality and fit
In the room
Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What’s underneath
The chemistry session is about fit and expectations, not proving brilliance. The coach should show how they work, clarify what coaching is and isn’t, and help the client decide.
Avoid here
Over-selling. Starting deep work before the contract is agreed. Being vague about logistics and confidentiality.
Example
A client asks how coaching will help. The coach does a short taste of coaching on a real topic, then explains confidentiality, sponsor involvement and how they would work together.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods136821
S9.9Team session: one voice dominates One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What is happening Team coaching; one person fills the spaceCoach move Structure turn-taking; widen perspectives; use spatial mapping
In the room
One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What’s underneath
Dominance may be habit, status or anxiety. Others’ silence may be agreement, fear or disengagement. The team coach balances voices without shaming anyone.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Publicly shutting the person down. Letting the session become a monologue.
Example
In a leadership team session, the CEO answers every question. The coach uses a round where each person speaks in turn, then a spatial map where each person places themselves.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods311293033

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Using it mechanically, without warmth, so it feels like a script.
  • Missing the exact moment the last, real item lands and moving past it too fast.

10Client traps

  • Filling the silence with more of the same category of answer, to look thorough.
  • Performing completeness rather than actually searching.

Three worked problems

1

Why they might leave. Reasons 1–3: pay, title, commute. “And what else?” A long silence, then: “I don’t respect the new CEO.” That’s the real work.

2

Options for a team issue. Client offers feedback, PIP, ignore. “And what else — including unwise?” produces: “Move them laterally.” “Do their job for them.” “Tell the truth that I hired the wrong person.” The last one is the avoided conversation.

3

What they want from coaching. “Clarity. A plan. Accountability.” And what else? “Someone who will not flinch if I say I want out.” The contract for the whole engagement changes.

Where it comes from

Popularised as the “AWE question” (“And what else?”) by Michael Bungay Stanier in The Coaching Habit.

My notes

4
Open family

Scale the Topic

Core move: Fog into a number; work +1 only
6 options10 questions9 situations

1What it really is

Turning vague, fog-like language (“things feel off”) into a number on a 1–10 scale, then working the increment right above where the client already is — never jumping straight to an imagined “10.”

Scaling gives a vague, hard-to-grasp feeling a simple number, so that both coach and client have something definite to work with. The coach asks where things are now on a 1–10 scale, then asks why it isn’t lower, which uncovers what is already working, and finally what one point higher would look like in daily life. The number itself has no objective meaning; what matters is what it represents to this client, in their own terms.

It sounds like: “On a scale of 1 to 10, where are you with this today?”, “What makes it a 4 and not a 2?”, or “What would a 5 look like on a normal Tuesday?” It is not a measurement exercise, a performance rating or a target to hit. It also works well across sessions, because the client can check in on the same scale and notice movement that would otherwise feel invisible. You know it has worked when the client can name one small, concrete thing that would move them up a single point this week.

4How it works, deeply

A number is not the point — the number’s only job is to become a handle the coach can pull on. Two moves make this work: (1) anchoring the number in a specific Tuesday-afternoon scene rather than leaving it as an abstract rating, and (2) refusing to let the client or the coach fixate on “10.” The gap between “wherever they are” and “one step better” is almost always small, concrete, and doable this week — the gap to “10” almost never is.

Scaling works because it gives shape to something with no edges. A feeling like “things are off” offers nothing to grip, while “a 4” immediately invites comparison: compared to what, compared to when, and what would make it different? The follow-up question “why not lower?” is often the most valuable part, because it makes the client name the resources and efforts that are already holding things up, which they usually overlook. This comes from solution-focused practice, where scaling questions are one of the core tools.

The “one step up” rule respects how change actually happens. Large leaps tend to trigger doubt and resistance, while small steps feel safe and are more likely to be taken. Each small step also produces evidence that change is possible, which builds confidence for the next one. Scales are flexible too: they can measure confidence, motivation, readiness, progress or importance, and using two scales side by side (for example importance and confidence) often shows exactly where the block is.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Vague language; need foothold, resources, next step
The move
Turn fog into a number, then work +1 and what is already working
Watch
Do not ask how to jump from 4 to 10. Work the next increment.
Four questions that often open it
  1. On a 1–10, where is this now?
  2. What already got you to that number rather than lower?
  3. What would +1 look like, specifically?
  4. When have you been higher on this scale before — what were you doing then?

2The client’s context

The client is speaking in abstractions with no foothold: “off,” “not great,” “I don’t know.” They need a concrete resource point to work from, not a leap to an idealized end-state that feels unreachable and therefore paralyzing.

3The coach’s options

Several scales are available depending on the presenting issue:

1Intensity scale — how bad, or how true, is this right now?
2Confidence scale — for an upcoming event or decision.
3Readiness-to-act scale — distinct from confidence; measures willingness to move.
4Relationship-quality scale — for interpersonal topics.
5Recovery/energy scale — for burnout or depletion.
6Historical scale — “when have you been higher on this before?” — mining the client’s own track record as evidence.

5Where it gets stuck

The client argues with the number itself (“is it a 4 or a 5?”) instead of using it as a tool. The coach treats “10” as the homework. The number becomes another abstraction with no Tuesday scene attached to it.

6How to move it forward

Anchor the number: “what does a 5 look like on Tuesday at 4pm?” Work only the +1 move. Harvest what already got them off the floor — the distance already travelled from 1 to their current number is itself useful data.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • On a 1–10, where is this now?
  • What already got you to that number rather than lower?
  • What would +1 look like, specifically?
  • When have you been higher on this scale before — what were you doing then?
  • Where is this number in your week, not in your head?
Going further
  • If the number went down by one instead of up, what would have to happen?
  • Who else would rate this differently than you just did, and why?
  • What would need to be true for you to say the number is wrong?
  • If you described a 7 the way you just described this number, what would change first?
  • What’s the smallest evidence that would move the number even a little?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.2Stuck in the problem Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the prese…
What is happening Problem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted lifeCoach move Preferred future / miracle / visualization
In the room
Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the present-continuous of suffering. Options, if any, are all forms of “stop the pain,” not “live something.”
What’s underneath
Solution-focused and narrative work share a claim: options generated against a fog of not-wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. The nervous system orients toward what it can picture. No picture, no true choice.
Avoid here
Future questions while flooded (capacity is offline — regulate first). More analysis, clean language on problem-words only, or option-generation from inside the trance. Pre-mortem (adds more doom to a doom-only map).
Example
Product lead can describe six reasons a launch is doomed. Miracle first sign: they open Slack without a spike in the chest, and the stand-up starts with one risk, not twelve. Piece already slightly true on Thursdays after a run. Experiment: protect that Thursday condition twice this week, then look at the launch from there.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods45621222324
S1.5Overwhelmed Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to …
What is happening Too much at once, pressure, no footholdCoach move Exceptions, resources, +1 on the scale
In the room
Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to outrun the body.
What’s underneath
An overloaded system cannot use a big plan. Load reduction and resource-finding are regulation, not soft extras. +1 and exceptions restore a sense of authorship without pretending the load is imaginary.
Avoid here
Giant homework. Preferred-future montage. Pre-mortem (more future weight). Who-would-you-need-to-be as a heroic identity.
Example
Six workstreams plus a sick parent. Exception: last Thursday when they declined two meetings. +1: decline the standing Thursday review that produces no decisions. Not a life-redesign.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods145740
S1.7Ready to move Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what…
What is happening Forward energy, asks for next step, new language already appearingCoach move Options, experiments, who they would need to be
In the room
Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what I need to do is…”
What’s underneath
Continued exploration at this point is often the coach’s need for thoroughness. Readiness is perishable. Land while the nervous system is still organized toward action.
Avoid here
More expand. Miracle question. Clean language archaeology. Another reframe “to be sure.”
Example
After naming “I have been managing their mood,” client is already drafting a sentence. Coach skips another why. One dated conversation Friday. Success = it happened.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods435363738
S3.13Feeling-only / no structure Mood as the only compass. No facts, dates, tests.
What is happening Mood as the only compassCoach move Add facts, scale, experiment, time
In the room
Mood as the only compass. No facts, dates, tests.
What’s underneath
Feelings are data, not the whole brief. Add facts, scale, experiment, time.
Avoid here
Only more feeling. Only a spreadsheet that shames feeling.
Example
“This job is wrong” at intensity 8, evidence 4. 2-week test: three named conditions logged daily. Structure supports the feeling; doesn’t obey it blindly.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods4
S6.26Chronic illness or health limits reshaping work (including menopause) Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What is happening Health limits energy or capacity; fear of being judged as unreliableCoach move Sort control; redesign work around real limits; plan the conversations
In the room
Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What’s underneath
Health changes the resources available, not the person’s value. The coaching challenge is redesigning work around real limits, communicating needs, and dealing with the identity hit. Medical questions belong with medical professionals.
Avoid here
Medical advice. Pushing performance goals as if health is unchanged. Treating it as purely a mindset issue.
Example
A senior lawyer going through menopause has poor sleep and brain fog. Coach helps sort what’s in her control, plan demanding work for her best hours, and prepare a conversation with HR.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods416323640
S8.7Silence that is stuck / freeze Blank. Frozen. Long and tight.
What is happening Blank, frozen, long and tightCoach move Offer a ramp: scale, choice, image, “would it help if…”
In the room
Blank. Frozen. Long and tight.
What’s underneath
Do not stare them down. Offer a ramp: scale, guess, two doors, “would it help if…”
Avoid here
More silence as purity.
Example
Tight blank after “shame.” Two doors: stay with the body, or talk about the meeting facts first. They pick facts, then return. Ramp, not stare.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods4
S8.17Signs of substance misuse Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.
What is happening Hints of using alcohol or substances to copeCoach move Notice and ask respectfully; evoke their own view; refer if they want help
In the room
Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.
What’s underneath
The coach is not there to diagnose or treat. But they can notice, ask with respect, and use a non-judgemental, motivational approach to help the client think about it. If the client wants help, the coach can point them to professional support.
Avoid here
Lecturing, labelling, or ignoring obvious signs. Acting as a counsellor.
Example
A sales director jokes about needing three drinks after every call. Coach asks, without judgement, how they feel about it. The client admits it worries them and agrees to talk to their doctor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods47840
S9.4Coaching isn’t working Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What is happening Sessions repeat without progress; frustration on one or both sidesCoach move Name it openly; review goals, fit and approach together
In the room
Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What’s underneath
Lack of progress is information. The topic, the fit, the timing or the method may be wrong. Naming it openly is better than carrying on politely.
Avoid here
Blaming the client. Pretending it’s fine. Trying harder with the same approach.
Example
After six sessions, nothing has changed. The coach names it and asks what isn’t working. The client admits the real topic is leaving, not leadership.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293439
S9.7Repeated cancellations or no-shows Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.
What is happening Sessions keep being cancelled or missedCoach move Name the pattern without blame; re-contract
In the room
Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.
What’s underneath
Repeated cancellations are information: about priority, avoidance, workload, or fit. Naming the pattern, without blame, helps the client decide what they want.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Getting annoyed. Making assumptions.
Example
A client cancels three times. The coach names the pattern kindly. The client admits the sessions feel like another obligation. They change frequency and focus.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14839

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Coaching toward the “jump” to a much higher number instead of the next increment.
  • Debating the rating itself rather than using it as a tool.
  • Forgetting to translate the number into a concrete scene (“film” it).

10Client traps

  • Picking a socially acceptable number rather than an honest one.
  • Using the scale to stay conceptual and avoid specificity.

Three worked problems

1

Confidence at 4 before a board meeting. +1 is not “be confident.” +1 is sending the pre-read 24 hours earlier and asking one director a question in the first ten minutes — something they’ve already done successfully in a product review.

2

Overwhelm at 2. What got them off 1? Two protected mornings. +1 is restoring one of those mornings this week, not a full wellness overhaul.

3

Relationship with a peer at 3. Higher last year when they had a weekly 15-minute standup. The experiment is restarting that specific practice, not a big “reset conversation.”

Where it comes from

Scaling questions come from solution-focused brief therapy (Steve de Shazer, Insoo Kim Berg and colleagues).

My notes

5
Open family

Exceptions and Resources

Core move: Find when it’s less true; do more of that
5 options10 questions17 situations

1What it really is

Finding the moments when the problem is less true, and doing more of whatever was different in those moments. This is distinct from Scale (method 4) in that it’s not measuring intensity — it’s hunting for concrete counter-examples to the claim “this is always true.”

Every problem has exceptions: days when it was a little better, moments when it didn’t happen, situations where the client handled it well. This method makes those exceptions the focus. The coach asks the client to describe one in detail (what was different, what they did, who was there, what time of day it was) and then explores how to recreate those conditions on purpose. It comes from solution-focused practice, where the working assumption is that the client already has more of the answer than they realise.

It sounds like: “Tell me about a time this was even slightly less of a problem”, “What were you doing differently then?”, or “What would it take to have one more day like that this week?” It is not a way of telling the client their problem isn’t real, and it never starts before the difficulty has been fully heard. It also doesn’t need dramatic successes; small, ordinary exceptions are often the most repeatable. It has worked when the client identifies a specific condition or action that they can deliberately try again.

4How it works, deeply

This method rests on a simple but easily-skipped discipline: hear the pain first. If a coach jumps to “well, when has it been better?” before the client feels heard, it lands as denial of their difficulty rather than useful inquiry. Once heard, exceptions function as evidence — proof that the client already possesses the resource needed, under specific conditions that can be identified and deliberately recreated. This is fundamentally different from a pep talk, because it’s built entirely from the client’s own lived history rather than the coach’s optimism.

The method challenges the way problems feel total. When people describe a problem, they usually speak in absolutes, “always,” “never,” “every time,” because the brain remembers difficult moments more vividly than ordinary or good ones. Searching for exceptions corrects that bias with real data. Each exception is small proof that the problem is not constant, and that something about the client or their circumstances can make a difference.

Exceptions also contain the beginnings of a solution that already fits the client. A strategy built from what worked last Tuesday is far more likely to work again than advice from outside, because it already fits their skills, their environment and their style. The coach’s job is to slow the client down enough to notice the details of what was different, since clients often dismiss exceptions as luck. Turning “that was a fluke” into “that happened because I…” is the key shift, because it gives the client agency over something they previously felt happened to them.

Quick card

Reach for it when
They talk as if the problem is 100% present, 100% of the time
The move
Find when it is less true and do more of that
Watch
Do not skip pain. Harvest resources after they have been heard.
Four questions that often open it
  1. When is this not a problem, or less of one?
  2. What is already working, even a little?
  3. When have you handled something similar?
  4. What strengths are you using without noticing?

2The client’s context

The client is speaking as if the problem is 100% present, 100% of the time — a “deficit trance.” Competence they’ve already demonstrated has been forgotten or discounted, often as luck, timing, or someone else’s help rather than their own skill.

3The coach’s options

Five places to look for exceptions:

1Time exceptions — is it different on Tuesday than Thursday?
2Context exceptions — better with this person than that one?
3Historical exceptions — have they handled a “cousin” version of this before?
4Hidden strengths already in use — noticed by nobody, including the client.
5Micro-exceptions the client discounts — small wins dismissed as “that doesn’t count” or “just luck.”

5Where it gets stuck

The coach skips past the pain straight into cheerleading, and the client feels unseen. Or, the opposite failure: the coach surfaces exceptions so early that the client doubles down, insisting “you don’t get how bad it really is” to defend the scale of the problem.

6How to move it forward

Hear the pain first, fully. Then ask for “10% less heavy” rather than a full turnaround. Treat exceptions strictly as data to be examined, not as a reason to feel better.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • When is this not a problem, or less of one?
  • What is already working, even a little?
  • When have you handled something similar?
  • What strengths are you using without noticing?
  • What is already giving life to this, even a little?
Going further
  • What’s different about the days this doesn’t happen?
  • Who is around, or not around, when this is at its least intense?
  • What did you do the last time this got even slightly better, that you might have stopped doing since?
  • If someone secretly filmed your best week with this, what would they see you doing?
  • What’s the smallest condition, if recreated, that would make tomorrow 5% easier?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.1Telling a rehearsed story Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Lo…
What is happening Fluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotionCoach move Expand: “What else?” / impact / feeling
In the room
Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Low emotion. They sound competent and slightly bored by their own plot.
What’s underneath
The first version is almost never wrong; it is rarely complete. Rehearsal is a social technology: it keeps the story stable so the teller does not have to feel it again. Professional coaching needs the unstable layer — impact, pattern, the word they are not using.
Avoid here
Preferred future too early (they have not arrived in the present). Reframe before they feel heard (lands as “you did not listen to my official version”). Generating options (there is no new material to option from). Pre-mortem (there is no plan; there is a performance).
Example
A VP tells a smooth story of a “difficult stakeholder.” Dates, emails, tone. Coach hears it once, then asks for impact. New sentence: “I rewrite every message three times and I hate who I am at 11pm.” That sentence is the topic. The stakeholder is context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods235673139
S1.2Stuck in the problem Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the prese…
What is happening Problem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted lifeCoach move Preferred future / miracle / visualization
In the room
Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the present-continuous of suffering. Options, if any, are all forms of “stop the pain,” not “live something.”
What’s underneath
Solution-focused and narrative work share a claim: options generated against a fog of not-wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. The nervous system orients toward what it can picture. No picture, no true choice.
Avoid here
Future questions while flooded (capacity is offline — regulate first). More analysis, clean language on problem-words only, or option-generation from inside the trance. Pre-mortem (adds more doom to a doom-only map).
Example
Product lead can describe six reasons a launch is doomed. Miracle first sign: they open Slack without a spike in the chest, and the stand-up starts with one risk, not twelve. Piece already slightly true on Thursdays after a run. Experiment: protect that Thursday condition twice this week, then look at the launch from there.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods45621222324
S1.5Overwhelmed Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to …
What is happening Too much at once, pressure, no footholdCoach move Exceptions, resources, +1 on the scale
In the room
Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to outrun the body.
What’s underneath
An overloaded system cannot use a big plan. Load reduction and resource-finding are regulation, not soft extras. +1 and exceptions restore a sense of authorship without pretending the load is imaginary.
Avoid here
Giant homework. Preferred-future montage. Pre-mortem (more future weight). Who-would-you-need-to-be as a heroic identity.
Example
Six workstreams plus a sick parent. Exception: last Thursday when they declined two meetings. +1: decline the standing Thursday review that produces no decisions. Not a life-redesign.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods145740
S1.17Very little language / “I don’t know” Shrugging. One-word answers. Blank look. Long gaps that are empty rather than working.
What is happening Shrugging, one-word answers, blank lookCoach move Offer structure: scale, image, guess, body, either/or
In the room
Shrugging. One-word answers. Blank look. Long gaps that are empty rather than working.
What’s underneath
“I don’t know” is often “I haven’t looked yet” or “it is unsafe to know.” Structure is kindness: scale, image, guess, either/or. Staring them down is not presence.
Avoid here
Wide open “what do you want from your life.” Challenge. Question cube.
Example
New director, one-word answers. Two doors: “the role, or the loneliness in it.” They pick loneliness. Language appears once the door is smaller.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5631
S1.20Wanting a diagnosis or label “What’s wrong with me?” “Am I a bad leader?” They want a verdict they can either collapse under or fight.
What is happening “What’s wrong with me?”, “Am I a bad leader?”Coach move Stay descriptive, not diagnostic. Separate identity from pattern
In the room
“What’s wrong with me?” “Am I a bad leader?” They want a verdict they can either collapse under or fight.
What’s underneath
Labels shrink possibility. Coaching describes patterns and choices. Diagnosis-hunger is often a wish for the uncertainty to end.
Avoid here
Informal diagnosis (“you’re a classic imposter”). Therapy-speak beyond contract. Reassurance only.
Example
“Am I an alcoholic leader or just stressed?” Coach stays in scope: the Friday snap pattern, sleep, what they want instead. Flag other support if clinical. No verdict from the coaching chair.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods51335
S2.2Numb / flat / shutdown Monotone. “Whatever.” Low energy. No charge.
What is happening Monotone, “whatever”, low energy, no chargeCoach move Gentle sensory/body, tiny scales, exception, warmth without pressure
In the room
Monotone. “Whatever.” Low energy. No charge.
What’s underneath
Shutdown is not the absence of a topic; it is a nervous-system setting. Turning enthusiasm to ten usually deepens it. Raise volume one notch: tiny scale, flicker, safe sliver.
Avoid here
Rally speeches. Who-you-need-to-be as a trumpet. Preferred-future cinema.
Example
“Career is fine I guess.” 5% care: they still notice ugly slide design. Tiny act: one craft conversation. Aliveness returns without a purpose workshop.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2531
S2.10Disappointed after a setback Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What is happening Deflation after effort, “why bother”Coach move Acknowledge the hit. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions
In the room
Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What’s underneath
The hit is real. Toxic positivity here breaks trust. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions. Smallest act of continuing.
Avoid here
Immediate next mountain. “Everything happens for…”
Example
Launch missed. Took: a quarter and a narrative. Did not take: their judgment with customers. Exception: 2019 dip → short learning review with one ally. Same move, sized small.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods59132241
S2.16Burned out / depleted Cynicism. Exhaustion. Sunday dread. Numbness plus irritability.
What is happening Cynicism, exhaustion, Sunday dread, numbness + irritabilityCoach move Energy before strategy. Recovery design. Reduce load, don’t add homework
In the room
Cynicism. Exhaustion. Sunday dread. Numbness plus irritability.
What’s underneath
Do not coach peak performance on an empty tank. Energy before strategy. Reduce load; do not add homework. Recovery is the strategy.
Avoid here
Who-you-need-to-be-as-a-high-performer. Big plans. Appreciation as pep.
Example
Sunday dread + cynicism. Must stop: Sunday night pre-writes for a meeting that never decides. Recovery design first. Performance later.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods53240
S3.4Over-generalizing from one event “I always.” “This always happens.” One event wrote a law.
What is happening “I always”, “this always happens”Coach move Particularize. Find exceptions. Name the rule they built
In the room
“I always.” “This always happens.” One event wrote a law.
What’s underneath
The rule is the coaching object, not the episode. Particularize. Find exceptions. Ask if the rule is optional.
Avoid here
Debating frequency. More episodes.
Example
One icy board = “I always freeze with seniors.” Exception: CFO meeting last month. Rule optional this Thursday with an ally present.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5
S3.6Fixed-mindset identity claims “That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”
What is happening “That’s just how I am”, “I’m not a people person”Coach move Historicize the belief. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity
In the room
“That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”
What’s underneath
Do not debate personality. Open it as a story / strategy that once helped. Historicize. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity.
Avoid here
Trait arguments. Typology rabbit holes.
Example
“Not a people person” started after a public humiliation at 24. Already untrue with their craft peers. 10% stretch: one curious question in the staff meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5153435
S3.10Confirmation-seeking Looks for evidence they are right or doomed. Cherry-picks.
What is happening Looks for evidence they are right or doomedCoach move Ask for disconfirming data on purpose
In the room
Looks for evidence they are right or doomed. Cherry-picks.
What’s underneath
Stay curious, not prosecutorial. Ask for disconfirming data on purpose.
Avoid here
Helping them build the case.
Example
“They are icing me out.” Disconfirming: they forwarded a useful intro yesterday. 10% doesn’t fit. Experiment: collect for the opposite case three days before concluding.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods511
S3.16Nostalgia / golden past “It used to be better.”
What is happening “It used to be better”Coach move Harvest what was living then. Recreate the quality, not the era
In the room
“It used to be better.”
What’s underneath
You cannot coach them back into last year. Harvest the quality. Recreate it inside today’s constraints. Name what is gone for good.
Avoid here
Time-travel plans. Trashing the past.
Example
Miss the startup intimacy. Quality: unfiltered craft talk. Today: a weekly 30-minute “ugly work” session with two people. Era is gone; quality is not.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods527
S4.12External locus dressed as realism “That’s just corporate life.”
What is happening “That’s just corporate life”Coach move Test which constraints are real, which are assumed
In the room
“That’s just corporate life.”
What’s underneath
Realism and resignation can sound identical. Test written rule vs cultural habit vs prediction.
Avoid here
Naive “just be courageous” that ignores real power.
Example
“No one pushes back on dates.” Not written. Two people have. 10%: one tradeoff sentence this Friday.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5101634
S5.17After a win they can’t own Luck, team, timing — never them.
What is happening Luck, team, timing — never themCoach move Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update
In the room
Luck, team, timing — never them.
What’s underneath
Unowned wins do not update self-concept. Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update.
Avoid here
Fake humility praise.
Example
Turnaround attributed to “the team and timing.” Specifics: they set a weekly tradeoff meeting and killed two projects. Identity that updates: someone who designs conditions, not a spectator of luck.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods593841
S6.1Fused with the problem (“I am the failure”) Identity language, not behavior language.
What is happening Identity language, not behavior languageCoach move Externalize the problem. You vs the pattern
In the room
Identity language, not behavior language.
What’s underneath
Never coach identity as a diagnosis. Externalize so they can relate to a pattern they have.
Avoid here
Labels. Pep “you’re not a failure.”
Example
“I am the anxiety of this team.” Character: Sunday Weather. Quiet after a written opening line. They have Sunday Weather; they are not it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5132030
S7.34Being made redundant Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What is happening Role ended by the organisation; shock, loss and practical pressureCoach move Absorb the shock first; then rebuild the value story; then design next steps
In the room
Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What’s underneath
Redundancy is a loss of role, income, routine and identity, often at once, and usually not personal. The client needs first to absorb the shock, then to rebuild a story of their value and design practical next steps.
Avoid here
Jumping straight to CV and LinkedIn. Silver-lining talk. Ignoring finances.
Example
A marketing director is told her role is cut. First session: the shock and the anger. Second: strengths and her story. Third: three experiments in the job market.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5792736
S9.13Team after a failure or setback Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.
What is happening Team has failed or had a setback; morale and trust are shakenCoach move Blame-free review; find what worked; agree what to change
In the room
Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.
What’s underneath
After a failure, teams tend either to look for someone to blame or to avoid the subject. Both waste the learning. A blame-free review that also finds what went well helps the team recover confidence and improve.
Avoid here
A blame hunt. Skipping the review. Forced positivity.
Example
A product launch fails. The coach runs a review in three parts: what happened, what we learned, what we’d keep. The team leaves with two process changes and renewed confidence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5123841

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Toxic positivity — moving to solutions before the pain is acknowledged.
  • Skipping grief that needs to be named before resources can be useful.
  • Inventing strengths the client never actually offered, which feels hollow.

10Client traps

  • Discounting real exceptions (“that doesn’t count, it was a fluke”).
  • Staying loyal to a “problem identity” because it has become part of how they explain themselves.

Three worked problems

1

“I always freeze in senior rooms.” Exception: last month with the CFO, they asked a clean question. Difference: they’d walked the numbers the night before and sat next to an ally. Design: recreate those two specific conditions — don’t try to “stop being anxious” in the abstract.

2

Team “never owns anything.” Exception: the launch war-room week. Difference: one owner, one daily board, no parallel workstreams. This becomes a system experiment, not a lecture about accountability.

3

Burnout story of total collapse. Exception: Saturday morning in the garden, phone in another room. That protected off-time is a proven resource; +1 is adding one such block on a weekday.

Where it comes from

Exception-finding is a core move of solution-focused practice (de Shazer, Berg).

My notes

6
Open family

Film It / Make It Observable

Core move: Turn slogans into a camera shot
5 options10 questions20 situations

1What it really is

Converting slogans, values, and moods (“integrity,” “presence,” “be more strategic”) into a specific camera-shot scene: who, where, what time, what’s said, what’s seen.

Many goals are stated as abstractions: “be more confident,” “show more leadership,” “have better balance.” The trouble is that nobody can act on an abstraction directly. This method asks the client to describe what a camera would actually record if the goal were happening: the room, the people, the words spoken, the posture, the time on the clock. The vague word becomes a scene, and the scene can be rehearsed, tried, and checked.

It sounds like: “If I were filming you being more strategic next Monday, what would I see?”, “What would you be saying, and to whom?”, or “What would someone watching notice first?” It is not about lowering ambition; the value or aspiration stays the same, it just gets a shape that can be lived. It also helps reveal disagreements, because two people who both want “better communication” often turn out to be imagining very different scenes. It has worked when the client can describe a specific moment they could create or notice within the next week.

4How it works, deeply

Abstractions are comfortable precisely because they can’t be tested or failed — nobody can prove “be more strategic” wrong. A camera shot can be. This method forces the vision to touch the calendar: specific room, specific hour, specific words, specific body language. Once a value has a scene, it also has a first step, because the scene itself implies concrete, observable behavior.

There is a cognitive reason for this. Abstract words like “strategic” or “present” are stored as concepts, while scenes are stored as experiences, with images, sounds and actions attached. The brain can prepare to act on an experience in a way it cannot for a concept; picturing a specific action engages some of the same processes as doing it. That is why a vivid scene often makes a goal feel suddenly more achievable, and why the first step becomes obvious once the scene is clear.

Making something observable also creates accountability without pressure. Once both coach and client know what “more confident” looks like on a Thursday afternoon, the next session can check whether it happened. This avoids a common trap where progress on abstract goals can neither be confirmed nor denied, so the client never feels any real sense of achievement. The method also reveals where the abstraction was hiding a conflict: sometimes, when asked to film the goal, the client realises they don’t actually want what the slogan described.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Slogans, values, moods with no scene
The move
Turn words into a camera shot
Watch
If they stay abstract, ask for dialogue, time of day, room, body.
Four questions that often open it
  1. If we filmed Tuesday at 4pm, what would we see?
  2. What would a colleague notice that tells them this has shifted?
  3. What would you stop doing that is visible?
  4. What is the first observable act of the person you want to be?

2The client’s context

The client is speaking entirely in adjectives with no attached scene — “I want to be more strategic,” “I need to show up as a leader.” These phrases sound meaningful but describe nothing a camera could actually capture, which means there’s nothing yet to practice or measure.

3The coach’s options

Five different “shots” to request:

1Film a Tuesday — an ordinary day, made concrete.
2Film the shift — what would a colleague specifically notice has changed?
3Film the stop-doing — what visibly disappears, not just what’s added?
4Film the first act of the new identity — the very first observable moment.
5Film two weeks — this week versus the wanted week, side by side.

5Where it gets stuck

The client stays comfortably in adjectives. Alternatively, the coach accepts the motto itself as if it were progress — nodding along to “I want to be more strategic” without ever pushing for the scene.

6How to move it forward

Ask directly for dialogue, time of day, room, and body: “If we had a camera at 4pm, what would we see and hear?”

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If we filmed Tuesday at 4pm, what would we see?
  • What would a colleague notice that tells them this has shifted?
  • What would you stop doing that is visible?
  • What is the first observable act of the person you want to be?
  • What would we see in a good week versus this week?
Going further
  • If I watched a silent video of you doing this well, with no sound, what would I see?
  • What’s the very first line of dialogue in the scene where this has changed?
  • Who is in the room when this new version of you shows up, and what are they reacting to?
  • What would surprise the people who know you best about this scene?
  • If this were a photo instead of a video, what single moment would it capture?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.1Telling a rehearsed story Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Lo…
What is happening Fluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotionCoach move Expand: “What else?” / impact / feeling
In the room
Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Low emotion. They sound competent and slightly bored by their own plot.
What’s underneath
The first version is almost never wrong; it is rarely complete. Rehearsal is a social technology: it keeps the story stable so the teller does not have to feel it again. Professional coaching needs the unstable layer — impact, pattern, the word they are not using.
Avoid here
Preferred future too early (they have not arrived in the present). Reframe before they feel heard (lands as “you did not listen to my official version”). Generating options (there is no new material to option from). Pre-mortem (there is no plan; there is a performance).
Example
A VP tells a smooth story of a “difficult stakeholder.” Dates, emails, tone. Coach hears it once, then asks for impact. New sentence: “I rewrite every message three times and I hate who I am at 11pm.” That sentence is the topic. The stakeholder is context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods235673139
S1.2Stuck in the problem Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the prese…
What is happening Problem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted lifeCoach move Preferred future / miracle / visualization
In the room
Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the present-continuous of suffering. Options, if any, are all forms of “stop the pain,” not “live something.”
What’s underneath
Solution-focused and narrative work share a claim: options generated against a fog of not-wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. The nervous system orients toward what it can picture. No picture, no true choice.
Avoid here
Future questions while flooded (capacity is offline — regulate first). More analysis, clean language on problem-words only, or option-generation from inside the trance. Pre-mortem (adds more doom to a doom-only map).
Example
Product lead can describe six reasons a launch is doomed. Miracle first sign: they open Slack without a spike in the chest, and the stand-up starts with one risk, not twelve. Piece already slightly true on Thursdays after a run. Experiment: protect that Thursday condition twice this week, then look at the launch from there.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods45621222324
S1.4Vague “Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.
What is happening “Things feel off”, “leadership”, “balance” with no pictureCoach move Scaling / “What would we see if we filmed it?”
In the room
“Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.
What’s underneath
Abstraction protects. As long as the topic stays a noun with no scene, no one can fail at it and no one can finish it. Advanced coaching operationalizes: values, identities, and moods become behavior in a room at a time of day.
Avoid here
Coaching the slogan. More values language. Big identity work with no scene. Generating a 10-step “confidence plan.”
Example
“I just need more balance.” Film: current Tuesday is Slack at 21:40. +1 is laptop closed at 19:00 two nights, calendar invite to themselves. Balance stops being a personality project.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6222835
S1.6Intellectualizing Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stage…
What is happening Models, analysis, “interestingly”, little felt experienceCoach move Body, emotion, metaphor, silence
In the room
Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stages of their own avoidance.
What’s underneath
Cognition ahead of felt experience gets rejected by the nervous system even when accurate — and here cognition is the defense. Out-analyzing them rewards the defense. Sideways routes (body, image, silence) restore data they have edited out.
Avoid here
Question cube as more architecture. Systemic reframe as another framework. Any method that stays in third-person analysis.
Example
Client maps their “avoidance pattern” with a 2x2. Coach does not add a quadrant. “If the 2x2 stepped aside…” Throat tight. Weather: locked archive room. Work becomes the unsent two-line message, not a better map of avoidance.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6714283138
S1.11Over-specific / lost in detail Names, dates, emails, who said what. Inbox as the room.
What is happening Names, dates, emails, who said whatCoach move Zoom out to pattern, purpose, and what they want instead
In the room
Names, dates, emails, who said what. Inbox as the room.
What’s underneath
Detail can be a hiding place — from feeling, from pattern, from a decision. Harvest one pattern, then leave the inbox.
Avoid here
Following each email. Clean language on every proper noun.
Example
Twelve-message CC war. Chapter title: “I will not ask directly.” Pattern, then one request. Inbox closed.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2639
S1.12Bringing someone else’s agenda “My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.
What is happening “My boss said I should…”, partner booked them, HR sent themCoach move Separate assigned topic from their topic. Restore ownership
In the room
“My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.
What’s underneath
Coaching requires authorship. You can work the overlap between organizational want and client want. You cannot become the organization’s enforcer and still be their coach.
Avoid here
Running the company’s curriculum. Ignoring the assigned topic entirely without naming the fork (can blow up sponsorship). Advice on how to “perform presence.”
Example
Assigned: executive presence. Owned: credit stolen by a peer. Overlap: one visible moment Thursday. Both agendas honored; neither colonizes the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods163540
S1.17Very little language / “I don’t know” Shrugging. One-word answers. Blank look. Long gaps that are empty rather than working.
What is happening Shrugging, one-word answers, blank lookCoach move Offer structure: scale, image, guess, body, either/or
In the room
Shrugging. One-word answers. Blank look. Long gaps that are empty rather than working.
What’s underneath
“I don’t know” is often “I haven’t looked yet” or “it is unsafe to know.” Structure is kindness: scale, image, guess, either/or. Staring them down is not presence.
Avoid here
Wide open “what do you want from your life.” Challenge. Question cube.
Example
New director, one-word answers. Two doors: “the role, or the loneliness in it.” They pick loneliness. Language appears once the door is smaller.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5631
S2.4Anxious / catastrophizing What-if chains. Worst-case movies spoken as present fact. Body tension.
What is happening What-if chains, worst-case movies, body tensionCoach move Present facts vs forecast. Scale likelihood. Small next experiment
In the room
What-if chains. Worst-case movies spoken as present fact. Body tension.
What’s underneath
Anxiety collapses time: forecast becomes now. Ground in known vs imagined. Scale likelihood. Coping-even-if. A 2% safer next step. Do not debate the catastrophe (argument feeds it).
Avoid here
Pre-mortem as first move (rehearses failure). Miracle question if they cannot leave the movie. “It won’t happen.”
Example
“I will be fired in the town hall.” Known: agenda has their update. Imagined: public humiliation chain. Likelihood they actually name: 3. 2% safer step: walk the update with an ally tonight. Tree stops growing.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods62030
S2.9Hopeful / lit up for the first time Energy rise. New language. Smile. Lean-in.
What is happening Energy rise, new language, smile, leaning inCoach move Harvest it. Make it specific. Lock a small embodiment
In the room
Energy rise. New language. Smile. Lean-in.
What’s underneath
Hope is fragile in its first minutes and dies under premature scrutiny. Harvest. Make specific. Lock a small embodiment. Do not immediately stress-test.
Avoid here
Pre-mortem. “But what if.” More analysis to make it robust.
Example
First genuine “I could try for the role.” Harvest. Body: lift in chest. Keep-alive: tell one safe person. No SWOT of the application today.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods63538
S3.8Simplifying too fast / slogans “I just need to be more confident.” Fluent motto, no scene.
What is happening “I just need to be more confident”Coach move Unpack the slogan into situations, skills, beliefs
In the room
“I just need to be more confident.” Fluent motto, no scene.
What’s underneath
Opposite of S3.7. Slogans feel like progress and stall work. Unpack into situation, skill, belief, first scene.
Avoid here
Better slogans. Affirmations.
Example
Confidence → the 3pm vendor call, one ask for a date. Scene, not motto.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods635
S3.11Abstract values with no behavior “Integrity.” “Excellence.” On the wall, missing from Tuesday.
What is happening “Integrity”, “excellence” as fogCoach move Operationalize. Film the value on a Tuesday
In the room
“Integrity.” “Excellence.” On the wall, missing from Tuesday.
What’s underneath
Values without scenes stay decorative. Values speeches without calendar change increase shame.
Avoid here
Values elicitation workshops with no Tuesday.
Example
Integrity gap: they sat silent when a number was massaged. 60-minute act: a private correction conversation, not a new value statement.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6
S5.5Procrastination / delay Starts Sunday night. Avoids the hard block.
What is happening Starts Sunday night, avoids the hard blockCoach move Name the avoided feeling. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes
In the room
Starts Sunday night. Avoids the hard block.
What’s underneath
Often emotion management, not time skills. Name the feeling at sit-down. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes.
Avoid here
Calendar lectures. Shame.
Example
Deck avoided. Feeling at sit-down: being seen as thin. First 10 minutes: ugly outline labeled DRAFT, one reader. Delay’s job handled another way.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods61415
S6.15Values-action gap Says family, lives inbox.
What is happening Says family, lives inboxCoach move Calendar audit. One aligned act. Repair
In the room
Says family, lives inbox.
What’s underneath
Values speeches without calendar change increase shame. Audit. One aligned act. What to stop.
Avoid here
More articulation.
Example
Family on the wall; 21:40 Slack. Stop: two nights closed laptop. One act beats a new value deck.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6
S6.20Rest guilt / always-on Phone in bed. Vacation inbox.
What is happening Phone in bed, vacation inboxCoach move Off-design. Identity beyond usefulness
In the room
Phone in bed. Vacation inbox.
What’s underneath
Always-on is often anxiety management. Off-design. Identity beyond usefulness.
Avoid here
Wellness slogans.
Example
Rest is for a nervous system that can think on Monday. Device in another room Saturday morning — already an exception that works. Do more of that.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6
S6.25Neurodivergence shaping how they work (ADHD, autism, dyslexia) Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted fro…
What is happening Work set up for different brains; strong in some areas, worn out in othersCoach move Spot strengths; design the environment and adjustments around how they work best
In the room
Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted from masking.
What’s underneath
The client’s mind works differently, not wrongly. Problems often come from a poor fit between how they work best and how the job is set up. Coaching works on fit, strengths and adjustments, not on “fixing” the person. Diagnosis is not the coach’s role.
Avoid here
Diagnosing or suggesting a diagnosis. Treating it as a confidence problem. Generic productivity advice.
Example
A product manager with ADHD loses track of long meetings. Coach helps design shorter meetings with written agendas, and they ask for this as a reasonable adjustment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods69163640
S7.3Difficult direct report Avoidance or over-control.
What is happening Avoidance or over-controlCoach move Clear standard, feedback, consequence, development stance
In the room
Avoidance or over-control.
What’s underneath
Caring is not the same as being clear. Standard, feedback, consequence, development stance.
Avoid here
More empathy without a standard. PIP talk as first move when the standard was never said.
Example
Late stakeholder updates. Standard never said plainly. First: say it. Then consequence if needed. Not a sudden PIP.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods637
S7.11Managing up poorly Surprises the boss, or hides.
What is happening Surprises the boss, or hidesCoach move Boss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics
In the room
Surprises the boss, or hides.
What’s underneath
Managing up is service, not sucking up. Boss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics.
Avoid here
“Be more authentic” as the whole play.
Example
They optimize for craft; boss optimizes for no Friday surprises. Cadence: Thursday risk note. Service, not surrender.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods63742
S9.1First session or chemistry meeting Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What is happening First meeting; deciding whether to work together and howCoach move Show how you work; clarify expectations, confidentiality and fit
In the room
Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What’s underneath
The chemistry session is about fit and expectations, not proving brilliance. The coach should show how they work, clarify what coaching is and isn’t, and help the client decide.
Avoid here
Over-selling. Starting deep work before the contract is agreed. Being vague about logistics and confidentiality.
Example
A client asks how coaching will help. The coach does a short taste of coaching on a real topic, then explains confidentiality, sponsor involvement and how they would work together.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods136821
S9.3Three-way meeting with client and sponsor Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What is happening Formal alignment or review meeting with sponsor presentCoach move Prepare the client to lead; facilitate goals and observable signs of change
In the room
Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What’s underneath
Three-way meetings align goals and show progress. The client should lead, the coach facilitates, and the sponsor gives perspective. Preparation matters.
Avoid here
Coach speaking for the client. Revealing session content. Letting the sponsor dominate.
Example
Before the meeting, the coach helps the client rehearse what to share. In the meeting, the client presents goals, and the boss shares what they would notice changing.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16263742
S9.12New or re-formed team with unclear roles Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.
What is happening Team is new or changed; roles and agreements are unclearCoach move Contract at team level: purpose, roles, decision rights, ways of working
In the room
Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.
What’s underneath
New teams need explicit agreements about purpose, roles and ways of working. Without them, people fill gaps based on old habits, and friction appears as personal conflict. Contracting at team level is the work.
Avoid here
Jumping to team-building games. Letting the leader define everything alone. Treating role confusion as a personality problem.
Example
After a merger, two teams become one. The coach runs a session where each person maps what they think they own. Gaps and overlaps become visible, and the team writes a one-page charter.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods163342

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Coaching the abstraction itself rather than pushing toward the scene.
  • Adding more values-language, which only compounds the vagueness.

10Client traps

  • Producing beautiful slogans that never touch an actual calendar.

Three worked problems

1

“I need to be more strategic.” Film: currently they accept every operational Slack message by 9:05am. The strategic Tuesday: first 90 minutes with no Slack, one memo on tradeoffs sent to the VP. Observable stop-doing: they don’t join the stand-up unless specifically asked.

2

“I want psychological safety on my team.” Film: in the next retro, they speak last, and publicly thank the person who disagreed with them. Not a poster on the wall.

3

“I want to show up as a leader.” First observable act: walking into the staff meeting without a laptop lid up, opening with purpose rather than status updates.

Where it comes from

Related to the “video description” or “action talk” used in solution-focused and brief therapy approaches: describing what would be seen and heard.

My notes

7
Open family

Slow Down: Reflect, Pause, Follow Heat

Core move: Presence as the intervention
5 options10 questions27 situations

1What it really is

Presence itself as the intervention. The coach reflects a single charged sentence back, exactly as said, and then waits — resisting the urge to add commentary, analysis, or a follow-up question.

This method is mostly about what the coach does not do. When the client says something with emotional weight (a sharp change of tone, a phrase that catches in the throat, a word repeated twice), the coach notices it, says it back exactly as the client said it, and then stays quiet. “Following heat” means following where the energy is, rather than where the logical next question would go. The client is given room to stay with something they would usually move past quickly.

It sounds like the coach repeating a phrase such as “‘I’m tired of being the one who holds it together’”, and then simply waiting. It is not a therapy technique for digging into pain, and the coach doesn’t push the client to feel more than they choose to. It’s also not an awkward silence; the coach’s attention stays warm and fully on the client. You know it is working when the client goes further on their own: they slow down, their voice changes, or they say what was underneath the first sentence without being asked.

4How it works, deeply

Speed, humor, and topic-jumping are all forms of anesthesia — ways a nervous system protects itself from sitting with something uncomfortable for too long. The coach’s silence is not passive; it is an active refusal to collude with the escape. Most coaches move on too quickly not because the client is finished, but because the coach is uncomfortable with the silence. This method requires the coach to tolerate that discomfort longer than instinct suggests.

Reflecting a phrase back exactly as it was spoken has a particular effect. Hearing their own words in someone else’s voice lets the client hear them freshly, almost as an observer, and often notice a weight or meaning in them they missed while speaking. Changing the words, even slightly, would replace the client’s meaning with the coach’s. The silence that follows gives the client’s attention time to settle on what was said, rather than being carried away by the next question.

Presence also has a calming effect on the nervous system. When the coach is unhurried, the client’s pace tends to slow too, because people unconsciously match the pace of those they are talking with. Slower pace allows more reflective thinking and makes it safer to approach uncomfortable material. “Following heat” means the coach trusts emotional signals, a change of tone, a pause, a repeated word, as a guide to what matters most, rather than the logical structure of the story. Often the important topic is hiding in a passing phrase, not in the headline the client opened with.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Speed, circling, or a charged sentence just landed
The move
Presence as the intervention
Watch
“What aren’t you telling me yet?” only when trust is strong.
Four questions that often open it
  1. You said ___. (then silence)
  2. Something changed when you said that. What is there?
  3. The words are about X. The energy seems to be about Y. Which one wants air today?
  4. What aren’t you telling me yet?

2The client’s context

The client is speeding up: circling, stacking clauses, talking fast, or has just landed on a charged sentence and is already moving past it. Sometimes a joke appears immediately after something important was said — a classic trapdoor. Sometimes the client jumps to a new topic right after something real has surfaced.

3The coach’s options

1Reflect-and-silence — repeat the exact sentence, then say nothing.
2Name the energy/content mismatch — “the words are about X, the energy seems to be about Y.”
3Follow heat, not the official title — go where the aliveness is, not where the agenda says to go.
4Pace down a flood of words — slow the tempo explicitly rather than matching it.
5Return to the sentence before the joke — go back one beat when humor appears right after something charged.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach matches the client’s speed and the fog only increases. Or the coach fills every silence out of their own discomfort. Or the coach chases every new topic the client offers as an escape route.

6How to move it forward

Take one sentence, repeat it exactly, and wait. Ask what changed in the body when it was said. Offer explicitly to stay with one thread for two minutes before moving on.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • You said ___. (then silence)
  • Something changed when you said that. What is there?
  • The words are about X. The energy seems to be about Y. Which one wants air today?
  • What aren’t you telling me yet? (only when trust is strong)
  • You moved off that quickly. May we go back one sentence?
Going further
  • What just happened in your body as you said that?
  • If you said that sentence again, slower, what would you notice?
  • What would happen if we just sat with that for a moment, without fixing it?
  • What did the joke let you skip past?
  • If you weren’t allowed to change the subject right now, what would you say next?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

  • Honor. Carry forward: the standard of clarity, not the dependency. Then the map.
S1.1Telling a rehearsed story Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Lo…
What is happening Fluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotionCoach move Expand: “What else?” / impact / feeling
In the room
Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Low emotion. They sound competent and slightly bored by their own plot.
What’s underneath
The first version is almost never wrong; it is rarely complete. Rehearsal is a social technology: it keeps the story stable so the teller does not have to feel it again. Professional coaching needs the unstable layer — impact, pattern, the word they are not using.
Avoid here
Preferred future too early (they have not arrived in the present). Reframe before they feel heard (lands as “you did not listen to my official version”). Generating options (there is no new material to option from). Pre-mortem (there is no plan; there is a performance).
Example
A VP tells a smooth story of a “difficult stakeholder.” Dates, emails, tone. Coach hears it once, then asks for impact. New sentence: “I rewrite every message three times and I hate who I am at 11pm.” That sentence is the topic. The stakeholder is context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods235673139
S1.5Overwhelmed Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to …
What is happening Too much at once, pressure, no footholdCoach move Exceptions, resources, +1 on the scale
In the room
Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to outrun the body.
What’s underneath
An overloaded system cannot use a big plan. Load reduction and resource-finding are regulation, not soft extras. +1 and exceptions restore a sense of authorship without pretending the load is imaginary.
Avoid here
Giant homework. Preferred-future montage. Pre-mortem (more future weight). Who-would-you-need-to-be as a heroic identity.
Example
Six workstreams plus a sick parent. Exception: last Thursday when they declined two meetings. +1: decline the standing Thursday review that produces no decisions. Not a life-redesign.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods145740
S1.6Intellectualizing Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stage…
What is happening Models, analysis, “interestingly”, little felt experienceCoach move Body, emotion, metaphor, silence
In the room
Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stages of their own avoidance.
What’s underneath
Cognition ahead of felt experience gets rejected by the nervous system even when accurate — and here cognition is the defense. Out-analyzing them rewards the defense. Sideways routes (body, image, silence) restore data they have edited out.
Avoid here
Question cube as more architecture. Systemic reframe as another framework. Any method that stays in third-person analysis.
Example
Client maps their “avoidance pattern” with a 2x2. Coach does not add a quadrant. “If the 2x2 stepped aside…” Throat tight. Weather: locked archive room. Work becomes the unsent two-line message, not a better map of avoidance.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6714283138
S1.9Skimming / staying on the surface Short answers. “It’s fine.” Jumps topics. Jokes away. No dwell time.
What is happening Short answers, “it’s fine”, jumps topics, jokes awayCoach move Slow down. One thread. Reflect + silence. Invite the unsaid
In the room
Short answers. “It’s fine.” Jumps topics. Jokes away. No dwell time.
What’s underneath
Surface is often safety, not shallowness. Chasing every new topic they offer as escape trains the dodge. One thread + silence is the intervention.
Avoid here
And-what-else as a machine gun. Deep identity work before safety. Challenge.
Example
Client hopscotches from team to school to a podcast they heard. Coach returns to “it’s fine.” Under it: they were copied off a thread. Two minutes there is the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods127
S1.13Avoiding the real topic Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.
What is happening Safe issue up front, energy elsewhere, late-session revealCoach move Follow energy, not the official title. Name the mismatch
In the room
Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.
What’s underneath
Avoidance is information about cost and safety, not a character flaw. Name the mismatch; do not ambush. They choose.
Avoid here
Clever “gotcha.” Deep dive with eight minutes left. Reframe of the safe topic as if it were the work.
Example
Official: calendar. Heat: “my partner booked this.” Offer the observation. They choose the authorship topic. Calendar was the costume.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12714
S1.14First time saying it out loud Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What is happening Hesitation, “this may sound silly”, long pause before the sentenceCoach move Safety first. Witness. Do not rush to fix or reframe
In the room
Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What’s underneath
Being heard is the intervention. Insight can wait. A reframe here is a small violence: it teaches them that this room, too, will rush to tidy what they just risked.
Avoid here
Immediate reframe, options, miracle, challenge.
Example
“I think I want to leave the field.” Coach does not build an exit plan. First work: they hear themselves. Then they choose hold vs move.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17133538
S1.16Talking very fast / flooding with words No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.
What is happening No pauses, stacked clauses, little breathCoach move Pace down. Reflect one piece. Ask for the headline
In the room
No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.
What’s underneath
Speed is often anesthesia or an attempt to get it all in before they are interrupted (history of not being given the floor). Pacing down is regulation. Headline restores choice.
Avoid here
Matching speed. And-what-else rapid fire. Complexifying.
Example
Seven-minute sentence about a reorg. Coach: one sentence. “I don’t know if I have a job.” That is the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods173132
S1.18Humor as deflection Jokes at the exact moment of heat. Self-mockery. Room laughs; topic dies.
What is happening Jokes at the exact moment of heat, self-mockeryCoach move Smile with them, then return to the moment before the joke
In the room
Jokes at the exact moment of heat. Self-mockery. Room laughs; topic dies.
What’s underneath
Humor is often a gifted regulator. Do not kill it. Use it as a doorway back to the sentence before the joke.
Avoid here
Tight-faced “let’s be serious.” Ignoring the joke and losing the heat marker.
Example
“My team doesn’t need me — lucky them!” Return. Unfunny version: fear of becoming ornamental after promotion. Work that.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71431
S1.19Jumping straight to solutions Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What is happening Action list before the topic is understoodCoach move Pause action. Check if the problem is the real problem
In the room
Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What’s underneath
Premature plans recycle the old frame. Sometimes action-hunger is anxiety management. Distinguish a planning hour from an understanding hour — and let them choose if both are live.
Avoid here
Helping them polish the premature plan. More options on an unexamined problem.
Example
Client arrives with a 9-point script for a fight with their peer. “If it worked, what would it give you?” “I want to stop being erased.” Understanding hour: erasure pattern. Then a shorter request, not a 9-point prosecution.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17102126
S2.1Emotionally flooded / activated Tears, shaking voice, heat, cannot finish sentences.
What is happening Tears, shaking voice, heat, can’t finish sentencesCoach move Safety, presence, breath, smaller slice. No big future questions yet
In the room
Tears, shaking voice, heat, cannot finish sentences.
What’s underneath
High arousal takes prefrontal capacity offline. Asking for a preferred future mid-flood is map-reading while the building is on fire. Presence and slice-size are the methods.
Avoid here
Miracle, future-self, pre-mortem, challenge, question cube, stacked powerful questions.
Example
Client breaks on “they announced the role without telling me.” Coach does not ask what future-them would do. Slice: this feeling, two minutes, feet on the floor. Later they choose a request to the sponsor — after speech returns.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods73238
S2.3Angry / blaming / righteous heat Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What is happening Other-focus, injustice language, clenched jawCoach move Validate the heat, then separate fact / interpretation / want
In the room
Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What’s underneath
Anger is often a protector of dignity, boundary, or grief. Do not moralize it; do not join the case. Sequence: validate heat → separate fact / interpretation / want → find the clean request.
Avoid here
Immediate perspective-take (“have you considered their side”) — feels like betrayal. Cheerful reframe.
Example
Rage at a peer who “stole” a project. Anger protecting: not being erasable. Clean request: shared ownership memo + a conversation. Prosecution energy drops when dignity has a next act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71011193740
S2.8Grief / loss mixed into a work topic Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”
What is happening Role loss, champion left, identity ending, eyes wet when “professional”Coach move Name the loss. Allow a beat. Then ask what wants to be carried forward
In the room
Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”
What’s underneath
Grief is not a lesson yet. Reframing it into growth too fast is a small desecration and breaks trust. Name what is ending and what is not. Then ask what wants to be carried forward.
Avoid here
Immediate silver lining. Options. “Who do you need to be now” in the first minute.
Example
Sponsor leaves. Client wants a “stakeholder map.” First: name the loss of being believed without a slide.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7233043
S5.2Action without insight / busywork Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.
What is happening Lots of doing, no learning, hamster wheelCoach move Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs motion
In the room
Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.
What’s underneath
Do not applaud motion that is avoidance. Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs anxiety-motion.
Avoid here
More productivity systems.
Example
14 status meetings. 50% less might reveal no decision owner. Stillness would show the missing contract, not a need for a 15th meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods172140
S5.16Need to have a difficult conversation Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What is happening Avoids the meeting, writes unsent emailsCoach move Purpose, request, opening line, body regulation, rehearsal
In the room
Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What’s underneath
Role-play beats more theory. Purpose, request, first sentence, body, live practice.
Avoid here
Longer essays. More theory of crucial conversations.
Example
Unsent prosecution email. Purpose: fewer surprises. First sentence practiced. Heat in chest named. Meeting request sent same day.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods731353740
S7.4Conflict-avoidant Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.
What is happening Keeps peace, stores residue, surprise explosions laterCoach move Micro-truths. Body first. 2-minute version of the conversation
In the room
Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.
What’s underneath
Teach titrated honesty, not a personality transplant. Body first. 2-minute version.
Avoid here
“Have the big fight.”
Example
Swallows “this date is fiction.” Body: swallow reflex. 2-minute version to the PM this week. Titration.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7313237
S7.33Disclosure of bullying, harassment or discrimination Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What is happening Client describes treatment that may be bullying, harassment or discriminationCoach move Listen and believe; map options and support; refer to formal channels
In the room
Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What’s underneath
This is not only a coaching topic. It may need HR, legal, union or other formal support. The coach listens, believes, helps the client understand their options and supports their choice. The coach does not investigate, judge or decide for them, and does not promise confidentiality they can’t keep.
Avoid here
Coaching their “resilience” to tolerate it. Telling them what to do. Investigating or confronting anyone. Minimising.
Example
A junior employee describes repeated comments about her accent from a manager. The coach listens, acknowledges how hard it is, and helps her map formal and informal options and who could support her.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17163740
S7.34Being made redundant Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What is happening Role ended by the organisation; shock, loss and practical pressureCoach move Absorb the shock first; then rebuild the value story; then design next steps
In the room
Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What’s underneath
Redundancy is a loss of role, income, routine and identity, often at once, and usually not personal. The client needs first to absorb the shock, then to rebuild a story of their value and design practical next steps.
Avoid here
Jumping straight to CV and LinkedIn. Silver-lining talk. Ignoring finances.
Example
A marketing director is told her role is cut. First session: the shock and the anger. Second: strengths and her story. Third: three experiments in the job market.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5792736
S7.35Having to make others redundant Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What is happening Must deliver redundancies; torn between the organisation and the peopleCoach move Hold both duties; rehearse clear and humane conversations; care for themselves
In the room
Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What’s underneath
The client holds two duties at once: to the organisation and to the people affected. Both are real. Coaching helps them act with integrity and care, prepare the conversations, and look after themselves without pretending the role is easy.
Avoid here
Helping them become cold or detached. Turning it into only a legal script. Ignoring their own wellbeing.
Example
A plant manager must lay off 40 people. Coach helps him rehearse a clear, humane opening sentence and plan support for those affected and for himself.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods714183237
S8.3Defensive when challenged Explains, justifies, tightens.
What is happening Explains, justifies, tightensCoach move Soften. More empathy first. Smaller challenge. Ask permission
In the room
Explains, justifies, tightens.
What’s underneath
A challenge before enough safety becomes an argument. Soften. Empathy first. Smaller challenge. Ask permission.
Avoid here
Bigger challenge. Debate.
Example
Challenge on heroics landed as contempt. Repair. Smaller: “May I say what I notice about the load?” Defense drops.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7
S8.15Client is performing leadership rather than exploring Keynote in the chair. No crack.
What is happening Keynote in the chair, no crackCoach move Ask for the unofficial version. Energy under the polish
In the room
Keynote in the chair. No crack.
What’s underneath
Status is a defense. Respect it, then invite the human. Kitchen-table version.
Avoid here
Competing keynotes. Calling them fake.
Example
Board version of a reorg. Kitchen table: they are scared they will become the person they disliked. Crack. Work that.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods738
S8.16Suicidal thoughts or risk disclosed Hopelessness. “What’s the point?” Talking about not being here, being a burden, or having a plan. May be hint…
What is happening Client hints at or states thoughts of ending their lifeCoach move Stop the coaching agenda; ask directly; listen; connect them to professional help
In the room
Hopelessness. “What’s the point?” Talking about not being here, being a burden, or having a plan. May be hinted rather than stated.
What’s underneath
Safety comes before coaching. Asking directly and calmly about suicidal thoughts does not plant the idea; it often brings relief. The coach stays calm, listens, takes it seriously, and helps the client connect with professional help: their GP, a mental health professional, or crisis services. The coach follows their contract and any safeguarding procedures, and gets supervision afterwards.
Avoid here
Carrying on with the coaching agenda. Panic or lecturing. Promising complete confidentiality. Ending the session without a plan for support.
Example
A client says, “Sometimes I think everyone would be better off without me.” The coach pauses the session, asks directly, listens, and stays with the client while they agree who they will contact for help that day.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1732
S8.17Signs of substance misuse Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.
What is happening Hints of using alcohol or substances to copeCoach move Notice and ask respectfully; evoke their own view; refer if they want help
In the room
Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.
What’s underneath
The coach is not there to diagnose or treat. But they can notice, ask with respect, and use a non-judgemental, motivational approach to help the client think about it. If the client wants help, the coach can point them to professional support.
Avoid here
Lecturing, labelling, or ignoring obvious signs. Acting as a counsellor.
Example
A sales director jokes about needing three drinks after every call. Coach asks, without judgement, how they feel about it. The client admits it worries them and agrees to talk to their doctor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods47840
S8.18Client far more senior or powerful than the coach The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.
What is happening Large status gap; coach tempted to defer or impressCoach move Contract for challenge; stay curious and independent
In the room
The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.
What’s underneath
Seniority and status are part of the room. If the coach defers, the client loses the challenge they need. The coach’s value is in their questions and their independence, not in matching the client’s status.
Avoid here
Deference. Performing expertise. Avoiding challenge.
Example
A new coach working with a CEO keeps agreeing. In supervision, the coach realises this. Next session they contract openly for challenge.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13728
S8.19Cultural or identity gap between coach and client Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.
What is happening Coach and client differ in culture, identity or experienceCoach move Name the gap; use the client’s own words; ask, don’t assume
In the room
Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.
What’s underneath
Culture, identity and lived experience shape what problems mean and what solutions are possible. The coach doesn’t need to share them, but does need curiosity, humility and willingness to name the gap and ask.
Avoid here
Assuming your own cultural norms are neutral. Avoiding the topic. Over-apologising.
Example
A coach from a low-hierarchy culture coaches a client from a high-hierarchy culture about “speaking up to the boss.” The coach asks what speaking up would look like in the client’s context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods171128
S8.20Attraction, over-familiarity or boundary pull Personal messages outside sessions. Requests to meet socially. Compliments that feel personal. The coach may …
What is happening Relationship drifting beyond the professional; personal pull on either sideCoach move Restate boundaries kindly and clearly; take it to supervision
In the room
Personal messages outside sessions. Requests to meet socially. Compliments that feel personal. The coach may feel flattered or uncomfortable.
What’s underneath
Coaching needs clear boundaries to stay safe and useful. The coach is responsible for holding them, kindly and clearly, whatever the client does. Supervision is important.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Encouraging it. Shaming the client.
Example
A client begins sending friendly late-night messages. The coach thanks them, restates how and when they communicate, and discusses it in supervision.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17
S9.5Client wants to stop early Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.
What is happening Client asks to end the engagement before plannedCoach move Respect the choice; reflect on what led to it; harvest the learning
In the room
Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.
What’s underneath
Stopping early can be the right choice or an avoidance. The coach respects the decision while inviting reflection on what led to it and what the client has gained.
Avoid here
Persuading them to stay. Taking it personally. Ending without reflection.
Example
A client wants to stop after three sessions. The coach asks what led to it. The client admits the topic got too close. They agree a final session to harvest learning.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17838
S9.8Remote session: camera off, distracted or multitasking Camera off, typing sounds, delayed answers. Short replies.
What is happening Client distracted or unseen in remote sessionsCoach move Name it; agree remote norms; help them arrive
In the room
Camera off, typing sounds, delayed answers. Short replies.
What’s underneath
Remote coaching needs agreed norms. Distraction may be workload, avoidance or connection problems. Naming it and agreeing what works helps the session be useful.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Getting irritated. Assuming bad faith.
Example
A client keeps checking email during sessions. The coach names it and asks what would help them be present. They agree to start each session with two minutes of settling.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1732

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Performing presence rather than actually being present.
  • Using “what aren’t you telling me” too early, before trust supports it.
  • Filling silence to manage the coach’s own discomfort, not the client’s needs.

10Client traps

  • Using speed as anesthesia against feeling.
  • Using jokes as trapdoors right after something real surfaces.
  • Using new topics as escape hatches from heat.

Three worked problems

1

Flood of project detail. Coach: “If you had only one sentence, what is the heart of this?” Client: “I think I have already failed.” The coach works that sentence, not the project detail.

2

Joke after “my team doesn’t need me.” Coach smiles with them, then reflects: “The joke came right after something important.” Underneath: fear of becoming ornamental after the promotion.

3

Safe topic, hot energy. Official title is calendar management. Energy spikes on “my partner booked this.” Following heat leads to authorship, not time-blocking.

Where it comes from

Draws on person-centred practice (Carl Rogers): reflection, empathy and presence as the intervention.

My notes

8
Open family

Evoke Change Talk (Work With Ambivalence)

Core move: Draw out their own reasons for change; don’t argue for it
5 options10 questions9 situations

1What it really is

Drawn from Motivational Interviewing (Miller & Rollnick). Instead of persuading a client to change, the coach listens for and draws out the client’s own reasons, desire, ability and need for change, and treats ambivalence as normal rather than as resistance. People are far more likely to act on arguments they hear themselves make than on arguments made to them.

Most people who come to coaching about a change feel two ways about it; part of them wants it and part of them doesn’t. Instead of taking the side of change and arguing for it, the coach is curious about both sides and especially listens for “change talk”: anything the client says about wanting, being able to, having reasons for, or needing to change. When change talk appears, the coach reflects it back, asks for more of it, and lets the client hear their own case.

It sounds like: “What makes this important to you right now?”, “On a scale of 1 to 10, how ready are you, and why not lower?”, or “If you did decide to change, how might you go about it?” It is not manipulation or a way of steering the client to a predetermined answer; the client may still decide not to change, and that is respected. It also isn’t neutral listening, because the coach chooses which statements to reflect. It has worked when the client’s language shifts from “I should” and “I can’t” towards “I want to” and “I could.”

4How it works, deeply

The method rests on a simple observation: when someone feels pushed, they push back, and in pushing back they talk themselves further out of change. The coach’s urge to fix (the “righting reflex”) creates exactly the resistance it wants to remove. When the coach instead asks the client to voice their own reasons, the client hears themselves argue for change. Commitment language (“I will”, “I’m going to”) usually follows change talk, not the other way round, so the coach’s job is to grow the change talk before asking for commitment.

Motivational Interviewing rests on research showing that what people say about change predicts what they do. The more a person voices their own desire, ability, reasons and need for change, the more likely they are to follow through, while arguing against change (sometimes called “sustain talk”) predicts staying the same. This makes the coach’s choice of what to ask about and what to reflect back critical: every question nudges the balance between the two.

Treating ambivalence as normal is also part of the mechanism. When the coach acknowledges that both sides make sense, the client doesn’t have to defend the side that resists change, and that frees them to explore the side that wants it. Techniques such as reflecting both sides in one sentence (“on one hand…, and on the other…”) help the client hold their ambivalence without being stuck in it. Underneath it all is respect for autonomy: when people feel their freedom to choose is honoured, they are far more willing to choose change.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client is ambivalent, says “I should” without moving, or resists every suggestion
The move
Draw out their own reasons for change and reflect them back
Watch
The moment you argue for change, they will argue against it.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What would be good about changing this?
  2. How important is it, 0–10, and why not lower?
  3. What worries you about things staying the same?
  4. What, if anything, do you want to do about it?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Two minds at once — “Part of me wants to, but…” Every reason for change is followed by a reason against.
  • Pushback to good advice — The more anyone (boss, partner, coach) argues for change, the more the client defends the status quo.
  • Sent to change — Someone else wants the change more than the client does, and the client hasn’t found their own stake yet.
  • Stalled commitment — They keep saying “I should” and “I’ll think about it” without movement.
  • Change in a sensitive area — Health, drinking, workload or habits, where lecturing reliably backfires.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses among five moves depending on where the ambivalence sits:

1Ask for the case for change — “What would be the good things about changing this?” Let the client build the argument.
2Use the importance ruler — “On 0–10, how important is this to you? Why a 6 and not a 3?” The answer is change talk.
3Reflect the change talk back — Selectively reflect the client’s own pro-change statements so they hear them twice.
4Roll with the sustain talk — When they argue against change, reflect it without fighting (“So right now it doesn’t feel worth the cost”).
5Look forward and back — “If nothing changes, where will this be in a year? What was it like before this started?”

5Where it gets stuck

The coach starts listing reasons for change, the client lists reasons against, and the session becomes a polite debate. Or the coach mistakes MI for passivity and simply reflects everything, so the conversation drifts with no direction.

6How to move it forward

Stop arguing. Ask the client why they gave themselves a 6 rather than a 3 on importance. Reflect only the change talk, then summarise it as a bouquet: “So you want more evenings back, you’re tired of being the bottleneck, and you think your team could handle more.” Then ask, “What, if anything, do you want to do about it?”

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What would be the good things about making this change?
  • On a scale of 0 to 10, how important is this to you right now?
  • Why that number and not a lower one?
  • If you did decide to change this, how might you go about it?
  • What would need to happen for this to move up one point?
Going further
  • What worries you most about things staying exactly as they are?
  • What has worked for you before when you made a change you were unsure about?
  • How would this change fit with what matters most to you?
  • What would someone who knows you well say your reasons are?
  • What’s the smallest step you’d be willing to consider, if any?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S4.5No ownership / “yes but” Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.
What is happening Agrees then undoes, external conditions alwaysCoach move Name the yes-but. Find the hidden loyalty or fear
In the room
Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.
What’s underneath
Yes-but is information, not just resistance. Often a clean no in costume, or a hidden loyalty/fear.
Avoid here
More action planning they will yes-but.
Example
“Yes I’ll talk to her but the offsite…” But protects fear of her anger. Clean not-yet: after the offsite, dated. Or clean no. Anything but a fake yes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods8151740
S5.10Compliance without buy-in Will do the homework to please you.
What is happening Will do the homework to please youCoach move Rebuild choice. They design the experiment or there is none
In the room
Will do the homework to please you.
What’s underneath
Compliant clients create empty sessions. They design the experiment or there is none. Your approval cannot be the engine.
Avoid here
More assigned homework.
Example
They complete every worksheet. None touch the leave-question. New rule: they design or we don’t assign.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods836
S5.11Resistance to action / “I’ll think about it” Soft close. No date. No witness.
What is happening Soft close, no date, no witnessCoach move Get specific or name the no. Explore the cost of thinking-about-it
In the room
Soft close. No date. No witness.
What’s underneath
A vague maybe is usually a hidden no. Get specific or name the no. Cost of thinking-about-it.
Avoid here
Fake deadline you invent.
Example
“I’ll think about the conversation with her.” In their life that means never. Honest not-yet: after Thursday’s results, decide Friday, tell you next session.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods836
S5.14Stuck between option A and B Oscillates daily. Seeks a sign.
What is happening Oscillates daily, seeks a signCoach move Values, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period
In the room
Oscillates daily. Seeks a sign.
What’s underneath
The torture is often the oscillation, not either option. Values, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period.
Avoid here
More comparison matrices.
Example
Two job offers. Oscillation is the torture. Future-you already lives in B when they describe Friday evening. 30-day trial not possible; announcement date is.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods82431
S5.15Stay-or-go decision Job, role, city, company. High identity load.
What is happening Job, role, city, companyCoach move Two-movie method. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible
In the room
Job, role, city, company. High identity load.
What’s underneath
Do not pick for them. Make both futures vivid, including costs. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible.
Avoid here
Pros/cons only. Coach’s career advice as the engine.
Example
Both films include costs. Stay-film costs self-respect; go-film costs money buffer. Non-negotiable: no more half-life. Experiment: 90-day full stay or a real search — pick one.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods82326
S8.17Signs of substance misuse Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.
What is happening Hints of using alcohol or substances to copeCoach move Notice and ask respectfully; evoke their own view; refer if they want help
In the room
Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.
What’s underneath
The coach is not there to diagnose or treat. But they can notice, ask with respect, and use a non-judgemental, motivational approach to help the client think about it. If the client wants help, the coach can point them to professional support.
Avoid here
Lecturing, labelling, or ignoring obvious signs. Acting as a counsellor.
Example
A sales director jokes about needing three drinks after every call. Coach asks, without judgement, how they feel about it. The client admits it worries them and agrees to talk to their doctor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods47840
S9.1First session or chemistry meeting Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What is happening First meeting; deciding whether to work together and howCoach move Show how you work; clarify expectations, confidentiality and fit
In the room
Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What’s underneath
The chemistry session is about fit and expectations, not proving brilliance. The coach should show how they work, clarify what coaching is and isn’t, and help the client decide.
Avoid here
Over-selling. Starting deep work before the contract is agreed. Being vague about logistics and confidentiality.
Example
A client asks how coaching will help. The coach does a short taste of coaching on a real topic, then explains confidentiality, sponsor involvement and how they would work together.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods136821
S9.5Client wants to stop early Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.
What is happening Client asks to end the engagement before plannedCoach move Respect the choice; reflect on what led to it; harvest the learning
In the room
Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.
What’s underneath
Stopping early can be the right choice or an avoidance. The coach respects the decision while inviting reflection on what led to it and what the client has gained.
Avoid here
Persuading them to stay. Taking it personally. Ending without reflection.
Example
A client wants to stop after three sessions. The coach asks what led to it. The client admits the topic got too close. They agree a final session to harvest learning.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17838
S9.7Repeated cancellations or no-shows Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.
What is happening Sessions keep being cancelled or missedCoach move Name the pattern without blame; re-contract
In the room
Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.
What’s underneath
Repeated cancellations are information: about priority, avoidance, workload, or fit. Naming the pattern, without blame, helps the client decide what they want.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Getting annoyed. Making assumptions.
Example
A client cancels three times. The coach names the pattern kindly. The client admits the sessions feel like another obligation. They change frequency and focus.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14839

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Arguing for change, which reliably triggers the client to argue against it.
  • Treating ambivalence as resistance or a character flaw.
  • Reflecting everything equally, including sustain talk, so the conversation has no direction.
  • Pushing for a commitment before enough change talk has been heard.

10Client traps

  • Agreeing quickly to end the pressure, then not following through.
  • Inviting the coach to argue (“Convince me”) so they can win the debate.
  • Hiding behind “I should” language that sounds like commitment but isn’t.

Three worked problems

1

Sent to “delegate more.” Every coach suggestion meets a “yes, but.” Coach stops suggesting and asks what would be good about delegating. The client lists four reasons, ends on “I could leave by six,” and proposes their own first step.

2

Drinking at client dinners. Client mentions it lightly. Coach asks, without judgement, how important cutting back is on 0–10. “A 5.” “Why not a 2?” “I hate how I feel at Friday meetings.” The client decides to try two dry dinners a month.

3

Stay or go, frozen for months. Coach reflects both sides, then asks what worries the client about another year of standing still. The answer, “I’ll have stopped believing I can leave,” becomes the turning point.

Where it comes from

Motivational Interviewing, developed by William R. Miller and Stephen Rollnick.

My notes

9
Open family

Spot Strengths in Action

Core move: Name the strengths already at work, then aim them at the problem
5 options10 questions7 situations

1What it really is

The coach notices and names the specific strengths the client is already using, often while telling a problem story, and then asks how those strengths could be brought to the current challenge. It draws on positive psychology and strengths research (for example the VIA character strengths). This is not praise. It is precise observation that gives the client evidence about themselves they tend to overlook.

Clients often describe a difficulty in a way that hides how resourceful they were in it. While listening, the coach watches for the strengths in action, such as persistence, fairness, curiosity, courage, or care for others, and names them with the specific evidence from the client’s own story. Then the coach asks how that same strength might help with the problem in front of them now, or whether it has been turned up too high and become part of the problem.

It sounds like: “As you told that story, I noticed how carefully you protected your team from the fallout. That looks like real loyalty. Where else could that help you here?” It is not flattery, reassurance or a way to cheer the client up, and it should never be used to skip over something that is genuinely hard. It works best when the client can check the evidence for themselves and agree with it. You know it is working when the client stops discounting the observation and starts to use the strength deliberately in their planning.

4How it works, deeply

People under pressure narrow their attention to threats and gaps, which is useful for survival but bad for problem-solving. Naming real, evidenced strengths widens the field again and gives the client resources to work with. It works only when it’s specific and backed by what the client actually did. Generic praise is discounted immediately, especially by clients with imposter feelings. The overuse angle matters too: most “weaknesses” in senior people are strengths turned up too high.

Research in positive psychology, including work on the VIA character strengths, suggests that people who use their strengths regularly tend to report greater engagement and wellbeing, and are often more effective at work. Many people, however, are better at describing their weaknesses than their strengths. Part of the reason is that strengths feel natural, so people assume they are ordinary. Naming them, with evidence, turns invisible capability into a resource the client can choose to use.

The method works best when the coach separates observation from evaluation. “You kept going after three rejections” is an observation the client can verify; “you’re so resilient” is a judgement they may reject. Once a strength is recognised, the coach can explore how it might be applied in a new context, or whether it is being overused. The overuse question is often the most valuable, because it lets the client see a difficulty as a strength to dial down rather than a flaw to eliminate.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client sees only gaps, is shaken by a setback, or discounts their own part in wins
The move
Name specific strengths already in use and aim them at the challenge
Watch
Specific and evidenced, or it will be discounted as flattery.
Four questions that often open it
  1. When were you at your best recently?
  2. What strengths did that take?
  3. How could you bring more of that here?
  4. When does this strength start to cost you?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Deficit lens — Talks only about what they lack; the self-description is a list of weaknesses.
  • After a blow — Redundancy, a lost bid or a bad review has shaken their sense of what they’re good at.
  • In transition — Moving into a new role or field and unsure what transfers.
  • Discounting wins — Credits luck, the team or timing for every success.
  • Overusing a strength — A real strength (thoroughness, loyalty, drive) has become the problem through overuse.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses among five ways to work with strengths:

1Spot it live — Interrupt gently: “Can I name something I just heard? That was real persistence.”
2Peak story — Ask for a time they were at their best, then pull out the strengths in it together.
3Transfer — “Where else in your life do you already do this well? How could that help here?”
4Overuse check — “When does this strength start costing you or others?” Find the dial, not the off switch.
5Others’ eyes — Ask three people what they rely on the client for, and compare with the client’s own list.

5Where it gets stuck

The client deflects every observation (“anyone would have done that”), or the coach drifts into cheerleading that feels hollow and makes the client trust them less.

6How to move it forward

Get more specific and more behavioural: quote the exact thing they did and its effect. Ask the client to rate how true the observation is rather than accept it. Use others’ evidence (feedback, results) instead of the coach’s opinion.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • When were you at your best recently? What were you doing?
  • What strengths did that take?
  • Where are you already using that strength, even in this difficult situation?
  • How could you bring more of it to this challenge?
  • When does this strength start to work against you?
Going further
  • What do people rely on you for, even when they don’t say it?
  • What comes so easily to you that you forget it’s a skill?
  • What did you do in that story that someone else might not have?
  • Which strength have you been leaving at home lately?
  • What would it look like to use this strength at 70% instead of 100%?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S2.10Disappointed after a setback Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What is happening Deflation after effort, “why bother”Coach move Acknowledge the hit. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions
In the room
Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What’s underneath
The hit is real. Toxic positivity here breaks trust. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions. Smallest act of continuing.
Avoid here
Immediate next mountain. “Everything happens for…”
Example
Launch missed. Took: a quarter and a narrative. Did not take: their judgment with customers. Exception: 2019 dip → short learning review with one ally. Same move, sized small.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods59132241
S5.17After a win they can’t own Luck, team, timing — never them.
What is happening Luck, team, timing — never themCoach move Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update
In the room
Luck, team, timing — never them.
What’s underneath
Unowned wins do not update self-concept. Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update.
Avoid here
Fake humility praise.
Example
Turnaround attributed to “the team and timing.” Specifics: they set a weekly tradeoff meeting and killed two projects. Identity that updates: someone who designs conditions, not a spectator of luck.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods593841
S6.2Imposter feelings Waiting to be found out. Over-prepares. Discounts praise.
What is happening Waiting to be found out, over-prepares, discounts praiseCoach move Evidence file. Belonging vs competence. Who they are becoming
In the room
Waiting to be found out. Over-prepares. Discounts praise.
What’s underneath
Not only a data problem. Belonging story. Do not just list achievements.
Avoid here
Trophy lists alone. “Fake it till you make it.”
Example
Fair jury: three years of delivery. Belonging story: first in family in rooms like this. Work both. Good-enough authority: speak without one more rehearsal.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods92338
S6.25Neurodivergence shaping how they work (ADHD, autism, dyslexia) Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted fro…
What is happening Work set up for different brains; strong in some areas, worn out in othersCoach move Spot strengths; design the environment and adjustments around how they work best
In the room
Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted from masking.
What’s underneath
The client’s mind works differently, not wrongly. Problems often come from a poor fit between how they work best and how the job is set up. Coaching works on fit, strengths and adjustments, not on “fixing” the person. Diagnosis is not the coach’s role.
Avoid here
Diagnosing or suggesting a diagnosis. Treating it as a confidence problem. Generic productivity advice.
Example
A product manager with ADHD loses track of long meetings. Coach helps design shorter meetings with written agendas, and they ask for this as a reasonable adjustment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods69163640
S7.32Job search / in-between identity Lost title. Narrative wobble.
What is happening Lost title, narrative wobbleCoach move Story of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications
In the room
Lost title. Narrative wobble.
What’s underneath
The search is a meaning project as well as a market project. Story of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications.
Avoid here
Only job-search tactics. Only identity fog with no market move.
Example
Ex-title wobble. Alive story: they design conditions for teams to decide. Experiment: two conversations in that language, not 40 generic applications. Chapter change, not apology.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3935
S7.34Being made redundant Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What is happening Role ended by the organisation; shock, loss and practical pressureCoach move Absorb the shock first; then rebuild the value story; then design next steps
In the room
Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What’s underneath
Redundancy is a loss of role, income, routine and identity, often at once, and usually not personal. The client needs first to absorb the shock, then to rebuild a story of their value and design practical next steps.
Avoid here
Jumping straight to CV and LinkedIn. Silver-lining talk. Ignoring finances.
Example
A marketing director is told her role is cut. First session: the shock and the anger. Second: strengths and her story. Third: three experiments in the job market.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5792736
S7.37Role reshaped or threatened by AI and automation Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What is happening Work changing because of AI or automation; uncertainty about the futureCoach move Separate tasks from value; picture two futures; run small experiments
In the room
Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What’s underneath
Some tasks will change; the client’s value is rarely only the tasks. Coaching helps separate fact from fear, find which strengths become more valuable, and run experiments with the new tools rather than waiting.
Avoid here
Reassuring that nothing will change. Predicting the future. Pure technical advice.
Example
A copywriter fears AI will replace her. Coach separates tasks from value. She experiments with AI tools for drafts and repositions as a brand strategist.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods29242636

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Turning it into praise or reassurance rather than observation.
  • Spotting strengths while the client still needs to be heard about the pain.
  • Ignoring overuse, so the strength that is causing the problem gets reinforced.
  • Using a strengths tool as a test result rather than a conversation starter.

10Client traps

  • Deflecting every observation so nothing lands.
  • Treating strengths as fixed identity (“I’m just a driver”) to avoid stretching.
  • Collecting strengths language without using it on the actual problem.

Three worked problems

1

Redundancy and “I’m nothing without the title.” Coach asks for three hardest problems they solved last year and names the strengths: calm in crisis, translating between technical and commercial teams. These become the core of a new CV story.

2

Thoroughness overused. A manager’s detailed reviews have slowed the team. Coach asks when thoroughness helps most. They keep it for client-facing work and set a “good enough” bar for internal drafts.

3

“I just got lucky.” Coach quotes back three specific decisions from the client’s own story about winning a contract. The client writes them down and, for the first time, mentions one in their review.

Where it comes from

Positive psychology and strengths research, including the VIA character strengths (Christopher Peterson and Martin Seligman).

My notes

Family 2 of 5 · Methods 10–20

Shift the Frame

Is the meaning of undisputed facts locked?

This family exists for when the facts of a situation are not in dispute, but the meaning the client has attached to them is treated as the only possible reading. The work is to loosen a locked interpretation without arguing the client out of it.

10
Shift the Frame family

Question the Topic Itself (Assumptions)

Core move: Socratic challenge of the story
5 options10 questions7 situations

1What it really is

A Socratic challenge to the story, not a debate against the client. The target is a frame the client is treating as an established fact — “obviously,” “this is just how it is.”

Every story contains assumptions, and some of them are treated as facts: “they’ll never promote me,” “I have to say yes,” “people like me don’t do that.” This method gently picks out one of those statements and asks how the client knows it is true, where it came from, and what it is costing them. In NLP terms, it uses precision questions to recover what has been deleted, generalised or distorted in the way the client describes their world.

It sounds like: “Never?”, “According to whom?”, “What would happen if you didn’t?”, or “What has to be true for that to make sense?” It is not a debate, a cross-examination or an attempt to prove the client wrong; the tone stays curious and respectful throughout. One well-chosen assumption is enough per session, since challenging several at once tends to make the client defensive. It has worked when the client softens a fixed statement on their own, for example from “I can’t” to “I haven’t yet” or “I’m not sure I can.”

4How it works, deeply

The most useful question in this method is usually not “is this true?” (which invites defensiveness) but “what would have to be true for this to make complete sense?” — because that question surfaces the load-bearing belief underneath the surface claim, rather than attacking the claim directly. Frames loosen when their cost becomes visible, not when they’re proven wrong.

This method borrows from the NLP Meta-Model, which describes three ways language loses information: deletion (leaving out important details), generalisation (turning one experience into a rule), and distortion (adding meaning that may not be there, such as mind-reading or cause-and-effect assumptions). Each pattern has matching questions. “They don’t value me” might prompt “Who specifically?” or “How do you know?” Each question reconnects the summary in the client’s head with the real experience underneath.

The deeper benefit is that clients start to see their beliefs as choices they made from limited information, rather than facts about the world. This doesn’t make beliefs wrong; it makes them open to revision. The coach must be careful with rapport, because precision questions asked coldly feel like an interrogation, and asked too often they make clients defensive. Used sparingly and with warmth, a single well-placed question can open a whole new set of options that were invisible while the assumption looked like a fact.

Quick card

Reach for it when
The topic is a frame treated as fact; certainty; “this is just how it is”
The move
Socratic challenge of the story, not an argument
Watch
They must discover the gap. You do not lecture it.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What are you assuming that might not be true?
  2. What story are you telling yourself about this?
  3. What would have to be true for this to make complete sense?
  4. What is the cost of keeping this view?

2The client’s context

The client speaks in absolutes with no visible curiosity about alternative readings: “obviously,” “this is just how it is,” “too late,” “if I speak, I lose the room.” Certainty has replaced inquiry — usually because the belief is doing important protective work the client can’t yet see.

3The coach’s options

Five common hidden-assumption categories to probe:

1About the other person — “they think I’m weak.”
2About the self — “I am not a people person.”
3About the system — “that’s just corporate life.”
4About time — “it’s too late.”
5About cost — “if I speak, I lose the room.”
Variation from NLPMeta-model questions

Precision questions that recover what everyday language leaves out: missing detail, sweeping generalisations and assumed cause and effect. Each one gently asks the client to look at what lies behind the words.

The client saysAsk
“They don’t respect me.”Who specifically? How do you know?
“I always mess this up.”Always? Has there been a time you didn’t?
“I can’t say no.”What stops you? What would happen if you did?
“It’s better to stay quiet.”Better than what? According to whom?
“He makes me angry.”How does what he does lead to you feeling angry?

Watch: Use one or two at a time, softly. Fired in a row they feel like cross-examination.

From Richard Bandler and John Grinder, The Structure of Magic. NLP tools are widely used in coaching, but research support for NLP’s core claims is limited. Treat this as a practical tool to test, not proven science. See also Other NLP techniques.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach lectures the gap in logic. The client defends the frame more strongly. What should be discovery turns into debate.

6How to move it forward

Soften the approach and ask permission before challenging. Particularize “always” and “never” into specific instances. Ask what would have to be true for the client’s view to make complete sense — this usually surfaces the real, load-bearing belief.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What are you assuming that might not be true?
  • What story are you telling yourself about this?
  • What would have to be true for this to make complete sense?
  • What is the cost of keeping this view?
  • How would the other person tell the same facts?
Going further
  • What evidence would change your mind about this, if it existed?
  • Is this true always, or true in one specific situation you’re generalizing from?
  • Who taught you this was true, and do they still believe it?
  • What would you have to give up believing if this weren’t true?
  • If a neutral observer watched the exact same events, what might they conclude instead?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.3Certain their view is the only one Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for…
What is happening Absolute language, “obviously”, no curiosity about other readingsCoach move Perspective shift / reframe / assumptions
In the room
Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for an ally, not a second chair.
What’s underneath
Certainty often does the job anxiety used to do: it removes ambiguity. Challenging the person feels like theft of that safety. Challenge the frame, never their intelligence for building it. Frames were almost always adaptive once.
Avoid here
Early reframe as correction. Argument. Joining the prosecution. Miracle question (they do not lack a picture; they lack plurality).
Example
“The board is anti-innovation.” After being heard: respected-chair lens — they are anti-surprise. Options change from “braver deck” to “pre-wire two directors.” Certainty loosens without a lecture on open-mindedness.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods10111216
S1.19Jumping straight to solutions Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What is happening Action list before the topic is understoodCoach move Pause action. Check if the problem is the real problem
In the room
Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What’s underneath
Premature plans recycle the old frame. Sometimes action-hunger is anxiety management. Distinguish a planning hour from an understanding hour — and let them choose if both are live.
Avoid here
Helping them polish the premature plan. More options on an unexamined problem.
Example
Client arrives with a 9-point script for a fight with their peer. “If it worked, what would it give you?” “I want to stop being erased.” Understanding hour: erasure pattern. Then a shorter request, not a 9-point prosecution.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17102126
S2.3Angry / blaming / righteous heat Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What is happening Other-focus, injustice language, clenched jawCoach move Validate the heat, then separate fact / interpretation / want
In the room
Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What’s underneath
Anger is often a protector of dignity, boundary, or grief. Do not moralize it; do not join the case. Sequence: validate heat → separate fact / interpretation / want → find the clean request.
Avoid here
Immediate perspective-take (“have you considered their side”) — feels like betrayal. Cheerful reframe.
Example
Rage at a peer who “stole” a project. Anger protecting: not being erasable. Clean request: shared ownership memo + a conversation. Prosecution energy drops when dignity has a next act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71011193740
S3.2Catastrophic forecast as fact Future spoken in present tense as doom. “It’s over.”
What is happening Future spoken in present tense as doomCoach move Time-stamp the fear. Probability. Coping even if
In the room
Future spoken in present tense as doom. “It’s over.”
What’s underneath
Time-stamp the fear. Forecast ≠ fact. Coping-even-if restores agency without fake reassurance.
Avoid here
“It won’t happen.” Pre-mortem as first move if they are already in the movie.
Example
“My career is over after that meeting.” Time-stamp: one meeting, Tuesday. Other outcomes listed. Next hour: send the correction note. Career-over court postponed.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1020
S4.12External locus dressed as realism “That’s just corporate life.”
What is happening “That’s just corporate life”Coach move Test which constraints are real, which are assumed
In the room
“That’s just corporate life.”
What’s underneath
Realism and resignation can sound identical. Test written rule vs cultural habit vs prediction.
Avoid here
Naive “just be courageous” that ignores real power.
Example
“No one pushes back on dates.” Not written. Two people have. 10%: one tradeoff sentence this Friday.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5101634
S7.1Conflict with a boss Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.
What is happening Walking on eggs, rage, mind-readingCoach move Intent/impact, request, manage-up map, power reality
In the room
Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.
What’s underneath
Work inside power reality without disappearing. Intent/impact, request, manage-up map. Do not coach rebellion they will not choose — or submission they will resent.
Avoid here
Courage speeches that ignore power. Joining the prosecution.
Example
Boss optimizes for no surprises, not for innovation. Smallest conversation: risk-flag cadence. Power named; voice not erased.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods10193740
S7.23Unclear expectations Aiming at a moving target.
What is happening Aiming at a moving targetCoach move Make the contract explicit. Success criteria
In the room
Aiming at a moving target.
What’s underneath
Mind-reading the scoreboard is optional. Asking is not. Make the contract explicit.
Avoid here
Working harder at a guessed target.
Example
Delivering a 40-page strategy nobody asked for. Scoreboard question to the sponsor this week. Assumed “depth = value.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1042

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Challenging the client’s intelligence rather than the frame itself.
  • Reframing before the client feels heard.
  • Becoming prosecutorial rather than curious.

10Client traps

  • Treating the frame as a form of loyalty (to a group, a story, a self-image).
  • Hearing any challenging question as a personal attack.

Three worked problems

1

“They think I’m weak.” No actual data behind the assumption. Separating observation from story reveals only one short email as the “evidence.” Other readings surface: they were traveling; they secretly agree; they are avoidant too. Experiment: one clean data-ask instead of a week of mind-reading.

2

“If I take the role I will disappear as an expert.” The load-bearing belief traces back to watching one specific predecessor. Naming the cost of the belief reveals the client is already half-in. The work shifts to “what kind of expert-leader is possible,” not a binary stay-or-go calculation.

3

“The culture will never allow dissent.” Asking who has dissented and survived surfaces two names. The frame loosens from “never” to “not in my old team.” The next move is a smaller, safer truth-telling test.

Where it comes from

Socratic questioning; also used in cognitive approaches to examine assumptions.

My notes

11
Shift the Frame family

Show Alternatives / Other Perspectives

Core move: Offer lenses without attachment
5 options10 questions9 situations

1What it really is

Offering other eyes, other chairs, or an opposite belief — presented lightly, without attachment to any particular one landing.

When a client sees a situation from only one position, usually their own, the coach offers other places to stand. That might be the view of a colleague, a customer, a mentor they respect, a neutral observer, or simply someone who believes the opposite. NLP describes these as perceptual positions: first position (my own view), second position (the other person’s view), and third position (an observer watching both). Each one shows something the others hide.

It sounds like: “How might your manager describe this same week?”, “If someone you admire were watching this, what would they notice?”, or “What would someone who disagrees with you say, at their most reasonable?” It is not about telling the client they are wrong or that the other person is right, and it isn’t a request for empathy on demand. The coach offers each lens lightly and lets it go if it doesn’t fit. It has worked when the client notices something new, such as a need, a fear or a constraint, that wasn’t visible from where they were standing before.

4How it works, deeply

The critical discipline here is non-attachment. The coach offers a lens the way you’d hand someone a different pair of glasses — to try, not to convince them to wear permanently. If a lens doesn’t fit, it’s dropped immediately, without persuasion. A useful variant when direct explanation doesn’t land: put the other person in an empty chair rather than explaining their likely view in the abstract — dialogue tends to unlock more than exposition.

Most conflict and stuckness comes from seeing only through one’s own eyes. Stepping into another position, even imaginatively, gives access to information the client already has but has not used: what the other person probably needs, fears, and is reacting to. The third, observer position adds emotional distance, which often reduces reactivity and lets the client see the pattern between the people rather than just their own side of it.

The physical movement often used in this method, such as moving chairs or standing in different spots, helps the shift feel real rather than intellectual. Changing location and posture makes it easier to leave one viewpoint and inhabit another. The coach also checks that the client fully returns to their own position at the end, carrying the new insights with them. The aim isn’t to agree with the other perspective, but to make a more informed choice from one’s own.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Single reading of events; locked interpretation
The move
Other eyes, other chairs, opposite belief — without attachment
Watch
Offer a lens. They decide if it fits. No selling the reframe.
Four questions that often open it
  1. How would someone you respect handle this?
  2. How would you advise a friend in the same position?
  3. What would the opposite belief sound like?
  4. If there were three other ways this could be true, what are they?

2The client’s context

The client has a single, locked interpretation of events and can genuinely only see from their own chair. They are not being stubborn; the alternative view simply hasn’t occurred to them as a live possibility.

3The coach’s options

Five distinct lenses to offer:

1Respected third person — “how would someone you respect handle this?”
2Advise-a-friend — “what would you tell a friend in this exact position?”
3Opposite belief — stating the reverse of the client’s current view.
4Three other ways this could be true — generating multiple alternative readings at once.
5Other stakeholder’s movie — imagining the situation entirely from someone else’s point of view.
Variation from NLPPerceptual positions

The client looks at the same situation from three places in turn: their own view (first position), the other person’s (second position) and a neutral observer’s (third position). Moving to a different chair for each position helps.

  1. First position — From where you stand, what do you see, hear and want?
  2. Second position — Step into their shoes. What matters to them? What do they notice about you?
  3. Third position — Watching both of you from the outside, what do you notice about the pattern between you?
  4. Back to first — Back in your own seat, what do you know now that you didn’t before?

Watch: Second position is imagination, not mind-reading. Invite the client to check what they guessed with the real person.

Developed within NLP. NLP tools are widely used in coaching, but research support for NLP’s core claims is limited. Treat this as a practical tool to test, not proven science. See also Other NLP techniques.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach starts “selling” the reframe, and the client politely nods while quietly keeping their original reading intact.

6How to move it forward

Offer the lens lightly. Ask how it lands. If it doesn’t fit, drop it immediately rather than defending it. Try an empty-chair dialogue for the other person rather than explaining their view for them.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • How would someone you respect handle this?
  • How would you advise a friend in the same position?
  • What would the opposite belief sound like?
  • If there were three other ways this could be true, what are they?
  • What would a person you respect see that you are not seeing?
Going further
  • If your harshest critic and your biggest fan both described this, what would each say?
  • What would this look like from ten years in the future, looking back?
  • Whose opinion on this matters to you, and what haven’t you asked them?
  • If you had to argue the opposite side convincingly, what’s the strongest point you’d make?
  • What would someone who has never met you notice about this situation?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.3Certain their view is the only one Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for…
What is happening Absolute language, “obviously”, no curiosity about other readingsCoach move Perspective shift / reframe / assumptions
In the room
Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for an ally, not a second chair.
What’s underneath
Certainty often does the job anxiety used to do: it removes ambiguity. Challenging the person feels like theft of that safety. Challenge the frame, never their intelligence for building it. Frames were almost always adaptive once.
Avoid here
Early reframe as correction. Argument. Joining the prosecution. Miracle question (they do not lack a picture; they lack plurality).
Example
“The board is anti-innovation.” After being heard: respected-chair lens — they are anti-surprise. Options change from “braver deck” to “pre-wire two directors.” Certainty loosens without a lecture on open-mindedness.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods10111216
S2.3Angry / blaming / righteous heat Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What is happening Other-focus, injustice language, clenched jawCoach move Validate the heat, then separate fact / interpretation / want
In the room
Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What’s underneath
Anger is often a protector of dignity, boundary, or grief. Do not moralize it; do not join the case. Sequence: validate heat → separate fact / interpretation / want → find the clean request.
Avoid here
Immediate perspective-take (“have you considered their side”) — feels like betrayal. Cheerful reframe.
Example
Rage at a peer who “stole” a project. Anger protecting: not being erasable. Clean request: shared ownership memo + a conversation. Prosecution energy drops when dignity has a next act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71011193740
S3.10Confirmation-seeking Looks for evidence they are right or doomed. Cherry-picks.
What is happening Looks for evidence they are right or doomedCoach move Ask for disconfirming data on purpose
In the room
Looks for evidence they are right or doomed. Cherry-picks.
What’s underneath
Stay curious, not prosecutorial. Ask for disconfirming data on purpose.
Avoid here
Helping them build the case.
Example
“They are icing me out.” Disconfirming: they forwarded a useful intro yesterday. 10% doesn’t fit. Experiment: collect for the opposite case three days before concluding.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods511
S7.2Conflict with a peer Territory, credit, style clash.
What is happening Territory, credit, style clashCoach move Shared purpose, clean requests, third-side view
In the room
Territory, credit, style clash.
What’s underneath
Often unstated score-keeping. Shared purpose. Clean requests. Third-side view.
Avoid here
Winning strategy only.
Example
Credit war. Score: last year’s launch. Shared purpose: this quarter’s customer. Request: names on the memo. Score named so it stops driving.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods111937
S7.19New boss arrived Lost the old contract. Reading the new one.
What is happening Lost the old contract, reading the new oneCoach move Observe, inquire, renegotiate value
In the room
Lost the old contract. Reading the new one.
What’s underneath
Loyalty to the old boss can sabotage the new chapter. Observe, inquire, renegotiate value in the new language.
Avoid here
Performing the old contract louder.
Example
Old boss loved craft essays. New boss wants three bullets and a risk. Re-explain value in bullets. Loyalty named and retired.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods11
S7.28Cross-cultural / remote / hybrid friction Misread tone. Time zones. Silence as meaning.
What is happening Misread tone, time zones, silence as meaningCoach move Make norms explicit. Charity of interpretation + clean checkouts
In the room
Misread tone. Time zones. Silence as meaning.
What’s underneath
Do not over-psychologize a systems/medium problem. Make norms explicit. Charity of interpretation + clean checkouts.
Avoid here
Personality theories about Slack punctuation.
Example
Short Slack from a remote colleague treated as contempt. Medium + time zone. Checkout: “How shall we close decisions in writing?” Norm stated.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods11
S8.19Cultural or identity gap between coach and client Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.
What is happening Coach and client differ in culture, identity or experienceCoach move Name the gap; use the client’s own words; ask, don’t assume
In the room
Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.
What’s underneath
Culture, identity and lived experience shape what problems mean and what solutions are possible. The coach doesn’t need to share them, but does need curiosity, humility and willingness to name the gap and ask.
Avoid here
Assuming your own cultural norms are neutral. Avoiding the topic. Over-apologising.
Example
A coach from a low-hierarchy culture coaches a client from a high-hierarchy culture about “speaking up to the boss.” The coach asks what speaking up would look like in the client’s context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods171128
S9.9Team session: one voice dominates One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What is happening Team coaching; one person fills the spaceCoach move Structure turn-taking; widen perspectives; use spatial mapping
In the room
One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What’s underneath
Dominance may be habit, status or anxiety. Others’ silence may be agreement, fear or disengagement. The team coach balances voices without shaming anyone.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Publicly shutting the person down. Letting the session become a monologue.
Example
In a leadership team session, the CEO answers every question. The coach uses a round where each person speaks in turn, then a spatial map where each person places themselves.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods311293033
S9.11Team blames another team (silos) “Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.
What is happening Team describes another team as the problemCoach move Map the system both teams sit in; find the team’s own part and one shared step
In the room
“Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.
What’s underneath
Silos usually come from structure, goals and incentives, not bad people. Blame protects the team’s identity but blocks shared problem-solving. The coach widens the lens to the whole system and helps the team see its own part without shaming it.
Avoid here
Joining the blame. Lecturing about collaboration. Coaching only the team in the room as if the other team doesn’t exist.
Example
A product team blames sales for over-promising. A systemic map shows both teams are rewarded on different targets. The team proposes one shared metric and a joint fortnightly review.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods11161933

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Getting attached to one particularly clever lens and pushing it.
  • Using “the other person’s view” as a smuggled-in version of the coach’s own opinion.

10Client traps

  • Performing open-mindedness without actually choosing or committing to any view.
  • Collecting perspectives endlessly as a way to avoid deciding.

Three worked problems

1

Peer “stole” a project. Friend-advice chair suggests: “Ask what they thought the handoff was.” Opposite belief: “They thought I was drowning and stepped in clumsily.” Third way: a shared-ownership memo. The client may still confront the peer — but now from a place of genuine request, not prosecution.

2

Board is “against innovation.” A respected former CEO’s lens reframes it: they’re against surprise, not innovation itself. The next move becomes pre-wiring stakeholders, not building a braver slide deck.

3

Self as “the problem” in the executive team’s dynamics. Three other readings surface: structural role conflict; a founder’s shadow; or being the only one naming a real risk. The work becomes sorting person, role, and system apart.

Where it comes from

Perspective-taking; related to reframing and to cognitive approaches that test alternative explanations.

My notes

12
Shift the Frame family

Reframe

Core move: Same facts, different meaning
5 options9 questions11 situations

1What it really is

Offering the same set of facts under a different lens that opens up new options — without arguing the client out of their current one.

A reframe keeps the facts exactly the same and changes the meaning given to them. A client who says “I’m indecisive” might also be someone who takes risks seriously; a project “failure” might also be the cheapest lesson the team has had all year. The coach offers a different frame as one possible way of looking, not as the correct one, so the client can try it on and see whether it opens up new options.

It sounds like: “Another way of seeing this might be… How does that land for you?” or “What if this isn’t a weakness, but a strength being used in the wrong place?” It is not spin, false positivity, or an attempt to make the client feel better about something that genuinely needs to change. A good reframe is true to the facts and useful to the client, not just comforting. It has worked when the client’s energy shifts, when they spontaneously pick up the new frame and use it in their own words, or when a new option suddenly seems available.

4How it works, deeply

Timing is everything with this method. A reframe offered before the client feels genuinely heard lands as correction, not insight — the client experiences being talked over rather than helped. The sequence matters: reflect first, then offer the new lens lightly (“another way to see this might be ___ — how does that land?”). If it doesn’t land, it simply isn’t the right reframe yet, and the coach drops it rather than arguing for it.

Reframing rests on a simple idea: events do not carry fixed meanings, people give them meaning, and different meanings lead to different feelings and actions. NLP distinguishes two common types. A context reframe asks where a behaviour that is a problem here would be useful somewhere else. A content (or meaning) reframe asks what else this same thing could mean. Both widen the client’s options without disputing the facts they have described.

A reframe only works if it is believable to the client, which means it must fit their values and experience. That is why the best reframes often come from the client’s own words, or are built from something they’ve already said. When a reframe lands, there is often a visible response, a laugh, a pause, a change in posture, because the emotional meaning of the situation has shifted. Even when a reframe doesn’t land, it can help, because it shows the client that their first interpretation was a choice, not the only option.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Same facts, only one meaning available to them
The move
Same data, different lens that opens options
Watch
Do not reframe before they feel heard. A reframe too early is a correction.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Another way to see this might be ___. How does that land?
  2. What else could this mean besides the meaning you have given it?
  3. If this were a chapter title other than the one you are using, what would it be?
  4. What becomes possible if this is incomplete rather than final?

2The client’s context

Only one meaning is currently available to the client for a set of events. The “chapter title” for what happened is already carved in stone, and everything downstream (mood, options, self-story) follows from that single interpretation.

3The coach’s options

Common reframe pairs to draw from:

1Incomplete vs. final — “this chapter isn’t over yet” vs. “this is the end of the story.”
2Failure vs. data — treating an outcome as information rather than verdict.
3Personal defect vs. design flaw — is the problem in the person, or in the system they’re operating inside?
4Ending vs. beginning of a chapter — reframing loss as also being a threshold.
5Character verdict vs. strategy that once helped — “you are X” vs. “you developed X as a strategy that used to work.”

5Where it gets stuck

Offered too early, the reframe feels like correction. The client experiences being talked over rather than met, and defends the original frame more strongly.

6How to move it forward

Reflect what’s been said first, fully. Then offer the new lens lightly and provisionally, checking how it lands rather than asserting it as truth.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Another way to see this might be ___. How does that land?
  • What else could this mean besides the meaning you have given it?
  • If this were a chapter title other than the one you are using, what would it be?
  • What becomes possible if this is incomplete rather than final?
Going further
  • If this were data instead of a verdict, what would it be telling you?
  • What’s a kinder explanation for this that’s also plausible?
  • If you had to defend this exact situation as good news, what argument could you make?
  • What would this mean if it were a beginning rather than an ending?
  • Is this actually about you, or about the design of the situation you were in?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.3Certain their view is the only one Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for…
What is happening Absolute language, “obviously”, no curiosity about other readingsCoach move Perspective shift / reframe / assumptions
In the room
Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for an ally, not a second chair.
What’s underneath
Certainty often does the job anxiety used to do: it removes ambiguity. Challenging the person feels like theft of that safety. Challenge the frame, never their intelligence for building it. Frames were almost always adaptive once.
Avoid here
Early reframe as correction. Argument. Joining the prosecution. Miracle question (they do not lack a picture; they lack plurality).
Example
“The board is anti-innovation.” After being heard: respected-chair lens — they are anti-surprise. Options change from “braver deck” to “pre-wire two directors.” Certainty loosens without a lecture on open-mindedness.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods10111216
S2.6Guilty / over-responsible Should have. My fault. I ruined it. They carry structural events as personal sin.
What is happening Should have, my fault, I ruined itCoach move Sort responsibility: mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination
In the room
Should have. My fault. I ruined it. They carry structural events as personal sin.
What’s underneath
Guilt can be a hidden form of control: if it is all mine, I am not powerless. Sort mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination.
Avoid here
“It’s not your fault” as a blanket (they will not believe it, and some piece may be theirs). More rumination disguised as processing.
Example
Reorg hurt their team. Theirs: how they communicated. Not theirs: the headcount decision. Repair: honest meeting. Rumination: nightly replay — extra.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods121640
S2.15Over-excited / manic planning Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.
What is happening Huge vision, no sleep, ten projectsCoach move Channel the energy. Sequence. Risk-check without killing it
In the room
Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.
What’s underneath
Do not match the high. Be the ballast. Channel, sequence, risk-check without killing life.
Avoid here
Matching with more vision. Shame about the high.
Example
Ten-project founder week. Keep the customer-evidence project 30 days. Pre-mortem on scope only. Energy stays; pile shrinks.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1122526
S2.17Afraid of hope / waiting for the other shoe Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.
What is happening Won’t celebrate, discounts winsCoach move Explore the protective logic of not hoping. Tiny allowed hope
In the room
Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.
What’s underneath
Not-hoping is a protective logic after previous crashes. Forcing celebration feels naive. Tiny allowed hope. Evidence they would need.
Avoid here
Party hats. Immediate stretch goals.
Example
After a previous failed promotion cycle. Not-hoping protects against public hope-then-humiliation. 5% safer: write the contribution list privately. Not a LinkedIn announcement.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12152538
S3.14Past-as-prison Origin story explains and excuses everything now.
What is happening Origin story explains and excuses everything nowCoach move Honor origin. Ask what the adult can choose now
In the room
Origin story explains and excuses everything now.
What’s underneath
Honor origin. Do not do archaeology for its own sake in performance coaching. Ask what the adult can choose now.
Avoid here
Deep childhood excavation beyond scope and contract.
Example
Humiliation at 24 explains freeze. Also true today: they run a 40-person org. Adult choice: ally in the room. History honored, not in the driver’s seat.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12252735
S4.4Blaming self for the system Structural problems worn as personal defect.
What is happening Takes structural problems as personal defectCoach move Sort person / role / system. Reduce false shame
In the room
Structural problems worn as personal defect.
What’s underneath
Sort person / role / system. Do not let them “work harder” at an unworkable design.
Avoid here
Only mindset. Only blame-the-org.
Example
Measured on personal heroics and team development. Unworkable. Conversation with boss to change the scoreboard — plus one delegation act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods121640
S6.6Worth = productivity Rest guilt. Weekend collapse. Metrics as self.
What is happening Rest guilt, weekend collapse, metrics as selfCoach move Decouple worth and output. Rest as strategy
In the room
Rest guilt. Weekend collapse. Metrics as self.
What’s underneath
Often cultural and familial, not only personal. Decouple worth and output. Rest as strategy.
Avoid here
Productivity hacks that keep the equation.
Example
24-hour off. Afraid rest reveals they are ordinary. Worth work is the topic; a sleep app is not.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1225
S6.10Legacy / last-chapter questions What will I leave. Who will I have been.
What is happening What will I leave, who will I have beenCoach move Contribution, people, body of work, unfinished conversations
In the room
What will I leave. Who will I have been.
What’s underneath
Legacy talk can avoid today’s messy conversation. Keep both. Today’s version of legacy, not only the eulogy.
Avoid here
Vision board only. Reducing it to KPIs.
Example
Talks legacy; unsent conversation with a brother. Today’s version: that call. Eulogy can wait.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122527
S6.22Midlife / quarter-life / chapter change Time awareness. Identity inventory.
What is happening Time awareness, identity inventoryCoach move Past-future-present deep dive. What to keep / drop / begin
In the room
Time awareness. Identity inventory.
What’s underneath
Do not pathologize a chapter change. Keep / drop / begin. What the last chapter cannot hold.
Avoid here
Crisis diagnosis. Instant reinvention plan.
Example
Expert chapter complete. Unfinished: a conversation with a co-founder. Calling with no name: making things with their hands. Next chapter must hold that; last one cannot.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122527
S7.5Conflict-seeking / always the fight Identity as the one who says it.
What is happening Identity as the one who says itCoach move Discern which fights matter. Tone vs content
In the room
Identity as the one who says it.
What’s underneath
Do not shame their courage. Aim it. Which fights matter. Tone vs content. Winning with the relationship intact.
Avoid here
Making them “nice.”
Example
Fights every process. Two that matter: safety and a false date. Retire the rest. Courage aimed.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122535
S9.13Team after a failure or setback Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.
What is happening Team has failed or had a setback; morale and trust are shakenCoach move Blame-free review; find what worked; agree what to change
In the room
Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.
What’s underneath
After a failure, teams tend either to look for someone to blame or to avoid the subject. Both waste the learning. A blame-free review that also finds what went well helps the team recover confidence and improve.
Avoid here
A blame hunt. Skipping the review. Forced positivity.
Example
A product launch fails. The coach runs a review in three parts: what happened, what we learned, what we’d keep. The team leaves with two process changes and renewed confidence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5123841

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Cleverness for its own sake.
  • Offering the reframe too early, before the client has been heard.
  • Arguing for the new “title” rather than offering it lightly.

10Client traps

  • Collecting poetic reframes that never actually change anything on a Tuesday.

Three worked problems

1

Missed promotion = “I am finished here.” After being fully heard, a possible new chapter title emerges: “the job I would have hated became visible.” Options open up: stay and reshape the role, leave cleanly, or run a 90-day test of the current role under different terms.

2

Team conflict = “I am a bad leader.” After the impact is fully named, the reframe offered is: “You have been running a family, not a team.” This opens the door to setting standards and relating adult-to-adult, rather than self-attack.

3

Product miss = identity as failure. Reframed as incomplete rather than final: one market, one quarter, one wrong assumption. A learning review replaces rumination.

Where it comes from

Reframing was described by Paul Watzlawick, John Weakland and Richard Fisch in Change (1974), and is widely used in therapy and coaching.

My notes

13
Shift the Frame family

Externalize the Problem

Core move: Separate person from pattern
5 options10 questions6 situations

1What it really is

Separating the person from the pattern so they can relate to it rather than being fused with it. The coach never treats identity itself as a diagnosis — the pattern is given its own name and its own logic, distinct from the client’s core self.

Clients often speak about a problem as if it were who they are: “I’m a procrastinator,” “I’m an anxious person.” Externalising, drawn from narrative practice, invites them to describe the problem as something separate that visits them, with its own name, habits and tactics. Instead of “I’m a perfectionist,” the conversation becomes about “the Perfectionism” and when it shows up, what it says, and what it wants from them.

It sounds like: “If this pattern had a name, what would you call it?”, “When does it tend to show up?”, or “What does it try to convince you of?” It is not a way of disowning responsibility; the client still chooses how to respond, and that choice becomes easier to see. It can be light and playful, but it should never mock the client or the pattern. It has worked when the client starts to talk about the problem from a little distance, for example “the Critic was loud this week, but I didn’t listen to it on Thursday.”

4How it works, deeply

Almost every stubborn pattern the client is fighting was, at some point, protective. The key move is asking what the pattern wants for them, even while acknowledging its method is costly — this respects the pattern’s history instead of declaring war on it. Once its protective job is acknowledged, the coach can negotiate a different method for achieving the same underlying goal, rather than trying to eliminate the pattern outright (which usually triggers more resistance, not less).

Externalising comes from narrative therapy, developed by Michael White and David Epston. Their insight was that people often absorb a problem into their identity, and that identity-level stories are very hard to change. By giving the problem its own name and character, the client gets distance from it. They can study it, notice its tactics and timing, and discover moments when they resisted it, without having to change who they fundamentally are.

The distance also reduces shame. It is very hard to examine a problem if it feels like proof that you are flawed; it is much easier to examine “the Worry” or “the Rush” as a pattern that turns up in certain conditions. Externalising also invites teamwork: coach and client can look at the problem together, side by side, instead of the problem sitting between them. Over time, clients often build a richer story about themselves as people who are able to stand up to the problem, which supports lasting change.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Identity fused with the issue (“I am the anxiety / the failure”)
The move
Separate person from pattern so they can relate to it
Watch
Never coach identity as a diagnosis.
Four questions that often open it
  1. You are not the doubt — when does the doubt show up, and what does it say?
  2. If this pattern were a character, what would you call it?
  3. What does it want for you, even if its method is costly?
  4. When is it quieter — what are you doing then?

2The client’s context

The client uses fusion language: “I am the anxiety,” “I am a procrastinator,” “I am the failure.” Their posture often collapses along with the identity verdict — the problem and the self have become indistinguishable in the client’s language.

3The coach’s options

1Name a character for the pattern (a nickname, a persona).
2Map the timing — when does it show up, and what does it say?
3Locate the protective purpose the pattern is serving.
4Identify conditions when it’s quieter.
5Use a third-entity chair for a more embodied, dialogic version (see Method 30).

5Where it gets stuck

The pattern becomes a cute mascot and nothing actually changes — externalizing becomes a way to talk about the problem without doing anything different. Alternatively, the coach pathologizes the pattern, which re-fuses the client with shame.

6How to move it forward

Ask what the pattern wants for the client, even acknowledging that its current method is costly. Then negotiate a different method for meeting that same underlying need — not exile of the pattern altogether.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • You are not the doubt — when does the doubt show up, and what does it say?
  • If this pattern were a character, what would you call it?
  • What does it want for you, even if its method is costly?
  • When is it quieter — what are you doing then?
  • What becomes possible if this is something you have, not something you are?
Going further
  • If this pattern could talk, what’s the very first thing it would say to you today?
  • How old were you when this pattern first started doing its job?
  • What has it protected you from that actually happened once?
  • If you thanked it out loud right now, what would you say?
  • What would it need to hear from you to trust a different approach?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.14First time saying it out loud Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What is happening Hesitation, “this may sound silly”, long pause before the sentenceCoach move Safety first. Witness. Do not rush to fix or reframe
In the room
Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What’s underneath
Being heard is the intervention. Insight can wait. A reframe here is a small violence: it teaches them that this room, too, will rush to tidy what they just risked.
Avoid here
Immediate reframe, options, miracle, challenge.
Example
“I think I want to leave the field.” Coach does not build an exit plan. First work: they hear themselves. Then they choose hold vs move.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17133538
S1.15Confidential / shame-tinged topic Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”
What is happening Lowered voice, looking away, moral languageCoach move Normalize, bound confidentiality, go at their pace, separate person from act
In the room
Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”
What’s underneath
Shame hears challenge as further verdict. Separate person from act before any learning. Confidentiality and pace are methods, not preamble.
Avoid here
Pry. Cheerleading “you’re great.” Diagnosis. Immediate experiment they will use as more evidence of defect if it fails.
Example
Client whispers about losing their temper in a 1:1. Separate: the snap is behavior. Pattern: Friday depletion. Clean learning: Friday is not a feedback day. No identity trial.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13141540
S1.20Wanting a diagnosis or label “What’s wrong with me?” “Am I a bad leader?” They want a verdict they can either collapse under or fight.
What is happening “What’s wrong with me?”, “Am I a bad leader?”Coach move Stay descriptive, not diagnostic. Separate identity from pattern
In the room
“What’s wrong with me?” “Am I a bad leader?” They want a verdict they can either collapse under or fight.
What’s underneath
Labels shrink possibility. Coaching describes patterns and choices. Diagnosis-hunger is often a wish for the uncertainty to end.
Avoid here
Informal diagnosis (“you’re a classic imposter”). Therapy-speak beyond contract. Reassurance only.
Example
“Am I an alcoholic leader or just stressed?” Coach stays in scope: the Friday snap pattern, sleep, what they want instead. Flag other support if clinical. No verdict from the coaching chair.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods51335
S2.5Ashamed / self-attacking “I’m such an idiot.” Collapsing posture. They beat you to the punch.
What is happening “I’m such an idiot”, collapsing postureCoach move Separate person from behavior. Compassion without skipping learning
In the room
“I’m such an idiot.” Collapsing posture. They beat you to the punch.
What’s underneath
Shame already passed a verdict. Any challenge sounds like more evidence. Separate person from behavior first. Rescuing (“no you’re great”) can block the look they need.
Avoid here
Challenge. Reframe-as-pep-talk. Immediate public experiment.
Example
Missed a number in a forum. Shame wants them not to look at the skipped rehearsal. Clean learning: rehearsal ritual. Extra punishment: a week of self-prosecution — named and dropped.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13
S2.10Disappointed after a setback Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What is happening Deflation after effort, “why bother”Coach move Acknowledge the hit. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions
In the room
Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What’s underneath
The hit is real. Toxic positivity here breaks trust. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions. Smallest act of continuing.
Avoid here
Immediate next mountain. “Everything happens for…”
Example
Launch missed. Took: a quarter and a narrative. Did not take: their judgment with customers. Exception: 2019 dip → short learning review with one ally. Same move, sized small.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods59132241
S6.1Fused with the problem (“I am the failure”) Identity language, not behavior language.
What is happening Identity language, not behavior languageCoach move Externalize the problem. You vs the pattern
In the room
Identity language, not behavior language.
What’s underneath
Never coach identity as a diagnosis. Externalize so they can relate to a pattern they have.
Avoid here
Labels. Pep “you’re not a failure.”
Example
“I am the anxiety of this team.” Character: Sunday Weather. Quiet after a written opening line. They have Sunday Weather; they are not it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5132030

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Diagnostic energy — treating the pattern as pathology rather than protection.
  • Skipping the pattern’s protective job entirely.
  • Fighting the pattern with the client, effectively turning the client against themselves.

10Client traps

  • Using the “character” as a way to avoid responsibility altogether.
  • Collapsing straight back into “I am it” the moment things get hard again.

Three worked problems

1

“I am a procrastinator.” Named character: “The Archivist,” who won’t start until every source is gathered. Its protective job: never be seen as sloppy, like a parent who was once publicly shamed. Negotiation: Version 1 with a labeled “draft” stamp. Identity stays intact; method changes.

2

“I am the anxious one on the exec team.” Shows up Sunday night, empty calendar for Monday’s forum. Quieter when there’s a written opening line ready. Externalized as “Sunday Weather.” Design: write the opening line on Friday, before the weather arrives.

3

“I am not a leader.” Pattern: an Over-preparer who never lets the team be visible. Its job is keeping the client safe from a messy public miss. Third way: let one direct report own a segment while the client stays in the room as sponsor, not disappearing entirely.

Where it comes from

Externalizing comes from narrative therapy (Michael White and David Epston).

My notes

14
Shift the Frame family

Parts Work / Empty Chair

Core move: Voice both inner pulls; find shared care
5 options10 questions17 situations

1What it really is

When a client expresses two competing inner pulls, both get a literal or figurative voice. The coach looks for what both parts care about, and deliberately does not pick a winner too early.

Clients often say things like “part of me wants to leave and part of me wants to stay.” Parts work takes that language seriously. The coach lets each side speak fully, sometimes by having the client move between two chairs, and sometimes just by asking them to speak as each part in turn. Each part is treated as having a good reason for its position, rather than one being right and the other being the obstacle.

It sounds like: “Let’s hear from the part that wants to stay. What does it want for you?”, followed by the same question to the other part, and then: “What do both of them care about?” It is not a diagnosis, and talking about parts doesn’t mean the client is fragmented; it is simply a useful way to hold an inner conflict. The coach keeps the tone respectful toward both sides. It has worked when the client stops feeling torn and starts seeing an option that takes both concerns into account.

4How it works, deeply

The single most important discipline in this method is not picking a winner. If the coach allies with the “healthy-sounding” part, the other part doesn’t disappear — it goes underground and sabotages the plan later, often invisibly. The productive question is not “which part should win” but “what is each part afraid will happen if the other one wins?” — because underneath the apparent conflict, both parts are usually protecting something the client genuinely values. A workable third way almost always exists once both fears are named out loud.

Inner conflict is a normal part of being human, and many approaches describe the mind as made up of parts with different priorities, including Internal Family Systems (Richard Schwartz), Gestalt therapy’s empty chair work, and NLP’s parts integration. Giving each part a clear voice lets the client hear what each one is really saying, which is often quite different from the vague tension they felt before. Speaking as a part also tends to surface feelings and reasons that remain hidden when the client talks about it from the outside.

Once both parts are heard, a pattern usually appears: both want something positive for the client, such as safety, growth, connection or freedom, and they only disagree about how to get it. When the client sees this shared aim, the conflict shifts from a fight to a design problem: how can I honour both needs? That creates options neither part could see on its own. It also builds self-understanding, because the client can now recognise these parts when they show up in future decisions.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Two inner pulls; “part of me wants X, part of me wants Y”
The move
Give both parts a voice; find what both care about
Watch
Do not pick a winner too early.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Can we hear from the part that wants X, then the part that wants safety?
  2. What is each part afraid will happen if the other wins?
  3. What do both parts care about?
  4. What third way would not exile either part?

2The client’s context

Classic language: “part of me wants X, part of me wants Y.” Common shapes include stay-or-go, ambition vs. peace, duty vs. desire, promotion vs. life. The client feels torn, and any premature resolution in favor of one side tends to provoke covert resistance from the other.

3The coach’s options

Five common configurations:

1Two chairs for two named parts.
2Protector vs. explorer — a very common polarity.
3Family-loyalty part vs. adult-choice part.
4Critic vs. chairperson (an internal executive function that mediates).
5Success-fear part that sabotages right near the finish line.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach allies with the “healthy” part. The other part goes underground and sabotages the plan later, often in ways that look unrelated to the original conflict.

6How to move it forward

Ask each part what it’s afraid will happen if the other one wins. Then explicitly ask for a third way that doesn’t exile either part.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Can we hear from the part that wants X, then the part that wants safety?
  • What is each part afraid will happen if the other wins?
  • What do both parts care about?
  • What third way would not exile either part?
  • How could you succeed and still keep what that part is protecting?
Going further
  • If each part had a name, what would they be called?
  • What does the cautious part know that the ambitious part is ignoring?
  • If both parts had to agree on one thing, what would it be?
  • What would the part you usually silence say if it got the floor for two full minutes?
  • Which part has been right before, even if it wasn’t the one you listened to?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.6Intellectualizing Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stage…
What is happening Models, analysis, “interestingly”, little felt experienceCoach move Body, emotion, metaphor, silence
In the room
Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stages of their own avoidance.
What’s underneath
Cognition ahead of felt experience gets rejected by the nervous system even when accurate — and here cognition is the defense. Out-analyzing them rewards the defense. Sideways routes (body, image, silence) restore data they have edited out.
Avoid here
Question cube as more architecture. Systemic reframe as another framework. Any method that stays in third-person analysis.
Example
Client maps their “avoidance pattern” with a 2x2. Coach does not add a quadrant. “If the 2x2 stepped aside…” Throat tight. Weather: locked archive room. Work becomes the unsent two-line message, not a better map of avoidance.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6714283138
S1.8Story-looping / circling the same plot Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and…
What is happening Repeats events, more detail, no new insight, time passingCoach move Stop the plot. Move to meaning, pattern, or wanted future
In the room
Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and they would match.
What’s underneath
More plot rarely creates change. Repetition usually means the intervention is at the wrong level — or the loop is protecting them from an act, a feeling, or an ending.
Avoid here
Expand-for-more-detail. Clean language on plot nouns. Sympathy that invites another lap.
Example
Third retelling of a board ambush. Chapter title: “I keep going in without a sponsor.” Level change: one pre-wire this week, or park the topic.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14213539
S1.13Avoiding the real topic Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.
What is happening Safe issue up front, energy elsewhere, late-session revealCoach move Follow energy, not the official title. Name the mismatch
In the room
Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.
What’s underneath
Avoidance is information about cost and safety, not a character flaw. Name the mismatch; do not ambush. They choose.
Avoid here
Clever “gotcha.” Deep dive with eight minutes left. Reframe of the safe topic as if it were the work.
Example
Official: calendar. Heat: “my partner booked this.” Offer the observation. They choose the authorship topic. Calendar was the costume.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12714
S1.15Confidential / shame-tinged topic Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”
What is happening Lowered voice, looking away, moral languageCoach move Normalize, bound confidentiality, go at their pace, separate person from act
In the room
Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”
What’s underneath
Shame hears challenge as further verdict. Separate person from act before any learning. Confidentiality and pace are methods, not preamble.
Avoid here
Pry. Cheerleading “you’re great.” Diagnosis. Immediate experiment they will use as more evidence of defect if it fails.
Example
Client whispers about losing their temper in a 1:1. Separate: the snap is behavior. Pattern: Friday depletion. Clean learning: Friday is not a feedback day. No identity trial.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13141540
S1.18Humor as deflection Jokes at the exact moment of heat. Self-mockery. Room laughs; topic dies.
What is happening Jokes at the exact moment of heat, self-mockeryCoach move Smile with them, then return to the moment before the joke
In the room
Jokes at the exact moment of heat. Self-mockery. Room laughs; topic dies.
What’s underneath
Humor is often a gifted regulator. Do not kill it. Use it as a doorway back to the sentence before the joke.
Avoid here
Tight-faced “let’s be serious.” Ignoring the joke and losing the heat marker.
Example
“My team doesn’t need me — lucky them!” Return. Unfunny version: fear of becoming ornamental after promotion. Work that.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71431
S1.21Comparing this to last time / “we already covered this” Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.
What is happening Impatience, “I know this”, cynicismCoach move Honor the known. Ask what is new in this version
In the room
Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.
What’s underneath
Repeating a topic is not failure. Integration may be missing. Knowing is not living. Honor the known; ask what is different about this week’s living.
Avoid here
Re-teaching the same insight more brilliantly. Shame about repetition.
Example
“We covered delegation.” Living it this week: they still took the deck back on Sunday. Integration = stop-doing list with their boss, not another article on empowerment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293839
S3.1All-or-nothing / binary thinking Success or failure. Stay or explode. Good or weak. No middle.
What is happening Success or failure, stay or explode, good or weakCoach move Insert the middle. Scale. Third options
In the room
Success or failure. Stay or explode. Good or weak. No middle.
What’s underneath
Binaries feel like clarity. They are usually fear. The middle is where most adult work lives.
Avoid here
Picking a pole with them. Moralizing the “extreme.”
Example
“Either I nail the offsite or I’m finished.” Middle: good-enough structure, one hostile question rehearsed, sleep. Alive and imperfect.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141824
S3.5Should / must / have-to language Duty voice. Little want-language.
What is happening Duty voice, little want-languageCoach move Translate should → want / value / fear / someone else’s voice
In the room
Duty voice. Little want-language.
What’s underneath
Don’t smash duty. Find the living value, fear, or borrowed voice under it. Then they can choose.
Avoid here
Adolescent rebellion coaching. Ignoring real duties (care, visa, safety).
Example
“I have to take the global role.” Whose: father’s immigrant script + a sponsor. Want-language: “I want work that uses my languages and a life with my kids.” Both/and experiment becomes speakable.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods114
S3.9Rumination / same thoughts on repeat Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What is happening Circular why, no new dataCoach move Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination
In the room
Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What’s underneath
More analysis of the same tape will not release it. Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination. Give its job another method.
Avoid here
Deeper why. Clean language on the same nouns for twenty minutes.
Example
Hundred loops of “why did they exclude me.” Job of rumination: prevent another surprise. Other method: a cadence question to the boss. Tape stops needing to play all night.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141520303943
S5.5Procrastination / delay Starts Sunday night. Avoids the hard block.
What is happening Starts Sunday night, avoids the hard blockCoach move Name the avoided feeling. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes
In the room
Starts Sunday night. Avoids the hard block.
What’s underneath
Often emotion management, not time skills. Name the feeling at sit-down. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes.
Avoid here
Calendar lectures. Shame.
Example
Deck avoided. Feeling at sit-down: being seen as thin. First 10 minutes: ugly outline labeled DRAFT, one reader. Delay’s job handled another way.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods61415
S5.8Sabotages near success Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the win.
What is happening Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the winCoach move Name the success-fear. Parts work. What would change if they succeeded
In the room
Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the win.
What’s underneath
Treat sabotage as protection, then negotiate. Success-fear. What would have to be true about them if they finished.
Avoid here
Scolding. More willpower.
Example
Fight with the producer the night before a keynote. Part protecting: don’t be seen then rejected. Negotiate: smaller exposure + debrief ally. Show happens.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141517
S6.11Inner critic running the meeting Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What is happening Harsh voice, pre-emptive attackCoach move Personify the critic. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime
In the room
Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What’s underneath
Don’t exile the critic. Give it a smaller seat. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime.
Avoid here
“Silence your inner critic” posters.
Example
Critic protects from a parent’s public shaming. Needs five minutes of risk-check, not the whole prep. Chairperson runs the rest.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1415202530
S6.12Parts in conflict One part wants the promotion, one wants peace.
What is happening One part wants the promotion, one wants peaceCoach move Parts / empty chair. Let both speak. Find a third way
In the room
One part wants the promotion, one wants peace.
What’s underneath
Do not pick a winner too early. Both care about something. Third way that does not exile either.
Avoid here
Aligning with the “healthy” part.
Example
Promotion vs marriage/sleep. Both care about a life that matters and a body that lasts. Third way: role with written non-negotiables, 90-day review.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1418
S6.13Success would break a loyalty Family script, class, culture. “People like us don’t…”
What is happening Family script, class, culture, “people like us don’t…”Coach move Name the loyalty. Grieve it. Design a both/and if possible
In the room
Family script, class, culture. “People like us don’t…”
What’s underneath
Sacred ground. Go slowly. Name the loyalty. Grieve it. Design both/and if possible. Multi-generational patience.
Avoid here
Individualist “just choose you” in session one.
Example
First to take equity over a stable profession. Honor: they still send money and stories home. Departure: “I am using what you survived to build,” not “you were wrong.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1417
S6.17Duty vs desire Should-career vs pull.
What is happening Should-career vs pullCoach move Both voices. Design experiments that honor both where possible
In the room
Should-career vs pull.
What’s underneath
Do not romanticize desire or sanctify duty. Both voices. Both/and for this season if possible.
Avoid here
Picking for them.
Example
Duty: keep the license. Desire: build the studio. Season deal: license hours three days; studio two. Review in six months.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1418
S6.18Family expectation vs own goal Invisible stakeholders at the table.
What is happening Invisible stakeholders at the tableCoach move Name who is in the room. Adult-to-adult with the script
In the room
Invisible stakeholders at the table.
What’s underneath
Go gently. Old loyalties. Name who is in the room. Adult-to-adult with the script.
Avoid here
Cutting-off fantasies as session one homework.
Example
Mother’s voice in the promotion no. Named. Living conversation possible; or a letter they do not send. Choice becomes theirs.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1433
S7.35Having to make others redundant Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What is happening Must deliver redundancies; torn between the organisation and the peopleCoach move Hold both duties; rehearse clear and humane conversations; care for themselves
In the room
Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What’s underneath
The client holds two duties at once: to the organisation and to the people affected. Both are real. Coaching helps them act with integrity and care, prepare the conversations, and look after themselves without pretending the role is easy.
Avoid here
Helping them become cold or detached. Turning it into only a legal script. Ignoring their own wellbeing.
Example
A plant manager must lay off 40 people. Coach helps him rehearse a clear, humane opening sentence and plan support for those affected and for himself.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods714183237

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Picking a winner between the parts.
  • Going into therapy-deep excavation beyond coaching’s scope.
  • Mocking or dismissing the more cautious part.

10Client traps

  • Performing “integration” without actually resolving anything.
  • Building a plan only the ambitious part actually signed off on.

Three worked problems

1

Promotion vs. peace. The ambition part fears dying unseen; the safety part fears the marriage and sleep. Both parts care about a life that matters and a body that lasts. Third way: accept the role with a written non-negotiable (no Sunday email, one protected evening), renegotiated at 90 days.

2

Leave vs. stay. The leave-part fears self-betrayal; the stay-part fears being ungrateful and financially reckless. Shared care underneath both: contribution and dignity. A 30-day trial is set: stay fully committed or begin a clean search — no half-measures either way.

3

Sabotage before a keynote. A part picks a fight with the producer the night before. Its job is protecting the client from being seen and then rejected. Negotiation: smaller exposure plus a debrief ally afterward, rather than cancellation.

Where it comes from

Parts work draws on Internal Family Systems (Richard Schwartz); the empty chair comes from Gestalt therapy (Fritz Perls).

My notes

15
Shift the Frame family

Positive Intent Reframe

Core move: Find the protective purpose first
5 options9 questions16 situations

1What it really is

Locating the protective purpose behind a behavior before asking it to change. This is not an excuse for the behavior — it’s a precondition for actually changing it.

Behind most unhelpful behaviour is a useful purpose. Overworking might be protecting against being seen as not good enough; avoiding conflict might be protecting relationships; procrastinating might be protecting against failure. This method, rooted in the NLP presupposition that every behaviour has a positive intention, asks first what the behaviour is trying to do for the client, and only then looks for other ways to achieve the same thing.

It sounds like: “What is this habit trying to protect you from?”, “What does it want for you?”, or “Is there another way you could get that same protection at less cost?” It is not a way of justifying harmful behaviour, and it doesn’t ask the client to accept the behaviour as it is. It simply recognises that change is easier once the client stops fighting against themselves. It has worked when the client feels understood rather than judged, and can name a safer alternative that still meets the original need.

4How it works, deeply

Fighting a behavior head-on, or excusing it entirely, both fail to change it — because neither addresses the actual job the behavior is doing. The sequence that works: thank the behavior for the job it’s done, then ask what it would need to hear in order to loosen its grip even slightly, and finally design a safer method for accomplishing the same protective goal. The behavior isn’t being asked to disappear — it’s being offered a less costly way to do its job.

In NLP, the presupposition that every behaviour has a positive intention is used as a working assumption rather than a moral judgement. Its value is practical. When a client attacks a habit, the part of them that relies on that habit defends it, and the struggle continues. When the protective purpose is acknowledged, that defensiveness drops. The client can then think clearly about whether the protection is still needed, and whether there is a better way to get it.

Intentions often sit at a deeper level than the behaviour. A habit of over-preparing may intend to avoid embarrassment, which in turn intends to protect belonging. Asking “and what does that give you?” a few times usually reveals a core need that the client clearly values. At that level, finding alternative behaviours becomes much easier, because many different behaviours could meet the same need. The method also builds self-compassion, which research suggests makes sustained behaviour change more, not less, likely.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client is at war with a part of their own behavior — procrastination, perfectionism, an irritating habit
The move
Locate the protective purpose the behavior is serving before asking it to change
Watch
This is not an excuse for the behavior. It is usually a faster route to changing it than a direct fight would be.
Four questions that often open it
  1. If this behavior were trying to protect you, from what?
  2. What has it successfully kept you safe from so far?
  3. How could you thank it while still asking for something different?
  4. What would it need to hear to loosen its grip a little?

2The client’s context

The client is at war with a piece of their own behavior — procrastination, perfectionism, people-pleasing, over-control, irritability. They typically want the behavior gone immediately and feel frustrated at themselves for not simply willing it away.

3The coach’s options

Common protective functions to explore:

1Perfectionism as protection from judgment.
2Delay as protection from feeling something painful.
3Pleasing as an old survival strategy from earlier in life.
4Heroics as protection from feeling unused or unneeded.
5Control as protection from chaos that once genuinely hurt them.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach either fights the behavior outright or excuses it entirely. Neither approach actually changes it, because neither engages with the protective function underneath.

6How to move it forward

Thank the behavior’s job explicitly. Ask what it would need to hear to loosen its grip a little. Then design a safer method for meeting that same underlying need.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If this behavior were trying to protect you, from what?
  • What has it successfully kept you safe from so far?
  • How could you thank it while still asking for something different?
  • What would it need to hear to loosen its grip a little?
Going further
  • When did this behavior first start working for you?
  • What would happen, in the worst case you imagine, if you didn’t do this?
  • If you could keep 10% of this behavior and let go of 90%, what would the 10% look like?
  • What’s a cheaper way to get the same protection?
  • Who taught you that this was the only way to stay safe?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.15Confidential / shame-tinged topic Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”
What is happening Lowered voice, looking away, moral languageCoach move Normalize, bound confidentiality, go at their pace, separate person from act
In the room
Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”
What’s underneath
Shame hears challenge as further verdict. Separate person from act before any learning. Confidentiality and pace are methods, not preamble.
Avoid here
Pry. Cheerleading “you’re great.” Diagnosis. Immediate experiment they will use as more evidence of defect if it fails.
Example
Client whispers about losing their temper in a 1:1. Separate: the snap is behavior. Pattern: Friday depletion. Clean learning: Friday is not a feedback day. No identity trial.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13141540
S2.7Afraid of being seen / visibility anxiety Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speaking. Over-prepares then ducks.
What is happening Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speakingCoach move Future-self who can be seen. Tiny exposure. Identity vs skill
In the room
Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speaking. Over-prepares then ducks.
What’s underneath
Often a belonging story, not a skills gap. Identity vs skill. Tiny exposure beats a forced keynote. Hiding has a protective job and a cost.
Avoid here
“Just believe in yourself.” Giant first stage. Listing achievements only (imposter cousin).
Example
Avoids speaking in the ops forum. Risk: being found ordinary. Tiny exposure: 60 seconds on one metric, ally in the room. Not the offsite keynote.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods152335
S2.17Afraid of hope / waiting for the other shoe Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.
What is happening Won’t celebrate, discounts winsCoach move Explore the protective logic of not hoping. Tiny allowed hope
In the room
Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.
What’s underneath
Not-hoping is a protective logic after previous crashes. Forcing celebration feels naive. Tiny allowed hope. Evidence they would need.
Avoid here
Party hats. Immediate stretch goals.
Example
After a previous failed promotion cycle. Not-hoping protects against public hope-then-humiliation. 5% safer: write the contribution list privately. Not a LinkedIn announcement.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12152538
S3.6Fixed-mindset identity claims “That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”
What is happening “That’s just how I am”, “I’m not a people person”Coach move Historicize the belief. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity
In the room
“That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”
What’s underneath
Do not debate personality. Open it as a story / strategy that once helped. Historicize. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity.
Avoid here
Trait arguments. Typology rabbit holes.
Example
“Not a people person” started after a public humiliation at 24. Already untrue with their craft peers. 10% stretch: one curious question in the staff meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5153435
S3.9Rumination / same thoughts on repeat Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What is happening Circular why, no new dataCoach move Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination
In the room
Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What’s underneath
More analysis of the same tape will not release it. Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination. Give its job another method.
Avoid here
Deeper why. Clean language on the same nouns for twenty minutes.
Example
Hundred loops of “why did they exclude me.” Job of rumination: prevent another surprise. Other method: a cadence question to the boss. Tape stops needing to play all night.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141520303943
S4.5No ownership / “yes but” Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.
What is happening Agrees then undoes, external conditions alwaysCoach move Name the yes-but. Find the hidden loyalty or fear
In the room
Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.
What’s underneath
Yes-but is information, not just resistance. Often a clean no in costume, or a hidden loyalty/fear.
Avoid here
More action planning they will yes-but.
Example
“Yes I’ll talk to her but the offsite…” But protects fear of her anger. Clean not-yet: after the offsite, dated. Or clean no. Anything but a fake yes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods8151740
S5.5Procrastination / delay Starts Sunday night. Avoids the hard block.
What is happening Starts Sunday night, avoids the hard blockCoach move Name the avoided feeling. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes
In the room
Starts Sunday night. Avoids the hard block.
What’s underneath
Often emotion management, not time skills. Name the feeling at sit-down. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes.
Avoid here
Calendar lectures. Shame.
Example
Deck avoided. Feeling at sit-down: being seen as thin. First 10 minutes: ugly outline labeled DRAFT, one reader. Delay’s job handled another way.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods61415
S5.6Perfection delay Won’t ship until flawless.
What is happening Won’t ship until flawlessCoach move Define good enough. Audience of one. Version 1
In the room
Won’t ship until flawless.
What’s underneath
Often fear of judgment wearing a high standard. Define good enough. Audience of one. Version 1.
Avoid here
“Lower your standards” as insult.
Example
Strategy deck. Audience of one: trusted peer Wednesday. 80% is problem, three options, recommendation. Cost of 100%: missing the slot.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods15
S5.8Sabotages near success Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the win.
What is happening Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the winCoach move Name the success-fear. Parts work. What would change if they succeeded
In the room
Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the win.
What’s underneath
Treat sabotage as protection, then negotiate. Success-fear. What would have to be true about them if they finished.
Avoid here
Scolding. More willpower.
Example
Fight with the producer the night before a keynote. Part protecting: don’t be seen then rejected. Negotiate: smaller exposure + debrief ally. Show happens.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141517
S6.4“That’s just who I am” as a closed door Personality as fate.
What is happening Personality as fateCoach move Traits as strategies that once worked
In the room
Personality as fate.
What’s underneath
Honor the strategy before asking it to retire. Traits as strategies that once worked.
Avoid here
Personality debate.
Example
Bluntness helped in a brutal early job. Costs them now in a partnership culture. 10%: one question before the verdict in the next design review.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods15
S6.8Mask vs authentic self at work Code-switch fatigue. Professional persona.
What is happening Code-switch fatigue, professional personaCoach move What the mask protects. Selective authenticity experiments
In the room
Code-switch fatigue. Professional persona.
What’s underneath
Full unmasking in an unsafe system can be unwise. Calibrate. What the mask buys. Selective authenticity experiments.
Avoid here
“Just be yourself” as slogan.
Example
Mask buys airtime with a volatile SVP. 10% more real with a peer. All-day cost: Sunday dread. Calibrated, not a confession in the all-hands.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods15
S6.11Inner critic running the meeting Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What is happening Harsh voice, pre-emptive attackCoach move Personify the critic. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime
In the room
Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What’s underneath
Don’t exile the critic. Give it a smaller seat. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime.
Avoid here
“Silence your inner critic” posters.
Example
Critic protects from a parent’s public shaming. Needs five minutes of risk-check, not the whole prep. Chairperson runs the rest.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1415202530
S6.21Creativity blocked Dry, bored, safe.
What is happening Dry, bored, safeCoach move Play, constraints as fuel, permission to make bad work
In the room
Dry, bored, safe.
What’s underneath
Block is often fear or depletion, not lack of talent. Play. Permission to make bad work. Constraints as fuel.
Avoid here
Inspiration speeches. Big projects.
Example
Block protecting them from being seen as less brilliant than their reputation. Private bad sketchbook. Reputation not invited.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1530
S7.6People-pleasing frame Yes first, resentment later.
What is happening Yes first, resentment laterCoach move Need vs please. Practice a boundaried no
In the room
Yes first, resentment later.
What’s underneath
Pleasing was often a brilliant old strategy. Need vs please. Practice a boundaried no.
Avoid here
“Just say no” without the old strategy honored.
Example
Pleasing started in a volatile house. Costs them now in scope creep. Kind no practiced. History honored.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1517
S7.15Received feedback they reject 360 sting. “That’s not me.”
What is happening 360 sting, “that’s not me”Coach move Separate grain from garbage. Impact vs intent
In the room
360 sting. “That’s not me.”
What’s underneath
Total rejection wastes the gift. Total collapse wastes the self. Grain from garbage. Impact vs intent.
Avoid here
“The 360 is the truth.” Or “ignore them.”
Example
“Arrogant.” Delivery was poor. 10%: they interrupt in design reviews. Want to be known for rigor and room for others. One behavior change, not a personality trial.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1542
S9.10Team avoids the real conflict Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.
What is happening Team tension that no one names openlyCoach move Make it safe to name; map it as a polarity or pattern, not a personal attack
In the room
Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.
What’s underneath
Avoided conflict doesn’t go away; it moves to corridors and email. The team coach makes it safe enough to name, often by mapping tensions as polarities or patterns rather than personal attacks.
Avoid here
Forcing confrontation. Taking sides. Pretending all is fine.
Example
A team says it agrees on priorities, but projects keep stalling. The coach maps the speed vs quality polarity. Both sides see their concern is valid and agree on a way to manage it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods15161819

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Using “positive intent” as spiritual bypass — skipping over real accountability.
  • Skipping the actual cost of the behavior in the client’s life.

10Client traps

  • Romanticizing the habit rather than working with it.
  • Refusing any compassion toward themselves as “letting myself off the hook.”

Three worked problems

1

Perfection-driven delay on a strategy deck. Protects the client from the public humiliation of a thin argument, experienced once in a former role. Thanking it: “You kept me employable.” The ask: send Version 1 to one trusted reader by Wednesday, not the whole board.

2

Snapping at the team on Fridays. Protects a collapsing energy budget. Its positive intent: keeping standards from rotting. New method: Friday becomes a no-new-work day; the standards conversation moves to Monday instead.

3

Cannot ask for help. Protects a first-generation family story: “we do not become a burden.” After thanking it, the smallest clean ask is made to one person, this week.

Where it comes from

Looking for the positive intention behind a behaviour is used in Internal Family Systems and in NLP-influenced coaching.

My notes

16
Shift the Frame family

Systemic Reframe (Zoom to the Ecosystem)

Core move: Widen from person to system
5 options10 questions23 situations

1What it really is

Widening the lens from the individual person to the team, family, or organization they’re embedded in — while holding both levels at once. Zooming out must never become a way to erase the client’s own part in the situation.

Many problems that feel personal are partly produced by the setting the person is in: unclear roles, conflicting priorities, an unwritten team rule, a family history, or a reward system that pays for the wrong things. This method widens the conversation so the client can see those forces clearly. It asks what in the system is shaping their behaviour, who else is involved, and what the system gains from things staying as they are.

It sounds like: “What in your organisation makes this behaviour make sense?”, “Who else would have to change for this to change?”, or “If you replaced yourself with someone else, would the same thing happen?” It is not a way to blame the organisation and let the client off the hook, and it doesn’t make the system the only explanation. The client still owns their part and chooses how to respond. It has worked when the client feels less personally at fault and can name both one thing they can change and one conversation that the system needs.

4How it works, deeply

This method requires holding two truths simultaneously without collapsing into either. If everything becomes “the system,” the client disappears and takes no ownership. If everything stays “my mindset,” real structural problems get ignored and the client is asked to perform peak output on an empty structural tank. The productive move is sorting into three piles — mine, role, system — and then committing to exactly one personal move and one system-level conversation, rather than an all-or-nothing verdict.

This method draws on systems thinking and family systems theory, which observe that people behave in ways that keep the system around them stable. A team member who is always the “fixer” may be filling a gap in roles, and an overworked manager may be carrying the cost of an unclear strategy. When an individual tries to change without changing the system, the system often pulls them back. Seeing the forces at play explains why personal effort alone hasn’t worked.

Zooming out also shows the client where they have leverage. Sometimes the most powerful move is not working on yourself, but naming a structural issue, renegotiating a role, or having a conversation that changes how others behave around you. At the same time, keeping the client’s own part in view protects against helplessness. Holding both levels lets the client act responsibly within the system while also influencing it, which tends to be more effective and less exhausting than either approach alone.

Quick card

Reach for it when
A problem is being carried entirely as personal, when it is also a pattern in the system around the client
The move
Widen the lens from the person to the team, family, or organization they sit inside
Watch
Zooming out should not become a way to avoid the client's own part in it. Hold both.
Four questions that often open it
  1. If this is not just your problem, what does it reveal about the system around you?
  2. Who else in this system feels a version of this?
  3. What would change if this were treated as a design flaw, not a personal one?
  4. What is the smallest system-level experiment you could run?

2The client’s context

The client is carrying an issue entirely as personal (“I am failing”) when it is also a pattern baked into an unworkable system design. This is especially common for people holding invisible loads insiders don’t notice — first-generation professionals, dual-career households, caregivers.

3The coach’s options

1Sort role vs. person vs. system — three separate lenses on the same problem.
2Look for an incentive or design flaw rather than a personal shortcoming.
3Distinguish a cultural habit from an actual written rule — many “rules” are just unquestioned norms.
4Look for a family system pattern that has migrated into the workplace.
5Name a load insiders don’t see — one carried disproportionately by the client’s specific circumstances.

5Where it gets stuck

Either everything becomes “the system” and the client vanishes from the equation, or everything stays framed as “my mindset” while real structural flaws go unaddressed.

6How to move it forward

Sort explicitly into three piles: mine, role, system. Commit to one personal move and one system-level conversation — not a full resolution of either alone.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If this is not just your problem, what does it reveal about the system around you?
  • Who else in this system feels a version of this?
  • What would change if this were treated as a design flaw, not a personal one?
  • What is the smallest system-level experiment you could run?
  • Which part is you, which is the role, which is the system?
Going further
  • If you handed this exact problem to your replacement, would it disappear or persist?
  • What would need to change in the structure — not in you — for this to get easier?
  • Who benefits from this staying exactly as it is?
  • If three other people in your position feel the same thing, what does that tell you?
  • What’s one thing you can change today, and one thing that needs a bigger conversation with someone else?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.3Certain their view is the only one Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for…
What is happening Absolute language, “obviously”, no curiosity about other readingsCoach move Perspective shift / reframe / assumptions
In the room
Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for an ally, not a second chair.
What’s underneath
Certainty often does the job anxiety used to do: it removes ambiguity. Challenging the person feels like theft of that safety. Challenge the frame, never their intelligence for building it. Frames were almost always adaptive once.
Avoid here
Early reframe as correction. Argument. Joining the prosecution. Miracle question (they do not lack a picture; they lack plurality).
Example
“The board is anti-innovation.” After being heard: respected-chair lens — they are anti-surprise. Options change from “braver deck” to “pre-wire two directors.” Certainty loosens without a lecture on open-mindedness.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods10111216
S2.6Guilty / over-responsible Should have. My fault. I ruined it. They carry structural events as personal sin.
What is happening Should have, my fault, I ruined itCoach move Sort responsibility: mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination
In the room
Should have. My fault. I ruined it. They carry structural events as personal sin.
What’s underneath
Guilt can be a hidden form of control: if it is all mine, I am not powerless. Sort mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination.
Avoid here
“It’s not your fault” as a blanket (they will not believe it, and some piece may be theirs). More rumination disguised as processing.
Example
Reorg hurt their team. Theirs: how they communicated. Not theirs: the headcount decision. Repair: honest meeting. Rumination: nightly replay — extra.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods121640
S2.12Lonely in the role / “no one gets it” Isolation. Peer gap. Cannot talk at home or work.
What is happening Isolation, peer gap, can’t talk at home or workCoach move Name the isolation. Build a support design, not only inner work
In the room
Isolation. Peer gap. Cannot talk at home or work.
What’s underneath
Insight without a place to belong often fades. This is not only inner work. Design support. The coach is not their only peer.
Avoid here
More self-reliance identity. Only inner resilience.
Example
New country manager. Coaching holds the weekly sense-making. Also: one external peer and one in-country ally. Belonging design, not just “hold the loneliness better.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods116
S3.12Data-only / feeling-blind Metrics, slides, no human field.
What is happening Metrics, slides, no human fieldCoach move Add stakeholder experience, body, relationship cost
In the room
Metrics, slides, no human field.
What’s underneath
Honor their strength in data; widen the instrument panel. Stakeholder experience, body, relationship cost.
Avoid here
Anti-data sermons.
Example
Cut a team to hit a ratio. Dashboard silent: trust in the remaining leads. They know. Work both panels.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1631
S4.1Victim stance / it’s all them They, the system, luck. No agency language.
What is happening They, the system, luck, no agency languageCoach move Validate constraint. Find the 5–20% they can move. Request vs complaint
In the room
They, the system, luck. No agency language.
What’s underneath
Often hides a request never made — they decided the answer would be no. Validate constraint. Find 5–20% they can move.
Avoid here
Shame. Heroic pep. Strategy pile-on.
Example
“Matrix makes delivery impossible.” True constraint. Unmade request: tradeoff sentence to the constraint-holder. 10% authorship.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods161940
S4.2Hero / I must fix everyone Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.
What is happening Over-functioning, no delegation, exhaustion prideCoach move Return work to its owner. Cost of heroics. Team as system
In the room
Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.
What’s underneath
Heroics are often rewarded. Name the price — to them and to the people who never get to carry their own work.
Avoid here
Time-management tips that leave the identity intact.
Example
Does the report’s stakeholder management. Cost: report stays junior, hero is exhausted. Week experiment: they send their own update. Standard reaches them.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16193540
S4.3Rescuer of the team / parent in the workplace Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.
What is happening Protects people from consequence, buffers the bossCoach move Adult-adult. Boundaries. Development vs rescue
In the room
Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.
What’s underneath
Rescue can be love and control at once. Development vs rescue. Let the standard reach them.
Avoid here
Softness with no standard.
Example
Softens every message from the SVP. Team never feels the real requirement. Fear: they will break. Adult: pass the standard, stay available.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16193740
S4.4Blaming self for the system Structural problems worn as personal defect.
What is happening Takes structural problems as personal defectCoach move Sort person / role / system. Reduce false shame
In the room
Structural problems worn as personal defect.
What’s underneath
Sort person / role / system. Do not let them “work harder” at an unworkable design.
Avoid here
Only mindset. Only blame-the-org.
Example
Measured on personal heroics and team development. Unworkable. Conversation with boss to change the scoreboard — plus one delegation act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods121640
S4.12External locus dressed as realism “That’s just corporate life.”
What is happening “That’s just corporate life”Coach move Test which constraints are real, which are assumed
In the room
“That’s just corporate life.”
What’s underneath
Realism and resignation can sound identical. Test written rule vs cultural habit vs prediction.
Avoid here
Naive “just be courageous” that ignores real power.
Example
“No one pushes back on dates.” Not written. Two people have. 10%: one tradeoff sentence this Friday.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5101634
S6.5Old identity dying (expert → leader, founder → CEO) Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What is happening Grief + incompetence of the new skinCoach move Name the identity funeral and the apprenticeship
In the room
Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What’s underneath
They need rites of passage, not only skills. Name the funeral and the apprenticeship. Newness is not incompetence.
Avoid here
Tool-only manager training.
Example
Founder still in every product thread. Funeral: “I am no longer the best doer in the room.” Apprenticeship: one thread they sponsor only. Old identity contributes taste, not keystrokes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods116233435
S6.7Being “too much” or “not enough” — or both Volume, tone, ambition policed.
What is happening Volume, tone, ambition policedCoach move Find the contexts. Recover range. Choose the room
In the room
Volume, tone, ambition policed.
What’s underneath
Do not shrink them to fit a small culture unexamined. Find contexts where “too much” is the right size. Recover range.
Avoid here
Tone-policing as the coaching.
Example
“Too much” in a conflict-avoidant culture; right size in customer rooms. Range: keep the gift, titrate this room, question whether this is the right room long-term.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16
S6.14First-generation / outsider-in-the-room load Translating worlds. Extra vigilance.
What is happening Translating worlds, extra vigilanceCoach move Name the extra labor. Resources. Belonging design
In the room
Translating worlds. Extra vigilance.
What’s underneath
Do not treat structural load as a confidence gap only. Name extra labor. Belonging design. Skill vs structural load.
Avoid here
Imposter toolkit only.
Example
Translates culture both ways all day. Support: one insider ally briefed. Stop translating: one meeting where they do not explain themselves.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16
S6.25Neurodivergence shaping how they work (ADHD, autism, dyslexia) Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted fro…
What is happening Work set up for different brains; strong in some areas, worn out in othersCoach move Spot strengths; design the environment and adjustments around how they work best
In the room
Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted from masking.
What’s underneath
The client’s mind works differently, not wrongly. Problems often come from a poor fit between how they work best and how the job is set up. Coaching works on fit, strengths and adjustments, not on “fixing” the person. Diagnosis is not the coach’s role.
Avoid here
Diagnosing or suggesting a diagnosis. Treating it as a confidence problem. Generic productivity advice.
Example
A product manager with ADHD loses track of long meetings. Coach helps design shorter meetings with written agendas, and they ask for this as a reasonable adjustment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods69163640
S6.26Chronic illness or health limits reshaping work (including menopause) Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What is happening Health limits energy or capacity; fear of being judged as unreliableCoach move Sort control; redesign work around real limits; plan the conversations
In the room
Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What’s underneath
Health changes the resources available, not the person’s value. The coaching challenge is redesigning work around real limits, communicating needs, and dealing with the identity hit. Medical questions belong with medical professionals.
Avoid here
Medical advice. Pushing performance goals as if health is unchanged. Treating it as purely a mindset issue.
Example
A senior lawyer going through menopause has poor sleep and brain fog. Coach helps sort what’s in her control, plan demanding work for her best hours, and prepare a conversation with HR.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods416323640
S7.10Politics / influence without authority No formal power. Needs movement.
What is happening No formal power, needs movementCoach move Stakeholder map, interests, allies, small bets
In the room
No formal power. Needs movement.
What’s underneath
Purity about politics can keep them ineffective. Stakeholder map, interests, allies, small bets.
Avoid here
Moral purity or Machiavelli cosplay.
Example
Quality initiative. Finance already cares about rework cost. Join that movement. Small bet: one joint slide, not a lone manifesto.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1633
S7.16Lonely at the top / no peers Can’t talk inside the company.
What is happening Can’t talk inside the companyCoach move Design an outside peer space. What can be said here
In the room
Can’t talk inside the company.
What’s underneath
The coach is not their only peer. Help them build a bench.
Avoid here
Insight without company.
Example
CEO client. Coaching holds weekly sense-making. Bench: two outside CEOs, one chair. Not coach-as-only-friend.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16
S7.20Reorg / merger / ambiguity Role fog. Rumor mill. Freeze.
What is happening Role fog, rumor mill, freezeCoach move Stabilize controllables. 30-day purpose. Network
In the room
Role fog. Rumor mill. Freeze.
What’s underneath
Do not pretend certainty you don’t have. Stabilize controllables. 30-day purpose. Network.
Avoid here
Five-year plans. False reassurance.
Example
Unknown: final structure. Known: customers still need X. 30-day purpose: protect X and stay connected to two nodes. Useful in fog.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1633
S7.22Under-resourced / budget / headcount Asked to do more with less.
What is happening Asked to do more with lessCoach move Renegotiate outcomes, not only hours. Tradeoff conversation
In the room
Asked to do more with less.
What’s underneath
Heroic absorption trains the system to give them less. Renegotiate outcomes, not only hours. Tradeoff conversation.
Avoid here
Resilience pep.
Example
Same outcomes, minus two people. Tradeoff sentence to the SVP. Absorption would train “they can always take more.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16
S7.26Organizational values clash Integrity heat. Political cost.
What is happening Integrity heat, political costCoach move Name the clash. Options: influence, bound, leave, choose battles
In the room
Integrity heat. Political cost.
What’s underneath
Do not moralize them into a resignation they don’t choose. Name the clash. Influence, bound, leave, choose battles.
Avoid here
Purity test.
Example
Values poster vs quarter-end number massage. Line: they will not sign a false number. This season’s battle: the number, not the entire culture war.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16
S7.30Work-life / caregiver / dual-career load Calendar collision. Guilt both ways.
What is happening Calendar collision, guilt both waysCoach move Design, not heroics. Negotiated load at home and work
In the room
Calendar collision. Guilt both ways.
What’s underneath
Do not treat structural overload as a mindset issue only. Design, not heroics. Negotiated load at home and work.
Avoid here
Resilience + a morning routine.
Example
Dual-career plus elder care. Heroics covering a missing paid hour of help and a meeting-culture renegotiation. Design both. Guilt unseated as scheduler.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1618
S7.33Disclosure of bullying, harassment or discrimination Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What is happening Client describes treatment that may be bullying, harassment or discriminationCoach move Listen and believe; map options and support; refer to formal channels
In the room
Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What’s underneath
This is not only a coaching topic. It may need HR, legal, union or other formal support. The coach listens, believes, helps the client understand their options and supports their choice. The coach does not investigate, judge or decide for them, and does not promise confidentiality they can’t keep.
Avoid here
Coaching their “resilience” to tolerate it. Telling them what to do. Investigating or confronting anyone. Minimising.
Example
A junior employee describes repeated comments about her accent from a manager. The coach listens, acknowledges how hard it is, and helps her map formal and informal options and who could support her.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17163740
S9.10Team avoids the real conflict Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.
What is happening Team tension that no one names openlyCoach move Make it safe to name; map it as a polarity or pattern, not a personal attack
In the room
Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.
What’s underneath
Avoided conflict doesn’t go away; it moves to corridors and email. The team coach makes it safe enough to name, often by mapping tensions as polarities or patterns rather than personal attacks.
Avoid here
Forcing confrontation. Taking sides. Pretending all is fine.
Example
A team says it agrees on priorities, but projects keep stalling. The coach maps the speed vs quality polarity. Both sides see their concern is valid and agree on a way to manage it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods15161819
S9.11Team blames another team (silos) “Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.
What is happening Team describes another team as the problemCoach move Map the system both teams sit in; find the team’s own part and one shared step
In the room
“Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.
What’s underneath
Silos usually come from structure, goals and incentives, not bad people. Blame protects the team’s identity but blocks shared problem-solving. The coach widens the lens to the whole system and helps the team see its own part without shaming it.
Avoid here
Joining the blame. Lecturing about collaboration. Coaching only the team in the room as if the other team doesn’t exist.
Example
A product team blames sales for over-promising. A systemic map shows both teams are rewarded on different targets. The team proposes one shared metric and a joint fortnightly review.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods11161933

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Doing “therapy of the org chart” — over-analyzing structure as a substitute for personal accountability.
  • Letting zoom-out become blame-out, attacking the system as a way to avoid any personal action.
  • Coaching for peak performance on top of a genuinely empty structural tank.

10Client traps

  • Adopting “victim of the system” as a fixed identity.
  • Heroic absorption — quietly training the system to give them even less support over time.

Three worked problems

1

New manager “bad at delegation.” The system reveals they’re measured on both personal output and team output, and their boss keeps assigning them expert-level work directly. Reframe: this is a design flaw. Experiment: renegotiate one workstream off their plate, in writing.

2

“I can’t influence without authority.” Others in the matrix feel the same way. The system-level experiment: map who else already cares about the outcome and join an existing movement rather than running a lone campaign.

3

Shame about missing school pickup. The personal piece is asking to leave earlier. The system piece is a meeting culture that treats 4:30pm as a normal end time for everyone. Both conversations are needed — neither alone solves it.

Where it comes from

Draws on systems thinking and family-systems approaches (for example Murray Bowen), and on systemic coaching.

My notes

17
Shift the Frame family

Immunity to Change Map

Core move: Find the hidden commitment that keeps a sincere goal from moving
5 options10 questions6 situations

1What it really is

Developed by Robert Kegan and Lisa Lahey. When a client sincerely wants to change but keeps not changing, the coach maps four columns: the improvement goal, what the client does or doesn’t do instead, the hidden competing commitment those behaviours protect, and the “big assumption” that makes the competing commitment feel necessary. The result shows the client that they aren’t lazy or weak. They are protecting something important without realising it.

The immunity map is used when a client genuinely wants something, works at it, and still keeps falling back. The coach builds four columns with the client: what they want to improve, what they actually do or fail to do instead, what they might be quietly committed to that those behaviours protect, and the big assumption that makes the hidden commitment feel essential. Built carefully, the map turns a frustrating failure of willpower into a sensible, if outdated, system of self-protection.

It sounds like: “If you imagine doing the opposite of what you’re doing now, what worry comes up?” and then “So what might you be committed to, without realising it?” It is not a quick fix, and it often takes more than one session to identify the big assumption accurately. It is also not about blaming the client for sabotaging themselves. It has worked when the client says something like “no wonder I keep doing this,” and can design a small, safe test of the assumption rather than another push of effort.

4How it works, deeply

The method works because it changes what the client thinks the problem is. Most change efforts attack the behaviours in column 2 with more willpower, which fails because those behaviours are doing a protective job. Once the competing commitment is visible (for example “I am committed to never being seen as incompetent”), the stall makes sense. The big assumption behind it is usually something learned long ago and never tested. Testing it safely, rather than fighting the behaviour, is what loosens the system.

Kegan and Lahey describe this as an “immune system” for the mind. Just as the body’s immune system protects us, and sometimes rejects things that would actually help, the mind protects us from dangers we learned to fear long ago. The behaviours that block change are often working perfectly, guarding against a risk the client has never examined. This is why technical solutions such as more planning or more discipline fail with adaptive challenges like these.

The real progress comes from testing the big assumption. The client designs a small, safe experiment that runs against the assumption, for example speaking up once in a low-stakes meeting, and then watches carefully what actually happens. Over time, the evidence often shows that the feared consequence doesn’t happen, or isn’t as bad as imagined. As the assumption loosens, the protective behaviours stop being necessary and the original goal becomes much easier to achieve, often without much willpower at all.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client sincerely wants to change but keeps not changing
The move
Map goal, behaviours, hidden commitment and big assumption, then test the assumption
Watch
If the competing commitment doesn’t surprise them, it isn’t the real one yet.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What change would matter most?
  2. What do you do that works against it?
  3. What’s scary about doing the opposite?
  4. What must you be assuming is true?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Knows but doesn’t do — Clear insight, real motivation, no lasting change.
  • New-year cycles — Commits with energy, slips back within weeks, feels ashamed.
  • Self-blame for “lack of discipline” — Explains the stall as a character flaw.
  • Change that matters a lot — The goal is important to their role or identity (delegating, speaking up, setting boundaries).
  • Hidden fear in the room — When the goal comes up, something tenses that the client can’t name.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses where to focus within the map:

1Column 1: the goal — Sharpen the improvement goal so it matters to the client and is stated as their own.
2Column 2: the honest inventory — List what they do or don’t do that works against it, without judgement or fixes.
3Column 3: the worry box — “If you imagine doing the opposite of column 2, what’s the most uncomfortable feeling?” The fear reveals the hidden commitment.
4Column 4: the big assumption — “What must you be assuming is true for that commitment to make sense?”
5Test the assumption — Design a small, safe experiment that gathers data about whether the big assumption is actually true.

5Where it gets stuck

The map stays on paper as an interesting exercise. Or the client writes a “safe” competing commitment that isn’t the real one, so the map produces no surprise.

6How to move it forward

Return to the worry box and ask for the feeling, not the logic: “What’s the scariest thing about doing the opposite?” If the commitment doesn’t create an “oh” moment, it isn’t the real one yet. Then design one small test of the big assumption, with a date and a way to notice what actually happened.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What is the one change that would make the biggest difference for you right now?
  • What do you do, or not do, that works against that goal?
  • If you imagine doing the opposite, what’s the most uncomfortable feeling that comes up?
  • What might you be committed to protecting by not changing?
  • What must you be assuming is true for that to make sense?
Going further
  • When did you first learn that assumption?
  • Where might that assumption not be true?
  • What would be a small, safe way to test it this week?
  • What would you notice if the assumption were wrong?
  • How does it feel to see the stall as protection rather than weakness?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S4.5No ownership / “yes but” Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.
What is happening Agrees then undoes, external conditions alwaysCoach move Name the yes-but. Find the hidden loyalty or fear
In the room
Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.
What’s underneath
Yes-but is information, not just resistance. Often a clean no in costume, or a hidden loyalty/fear.
Avoid here
More action planning they will yes-but.
Example
“Yes I’ll talk to her but the offsite…” But protects fear of her anger. Clean not-yet: after the offsite, dated. Or clean no. Anything but a fake yes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods8151740
S5.1Insight without behavior change Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What is happening Beautiful ahas, same week as last monthCoach move Close the knowing-doing gap. Smaller, scheduled, observable acts
In the room
Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What’s underneath
Knowing-doing gap. More insight can become another hiding place. Integration is a scheduled act, not a better sentence.
Avoid here
Another brilliant why.
Example
Third “I need to stop rescuing.” Integration: one update they do not rewrite this week. Insight without that act is décor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1735383943
S5.7Starts strong then fades Week-1 hero, week-3 ghost.
What is happening Week-1 hero, week-3 ghostCoach move Design environment, identity, review rhythm — not willpower
In the room
Week-1 hero, week-3 ghost.
What’s underneath
Motivation is a bad operating system. Design beats mood: environment, identity, review rhythm.
Avoid here
More inspiration. Bigger goals.
Example
Fade begins Sunday night when calendar fills. Design: Friday 15-minute review locked with a peer. Identity: “person who reviews,” not “person who starts.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1735
S5.8Sabotages near success Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the win.
What is happening Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the winCoach move Name the success-fear. Parts work. What would change if they succeeded
In the room
Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the win.
What’s underneath
Treat sabotage as protection, then negotiate. Success-fear. What would have to be true about them if they finished.
Avoid here
Scolding. More willpower.
Example
Fight with the producer the night before a keynote. Part protecting: don’t be seen then rejected. Negotiate: smaller exposure + debrief ally. Show happens.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141517
S6.13Success would break a loyalty Family script, class, culture. “People like us don’t…”
What is happening Family script, class, culture, “people like us don’t…”Coach move Name the loyalty. Grieve it. Design a both/and if possible
In the room
Family script, class, culture. “People like us don’t…”
What’s underneath
Sacred ground. Go slowly. Name the loyalty. Grieve it. Design both/and if possible. Multi-generational patience.
Avoid here
Individualist “just choose you” in session one.
Example
First to take equity over a stable profession. Honor: they still send money and stories home. Departure: “I am using what you survived to build,” not “you were wrong.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1417
S7.6People-pleasing frame Yes first, resentment later.
What is happening Yes first, resentment laterCoach move Need vs please. Practice a boundaried no
In the room
Yes first, resentment later.
What’s underneath
Pleasing was often a brilliant old strategy. Need vs please. Practice a boundaried no.
Avoid here
“Just say no” without the old strategy honored.
Example
Pleasing started in a volatile house. Costs them now in scope creep. Kind no practiced. History honored.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1517

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Jumping to fix column 2 behaviours, which repeats the cycle.
  • Accepting the first, polite competing commitment.
  • Treating the big assumption as false and arguing with it, instead of testing it.
  • Running it as a worksheet without the felt “oh” moment.

10Client traps

  • Writing an intellectual map that doesn’t touch the real fear.
  • Using the insight as a new explanation for not changing.
  • Designing a test too big to be safe, so it gets postponed.

Three worked problems

1

“I want to delegate more.” Column 2: rewrites reports, takes over calls. Worry: “My team will see I’m not needed.” Commitment: being indispensable. Big assumption: “If I’m not indispensable, I’ll be dropped.” Test: hand one report over fully and see what happens to how leadership treats them.

2

Speaking up in executive meetings. Hidden commitment: never saying something that sounds naive. Assumption: one weak comment ruins credibility. Test: ask one genuine question in Thursday’s meeting and track reactions.

3

Setting boundaries with a demanding client. Commitment: never disappointing anyone. Assumption: disappointment ends relationships. Test: decline one out-of-scope request politely and watch whether the relationship actually suffers.

Where it comes from

Immunity to Change, developed by Robert Kegan and Lisa Lahey (Immunity to Change, 2009).

My notes

18
Shift the Frame family

Polarity Map (Both/And)

Core move: Manage an ongoing tension instead of trying to solve it
5 options10 questions8 situations

1What it really is

From Barry Johnson’s polarity management. Some dilemmas are not problems with a right answer but ongoing tensions between two goods: stability and change, delivery and development, duty and desire, team and individual. The coach maps the upsides and downsides of each pole, the early warning signs of over-focusing on one, and the actions that keep both healthy. The question changes from “which one?” to “how do I get the best of both over time?”

Some tensions can’t be solved once and for all, because both sides are valuable and neglecting either one eventually causes problems. A polarity map lays them side by side: the benefits of each side, the costs of over-focusing on each side, the early warning signs that the balance is slipping, and the simple actions that keep both healthy. The client stops trying to make a final choice and starts managing the balance over time.

It sounds like: “What do you gain from focusing on stability? What happens when you have too much of it?” and the same for the other pole, followed by “What would tell you early that you’re leaning too far?” It is not a compromise where both sides are watered down, and it isn’t a way of avoiding decisions that really do need to be made. Some problems do have a right answer, and the coach checks for that first. It has worked when the client relaxes about the tension and can name specific, regular actions for each pole.

4How it works, deeply

Treating a polarity like a problem creates the swing: you pick one pole, enjoy its upside, slowly hit its downside, then over-correct to the other. Mapping makes the whole cycle visible, which removes the guilt (“the downside isn’t my failure, it’s the cost of over-focus”) and replaces big decisions with small, regular adjustments. It also defuses conflict, because people defending opposite poles can see they are protecting different upsides of the same system.

Johnson’s key distinction is between problems to solve, which have a right answer, and polarities to manage, where two interdependent values both matter. Treating a polarity as a problem leads to a predictable cycle: one pole is chosen, its downsides appear over time, and there is a swing to the other pole, which then shows its own downsides. Organisations and individuals can spend years going back and forth between the two, each time believing they have finally found the answer.

The map works by making the whole system visible at once. Seeing both upsides helps people stop arguing for one side and start protecting both. The early warning signs act like a dashboard, showing when the balance is slipping before the downside becomes painful. Action steps for each pole create a rhythm rather than a one-off decision. Many clients find relief here, because they realise the tension they feel isn’t a failure to decide; it is a natural part of a valuable situation that needs ongoing attention.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client swings between two goods or treats an ongoing tension as a one-time choice
The move
Map both poles’ upsides, downsides and warning signs; manage, don’t solve
Watch
Check it isn’t a real one-time decision first.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What two things are you trying to hold?
  2. What’s good about each when it works?
  3. What are early signs you’ve leaned too far?
  4. What keeps both healthy over time?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Swinging back and forth — Over-corrects from one extreme to the other every few months.
  • Either/or framing — “Either I’m a hands-on leader or I’m strategic.”
  • Dilemma that won’t solve — They’ve “decided” many times, but the tension keeps returning.
  • Two camps arguing — A team or family split into sides that each defend one pole.
  • Guilt both ways — Whichever way they lean, they feel they are failing at the other.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses how much of the map to build:

1Name the two poles — Restate the dilemma as two neutral goods joined by “and”, such as “Work and Family.”
2Fill the four quadrants — Upsides and downsides of each pole, ideally in the client’s own words.
3Find early warnings — “What would tell you early that you’ve leaned too far toward this side?”
4Design action steps — Concrete practices that keep each pole’s upside alive.
5Set a review rhythm — Agree when to check the warning signs again: weekly, monthly or quarterly.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach uses the map for a real either/or decision that does need a choice (job A or job B), and the client feels the conversation is avoiding the decision.

6How to move it forward

Check first: “Is this a choice you make once, or a tension you’ll keep managing?” If it’s a one-time choice, use Two Futures or the decision methods instead. If it’s a polarity, keep the map small: two poles, one warning sign each, one action each.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What are the two things you’re trying to hold at once?
  • What’s good about each side when it’s working well?
  • What happens when you lean too far into either side?
  • What are the early signs that you’re leaning too far?
  • What could you do regularly to keep both sides healthy?
Going further
  • Is this a decision you make once, or a tension you’ll manage for years?
  • Who around you is defending the other side, and what are they protecting?
  • When have you managed to hold both well, even briefly?
  • What would a small weekly adjustment look like?
  • How would you know it’s time to lean the other way?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S3.1All-or-nothing / binary thinking Success or failure. Stay or explode. Good or weak. No middle.
What is happening Success or failure, stay or explode, good or weakCoach move Insert the middle. Scale. Third options
In the room
Success or failure. Stay or explode. Good or weak. No middle.
What’s underneath
Binaries feel like clarity. They are usually fear. The middle is where most adult work lives.
Avoid here
Picking a pole with them. Moralizing the “extreme.”
Example
“Either I nail the offsite or I’m finished.” Middle: good-enough structure, one hostile question rehearsed, sleep. Alive and imperfect.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141824
S6.12Parts in conflict One part wants the promotion, one wants peace.
What is happening One part wants the promotion, one wants peaceCoach move Parts / empty chair. Let both speak. Find a third way
In the room
One part wants the promotion, one wants peace.
What’s underneath
Do not pick a winner too early. Both care about something. Third way that does not exile either.
Avoid here
Aligning with the “healthy” part.
Example
Promotion vs marriage/sleep. Both care about a life that matters and a body that lasts. Third way: role with written non-negotiables, 90-day review.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1418
S6.17Duty vs desire Should-career vs pull.
What is happening Should-career vs pullCoach move Both voices. Design experiments that honor both where possible
In the room
Should-career vs pull.
What’s underneath
Do not romanticize desire or sanctify duty. Both voices. Both/and for this season if possible.
Avoid here
Picking for them.
Example
Duty: keep the license. Desire: build the studio. Season deal: license hours three days; studio two. Review in six months.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1418
S6.19Money vs meaning tension Golden handcuffs. Lifestyle lock.
What is happening Golden handcuffs, lifestyle lockCoach move Numbers + values. Runway. Enough definition
In the room
Golden handcuffs. Lifestyle lock.
What’s underneath
Fantasy exits without numbers stay fantasy. Enough definition. Runway. Numbers + values.
Avoid here
“Follow the bliss” with no math.
Example
Enough is named as a number for the first time. Bridge: two years, one consulting retainer. Fantasy becomes a plan or an honest stay.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1824
S7.30Work-life / caregiver / dual-career load Calendar collision. Guilt both ways.
What is happening Calendar collision, guilt both waysCoach move Design, not heroics. Negotiated load at home and work
In the room
Calendar collision. Guilt both ways.
What’s underneath
Do not treat structural overload as a mindset issue only. Design, not heroics. Negotiated load at home and work.
Avoid here
Resilience + a morning routine.
Example
Dual-career plus elder care. Heroics covering a missing paid hour of help and a meeting-culture renegotiation. Design both. Guilt unseated as scheduler.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1618
S7.35Having to make others redundant Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What is happening Must deliver redundancies; torn between the organisation and the peopleCoach move Hold both duties; rehearse clear and humane conversations; care for themselves
In the room
Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What’s underneath
The client holds two duties at once: to the organisation and to the people affected. Both are real. Coaching helps them act with integrity and care, prepare the conversations, and look after themselves without pretending the role is easy.
Avoid here
Helping them become cold or detached. Turning it into only a legal script. Ignoring their own wellbeing.
Example
A plant manager must lay off 40 people. Coach helps him rehearse a clear, humane opening sentence and plan support for those affected and for himself.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods714183237
S7.36Returning from parental leave Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What is happening Back from parental leave; new identity, new demands, out of the loopCoach move Map the polarity; set clear agreements at work and home
In the room
Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What’s underneath
The client is adjusting to a new identity and a new set of demands. Work may have moved on. The tension between career and family is ongoing, not a problem to solve once. Clear agreements at work and at home matter.
Avoid here
Assuming they want less, or more, ambition. Treating guilt as a problem to eliminate.
Example
A software lead returns after a year. Coach maps the Work and Family polarity, and helps plan conversations with her boss about the first three months.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1821244042
S9.10Team avoids the real conflict Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.
What is happening Team tension that no one names openlyCoach move Make it safe to name; map it as a polarity or pattern, not a personal attack
In the room
Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.
What’s underneath
Avoided conflict doesn’t go away; it moves to corridors and email. The team coach makes it safe enough to name, often by mapping tensions as polarities or patterns rather than personal attacks.
Avoid here
Forcing confrontation. Taking sides. Pretending all is fine.
Example
A team says it agrees on priorities, but projects keep stalling. The coach maps the speed vs quality polarity. Both sides see their concern is valid and agree on a way to manage it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods15161819

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Using it for real one-time decisions.
  • Filling the map with the coach’s words instead of the client’s.
  • Making it a beautiful diagram with no action steps or warning signs.
  • Quietly favouring the pole the coach prefers.

10Client traps

  • Using “both/and” to avoid ever making a hard trade-off.
  • Listing upsides for one pole only and downsides for the other.
  • Agreeing to the map but not tracking the warning signs.

Three worked problems

1

“Hands-on or strategic?” Map: hands-on keeps quality and credibility; too much means no time to think. Strategic gives direction; too much means losing touch. Warning sign: last-minute fixes three weeks running. Action: one customer call a week and one protected thinking morning.

2

Parent returning from leave. Poles: Career and Family. Guilt both ways disappears once the client sees the downsides as over-focus, not failure. Monthly check of two warning signs replaces nightly guilt.

3

Team split on speed vs quality. Coach maps the polarity with the whole team. Both camps see their pole’s downside. They agree on a “quality gate” for customer-facing releases only.

Where it comes from

Polarity management, developed by Barry Johnson (Polarity Management).

My notes

19
Shift the Frame family

Map the Drama Triangle

Core move: Spot the Victim–Rescuer–Persecutor roles; step into a healthier stance
5 options10 questions8 situations

1What it really is

Based on Stephen Karpman’s drama triangle from transactional analysis, with David Emerald’s “Empowerment Dynamic” as the way out. In repeating conflicts, people switch between three roles: Victim (“poor me”), Persecutor (“it’s your fault”) and Rescuer (“let me fix it for you”). The coach helps the client see which role they take and when, and then explore the healthier alternatives: Creator instead of Victim, Challenger instead of Persecutor, and Coach instead of Rescuer.

The drama triangle helps a client see that a recurring conflict follows a familiar script with three roles. The Victim feels powerless and hard done by, the Persecutor blames and criticises, and the Rescuer steps in to help in ways that keep others dependent. People move between all three, often within a single conversation. The coach draws the triangle, helps the client place themselves and others on it, and then explores what the healthier roles of Creator, Challenger and Coach would look like in the same situation.

It sounds like: “Where would you place yourself on the triangle in that meeting?”, “When did you switch roles?”, or “What would the Creator do here instead?” It is not a way of labelling people, and it shouldn’t be used to accuse anyone, including the client. Everyone steps onto the triangle sometimes. It has worked when the client recognises their own role switches without defensiveness, and can name one specific way to respond differently next time the pattern starts.

4How it works, deeply

The triangle works because it is easy to grasp and takes the shame out of the pattern. Roles are positions anyone can step into, not personality flaws. Seeing the switches explains why “helping” so often ends in resentment and why blame never solves anything: each role keeps the triangle going. The empowerment alternatives give the client somewhere to go instead of just something to stop.

The triangle shows how roles feed each other. A Victim invites a Rescuer, whose help can confirm the Victim’s helplessness; a Rescuer who isn’t appreciated may become a Persecutor; and a Persecutor may feel attacked and shift into Victim. This is why the same arguments repeat across different people and situations: the roles stay the same, even when the faces change. Recognising this pattern is often a relief, because it explains so much at once.

Emerald’s alternatives work by changing the underlying focus from problems to outcomes. The Creator asks what they want and takes responsibility for their response, the Challenger provokes growth without attacking, and the Coach supports others to find their own solutions instead of fixing for them. Each new role meets the same underlying need as the old one, which is why it’s possible to switch. Practised over time, these roles can replace the triangle with healthier patterns of relating.

Quick card

Reach for it when
The same conflict repeats, helping turns to resentment, or blame drives every story
The move
Map who is in which role, find the switches, and choose an empowerment role
Watch
Keep the focus on the client’s own role, not on labelling others.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Where were you on the triangle?
  2. When did you switch roles?
  3. What does that role give you?
  4. What would the Creator or Coach version do?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Same fight, different cast — The same conflict pattern repeats across bosses, teams or relationships.
  • Exhausted helper — Keeps rescuing others and resents it.
  • Blame on repeat — Every story has a villain, and it is never them.
  • Role switching — Starts as the helper, ends as the injured party or the attacker.
  • Team drama — A team where a few people are always the rescuers, the targets or the critics.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses how to use the triangle:

1Map one incident — Walk through one recent conflict and place each person on the triangle, step by step.
2Find the switch point — “When did you move from helping to feeling used?”
3Name the payoff — Each role gives something: sympathy, control, being needed. What does theirs give?
4Shift to the empowerment roles — Ask what a Creator, Challenger or Coach version of them would do.
5Rehearse the new stance — Practise one sentence from the healthier role for the next conflict.

5Where it gets stuck

The client uses the triangle to label other people (“she’s such a Victim”) and the session becomes a new form of blame.

6How to move it forward

Bring it back to the client: “Where were you on the triangle in that moment?” Keep the focus on their own switch points and their next choice, not on diagnosing others.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • In that conflict, who was rescuing, who was blaming, and who felt like the victim?
  • Where were you at the start? Where were you at the end?
  • What did that role give you?
  • What would a Creator, Challenger or Coach version of you have done?
  • What will you say next time, from the healthier role?
Going further
  • When did helping turn into resentment?
  • What happens to the others when you step off the triangle?
  • Which role do you slip into most when you’re tired?
  • Who in your life is skilled at staying off the triangle?
  • What would you need to let someone else solve their own problem?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S2.3Angry / blaming / righteous heat Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What is happening Other-focus, injustice language, clenched jawCoach move Validate the heat, then separate fact / interpretation / want
In the room
Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What’s underneath
Anger is often a protector of dignity, boundary, or grief. Do not moralize it; do not join the case. Sequence: validate heat → separate fact / interpretation / want → find the clean request.
Avoid here
Immediate perspective-take (“have you considered their side”) — feels like betrayal. Cheerful reframe.
Example
Rage at a peer who “stole” a project. Anger protecting: not being erasable. Clean request: shared ownership memo + a conversation. Prosecution energy drops when dignity has a next act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71011193740
S4.1Victim stance / it’s all them They, the system, luck. No agency language.
What is happening They, the system, luck, no agency languageCoach move Validate constraint. Find the 5–20% they can move. Request vs complaint
In the room
They, the system, luck. No agency language.
What’s underneath
Often hides a request never made — they decided the answer would be no. Validate constraint. Find 5–20% they can move.
Avoid here
Shame. Heroic pep. Strategy pile-on.
Example
“Matrix makes delivery impossible.” True constraint. Unmade request: tradeoff sentence to the constraint-holder. 10% authorship.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods161940
S4.2Hero / I must fix everyone Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.
What is happening Over-functioning, no delegation, exhaustion prideCoach move Return work to its owner. Cost of heroics. Team as system
In the room
Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.
What’s underneath
Heroics are often rewarded. Name the price — to them and to the people who never get to carry their own work.
Avoid here
Time-management tips that leave the identity intact.
Example
Does the report’s stakeholder management. Cost: report stays junior, hero is exhausted. Week experiment: they send their own update. Standard reaches them.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16193540
S4.3Rescuer of the team / parent in the workplace Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.
What is happening Protects people from consequence, buffers the bossCoach move Adult-adult. Boundaries. Development vs rescue
In the room
Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.
What’s underneath
Rescue can be love and control at once. Development vs rescue. Let the standard reach them.
Avoid here
Softness with no standard.
Example
Softens every message from the SVP. Team never feels the real requirement. Fear: they will break. Adult: pass the standard, stay available.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16193740
S7.1Conflict with a boss Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.
What is happening Walking on eggs, rage, mind-readingCoach move Intent/impact, request, manage-up map, power reality
In the room
Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.
What’s underneath
Work inside power reality without disappearing. Intent/impact, request, manage-up map. Do not coach rebellion they will not choose — or submission they will resent.
Avoid here
Courage speeches that ignore power. Joining the prosecution.
Example
Boss optimizes for no surprises, not for innovation. Smallest conversation: risk-flag cadence. Power named; voice not erased.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods10193740
S7.2Conflict with a peer Territory, credit, style clash.
What is happening Territory, credit, style clashCoach move Shared purpose, clean requests, third-side view
In the room
Territory, credit, style clash.
What’s underneath
Often unstated score-keeping. Shared purpose. Clean requests. Third-side view.
Avoid here
Winning strategy only.
Example
Credit war. Score: last year’s launch. Shared purpose: this quarter’s customer. Request: names on the memo. Score named so it stops driving.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods111937
S9.10Team avoids the real conflict Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.
What is happening Team tension that no one names openlyCoach move Make it safe to name; map it as a polarity or pattern, not a personal attack
In the room
Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.
What’s underneath
Avoided conflict doesn’t go away; it moves to corridors and email. The team coach makes it safe enough to name, often by mapping tensions as polarities or patterns rather than personal attacks.
Avoid here
Forcing confrontation. Taking sides. Pretending all is fine.
Example
A team says it agrees on priorities, but projects keep stalling. The coach maps the speed vs quality polarity. Both sides see their concern is valid and agree on a way to manage it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods15161819
S9.11Team blames another team (silos) “Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.
What is happening Team describes another team as the problemCoach move Map the system both teams sit in; find the team’s own part and one shared step
In the room
“Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.
What’s underneath
Silos usually come from structure, goals and incentives, not bad people. Blame protects the team’s identity but blocks shared problem-solving. The coach widens the lens to the whole system and helps the team see its own part without shaming it.
Avoid here
Joining the blame. Lecturing about collaboration. Coaching only the team in the room as if the other team doesn’t exist.
Example
A product team blames sales for over-promising. A systemic map shows both teams are rewarded on different targets. The team proposes one shared metric and a joint fortnightly review.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods11161933

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Using the roles as labels for people rather than positions people take.
  • Letting the client analyse others instead of their own part.
  • Moralising about the payoff, which creates shame.
  • Stopping at the diagnosis without the empowerment alternatives.

10Client traps

  • Applying the triangle to everyone except themselves.
  • Admitting the pattern intellectually while keeping the payoff.
  • Rescuing the coach (agreeing, pleasing) inside the session itself.

Three worked problems

1

The always-helpful manager. Rescues an underperformer for months, then explodes (Persecutor) and feels guilty (Victim). Coach maps it. Next step from the Coach role: a clear standard and support offer, with the employee owning the plan.

2

Peer conflict over credit. Client sees they start as Victim (“they took my work”), then become Persecutor in emails. Challenger version: one direct, calm request about how credit is shared.

3

Family business tension. The founder rescues a child in the business, the other sibling persecutes. Mapping it gives everyone language to step off the triangle in family meetings.

Where it comes from

The drama triangle was described by Stephen Karpman (1968) within transactional analysis; the empowerment roles come from David Emerald (The Power of TED*).

My notes

20
Shift the Frame family

Defuse From the Thought

Core move: Hold the thought lightly; act on values, not on the thought
5 options10 questions5 situations

1What it really is

From Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and Training (ACT, Steven Hayes and others). Instead of arguing with an unhelpful thought, the client learns to notice it as a thought: words and pictures in the mind, not a fact or a command. The coach then helps them choose a values-based action even while the thought and its discomfort are still present. The aim isn’t to make the thought go away. It’s to stop it running the show.

Some thoughts are hard to argue with, like “I’m not good enough” or “this will go wrong.” Instead of debating them, defusion helps the client step back and see the thought as a thought. Simple practices help: saying “I’m having the thought that…,” giving a recurring story a name, or noticing the thought as words passing through the mind. The thought may still be there, but it no longer gets to decide what the client does.

It sounds like: “What happens if you say, ‘I’m noticing the thought that I’ll fail’?”, “Is this thought helping you right now?”, or “If the thought came along for the ride, what would you do anyway?” It is not positive thinking and it doesn’t try to replace the thought with a better one. It also isn’t a dismissal of the client’s experience, since the discomfort is treated as real. It has worked when the client can name the thought without being caught by it, and can choose an action that fits their values while the thought is still present.

4How it works, deeply

Arguing with a thought keeps the mind engaged with it, and often makes it louder. Defusion changes the client’s relationship to the thought rather than its content, which makes it useful for thoughts that are partly true, very old, or impossible to disprove. Combined with values, it gives the client a way to act now rather than waiting for confidence. Many people find the discomfort becomes more bearable when it serves something they care about.

ACT draws on research into how language shapes experience. Because we think in words, thoughts can feel like literal truths, a phenomenon called cognitive fusion. When fused, a thought like “I’ll fail” feels like a prediction rather than a passing mental event. Defusion techniques create a small gap between the person and the thought. In that gap, the client can notice the thought, recognise its familiar pattern, and decide whether it is useful in this moment.

This method pairs naturally with values. Instead of waiting for difficult thoughts to disappear, which may never happen, the client asks what matters to them and chooses actions in that direction. This is what ACT calls psychological flexibility: being able to stay in contact with the present moment, including discomfort, while acting on what matters. Research suggests psychological flexibility is linked to wellbeing and performance across many settings, which is why this method is increasingly used in workplace coaching.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client treats a thought as a fact, argues with it endlessly, or waits to feel ready
The move
Notice the thought as a thought, then act on values with it present
Watch
The aim is not to remove the thought, but to stop it deciding.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What is your mind telling you?
  2. Is this an old familiar story?
  3. If it were background noise, what would you do?
  4. Are you willing to feel this for what matters?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Fused with a thought — “I’m going to fail” is treated as a fact, not a prediction.
  • Endless self-debate — Has tried positive thinking and arguing back, and the thought still wins.
  • Waiting to feel ready — Won’t act until the fear or doubt disappears.
  • Harsh inner commentary — A critical voice narrates every action.
  • Rumination loops — The same worried thoughts replay without new information.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses among five defusion and values moves:

1Name the thought — “I notice I’m having the thought that…” creates distance from the content.
2Name the story — “Ah, the ‘not good enough’ story again.” Give the recurring theme a title.
3Thank the mind — Treat the thought as an overprotective helper: “Thanks, mind, I’ve got it.”
4Values compass — “If this thought were just background noise, what would you do that matters to you?”
5Willingness — “Are you willing to have this discomfort, in service of what matters?”

5Where it gets stuck

The client uses defusion techniques to try to get rid of the thought, and is frustrated when it comes back. Or the exercises feel silly and the client disengages.

6How to move it forward

Clarify the aim: the thought may stay, and that’s fine; the question is whether it decides. Keep the language natural and the techniques light. Move quickly to the values question and a concrete action.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What is your mind telling you right now?
  • If you put “I’m having the thought that…” in front of it, what changes?
  • Is this a new thought, or an old familiar story?
  • If that thought were just background noise, what would you do?
  • Are you willing to feel some of this discomfort for something that matters to you?
Going further
  • What has arguing with this thought achieved so far?
  • What would you name this story if it were a book title?
  • What is the thought trying to protect you from?
  • What matters enough to you to act even with the doubt present?
  • What’s one small action you could take with the thought along for the ride?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S2.4Anxious / catastrophizing What-if chains. Worst-case movies spoken as present fact. Body tension.
What is happening What-if chains, worst-case movies, body tensionCoach move Present facts vs forecast. Scale likelihood. Small next experiment
In the room
What-if chains. Worst-case movies spoken as present fact. Body tension.
What’s underneath
Anxiety collapses time: forecast becomes now. Ground in known vs imagined. Scale likelihood. Coping-even-if. A 2% safer next step. Do not debate the catastrophe (argument feeds it).
Avoid here
Pre-mortem as first move (rehearses failure). Miracle question if they cannot leave the movie. “It won’t happen.”
Example
“I will be fired in the town hall.” Known: agenda has their update. Imagined: public humiliation chain. Likelihood they actually name: 3. 2% safer step: walk the update with an ally tonight. Tree stops growing.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods62030
S3.2Catastrophic forecast as fact Future spoken in present tense as doom. “It’s over.”
What is happening Future spoken in present tense as doomCoach move Time-stamp the fear. Probability. Coping even if
In the room
Future spoken in present tense as doom. “It’s over.”
What’s underneath
Time-stamp the fear. Forecast ≠ fact. Coping-even-if restores agency without fake reassurance.
Avoid here
“It won’t happen.” Pre-mortem as first move if they are already in the movie.
Example
“My career is over after that meeting.” Time-stamp: one meeting, Tuesday. Other outcomes listed. Next hour: send the correction note. Career-over court postponed.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1020
S3.9Rumination / same thoughts on repeat Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What is happening Circular why, no new dataCoach move Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination
In the room
Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What’s underneath
More analysis of the same tape will not release it. Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination. Give its job another method.
Avoid here
Deeper why. Clean language on the same nouns for twenty minutes.
Example
Hundred loops of “why did they exclude me.” Job of rumination: prevent another surprise. Other method: a cadence question to the boss. Tape stops needing to play all night.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141520303943
S6.1Fused with the problem (“I am the failure”) Identity language, not behavior language.
What is happening Identity language, not behavior languageCoach move Externalize the problem. You vs the pattern
In the room
Identity language, not behavior language.
What’s underneath
Never coach identity as a diagnosis. Externalize so they can relate to a pattern they have.
Avoid here
Labels. Pep “you’re not a failure.”
Example
“I am the anxiety of this team.” Character: Sunday Weather. Quiet after a written opening line. They have Sunday Weather; they are not it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5132030
S6.11Inner critic running the meeting Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What is happening Harsh voice, pre-emptive attackCoach move Personify the critic. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime
In the room
Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What’s underneath
Don’t exile the critic. Give it a smaller seat. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime.
Avoid here
“Silence your inner critic” posters.
Example
Critic protects from a parent’s public shaming. Needs five minutes of risk-check, not the whole prep. Chairperson runs the rest.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1415202530

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Turning defusion into another way of fighting the thought.
  • Using it to dismiss real concerns that deserve problem-solving.
  • Overusing exercises so they feel like gimmicks.
  • Forgetting the values and action step.

10Client traps

  • Waiting for the thought to disappear before acting.
  • Intellectualising the method instead of practising it.
  • Using “it’s just a thought” to ignore genuine warning signs.

Three worked problems

1

“I’ll embarrass myself in the keynote.” Coach invites “I’m having the thought that I’ll embarrass myself.” The client laughs a little. Value: sharing what the team learned. Action: rehearse once with the thought present, rather than waiting to feel confident.

2

The “not good enough” story. Client names it “The Exam.” When it appears before reviews, they say “The Exam’s on again” and continue preparing. The thought shows up less loudly over a month.

3

3am rumination about a decision. Instead of solving it again at night, client notes the thought, thanks their mind, and keeps a one-line note for the morning. Sleep improves; the decision gets one proper review slot.

Where it comes from

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and Training (Steven Hayes, Kelly Wilson, Kirk Strosahl and others); see Russ Harris, ACT Made Simple.

My notes

Family 3 of 5 · Methods 21–27

Move in Time

Is the client standing only inside today’s problem?

This family exists for clients who are standing entirely inside today’s version of the problem, with no picture of what “solved” looks like. The work is to travel — forward, or through another’s eyes across time — before generating options.

21
Move in Time family

Imagine a Preferred Future

Core move: Destination before options
4 options10 questions12 situations

1What it really is

Moving the client out of analysis of what’s wrong and into a concrete, sensory picture of the wanted life — establishing the destination before generating options for how to get there.

Clients often arrive full of analysis about what’s wrong, and that analysis can continue for a long time without producing movement. This method switches direction: the coach invites the client to describe, in specific and sensory detail, what life looks like when things are as they want them to be. What do they see, hear and feel? Where are they, who is with them, and what are they doing on an ordinary day?

It sounds like: “Imagine it’s six months from now and this has gone well. Walk me through a typical morning,” or “What would you notice first?” It is not daydreaming or wishful thinking, and it doesn’t ignore real constraints. It gives the conversation a destination, so later choices can be checked against something concrete. It has worked when the client’s energy and language lift, when they describe the future as something present rather than something absent, and when they can name what matters most in the picture.

4How it works, deeply

The ordering matters enormously: destination before options. If a coach generates options before the client has a real, embodied picture of the destination, the options end up serving the problem’s logic (“how do I stop this from happening”) rather than the wanted life’s logic (“how do I build toward this”). Two problems generate very different option sets from “how do I win this political fight” versus a vivid Tuesday scene of presenting a one-page tradeoff and leaving on time.

A clear picture of the future works partly by changing what the client pays attention to. Once the brain has a concrete target, it starts noticing opportunities, resources and steps related to it, much like noticing a car model everywhere after deciding to buy one. A vivid, sensory picture also creates positive emotion, and research on positive emotions suggests they broaden thinking and make people more creative and open to options. Problem analysis tends to narrow attention, which is useful for diagnosis but not for designing something new.

The preferred future also becomes a measuring stick. Once it is described in detail, the client can judge options by whether they move toward it, which makes choices clearer and less agonising. It also helps distinguish what the client really wants from what they think they should want. Sometimes, describing a future in detail makes the client realise the original goal was someone else’s. Discovering that early saves a great deal of effort spent on the wrong destination.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Stuck in problem analysis; need destination before options
The move
Move from problem trance into a concrete wanted life
Watch
Stay sensory and behavioral. Avoid vague “happier / better.”
Four questions that often open it
  1. If this were resolved, what would be different in your day-to-day?
  2. What would you like that looks almost impossible now — and if achieved would change everything?
  3. What will you see, do, feel, say, and stop doing when this is handled?
  4. How will you know this coaching was useful, looking back?

2The client’s context

The client is stuck in problem-analysis and can describe the absence of the problem far more easily than the presence of what they actually want. “I don’t want to feel this way anymore” is common; “here’s what my Tuesday would look like instead” is rare and needs to be drawn out.

3The coach’s options

1Day-to-day future — an ordinary day made vivid.
2Almost-impossible future — something that seems out of reach but would change everything if achieved.
3Sensory/behavioral future — what they’ll see, do, feel, say, and stop doing.
4Looking-back criterion — “how will you know, in retrospect, that this coaching helped?”

5Where it gets stuck

The client stays at “happier” or “better” — too vague to be sensory. Or future questions are asked while the client is still flooded emotionally, which bounces off entirely. Or a vision emerges with no connection back to next Tuesday.

6How to move it forward

If the client is flooded, ground them first. Then stay strictly sensory (see, hear, feel, do). Reverse-engineer backward from the vision across seven days. Land one embodiment this week — not a twenty-step plan.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If this were resolved, what would be different in your day-to-day?
  • What would you like that looks almost impossible now — and if achieved would change everything?
  • What will you see, do, feel, say, and stop doing when this is handled?
  • How will you know this coaching was useful, looking back?
  • What would Tuesday morning look like if this were becoming true?
Going further
  • If a stranger watched your ideal week on video, what would tip them off that something had changed?
  • What’s the first sound, smell, or sight in the version of this you actually want?
  • If you woke up already living this, what would you notice missing from your current life?
  • What would you finally stop apologizing for?
  • If this future were already true, what would today’s conversation be about instead?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.2Stuck in the problem Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the prese…
What is happening Problem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted lifeCoach move Preferred future / miracle / visualization
In the room
Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the present-continuous of suffering. Options, if any, are all forms of “stop the pain,” not “live something.”
What’s underneath
Solution-focused and narrative work share a claim: options generated against a fog of not-wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. The nervous system orients toward what it can picture. No picture, no true choice.
Avoid here
Future questions while flooded (capacity is offline — regulate first). More analysis, clean language on problem-words only, or option-generation from inside the trance. Pre-mortem (adds more doom to a doom-only map).
Example
Product lead can describe six reasons a launch is doomed. Miracle first sign: they open Slack without a spike in the chest, and the stand-up starts with one risk, not twelve. Piece already slightly true on Thursdays after a run. Experiment: protect that Thursday condition twice this week, then look at the launch from there.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods45621222324
S1.8Story-looping / circling the same plot Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and…
What is happening Repeats events, more detail, no new insight, time passingCoach move Stop the plot. Move to meaning, pattern, or wanted future
In the room
Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and they would match.
What’s underneath
More plot rarely creates change. Repetition usually means the intervention is at the wrong level — or the loop is protecting them from an act, a feeling, or an ending.
Avoid here
Expand-for-more-detail. Clean language on plot nouns. Sympathy that invites another lap.
Example
Third retelling of a board ambush. Chapter title: “I keep going in without a sponsor.” Level change: one pre-wire this week, or park the topic.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14213539
S1.19Jumping straight to solutions Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What is happening Action list before the topic is understoodCoach move Pause action. Check if the problem is the real problem
In the room
Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What’s underneath
Premature plans recycle the old frame. Sometimes action-hunger is anxiety management. Distinguish a planning hour from an understanding hour — and let them choose if both are live.
Avoid here
Helping them polish the premature plan. More options on an unexamined problem.
Example
Client arrives with a 9-point script for a fight with their peer. “If it worked, what would it give you?” “I want to stop being erased.” Understanding hour: erasure pattern. Then a shorter request, not a 9-point prosecution.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17102126
S3.15Future-as-fantasy without steps Beautiful vision. No next Tuesday.
What is happening Beautiful vision, no next TuesdayCoach move Sensory future, then reverse-engineer 7 days
In the room
Beautiful vision. No next Tuesday.
What’s underneath
Do not kill the vision. Give it legs. Sensory future, then reverse-engineer 7 days.
Avoid here
More vision. Cynical “be realistic” that shames wanting.
Example
“A studio of my own.” Tuesday: 90 minutes of making before Slack. 7-day version exists inside the current job.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2123
S5.2Action without insight / busywork Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.
What is happening Lots of doing, no learning, hamster wheelCoach move Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs motion
In the room
Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.
What’s underneath
Do not applaud motion that is avoidance. Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs anxiety-motion.
Avoid here
More productivity systems.
Example
14 status meetings. 50% less might reveal no decision owner. Stillness would show the missing contract, not a need for a 15th meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods172140
S5.4No options they can see “There is no way.” Frozen imagination.
What is happening “There is no way”Coach move Invent 8 ideas including bad ones. Constraint-busting. Borrow others’ moves
In the room
“There is no way.” Frozen imagination.
What’s underneath
First “no options” is usually freeze, not physics. Invent eight including unwise. Constraint-busting.
Avoid here
Picking from their empty list. Premature experiment.
Example
“Cannot move the date.” Eight options include lying, cutting 40%, pairing, public tradeoff. Option 9: cut scope and say the tradeoff sentence. Imagination thaws.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods32122
S6.3High achiever crash / arrival fallacy “I got it and I feel nothing.”
What is happening “I got it and I feel nothing”Coach move Meaning, next chapter, human needs beyond achievement
In the room
“I got it and I feel nothing.”
What’s underneath
Do not immediately set a bigger mountain. Meaning, next chapter, human needs beyond achievement.
Avoid here
Next goal as antidepressant.
Example
Made partner. Felt nothing. Thought it would give belonging. Need now: unperformed friendship and a craft that is play. Not a bigger book of business this week.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2122
S6.16Purpose fog / “is this all?” Success without meaning.
What is happening Success without meaningCoach move Life chapters, contribution, aliveness clues
In the room
Success without meaning.
What’s underneath
Purpose is found in clues and experiments, not one slogan. Aliveness. What wants to end. What wants a bigger place.
Avoid here
Purpose statement workshop as the product.
Example
Last alive: teaching juniors on a whiteboard. Experiment: two hours of that protected. Slogan later, if ever.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2122
S6.23Spiritual / existential edge in a work topic Mortality, meaning, faith, emptiness arriving inside a work title.
What is happening Mortality, meaning, faith, emptinessCoach move Respect the depth. Don't reduce to a productivity plan
In the room
Mortality, meaning, faith, emptiness arriving inside a work title.
What’s underneath
Respect the depth. Don’t reduce to a productivity plan. Stay in coaching scope. Refer if clinical despair. Some of this wants reverence, not a framework.
Avoid here
OKRs for a soul. Amateur theology.
Example
After a parent’s illness, “is this all” arrives in a role conversation. Coaching holds: what a meaningful next year includes at work. Also names: this edge may want pastoral or clinical support they choose.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods21
S6.24Retirement or late-career transition Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What is happening End of career in sight; identity, structure and status about to changeCoach move Walk the timeline; find what carries forward; picture a wanted next chapter
In the room
Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What’s underneath
Retirement is an identity transition, not just a date. Work has provided structure, status and belonging. Without a picture of what replaces them, the end feels like a cliff. Grief and excitement can sit side by side.
Avoid here
Turning it into a hobby list. Assuming retirement means stopping all work. Rushing past the loss.
Example
A finance director with 30 years’ service plans to stop in six months. Timeline work shows the thread is developing people. The plan becomes two non-executive roles and a mentoring programme, not golf.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2123274143
S7.36Returning from parental leave Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What is happening Back from parental leave; new identity, new demands, out of the loopCoach move Map the polarity; set clear agreements at work and home
In the room
Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What’s underneath
The client is adjusting to a new identity and a new set of demands. Work may have moved on. The tension between career and family is ongoing, not a problem to solve once. Clear agreements at work and at home matter.
Avoid here
Assuming they want less, or more, ambition. Treating guilt as a problem to eliminate.
Example
A software lead returns after a year. Coach maps the Work and Family polarity, and helps plan conversations with her boss about the first three months.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1821244042
S9.1First session or chemistry meeting Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What is happening First meeting; deciding whether to work together and howCoach move Show how you work; clarify expectations, confidentiality and fit
In the room
Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.
What’s underneath
The chemistry session is about fit and expectations, not proving brilliance. The coach should show how they work, clarify what coaching is and isn’t, and help the client decide.
Avoid here
Over-selling. Starting deep work before the contract is agreed. Being vague about logistics and confidentiality.
Example
A client asks how coaching will help. The coach does a short taste of coaching on a real topic, then explains confidentiality, sponsor involvement and how they would work together.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods136821

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Skipping contracting and exploration and jumping straight to the future.
  • Either killing the vision with premature realism, or leaving it as ungrounded fantasy.
  • Asking future-oriented questions while the client is mid-flood emotionally.

10Client traps

  • Producing a cinematic future with no body or sensory detail in it.
  • Using the vision itself as a way to avoid today’s harder conversation.

Three worked problems

1

Stuck in a political fight. Preferred Tuesday: they present a one-page tradeoff instead of a 40-page defense, and leave the meeting at the scheduled time. Options generated from this picture look completely different from options generated from “how do I win.”

2

Purpose fog. Almost-impossible future: three afternoons a month making something no one asked for. First embodiment: one private, small, imperfect thing, this week.

3

Team distrust. Preferred future film: disagreement happens in the room, not in Slack afterward. Stop-doing: side conversations that re-litigate the meeting after it ends.

Where it comes from

The preferred-future question is central to solution-focused practice.

My notes

22
Move in Time family

Miracle Question

Core move: Overnight resolution; hunt for first signs
4 options9 questions6 situations

1What it really is

Asking the client to imagine an overnight resolution they didn’t witness happening, then hunting for the first signs that would tell them it occurred. Especially useful when the client can only describe the absence of the problem, not its resolution.

The miracle question comes from solution-focused brief therapy, developed by Steve de Shazer and Insoo Kim Berg. The coach asks the client to imagine that while they slept, the problem was solved, but because they were asleep they don’t know it happened. The rest of the conversation explores how they would gradually discover the change: what they would notice first, what they would do differently, and who else would notice.

It sounds like: “When you wake up tomorrow, what’s the first small thing that tells you something has changed?”, “What would your colleagues notice?”, and “Which of those things is already happening, even a little?” It is not magical thinking, and the coach never pretends the problem will disappear. The question is simply a way of making the desired outcome concrete and observable. It has worked when the client describes specific, positive signs rather than just the absence of the problem, and recognises that some of them are already within reach.

4How it works, deeply

The critical discipline is insisting on presence language, not absence. If a client answers “the problem would be gone,” that’s still absence-framing and needs a follow-up push toward specifics: what would actually be there instead? The other key move is de-escalating the fantastical framing if it doesn’t land — dropping the word “miracle” entirely and simply asking “suppose tomorrow the outcome you want is present” works just as well for a more literal-minded or skeptical client.

The miracle question works because it makes it safe to think beyond the current constraints. By placing the change in the realm of the unexplained, it suspends the usual “but how?” that stops people imagining a better future. Once the picture is clear, the coach asks about the very first signs, because small, specific signs are easier to recognise and recreate than a large transformation. The client often discovers that some of those signs are already happening.

The question also moves the client from problem talk into solution talk, a key idea in solution-focused practice. Problem talk tends to deepen understanding of why things are hard; solution talk builds understanding of how things could be better. Asking who else would notice the change brings in the social dimension, showing how relationships and roles would shift. Together, these details create a detailed, practical map of change, built entirely from the client’s own imagination and experience.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client can only describe the absence of the problem, not the presence of the wanted life
The move
Overnight resolution they did not see happen — first signs
Watch
If “miracle” lands as naive, drop the word: “Suppose tomorrow the outcome you want is present — first clue?”
Four questions that often open it
  1. Suppose tonight you sleep as usual. A miracle happens and this is resolved, but you do not know. When you wake, what is the first thing that tells you it happened?
  2. What else would you notice — in your body, inbox, first meeting, first conversation?
  3. Who else would notice, and how?
  4. What small piece of that miracle is already slightly true some days?

2The client’s context

The client speaks only in problem-language: “I just don’t want to feel like this.” They have no available picture of what presence — rather than absence — would actually look like.

3The coach’s options

1Classic overnight miracle — the traditional framing.
2Softened wording if “miracle” itself lands as naive or off-putting to this particular client.
3Who else would notice — bringing in an outside observer’s perspective.
4A piece of the miracle already slightly true — hunting for a fragment that already exists on some days.

5Where it gets stuck

The client scoffs at the premise itself, or the coach starts debating whether miracles are realistic. The miracle stays entirely magical, with no concrete first clue attached to it.

6How to move it forward

Drop the loaded word if it doesn’t land: “Suppose tomorrow the outcome you want is present — what’s the first clue?” Hunt specifically for a piece of that outcome that’s already slightly true on some days.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Suppose tonight you sleep as usual. A miracle happens and this is resolved, but you do not know. When you wake, what is the first thing that tells you it happened?
  • What else would you notice — in your body, inbox, first meeting, first conversation?
  • Who else would notice, and how?
  • What small piece of that miracle is already slightly true some days?
Going further
  • What would you do in the first hour of that day that you don’t do now?
  • If someone who loves you noticed the change before you said a word, what would they see?
  • What would be missing from your morning routine that’s usually there?
  • How would your voice sound different on the phone that day?
  • If this happened, what would you finally give yourself permission to stop worrying about?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.2Stuck in the problem Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the prese…
What is happening Problem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted lifeCoach move Preferred future / miracle / visualization
In the room
Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the present-continuous of suffering. Options, if any, are all forms of “stop the pain,” not “live something.”
What’s underneath
Solution-focused and narrative work share a claim: options generated against a fog of not-wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. The nervous system orients toward what it can picture. No picture, no true choice.
Avoid here
Future questions while flooded (capacity is offline — regulate first). More analysis, clean language on problem-words only, or option-generation from inside the trance. Pre-mortem (adds more doom to a doom-only map).
Example
Product lead can describe six reasons a launch is doomed. Miracle first sign: they open Slack without a spike in the chest, and the stand-up starts with one risk, not twelve. Piece already slightly true on Thursdays after a run. Experiment: protect that Thursday condition twice this week, then look at the launch from there.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods45621222324
S1.4Vague “Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.
What is happening “Things feel off”, “leadership”, “balance” with no pictureCoach move Scaling / “What would we see if we filmed it?”
In the room
“Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.
What’s underneath
Abstraction protects. As long as the topic stays a noun with no scene, no one can fail at it and no one can finish it. Advanced coaching operationalizes: values, identities, and moods become behavior in a room at a time of day.
Avoid here
Coaching the slogan. More values language. Big identity work with no scene. Generating a 10-step “confidence plan.”
Example
“I just need more balance.” Film: current Tuesday is Slack at 21:40. +1 is laptop closed at 19:00 two nights, calendar invite to themselves. Balance stops being a personality project.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6222835
S2.10Disappointed after a setback Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What is happening Deflation after effort, “why bother”Coach move Acknowledge the hit. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions
In the room
Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What’s underneath
The hit is real. Toxic positivity here breaks trust. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions. Smallest act of continuing.
Avoid here
Immediate next mountain. “Everything happens for…”
Example
Launch missed. Took: a quarter and a narrative. Did not take: their judgment with customers. Exception: 2019 dip → short learning review with one ally. Same move, sized small.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods59132241
S5.4No options they can see “There is no way.” Frozen imagination.
What is happening “There is no way”Coach move Invent 8 ideas including bad ones. Constraint-busting. Borrow others’ moves
In the room
“There is no way.” Frozen imagination.
What’s underneath
First “no options” is usually freeze, not physics. Invent eight including unwise. Constraint-busting.
Avoid here
Picking from their empty list. Premature experiment.
Example
“Cannot move the date.” Eight options include lying, cutting 40%, pairing, public tradeoff. Option 9: cut scope and say the tradeoff sentence. Imagination thaws.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods32122
S6.3High achiever crash / arrival fallacy “I got it and I feel nothing.”
What is happening “I got it and I feel nothing”Coach move Meaning, next chapter, human needs beyond achievement
In the room
“I got it and I feel nothing.”
What’s underneath
Do not immediately set a bigger mountain. Meaning, next chapter, human needs beyond achievement.
Avoid here
Next goal as antidepressant.
Example
Made partner. Felt nothing. Thought it would give belonging. Need now: unperformed friendship and a craft that is play. Not a bigger book of business this week.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2122
S6.16Purpose fog / “is this all?” Success without meaning.
What is happening Success without meaningCoach move Life chapters, contribution, aliveness clues
In the room
Success without meaning.
What’s underneath
Purpose is found in clues and experiments, not one slogan. Aliveness. What wants to end. What wants a bigger place.
Avoid here
Purpose statement workshop as the product.
Example
Last alive: teaching juniors on a whiteboard. Experiment: two hours of that protected. Slogan later, if ever.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2122

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Using it as a party trick rather than a genuine inquiry.
  • Stacking future-oriented questions onto an already-flooded nervous system.

10Client traps

  • Answering only with “the problem would be gone” — the coach needs to push past absence-language toward what’s actually present.

Three worked problems

1

Anxiety about a new role. First sign: making coffee without opening email first. Body is quieter. A piece already true: two mornings last month, after exercise. Experiment: protect that specific morning ritual during week one of the new role.

2

Conflict-avoidant leader. First sign: sending the two-line meeting request they’ve rewritten eight times. Who notices: their EA, because the calendar itself changes.

3

Grief mixed into a role change. The miracle isn’t “I don’t miss them” — the first sign is being able to say the person’s name in a meeting without leaving the room. Honor the loss first, then find one carrying-forward act.

Where it comes from

The miracle question was developed by Steve de Shazer and Insoo Kim Berg in solution-focused brief therapy.

My notes

23
Move in Time family

Future-Self / Identity in the Future

Core move: Visit who they’d be, having handled this well
5 options10 questions12 situations

1What it really is

Visiting the person the client would be after handling the current issue well — a shift from tactics into identity-in-action.

This method invites the client to imagine the version of themselves who has already handled the current challenge well. Instead of asking “what should I do?”, the question becomes “who would I be, and how would that person approach this?” Thinking from the future identity often reveals qualities, priorities and habits that the client can start to practise now, rather than waiting until they somehow become that person.

It sounds like: “Picture yourself a year from now, having handled this really well. What is that person like?”, “What would they tell you about this week?”, or “How would they walk into Monday’s meeting?” It is not a fantasy of a perfect self, and it doesn’t require the client to believe they are already there. It works because the future self is still the client, only further along. It has worked when the client can name one specific quality or action from that future self that they are willing to practise in the next few days.

4How it works, deeply

The trap this method must avoid is turning into a “career fantasy montage” — an inspiring but inert vision with no connection to this week’s actual behavior. The discipline is always the same: land exactly one embodied act this week that belongs to the future identity. “If you were already that person, how would you walk into the room?” bridges the gap between imagined identity and a testable behavior today.

Research on future self-continuity, notably by Hal Hershfield, suggests that people who feel more connected to their future selves tend to make better long-term choices. When the future self feels like a stranger, it is easy to put off the actions that would help them. Visiting the future self in detail strengthens that connection. The client starts to see current choices as investments in someone they care about, rather than sacrifices for an abstract person.

Identity also shapes behaviour more powerfully than goals alone. People tend to act in ways that are consistent with who they believe they are, so stepping into the future identity makes the related behaviours feel more natural. The method works best when the coach helps the client notice that the future self’s qualities already exist in them in seed form. Then the gap feels like growth rather than transformation, and the first act becomes an expression of who they already are, practised a little more boldly.

Quick card

Reach for it when
They want a result but have not stepped into the person who lives it
The move
Visit the person they would be after handling this well
Watch
Do not skip from vision to a 20-step plan. One embodiment this week.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Imagine you 12 months from now, having handled this well. What did you do?
  2. Who did you become?
  3. What would that future-you say to you tonight?
  4. If you wrote a letter from that future-you, what would it thank you for starting this week?

2The client’s context

The client wants a result but hasn’t yet stepped into the identity of the person who naturally produces that result. Common in visibility anxiety, new-role transitions, and situations where tactics alone haven’t moved anything because the underlying self-concept hasn’t shifted.

3The coach’s options

112-month future-you — a specific future check-in point.
2Letter from future-you — written, addressed to the present self.
3Walk-into-the-room as that person — an embodied rehearsal.
4One act this week that belongs specifically to that future identity.
5Wiser/older variant — see Method 25, Temporal Reframe, for a longer time horizon.

5Where it gets stuck

The vision balloons into a 20-step plan, or identity-talk stays purely theatrical with no Tuesday act attached to it.

6How to move it forward

Land one embodiment act this week. Ask directly: “If you were already that person, how would you walk into the room?”

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Imagine you 12 months from now, having handled this well. What did you do?
  • Who did you become?
  • What would that future-you say to you tonight?
  • If you wrote a letter from that future-you, what would it thank you for starting this week?
  • Who would you need to be to handle this?
Going further
  • What would future-you be relieved you finally stopped doing?
  • If future-you walked into today’s meeting instead of you, what would be different in the first two minutes?
  • What does future-you know about this situation that you don’t yet?
  • What’s one habit future-you has that you don’t currently have?
  • If you called future-you for advice right now, what’s the first thing they’d say?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.2Stuck in the problem Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the prese…
What is happening Problem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted lifeCoach move Preferred future / miracle / visualization
In the room
Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the present-continuous of suffering. Options, if any, are all forms of “stop the pain,” not “live something.”
What’s underneath
Solution-focused and narrative work share a claim: options generated against a fog of not-wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. The nervous system orients toward what it can picture. No picture, no true choice.
Avoid here
Future questions while flooded (capacity is offline — regulate first). More analysis, clean language on problem-words only, or option-generation from inside the trance. Pre-mortem (adds more doom to a doom-only map).
Example
Product lead can describe six reasons a launch is doomed. Miracle first sign: they open Slack without a spike in the chest, and the stand-up starts with one risk, not twelve. Piece already slightly true on Thursdays after a run. Experiment: protect that Thursday condition twice this week, then look at the launch from there.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods45621222324
S2.7Afraid of being seen / visibility anxiety Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speaking. Over-prepares then ducks.
What is happening Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speakingCoach move Future-self who can be seen. Tiny exposure. Identity vs skill
In the room
Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speaking. Over-prepares then ducks.
What’s underneath
Often a belonging story, not a skills gap. Identity vs skill. Tiny exposure beats a forced keynote. Hiding has a protective job and a cost.
Avoid here
“Just believe in yourself.” Giant first stage. Listing achievements only (imposter cousin).
Example
Avoids speaking in the ops forum. Risk: being found ordinary. Tiny exposure: 60 seconds on one metric, ally in the room. Not the offsite keynote.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods152335
S2.8Grief / loss mixed into a work topic Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”
What is happening Role loss, champion left, identity ending, eyes wet when “professional”Coach move Name the loss. Allow a beat. Then ask what wants to be carried forward
In the room
Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”
What’s underneath
Grief is not a lesson yet. Reframing it into growth too fast is a small desecration and breaks trust. Name what is ending and what is not. Then ask what wants to be carried forward.
Avoid here
Immediate silver lining. Options. “Who do you need to be now” in the first minute.
Example
Sponsor leaves. Client wants a “stakeholder map.” First: name the loss of being believed without a slide. Honor. Carry forward: the standard of clarity, not the dependency. Then the map.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7233043
S3.15Future-as-fantasy without steps Beautiful vision. No next Tuesday.
What is happening Beautiful vision, no next TuesdayCoach move Sensory future, then reverse-engineer 7 days
In the room
Beautiful vision. No next Tuesday.
What’s underneath
Do not kill the vision. Give it legs. Sensory future, then reverse-engineer 7 days.
Avoid here
More vision. Cynical “be realistic” that shames wanting.
Example
“A studio of my own.” Tuesday: 90 minutes of making before Slack. 7-day version exists inside the current job.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2123
S4.7Wanting permission Looks to coach, boss, spouse to bless the choice.
What is happening Looks to coach, boss, spouse to bless the choiceCoach move Return authority. Practice self-authorization
In the room
Looks to coach, boss, spouse to bless the choice.
What’s underneath
Do not become the new parent who says yes. Practice self-authorization.
Avoid here
Blessing the choice. Advice they will treat as permission.
Example
“Should I apply?” Coach will not vote. Already authorized act: write the three contributions, then decide.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods23
S5.9Wants a giant leap only Allergic to small steps. “That’s not enough.”
What is happening Allergic to small steps, “that’s not enough”Coach move Link small steps to identity and compounding. Define a bold small
In the room
Allergic to small steps. “That’s not enough.”
What’s underneath
Sometimes they need a meaningful experiment, not a trivial one. Sometimes the giant leap is a wish to skip becoming. Discern which.
Avoid here
Tiny trivial homework they will despise. Matching the leap with an unsized plan.
Example
Wants to “quit and start the firm.” Meaningful-small: one paid pilot with a real contract this month — scary, not trivial, not the whole leap.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2326
S5.15Stay-or-go decision Job, role, city, company. High identity load.
What is happening Job, role, city, companyCoach move Two-movie method. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible
In the room
Job, role, city, company. High identity load.
What’s underneath
Do not pick for them. Make both futures vivid, including costs. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible.
Avoid here
Pros/cons only. Coach’s career advice as the engine.
Example
Both films include costs. Stay-film costs self-respect; go-film costs money buffer. Non-negotiable: no more half-life. Experiment: 90-day full stay or a real search — pick one.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods82326
S6.2Imposter feelings Waiting to be found out. Over-prepares. Discounts praise.
What is happening Waiting to be found out, over-prepares, discounts praiseCoach move Evidence file. Belonging vs competence. Who they are becoming
In the room
Waiting to be found out. Over-prepares. Discounts praise.
What’s underneath
Not only a data problem. Belonging story. Do not just list achievements.
Avoid here
Trophy lists alone. “Fake it till you make it.”
Example
Fair jury: three years of delivery. Belonging story: first in family in rooms like this. Work both. Good-enough authority: speak without one more rehearsal.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods92338
S6.5Old identity dying (expert → leader, founder → CEO) Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What is happening Grief + incompetence of the new skinCoach move Name the identity funeral and the apprenticeship
In the room
Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What’s underneath
They need rites of passage, not only skills. Name the funeral and the apprenticeship. Newness is not incompetence.
Avoid here
Tool-only manager training.
Example
Founder still in every product thread. Funeral: “I am no longer the best doer in the room.” Apprenticeship: one thread they sponsor only. Old identity contributes taste, not keystrokes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods116233435
S6.24Retirement or late-career transition Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What is happening End of career in sight; identity, structure and status about to changeCoach move Walk the timeline; find what carries forward; picture a wanted next chapter
In the room
Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What’s underneath
Retirement is an identity transition, not just a date. Work has provided structure, status and belonging. Without a picture of what replaces them, the end feels like a cliff. Grief and excitement can sit side by side.
Avoid here
Turning it into a hobby list. Assuming retirement means stopping all work. Rushing past the loss.
Example
A finance director with 30 years’ service plans to stop in six months. Timeline work shows the thread is developing people. The plan becomes two non-executive roles and a mentoring programme, not golf.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2123274143
S7.18Expert becoming manager Still the smartest doer in the room.
What is happening Still the smartest doer in the roomCoach move From answers to questions. Develop others
In the room
Still the smartest doer in the room.
What’s underneath
Expertise is an asset that can become a trap. From answers to questions. Develop others.
Avoid here
“Stop being so smart.”
Example
They answer in 8 seconds. Replace with one question in the design review. Team starts thinking in the room.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2334
S7.27Ethics gray zone Not illegal, not clean.
What is happening Not illegal, not cleanCoach move Values, stakeholders, future-self, counsel
In the room
Not illegal, not clean.
What’s underneath
Stay in coaching. Flag when they need legal/HR, not a coach. Values, stakeholders, future-self, counsel.
Avoid here
Amateur legal opinions.
Example
Channel stuffing adjacent. Two-year self would not respect silence. Also: this needs counsel, not only a values chat. Both named.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods23

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Letting it become a “career fantasy montage” with no grounding.
  • Skipping the concrete act entirely.
  • Debating personality traits in the abstract rather than behavior.

10Client traps

  • Using an idealized future-self to attack the present self (“I should already be there”).

Three worked problems

1

Expert becoming a manager. Future-self 12 months on is someone who asks more than they answer. This week’s act: replace one answer with a question in the design review.

2

Afraid of being seen. Future-self can be in the room without disappearing. Tiny exposure step: speak for 60 seconds in a mid-stakes meeting, not a full keynote.

3

After a win they cannot own. Future-self has already integrated the identity. The letter thanks present-self for writing down three specific contributions before deflecting credit.

Where it comes from

Draws on future-self visualisation and on research into how people relate to their future selves (for example Hal Hershfield).

My notes

24
Move in Time family

Two Futures / Two Videos

Core move: Make both futures vivid; choose from experience
5 options10 questions10 situations

1What it really is

Making both possible futures vivid and specific, then letting the client choose from lived experience rather than a pros-and-cons list alone. The coach never picks for the client, even implicitly.

When a client is stuck between two options, lists of pros and cons often go round in circles. This method asks the client to play two short “videos” in detail: one for each choice, a year or more into the future. What does a normal day look like in each? Who is around? How do they feel at the end of the day? The aim is to let the client sense the two futures rather than only reason about them.

It sounds like: “Let’s run the video where you take the job. It’s a Wednesday next spring. What are you doing?”, followed by the same for the other option, and then “Which one did your body lean toward?” It is not a way for the coach to steer the decision, and neither future should be described more attractively than the other. It doesn’t replace analysis; it adds the information the analysis was missing. It has worked when the client feels a clearer preference, or discovers that something both futures lack is the real issue.

4How it works, deeply

Often the real problem is not A versus B — it’s the oscillation itself, which can feel like its own kind of torture. Naming that directly (“the torture may be the swinging, not A or B”) can be more useful than another round of comparison. The body-lean test bypasses the analytical mind’s endless list-making by asking what physically happens when each future is described in vivid, sensory detail.

Decisions involve both analytical thinking and emotional signals. Antonio Damasio’s work on somatic markers suggests that feelings in the body carry information from past experience, and that people with damage to those signals struggle to make good choices even when their reasoning is intact. Lists of pros and cons engage only the analytical side. Imagining two vivid futures lets the client’s body respond to each one, adding information that analysis alone misses.

Making both futures equally vivid is essential to fairness. If one option is imagined in detail and the other remains vague, the detailed one will usually feel more real and therefore more attractive, regardless of its actual merits. Running both videos with equal care, and noticing the body’s responses, gives a more balanced signal. Sometimes neither future feels right, which is also valuable: it suggests the real decision lies elsewhere, perhaps in a third option, or in a need that neither choice meets.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Stay-or-go, A vs B, or problem-life vs wanted-life
The move
Make both futures vivid, then choose from experience not pros/cons only
Watch
Do not pick for them. Make both futures honest, including costs.
Four questions that often open it
  1. If both lives were films, which one do you want to star in?
  2. Video 1 is this continuing. Video 2 is the preferred outcome. What do you see in each?
  3. Which future does your body lean toward when you describe it?
  4. What do you lose by not choosing?

2The client’s context

Classic shapes: stay-or-go, A vs. B, problem-life vs. wanted-life, oscillation between two options, title-hunger pulling against lifestyle preference. The client is often stuck in an endless comparison loop that never resolves.

3The coach’s options

1Two films/two videos — vivid, parallel scenes of each future.
2Body-lean test — which future does the body physically lean toward while describing it?
3Cost of not choosing — what is lost by staying in oscillation?
430-day trial in one future — a low-stakes experiment before full commitment.
5Non-negotiables in either life — identifying constants that must hold regardless of which path is chosen.

5Where it gets stuck

More comparison spreadsheets get built. The coach develops a visible favorite. Oscillation continues indefinitely because the swinging itself has become the pattern, not a genuine indecision about the two options.

6How to move it forward

Name that the torture may be the oscillation itself, not either option. Ask which future the body leans toward when described vividly. Ask what’s lost specifically by continuing not to choose.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If both lives were films, which one do you want to star in?
  • Video 1 is this continuing. Video 2 is the preferred outcome. What do you see in each?
  • Which future does your body lean toward when you describe it?
  • What do you lose by not choosing?
  • If the title were stripped away, would you still want the days?
Going further
  • If you had to live inside video 1 for one more year with no changes, what would that actually feel like?
  • What would each future cost you that the other wouldn’t?
  • If a friend was choosing between these two exact futures, what would you tell them?
  • What non-negotiable would you keep no matter which future you chose?
  • If you flipped a coin right now, which result would disappoint you — and what does that tell you?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.2Stuck in the problem Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the prese…
What is happening Problem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted lifeCoach move Preferred future / miracle / visualization
In the room
Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the present-continuous of suffering. Options, if any, are all forms of “stop the pain,” not “live something.”
What’s underneath
Solution-focused and narrative work share a claim: options generated against a fog of not-wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. The nervous system orients toward what it can picture. No picture, no true choice.
Avoid here
Future questions while flooded (capacity is offline — regulate first). More analysis, clean language on problem-words only, or option-generation from inside the trance. Pre-mortem (adds more doom to a doom-only map).
Example
Product lead can describe six reasons a launch is doomed. Miracle first sign: they open Slack without a spike in the chest, and the stand-up starts with one risk, not twelve. Piece already slightly true on Thursdays after a run. Experiment: protect that Thursday condition twice this week, then look at the launch from there.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods45621222324
S2.13Resentful / bitter Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.
What is happening Kept score, “after all I did”, tightnessCoach move Find the unmet contract. Turn resentment into a request or a boundary
In the room
Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.
What’s underneath
Resentment is often an unmet contract that was never spoken. Venting without a request keeps them stuck. Turn into a request or a boundary — or a clean decision to stop waiting.
Avoid here
More venting as the whole method. Moral lecture about gratitude.
Example
Covered a peer’s region for a year. Never agreed; never asked. Clean ask or stop covering. Bitterness was unpaid invoice plus silence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1243740
S3.1All-or-nothing / binary thinking Success or failure. Stay or explode. Good or weak. No middle.
What is happening Success or failure, stay or explode, good or weakCoach move Insert the middle. Scale. Third options
In the room
Success or failure. Stay or explode. Good or weak. No middle.
What’s underneath
Binaries feel like clarity. They are usually fear. The middle is where most adult work lives.
Avoid here
Picking a pole with them. Moralizing the “extreme.”
Example
“Either I nail the offsite or I’m finished.” Middle: good-enough structure, one hostile question rehearsed, sleep. Alive and imperfect.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141824
S5.3Analysis paralysis / too many options Pros/cons forever. More research.
What is happening Pros/cons forever, more researchCoach move Limit options to 2–3. Decide by value + reversible test
In the room
Pros/cons forever. More research.
What’s underneath
More options after a point reduce action. Decide by value + reversible test. What is research hoping to spare them from feeling.
Avoid here
Invent-eight here (wrong situation — that is for no options). Question cube as more dimensions.
Example
Four vendors, sixth comparison sheet. Research spares them from disappointing a friend-vendor. Named; pick with a 30-day out.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2429
S5.14Stuck between option A and B Oscillates daily. Seeks a sign.
What is happening Oscillates daily, seeks a signCoach move Values, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period
In the room
Oscillates daily. Seeks a sign.
What’s underneath
The torture is often the oscillation, not either option. Values, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period.
Avoid here
More comparison matrices.
Example
Two job offers. Oscillation is the torture. Future-you already lives in B when they describe Friday evening. 30-day trial not possible; announcement date is.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods82431
S6.19Money vs meaning tension Golden handcuffs. Lifestyle lock.
What is happening Golden handcuffs, lifestyle lockCoach move Numbers + values. Runway. Enough definition
In the room
Golden handcuffs. Lifestyle lock.
What’s underneath
Fantasy exits without numbers stay fantasy. Enough definition. Runway. Numbers + values.
Avoid here
“Follow the bliss” with no math.
Example
Enough is named as a number for the first time. Bridge: two years, one consulting retainer. Fantasy becomes a plan or an honest stay.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1824
S7.24Promotion ambivalence Want the level, not the life.
What is happening Want the level, not the lifeCoach move Two futures. Role reality, not the title shine
In the room
Want the level, not the life.
What’s underneath
Title hunger can hide a lifestyle no. Two futures. Role reality, not title shine.
Avoid here
Ambition pep.
Example
Want the strategy work, not the political evenings. Title stripped: mixed. Negotiation for a scoped role becomes possible.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods24
S7.25Exit energy / quiet quitting in themselves Doing the minimum. Checked out. Still there.
What is happening Doing the minimum, checked out, still thereCoach move Tell the truth. Stay fully or leave cleanly. No half-life
In the room
Doing the minimum. Checked out. Still there.
What’s underneath
A long maybe hurts them and the team. Stay fully or leave cleanly. No half-life.
Avoid here
Engagement hacks.
Example
Body has left. Clean stay: 90 days of real contribution while they search. Or clean leave conversation. Half-life named as the costliest option.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods24
S7.36Returning from parental leave Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What is happening Back from parental leave; new identity, new demands, out of the loopCoach move Map the polarity; set clear agreements at work and home
In the room
Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What’s underneath
The client is adjusting to a new identity and a new set of demands. Work may have moved on. The tension between career and family is ongoing, not a problem to solve once. Clear agreements at work and at home matter.
Avoid here
Assuming they want less, or more, ambition. Treating guilt as a problem to eliminate.
Example
A software lead returns after a year. Coach maps the Work and Family polarity, and helps plan conversations with her boss about the first three months.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1821244042
S7.37Role reshaped or threatened by AI and automation Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What is happening Work changing because of AI or automation; uncertainty about the futureCoach move Separate tasks from value; picture two futures; run small experiments
In the room
Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What’s underneath
Some tasks will change; the client’s value is rarely only the tasks. Coaching helps separate fact from fear, find which strengths become more valuable, and run experiments with the new tools rather than waiting.
Avoid here
Reassuring that nothing will change. Predicting the future. Pure technical advice.
Example
A copywriter fears AI will replace her. Coach separates tasks from value. She experiments with AI tools for drafts and repositions as a brand strategist.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods29242636

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Picking a favorite future, even implicitly.
  • Softening the real costs of the preferred film to make the choice easier.
  • Rushing the client toward an announcement before they’re ready.

10Client traps

  • Waiting for an external “sign” to decide instead of choosing.
  • Keeping both doors open as a form of identity insurance.

Three worked problems

1

Leave the company or stay for the grant. Film 1: another year of half-life. Film 2: a search conducted with dignity and a real, well-finished last quarter. The body leans toward film 2 when describing Friday evenings specifically. Experiment: one external conversation this month, plus a clean 90-day contribution plan — no quiet quitting in the meantime.

2

City A vs. city B for a dual-career household. Non-negotiables only surface once both films include school pickup, parents’ health, and the actual texture of job days — not just salary numbers. The decision becomes about values plus a 24-month review point, not a gut feeling.

3

Promotion ambivalence. Title shine appears in film 2, but so does Sunday dread. The client realizes they want the work of the job, not its political load. This opens the door to negotiating a scoped version of the role.

Where it comes from

Related to scenario thinking and to decision approaches that make each option vivid before choosing.

My notes

25
Move in Time family

Temporal Reframe (Wiser Future Self)

Core move: Borrow distance from an older self
5 options9 questions9 situations

1What it really is

Borrowing the perspective of a much older, wiser version of the client. Psychological distance matters more than the specific number of years — if “eighty years old” feels gimmicky to a particular client, “five years from now” works just as well.

When a client is caught up in the pressure of right now, they often lose perspective. This method invites them to imagine a wiser, older version of themselves looking back at the current situation. That older self has the benefit of hindsight and knows how much this moment really mattered. What would they say? What would they want the client to pay attention to, and what would they want them to let go of?

It sounds like: “Imagine you at eighty, looking back on this year. What would they want you to know?”, or simply “Five years from now, what will you be glad you did here?” It is not a way of dismissing the current problem as trivial, and the older self should be kind, not dismissive. The aim is to change the client’s relationship to the problem, not to minimise it. It has worked when the client finds a calmer, clearer view and turns it into one word or one action for this week.

4How it works, deeply

Time-distance works because it interrupts the urgency that’s driving reactive decisions. But the method fails if it stays abstract — the coach must always shorten the distance back down to this week: one word, one act. Without that closing loop, the exercise becomes pleasant but inert, a “fortune cookie” moment rather than a genuine shift in decision-making.

Psychologists call this kind of perspective shift “self-distancing.” Research by Ethan Kross and others suggests that viewing one’s situation from a distance, whether in time, space, or by using one’s own name, reduces emotional reactivity and supports wiser reasoning. In the moment, a problem can feel all-consuming. Seen from years ahead, it takes its proper place in a longer life, and the client can see more clearly what really matters.

The older self also brings qualities that are hard to reach under pressure: patience, perspective, compassion and a sense of what lasts. By imagining themselves as that person, the client gets temporary access to those qualities without having to wait years to develop them. The return journey to the present is essential. The insight from the future must be translated into a concrete choice now, or the exercise remains a pleasant reflection rather than a change in direction.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client is deciding from inside today's fear or urgency, without any distance on it
The move
Borrow the perspective of a much older, wiser version of themselves
Watch
If "eighty years old" feels like a gimmick to this client, use "five years from now" instead. The distance matters more than the number.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Imagine yourself at eighty, looking back on this exact moment — what do they say?
  2. What would that version of you tell you not to waste energy on?
  3. What would they be proud you did anyway?
  4. What is one word they would want you to remember this week?

2The client’s context

The client is deciding entirely from inside today’s fear or urgency, with no distance from the immediate moment. Often accompanied by a catastrophic, present-tense forecast about what will happen.

3The coach’s options

1Eighty-year-old looking back — maximum distance.
2Five-year self — a shorter, sometimes more credible horizon.
3What not to waste energy on — asking the elder what’s not worth the current fight.
4What they’d be proud you did anyway — surfacing courage rather than caution.
5One word to remember this week — condensing the wisdom into something portable.

5Where it gets stuck

Gimmick energy takes over — the client intellectualizes the elder perspective rather than actually inhabiting it. No word or act comes back down to this week.

6How to move it forward

Shorten the distance if it’s not landing (eighty to five years, for example). Ask for exactly one word and one act. Pair it with a small, concrete experiment.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Imagine yourself at eighty, looking back on this exact moment — what do they say?
  • What would that version of you tell you not to waste energy on?
  • What would they be proud you did anyway?
  • What is one word they would want you to remember this week?
Going further
  • What would your older self laugh about, that feels deadly serious to you right now?
  • If your older self could give you one sentence of permission, what would it be?
  • What would they tell you that you already know but are avoiding?
  • What’s a decision your older self has already made peace with, that you’re still fighting?
  • If this moment became a story you told your older self’s grandchildren, how would you want it to end?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S2.15Over-excited / manic planning Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.
What is happening Huge vision, no sleep, ten projectsCoach move Channel the energy. Sequence. Risk-check without killing it
In the room
Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.
What’s underneath
Do not match the high. Be the ballast. Channel, sequence, risk-check without killing life.
Avoid here
Matching with more vision. Shame about the high.
Example
Ten-project founder week. Keep the customer-evidence project 30 days. Pre-mortem on scope only. Energy stays; pile shrinks.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1122526
S2.17Afraid of hope / waiting for the other shoe Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.
What is happening Won’t celebrate, discounts winsCoach move Explore the protective logic of not hoping. Tiny allowed hope
In the room
Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.
What’s underneath
Not-hoping is a protective logic after previous crashes. Forcing celebration feels naive. Tiny allowed hope. Evidence they would need.
Avoid here
Party hats. Immediate stretch goals.
Example
After a previous failed promotion cycle. Not-hoping protects against public hope-then-humiliation. 5% safer: write the contribution list privately. Not a LinkedIn announcement.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12152538
S3.14Past-as-prison Origin story explains and excuses everything now.
What is happening Origin story explains and excuses everything nowCoach move Honor origin. Ask what the adult can choose now
In the room
Origin story explains and excuses everything now.
What’s underneath
Honor origin. Do not do archaeology for its own sake in performance coaching. Ask what the adult can choose now.
Avoid here
Deep childhood excavation beyond scope and contract.
Example
Humiliation at 24 explains freeze. Also true today: they run a 40-person org. Adult choice: ally in the room. History honored, not in the driver’s seat.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12252735
S6.6Worth = productivity Rest guilt. Weekend collapse. Metrics as self.
What is happening Rest guilt, weekend collapse, metrics as selfCoach move Decouple worth and output. Rest as strategy
In the room
Rest guilt. Weekend collapse. Metrics as self.
What’s underneath
Often cultural and familial, not only personal. Decouple worth and output. Rest as strategy.
Avoid here
Productivity hacks that keep the equation.
Example
24-hour off. Afraid rest reveals they are ordinary. Worth work is the topic; a sleep app is not.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1225
S6.9Comparing to a past self “I used to be sharper / braver.”
What is happening “I used to be sharper / braver”Coach move Honor then. Meet now. Different season, different strengths
In the room
“I used to be sharper / braver.”
What’s underneath
Nostalgia for a past self can insult the present one. Different season, different strengths.
Avoid here
Trying to resurrect 32-year-old them.
Example
Past self had speed. This season requires political patience they did not have. Insult hidden: “you got soft.” Also true now: they can keep a team.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods25
S6.10Legacy / last-chapter questions What will I leave. Who will I have been.
What is happening What will I leave, who will I have beenCoach move Contribution, people, body of work, unfinished conversations
In the room
What will I leave. Who will I have been.
What’s underneath
Legacy talk can avoid today’s messy conversation. Keep both. Today’s version of legacy, not only the eulogy.
Avoid here
Vision board only. Reducing it to KPIs.
Example
Talks legacy; unsent conversation with a brother. Today’s version: that call. Eulogy can wait.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122527
S6.11Inner critic running the meeting Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What is happening Harsh voice, pre-emptive attackCoach move Personify the critic. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime
In the room
Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What’s underneath
Don’t exile the critic. Give it a smaller seat. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime.
Avoid here
“Silence your inner critic” posters.
Example
Critic protects from a parent’s public shaming. Needs five minutes of risk-check, not the whole prep. Chairperson runs the rest.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1415202530
S6.22Midlife / quarter-life / chapter change Time awareness. Identity inventory.
What is happening Time awareness, identity inventoryCoach move Past-future-present deep dive. What to keep / drop / begin
In the room
Time awareness. Identity inventory.
What’s underneath
Do not pathologize a chapter change. Keep / drop / begin. What the last chapter cannot hold.
Avoid here
Crisis diagnosis. Instant reinvention plan.
Example
Expert chapter complete. Unfinished: a conversation with a co-founder. Calling with no name: making things with their hands. Next chapter must hold that; last one cannot.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122527
S7.5Conflict-seeking / always the fight Identity as the one who says it.
What is happening Identity as the one who says itCoach move Discern which fights matter. Tone vs content
In the room
Identity as the one who says it.
What’s underneath
Do not shame their courage. Aim it. Which fights matter. Tone vs content. Winning with the relationship intact.
Avoid here
Making them “nice.”
Example
Fights every process. Two that matter: safety and a false date. Retire the rest. Courage aimed.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122535

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Fortune-cookie tone that stays surface-level.
  • Using the elder’s “wisdom” to smuggle in the coach’s own advice.

10Client traps

  • Using elder-wisdom to wave away genuinely real present-day constraints (money, visa status, caregiving obligations).

Three worked problems

1

Urgency to send a rage email. The eighty-year-old says: “Do not spend a chapter on this person.” Proud-anyway: a clean boundary sentence, not a prosecution. Act: write the angry email, sleep on it, then send a four-line version instead.

2

Career panic at 42. The five-year self cares less about the missed title and more about an unfinished conversation with a sibling and work that feels alive. This week’s word: alive. A calendar audit follows.

3

Afraid of hope after a previous crash. The elder’s message: hoping 10% is not naivete; refusing all hope cost a whole decade. A safer 5% version of hope: celebrate the win privately, with one witness.

Where it comes from

Related to research on self-distancing and temporal distancing (for example Ethan Kross, Chatter).

My notes

26
Move in Time family

Pre-Mortem

Core move: Imagine failure; work backward to causes
5 options10 questions7 situations

1What it really is

Moving forward to an imagined future failure, then working backward to identify causes. Used specifically for blind certainty in an already-chosen plan. This is not pessimism, and the method explicitly stops once the risks are named — it does not become a rehearsal for failure.

A pre-mortem asks the client to imagine that their plan has already been carried out and has failed, then to explain why. It was popularised by the psychologist Gary Klein for project teams, and it works just as well for individual decisions. Because the failure is imagined as having already happened, people find it easier to name risks they had been quietly avoiding, without seeming negative or disloyal to their own plan.

It sounds like: “It’s six months from now and this didn’t work. What are the three most likely reasons?” followed by “Which of those can you protect against now?” It is not a way of talking the client out of their plan, and it is not a worst-case brainstorm. The plan usually survives; it just gets stronger. It is also time-limited, so the conversation doesn’t slide into worry. It has worked when the client leaves with one early warning sign to watch for and one safeguard built into the plan.

4How it works, deeply

This method is deliberately time-boxed — three reasons only, not an open-ended catastrophizing session. It must never be used on a client who is already catastrophizing (wrong tool entirely; ground them first with a different method). Used correctly, it converts vague overconfidence into two concrete outputs: one early warning sign to watch for, and one protective structure to build in now, before it’s needed.

Klein’s research drew on the idea of prospective hindsight. Studies have suggested that imagining an event has already happened increases people’s ability to identify reasons for an outcome, compared with asking what might go wrong. Asking “why did this fail?” as if it were a fact unlocks more specific and creative answers. It also works around the social and personal pressure to stay positive about a plan you’re committed to.

The method is designed to counter overconfidence and planning fallacy, the well-documented tendency to underestimate time, cost and risk. In a coaching context, it is quick and focused: three causes, one warning sign, one safeguard. This structure keeps the process practical and prevents it becoming general worry. Clients often report feeling more confident after a pre-mortem, not less, because they have looked squarely at the risks and know what they will do if those risks appear.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client is deep in planning or has already decided, and confidence has crossed over into blind certainty
The move
Move forward in time to an imagined failure, then work backward to the causes
Watch
This is not pessimism. Stop as soon as the risks are named — do not let it turn into rehearsal for failure.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Imagine it's a year from now and this has failed. What are the top three reasons?
  2. Which of those is most likely to actually happen?
  3. What would you need to see early to catch it in time?
  4. What would you build in now, knowing what future-you just told you?

2The client’s context

The client is deep in planning, and confidence has crossed the line into certainty. Sometimes accompanied by a huge vision spread across ten simultaneous projects with no ballast or risk-checking anywhere in sight.

3The coach’s options

1Year-from-now failure — the classic framing.
2Most likely cause vs. colorful cause — sorting probable risks from dramatic but unlikely ones.
3Early warning signals — what would show up first if things start going wrong?
4Build-in-now protections — concrete safeguards designed before the risk materializes.
5Ballast for manic planning — specifically useful when a client has taken on far too much at once.

5Where it gets stuck

It turns into rehearsal for failure — either the coach uses it to deliberately deflate the client’s energy, or the client spirals into open-ended anxiety about everything that could go wrong.

6How to move it forward

Time-box it strictly: three reasons only. Then extract exactly one early warning signal and one thing to build in now.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Imagine it is a year from now and this has failed. What are the top three reasons?
  • Which of those is most likely to actually happen?
  • What would you need to see early to catch it in time?
  • What would you build in now, knowing what future-you just told you?
  • What would future-you thank you for not starting?
Going further
  • If this fails, what would the postmortem report say was the root cause, not the surface cause?
  • What are you most tempted to skip right now that you’d regret skipping later?
  • Who would have seen this risk coming, and have you asked them?
  • What’s the boring, unglamorous risk you’re least excited to think about?
  • If you only had time to build in one safeguard, which one would matter most?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.19Jumping straight to solutions Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What is happening Action list before the topic is understoodCoach move Pause action. Check if the problem is the real problem
In the room
Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.
What’s underneath
Premature plans recycle the old frame. Sometimes action-hunger is anxiety management. Distinguish a planning hour from an understanding hour — and let them choose if both are live.
Avoid here
Helping them polish the premature plan. More options on an unexamined problem.
Example
Client arrives with a 9-point script for a fight with their peer. “If it worked, what would it give you?” “I want to stop being erased.” Understanding hour: erasure pattern. Then a shorter request, not a 9-point prosecution.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17102126
S2.15Over-excited / manic planning Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.
What is happening Huge vision, no sleep, ten projectsCoach move Channel the energy. Sequence. Risk-check without killing it
In the room
Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.
What’s underneath
Do not match the high. Be the ballast. Channel, sequence, risk-check without killing life.
Avoid here
Matching with more vision. Shame about the high.
Example
Ten-project founder week. Keep the customer-evidence project 30 days. Pre-mortem on scope only. Energy stays; pile shrinks.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1122526
S5.9Wants a giant leap only Allergic to small steps. “That’s not enough.”
What is happening Allergic to small steps, “that’s not enough”Coach move Link small steps to identity and compounding. Define a bold small
In the room
Allergic to small steps. “That’s not enough.”
What’s underneath
Sometimes they need a meaningful experiment, not a trivial one. Sometimes the giant leap is a wish to skip becoming. Discern which.
Avoid here
Tiny trivial homework they will despise. Matching the leap with an unsized plan.
Example
Wants to “quit and start the firm.” Meaningful-small: one paid pilot with a real contract this month — scary, not trivial, not the whole leap.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2326
S5.15Stay-or-go decision Job, role, city, company. High identity load.
What is happening Job, role, city, companyCoach move Two-movie method. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible
In the room
Job, role, city, company. High identity load.
What’s underneath
Do not pick for them. Make both futures vivid, including costs. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible.
Avoid here
Pros/cons only. Coach’s career advice as the engine.
Example
Both films include costs. Stay-film costs self-respect; go-film costs money buffer. Non-negotiable: no more half-life. Experiment: 90-day full stay or a real search — pick one.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods82326
S7.29High-stakes event coming (board, keynote, review) Performance anxiety + preparation swirl.
What is happening Performance anxiety + preparation swirlCoach move Purpose, audience, state regulation, rehearsal, good-enough structure
In the room
Performance anxiety + preparation swirl.
What’s underneath
More content is rarely the missing piece. Purpose for the audience. State regulation. Rehearsal. Good-enough structure.
Avoid here
More slides.
Example
60 extra slides are anxiety. Audience success: three decisions. Hour before: walk, not tinkering. Structure good enough.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods263237
S7.37Role reshaped or threatened by AI and automation Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What is happening Work changing because of AI or automation; uncertainty about the futureCoach move Separate tasks from value; picture two futures; run small experiments
In the room
Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What’s underneath
Some tasks will change; the client’s value is rarely only the tasks. Coaching helps separate fact from fear, find which strengths become more valuable, and run experiments with the new tools rather than waiting.
Avoid here
Reassuring that nothing will change. Predicting the future. Pure technical advice.
Example
A copywriter fears AI will replace her. Coach separates tasks from value. She experiments with AI tools for drafts and repositions as a brand strategist.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods29242636
S9.3Three-way meeting with client and sponsor Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What is happening Formal alignment or review meeting with sponsor presentCoach move Prepare the client to lead; facilitate goals and observable signs of change
In the room
Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What’s underneath
Three-way meetings align goals and show progress. The client should lead, the coach facilitates, and the sponsor gives perspective. Preparation matters.
Avoid here
Coach speaking for the client. Revealing session content. Letting the sponsor dominate.
Example
Before the meeting, the coach helps the client rehearse what to share. In the meeting, the client presents goals, and the boss shares what they would notice changing.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16263742

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Turning it into anxiety theatre.
  • Using it on a client who is already catastrophizing — the wrong tool for that state; ground them first instead.

10Client traps

  • Collecting risks as a reason never to start at all.
  • Ignoring the most boring, most likely risk in favor of dramatic but improbable ones.

Three worked problems

1

Transformation program already “decided.” Pre-mortem reveals it failed because middle managers were informed rather than involved, the sponsor changed mid-stream, and scope doubled. Most likely cause: scope creep. Build-in: a written stop-list and a monthly scope review board.

2

Manic ten-project season. Future-you thanks the client for not starting seven of the ten. One project is kept alive for the next 30 days; the rest are shelved.

3

Public launch. Failure reasons include sleep debt and no rehearsal against a hostile questioner. Early signal: irritability showing up at home. Build-in: a rehearsal on Friday, a hard stop on Sunday.

Where it comes from

The pre-mortem was developed by psychologist Gary Klein (see “Performing a Project Premortem”, Harvard Business Review, 2007).

My notes

27
Move in Time family

Walk the Timeline

Core move: Lay the story out in time to see the turning points and what carries forward
5 options10 questions6 situations

1What it really is

The coach invites the client to lay their story out along a line of time, on paper, on the floor, or simply in conversation, from past through present to a possible future. Physically or visually moving along it helps the client see turning points, recurring patterns, what they have already survived, and what they want to carry into the next chapter. The method draws on narrative and timeline approaches used in coaching and career work.

Walking the timeline invites the client to lay out their story along a line from the past, through the present, to a possible future. They might draw it, place cards on a table, or physically walk along a line on the floor, stopping at key moments. The coach asks what happened at each turning point, what the client learned or decided there, and what they want to carry forward into the next part of the line.

It sounds like: “Where would you put the start of this story?”, “What was going on here, at this turning point?”, or “Standing here in the present, looking forward, what do you want to take with you?” It is not a therapy exercise for processing trauma, and the coach keeps the focus on patterns, resources and choices, not on reliving painful events. It works particularly well during transitions. It has worked when the client sees a pattern or strength across their history and can link it to a choice they are facing now.

4How it works, deeply

Time gives perspective. Seeing the whole arc reminds the client that the present is one chapter, not the whole story, and that they have already moved through difficult transitions. Turning points reveal patterns and values that a single conversation about now can miss. Physically walking a line on the floor adds a felt sense of distance between past, present and future, which can loosen a stuck present.

Narrative psychology suggests that people make sense of their lives by organising experiences into stories, and that the shape of those stories influences how they feel about the future. When the client lays out their timeline, they can look at the story as a whole and notice which chapters they emphasise, which they skip, and what themes recur. Turning points often reveal values, because they are moments when the client chose one direction over another.

Physically walking the timeline uses space as a thinking tool. Standing in the past, the client can recall what they felt and knew then; standing in the present, they can see how far they’ve come; looking toward the future, they can imagine the next chapter with a sense of continuity. NLP timeline approaches use similar movement to help clients connect resources from the past with challenges in the present. The result is often a stronger sense of agency and coherence.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client is at a transition, stuck in the past, or can’t see the thread of their story
The move
Lay the story out in time, find turning points and the thread, then step forward
Watch
Keep a focusing question so it doesn’t become a biography.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Where are the highs and lows?
  2. What were the turning points?
  3. What has stayed constant?
  4. From the future, what do you see?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • At a crossroads — Career change, retirement, redundancy or a life stage shift.
  • Past as a prison — Explains everything now through one old event.
  • Lost the thread — Can’t see how their working life fits together.
  • Nostalgia — Believes the best is behind them.
  • Big future, no bridge — Can describe a wanted future but not how they’d get there.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses how to use the timeline:

1Draw the line — Ask the client to sketch the last 10–20 years with high and low points.
2Mark the turning points — Pick three moments that changed direction and ask what each taught them.
3Find the thread — “What has stayed constant through all of these chapters?”
4Walk forward — Step to a point one, three or ten years ahead and describe it from there.
5Look back from the future — From the future point, ask what the client did now that made the difference.

5Where it gets stuck

The timeline turns into a long biography with no question driving it, or it lands on a painful past that needs more care than a coaching session should give.

6How to move it forward

Keep a focusing question in view: “We’re looking for what carries forward into this decision.” Limit the past to three turning points. If something painful opens, slow down, acknowledge it, and check whether it belongs in coaching or would be better supported elsewhere.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If you drew the last fifteen years as a line, where are the highs and lows?
  • What were the three biggest turning points?
  • What did each of them teach you?
  • What has stayed constant through every chapter?
  • Standing five years from now, what do you see?
Going further
  • What did you survive that you had forgotten you survived?
  • Which chapter do you most want to carry forward?
  • What is ending now, and what is beginning?
  • From the future, what do you thank your present self for?
  • What would the title of this next chapter be?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S3.14Past-as-prison Origin story explains and excuses everything now.
What is happening Origin story explains and excuses everything nowCoach move Honor origin. Ask what the adult can choose now
In the room
Origin story explains and excuses everything now.
What’s underneath
Honor origin. Do not do archaeology for its own sake in performance coaching. Ask what the adult can choose now.
Avoid here
Deep childhood excavation beyond scope and contract.
Example
Humiliation at 24 explains freeze. Also true today: they run a 40-person org. Adult choice: ally in the room. History honored, not in the driver’s seat.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12252735
S3.16Nostalgia / golden past “It used to be better.”
What is happening “It used to be better”Coach move Harvest what was living then. Recreate the quality, not the era
In the room
“It used to be better.”
What’s underneath
You cannot coach them back into last year. Harvest the quality. Recreate it inside today’s constraints. Name what is gone for good.
Avoid here
Time-travel plans. Trashing the past.
Example
Miss the startup intimacy. Quality: unfiltered craft talk. Today: a weekly 30-minute “ugly work” session with two people. Era is gone; quality is not.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods527
S6.10Legacy / last-chapter questions What will I leave. Who will I have been.
What is happening What will I leave, who will I have beenCoach move Contribution, people, body of work, unfinished conversations
In the room
What will I leave. Who will I have been.
What’s underneath
Legacy talk can avoid today’s messy conversation. Keep both. Today’s version of legacy, not only the eulogy.
Avoid here
Vision board only. Reducing it to KPIs.
Example
Talks legacy; unsent conversation with a brother. Today’s version: that call. Eulogy can wait.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122527
S6.22Midlife / quarter-life / chapter change Time awareness. Identity inventory.
What is happening Time awareness, identity inventoryCoach move Past-future-present deep dive. What to keep / drop / begin
In the room
Time awareness. Identity inventory.
What’s underneath
Do not pathologize a chapter change. Keep / drop / begin. What the last chapter cannot hold.
Avoid here
Crisis diagnosis. Instant reinvention plan.
Example
Expert chapter complete. Unfinished: a conversation with a co-founder. Calling with no name: making things with their hands. Next chapter must hold that; last one cannot.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122527
S6.24Retirement or late-career transition Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What is happening End of career in sight; identity, structure and status about to changeCoach move Walk the timeline; find what carries forward; picture a wanted next chapter
In the room
Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What’s underneath
Retirement is an identity transition, not just a date. Work has provided structure, status and belonging. Without a picture of what replaces them, the end feels like a cliff. Grief and excitement can sit side by side.
Avoid here
Turning it into a hobby list. Assuming retirement means stopping all work. Rushing past the loss.
Example
A finance director with 30 years’ service plans to stop in six months. Timeline work shows the thread is developing people. The plan becomes two non-executive roles and a mentoring programme, not golf.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2123274143
S7.34Being made redundant Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What is happening Role ended by the organisation; shock, loss and practical pressureCoach move Absorb the shock first; then rebuild the value story; then design next steps
In the room
Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What’s underneath
Redundancy is a loss of role, income, routine and identity, often at once, and usually not personal. The client needs first to absorb the shock, then to rebuild a story of their value and design practical next steps.
Avoid here
Jumping straight to CV and LinkedIn. Silver-lining talk. Ignoring finances.
Example
A marketing director is told her role is cut. First session: the shock and the anger. Second: strengths and her story. Third: three experiments in the job market.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5792736

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Letting it become an unfocused life story.
  • Digging into trauma without the right scope or skills.
  • Forgetting to bring insights back to the present decision.
  • Imposing a neat narrative the client doesn’t recognise.

10Client traps

  • Staying in the past chapters because they feel safer than the future.
  • Rewriting history so every past choice was a mistake.
  • Describing the future vividly but never stepping back to the present action.

Three worked problems

1

Senior leader facing retirement. Timeline shows the thread: developing young people. Walking forward, the client sees a mentoring role, not a hobby. Action: two informal mentoring conversations this month.

2

Redundancy after 18 years. Three earlier turning points show the client has reinvented themselves twice before. The fear eases and the job search starts from experience, not panic.

3

“My first boss ruined me.” Seeing that event alongside later successes puts it in proportion. The client names what they learned from it and what they no longer need to carry.

Where it comes from

Timeline and life-line exercises are used in narrative, career and NLP-influenced coaching.

My notes

Family 4 of 5 · Methods 28–34

Precise Inquiry

Has an ordinary open question stopped producing anything new?

This family is for the moment when ordinary open questions have gone flat — the obvious questions have already been asked, and something more structured is needed to produce genuinely new material.

28
Precise Inquiry family

Clean Language

Core move: Ask about the client’s exact word only
4 options9 questions4 situations

1What it really is

Asking about the client’s exact word, adding no new metaphor or language of the coach’s own. Built specifically for loaded or vivid words the client has used: “pressure,” “stuck,” “heavy,” “fog,” “wall.”

Clean Language was developed by the counselling psychologist David Grove. The coach uses a small set of simple questions built entirely from the client’s own words, so the client’s inner picture stays theirs. If a client says they feel “stuck in a fog,” the coach doesn’t suggest what the fog is like; they ask questions such as “What kind of fog is that fog?” or “Is there anything else about that fog?” and let the client fill in the detail.

It sounds like: “And what kind of ‘pressure’ is that pressure?”, “And where is that ‘wall’?”, or “And when ‘stuck’, what would you like to have happen?” It is not a script to be recited mechanically, and it can feel strange at first, so it helps to explain briefly what you are doing. It works best with words the client has emphasised or repeated. It has worked when the client’s metaphor becomes richer and more detailed, and when it begins to reveal what they need or want in a way plain description didn’t.

4How it works, deeply

The core discipline is radical restraint: the coach adds zero new imagery of their own — no “is it like a mountain?” or “sounds heavy, like a weight.” Every question uses only the client’s own word, fed back exactly. This protects the client’s own internal map from being overwritten by the coach’s imagination, and it’s precisely this restraint that lets the client’s own metaphor develop and reveal more than a conventional paraphrase ever could.

Grove noticed that clients’ metaphors were not decorations but carried their inner experience in symbolic form. When a coach introduces their own words or images, they unintentionally reshape that experience to match their own map. Clean questions keep the client’s metaphor intact and invite them to explore it further. Over time, the metaphor often develops into a detailed landscape of how the client experiences the problem, which in turn suggests what would need to change.

The questions also work because they are short and repetitive, which focuses attention entirely on the client’s experience. Because they contain almost no content of the coach’s, they reduce the risk of suggestion and allow the client to discover information for themselves. Clean Language is used in coaching, therapy, research interviews and organisational development for this reason. Even when used lightly, a single clean question about a vivid word can open more than several minutes of paraphrasing.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client uses a loaded or vivid word — "pressure", "stuck", "heavy" — and the coach's own paraphrase risks importing assumptions
The move
Ask about the client's exact word, adding no new language of your own
Watch
The discipline is not adding your own words. The moment you supply a metaphor of your own, you are no longer following theirs.
Four questions that often open it
  1. And when there is [pressure], what kind of [pressure] is that?
  2. Is there anything else about that [pressure]?
  3. Whereabouts is that [pressure]?
  4. What would that [pressure] like to have happen?

2The client’s context

An ordinary paraphrase from the coach would import the coach’s own metaphor and subtly overwrite the client’s. The client’s chosen word is clearly doing significant work — it’s carrying more meaning than its literal definition suggests.

3The coach’s options

Four standard clean-language question forms:

1“What kind of X?” — developing the metaphor’s specific quality.
2“Anything else about X?” — expanding without adding new content.
3“Whereabouts is X?” — locating it, often in the body or in time.
4“What would X like to have happen?” — asking the metaphor itself what it wants.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach supplies a prettier metaphor of their own, which hijacks the client’s original image. Or the inquiry becomes clinical and interrogative, especially if used rapid-fire, or used as a first move purely to sound trained.

6How to move it forward

Return to exactly one client word. If clean questions go dry, switch families entirely — try body-based inquiry, scaling, or an experiment instead.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • And when there is [pressure], what kind of [pressure] is that?
  • Is there anything else about that [pressure]?
  • Whereabouts is that [pressure]?
  • What would that [pressure] like to have happen?
Going further
  • And is there anything else about [X]?
  • Does [X] have a size or a shape?
  • And where does [X] come from?
  • And what happens just before [X]?
  • And when [X], what would you like to have happen instead?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.4Vague “Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.
What is happening “Things feel off”, “leadership”, “balance” with no pictureCoach move Scaling / “What would we see if we filmed it?”
In the room
“Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.
What’s underneath
Abstraction protects. As long as the topic stays a noun with no scene, no one can fail at it and no one can finish it. Advanced coaching operationalizes: values, identities, and moods become behavior in a room at a time of day.
Avoid here
Coaching the slogan. More values language. Big identity work with no scene. Generating a 10-step “confidence plan.”
Example
“I just need more balance.” Film: current Tuesday is Slack at 21:40. +1 is laptop closed at 19:00 two nights, calendar invite to themselves. Balance stops being a personality project.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6222835
S1.6Intellectualizing Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stage…
What is happening Models, analysis, “interestingly”, little felt experienceCoach move Body, emotion, metaphor, silence
In the room
Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stages of their own avoidance.
What’s underneath
Cognition ahead of felt experience gets rejected by the nervous system even when accurate — and here cognition is the defense. Out-analyzing them rewards the defense. Sideways routes (body, image, silence) restore data they have edited out.
Avoid here
Question cube as more architecture. Systemic reframe as another framework. Any method that stays in third-person analysis.
Example
Client maps their “avoidance pattern” with a 2x2. Coach does not add a quadrant. “If the 2x2 stepped aside…” Throat tight. Weather: locked archive room. Work becomes the unsent two-line message, not a better map of avoidance.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6714283138
S8.18Client far more senior or powerful than the coach The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.
What is happening Large status gap; coach tempted to defer or impressCoach move Contract for challenge; stay curious and independent
In the room
The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.
What’s underneath
Seniority and status are part of the room. If the coach defers, the client loses the challenge they need. The coach’s value is in their questions and their independence, not in matching the client’s status.
Avoid here
Deference. Performing expertise. Avoiding challenge.
Example
A new coach working with a CEO keeps agreeing. In supervision, the coach realises this. Next session they contract openly for challenge.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13728
S8.19Cultural or identity gap between coach and client Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.
What is happening Coach and client differ in culture, identity or experienceCoach move Name the gap; use the client’s own words; ask, don’t assume
In the room
Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.
What’s underneath
Culture, identity and lived experience shape what problems mean and what solutions are possible. The coach doesn’t need to share them, but does need curiosity, humility and willingness to name the gap and ask.
Avoid here
Assuming your own cultural norms are neutral. Avoiding the topic. Over-apologising.
Example
A coach from a low-hierarchy culture coaches a client from a high-hierarchy culture about “speaking up to the boss.” The coach asks what speaking up would look like in the client’s context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods171128

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Adding your own weather, animal, or image on top of the client’s — this is the single biggest violation of the method.
  • Rapid-firing clean questions without warmth or pacing.

10Client traps

  • None specific to the client — this method is explicitly designed to protect the client’s own map. The risk here sits entirely on the coach’s side.

Three worked problems

1

“There’s a wall.” Kind of wall: glass. Whereabouts: between chest and the room. What it wants: a door they open themselves, not one kicked in. Experiment: one sentence spoken through the glass this week — not a full personality transplant.

2

“Heavy.” Kind: a wet coat. Location: shoulders, after 4pm. Wants to be hung up. Calendar question: what gets “hung up” at 4pm specifically?

3

“Stuck.” Kind: gears grinding, not fully frozen. Already slightly moving on Thursdays. The move is to do more of whatever the Thursday conditions are.

Where it comes from

Clean Language was developed by David Grove and extended into Symbolic Modelling by Penny Tompkins and James Lawley (Metaphors in Mind).

My notes

29
Precise Inquiry family

The Question Cube / Five-Dimensional Inquiry

Core move: Rotate purpose, perspective, time, action, depth
5 options9 questions7 situations

1What it really is

When the obvious question has already been asked and the conversation has gone flat, this method rotates through five distinct dimensions one at a time: purpose, perspective, time, action, and depth.

The Question Cube is a simple tool for when a conversation has gone flat because it keeps asking the same type of question. It reminds the coach that there are five distinct directions a question can take: purpose (why), perspective (who else), time (past and future), action (what next), and depth (who am I in this). By deliberately turning to a different face, the coach gives the client a fresh angle on the same topic.

It sounds like the coach noticing they have asked three “how” questions and switching to “What would solving this give you?” or “How would your team describe this?” It is not a checklist to work through in order, and not every face needs to be used in every session. One well-chosen turn is usually enough. It has worked when the client stops repeating familiar answers and offers something new, or when energy returns to a conversation that had become circular.

4How it works, deeply

The discipline here is rotation, not accumulation. Cycling through all five dimensions in a single breath turns the method into an interrogation. Instead, the coach rotates one dimension, asks the question, and waits — allowing that single shift in angle to do its work before considering whether another rotation is needed.

Each face of the cube asks a different kind of question. Purpose asks why; perspective asks who else; time asks when and how long; action asks what next; depth asks who am I in this. A conversation usually goes flat because it has been asking the same kind of question in different words. Turning to a new face forces the client to generate something new rather than retrieve something already rehearsed.

Conversations tend to fall into grooves. Once the coach and client have been asking “how” questions for a while, both are mentally set up to keep producing “how” answers, even when the real block lies in purpose or identity. Switching dimensions breaks that groove. It forces the client’s attention to a different aspect of the situation, where fresh information is often waiting. The cube is a reminder of how many directions there are to turn.

Each dimension connects to a distinct part of the client’s experience: motivation (purpose), relationships (perspective), history and future (time), behaviour (action) and identity (depth). A difficulty can be stuck in any of these, and the coach’s observation of where energy drops or rises guides which face to turn to next. Used well, the cube makes the coach more flexible without making the session mechanical, because each question still responds to what the client has just said.

  • Purpose — Turn here when the client is busy with how but has lost sight of why. “What would solving this give you?”
  • Perspective — Turn here when the story only has one point of view. “How would your team describe this problem?”
  • Time — Turn here when the client is trapped in now. “What was different a year ago? Where do you want this in six months?”
  • Action — Turn here when there is understanding but no movement. “What could you do in the next 48 hours?”
  • Depth — Turn here when the topic keeps returning in new forms. “Who are you being while this keeps happening?”

Quick card

Reach for it when
The obvious question has already been asked and answered; the conversation has gone flat
The move
Rotate the topic through purpose, perspective, time, and action to generate a genuinely new angle
Watch
Rotate one dimension at a time. Cycling through all of them in one breath turns inquiry into interrogation.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What is the deeper purpose of exploring this today?
  2. Who else has a stake in this, and what is their view?
  3. How long has this been true, and how long do you want it to remain true?
  4. What is the smallest step that would shift this?

2The client’s context

Flatness after a run of competent, open questions — the conversation is stuck at the same altitude, producing no new data despite genuine effort on both sides.

  • Polite but flat — Competent answers, no new language, both people working hard and getting nowhere.
  • Same angle every time — Every question so far has looked at the topic from the client’s own viewpoint, in the present.
  • Over-worked dimension — The conversation keeps returning to one kind of question, usually “what should I do?”, without progress.
  • Lost thread — The session has drifted and needs a fresh angle rather than more of the same.

3The coach’s options

Five dimensions to rotate through:

1Purpose — why this, today, really?
2Perspective — who else has a stake in this?
3Time — how long has it been true, and how long is it wanted?
4Action — what’s the smallest possible shift?
5Depth/identity — who are they, inside this situation?

How to choose the face: notice which dimension the conversation has been circling, then turn to the one it hasn’t touched. If everything so far has been about action, try purpose or depth. If it has all been the client’s view, try perspective. If it has all been about now, try time.

5Where it gets stuck

Cycling through all five dimensions in one breath turns the tool into an interrogation rather than an inquiry.

6How to move it forward

Rotate exactly one dimension. Then wait, fully, before considering another.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What is the deeper purpose of exploring this today?
  • Who else has a stake in this, and what is their view?
  • How long has this been true, and how long do you want it to remain true?
  • What is the smallest step that would shift this?
Going further
  • Purpose: What would it mean if you never resolved this?
  • Perspective: If your team could vote on this, what would they choose?
  • Time: What was different about this a year ago?
  • Action: What’s one thing you could do in the next ten minutes?
  • Depth/identity: Who are you being right now while you describe this?

8Situations from the field

Situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move.

S1.21Comparing this to last time / “we already covered this” Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.
What is happening Impatience, “I know this”, cynicismCoach move Honor the known. Ask what is new in this version
In the room
Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.
What’s underneath
Repeating a topic is not failure. Integration may be missing. Knowing is not living. Honor the known; ask what is different about this week’s living.
Avoid here
Re-teaching the same insight more brilliantly. Shame about repetition.
Example
“We covered delegation.” Living it this week: they still took the deck back on Sunday. Integration = stop-doing list with their boss, not another article on empowerment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293839
S3.7Complexifying / adding layers to stay safe More frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decision.
What is happening More frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decisionCoach move Simplify to the real choice. Time-box complexity
In the room
More frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decision.
What’s underneath
Complexity can be highly intelligent avoidance. Time-box. 70% information. Actual Friday choice.
Avoid here
Question cube used as more layers. More stakeholder maps.
Example
Nine-stakeholder model for a hire. Friday choice: A or B, 30-day review. Fear under complexity: being seen to pick wrong. Named; then picked.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods129
S5.3Analysis paralysis / too many options Pros/cons forever. More research.
What is happening Pros/cons forever, more researchCoach move Limit options to 2–3. Decide by value + reversible test
In the room
Pros/cons forever. More research.
What’s underneath
More options after a point reduce action. Decide by value + reversible test. What is research hoping to spare them from feeling.
Avoid here
Invent-eight here (wrong situation — that is for no options). Question cube as more dimensions.
Example
Four vendors, sixth comparison sheet. Research spares them from disappointing a friend-vendor. Named; pick with a 30-day out.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2429
S8.5Intellectual sparring with the coach Debates the model. Stays in the head.
What is happening Debates the model, stays in the headCoach move Step out of the tennis match. Go to experience
In the room
Debates the model. Stays in the head.
What’s underneath
Do not win the debate. Leave the court. Go to experience.
Avoid here
Better theory.
Example
Debate on adult development. Live issue: they froze in Tuesday’s forum. Week, not model.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2931
S8.11Session energy drops / both get sleepy Fog. Circles.
What is happening Fog, going in circlesCoach move Call it. Stand, breathe, pick a sharper question or close this thread
In the room
Fog. Circles.
What’s underneath
Polite persistence in a dead thread wastes the hour. Call it. Stand, breathe, sharper slice or park.
Avoid here
One more question at the same altitude.
Example
Fog on a stakeholder map. Real topic was the leave-question they stepped around. Naming the drop finds it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods129
S9.4Coaching isn’t working Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What is happening Sessions repeat without progress; frustration on one or both sidesCoach move Name it openly; review goals, fit and approach together
In the room
Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What’s underneath
Lack of progress is information. The topic, the fit, the timing or the method may be wrong. Naming it openly is better than carrying on politely.
Avoid here
Blaming the client. Pretending it’s fine. Trying harder with the same approach.
Example
After six sessions, nothing has changed. The coach names it and asks what isn’t working. The client admits the real topic is leaving, not leadership.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293439
S9.9Team session: one voice dominates One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What is happening Team coaching; one person fills the spaceCoach move Structure turn-taking; widen perspectives; use spatial mapping
In the room
One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What’s underneath
Dominance may be habit, status or anxiety. Others’ silence may be agreement, fear or disengagement. The team coach balances voices without shaming anyone.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Publicly shutting the person down. Letting the session become a monologue.
Example
In a leadership team session, the CEO answers every question. The coach uses a round where each person speaks in turn, then a spatial map where each person places themselves.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods311293033

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Using the cube as a party trick to impress rather than genuinely serve the client.
  • Reaching for it instead of simply sitting in silence when silence is what’s actually needed.
  • Turning the faces in a fixed order instead of choosing the one the conversation has neglected.
  • Treating action as the default exit when the missing face is really purpose or depth.

10Client traps

  • Answering each dimension intellectually without ever touching the actual heat underneath.
  • Using perspective questions to talk about other people and avoid their own part.
  • Giving quick, clever answers on every face so that none of them is felt.

Three worked problems

1

Flat “stakeholder management” topic. Rotating the purpose dimension surfaces: “I want to stop abandoning myself in that room.” That’s an entirely different hour of work.

2

Long-running resentment. Rotating the time dimension reveals it’s been true for nine years, but the client wants it resolved in 30 days. This reveals the real work is making a request or an ending, not more analysis.

3

Stuck strategy choice. Rotating perspective reveals finance, customers, and the team all want different outcomes. The smallest step: one conversation with finance before any more modelling.

Where it comes from

A structured questioning framework with no single published origin; it reflects the general idea of rotating question types (purpose, perspective, time, action, depth) to open new ground.

My notes

30
Precise Inquiry family

The Third Entity (Empty Chair for the Topic)

Core move: Give the topic its own seat and voice
5 options9 questions8 situations

1What it really is

Giving the topic itself a seat and a voice, separate from the client. This is a close cousin of externalizing (Method 13), but uses a concrete third seat when an abstract character name isn’t landing.

The Third Entity gives the topic its own place in the room, usually an empty chair or an object, separate from both client and coach. The client can then look at it, talk to it, and sometimes answer back as it. This is especially useful when the topic is something larger than a person, such as a business, a role, a project or a deadline, and the client feels too entangled with it to think clearly.

It sounds like: “If ‘the business’ were sitting in that chair, what would you want to say to it?” or, with permission, “Would you be willing to sit there and answer as the business?” It is not theatre or role-play for its own sake, and the client is always free to stay seated and simply describe what they would say. The debrief at the end matters as much as the dialogue. It has worked when the client feels more separate from the topic and gains a new understanding of what it needs, or what they need from it.

4How it works, deeply

The physical or imagined chair does real psychological work by creating spatial separation where linguistic separation has failed. Speaking to something rather than about it changes the register of the conversation — it becomes a negotiation rather than a description. When the physical setting doesn’t allow an actual chair, the coach can switch to naming the pattern verbally instead, without losing the dialogic quality.

This method draws on the same insight as Gestalt empty chair work: speaking directly to something brings out feelings, needs and intentions that stay hidden when we talk about it. The client finds themselves using different words and tone, and often says things they didn’t realise they felt. Answering as the entity can be even more revealing, because the client briefly sees their own situation from outside, through the eyes of the thing they have been struggling with.

The physical separation also helps clients who feel overwhelmed by a topic. When the business or the role is “over there” in a chair, it is no longer filling the whole room. The client can see it as one thing in their life rather than the frame around everything. The debrief completes the method by bringing the insights back into the client’s ordinary perspective. Without that step, the experience can stay vivid but unintegrated, so the coach always reserves time for it.

How to run it, step by step:

  • Name it — Agree what the entity is: “the deadline”, “the business”, “the old role”.
  • Place it — An empty chair, an object on the table, or a point in the room.
  • Describe it — “If it had a face and a voice, what would it look and sound like?”
  • Speak to it — The client talks to the entity, not about it.
  • Answer as it (optional) — With permission, the client moves to its seat and replies in its voice.
  • Step out and debrief — Back in their own seat: “What did you notice? What’s different now?” Always end here.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client and problem have become tangled together in every sentence; hard to separate "me" from "it"
The move
Give the topic itself a seat and a voice, separate from the client
Watch
A cousin of externalizing the problem. Use a concrete third seat when an abstract character name isn't landing.
Four questions that often open it
  1. If this topic were a third person sitting in that chair, what would it say to you?
  2. What is it asking of you, and what are you asking of it?
  3. What does it need in order to loosen its grip?
  4. If you spoke back to it right now, what would you say?

2The client’s context

The client and the problem are tangled together in every sentence — it’s genuinely hard to separate “me” from “it” in their language.

  • Tangled language — “I am the deadline.” “It’s just me and this anxiety.” Person and problem are fused.
  • Externalizing hasn’t landed — Giving the pattern a name felt abstract or silly; the client needs something more concrete.
  • Pushed around by a force — Anxiety, the inner critic, the business or a deadline seems to be in charge.
  • A relationship never spoken to — A long relationship with an organisation, role or loss that the client has never addressed directly.

3The coach’s options

1Chair for the topic itself.
2Chair for a relationship.
3Chair for the company or organization.
4Chair for the deadline, the board, or the fear — any pressuring force.
5Dialogue back to the entity, not just a monologue at it.

5Where it gets stuck

It can feel gimmicky, and the client ends up talking about the chair rather than to it.

6How to move it forward

Make it physically real if the setting allows an actual chair. Otherwise, switch to naming the pattern conversationally without the physical prop.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If this topic were a third person sitting in that chair, what would it say to you?
  • What is it asking of you, and what are you asking of it?
  • What does it need in order to loosen its grip?
  • If you spoke back to it right now, what would you say?
Going further
  • What does it look like, if it had a face?
  • If it could only say one sentence to you, what would it be?
  • What has it never told you before, that it might tell you now?
  • If you asked it what it actually wants from you, what would it say?
  • What would change between you and it if you stopped fighting it?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S2.4Anxious / catastrophizing What-if chains. Worst-case movies spoken as present fact. Body tension.
What is happening What-if chains, worst-case movies, body tensionCoach move Present facts vs forecast. Scale likelihood. Small next experiment
In the room
What-if chains. Worst-case movies spoken as present fact. Body tension.
What’s underneath
Anxiety collapses time: forecast becomes now. Ground in known vs imagined. Scale likelihood. Coping-even-if. A 2% safer next step. Do not debate the catastrophe (argument feeds it).
Avoid here
Pre-mortem as first move (rehearses failure). Miracle question if they cannot leave the movie. “It won’t happen.”
Example
“I will be fired in the town hall.” Known: agenda has their update. Imagined: public humiliation chain. Likelihood they actually name: 3. 2% safer step: walk the update with an ally tonight. Tree stops growing.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods62030
S2.8Grief / loss mixed into a work topic Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”
What is happening Role loss, champion left, identity ending, eyes wet when “professional”Coach move Name the loss. Allow a beat. Then ask what wants to be carried forward
In the room
Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”
What’s underneath
Grief is not a lesson yet. Reframing it into growth too fast is a small desecration and breaks trust. Name what is ending and what is not. Then ask what wants to be carried forward.
Avoid here
Immediate silver lining. Options. “Who do you need to be now” in the first minute.
Example
Sponsor leaves. Client wants a “stakeholder map.” First: name the loss of being believed without a slide.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7233043
S3.9Rumination / same thoughts on repeat Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What is happening Circular why, no new dataCoach move Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination
In the room
Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What’s underneath
More analysis of the same tape will not release it. Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination. Give its job another method.
Avoid here
Deeper why. Clean language on the same nouns for twenty minutes.
Example
Hundred loops of “why did they exclude me.” Job of rumination: prevent another surprise. Other method: a cadence question to the boss. Tape stops needing to play all night.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141520303943
S6.1Fused with the problem (“I am the failure”) Identity language, not behavior language.
What is happening Identity language, not behavior languageCoach move Externalize the problem. You vs the pattern
In the room
Identity language, not behavior language.
What’s underneath
Never coach identity as a diagnosis. Externalize so they can relate to a pattern they have.
Avoid here
Labels. Pep “you’re not a failure.”
Example
“I am the anxiety of this team.” Character: Sunday Weather. Quiet after a written opening line. They have Sunday Weather; they are not it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5132030
S6.11Inner critic running the meeting Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What is happening Harsh voice, pre-emptive attackCoach move Personify the critic. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime
In the room
Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.
What’s underneath
Don’t exile the critic. Give it a smaller seat. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime.
Avoid here
“Silence your inner critic” posters.
Example
Critic protects from a parent’s public shaming. Needs five minutes of risk-check, not the whole prep. Chairperson runs the rest.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1415202530
S6.21Creativity blocked Dry, bored, safe.
What is happening Dry, bored, safeCoach move Play, constraints as fuel, permission to make bad work
In the room
Dry, bored, safe.
What’s underneath
Block is often fear or depletion, not lack of talent. Play. Permission to make bad work. Constraints as fuel.
Avoid here
Inspiration speeches. Big projects.
Example
Block protecting them from being seen as less brilliant than their reputation. Private bad sketchbook. Reputation not invited.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1530
S8.8Transference onto the coach (boss, parent, judge) Extra heat, extra pleasing, extra fight.
What is happening Extra heat, extra pleasing, extra fightCoach move Notice in supervision. Gently name the pattern if useful
In the room
Extra heat, extra pleasing, extra fight.
What’s underneath
Notice in supervision. Gently name if useful and inside agreement. Do not interpret like a therapist if that is outside contract. Be clean.
Avoid here
Deep interpretation. Acting into the role.
Example
Extra fight when the coach is quiet. Reminds them of a silent father. Named lightly. Need this hour: a coach who stays, not a father to defeat.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods30
S9.9Team session: one voice dominates One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What is happening Team coaching; one person fills the spaceCoach move Structure turn-taking; widen perspectives; use spatial mapping
In the room
One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What’s underneath
Dominance may be habit, status or anxiety. Others’ silence may be agreement, fear or disengagement. The team coach balances voices without shaming anyone.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Publicly shutting the person down. Letting the session become a monologue.
Example
In a leadership team session, the CEO answers every question. The coach uses a round where each person speaks in turn, then a spatial map where each person places themselves.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods311293033

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Forcing drama that doesn’t fit the client’s style.
  • Interpreting the dialogue like a therapist, beyond what the coaching relationship has agreed to.
  • Skipping the debrief, so the client leaves still half inside the role.
  • Pushing the client to sit in the entity’s chair after they have said no.

10Client traps

  • Performing the dialogue rather than genuinely inhabiting it.
  • Fusing back with the problem immediately after the exercise ends.
  • Letting the entity win every exchange, which reinforces its power.

Three worked problems

1

“The business” as a person who is never satisfied. It says: “If you rest, I die.” The client responds: “If I don’t rest, you die anyway.” Negotiation: one protected off-period, framed as a business continuity act rather than a personal indulgence.

2

Grief in the chair. The old role says, “don’t you forget me.” The client answers: “I will carry the standard, not the hours.” This allows honoring the past role without remaining occupied by a ghost job.

3

Anxiety in the chair. It asks for certainty. The client cannot give certainty but can offer a 48-hour plan and a check-in. Its grip loosens once given something concrete instead of an impossible guarantee.

Where it comes from

Combines the Gestalt empty chair (Fritz Perls) with narrative externalizing (Michael White).

My notes

31
Precise Inquiry family

Metaphor, Image, Body

Core move: Go sideways through image or sensation
5 options10 questions12 situations

1What it really is

Going sideways through image, weather, place, or physical sensation when pure analysis is stuck, or when the topic is genuinely pre-verbal.

When talking about a problem directly has stopped helping, the coach invites the client to approach it sideways. They might describe it as an image (“it’s like a locked door”), as weather (“a grey drizzle that never stops”), as a place, or as a physical sensation (“a tight band across my chest”). These descriptions often carry information the client couldn’t put into ordinary language, and they can change in ways that point toward what would help.

It sounds like: “If this situation were weather, what would it be?”, “Where do you notice this in your body right now?”, or “If that image changed just slightly, how would it change?” It is not about interpreting the client’s images for them; the meaning stays theirs to discover. It also doesn’t require dramatic emotional responses, and tiny shifts are enough. It has worked when the image or sensation changes, or when the client makes a new connection that they couldn’t have reached through analysis alone.

4How it works, deeply

This method works because it bypasses the analytical, narrative-generating part of the mind that has already exhausted itself on the topic. Two failure modes bookend it: pushing an intellectualizer to “feel more” tends to deepen their intellectualizing defense rather than dissolve it, while pushing a numb or shut-down client toward big feeling questions can deepen the shutdown. The correct calibration for numbness is a tiny increase — 5% sensation, or simply naming a color — never a full emotional breakthrough in one move.

Metaphor and image draw on different mental processes from step-by-step analysis. Images can hold many elements and relationships at once, and they connect easily with emotion and memory. When a client describes their situation as “a tangle of wires,” they convey complexity, frustration and possibly a sense of danger in a few words. Working with the image, for example asking where the tangle starts, often reveals something analysis missed.

The body adds another channel of information. Physical sensations such as tightness, heaviness or lightness often reflect emotional states before the client can name them. Research on interoception, the ability to sense internal body signals, suggests it is linked to emotional awareness and regulation. By noticing these signals and allowing small changes, clients can shift their state and gain insight at the same time. The coach’s skill lies in matching the depth of the invitation to what the client can comfortably engage with.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Analysis is stuck; topic is pre-verbal; energy is in the body
The move
Go sideways through image, weather, place, sensation
Watch
Work the metaphor they give you. Do not impose yours.
Four questions that often open it
  1. If this topic were an image, object, weather, or place, what would it be?
  2. Where do you feel this in your body?
  3. If you gave this problem a name, what would you call it?
  4. What does this image want — and what would change it?

2The client’s context

The client is intellectualizing heavily — “interestingly…” with no felt experience underneath the analysis. Energy is visibly in the body but hasn’t been named. Sometimes the opposite presentation: numbness, needing just a small notch of sensation to reconnect.

3The coach’s options

1Image/object/weather/place — inviting a symbolic representation.
2Body location — where is this felt physically?
3Name the problem — giving it a word or title.
4What the image wants — asking the metaphor itself what would change it.
5One-notch volume for a shutdown or numb state — a very small, deliberate increase in sensation, not a full catharsis.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach imposes their own metaphor onto the client’s experience. Or, with a shut-down client, pushing for passion or big feeling actually deepens the shutdown rather than opening it.

6How to move it forward

Work strictly with the client’s own image. If they’re numb, ask for just 5% more sensation, or a single color — not a catharsis.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If this topic were an image, object, weather, or place, what would it be?
  • Where do you feel this in your body?
  • If you gave this problem a name, what would you call it?
  • What does this image want — and what would change it?
  • If the volume on this were turned up one notch, what would we hear?
Going further
  • If this feeling had a temperature, what would it be?
  • What color is this right now, if it had one?
  • If your body could speak for thirty seconds, what would it say?
  • What season does this feel like?
  • If the image shifted just slightly, what would the smallest shift look like?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.1Telling a rehearsed story Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Lo…
What is happening Fluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotionCoach move Expand: “What else?” / impact / feeling
In the room
Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Low emotion. They sound competent and slightly bored by their own plot.
What’s underneath
The first version is almost never wrong; it is rarely complete. Rehearsal is a social technology: it keeps the story stable so the teller does not have to feel it again. Professional coaching needs the unstable layer — impact, pattern, the word they are not using.
Avoid here
Preferred future too early (they have not arrived in the present). Reframe before they feel heard (lands as “you did not listen to my official version”). Generating options (there is no new material to option from). Pre-mortem (there is no plan; there is a performance).
Example
A VP tells a smooth story of a “difficult stakeholder.” Dates, emails, tone. Coach hears it once, then asks for impact. New sentence: “I rewrite every message three times and I hate who I am at 11pm.” That sentence is the topic. The stakeholder is context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods235673139
S1.6Intellectualizing Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stage…
What is happening Models, analysis, “interestingly”, little felt experienceCoach move Body, emotion, metaphor, silence
In the room
Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stages of their own avoidance.
What’s underneath
Cognition ahead of felt experience gets rejected by the nervous system even when accurate — and here cognition is the defense. Out-analyzing them rewards the defense. Sideways routes (body, image, silence) restore data they have edited out.
Avoid here
Question cube as more architecture. Systemic reframe as another framework. Any method that stays in third-person analysis.
Example
Client maps their “avoidance pattern” with a 2x2. Coach does not add a quadrant. “If the 2x2 stepped aside…” Throat tight. Weather: locked archive room. Work becomes the unsent two-line message, not a better map of avoidance.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6714283138
S1.16Talking very fast / flooding with words No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.
What is happening No pauses, stacked clauses, little breathCoach move Pace down. Reflect one piece. Ask for the headline
In the room
No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.
What’s underneath
Speed is often anesthesia or an attempt to get it all in before they are interrupted (history of not being given the floor). Pacing down is regulation. Headline restores choice.
Avoid here
Matching speed. And-what-else rapid fire. Complexifying.
Example
Seven-minute sentence about a reorg. Coach: one sentence. “I don’t know if I have a job.” That is the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods173132
S1.17Very little language / “I don’t know” Shrugging. One-word answers. Blank look. Long gaps that are empty rather than working.
What is happening Shrugging, one-word answers, blank lookCoach move Offer structure: scale, image, guess, body, either/or
In the room
Shrugging. One-word answers. Blank look. Long gaps that are empty rather than working.
What’s underneath
“I don’t know” is often “I haven’t looked yet” or “it is unsafe to know.” Structure is kindness: scale, image, guess, either/or. Staring them down is not presence.
Avoid here
Wide open “what do you want from your life.” Challenge. Question cube.
Example
New director, one-word answers. Two doors: “the role, or the loneliness in it.” They pick loneliness. Language appears once the door is smaller.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5631
S1.18Humor as deflection Jokes at the exact moment of heat. Self-mockery. Room laughs; topic dies.
What is happening Jokes at the exact moment of heat, self-mockeryCoach move Smile with them, then return to the moment before the joke
In the room
Jokes at the exact moment of heat. Self-mockery. Room laughs; topic dies.
What’s underneath
Humor is often a gifted regulator. Do not kill it. Use it as a doorway back to the sentence before the joke.
Avoid here
Tight-faced “let’s be serious.” Ignoring the joke and losing the heat marker.
Example
“My team doesn’t need me — lucky them!” Return. Unfunny version: fear of becoming ornamental after promotion. Work that.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71431
S2.2Numb / flat / shutdown Monotone. “Whatever.” Low energy. No charge.
What is happening Monotone, “whatever”, low energy, no chargeCoach move Gentle sensory/body, tiny scales, exception, warmth without pressure
In the room
Monotone. “Whatever.” Low energy. No charge.
What’s underneath
Shutdown is not the absence of a topic; it is a nervous-system setting. Turning enthusiasm to ten usually deepens it. Raise volume one notch: tiny scale, flicker, safe sliver.
Avoid here
Rally speeches. Who-you-need-to-be as a trumpet. Preferred-future cinema.
Example
“Career is fine I guess.” 5% care: they still notice ugly slide design. Tiny act: one craft conversation. Aliveness returns without a purpose workshop.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2531
S3.12Data-only / feeling-blind Metrics, slides, no human field.
What is happening Metrics, slides, no human fieldCoach move Add stakeholder experience, body, relationship cost
In the room
Metrics, slides, no human field.
What’s underneath
Honor their strength in data; widen the instrument panel. Stakeholder experience, body, relationship cost.
Avoid here
Anti-data sermons.
Example
Cut a team to hit a ratio. Dashboard silent: trust in the remaining leads. They know. Work both panels.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1631
S5.14Stuck between option A and B Oscillates daily. Seeks a sign.
What is happening Oscillates daily, seeks a signCoach move Values, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period
In the room
Oscillates daily. Seeks a sign.
What’s underneath
The torture is often the oscillation, not either option. Values, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period.
Avoid here
More comparison matrices.
Example
Two job offers. Oscillation is the torture. Future-you already lives in B when they describe Friday evening. 30-day trial not possible; announcement date is.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods82431
S5.16Need to have a difficult conversation Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What is happening Avoids the meeting, writes unsent emailsCoach move Purpose, request, opening line, body regulation, rehearsal
In the room
Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What’s underneath
Role-play beats more theory. Purpose, request, first sentence, body, live practice.
Avoid here
Longer essays. More theory of crucial conversations.
Example
Unsent prosecution email. Purpose: fewer surprises. First sentence practiced. Heat in chest named. Meeting request sent same day.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods731353740
S7.4Conflict-avoidant Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.
What is happening Keeps peace, stores residue, surprise explosions laterCoach move Micro-truths. Body first. 2-minute version of the conversation
In the room
Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.
What’s underneath
Teach titrated honesty, not a personality transplant. Body first. 2-minute version.
Avoid here
“Have the big fight.”
Example
Swallows “this date is fiction.” Body: swallow reflex. 2-minute version to the PM this week. Titration.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7313237
S7.31Compensation / raise / negotiation topic Worth, fear, market story.
What is happening Worth, fear, market storyCoach move Value case, ask, BATNA, practice the sentence
In the room
Worth, fear, market story.
What’s underneath
Money talk is often identity talk. Work both. Value case, ask, BATNA, practice the sentence.
Avoid here
Only market data or only inner-child-of-money.
Example
Number spoken; voice shrinks. Practice twice. Enough and walk-away defined so the ask is not a plea. Identity and tactic.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods31
S8.5Intellectual sparring with the coach Debates the model. Stays in the head.
What is happening Debates the model, stays in the headCoach move Step out of the tennis match. Go to experience
In the room
Debates the model. Stays in the head.
What’s underneath
Do not win the debate. Leave the court. Go to experience.
Avoid here
Better theory.
Example
Debate on adult development. Live issue: they froze in Tuesday’s forum. Week, not model.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2931

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Trying to out-analyze someone who is already intellectualizing — this only fuels the defense.
  • Imposing the coach’s own images rather than working with the client’s.
  • Asking big-feeling questions of a flooded or shut-down nervous system.

10Client traps

  • Turning the metaphor itself into another clever analytical model, sidestepping the felt experience it was meant to access.

Three worked problems

1

Intellectualizer describing a reorg with frameworks. Weather image: a low grey ceiling. Body: a tight throat. The ceiling “wants a window.” Practical move: one honest sentence to a peer outside the company this week.

2

Numb “whatever” about a stalled career. Color: dull green. 5% of care remaining: they still notice good design when they see it. Tiny act: sending one note of craft-appreciation to a junior colleague, which restarts aliveness without needing a grand purpose statement.

3

Flooded tears mid-topic. No metaphor is added here. Body comes first: “We can slow this down. What do you need to stay with it?” The slice of the conversation is sized down immediately.

Where it comes from

Draws on Clean Language and Symbolic Modelling, and on Focusing (Eugene Gendlin), which works with the body’s “felt sense”.

My notes

32
Precise Inquiry family

Centre and Ground (Somatic Practice)

Core move: Work with breath, posture and sensation to change the state, then the conversation
5 options10 questions9 situations

1What it really is

Drawn from somatic coaching (for example Richard Strozzi-Heckler and the Strozzi Institute) and body-based regulation practices. The coach invites the client to notice and adjust breath, posture, feet on the floor and muscle tension, both to steady a flooded state and to try a new way of standing in a challenge. The body is treated as part of the coaching conversation, not a distraction from it.

In practice, this method is often very simple. The coach invites the client to slow their breathing, feel their feet on the floor, notice where they are holding tension, and let their posture settle. When a client is anxious, angry or overwhelmed, these small physical shifts can help them settle enough to think. The method is also used to practise new ways of being: standing tall before a difficult conversation, or finding a centred posture to return to under pressure.

It sounds like: “Before we go on, let’s take a moment. Notice your feet on the floor… let your out-breath be a little longer,” or “What posture would someone confident in this situation have?” It is not therapy, and the coach doesn’t push the client to explore physical sensations they’d rather not. It is also not a relaxation technique for its own sake; the aim is to make the conversation work better. It has worked when the client’s breathing or voice visibly steadies, or when they can recreate a resourceful state on their own.

4How it works, deeply

Thinking and feeling don’t happen only in the head. A threatened body narrows attention and makes complex thinking harder. Simple practices like longer out-breaths and grounding can help many people feel steadier in the moment, which makes reflection possible again. Practising a posture or way of standing can also make a new behaviour feel more possible, because the client has already tried it physically rather than only imagined it.

Somatic coaching is based on the idea that our habits of feeling and acting are held in the body as well as the mind. Under stress, the body moves into protective patterns, such as shallow breathing, raised shoulders or a forward lean, which can then keep the stress going. Deliberately changing those patterns can interrupt the loop. Slow breathing with a longer out-breath, in particular, is widely associated with activating the body’s calming response.

Centring practices also give the client a reliable reset they can use on their own. With repetition, the steps become quicker and more automatic, so the client can return to a steadier state in a tense meeting or before a difficult call. NLP’s anchoring works in a similar way, linking a resourceful state to a simple cue such as a gesture or word. Over time, practising new postures or ways of standing can make new behaviours feel familiar before they are tried in real life.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Client is flooded, collapses under pressure, or faces a high-stakes moment
The move
Ground, notice, centre, then practise the new stance
Watch
Ask permission; keep it short and inside coaching scope.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Where do you notice this in your body?
  2. What happens with a slower out-breath?
  3. How would you stand if you said it with confidence?
  4. Can you say it again from there?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Flooded — Fast breathing, shaky voice, can’t finish sentences.
  • Before a big moment — High-stakes meeting, keynote or difficult conversation coming up.
  • Habitual collapse — Shoulders curl, voice drops, whenever conflict appears.
  • Remote and distracted — Multitasking, camera off, attention scattered.
  • Knows it in the head only — Can say what they want to do but can’t feel themselves doing it.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses among five body-based moves:

1Ground — Feet flat, feel the chair, slow breath out longer than breath in.
2Notice — “Where do you feel this in your body right now?” No fixing, just noticing.
3Centre — Lengthen the spine, widen the shoulders, settle the weight. Then ask the question again.
4Shape the new stance — “How would you stand if you were saying this with confidence?” Try it.
5Practise under light pressure — Rehearse a sentence while keeping the centred posture.
Variation from NLPAnchoring a resourceful state

Linking a resourceful state, such as calm or confidence, to a simple cue the client can use later, just before the moment that matters.

  1. Recall — When have you felt exactly the state you need? Go back there now.
  2. Intensify — What do you see, hear and feel? Let it build.
  3. Link — As it peaks, add a small cue: press thumb and finger together, say a word, or picture an image.
  4. Break and test — Shake it off, then use the cue. What comes back?
  5. Use — Where and when will you use it before the real moment?

Watch: It works best with the breath and posture work in this method. It is a cue, not a magic switch.

A core NLP technique. NLP tools are widely used in coaching, but research support for NLP’s core claims is limited. Treat this as a practical tool to test, not proven science. See also Other NLP techniques.

5Where it gets stuck

The client finds it awkward or “too soft” and disengages. Or the coach pushes into strong emotion or trauma without the skills or the agreement to do so.

6How to move it forward

Ask permission and frame it practically: “Can we try something quick that some leaders use before big meetings?” Keep it short, optional and professional. If strong emotion or trauma appears, slow down, keep the client grounded and safe, and consider referral.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Where do you notice this in your body right now?
  • What happens if you let your breath out a little more slowly?
  • How are you standing or sitting as you say that?
  • How would you stand if you were saying it with full confidence?
  • Can you say that sentence again from this posture?
Going further
  • What does your body do just before you stay silent in meetings?
  • What helps your body feel steady when you’re under pressure?
  • What do you notice changes after a minute of slower breathing?
  • Where in your body do you feel the yes, and where the no?
  • What small practice could you do before the meeting tomorrow?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S1.16Talking very fast / flooding with words No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.
What is happening No pauses, stacked clauses, little breathCoach move Pace down. Reflect one piece. Ask for the headline
In the room
No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.
What’s underneath
Speed is often anesthesia or an attempt to get it all in before they are interrupted (history of not being given the floor). Pacing down is regulation. Headline restores choice.
Avoid here
Matching speed. And-what-else rapid fire. Complexifying.
Example
Seven-minute sentence about a reorg. Coach: one sentence. “I don’t know if I have a job.” That is the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods173132
S2.1Emotionally flooded / activated Tears, shaking voice, heat, cannot finish sentences.
What is happening Tears, shaking voice, heat, can’t finish sentencesCoach move Safety, presence, breath, smaller slice. No big future questions yet
In the room
Tears, shaking voice, heat, cannot finish sentences.
What’s underneath
High arousal takes prefrontal capacity offline. Asking for a preferred future mid-flood is map-reading while the building is on fire. Presence and slice-size are the methods.
Avoid here
Miracle, future-self, pre-mortem, challenge, question cube, stacked powerful questions.
Example
Client breaks on “they announced the role without telling me.” Coach does not ask what future-them would do. Slice: this feeling, two minutes, feet on the floor. Later they choose a request to the sponsor — after speech returns.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods73238
S2.16Burned out / depleted Cynicism. Exhaustion. Sunday dread. Numbness plus irritability.
What is happening Cynicism, exhaustion, Sunday dread, numbness + irritabilityCoach move Energy before strategy. Recovery design. Reduce load, don’t add homework
In the room
Cynicism. Exhaustion. Sunday dread. Numbness plus irritability.
What’s underneath
Do not coach peak performance on an empty tank. Energy before strategy. Reduce load; do not add homework. Recovery is the strategy.
Avoid here
Who-you-need-to-be-as-a-high-performer. Big plans. Appreciation as pep.
Example
Sunday dread + cynicism. Must stop: Sunday night pre-writes for a meeting that never decides. Recovery design first. Performance later.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods53240
S6.26Chronic illness or health limits reshaping work (including menopause) Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What is happening Health limits energy or capacity; fear of being judged as unreliableCoach move Sort control; redesign work around real limits; plan the conversations
In the room
Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What’s underneath
Health changes the resources available, not the person’s value. The coaching challenge is redesigning work around real limits, communicating needs, and dealing with the identity hit. Medical questions belong with medical professionals.
Avoid here
Medical advice. Pushing performance goals as if health is unchanged. Treating it as purely a mindset issue.
Example
A senior lawyer going through menopause has poor sleep and brain fog. Coach helps sort what’s in her control, plan demanding work for her best hours, and prepare a conversation with HR.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods416323640
S7.4Conflict-avoidant Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.
What is happening Keeps peace, stores residue, surprise explosions laterCoach move Micro-truths. Body first. 2-minute version of the conversation
In the room
Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.
What’s underneath
Teach titrated honesty, not a personality transplant. Body first. 2-minute version.
Avoid here
“Have the big fight.”
Example
Swallows “this date is fiction.” Body: swallow reflex. 2-minute version to the PM this week. Titration.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7313237
S7.29High-stakes event coming (board, keynote, review) Performance anxiety + preparation swirl.
What is happening Performance anxiety + preparation swirlCoach move Purpose, audience, state regulation, rehearsal, good-enough structure
In the room
Performance anxiety + preparation swirl.
What’s underneath
More content is rarely the missing piece. Purpose for the audience. State regulation. Rehearsal. Good-enough structure.
Avoid here
More slides.
Example
60 extra slides are anxiety. Audience success: three decisions. Hour before: walk, not tinkering. Structure good enough.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods263237
S7.35Having to make others redundant Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What is happening Must deliver redundancies; torn between the organisation and the peopleCoach move Hold both duties; rehearse clear and humane conversations; care for themselves
In the room
Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What’s underneath
The client holds two duties at once: to the organisation and to the people affected. Both are real. Coaching helps them act with integrity and care, prepare the conversations, and look after themselves without pretending the role is easy.
Avoid here
Helping them become cold or detached. Turning it into only a legal script. Ignoring their own wellbeing.
Example
A plant manager must lay off 40 people. Coach helps him rehearse a clear, humane opening sentence and plan support for those affected and for himself.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods714183237
S8.16Suicidal thoughts or risk disclosed Hopelessness. “What’s the point?” Talking about not being here, being a burden, or having a plan. May be hint…
What is happening Client hints at or states thoughts of ending their lifeCoach move Stop the coaching agenda; ask directly; listen; connect them to professional help
In the room
Hopelessness. “What’s the point?” Talking about not being here, being a burden, or having a plan. May be hinted rather than stated.
What’s underneath
Safety comes before coaching. Asking directly and calmly about suicidal thoughts does not plant the idea; it often brings relief. The coach stays calm, listens, takes it seriously, and helps the client connect with professional help: their GP, a mental health professional, or crisis services. The coach follows their contract and any safeguarding procedures, and gets supervision afterwards.
Avoid here
Carrying on with the coaching agenda. Panic or lecturing. Promising complete confidentiality. Ending the session without a plan for support.
Example
A client says, “Sometimes I think everyone would be better off without me.” The coach pauses the session, asks directly, listens, and stays with the client while they agree who they will contact for help that day.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1732
S9.8Remote session: camera off, distracted or multitasking Camera off, typing sounds, delayed answers. Short replies.
What is happening Client distracted or unseen in remote sessionsCoach move Name it; agree remote norms; help them arrive
In the room
Camera off, typing sounds, delayed answers. Short replies.
What’s underneath
Remote coaching needs agreed norms. Distraction may be workload, avoidance or connection problems. Naming it and agreeing what works helps the session be useful.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Getting irritated. Assuming bad faith.
Example
A client keeps checking email during sessions. The coach names it and asks what would help them be present. They agree to start each session with two minutes of settling.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1732

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Introducing it without consent or explanation.
  • Pushing into intense emotion or trauma beyond coaching scope.
  • Making it so long or unusual that the client feels exposed.
  • Forgetting to link the practice back to the real situation.

10Client traps

  • Dismissing body work as irrelevant to “real” leadership.
  • Doing the practice in session but never outside it.
  • Using grounding to avoid saying the hard thing.

Three worked problems

1

Shaky before the board. Two minutes of grounding and longer out-breaths before rehearsing the opening line. The client reports the first minute of the real meeting felt “slower and clearer.”

2

Collapses when challenged. Coach notices shoulders curling. Client practises one sentence from a centred stance three times. They agree a cue (feet on the floor) for Thursday’s meeting.

3

Flooded after bad news. Coach slows everything down, invites feet on the floor and a slower breath. Only then does the client decide what to do next.

Where it comes from

Somatic coaching, especially the work of Richard Strozzi-Heckler (The Leadership Dojo).

My notes

33
Precise Inquiry family

Map It in Space (Constellation and Sculpting)

Core move: Place the people and parts of a system in space to see the relationships
5 options10 questions7 situations

1What it really is

Drawn from systemic constellation work and family-systems “sculpting.” The client uses objects on a table (coins, cups, figures) or positions in a room to represent the people, teams or forces in a situation, placing them by closeness, distance and direction. Seeing the system laid out often reveals what words haven’t: who is excluded, who is too close, where the client stands, and what small move might change things.

Mapping in space asks the client to use simple objects to represent the people, groups or forces in their situation, placing them on a table or in a room. How close or far apart they are, which way they face, and who is in the middle or on the edge all show something about the relationships. The coach invites the client to look at the arrangement, notice what stands out, and then try moving one piece to see what changes.

It sounds like: “Choose something to represent each person on the team, and place them as they feel to you right now,” followed by “What do you notice?” and “What small move would make it feel better?” It is not a literal map of reality, and there is no correct layout. It is also not the same as the more intense group constellation work; at the coaching level it stays simple and client-led. It has worked when the client sees a relationship or pattern they hadn’t recognised, and links one small move on the table to one action in real life.

4How it works, deeply

People hold rich, partly unspoken knowledge about relationships that is hard to put into sentences. Laying it out spatially lets the client use that knowledge directly. Distance, direction and grouping make patterns visible at a glance. Small experimental moves on the table give a safe rehearsal for real moves in the system. It also helps clients see themselves as one part of a system rather than the whole problem.

Placing elements in space makes use of how people naturally think about relationships. Everyday language already uses spatial terms, such as “close to,” “distant,” “on the outside,” “above me,” and putting those relationships into a physical layout makes them concrete. The client sees the whole system at once, which is hard to do in conversation where things are discussed one at a time. Patterns of exclusion, alliance or imbalance often become obvious immediately.

The ability to move pieces gives the client a low-risk way to test changes. Moving one figure closer, turning another to face a new direction, or moving themselves to a different spot allows the client to notice how the change feels before trying it in reality. Clients sometimes report a felt sense of rightness or discomfort with certain arrangements. That reaction is useful information, pointing toward which relationships or positions need attention in the real system.

Quick card

Reach for it when
The system is complex, relationships are tangled, or words have stopped producing insight
The move
Place people as objects, notice the shape, try one small move
Watch
Let the client find the meaning; don’t interpret it for them.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Where would you place each person?
  2. Where are you on the map?
  3. Who or what is missing?
  4. What changes if you move one thing?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Complex politics — Many stakeholders, unclear alliances, influence without authority.
  • Reorg confusion — Lines and loyalties shifting, unclear where they now fit.
  • Family or legacy pressure — Invisible people (parents, founders) seem to be present in decisions.
  • Team stuck — A team that keeps circling the same unspoken issue.
  • Words running out — Plenty of analysis but no new insight.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses how to use the map:

1Table map — Client chooses objects to stand for each person or group and places them on the table.
2Notice the shape — “What do you notice about who is close, who is far, who faces whom?”
3Include the missing — “Who or what isn’t on the table yet but has influence?”
4Try a move — Move one object slightly and ask what changes.
5Ideal map — Create a second map showing how the client would like it to be, and find the first small move.

5Where it gets stuck

The client gets self-conscious, or the coach interprets the map for them (“clearly your boss is excluded”) instead of letting the client find the meaning.

6How to move it forward

Keep the coach’s role to questions about what the client notices. Use simple objects and a light tone. If the client is uncomfortable with the physical version, use a quick sketch with circles and arrows instead.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • If each person here were an object on this table, where would you put them?
  • Where are you on the map?
  • What do you notice about the shape?
  • Who or what is missing from the map?
  • If you moved one thing a little, what would change?
Going further
  • Who is facing away from whom?
  • What would the map look like if it were working well?
  • What’s the smallest move toward that picture?
  • How does it feel to look at it from the outside?
  • Who else would need to see this map?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S6.18Family expectation vs own goal Invisible stakeholders at the table.
What is happening Invisible stakeholders at the tableCoach move Name who is in the room. Adult-to-adult with the script
In the room
Invisible stakeholders at the table.
What’s underneath
Go gently. Old loyalties. Name who is in the room. Adult-to-adult with the script.
Avoid here
Cutting-off fantasies as session one homework.
Example
Mother’s voice in the promotion no. Named. Living conversation possible; or a letter they do not send. Choice becomes theirs.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1433
S7.10Politics / influence without authority No formal power. Needs movement.
What is happening No formal power, needs movementCoach move Stakeholder map, interests, allies, small bets
In the room
No formal power. Needs movement.
What’s underneath
Purity about politics can keep them ineffective. Stakeholder map, interests, allies, small bets.
Avoid here
Moral purity or Machiavelli cosplay.
Example
Quality initiative. Finance already cares about rework cost. Join that movement. Small bet: one joint slide, not a lone manifesto.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1633
S7.12Friendship or dual relationship at work Blurred lines. Leftover personal.
What is happening Blurred lines, leftover personalCoach move Name the dual hats. Separate roles in the conversation
In the room
Blurred lines. Leftover personal.
What’s underneath
Denial of the dual relationship creates mess. Name the hats. Separate roles in the conversation.
Avoid here
Pretending there is one relationship.
Example
Friend-report late on updates. Role hat: standard. Kind-and-clean: name the dual hats out loud and set the work agreement.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3337
S7.20Reorg / merger / ambiguity Role fog. Rumor mill. Freeze.
What is happening Role fog, rumor mill, freezeCoach move Stabilize controllables. 30-day purpose. Network
In the room
Role fog. Rumor mill. Freeze.
What’s underneath
Do not pretend certainty you don’t have. Stabilize controllables. 30-day purpose. Network.
Avoid here
Five-year plans. False reassurance.
Example
Unknown: final structure. Known: customers still need X. 30-day purpose: protect X and stay connected to two nodes. Useful in fog.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1633
S9.9Team session: one voice dominates One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What is happening Team coaching; one person fills the spaceCoach move Structure turn-taking; widen perspectives; use spatial mapping
In the room
One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.
What’s underneath
Dominance may be habit, status or anxiety. Others’ silence may be agreement, fear or disengagement. The team coach balances voices without shaming anyone.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Publicly shutting the person down. Letting the session become a monologue.
Example
In a leadership team session, the CEO answers every question. The coach uses a round where each person speaks in turn, then a spatial map where each person places themselves.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods311293033
S9.11Team blames another team (silos) “Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.
What is happening Team describes another team as the problemCoach move Map the system both teams sit in; find the team’s own part and one shared step
In the room
“Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.
What’s underneath
Silos usually come from structure, goals and incentives, not bad people. Blame protects the team’s identity but blocks shared problem-solving. The coach widens the lens to the whole system and helps the team see its own part without shaming it.
Avoid here
Joining the blame. Lecturing about collaboration. Coaching only the team in the room as if the other team doesn’t exist.
Example
A product team blames sales for over-promising. A systemic map shows both teams are rewarded on different targets. The team proposes one shared metric and a joint fortnightly review.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods11161933
S9.12New or re-formed team with unclear roles Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.
What is happening Team is new or changed; roles and agreements are unclearCoach move Contract at team level: purpose, roles, decision rights, ways of working
In the room
Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.
What’s underneath
New teams need explicit agreements about purpose, roles and ways of working. Without them, people fill gaps based on old habits, and friction appears as personal conflict. Contracting at team level is the work.
Avoid here
Jumping to team-building games. Letting the leader define everything alone. Treating role confusion as a personality problem.
Example
After a merger, two teams become one. The coach runs a session where each person maps what they think they own. Gaps and overlaps become visible, and the team writes a one-page charter.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods163342

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Interpreting the map for the client.
  • Making it mystical or dramatic, which puts professional clients off.
  • Rushing to the ideal map before the current one is understood.
  • Using it without a clear question.

10Client traps

  • Placing objects “correctly” rather than honestly.
  • Treating the map as the truth about others rather than their own perception.
  • Enjoying the insight but making no move in real life.

Three worked problems

1

Influence without authority. The client places the CFO far away, facing away. Moving their own coin nearer to the CFO’s chief of staff shows a route in. Next step: a coffee with the chief of staff.

2

Family business succession. A coin for the late founder is placed between the two siblings. Naming that “Dad’s still in the middle” opens a different conversation about how decisions are made.

3

Team stuck after merger. Each team member places themselves. Two clear sub-groups appear. The team talks about the divide for the first time.

Where it comes from

Systemic constellation work and family “sculpting” from family therapy (for example Virginia Satir).

My notes

34
Precise Inquiry family

Developmental Lens (Subject–Object Shift)

Core move: Help what they’re run by become something they can look at
5 options10 questions6 situations

1What it really is

Drawn from adult development theory, especially Robert Kegan’s subject–object idea and vertical development approaches. Some challenges can’t be solved with a new skill because they ask the client to see their situation from a bigger perspective. What a person is “subject to” runs them without being noticed: a need for approval, loyalty to a system, a fixed view of success. The coach uses questions to help that thing become “object,” something the client can see, question and choose about.

This method is used when a challenge doesn’t really need new skills, but a bigger way of seeing. The coach notices what the client seems to be “subject to,” meaning something they can’t yet step back from, like the need to be liked, loyalty to a boss, or a single definition of success. Through careful questions, the client gradually becomes able to look at that thing, rather than being run by it, and choose what to do about it.

It sounds like: “What is it about being seen as competent that matters so much to you?”, “Whose voice is that?”, or “What would you do here if you didn’t need anyone’s approval?” It is not a way of judging the client as less developed, and it isn’t something that happens in one session. Development is slow and the coach is patient. It has worked when the client can talk about something that used to control them as a pattern they notice, and can sometimes make a different choice.

4How it works, deeply

Horizontal development adds skills; vertical development changes how a person makes sense of the world. Many senior challenges are vertical: they need the client to stop being defined by others’ expectations, or to hold several conflicting perspectives without collapsing into one. This shift happens slowly, through repeated experiences of seeing one’s own assumptions from the outside. The coach’s questions provide those moments, and stretch assignments make them stick.

Kegan’s theory describes stages of adult meaning-making. In one common stage, a person’s sense of self is largely shaped by the expectations of important others; in a later stage, they develop their own internal standards and can evaluate those expectations. Moving from one to the next means that what used to define the person becomes something they can look at. This is the subject–object shift, and it changes what problems a person can solve, not just how well they solve them.

The coach supports this shift through questions that invite the client to step outside their usual frame, and by tolerating the discomfort this can bring. Growth at this level often feels unsettling, because old certainties are loosening before new ones have formed. Challenges that are slightly too big for the client’s current way of thinking, combined with support, tend to promote development. The coach provides that support, helping the client stay with the stretch rather than retreating to the familiar.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Skills aren’t enough; the role needs a bigger perspective or the client is run by others’ standards
The move
Make the unquestioned rule visible, then author their own standard
Watch
Never label the client’s stage; stay with their actual sense-making.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What are you assuming must be true?
  2. Whose rule is that?
  3. What else could be true?
  4. What standard would you set yourself?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Role outgrows the person — New leader or expert-turned-manager who keeps doing the old role well and the new one poorly.
  • Skills aren’t working — Has learned the techniques but can’t use them when it matters.
  • Defined by others’ views — Self-worth depends heavily on approval from bosses or peers.
  • Locked in one system — Can only see the problem through their organisation’s or profession’s rules.
  • Repeated plateau — The same issue keeps coming back, at a higher level each time.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses among five developmental moves:

1Notice what runs them — “What are you assuming must be true here?” Look for the unquestioned rule.
2Ask whose voice it is — “Where does that standard come from: you, your boss, your profession?”
3Hold two views at once — “How would someone who disagrees see this? What’s true in their view too?”
4Author your own standard — “If you set the standard yourself, what would it be?”
5Stretch assignment — Agree a real-world experiment that requires the bigger perspective.

5Where it gets stuck

The coach privately labels the client’s “stage” and starts coaching to the label, which is both inaccurate and disrespectful. Or the conversation becomes abstract theory.

6How to move it forward

Drop the labels and stay with the client’s actual sense-making: “What are you assuming? Whose rule is that? What else could be true?” Tie every insight to a concrete stretch in their real work.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What are you assuming has to be true here?
  • Where does that rule or standard come from?
  • What would someone you respect, who sees it differently, say?
  • If you set the standard yourself, what would it be?
  • What situation this month would stretch you to act from that bigger view?
Going further
  • What do you need from others to feel you’re doing well?
  • What would change if you didn’t need that?
  • What’s a view you used to hold that you’ve now outgrown?
  • How would the leader you’re becoming handle this?
  • What feels risky about seeing it differently?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S3.6Fixed-mindset identity claims “That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”
What is happening “That’s just how I am”, “I’m not a people person”Coach move Historicize the belief. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity
In the room
“That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”
What’s underneath
Do not debate personality. Open it as a story / strategy that once helped. Historicize. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity.
Avoid here
Trait arguments. Typology rabbit holes.
Example
“Not a people person” started after a public humiliation at 24. Already untrue with their craft peers. 10% stretch: one curious question in the staff meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5153435
S4.12External locus dressed as realism “That’s just corporate life.”
What is happening “That’s just corporate life”Coach move Test which constraints are real, which are assumed
In the room
“That’s just corporate life.”
What’s underneath
Realism and resignation can sound identical. Test written rule vs cultural habit vs prediction.
Avoid here
Naive “just be courageous” that ignores real power.
Example
“No one pushes back on dates.” Not written. Two people have. 10%: one tradeoff sentence this Friday.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5101634
S6.5Old identity dying (expert → leader, founder → CEO) Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What is happening Grief + incompetence of the new skinCoach move Name the identity funeral and the apprenticeship
In the room
Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What’s underneath
They need rites of passage, not only skills. Name the funeral and the apprenticeship. Newness is not incompetence.
Avoid here
Tool-only manager training.
Example
Founder still in every product thread. Funeral: “I am no longer the best doer in the room.” Apprenticeship: one thread they sponsor only. Old identity contributes taste, not keystrokes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods116233435
S7.17New leader / first-time manager Still doing the old job. Conflict-shy.
What is happening Still doing the old job, conflict-shyCoach move Role contract, let-go list, first conversations
In the room
Still doing the old job. Conflict-shy.
What’s underneath
Do not only teach tools. Shift identity. Role contract. Let-go list. First conversations.
Avoid here
Toolkits without identity funeral.
Example
Still the best analyst on the team. Stop-doing: last-pass on every model. First conversation: who owns the last-pass now.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13435
S7.18Expert becoming manager Still the smartest doer in the room.
What is happening Still the smartest doer in the roomCoach move From answers to questions. Develop others
In the room
Still the smartest doer in the room.
What’s underneath
Expertise is an asset that can become a trap. From answers to questions. Develop others.
Avoid here
“Stop being so smart.”
Example
They answer in 8 seconds. Replace with one question in the design review. Team starts thinking in the room.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2334
S9.4Coaching isn’t working Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What is happening Sessions repeat without progress; frustration on one or both sidesCoach move Name it openly; review goals, fit and approach together
In the room
Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What’s underneath
Lack of progress is information. The topic, the fit, the timing or the method may be wrong. Naming it openly is better than carrying on politely.
Avoid here
Blaming the client. Pretending it’s fine. Trying harder with the same approach.
Example
After six sessions, nothing has changed. The coach names it and asks what isn’t working. The client admits the real topic is leaving, not leadership.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293439

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Labelling the client by developmental stage.
  • Teaching theory instead of asking questions.
  • Expecting quick shifts in what is slow development.
  • Pushing a bigger perspective before the client feels safe.

10Client traps

  • Using the theory to feel advanced rather than to change.
  • Agreeing in principle but returning to old rules under pressure.
  • Seeking the coach’s approval as the new external standard.

Three worked problems

1

Expert turned manager. Client’s rule: “a good leader always has the answer.” Seeing it as an inherited rule lets them try a new one: “a good leader helps the team find the answer.” Stretch: run one problem-solving meeting without offering a solution.

2

Approval-driven high performer. Coach asks what they need from their boss to feel they did well. Naming that dependency makes it visible. Experiment: rate their own work before asking for feedback.

3

“That’s just how banking works.” Coach invites views from three other industries. The client sees their rule as one option among several and redesigns one process.

Where it comes from

Adult development theory, especially Robert Kegan’s subject–object idea (In Over Our Heads), and vertical development approaches.

My notes

Family 5 of 5 · Methods 35–43

Land It

Has enough opened that it must become durable?

This family is for the point in a session where enough has genuinely opened up that it needs to become durable — an insight, an identity shift, or a concrete commitment that survives past the end of the hour.

35
Land It family

Who Would You Need to Be?

Core move: Identity-in-action, paired with one act
5 options9 questions23 situations

1What it really is

Shifting from technique-talk to identity-in-action, always paired with one concrete act belonging to that identity.

Rather than asking “what should I do?”, this method asks “who would I need to be to do this?” It moves the conversation from techniques to identity: the values, beliefs and sense of self that would make the action natural. In NLP, this connects to Robert Dilts’ logical levels, which suggest that change at the level of identity can make change at the level of behaviour much easier. The identity is always linked to a specific action that the client can take soon.

It sounds like: “Who would you need to be to have that conversation with ease?”, followed by “What would that person do first, this week?” It is not about pretending to be someone else, and it isn’t only a feel-good exercise; without a concrete action it doesn’t count. It works best at the end of a session, when the client is ready to commit. It has worked when the client describes a believable identity in their own words and links it to one observable act they will do before the next session.

4How it works, deeply

This method is functionally the “Land It” version of Future-Self (Method 23) — same mechanism, but deployed specifically at the moment of commitment rather than during exploration. The discipline is identical: never let identity-talk stay purely theatrical. It must always be paired with exactly one observable act this week that belongs to the identity being described.

Dilts’ logical levels describe layers of experience: environment, behaviour, capabilities, beliefs and values, identity, and a sense of purpose beyond the self. Change at a higher level tends to ripple down to the levels beneath it. When a client shifts how they see themselves, new beliefs, skills and behaviours follow more easily, because they now fit the person the client believes they are. Trying to change behaviour without addressing identity often leads to effort that feels forced and doesn’t last.

Research on identity-based motivation supports a similar idea: people are more likely to act when an action feels congruent with who they are. Asking “who would you need to be?” invites the client to borrow an identity they find inspiring, and the single concrete action anchors it in reality. Each time the client carries out that action, they create evidence that supports the new identity. Over repeated cycles, identity and behaviour reinforce each other, producing change that feels natural rather than imposed.

Quick card

Reach for it when
They have tactics but the identity has not moved
The move
Shift from technique to identity-in-action
Watch
Identity work without a Tuesday act stays theatre.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Who would you need to be to handle this?
  2. If you were already that person, how would you walk into the room?
  3. What would need to change for you to become that person?
  4. What is one act this week that belongs to that identity?

2The client’s context

The client already has tactics available, but identity hasn’t moved to match — common in new roles, visibility challenges, hard conversations ahead, or difficulty owning a recent win.

3The coach’s options

1Identity for a specific conversation.
2Identity for a role transition.
3Identity beyond output — separating self-worth from productivity.
4Identity that can receive credit gracefully.
5Identity that can disappoint someone without collapsing.
Variation from NLPLogical levels walk

Robert Dilts’ logical levels, based on the work of Gregory Bateson, look at a goal on six levels. Change at a higher level usually ripples down, and a mismatch between levels often shows where someone is stuck. (These are different from this guide’s six levels, Story to Experiment, which describe the level of the conversation.)

  1. Environment — Where and when will this happen? Who will be around?
  2. Behaviour — What will you actually be doing?
  3. Capabilities — What skills and strategies will you use?
  4. Beliefs and values — What do you believe that makes this possible and worth it?
  5. Identity — Who are you, when you do this?
  6. Purpose — What bigger thing, or whom, is this in service of?

Walk up the levels one at a time, often stepping along markers on the floor. At the top, pause, then walk back down, carrying what you found at the higher levels into each lower one.

Watch: Keep it at walking pace. Rushing up to identity and purpose skips the concrete levels that make it real.

Robert Dilts, drawing on Gregory Bateson. NLP tools are widely used in coaching, but research support for NLP’s core claims is limited. Treat this as a practical tool to test, not proven science. See also Other NLP techniques.

5Where it gets stuck

It turns into theatre — beautiful identity language with no connection to next Tuesday.

6How to move it forward

Ask directly: “If you were already that person, how would you walk into the room?” Land exactly one act this week.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Who would you need to be to handle this?
  • If you were already that person, how would you walk into the room?
  • What would need to change for you to become that person?
  • What is one act this week that belongs to that identity?
Going further
  • What would that person wear, physically stand like, or sound like?
  • What would that person say no to, that you currently say yes to?
  • If you already were that person for just one hour tomorrow, which hour would you choose?
  • What’s the smallest visible sign that you’ve already started becoming them?
  • Who already sees you as that person, even if you don’t yet?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.4Vague “Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.
What is happening “Things feel off”, “leadership”, “balance” with no pictureCoach move Scaling / “What would we see if we filmed it?”
In the room
“Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.
What’s underneath
Abstraction protects. As long as the topic stays a noun with no scene, no one can fail at it and no one can finish it. Advanced coaching operationalizes: values, identities, and moods become behavior in a room at a time of day.
Avoid here
Coaching the slogan. More values language. Big identity work with no scene. Generating a 10-step “confidence plan.”
Example
“I just need more balance.” Film: current Tuesday is Slack at 21:40. +1 is laptop closed at 19:00 two nights, calendar invite to themselves. Balance stops being a personality project.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6222835
S1.7Ready to move Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what…
What is happening Forward energy, asks for next step, new language already appearingCoach move Options, experiments, who they would need to be
In the room
Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what I need to do is…”
What’s underneath
Continued exploration at this point is often the coach’s need for thoroughness. Readiness is perishable. Land while the nervous system is still organized toward action.
Avoid here
More expand. Miracle question. Clean language archaeology. Another reframe “to be sure.”
Example
After naming “I have been managing their mood,” client is already drafting a sentence. Coach skips another why. One dated conversation Friday. Success = it happened.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods435363738
S1.8Story-looping / circling the same plot Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and…
What is happening Repeats events, more detail, no new insight, time passingCoach move Stop the plot. Move to meaning, pattern, or wanted future
In the room
Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and they would match.
What’s underneath
More plot rarely creates change. Repetition usually means the intervention is at the wrong level — or the loop is protecting them from an act, a feeling, or an ending.
Avoid here
Expand-for-more-detail. Clean language on plot nouns. Sympathy that invites another lap.
Example
Third retelling of a board ambush. Chapter title: “I keep going in without a sponsor.” Level change: one pre-wire this week, or park the topic.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14213539
S1.12Bringing someone else’s agenda “My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.
What is happening “My boss said I should…”, partner booked them, HR sent themCoach move Separate assigned topic from their topic. Restore ownership
In the room
“My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.
What’s underneath
Coaching requires authorship. You can work the overlap between organizational want and client want. You cannot become the organization’s enforcer and still be their coach.
Avoid here
Running the company’s curriculum. Ignoring the assigned topic entirely without naming the fork (can blow up sponsorship). Advice on how to “perform presence.”
Example
Assigned: executive presence. Owned: credit stolen by a peer. Overlap: one visible moment Thursday. Both agendas honored; neither colonizes the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods163540
S1.14First time saying it out loud Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What is happening Hesitation, “this may sound silly”, long pause before the sentenceCoach move Safety first. Witness. Do not rush to fix or reframe
In the room
Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What’s underneath
Being heard is the intervention. Insight can wait. A reframe here is a small violence: it teaches them that this room, too, will rush to tidy what they just risked.
Avoid here
Immediate reframe, options, miracle, challenge.
Example
“I think I want to leave the field.” Coach does not build an exit plan. First work: they hear themselves. Then they choose hold vs move.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17133538
S1.20Wanting a diagnosis or label “What’s wrong with me?” “Am I a bad leader?” They want a verdict they can either collapse under or fight.
What is happening “What’s wrong with me?”, “Am I a bad leader?”Coach move Stay descriptive, not diagnostic. Separate identity from pattern
In the room
“What’s wrong with me?” “Am I a bad leader?” They want a verdict they can either collapse under or fight.
What’s underneath
Labels shrink possibility. Coaching describes patterns and choices. Diagnosis-hunger is often a wish for the uncertainty to end.
Avoid here
Informal diagnosis (“you’re a classic imposter”). Therapy-speak beyond contract. Reassurance only.
Example
“Am I an alcoholic leader or just stressed?” Coach stays in scope: the Friday snap pattern, sleep, what they want instead. Flag other support if clinical. No verdict from the coaching chair.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods51335
S2.7Afraid of being seen / visibility anxiety Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speaking. Over-prepares then ducks.
What is happening Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speakingCoach move Future-self who can be seen. Tiny exposure. Identity vs skill
In the room
Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speaking. Over-prepares then ducks.
What’s underneath
Often a belonging story, not a skills gap. Identity vs skill. Tiny exposure beats a forced keynote. Hiding has a protective job and a cost.
Avoid here
“Just believe in yourself.” Giant first stage. Listing achievements only (imposter cousin).
Example
Avoids speaking in the ops forum. Risk: being found ordinary. Tiny exposure: 60 seconds on one metric, ally in the room. Not the offsite keynote.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods152335
S2.9Hopeful / lit up for the first time Energy rise. New language. Smile. Lean-in.
What is happening Energy rise, new language, smile, leaning inCoach move Harvest it. Make it specific. Lock a small embodiment
In the room
Energy rise. New language. Smile. Lean-in.
What’s underneath
Hope is fragile in its first minutes and dies under premature scrutiny. Harvest. Make specific. Lock a small embodiment. Do not immediately stress-test.
Avoid here
Pre-mortem. “But what if.” More analysis to make it robust.
Example
First genuine “I could try for the role.” Harvest. Body: lift in chest. Keep-alive: tell one safe person. No SWOT of the application today.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods63538
S2.14Envious / comparing Their title, their ease, social proof. Then self-attack for being envious.
What is happening Their title, their ease, social proofCoach move Use envy as a compass: what does it point to that they want?
In the room
Their title, their ease, social proof. Then self-attack for being envious.
What’s underneath
Shame about envy hides useful data. Envy is a compass: it points to a want. Work the want, not the character trial.
Avoid here
Moralizing. Imitation plan that copies their life.
Example
Envy of a peer’s keynote ease. Want: to be at ease being seen. Their version: a 60-second forum speak, not that peer’s brand.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods35
S3.6Fixed-mindset identity claims “That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”
What is happening “That’s just how I am”, “I’m not a people person”Coach move Historicize the belief. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity
In the room
“That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”
What’s underneath
Do not debate personality. Open it as a story / strategy that once helped. Historicize. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity.
Avoid here
Trait arguments. Typology rabbit holes.
Example
“Not a people person” started after a public humiliation at 24. Already untrue with their craft peers. 10% stretch: one curious question in the staff meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5153435
S3.8Simplifying too fast / slogans “I just need to be more confident.” Fluent motto, no scene.
What is happening “I just need to be more confident”Coach move Unpack the slogan into situations, skills, beliefs
In the room
“I just need to be more confident.” Fluent motto, no scene.
What’s underneath
Opposite of S3.7. Slogans feel like progress and stall work. Unpack into situation, skill, belief, first scene.
Avoid here
Better slogans. Affirmations.
Example
Confidence → the 3pm vendor call, one ask for a date. Scene, not motto.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods635
S3.14Past-as-prison Origin story explains and excuses everything now.
What is happening Origin story explains and excuses everything nowCoach move Honor origin. Ask what the adult can choose now
In the room
Origin story explains and excuses everything now.
What’s underneath
Honor origin. Do not do archaeology for its own sake in performance coaching. Ask what the adult can choose now.
Avoid here
Deep childhood excavation beyond scope and contract.
Example
Humiliation at 24 explains freeze. Also true today: they run a 40-person org. Adult choice: ally in the room. History honored, not in the driver’s seat.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12252735
S4.2Hero / I must fix everyone Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.
What is happening Over-functioning, no delegation, exhaustion prideCoach move Return work to its owner. Cost of heroics. Team as system
In the room
Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.
What’s underneath
Heroics are often rewarded. Name the price — to them and to the people who never get to carry their own work.
Avoid here
Time-management tips that leave the identity intact.
Example
Does the report’s stakeholder management. Cost: report stays junior, hero is exhausted. Week experiment: they send their own update. Standard reaches them.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16193540
S5.1Insight without behavior change Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What is happening Beautiful ahas, same week as last monthCoach move Close the knowing-doing gap. Smaller, scheduled, observable acts
In the room
Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What’s underneath
Knowing-doing gap. More insight can become another hiding place. Integration is a scheduled act, not a better sentence.
Avoid here
Another brilliant why.
Example
Third “I need to stop rescuing.” Integration: one update they do not rewrite this week. Insight without that act is décor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1735383943
S5.7Starts strong then fades Week-1 hero, week-3 ghost.
What is happening Week-1 hero, week-3 ghostCoach move Design environment, identity, review rhythm — not willpower
In the room
Week-1 hero, week-3 ghost.
What’s underneath
Motivation is a bad operating system. Design beats mood: environment, identity, review rhythm.
Avoid here
More inspiration. Bigger goals.
Example
Fade begins Sunday night when calendar fills. Design: Friday 15-minute review locked with a peer. Identity: “person who reviews,” not “person who starts.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1735
S5.16Need to have a difficult conversation Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What is happening Avoids the meeting, writes unsent emailsCoach move Purpose, request, opening line, body regulation, rehearsal
In the room
Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What’s underneath
Role-play beats more theory. Purpose, request, first sentence, body, live practice.
Avoid here
Longer essays. More theory of crucial conversations.
Example
Unsent prosecution email. Purpose: fewer surprises. First sentence practiced. Heat in chest named. Meeting request sent same day.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods731353740
S6.5Old identity dying (expert → leader, founder → CEO) Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What is happening Grief + incompetence of the new skinCoach move Name the identity funeral and the apprenticeship
In the room
Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.
What’s underneath
They need rites of passage, not only skills. Name the funeral and the apprenticeship. Newness is not incompetence.
Avoid here
Tool-only manager training.
Example
Founder still in every product thread. Funeral: “I am no longer the best doer in the room.” Apprenticeship: one thread they sponsor only. Old identity contributes taste, not keystrokes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods116233435
S7.5Conflict-seeking / always the fight Identity as the one who says it.
What is happening Identity as the one who says itCoach move Discern which fights matter. Tone vs content
In the room
Identity as the one who says it.
What’s underneath
Do not shame their courage. Aim it. Which fights matter. Tone vs content. Winning with the relationship intact.
Avoid here
Making them “nice.”
Example
Fights every process. Two that matter: safety and a false date. Retire the rest. Courage aimed.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods122535
S7.8Can’t receive help / praise / credit Deflects. Immediately gives it away.
What is happening Deflects, immediately gives it awayCoach move Practice receiving as a skill. 3-second pause
In the room
Deflects. Immediately gives it away.
What’s underneath
Receiving is a leadership skill. 3-second pause. Identity that would have to update.
Avoid here
More compliments to overpower deflection.
Example
Credit arrives; body moves it on in one second. Practice three seconds. Receiving gives the giver the dignity of having given.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3538
S7.14Need to give hard feedback Writes the speech. Never delivers.
What is happening Writes the speech, never deliversCoach move One behavior, one impact, intention, ask. Rehearse
In the room
Writes the speech. Never delivers.
What’s underneath
Rehearse out loud. Written essays rarely get spoken. One behavior, one impact, intention, ask.
Avoid here
Longer essays.
Example
Speech is four pages. One minute: late updates, sponsor blindsided, intention to set them up to win, ask for 24-hour pre-alert.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3537
S7.17New leader / first-time manager Still doing the old job. Conflict-shy.
What is happening Still doing the old job, conflict-shyCoach move Role contract, let-go list, first conversations
In the room
Still doing the old job. Conflict-shy.
What’s underneath
Do not only teach tools. Shift identity. Role contract. Let-go list. First conversations.
Avoid here
Toolkits without identity funeral.
Example
Still the best analyst on the team. Stop-doing: last-pass on every model. First conversation: who owns the last-pass now.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13435
S7.32Job search / in-between identity Lost title. Narrative wobble.
What is happening Lost title, narrative wobbleCoach move Story of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications
In the room
Lost title. Narrative wobble.
What’s underneath
The search is a meaning project as well as a market project. Story of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications.
Avoid here
Only job-search tactics. Only identity fog with no market move.
Example
Ex-title wobble. Alive story: they design conditions for teams to decide. Experiment: two conversations in that language, not 40 generic applications. Chapter change, not apology.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3935
S9.6Ending the engagement well Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.
What is happening Final session or sessions of an engagementCoach move Harvest learning; celebrate progress; plan how to continue without the coach
In the room
Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.
What’s underneath
Endings matter. A good ending helps the client own their progress, plan how to keep it going and leave with confidence rather than dependency.
Avoid here
Ending abruptly. Adding new topics at the last minute. Fostering dependency.
Example
In the last session, the client reviews their goals, names three key learnings, and writes a letter from their future self to keep.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods35384143

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Treating identity work as branding exercise rather than genuine shift.
  • Skipping the embodiment step and staying purely conceptual.

10Client traps

  • Using the new identity label as a weapon of self-attack (“I should already be that”).

Three worked problems

1

Must give hard feedback. Identity: a clear adult, not a parent or a prosecutor. Act: one behavior, one impact, one ask, rehearsed out loud beforehand.

2

Cannot receive praise. Identity: someone who can let credit land for three full seconds before deflecting. Act: practice that pause once this week.

3

Worth tied entirely to productivity. Identity for when the dashboard is dark. Act: 24 hours with no production at all, then noticing who they are underneath the output.

Where it comes from

Related to identity-based approaches to change, including Robert Dilts’ logical levels.

My notes

36
Land It family

Generate Options Then One Experiment

Core move: Widen choices; converge on one owned test
5 options10 questions9 situations

1What it really is

Widening the field of choices — more than two, deliberately including unwise ones — then converging on exactly one owned, dated, observable test. The experiment must belong to the client; mere compliance is not commitment.

This method has two phases. First, the client widens their options, deliberately including unusual or even unwise ones, because those often reveal hidden possibilities. Dilts’ Disney strategy can help here: dreaming freely first, then being realistic about how, and only then being critical. Then the client narrows down to one specific experiment: something small, owned, observable, and with a date attached, that they genuinely want to try.

It sounds like: “What are all the things you could do, including the crazy ones?”, “Which of these are you actually willing to try?”, and “What exactly will you do, and by when?” It is not a full action plan, and the experiment doesn’t have to succeed; whatever happens, the client learns something. It also isn’t a task assigned by the coach. It has worked when the client chooses an experiment with real energy, describes it in their own words, and can say how they will know whether it went well.

4How it works, deeply

The single most important discipline is distinguishing compliance from commitment. A coach can manufacture a tidy-looking plan at the end of a session purely to end on a productive note — but if the client didn’t design it, it won’t survive contact with the following week. The test for readiness is blunt and direct: “Which of these are you actually willing to try?” If the honest answer is none, the coach should name the “not-yet” openly rather than pushing a plan the client has already silently rejected.

Generating many options first protects against a common thinking trap: settling on the first workable idea. Including unwise options lowers the pressure to be sensible and often frees up creative thinking; sometimes a ridiculous idea contains a useful kernel. Dilts’ Disney strategy separates dreaming, planning and critiquing into distinct stages, because mixing them, especially criticising too early, tends to kill new ideas before they are developed.

Narrowing to one experiment makes action manageable. Research on implementation intentions, by Peter Gollwitzer and others, suggests that specifying when, where and how you will act makes follow-through more likely. Framing the action as an experiment also reduces fear of failure, since experiments are expected to produce learning rather than guaranteed success. Because the client chooses the experiment, motivation comes from within, and the results, whatever they are, give real information for the next session.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Exploration has gone far enough; energy turns forward
The move
Widen choices, then one owned, dated, observable test
Watch
The experiment must be theirs. Compliance is not commitment.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What options do you see — give me more than two, including unwise ones?
  2. Which of these are you actually willing to try?
  3. By when, and how will we know it happened?
  4. If it does not go as you hope, what will you do then?

2The client’s context

This method arrives when exploration has gone far enough and energy has genuinely turned forward — the client is ready to move. It also arrives in the opposite state: when the client truly cannot see any options at all.

3The coach’s options

1Invent eight options, including bad ones — deliberately widening past the safe two or three.
2Limit to 2–3 options when the client is instead stuck in analysis paralysis from too many.
3Design a reversible test — lower stakes, easier to commit to.
4Size the experiment — 15 minutes, 7 days, or 30 days.
5Client-designed vs. coach-assigned — the experiment must originate from the client, not be handed down.
Variation from NLPDisney strategy

Three kinds of thinking about a plan, kept separate so each gets its full turn: the Dreamer, the Realist and the Critic. Use three different chairs or spots for the three roles.

  1. Dreamer — If anything were possible, what would you create? What would it look like?
  2. Realist — How would it actually work? What are the first three steps, and who and what would you need?
  3. Critic — What is missing? What could make this fail? (Critique the plan, never the person.)
  4. Cycle — Take the Critic’s points back to the Dreamer and the Realist until the plan holds.

Watch: Keep the Critic out of the Dreamer’s chair. Mixing them is how good ideas die early.

Robert Dilts’ model of how Walt Disney moved between roles. NLP tools are widely used in coaching, but research support for NLP’s core claims is limited. Treat this as a practical tool to test, not proven science. See also Other NLP techniques.

5Where it gets stuck

Generating more options past a certain point actually reduces action rather than helping it. A false plan gets manufactured to end the session looking productive. Homework gets accepted only to please the coach, not because the client actually intends to do it.

6How to move it forward

Ask directly: “Which of these are you actually willing to try?” If none, name the “not-yet” honestly. Shrink the size of the experiment. Or ask what they’d do if the coach never followed up on it again.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What options do you see — give me more than two, including unwise ones?
  • Which of these are you actually willing to try?
  • By when, and how will we know it happened?
  • If it does not go as you hope, what will you do then?
  • What would you do if you were not trying to be a good client?
Going further
  • What’s the option you’re embarrassed to say out loud?
  • If money and other people’s opinions weren’t a factor, what would you choose?
  • What’s the smallest possible version of the boldest option?
  • What would make this experiment feel like it was designed by you, not for you?
  • If you had to bet money on which option you’ll actually do, which would you bet on?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.7Ready to move Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what…
What is happening Forward energy, asks for next step, new language already appearingCoach move Options, experiments, who they would need to be
In the room
Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what I need to do is…”
What’s underneath
Continued exploration at this point is often the coach’s need for thoroughness. Readiness is perishable. Land while the nervous system is still organized toward action.
Avoid here
More expand. Miracle question. Clean language archaeology. Another reframe “to be sure.”
Example
After naming “I have been managing their mood,” client is already drafting a sentence. Coach skips another why. One dated conversation Friday. Success = it happened.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods435363738
S5.10Compliance without buy-in Will do the homework to please you.
What is happening Will do the homework to please youCoach move Rebuild choice. They design the experiment or there is none
In the room
Will do the homework to please you.
What’s underneath
Compliant clients create empty sessions. They design the experiment or there is none. Your approval cannot be the engine.
Avoid here
More assigned homework.
Example
They complete every worksheet. None touch the leave-question. New rule: they design or we don’t assign.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods836
S5.11Resistance to action / “I’ll think about it” Soft close. No date. No witness.
What is happening Soft close, no date, no witnessCoach move Get specific or name the no. Explore the cost of thinking-about-it
In the room
Soft close. No date. No witness.
What’s underneath
A vague maybe is usually a hidden no. Get specific or name the no. Cost of thinking-about-it.
Avoid here
Fake deadline you invent.
Example
“I’ll think about the conversation with her.” In their life that means never. Honest not-yet: after Thursday’s results, decide Friday, tell you next session.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods836
S5.12Missed the last commitment Didn’t do it. Shame or shrug.
What is happening Didn’t do it, shame or shrugCoach move No prosecution. Learning review. Redesign, don’t double the load
In the room
Didn’t do it. Shame or shrug.
What’s underneath
No prosecution. Was it wrong-sized or wrong-owned? Redesign; don’t double the load. Shame resets the same cycle.
Avoid here
Pep plus a bigger task.
Example
Missed the 90-minute deep work. Wrong-sized for a travel week. Honest next: 15 minutes at the gate, or no commitment this week.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods36
S6.25Neurodivergence shaping how they work (ADHD, autism, dyslexia) Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted fro…
What is happening Work set up for different brains; strong in some areas, worn out in othersCoach move Spot strengths; design the environment and adjustments around how they work best
In the room
Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted from masking.
What’s underneath
The client’s mind works differently, not wrongly. Problems often come from a poor fit between how they work best and how the job is set up. Coaching works on fit, strengths and adjustments, not on “fixing” the person. Diagnosis is not the coach’s role.
Avoid here
Diagnosing or suggesting a diagnosis. Treating it as a confidence problem. Generic productivity advice.
Example
A product manager with ADHD loses track of long meetings. Coach helps design shorter meetings with written agendas, and they ask for this as a reasonable adjustment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods69163640
S6.26Chronic illness or health limits reshaping work (including menopause) Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What is happening Health limits energy or capacity; fear of being judged as unreliableCoach move Sort control; redesign work around real limits; plan the conversations
In the room
Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What’s underneath
Health changes the resources available, not the person’s value. The coaching challenge is redesigning work around real limits, communicating needs, and dealing with the identity hit. Medical questions belong with medical professionals.
Avoid here
Medical advice. Pushing performance goals as if health is unchanged. Treating it as purely a mindset issue.
Example
A senior lawyer going through menopause has poor sleep and brain fog. Coach helps sort what’s in her control, plan demanding work for her best hours, and prepare a conversation with HR.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods416323640
S7.34Being made redundant Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What is happening Role ended by the organisation; shock, loss and practical pressureCoach move Absorb the shock first; then rebuild the value story; then design next steps
In the room
Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.
What’s underneath
Redundancy is a loss of role, income, routine and identity, often at once, and usually not personal. The client needs first to absorb the shock, then to rebuild a story of their value and design practical next steps.
Avoid here
Jumping straight to CV and LinkedIn. Silver-lining talk. Ignoring finances.
Example
A marketing director is told her role is cut. First session: the shock and the anger. Second: strengths and her story. Third: three experiments in the job market.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5792736
S7.37Role reshaped or threatened by AI and automation Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What is happening Work changing because of AI or automation; uncertainty about the futureCoach move Separate tasks from value; picture two futures; run small experiments
In the room
Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.
What’s underneath
Some tasks will change; the client’s value is rarely only the tasks. Coaching helps separate fact from fear, find which strengths become more valuable, and run experiments with the new tools rather than waiting.
Avoid here
Reassuring that nothing will change. Predicting the future. Pure technical advice.
Example
A copywriter fears AI will replace her. Coach separates tasks from value. She experiments with AI tools for drafts and repositions as a brand strategist.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods29242636
S8.9Coach-pleasing / doing homework for you Looks for a gold star.
What is happening Looks for gold starCoach move Return the work to their life. They pick the experiment
In the room
Looks for a gold star.
What’s underneath
Your approval cannot be the engine. Return the work to their life. They pick the experiment.
Avoid here
Gold stars.
Example
Worksheets complete; leave-question untouched. New contract: experiments they would do if you disappeared.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods36

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Manufacturing a plan simply because the session clock is running out.
  • Applauding motion that is really avoidance dressed up as action.
  • Doubling the size of an assignment after a client misses a previous commitment.

10Client traps

  • Compliance rather than genuine ownership.
  • Choosing only a giant, all-or-nothing leap.
  • Vague “I’ll think about it” as a way to avoid committing to anything specific.

Three worked problems

1

Ready-to-move product lead. Options include a messy customer call, a pause, a prototype, and “do nothing for a week.” They choose the customer call by Thursday. Success criterion: the call happened, not that it went perfectly.

2

“There is no way.” Eight options generated, including unwise ones: quit on Slack, hire a ghostwriter, tell the board the date is a lie, pair with a peer, cut scope by 40%. A ninth option emerges: cut scope and tell one stakeholder on Friday. The frozen imagination thaws.

3

Missed last week’s commitment. No prosecution follows. Instead: was it wrong-sized, or wrong-owned? The experiment is redesigned down to a 15-minute start, not a doubled-up assignment.

Where it comes from

Mirrors the Options and Will stages of the GROW model (John Whitmore, Coaching for Performance) and the test-and-learn logic of design thinking.

My notes

37
Land It family

Rehearse the Hard Conversation

Core move: Purpose, first sentence, live practice
5 options10 questions23 situations

1What it really is

Working through purpose, request, first sentence, and body sensation, then practicing live. Role-play beats abstract theory here — keep the rehearsal short and real, not a polished performance.

This method prepares the client for a difficult conversation by working through it in practical steps. First, what is the purpose of the conversation, and what is the specific request? Then, what is the first sentence they will say? Finally, the client says it out loud, and the coach may play the other person so the client can practise responding. Throughout, the coach notices what happens to the client’s voice, breathing and body as they speak.

It sounds like: “What do you want to be true after this conversation?”, “What’s your opening line?”, and “Say it to me as if I were them.” It is not about writing a script for the whole conversation, which rarely survives real life. It also isn’t about rehearsing until it’s perfect; two or three short rounds are usually enough. It has worked when the client can say their first sentence clearly and calmly, and feels ready to have the real conversation within a set time.

4How it works, deeply

The core failure this method is designed against is the gap between writing and speaking. A perfectly worded email or an internally rehearsed speech is not the same skill as saying something out loud, live, in front of another person, under time pressure. Getting the first sentence out loud in the session — and noticing what happens in the body when it’s said — surfaces the real obstacle much faster than more theoretical planning ever could.

Speaking aloud engages different processes from thinking or writing. Under pressure, people tend to fall back on familiar habits, so a conversation that has only been planned in the head is vulnerable to old patterns as soon as emotions rise. Practising out loud, with someone responding, begins to build new habits. Rehearsal also reduces the novelty of the situation, which lowers anxiety when the real conversation comes.

Paying attention to the body during rehearsal reveals where the true difficulty lies. A client may speak confidently until a certain sentence, then their voice drops or their shoulders rise. That moment usually points to a fear, belief or value that needs attention before the real conversation. Clarifying purpose and request first keeps the rehearsal anchored to what matters, so the client can stay on track even if the other person responds unexpectedly.

Quick card

Reach for it when
They need to speak to someone and keep rewriting the email
The move
Purpose, request, first sentence, body, live practice
Watch
Role-play beats more theory. Keep it short and real.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What is the clean purpose of the conversation?
  2. What is the first sentence?
  3. What are you afraid they will feel or do?
  4. Say it out loud as if I am them — then what do you notice?

2The client’s context

The client needs to speak to someone and is instead rewriting an email endlessly, avoiding the meeting, or writing a speech they never intend to actually deliver.

3The coach’s options

1Upward conversation — to a boss or higher authority.
2Peer / credit / territory conversation.
3Direct-report standard and consequence conversation.
4Repair after a trust break.
5Raise / scope / tradeoff sentence — a specific ask with financial or scope stakes.

5Where it gets stuck

More theory accumulates about “crucial conversations” in the abstract. Written essays get produced that will never actually be spoken aloud. A surgical conversation gets opened with only eight minutes left in the session.

6How to move it forward

Get the first sentence out loud, in the room. Notice what happens in the body. Shorten the message. Contract explicitly whether this is a rehearsal hour or purely an understanding hour.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What is the clean purpose of the conversation?
  • What is the first sentence?
  • What are you afraid they will feel or do?
  • Say it out loud as if I am them — then what do you notice?
  • What is the one behavior and one impact?
Going further
  • What’s the shortest version of this request you could make?
  • What tone do you want them to walk away remembering?
  • What would you say if you had exactly thirty seconds?
  • If they push back the way you fear, what’s your one-line response?
  • What do you need to feel steady enough to say this out loud right now?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.7Ready to move Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what…
What is happening Forward energy, asks for next step, new language already appearingCoach move Options, experiments, who they would need to be
In the room
Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what I need to do is…”
What’s underneath
Continued exploration at this point is often the coach’s need for thoroughness. Readiness is perishable. Land while the nervous system is still organized toward action.
Avoid here
More expand. Miracle question. Clean language archaeology. Another reframe “to be sure.”
Example
After naming “I have been managing their mood,” client is already drafting a sentence. Coach skips another why. One dated conversation Friday. Success = it happened.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods435363738
S2.3Angry / blaming / righteous heat Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What is happening Other-focus, injustice language, clenched jawCoach move Validate the heat, then separate fact / interpretation / want
In the room
Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What’s underneath
Anger is often a protector of dignity, boundary, or grief. Do not moralize it; do not join the case. Sequence: validate heat → separate fact / interpretation / want → find the clean request.
Avoid here
Immediate perspective-take (“have you considered their side”) — feels like betrayal. Cheerful reframe.
Example
Rage at a peer who “stole” a project. Anger protecting: not being erasable. Clean request: shared ownership memo + a conversation. Prosecution energy drops when dignity has a next act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71011193740
S2.11Embarrassed after a public miss Replay of the meeting. Heat in face. Reputation fear.
What is happening Replay of meeting, heat in face, reputation fearCoach move Normalize the human moment. Extract one learning. Design repair if needed
In the room
Replay of the meeting. Heat in face. Reputation fear.
What’s underneath
Embarrassment wants completion of a cycle: one learning, repair if needed, next showing. Minimizing leaves the loop running at 1am.
Avoid here
“Everyone forgets.” Ten-point improvement plan (punishment).
Example
Wrong figure in a board pack. Feared story: “sloppy.” Repair they respect: corrected note today + one process change. Cycle completes; 1am court adjourns.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods37
S2.13Resentful / bitter Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.
What is happening Kept score, “after all I did”, tightnessCoach move Find the unmet contract. Turn resentment into a request or a boundary
In the room
Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.
What’s underneath
Resentment is often an unmet contract that was never spoken. Venting without a request keeps them stuck. Turn into a request or a boundary — or a clean decision to stop waiting.
Avoid here
More venting as the whole method. Moral lecture about gratitude.
Example
Covered a peer’s region for a year. Never agreed; never asked. Clean ask or stop covering. Bitterness was unpaid invoice plus silence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1243740
S3.3Mind-reading others “They think I’m…” No data.
What is happening “They think I’m…”, no dataCoach move Separate observation from story. What was actually said or done
In the room
“They think I’m…” No data.
What’s underneath
Mind-reading is an attempt to stay safe without risking contact. Invite a clean data-ask rather than better speculation.
Avoid here
Helping them build a richer theory of the other mind.
Example
Short email from a director = “she thinks I’m weak.” Seen: four words, sent from a phone at 22:10. Data-ask: “What do you need from me on this?”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods37
S4.3Rescuer of the team / parent in the workplace Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.
What is happening Protects people from consequence, buffers the bossCoach move Adult-adult. Boundaries. Development vs rescue
In the room
Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.
What’s underneath
Rescue can be love and control at once. Development vs rescue. Let the standard reach them.
Avoid here
Softness with no standard.
Example
Softens every message from the SVP. Team never feels the real requirement. Fear: they will break. Adult: pass the standard, stay available.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16193740
S4.8Decision already made but not owned Energy is done. Words still “considering.”
What is happening Energy is done, words still “considering”Coach move Name it. Help them admit the choice and plan the conversation
In the room
Energy is done. Words still “considering.”
What’s underneath
Thinking can be a delay of the announcement. Help them admit the choice and plan the conversation.
Avoid here
More pros/cons.
Example
Energy dead on staying. Words: “exploring options.” Naming: they have left internally. Next: sentence to the sponsor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods37
S4.11Over-owning other people’s emotions I made them upset. I must fix their feeling.
What is happening I made them upset, I must fix their feelingCoach move Return their feelings to them. Clean impact vs imagined impact
In the room
I made them upset. I must fix their feeling.
What’s underneath
Empathy without boundary becomes fusion. Clean impact vs imagined impact. Let them have their reaction.
Avoid here
Scripts for managing the other person’s inner life.
Example
Gave fair feedback; colleague cried. Clean: check they understood and are resourced. Extra: rewriting the feedback into mush. Respect includes their reaction.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3740
S5.16Need to have a difficult conversation Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What is happening Avoids the meeting, writes unsent emailsCoach move Purpose, request, opening line, body regulation, rehearsal
In the room
Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What’s underneath
Role-play beats more theory. Purpose, request, first sentence, body, live practice.
Avoid here
Longer essays. More theory of crucial conversations.
Example
Unsent prosecution email. Purpose: fewer surprises. First sentence practiced. Heat in chest named. Meeting request sent same day.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods731353740
S7.1Conflict with a boss Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.
What is happening Walking on eggs, rage, mind-readingCoach move Intent/impact, request, manage-up map, power reality
In the room
Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.
What’s underneath
Work inside power reality without disappearing. Intent/impact, request, manage-up map. Do not coach rebellion they will not choose — or submission they will resent.
Avoid here
Courage speeches that ignore power. Joining the prosecution.
Example
Boss optimizes for no surprises, not for innovation. Smallest conversation: risk-flag cadence. Power named; voice not erased.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods10193740
S7.2Conflict with a peer Territory, credit, style clash.
What is happening Territory, credit, style clashCoach move Shared purpose, clean requests, third-side view
In the room
Territory, credit, style clash.
What’s underneath
Often unstated score-keeping. Shared purpose. Clean requests. Third-side view.
Avoid here
Winning strategy only.
Example
Credit war. Score: last year’s launch. Shared purpose: this quarter’s customer. Request: names on the memo. Score named so it stops driving.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods111937
S7.3Difficult direct report Avoidance or over-control.
What is happening Avoidance or over-controlCoach move Clear standard, feedback, consequence, development stance
In the room
Avoidance or over-control.
What’s underneath
Caring is not the same as being clear. Standard, feedback, consequence, development stance.
Avoid here
More empathy without a standard. PIP talk as first move when the standard was never said.
Example
Late stakeholder updates. Standard never said plainly. First: say it. Then consequence if needed. Not a sudden PIP.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods637
S7.4Conflict-avoidant Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.
What is happening Keeps peace, stores residue, surprise explosions laterCoach move Micro-truths. Body first. 2-minute version of the conversation
In the room
Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.
What’s underneath
Teach titrated honesty, not a personality transplant. Body first. 2-minute version.
Avoid here
“Have the big fight.”
Example
Swallows “this date is fiction.” Body: swallow reflex. 2-minute version to the PM this week. Titration.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7313237
S7.7Can’t ask for help Solo hero. Shame about need.
What is happening Solo hero, shame about needCoach move Normalize interdependence. Script the ask. Start small
In the room
Solo hero. Shame about need.
What’s underneath
Help-refusal can look like strength and cost the system. Normalize interdependence. Smallest clean ask.
Avoid here
Lecture on teamwork.
Example
Proving they are not a burden. Smallest ask: a peer reviews the deck for 15 minutes. Dangerous and doable.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods37
S7.9Trust broken — they broke it or it was broken Repair vs rumination vs exit.
What is happening Repair vs rumination vs exitCoach move Repair conversation, amends, new agreement, or clean ending
In the room
Repair vs rumination vs exit.
What’s underneath
Not everything is repairable. Don’t force it. Repair conversation, amends, new agreement, or clean ending.
Avoid here
Forgiveness slogans. Endless rumination.
Example
Peer leaked a draft. Repair would require an account and a new handling agreement. They would know in 30 days of behavior, not apology poetry. If not, clean ending of that channel.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods37
S7.11Managing up poorly Surprises the boss, or hides.
What is happening Surprises the boss, or hidesCoach move Boss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics
In the room
Surprises the boss, or hides.
What’s underneath
Managing up is service, not sucking up. Boss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics.
Avoid here
“Be more authentic” as the whole play.
Example
They optimize for craft; boss optimizes for no Friday surprises. Cadence: Thursday risk note. Service, not surrender.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods63742
S7.12Friendship or dual relationship at work Blurred lines. Leftover personal.
What is happening Blurred lines, leftover personalCoach move Name the dual hats. Separate roles in the conversation
In the room
Blurred lines. Leftover personal.
What’s underneath
Denial of the dual relationship creates mess. Name the hats. Separate roles in the conversation.
Avoid here
Pretending there is one relationship.
Example
Friend-report late on updates. Role hat: standard. Kind-and-clean: name the dual hats out loud and set the work agreement.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3337
S7.13Feeling unseen / credit stolen Heat + helplessness.
What is happening Heat + helplessnessCoach move Visibility design, documentation, allies, direct conversation
In the room
Heat + helplessness.
What’s underneath
Victim-only or aggression-only both usually fail. Visibility design, documentation, allies, direct conversation.
Avoid here
Only rumination or only war.
Example
Section landed in a peer’s deck. Clean: follow-up note with the original artifact copied to the sponsor. Ally already knows. Not a war; not silence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3742
S7.14Need to give hard feedback Writes the speech. Never delivers.
What is happening Writes the speech, never deliversCoach move One behavior, one impact, intention, ask. Rehearse
In the room
Writes the speech. Never delivers.
What’s underneath
Rehearse out loud. Written essays rarely get spoken. One behavior, one impact, intention, ask.
Avoid here
Longer essays.
Example
Speech is four pages. One minute: late updates, sponsor blindsided, intention to set them up to win, ask for 24-hour pre-alert.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3537
S7.29High-stakes event coming (board, keynote, review) Performance anxiety + preparation swirl.
What is happening Performance anxiety + preparation swirlCoach move Purpose, audience, state regulation, rehearsal, good-enough structure
In the room
Performance anxiety + preparation swirl.
What’s underneath
More content is rarely the missing piece. Purpose for the audience. State regulation. Rehearsal. Good-enough structure.
Avoid here
More slides.
Example
60 extra slides are anxiety. Audience success: three decisions. Hour before: walk, not tinkering. Structure good enough.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods263237
S7.33Disclosure of bullying, harassment or discrimination Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What is happening Client describes treatment that may be bullying, harassment or discriminationCoach move Listen and believe; map options and support; refer to formal channels
In the room
Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What’s underneath
This is not only a coaching topic. It may need HR, legal, union or other formal support. The coach listens, believes, helps the client understand their options and supports their choice. The coach does not investigate, judge or decide for them, and does not promise confidentiality they can’t keep.
Avoid here
Coaching their “resilience” to tolerate it. Telling them what to do. Investigating or confronting anyone. Minimising.
Example
A junior employee describes repeated comments about her accent from a manager. The coach listens, acknowledges how hard it is, and helps her map formal and informal options and who could support her.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17163740
S7.35Having to make others redundant Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What is happening Must deliver redundancies; torn between the organisation and the peopleCoach move Hold both duties; rehearse clear and humane conversations; care for themselves
In the room
Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.
What’s underneath
The client holds two duties at once: to the organisation and to the people affected. Both are real. Coaching helps them act with integrity and care, prepare the conversations, and look after themselves without pretending the role is easy.
Avoid here
Helping them become cold or detached. Turning it into only a legal script. Ignoring their own wellbeing.
Example
A plant manager must lay off 40 people. Coach helps him rehearse a clear, humane opening sentence and plan support for those affected and for himself.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods714183237
S9.3Three-way meeting with client and sponsor Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What is happening Formal alignment or review meeting with sponsor presentCoach move Prepare the client to lead; facilitate goals and observable signs of change
In the room
Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What’s underneath
Three-way meetings align goals and show progress. The client should lead, the coach facilitates, and the sponsor gives perspective. Preparation matters.
Avoid here
Coach speaking for the client. Revealing session content. Letting the sponsor dominate.
Example
Before the meeting, the coach helps the client rehearse what to share. In the meeting, the client presents goals, and the boss shares what they would notice changing.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16263742

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Writing the client’s script for them.
  • Over-rehearsing to the point of stiffness rather than authenticity.
  • Skipping any regulation work needed before the rehearsal begins.

10Client traps

  • Waiting to “feel ready” before ever attempting the conversation.
  • Confusing a prepared speech with an actual request.

Three worked problems

1

Unsent email to a boss who surprises them. Purpose: fewer surprises, shared risk flags. First sentence: “I want a cadence that means you are never ambushed.” Body: heat in the chest. The speech is shortened. The meeting request is sent the same day.

2

Hard feedback to a friend-report. Dual hats are named first. Only the role-hat is rehearsed. One behavior (late stakeholder updates), one impact (you get blindsided), one ask (24-hour pre-alert).

3

Compensation conversation. The number is spoken out loud in session first. What happens: the voice shrinks. Practiced twice. A walk-away point is defined so the ask becomes a request, not a plea.

Where it comes from

Behavioural rehearsal and role-play, used across coaching, training and cognitive-behavioural approaches.

My notes

38
Land It family

Harvest a Just-Landed Insight

Core move: Stop and anchor; don’t keep questioning
5 options10 questions17 situations

1What it really is

Recognizing the specific signature of a live insight — quiet, new language, wet eyes, an audible “oh” — and immediately stopping the questioning to anchor it, rather than continuing to probe.

Sometimes in a session the client realises something important. There’s a visible change: they go quiet, their voice softens, they use words they haven’t used before. This method asks the coach to recognise that moment and stop asking new questions. Instead, the coach helps the client stay with the insight, name it in their own words, and fix it in a way they will remember, such as writing it down or noting where they feel it in the body.

It sounds like: “Let’s pause here for a moment. What just happened?”, “Can you say that again, in one sentence?”, or “What do you want to remember from this?” It is not the moment to analyse or extend the insight, and it’s not a time to plan actions immediately either. Those can come later. The main job is protection. It has worked when the client can clearly state the insight and still recalls it at the next session, often with signs it has already changed how they act.

4How it works, deeply

The greatest risk to a fresh insight is the coach’s own next clever question — out of habit, coaches often keep probing right past the moment that actually mattered. The discipline required is counter-intuitive: literally saying out loud “let’s not move yet,” then doing far less rather than more. A small, physical embodiment (noticing where it’s felt in the body, writing the sentence down once) protects the insight better than further discussion, which tends to talk it away.

Insights are fragile when they first appear. They often arrive with a strong emotional charge, but without anchoring they can fade quickly, especially if the conversation moves on. Pausing allows the insight to settle, and asking the client to put it in their own words strengthens it in memory. Research on memory suggests that actively generating and recalling information makes it more durable than passively hearing it.

Physical and written anchors add further layers. Noticing where the insight is felt in the body links it to a sensation the client can return to; writing it down creates a record they can see again. These anchors make it easier for the insight to show up in daily life, when the client faces the old situation again. The coach’s willingness to slow down also shows respect for the client’s discovery, communicating that this realisation is theirs and that it matters.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Quiet, new language, wet eyes, “oh”
The move
Stop adding questions. Anchor it.
Watch
The next clever question can steal the insight.
Four questions that often open it
  1. Let’s not move yet. Where do you feel that?
  2. What just became clear?
  3. What wants to be remembered when you leave this room?
  4. What is the smallest way to keep this alive this week?

2The client’s context

An energy drop into stillness that is alive, not sleepy or checked-out. A genuinely new sentence appears. A visible shoulder drop or physical release.

3The coach’s options

1Body anchor — locating and marking the physical sensation.
2Sentence to remember — capturing the exact new language used.
3Smallest way to keep it alive — a minimal, protective follow-through.
4Protect it from being talked away — resisting the urge to over-explain it.
5Integration vs. more insight — choosing to let this one land rather than chasing another.

5Where it gets stuck

The next clever question steals the insight before it can settle. The session resumes analytical momentum purely out of coaching habit.

6How to move it forward

Say explicitly: “let’s not move yet.” Then offer one small embodiment — nothing more.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • Let’s not move yet. Where do you feel that?
  • What just became clear?
  • What wants to be remembered when you leave this room?
  • What is the smallest way to keep this alive this week?
  • What would steal this if we kept talking?
Going further
  • If you wrote that sentence down right now, exactly as you said it, what would it say?
  • What does your body want to do with this right now — nothing, or something small?
  • Who, if anyone, do you want to tell about this, and who should you not tell yet?
  • What would make this feel real again on Wednesday, when the room isn’t here anymore?
  • Is there anything you want to protect this from, this week?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.6Intellectualizing Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stage…
What is happening Models, analysis, “interestingly”, little felt experienceCoach move Body, emotion, metaphor, silence
In the room
Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stages of their own avoidance.
What’s underneath
Cognition ahead of felt experience gets rejected by the nervous system even when accurate — and here cognition is the defense. Out-analyzing them rewards the defense. Sideways routes (body, image, silence) restore data they have edited out.
Avoid here
Question cube as more architecture. Systemic reframe as another framework. Any method that stays in third-person analysis.
Example
Client maps their “avoidance pattern” with a 2x2. Coach does not add a quadrant. “If the 2x2 stepped aside…” Throat tight. Weather: locked archive room. Work becomes the unsent two-line message, not a better map of avoidance.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods6714283138
S1.7Ready to move Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what…
What is happening Forward energy, asks for next step, new language already appearingCoach move Options, experiments, who they would need to be
In the room
Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what I need to do is…”
What’s underneath
Continued exploration at this point is often the coach’s need for thoroughness. Readiness is perishable. Land while the nervous system is still organized toward action.
Avoid here
More expand. Miracle question. Clean language archaeology. Another reframe “to be sure.”
Example
After naming “I have been managing their mood,” client is already drafting a sentence. Coach skips another why. One dated conversation Friday. Success = it happened.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods435363738
S1.14First time saying it out loud Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What is happening Hesitation, “this may sound silly”, long pause before the sentenceCoach move Safety first. Witness. Do not rush to fix or reframe
In the room
Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.
What’s underneath
Being heard is the intervention. Insight can wait. A reframe here is a small violence: it teaches them that this room, too, will rush to tidy what they just risked.
Avoid here
Immediate reframe, options, miracle, challenge.
Example
“I think I want to leave the field.” Coach does not build an exit plan. First work: they hear themselves. Then they choose hold vs move.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17133538
S1.21Comparing this to last time / “we already covered this” Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.
What is happening Impatience, “I know this”, cynicismCoach move Honor the known. Ask what is new in this version
In the room
Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.
What’s underneath
Repeating a topic is not failure. Integration may be missing. Knowing is not living. Honor the known; ask what is different about this week’s living.
Avoid here
Re-teaching the same insight more brilliantly. Shame about repetition.
Example
“We covered delegation.” Living it this week: they still took the deck back on Sunday. Integration = stop-doing list with their boss, not another article on empowerment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293839
S2.1Emotionally flooded / activated Tears, shaking voice, heat, cannot finish sentences.
What is happening Tears, shaking voice, heat, can’t finish sentencesCoach move Safety, presence, breath, smaller slice. No big future questions yet
In the room
Tears, shaking voice, heat, cannot finish sentences.
What’s underneath
High arousal takes prefrontal capacity offline. Asking for a preferred future mid-flood is map-reading while the building is on fire. Presence and slice-size are the methods.
Avoid here
Miracle, future-self, pre-mortem, challenge, question cube, stacked powerful questions.
Example
Client breaks on “they announced the role without telling me.” Coach does not ask what future-them would do. Slice: this feeling, two minutes, feet on the floor. Later they choose a request to the sponsor — after speech returns.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods73238
S2.9Hopeful / lit up for the first time Energy rise. New language. Smile. Lean-in.
What is happening Energy rise, new language, smile, leaning inCoach move Harvest it. Make it specific. Lock a small embodiment
In the room
Energy rise. New language. Smile. Lean-in.
What’s underneath
Hope is fragile in its first minutes and dies under premature scrutiny. Harvest. Make specific. Lock a small embodiment. Do not immediately stress-test.
Avoid here
Pre-mortem. “But what if.” More analysis to make it robust.
Example
First genuine “I could try for the role.” Harvest. Body: lift in chest. Keep-alive: tell one safe person. No SWOT of the application today.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods63538
S2.17Afraid of hope / waiting for the other shoe Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.
What is happening Won’t celebrate, discounts winsCoach move Explore the protective logic of not hoping. Tiny allowed hope
In the room
Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.
What’s underneath
Not-hoping is a protective logic after previous crashes. Forcing celebration feels naive. Tiny allowed hope. Evidence they would need.
Avoid here
Party hats. Immediate stretch goals.
Example
After a previous failed promotion cycle. Not-hoping protects against public hope-then-humiliation. 5% safer: write the contribution list privately. Not a LinkedIn announcement.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods12152538
S5.1Insight without behavior change Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What is happening Beautiful ahas, same week as last monthCoach move Close the knowing-doing gap. Smaller, scheduled, observable acts
In the room
Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What’s underneath
Knowing-doing gap. More insight can become another hiding place. Integration is a scheduled act, not a better sentence.
Avoid here
Another brilliant why.
Example
Third “I need to stop rescuing.” Integration: one update they do not rewrite this week. Insight without that act is décor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1735383943
S5.17After a win they can’t own Luck, team, timing — never them.
What is happening Luck, team, timing — never themCoach move Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update
In the room
Luck, team, timing — never them.
What’s underneath
Unowned wins do not update self-concept. Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update.
Avoid here
Fake humility praise.
Example
Turnaround attributed to “the team and timing.” Specifics: they set a weekly tradeoff meeting and killed two projects. Identity that updates: someone who designs conditions, not a spectator of luck.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods593841
S6.2Imposter feelings Waiting to be found out. Over-prepares. Discounts praise.
What is happening Waiting to be found out, over-prepares, discounts praiseCoach move Evidence file. Belonging vs competence. Who they are becoming
In the room
Waiting to be found out. Over-prepares. Discounts praise.
What’s underneath
Not only a data problem. Belonging story. Do not just list achievements.
Avoid here
Trophy lists alone. “Fake it till you make it.”
Example
Fair jury: three years of delivery. Belonging story: first in family in rooms like this. Work both. Good-enough authority: speak without one more rehearsal.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods92338
S7.8Can’t receive help / praise / credit Deflects. Immediately gives it away.
What is happening Deflects, immediately gives it awayCoach move Practice receiving as a skill. 3-second pause
In the room
Deflects. Immediately gives it away.
What’s underneath
Receiving is a leadership skill. 3-second pause. Identity that would have to update.
Avoid here
More compliments to overpower deflection.
Example
Credit arrives; body moves it on in one second. Practice three seconds. Receiving gives the giver the dignity of having given.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3538
S8.6Silence that is working Thinking face. Eyes moving. Processing.
What is happening Thinking face, eyes moving, processingCoach move Wait. Do not fill. After, harvest
In the room
Thinking face. Eyes moving. Processing.
What’s underneath
Anxious coaches ruin the best minutes of the session. Wait. Then harvest.
Avoid here
A second question.
Example
After “I think I want out,” 20 seconds of living silence. New sentence arrives. The next clever question would have stolen it.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods38
S8.12Big insight just landed — needs integration Quiet. Wet eyes. “Oh.”
What is happening Quiet, wet eyes, “oh”Coach move Stop adding questions. Let it settle. Anchor in body and next hour
In the room
Quiet. Wet eyes. “Oh.”
What’s underneath
The next clever question can steal the insight. Stop. Anchor in body and next hour.
Avoid here
Stress-test. Another why.
Example
“I’ve been applying for my father’s approval in this job.” Stop. Body. One sentence written. No org-chart analysis today.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3843
S8.15Client is performing leadership rather than exploring Keynote in the chair. No crack.
What is happening Keynote in the chair, no crackCoach move Ask for the unofficial version. Energy under the polish
In the room
Keynote in the chair. No crack.
What’s underneath
Status is a defense. Respect it, then invite the human. Kitchen-table version.
Avoid here
Competing keynotes. Calling them fake.
Example
Board version of a reorg. Kitchen table: they are scared they will become the person they disliked. Crack. Work that.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods738
S9.5Client wants to stop early Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.
What is happening Client asks to end the engagement before plannedCoach move Respect the choice; reflect on what led to it; harvest the learning
In the room
Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.
What’s underneath
Stopping early can be the right choice or an avoidance. The coach respects the decision while inviting reflection on what led to it and what the client has gained.
Avoid here
Persuading them to stay. Taking it personally. Ending without reflection.
Example
A client wants to stop after three sessions. The coach asks what led to it. The client admits the topic got too close. They agree a final session to harvest learning.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17838
S9.6Ending the engagement well Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.
What is happening Final session or sessions of an engagementCoach move Harvest learning; celebrate progress; plan how to continue without the coach
In the room
Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.
What’s underneath
Endings matter. A good ending helps the client own their progress, plan how to keep it going and leave with confidence rather than dependency.
Avoid here
Ending abruptly. Adding new topics at the last minute. Fostering dependency.
Example
In the last session, the client reviews their goals, names three key learnings, and writes a letter from their future self to keep.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods35384143
S9.13Team after a failure or setback Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.
What is happening Team has failed or had a setback; morale and trust are shakenCoach move Blame-free review; find what worked; agree what to change
In the room
Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.
What’s underneath
After a failure, teams tend either to look for someone to blame or to avoid the subject. Both waste the learning. A blame-free review that also finds what went well helps the team recover confidence and improve.
Avoid here
A blame hunt. Skipping the review. Forced positivity.
Example
A product launch fails. The coach runs a review in three parts: what happened, what we learned, what we’d keep. The team leaves with two process changes and renewed confidence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5123841

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Excessive thoroughness that overrides the moment.
  • Stress-testing the hope or insight in its very first minutes.
  • Performing “more value” by continuing to add material.

10Client traps

  • Explaining the insight so much that it talks itself away.
  • Asking the coach to confirm or validate it, rather than simply letting it be theirs.

Three worked problems

1

New sentence: “I have been applying for my father’s approval in this job.” Harvest immediately. Body: heat in the face. Keep-alive: write the sentence down once, don’t discuss it at home yet, take one action that belongs entirely to the client, not to the father.

2

Hope arriving after months of cynicism. No pre-mortem on the hope yet. Smallest keep-alive: tell one safe person one true, good thing.

3

Insight without last month’s matching behavior change. The insight is harvested, and the question shifts to what integration looks like this week — not more understanding.

Where it comes from

A common coaching practice for anchoring insight; related to consolidation and reflection in adult learning.

My notes

39
Land It family

Name the Loop

Core move: Change the level: identity, system, experiment, ending
5 options10 questions9 situations

1What it really is

Naming, directly and without blame, that the same topic keeps returning at the same floor, session after session — then deliberately changing the level of engagement: identity, system, experiment, or ending.

Some topics come back session after session in nearly the same form, with the same story, the same frustration, and the same lack of movement. This method invites the coach to name that pattern openly and kindly, and then to change how the topic is being approached. That might mean looking at the identity question underneath it, at the system around it, at a specific experiment, or at whether this topic should come off the coaching agenda altogether.

It sounds like: “I notice this is the third time we’ve come back to this in a similar way. What do you make of that?” or “What would need to be different for us to make progress this time?” It is not a criticism of the client, and it doesn’t mean the coaching has failed; loops are normal. Naming them is often what lets them move. It has worked when the client responds with curiosity rather than defensiveness, and the conversation shifts to a new level or a new kind of question.

4How it works, deeply

The critical discipline is naming the loop without exasperation — irritation in the coach’s tone turns the observation into an accusation. The productive question isn’t “why haven’t you changed” but “what are you protecting by staying in this conversation as it currently is?” Loops are rarely stupidity; they’re usually protection from something the client hasn’t yet been willing to name directly.

Repetitive loops often persist because both coach and client unconsciously collude to keep the conversation comfortable. Each session feels productive, but nothing actually changes. Naming the loop breaks this unspoken agreement and makes the pattern itself the subject of the conversation. This is a form of meta-communication, talking about how we are talking, which often reveals what the content of the conversation has been avoiding.

Changing the level works because loops are often maintained at one level and solvable at another. A behavioural topic that keeps returning may be rooted in identity, in a system that reinforces it, or in a lack of real experimentation. Sometimes the most honest move is to consider ending the topic or the coaching engagement, if the client is not ready or the topic needs a different kind of support. Naming that possibility respectfully can itself free up movement, because it makes the choice to engage explicit.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Same topic, same floor, session after session
The move
Change the level: identity, system, experiment, or ending
Watch
Repetition usually means the intervention is at the wrong level.
Four questions that often open it
  1. We have visited this room before. What have we not been willing to do?
  2. What would make this the last time we talk about it this way?
  3. Are we working the topic at the wrong level — story, feeling, belief, system, action?
  4. What are you protecting by staying in this conversation as it is?

2The client’s context

The same events get repeated verbally. “We already covered this” hangs unspoken in the room. Impatience is present alongside a total absence of actual shift. Coach and client are, in effect, circling the same drain together.

3The coach’s options

1Wrong altitude — the conversation has been stuck at “story” when it needs “action,” or vice versa.
2Missing experiment — insight has accumulated with no test of it in the world.
3Missing system conversation — the loop is actually structural, not personal.
4Protective function of the loop itself — the repetition may be serving a purpose.
5Ending the coaching topic or the engagement — sometimes the honest move is to stop, not to keep trying.

5Where it gets stuck

More of the same intervention gets applied at the same level. Shame about the repetition builds. False harmony sets in, where both parties pretend progress that isn’t happening.

6How to move it forward

Name the loop without exasperation in the tone. Ask what they’re protecting by staying in this exact pattern. Ask what would make this genuinely the last time they discuss it this way.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • We have visited this room before. What have we not been willing to do?
  • What would make this the last time we talk about it this way?
  • Are we working the topic at the wrong level — story, feeling, belief, system, action?
  • What are you protecting by staying in this conversation as it is?
  • What still doesn’t shift even though you know?
Going further
  • What would it cost you to actually finish this topic?
  • If we never spoke about this again, what would have to be true?
  • What have you been hoping I would ask that I haven’t?
  • What’s the version of this conversation you’re avoiding having with someone else, not with me?
  • If staying stuck here is protecting something, what would happen if that thing were exposed?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.1Telling a rehearsed story Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Lo…
What is happening Fluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotionCoach move Expand: “What else?” / impact / feeling
In the room
Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Low emotion. They sound competent and slightly bored by their own plot.
What’s underneath
The first version is almost never wrong; it is rarely complete. Rehearsal is a social technology: it keeps the story stable so the teller does not have to feel it again. Professional coaching needs the unstable layer — impact, pattern, the word they are not using.
Avoid here
Preferred future too early (they have not arrived in the present). Reframe before they feel heard (lands as “you did not listen to my official version”). Generating options (there is no new material to option from). Pre-mortem (there is no plan; there is a performance).
Example
A VP tells a smooth story of a “difficult stakeholder.” Dates, emails, tone. Coach hears it once, then asks for impact. New sentence: “I rewrite every message three times and I hate who I am at 11pm.” That sentence is the topic. The stakeholder is context.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods235673139
S1.8Story-looping / circling the same plot Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and…
What is happening Repeats events, more detail, no new insight, time passingCoach move Stop the plot. Move to meaning, pattern, or wanted future
In the room
Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and they would match.
What’s underneath
More plot rarely creates change. Repetition usually means the intervention is at the wrong level — or the loop is protecting them from an act, a feeling, or an ending.
Avoid here
Expand-for-more-detail. Clean language on plot nouns. Sympathy that invites another lap.
Example
Third retelling of a board ambush. Chapter title: “I keep going in without a sponsor.” Level change: one pre-wire this week, or park the topic.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14213539
S1.11Over-specific / lost in detail Names, dates, emails, who said what. Inbox as the room.
What is happening Names, dates, emails, who said whatCoach move Zoom out to pattern, purpose, and what they want instead
In the room
Names, dates, emails, who said what. Inbox as the room.
What’s underneath
Detail can be a hiding place — from feeling, from pattern, from a decision. Harvest one pattern, then leave the inbox.
Avoid here
Following each email. Clean language on every proper noun.
Example
Twelve-message CC war. Chapter title: “I will not ask directly.” Pattern, then one request. Inbox closed.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2639
S1.21Comparing this to last time / “we already covered this” Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.
What is happening Impatience, “I know this”, cynicismCoach move Honor the known. Ask what is new in this version
In the room
Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.
What’s underneath
Repeating a topic is not failure. Integration may be missing. Knowing is not living. Honor the known; ask what is different about this week’s living.
Avoid here
Re-teaching the same insight more brilliantly. Shame about repetition.
Example
“We covered delegation.” Living it this week: they still took the deck back on Sunday. Integration = stop-doing list with their boss, not another article on empowerment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293839
S3.9Rumination / same thoughts on repeat Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What is happening Circular why, no new dataCoach move Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination
In the room
Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What’s underneath
More analysis of the same tape will not release it. Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination. Give its job another method.
Avoid here
Deeper why. Clean language on the same nouns for twenty minutes.
Example
Hundred loops of “why did they exclude me.” Job of rumination: prevent another surprise. Other method: a cadence question to the boss. Tape stops needing to play all night.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141520303943
S5.1Insight without behavior change Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What is happening Beautiful ahas, same week as last monthCoach move Close the knowing-doing gap. Smaller, scheduled, observable acts
In the room
Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What’s underneath
Knowing-doing gap. More insight can become another hiding place. Integration is a scheduled act, not a better sentence.
Avoid here
Another brilliant why.
Example
Third “I need to stop rescuing.” Integration: one update they do not rewrite this week. Insight without that act is décor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1735383943
S8.10Repeating the same topic session after session Same title. Same floor.
What is happening Same title, same floorCoach move Name the loop. Change the level: identity, system, experiment, or ending
In the room
Same title. Same floor.
What’s underneath
Repetition means the intervention is at the wrong level. Name the loop. Identity, system, experiment, or ending.
Avoid here
Better insight at the same level.
Example
Four sessions on the peer. Never sent the request. Protecting: not being seen as political. Level change: send it or park the topic.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods39
S9.4Coaching isn’t working Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What is happening Sessions repeat without progress; frustration on one or both sidesCoach move Name it openly; review goals, fit and approach together
In the room
Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.
What’s underneath
Lack of progress is information. The topic, the fit, the timing or the method may be wrong. Naming it openly is better than carrying on politely.
Avoid here
Blaming the client. Pretending it’s fine. Trying harder with the same approach.
Example
After six sessions, nothing has changed. The coach names it and asks what isn’t working. The client admits the real topic is leaving, not leadership.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14293439
S9.7Repeated cancellations or no-shows Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.
What is happening Sessions keep being cancelled or missedCoach move Name the pattern without blame; re-contract
In the room
Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.
What’s underneath
Repeated cancellations are information: about priority, avoidance, workload, or fit. Naming the pattern, without blame, helps the client decide what they want.
Avoid here
Ignoring it. Getting annoyed. Making assumptions.
Example
A client cancels three times. The coach names the pattern kindly. The client admits the sessions feel like another obligation. They change frequency and focus.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14839

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • An irritated tone when naming the loop.
  • Offering more insight at the exact same level that’s already failed to shift anything.
  • Colluding with the loop because the repetition itself feels like depth.

10Client traps

  • Using insight as a hiding place — understanding the pattern intellectually as a substitute for changing it.
  • Using cynicism as a form of protection from disappointment.

Three worked problems

1

Third session on “difficult peer.” The request has never actually been sent. The loop is protection from being seen as political. Changing the level: a 15-minute conversation this week, or the topic is explicitly parked.

2

“I know I should delegate.” Knowledge was never the gap — identity and system incentives are. New level: a stop-doing list, written together with their boss.

3

Purpose fog for six months. The loop is protecting the client from disappointing a family script. New level: naming the loyalty directly, then designing one experiment that is 10% more genuinely theirs.

Where it comes from

Naming the pattern in the room draws on process consultation (Edgar Schein) and systemic practice.

My notes

40
Land It family

Sort Control

Core move: Mine / ours / not mine, then one clean move
5 options10 questions27 situations

1What it really is

A three-way sort — mine, ours, not mine — followed by exactly one clean move. Used for heroics, victimhood, or fusion with other people’s feelings.

This method helps clients who are taking on too much, or too little, responsibility. Together, coach and client sort everything involved in the situation into three groups: what is mine (in my control), what is ours (shared or influenced), and what is not mine (outside my control). The client then picks one clean move: one thing to do in their own area, one request to make in the shared area, or one thing to stop carrying from the area that isn’t theirs.

It sounds like: “Let’s list everything that’s weighing on you. Which of these are actually yours?”, followed by “What’s one thing you could put down this week?” It is not a way of avoiding responsibility, and it isn’t meant to make the client feel blamed for what is theirs. It brings clarity, which usually brings relief. It has worked when the client feels lighter, and can name a specific thing they will either do, ask for, or stop worrying about before the next session.

4How it works, deeply

Both extremes — total victimhood and total heroic over-responsibility — are ways of avoiding a clean, accurate accounting of what actually belongs to whom. The sorting itself (mine / ours / not mine) is often the whole intervention, because most clients haven’t consciously separated these categories before. The final step — one request not yet made, or one thing to put down for a week — converts the sorting from an intellectual exercise into an actual behavioral shift.

This method connects to the idea of locus of control, which describes how much people believe they influence what happens to them. People who believe they control nothing often feel helpless, while people who believe they control everything often feel overwhelmed and guilty. Both views are inaccurate. Sorting responsibilities into three categories creates a more realistic picture, which often reduces stress immediately because the client can stop carrying what isn’t theirs.

The shared category is especially important. Many workplace and family issues fall into this middle ground, where the client can influence an outcome but not decide it alone. Recognising that turns frustration into a question of how to influence well, through requests, negotiation or clear communication. The final single move keeps the method practical and achievable. Over time, clients often internalise the sorting and start doing it automatically when they feel overloaded.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Heroics, victimhood, or fusion with others’ feelings
The move
Mine / ours / not mine — then one clean move
Watch
Do not shame the victim stance. It was often learned for survival.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What part of this is in your control, and what part is not?
  2. What is yours, what is ours, what is not yours?
  3. What request have you not made?
  4. What would clean responsibility look like, without extra punishment or extra rescue?

2The client’s context

Language patterns like: “they / the system / I have no choice,” or “I have to fix everyone,” or “I made them upset” (taking ownership of someone else’s emotional reaction).

3The coach’s options

1Victim stance — find the genuine 5–20% that actually is movable.
2Hero / rescuer — return the work to its rightful owner.
3Over-owning others’ emotions — separating what belongs to the client from what belongs to someone else.
4Clean responsibility — without extra punishment or extra rescuing layered on top.
5Request vs. complaint — converting venting into an actual, specific ask.

5Where it gets stuck

Shaming the victim stance (which was often learned as a genuine survival strategy) backfires. The coach can slip into becoming the person who “grants permission.” Venting happens without ever converting into an actual request.

6How to move it forward

Sort into three explicit columns. Identify one request that hasn’t yet been made. Identify one thing to put down for a week.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What part of this is in your control, and what part is not?
  • What is yours, what is ours, what is not yours?
  • What request have you not made?
  • What would clean responsibility look like, without extra punishment or extra rescue?
  • If you took 10% more authorship, what would you do?
Going further
  • What are you carrying that was never actually yours to carry?
  • If you stopped rescuing this person for one week, what would happen?
  • What’s the complaint underneath, and what’s the request hiding inside it?
  • Whose reaction are you managing that isn’t actually your job to manage?
  • What would “enough” responsibility look like here, versus too much or too little?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S1.5Overwhelmed Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to …
What is happening Too much at once, pressure, no footholdCoach move Exceptions, resources, +1 on the scale
In the room
Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to outrun the body.
What’s underneath
An overloaded system cannot use a big plan. Load reduction and resource-finding are regulation, not soft extras. +1 and exceptions restore a sense of authorship without pretending the load is imaginary.
Avoid here
Giant homework. Preferred-future montage. Pre-mortem (more future weight). Who-would-you-need-to-be as a heroic identity.
Example
Six workstreams plus a sick parent. Exception: last Thursday when they declined two meetings. +1: decline the standing Thursday review that produces no decisions. Not a life-redesign.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods145740
S1.10Dumping everything at once / multiple topics Long list. Urgency. No priority. Breathless. They watch to see which fire you will pick.
What is happening Long list, urgency, no priority, breathlessCoach move Contract. Choose the thread with the most energy
In the room
Long list. Urgency. No priority. Breathless. They watch to see which fire you will pick.
What’s underneath
The list is data. The session still needs one focus. Several topics at once usually means the real work is choosing, not answering all of them.
Avoid here
Trying to land six micro-plans. Expanding every item. Being the project manager.
Example
Reorg, hire, board pack, leave-question. Heat is on the leave-question when they say it. Contract twenty minutes there; the rest becomes context for whether they stay.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods140
S1.12Bringing someone else’s agenda “My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.
What is happening “My boss said I should…”, partner booked them, HR sent themCoach move Separate assigned topic from their topic. Restore ownership
In the room
“My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.
What’s underneath
Coaching requires authorship. You can work the overlap between organizational want and client want. You cannot become the organization’s enforcer and still be their coach.
Avoid here
Running the company’s curriculum. Ignoring the assigned topic entirely without naming the fork (can blow up sponsorship). Advice on how to “perform presence.”
Example
Assigned: executive presence. Owned: credit stolen by a peer. Overlap: one visible moment Thursday. Both agendas honored; neither colonizes the hour.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods163540
S1.15Confidential / shame-tinged topic Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”
What is happening Lowered voice, looking away, moral languageCoach move Normalize, bound confidentiality, go at their pace, separate person from act
In the room
Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”
What’s underneath
Shame hears challenge as further verdict. Separate person from act before any learning. Confidentiality and pace are methods, not preamble.
Avoid here
Pry. Cheerleading “you’re great.” Diagnosis. Immediate experiment they will use as more evidence of defect if it fails.
Example
Client whispers about losing their temper in a 1:1. Separate: the snap is behavior. Pattern: Friday depletion. Clean learning: Friday is not a feedback day. No identity trial.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods13141540
S2.3Angry / blaming / righteous heat Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What is happening Other-focus, injustice language, clenched jawCoach move Validate the heat, then separate fact / interpretation / want
In the room
Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.
What’s underneath
Anger is often a protector of dignity, boundary, or grief. Do not moralize it; do not join the case. Sequence: validate heat → separate fact / interpretation / want → find the clean request.
Avoid here
Immediate perspective-take (“have you considered their side”) — feels like betrayal. Cheerful reframe.
Example
Rage at a peer who “stole” a project. Anger protecting: not being erasable. Clean request: shared ownership memo + a conversation. Prosecution energy drops when dignity has a next act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods71011193740
S2.6Guilty / over-responsible Should have. My fault. I ruined it. They carry structural events as personal sin.
What is happening Should have, my fault, I ruined itCoach move Sort responsibility: mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination
In the room
Should have. My fault. I ruined it. They carry structural events as personal sin.
What’s underneath
Guilt can be a hidden form of control: if it is all mine, I am not powerless. Sort mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination.
Avoid here
“It’s not your fault” as a blanket (they will not believe it, and some piece may be theirs). More rumination disguised as processing.
Example
Reorg hurt their team. Theirs: how they communicated. Not theirs: the headcount decision. Repair: honest meeting. Rumination: nightly replay — extra.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods121640
S2.13Resentful / bitter Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.
What is happening Kept score, “after all I did”, tightnessCoach move Find the unmet contract. Turn resentment into a request or a boundary
In the room
Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.
What’s underneath
Resentment is often an unmet contract that was never spoken. Venting without a request keeps them stuck. Turn into a request or a boundary — or a clean decision to stop waiting.
Avoid here
More venting as the whole method. Moral lecture about gratitude.
Example
Covered a peer’s region for a year. Never agreed; never asked. Clean ask or stop covering. Bitterness was unpaid invoice plus silence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1243740
S2.16Burned out / depleted Cynicism. Exhaustion. Sunday dread. Numbness plus irritability.
What is happening Cynicism, exhaustion, Sunday dread, numbness + irritabilityCoach move Energy before strategy. Recovery design. Reduce load, don’t add homework
In the room
Cynicism. Exhaustion. Sunday dread. Numbness plus irritability.
What’s underneath
Do not coach peak performance on an empty tank. Energy before strategy. Reduce load; do not add homework. Recovery is the strategy.
Avoid here
Who-you-need-to-be-as-a-high-performer. Big plans. Appreciation as pep.
Example
Sunday dread + cynicism. Must stop: Sunday night pre-writes for a meeting that never decides. Recovery design first. Performance later.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods53240
S4.1Victim stance / it’s all them They, the system, luck. No agency language.
What is happening They, the system, luck, no agency languageCoach move Validate constraint. Find the 5–20% they can move. Request vs complaint
In the room
They, the system, luck. No agency language.
What’s underneath
Often hides a request never made — they decided the answer would be no. Validate constraint. Find 5–20% they can move.
Avoid here
Shame. Heroic pep. Strategy pile-on.
Example
“Matrix makes delivery impossible.” True constraint. Unmade request: tradeoff sentence to the constraint-holder. 10% authorship.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods161940
S4.2Hero / I must fix everyone Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.
What is happening Over-functioning, no delegation, exhaustion prideCoach move Return work to its owner. Cost of heroics. Team as system
In the room
Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.
What’s underneath
Heroics are often rewarded. Name the price — to them and to the people who never get to carry their own work.
Avoid here
Time-management tips that leave the identity intact.
Example
Does the report’s stakeholder management. Cost: report stays junior, hero is exhausted. Week experiment: they send their own update. Standard reaches them.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16193540
S4.3Rescuer of the team / parent in the workplace Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.
What is happening Protects people from consequence, buffers the bossCoach move Adult-adult. Boundaries. Development vs rescue
In the room
Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.
What’s underneath
Rescue can be love and control at once. Development vs rescue. Let the standard reach them.
Avoid here
Softness with no standard.
Example
Softens every message from the SVP. Team never feels the real requirement. Fear: they will break. Adult: pass the standard, stay available.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16193740
S4.4Blaming self for the system Structural problems worn as personal defect.
What is happening Takes structural problems as personal defectCoach move Sort person / role / system. Reduce false shame
In the room
Structural problems worn as personal defect.
What’s underneath
Sort person / role / system. Do not let them “work harder” at an unworkable design.
Avoid here
Only mindset. Only blame-the-org.
Example
Measured on personal heroics and team development. Unworkable. Conversation with boss to change the scoreboard — plus one delegation act.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods121640
S4.5No ownership / “yes but” Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.
What is happening Agrees then undoes, external conditions alwaysCoach move Name the yes-but. Find the hidden loyalty or fear
In the room
Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.
What’s underneath
Yes-but is information, not just resistance. Often a clean no in costume, or a hidden loyalty/fear.
Avoid here
More action planning they will yes-but.
Example
“Yes I’ll talk to her but the offsite…” But protects fear of her anger. Clean not-yet: after the offsite, dated. Or clean no. Anything but a fake yes.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods8151740
S4.6Waiting for perfect conditions “Once the reorg / hire / budget…”
What is happening “Once the reorg / hire / budget…”Coach move Act inside constraints. 70% rule. Controllables
In the room
“Once the reorg / hire / budget…”
What’s underneath
Perfect conditions are often postponement with a respectable excuse. Act inside constraints. 70% rule.
Avoid here
Strategy that starts “after.”
Example
Waiting for the hire to start culture work. 10% now: one team norm they can set without the hire.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods40
S4.10Hiding in “we” Team language when it is an I-issue.
What is happening Team language when it is an I-issueCoach move Shift we → I. Personal stance
In the room
Team language when it is an I-issue.
What’s underneath
We can be diplomacy or disappearance. Shift we → I.
Avoid here
More org-speak.
Example
“We are unsure about the date.” I-sentence: “I think the date is a lie and I have not said so.” That’s the work.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods40
S4.11Over-owning other people’s emotions I made them upset. I must fix their feeling.
What is happening I made them upset, I must fix their feelingCoach move Return their feelings to them. Clean impact vs imagined impact
In the room
I made them upset. I must fix their feeling.
What’s underneath
Empathy without boundary becomes fusion. Clean impact vs imagined impact. Let them have their reaction.
Avoid here
Scripts for managing the other person’s inner life.
Example
Gave fair feedback; colleague cried. Clean: check they understood and are resourced. Extra: rewriting the feedback into mush. Respect includes their reaction.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3740
S5.2Action without insight / busywork Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.
What is happening Lots of doing, no learning, hamster wheelCoach move Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs motion
In the room
Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.
What’s underneath
Do not applaud motion that is avoidance. Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs anxiety-motion.
Avoid here
More productivity systems.
Example
14 status meetings. 50% less might reveal no decision owner. Stillness would show the missing contract, not a need for a 15th meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods172140
S5.16Need to have a difficult conversation Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What is happening Avoids the meeting, writes unsent emailsCoach move Purpose, request, opening line, body regulation, rehearsal
In the room
Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.
What’s underneath
Role-play beats more theory. Purpose, request, first sentence, body, live practice.
Avoid here
Longer essays. More theory of crucial conversations.
Example
Unsent prosecution email. Purpose: fewer surprises. First sentence practiced. Heat in chest named. Meeting request sent same day.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods731353740
S6.25Neurodivergence shaping how they work (ADHD, autism, dyslexia) Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted fro…
What is happening Work set up for different brains; strong in some areas, worn out in othersCoach move Spot strengths; design the environment and adjustments around how they work best
In the room
Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted from masking.
What’s underneath
The client’s mind works differently, not wrongly. Problems often come from a poor fit between how they work best and how the job is set up. Coaching works on fit, strengths and adjustments, not on “fixing” the person. Diagnosis is not the coach’s role.
Avoid here
Diagnosing or suggesting a diagnosis. Treating it as a confidence problem. Generic productivity advice.
Example
A product manager with ADHD loses track of long meetings. Coach helps design shorter meetings with written agendas, and they ask for this as a reasonable adjustment.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods69163640
S6.26Chronic illness or health limits reshaping work (including menopause) Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What is happening Health limits energy or capacity; fear of being judged as unreliableCoach move Sort control; redesign work around real limits; plan the conversations
In the room
Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.
What’s underneath
Health changes the resources available, not the person’s value. The coaching challenge is redesigning work around real limits, communicating needs, and dealing with the identity hit. Medical questions belong with medical professionals.
Avoid here
Medical advice. Pushing performance goals as if health is unchanged. Treating it as purely a mindset issue.
Example
A senior lawyer going through menopause has poor sleep and brain fog. Coach helps sort what’s in her control, plan demanding work for her best hours, and prepare a conversation with HR.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods416323640
S7.1Conflict with a boss Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.
What is happening Walking on eggs, rage, mind-readingCoach move Intent/impact, request, manage-up map, power reality
In the room
Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.
What’s underneath
Work inside power reality without disappearing. Intent/impact, request, manage-up map. Do not coach rebellion they will not choose — or submission they will resent.
Avoid here
Courage speeches that ignore power. Joining the prosecution.
Example
Boss optimizes for no surprises, not for innovation. Smallest conversation: risk-flag cadence. Power named; voice not erased.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods10193740
S7.21Scope creep / everything is urgent Calendar as crime scene.
What is happening Calendar as crime sceneCoach move Priorities as values. What to stop. Stakeholder reset
In the room
Calendar as crime scene.
What’s underneath
A calendar is a values document. Read it aloud. What to stop. Whom to disappoint on purpose. Stakeholder reset.
Avoid here
Time-hacking the unworkable pile.
Example
Calendar says they value being unrefusable. Three outcomes named. Reset with the adder. Values become visible.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods40
S7.33Disclosure of bullying, harassment or discrimination Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What is happening Client describes treatment that may be bullying, harassment or discriminationCoach move Listen and believe; map options and support; refer to formal channels
In the room
Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).
What’s underneath
This is not only a coaching topic. It may need HR, legal, union or other formal support. The coach listens, believes, helps the client understand their options and supports their choice. The coach does not investigate, judge or decide for them, and does not promise confidentiality they can’t keep.
Avoid here
Coaching their “resilience” to tolerate it. Telling them what to do. Investigating or confronting anyone. Minimising.
Example
A junior employee describes repeated comments about her accent from a manager. The coach listens, acknowledges how hard it is, and helps her map formal and informal options and who could support her.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods17163740
S7.36Returning from parental leave Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What is happening Back from parental leave; new identity, new demands, out of the loopCoach move Map the polarity; set clear agreements at work and home
In the room
Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What’s underneath
The client is adjusting to a new identity and a new set of demands. Work may have moved on. The tension between career and family is ongoing, not a problem to solve once. Clear agreements at work and at home matter.
Avoid here
Assuming they want less, or more, ambition. Treating guilt as a problem to eliminate.
Example
A software lead returns after a year. Coach maps the Work and Family polarity, and helps plan conversations with her boss about the first three months.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1821244042
S8.17Signs of substance misuse Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.
What is happening Hints of using alcohol or substances to copeCoach move Notice and ask respectfully; evoke their own view; refer if they want help
In the room
Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.
What’s underneath
The coach is not there to diagnose or treat. But they can notice, ask with respect, and use a non-judgemental, motivational approach to help the client think about it. If the client wants help, the coach can point them to professional support.
Avoid here
Lecturing, labelling, or ignoring obvious signs. Acting as a counsellor.
Example
A sales director jokes about needing three drinks after every call. Coach asks, without judgement, how they feel about it. The client admits it worries them and agrees to talk to their doctor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods47840
S8.21Confidentiality clashes with safety or legal duty The client shares something that may put them or others at risk, or that may be illegal. The coach feels torn…
What is happening Information shared may require action beyond the coaching relationshipCoach move Revisit the agreed limits; explore the client acting first; seek advice
In the room
The client shares something that may put them or others at risk, or that may be illegal. The coach feels torn.
What’s underneath
Confidentiality has limits, which should be agreed in the contract at the start. When serious risk to someone or legal duties are involved, the coach may need to act. Being honest with the client about those limits keeps trust.
Avoid here
Promising total confidentiality. Acting without telling the client. Ignoring the risk.
Example
A client reveals they are covering up a safety risk at work. The coach reminds them of the agreed limits of confidentiality and explores how the client can report it themselves.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods140
S9.2Sponsor asks what the client said A manager or HR contact asks for updates or details from sessions.
What is happening Sponsor wants information about sessionsCoach move Restate the agreement; redirect to client-owned progress updates
In the room
A manager or HR contact asks for updates or details from sessions.
What’s underneath
The sponsor has a legitimate interest in progress, but not in session content. Confidentiality and reporting should be agreed upfront in a three-way contract. The client, not the coach, should own the progress updates.
Avoid here
Sharing session content. Being evasive without explaining why.
Example
An HR manager asks how sessions are going and what the client said about their boss. The coach explains the agreement and suggests the client gives a progress update in the next three-way meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14042

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Moralizing either the anger or the victimhood.
  • Joining the client’s internal prosecution of themselves or others.
  • Accidentally relocating authorship onto the coach instead of the client.

10Client traps

  • Heroic absorption of others’ problems.
  • “Yes, but” as a way to reject every option offered.
  • Waiting for perfect conditions before making any move.

Three worked problems

1

“The matrix makes delivery impossible.” Outside their control: the structure itself. Inside their control: one clear tradeoff sentence delivered to the person who actually holds the constraint. The move: stop absorbing the pressure in silence.

2

Rescuer of the team. Carrying a direct report’s stakeholder management for them. Cost: the report never learns, and the coach’s client is exhausted. The move: put it down for a week; let the standard reach the report directly.

3

Guilt after a reorg they did not design. Clean responsibility covers how they communicated it. Extra punishment would be taking the entire system’s failure as a personal character flaw. The move: a repair conversation, plus deliberately stopping the rumination.

Where it comes from

Related to Stephen Covey’s circles of concern and influence, and to the much older Stoic idea of separating what is and isn’t in our control.

My notes

41
Land It family

Appreciative / What Is Working

Core move: Discover life-giving factors; do more of them
5 options10 questions5 situations

1What it really is

Deliberately discovering life-giving factors already present and doing more of them. Appreciation here is treated as data about what genuinely works — not as cheerleading or forced positivity.

Rooted in Appreciative Inquiry, developed by David Cooperrider, this method focuses on what is already working well, and why. The coach asks the client to describe times they were at their best, when the team was energised, or when things went right. Together they look for the specific conditions that made those moments possible, then design ways to create more of them. Success is studied as carefully as failure usually is.

It sounds like: “Tell me about a time when this team was at its best. What was happening?”, “What made that possible?”, or “How could you build more of that into next month?” It is not a way of ignoring problems, and it doesn’t ask the client to be positive when they are struggling. It works best once the difficulties have been fully heard. It has worked when the client identifies concrete, repeatable factors, and feels more energy and hope about the situation rather than less.

4How it works, deeply

The line between genuine appreciative inquiry and toxic positivity is thin and easy to cross. The discipline that keeps the method honest: hear the hit — the real disappointment, grief, or shame — fully first, before offering even one precise, specific resource. A generic list of past achievements offered to someone in an imposter-feeling state will land as gaslighting; a specific piece of evidence tied to their actual belonging story will land as genuine support.

Appreciative Inquiry is based on the idea that systems move in the direction of what they study. If an organisation focuses on problems, it learns a lot about problems; if it focuses on successes, it learns how to create more success. Studying peak moments reveals the specific conditions, behaviours and relationships that made them possible. These conditions are often transferable to current challenges in ways that problem analysis does not show.

The method also affects energy and motivation. Recalling moments of strength and success can raise confidence and engagement, providing fuel for change. However, the effect depends on authenticity. Positive questions must follow genuine acknowledgement of difficulty, or they will feel dismissive. When balanced well, appreciative questions create a sense of possibility that is grounded in evidence, which is far more durable than optimism alone.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Deficit trance; they have forgotten their own competence
The move
Discover life-giving factors and do more of them
Watch
Appreciation is not cheerleading. It is data about what works.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What is already giving life to this, even a little?
  2. When did you last handle a version of this well?
  3. What do you want more of, not only less of?
  4. If you designed from your strengths, what would you try?

2The client’s context

A “deficit trance” — forgotten competence, a period following a setback, or burnout where only the draining elements of life are currently visible to the client.

3The coach’s options

1Life-giving factors present now — even small, currently-overlooked ones.
2Past handling of a “cousin” problem — a similar challenge already successfully navigated before.
3Want-more-of, not just less-of — reframing the goal in positive rather than purely subtractive terms.
4Design from strengths — building the solution around existing capability, not around fixing a deficit.
5Harvesting contribution after a win they can’t own — specifically for clients who deflect credit.

5Where it gets stuck

It sounds like a pep rally. A client in genuine shame or grief experiences it as being gaslit rather than supported.

6How to move it forward

Hear the hit first, completely. Then offer exactly one precise resource. Pair it with a small act of continuation, not a wholesale mood shift.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What is already giving life to this, even a little?
  • When did you last handle a version of this well?
  • What do you want more of, not only less of?
  • If you designed from your strengths, what would you try?
  • What did you specifically do that made this possible?
Going further
  • What have you survived before that felt just as impossible at the time?
  • Who noticed you doing something well recently, that you brushed off?
  • What’s one thing you’re proud of that you haven’t said out loud yet?
  • If you had to teach someone else how you got through a hard version of this before, what would you tell them?
  • What’s already going right that you’ve stopped noticing because it’s become normal?

8Situations from the field

These are the recognizable situations where this method is a first-line or strong second-line move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation — not just to the topic’s content — is what separates a move that lands from one that bounces off.

S2.10Disappointed after a setback Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What is happening Deflation after effort, “why bother”Coach move Acknowledge the hit. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions
In the room
Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”
What’s underneath
The hit is real. Toxic positivity here breaks trust. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions. Smallest act of continuing.
Avoid here
Immediate next mountain. “Everything happens for…”
Example
Launch missed. Took: a quarter and a narrative. Did not take: their judgment with customers. Exception: 2019 dip → short learning review with one ally. Same move, sized small.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods59132241
S5.17After a win they can’t own Luck, team, timing — never them.
What is happening Luck, team, timing — never themCoach move Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update
In the room
Luck, team, timing — never them.
What’s underneath
Unowned wins do not update self-concept. Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update.
Avoid here
Fake humility praise.
Example
Turnaround attributed to “the team and timing.” Specifics: they set a weekly tradeoff meeting and killed two projects. Identity that updates: someone who designs conditions, not a spectator of luck.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods593841
S6.24Retirement or late-career transition Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What is happening End of career in sight; identity, structure and status about to changeCoach move Walk the timeline; find what carries forward; picture a wanted next chapter
In the room
Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What’s underneath
Retirement is an identity transition, not just a date. Work has provided structure, status and belonging. Without a picture of what replaces them, the end feels like a cliff. Grief and excitement can sit side by side.
Avoid here
Turning it into a hobby list. Assuming retirement means stopping all work. Rushing past the loss.
Example
A finance director with 30 years’ service plans to stop in six months. Timeline work shows the thread is developing people. The plan becomes two non-executive roles and a mentoring programme, not golf.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2123274143
S9.6Ending the engagement well Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.
What is happening Final session or sessions of an engagementCoach move Harvest learning; celebrate progress; plan how to continue without the coach
In the room
Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.
What’s underneath
Endings matter. A good ending helps the client own their progress, plan how to keep it going and leave with confidence rather than dependency.
Avoid here
Ending abruptly. Adding new topics at the last minute. Fostering dependency.
Example
In the last session, the client reviews their goals, names three key learnings, and writes a letter from their future self to keep.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods35384143
S9.13Team after a failure or setback Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.
What is happening Team has failed or had a setback; morale and trust are shakenCoach move Blame-free review; find what worked; agree what to change
In the room
Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.
What’s underneath
After a failure, teams tend either to look for someone to blame or to avoid the subject. Both waste the learning. A blame-free review that also finds what went well helps the team recover confidence and improve.
Avoid here
A blame hunt. Skipping the review. Forced positivity.
Example
A product launch fails. The coach runs a review in three parts: what happened, what we learned, what we’d keep. The team leaves with two process changes and renewed confidence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods5123841

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Toxic positivity immediately following a genuine setback.
  • Listing achievements at an imposter-feeling client without engaging the underlying belonging story.

10Client traps

  • Discounting what’s actually working as luck, the team’s effort, or timing rather than their own contribution.

Three worked problems

1

Disappointed after a failed launch. The hit is acknowledged first. Exception found: they’ve come back from a similar dip before by running a short learning review with one ally, not a full post-mortem tribunal. Smallest act of continuing: schedule that same review.

2

Imposter after a promotion. An evidence file and a belonging story are built together — fair, specific evidence, plus directly examining “who decided you don’t belong.” Not just a trophy list recited back.

3

Burned-out leader. Mapping what restores versus what drains. A 10% lighter week is designed, including what must actively stop. Recovery design comes before any performance coaching resumes.

Where it comes from

Appreciative Inquiry was developed by David Cooperrider and colleagues.

My notes

42
Land It family

Feedforward and Stakeholder Loop

Core move: Ask stakeholders for future suggestions and check in regularly on progress
5 options10 questions8 situations

1What it really is

Combines Marshall Goldsmith’s “feedforward” and stakeholder-centred coaching. Instead of asking for feedback on the past, the client asks a few key colleagues for suggestions for the future on one specific goal, thanks them without arguing, and checks back regularly. This involves the people around the client in the change, makes progress visible to them, and turns coaching from a private conversation into something the workplace can see.

This method brings the people around the client into the coaching. The client chooses one specific behaviour to improve and tells a few key colleagues about it. They then ask each person for one or two suggestions for the future, listen without arguing or explaining, and simply say thank you. Every few weeks they check back in: “How am I doing on this? What else would help?” Over time, colleagues notice the change and become part of making it stick.

It sounds like: “I’m working on listening better in meetings. Do you have one or two suggestions for how I could do that over the next few months?” It is not a 360-degree review, and it isn’t a request to discuss past mistakes; the focus stays forward. The client also doesn’t need to accept every suggestion, only to listen and thank. It has worked when the client follows through on regular check-ins, and when stakeholders start reporting that they have noticed the change.

4How it works, deeply

Feedback about the past invites defending and explaining. Suggestions about the future are easier to hear and easier to act on. Telling stakeholders what you’re working on also changes how they watch you: they start noticing the improvements, which closes the perception gap. Regular follow-up keeps the client accountable and makes the change visible to the system, which is usually where the change needs to be recognised.

Goldsmith’s approach recognises that behavioural change at work is judged by others, not just by the person changing. People often keep seeing a colleague in light of their past behaviour, even after it has improved. By telling stakeholders what they are working on and asking for suggestions, the client changes what others pay attention to. Regular follow-up keeps the change visible and gives stakeholders a stake in its success.

The discipline of saying only “thank you” to suggestions is important. Arguing or explaining discourages future input and can damage relationships, while gratitude encourages honest suggestions and shows openness to change. Goldsmith’s research with leaders found that those who followed up consistently with stakeholders were much more likely to be seen as improving, which shows that the process of follow-up matters as much as the change itself. The method also builds supportive relationships around the client.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Others still see the old version, or sponsored coaching needs visible progress
The move
Ask stakeholders for future suggestions on one goal, thank, follow up monthly
Watch
Thank only; never debate a suggestion.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What one behaviour should others notice change?
  2. Who sees it most often?
  3. How will you ask for suggestions?
  4. When will you check back?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Perception lag — Has changed, but others still see the old version.
  • Defensive about feedback — Rejects or argues with criticism of the past.
  • Unclear expectations — Doesn’t know what “good” looks like to their stakeholders.
  • Sponsored coaching — An organisation is paying and wants to see progress.
  • Change that relies on others — The goal involves how they work with peers, boss or team.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses how to set up the loop:

1Pick one goal — Agree one clear development goal stated in plain language.
2Choose stakeholders — Select 3–8 people who see the client’s work regularly.
3Ask for feedforward — “I’m working on X. What are two suggestions for how I could do that better in future?”
4Thank, don’t debate — Practise saying “thank you” and nothing else.
5Monthly pulse — A short follow-up: “Have I improved on this? Any new suggestions?”

5Where it gets stuck

The client asks for suggestions, then argues with them or explains why they won’t work. Or the loop starts well but the follow-ups quietly stop.

6How to move it forward

Rehearse the “thank you only” response. Schedule the follow-ups in the calendar during the session. Keep the questions very short so they are easy for busy stakeholders.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What is the one behaviour you most want others to notice changing?
  • Who sees this behaviour most often?
  • How will you ask them for suggestions for the future?
  • How will you respond when they give you a suggestion you disagree with?
  • When will you check back with them?
Going further
  • What would they need to see to believe you’ve changed?
  • What will you say to explain why you’re asking?
  • Which suggestion will you try first?
  • How will you share progress with your sponsor?
  • What would make it easy for them to keep giving input?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S7.11Managing up poorly Surprises the boss, or hides.
What is happening Surprises the boss, or hidesCoach move Boss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics
In the room
Surprises the boss, or hides.
What’s underneath
Managing up is service, not sucking up. Boss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics.
Avoid here
“Be more authentic” as the whole play.
Example
They optimize for craft; boss optimizes for no Friday surprises. Cadence: Thursday risk note. Service, not surrender.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods63742
S7.13Feeling unseen / credit stolen Heat + helplessness.
What is happening Heat + helplessnessCoach move Visibility design, documentation, allies, direct conversation
In the room
Heat + helplessness.
What’s underneath
Victim-only or aggression-only both usually fail. Visibility design, documentation, allies, direct conversation.
Avoid here
Only rumination or only war.
Example
Section landed in a peer’s deck. Clean: follow-up note with the original artifact copied to the sponsor. Ally already knows. Not a war; not silence.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3742
S7.15Received feedback they reject 360 sting. “That’s not me.”
What is happening 360 sting, “that’s not me”Coach move Separate grain from garbage. Impact vs intent
In the room
360 sting. “That’s not me.”
What’s underneath
Total rejection wastes the gift. Total collapse wastes the self. Grain from garbage. Impact vs intent.
Avoid here
“The 360 is the truth.” Or “ignore them.”
Example
“Arrogant.” Delivery was poor. 10%: they interrupt in design reviews. Want to be known for rigor and room for others. One behavior change, not a personality trial.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1542
S7.23Unclear expectations Aiming at a moving target.
What is happening Aiming at a moving targetCoach move Make the contract explicit. Success criteria
In the room
Aiming at a moving target.
What’s underneath
Mind-reading the scoreboard is optional. Asking is not. Make the contract explicit.
Avoid here
Working harder at a guessed target.
Example
Delivering a 40-page strategy nobody asked for. Scoreboard question to the sponsor this week. Assumed “depth = value.”
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1042
S7.36Returning from parental leave Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What is happening Back from parental leave; new identity, new demands, out of the loopCoach move Map the polarity; set clear agreements at work and home
In the room
Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.
What’s underneath
The client is adjusting to a new identity and a new set of demands. Work may have moved on. The tension between career and family is ongoing, not a problem to solve once. Clear agreements at work and at home matter.
Avoid here
Assuming they want less, or more, ambition. Treating guilt as a problem to eliminate.
Example
A software lead returns after a year. Coach maps the Work and Family polarity, and helps plan conversations with her boss about the first three months.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1821244042
S9.2Sponsor asks what the client said A manager or HR contact asks for updates or details from sessions.
What is happening Sponsor wants information about sessionsCoach move Restate the agreement; redirect to client-owned progress updates
In the room
A manager or HR contact asks for updates or details from sessions.
What’s underneath
The sponsor has a legitimate interest in progress, but not in session content. Confidentiality and reporting should be agreed upfront in a three-way contract. The client, not the coach, should own the progress updates.
Avoid here
Sharing session content. Being evasive without explaining why.
Example
An HR manager asks how sessions are going and what the client said about their boss. The coach explains the agreement and suggests the client gives a progress update in the next three-way meeting.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods14042
S9.3Three-way meeting with client and sponsor Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What is happening Formal alignment or review meeting with sponsor presentCoach move Prepare the client to lead; facilitate goals and observable signs of change
In the room
Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.
What’s underneath
Three-way meetings align goals and show progress. The client should lead, the coach facilitates, and the sponsor gives perspective. Preparation matters.
Avoid here
Coach speaking for the client. Revealing session content. Letting the sponsor dominate.
Example
Before the meeting, the coach helps the client rehearse what to share. In the meeting, the client presents goals, and the boss shares what they would notice changing.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods16263742
S9.12New or re-formed team with unclear roles Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.
What is happening Team is new or changed; roles and agreements are unclearCoach move Contract at team level: purpose, roles, decision rights, ways of working
In the room
Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.
What’s underneath
New teams need explicit agreements about purpose, roles and ways of working. Without them, people fill gaps based on old habits, and friction appears as personal conflict. Contracting at team level is the work.
Avoid here
Jumping to team-building games. Letting the leader define everything alone. Treating role confusion as a personality problem.
Example
After a merger, two teams become one. The coach runs a session where each person maps what they think they own. Gaps and overlaps become visible, and the team writes a one-page charter.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods163342

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Choosing too many goals at once.
  • Letting the client select only friendly stakeholders.
  • Skipping the follow-ups, which is where the value lies.
  • Breaking confidentiality by sharing session content with stakeholders.

10Client traps

  • Debating suggestions instead of thanking.
  • Asking once and never returning.
  • Choosing a goal that sounds good but isn’t what others actually want changed.

Three worked problems

1

“They still see me as the old me.” Client tells six colleagues they’re working on listening and asks for two suggestions each. Monthly pulses show steady improvement, and the boss mentions it in the review.

2

Manager who argued with feedback. Coach rehearses saying only “thank you.” The client notices it feels uncomfortable but gets more honest suggestions within two weeks.

3

Sponsor wants visible progress. Stakeholder loop gives the sponsor regular, client-owned evidence without the coach sharing any session content.

Where it comes from

Feedforward and stakeholder-centred coaching, associated with Marshall Goldsmith.

My notes

43
Land It family

Reflective Writing and Letters

Core move: Put it on paper: letters, logs and notes that carry the work between sessions
5 options10 questions6 situations

1What it really is

The coach invites the client to write: a short reflection after the session, a letter they may never send, a letter from their future self, or a simple evidence log of progress. Writing slows thinking down, makes vague feelings concrete, and creates a record the client can return to. It is a way of integrating insight and carrying the coaching into daily life.

This method uses writing to support the coaching between sessions. The form depends on what the client needs: a few lines of reflection after each session, a letter to someone that will never be sent, a letter from their future self, a journal of moments when they used a new skill, or a simple log of evidence that contradicts an old belief. The writing is private unless the client chooses to share it.

It sounds like: “Before our next session, would you be willing to write a letter you won’t send?” or “Each evening, note one moment you handled better than you used to.” It is not homework to be checked or graded, and it doesn’t need to be well written. Short and honest beats long and polished. It also isn’t for everyone; some clients prefer voice notes or drawings. It has worked when the client brings new insight from the writing into the session, or when looking back over their notes shows them progress they hadn’t noticed.

4How it works, deeply

Writing moves thoughts from a loop in the mind to a page that can be looked at. It forces specifics, which often reveals what matters. Unsent letters let strong feelings be expressed safely before deciding what to say for real. Evidence logs counter the mind’s tendency to forget small progress. And writing creates continuity between sessions, so the coaching keeps working when the coach isn’t there.

Research on expressive writing, notably by James Pennebaker, suggests that writing about thoughts and feelings can help people process experiences and may support wellbeing. Writing forces a degree of structure: the client must choose words and order, which can bring clarity to experiences that felt chaotic. Writing letters to or from specific people, including a future self, adds perspective and helps the client explore relationships safely.

Writing also extends coaching in time. A session lasts an hour, but reflection and change happen throughout the weeks between sessions. A simple log of progress counters the tendency to remember setbacks more vividly than successes, giving the client a more accurate picture of how they are doing. Reviewing past entries can reveal patterns and growth that weren’t visible at the time, often becoming a rich source of material for future sessions.

Quick card

Reach for it when
Insight fades between sessions, feelings need a safe outlet, or something is ending
The move
Offer a short writing form the client chooses and owns
Watch
Optional and short, or it becomes guilt-inducing homework.
Four questions that often open it
  1. What do you want to remember from today?
  2. Who would an unsent letter be to?
  3. What would your future self write?
  4. What evidence of progress could you note?

2The client’s context

A client needing this method usually shows up in one of these states:

  • Insight fades — Gets clarity in session, loses it by the next week.
  • Unsaid words — Has something to say to someone that can’t, or shouldn’t, be said directly yet.
  • Rumination — Thoughts spin at night with nowhere to go.
  • Endings — Leaving a role, finishing coaching, retiring or grieving a loss.
  • Thinks best in writing — Reflective, introverted or more articulate on paper than out loud.

3The coach’s options

The coach chooses among five writing forms:

1Session note — Three lines after each session: what I learned, what I’ll do, what I want to remember.
2Unsent letter — Write everything to the person or situation, without sending it.
3Letter from the future — Write from yourself a year ahead, describing what you did and what mattered.
4Evidence log — Note small wins and examples of the new behaviour weekly.
5Worry page — Write the worrying thought down at night with a time to look at it tomorrow.

5Where it gets stuck

Writing becomes homework the client feels guilty about not doing, or a long diary that repeats the same complaints.

6How to move it forward

Keep it very short and optional. Let the client choose the form. Ask them to bring one line from it to the next session rather than the whole thing.

7Questions to use

Core questions
  • What do you want to remember from today, in one sentence?
  • If you wrote a letter you’d never send, who would it be to?
  • What would your future self write to you about this time?
  • What small evidence of progress could you note each week?
  • What’s the shortest writing habit you’d actually keep?
Going further
  • What surprised you when you read back what you wrote?
  • What did the letter say that you haven’t said out loud?
  • What would you keep, and what would you cut, before sending a real message?
  • What pattern do you notice in your notes over the month?
  • What do you want to read again on a hard day?

8Situations from the field

These are the situations from the atlas where this method is a strong first or second move. Matching the method to the shape of the situation, not just the topic, is what makes a move land.

S2.8Grief / loss mixed into a work topic Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”
What is happening Role loss, champion left, identity ending, eyes wet when “professional”Coach move Name the loss. Allow a beat. Then ask what wants to be carried forward
In the room
Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”
What’s underneath
Grief is not a lesson yet. Reframing it into growth too fast is a small desecration and breaks trust. Name what is ending and what is not. Then ask what wants to be carried forward.
Avoid here
Immediate silver lining. Options. “Who do you need to be now” in the first minute.
Example
Sponsor leaves. Client wants a “stakeholder map.” First: name the loss of being believed without a slide.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods7233043
S3.9Rumination / same thoughts on repeat Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What is happening Circular why, no new dataCoach move Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination
In the room
Circular why. No new data. Same tape.
What’s underneath
More analysis of the same tape will not release it. Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination. Give its job another method.
Avoid here
Deeper why. Clean language on the same nouns for twenty minutes.
Example
Hundred loops of “why did they exclude me.” Job of rumination: prevent another surprise. Other method: a cadence question to the boss. Tape stops needing to play all night.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods141520303943
S5.1Insight without behavior change Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What is happening Beautiful ahas, same week as last monthCoach move Close the knowing-doing gap. Smaller, scheduled, observable acts
In the room
Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.
What’s underneath
Knowing-doing gap. More insight can become another hiding place. Integration is a scheduled act, not a better sentence.
Avoid here
Another brilliant why.
Example
Third “I need to stop rescuing.” Integration: one update they do not rewrite this week. Insight without that act is décor.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods1735383943
S6.24Retirement or late-career transition Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What is happening End of career in sight; identity, structure and status about to changeCoach move Walk the timeline; find what carries forward; picture a wanted next chapter
In the room
Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.
What’s underneath
Retirement is an identity transition, not just a date. Work has provided structure, status and belonging. Without a picture of what replaces them, the end feels like a cliff. Grief and excitement can sit side by side.
Avoid here
Turning it into a hobby list. Assuming retirement means stopping all work. Rushing past the loss.
Example
A finance director with 30 years’ service plans to stop in six months. Timeline work shows the thread is developing people. The plan becomes two non-executive roles and a mentoring programme, not golf.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods2123274143
S8.12Big insight just landed — needs integration Quiet. Wet eyes. “Oh.”
What is happening Quiet, wet eyes, “oh”Coach move Stop adding questions. Let it settle. Anchor in body and next hour
In the room
Quiet. Wet eyes. “Oh.”
What’s underneath
The next clever question can steal the insight. Stop. Anchor in body and next hour.
Avoid here
Stress-test. Another why.
Example
“I’ve been applying for my father’s approval in this job.” Stop. Body. One sentence written. No org-chart analysis today.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods3843
S9.6Ending the engagement well Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.
What is happening Final session or sessions of an engagementCoach move Harvest learning; celebrate progress; plan how to continue without the coach
In the room
Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.
What’s underneath
Endings matter. A good ending helps the client own their progress, plan how to keep it going and leave with confidence rather than dependency.
Avoid here
Ending abruptly. Adding new topics at the last minute. Fostering dependency.
Example
In the last session, the client reviews their goals, names three key learnings, and writes a letter from their future self to keep.
Full situation card: questions, more examples, sample exchange
Filed under methods35384143

9Coach mistakes & watch-outs

  • Making it compulsory homework.
  • Asking to read private writing the client didn’t offer.
  • Using an unsent letter as a substitute for a needed conversation.
  • Setting writing that is too long to sustain.

10Client traps

  • Writing the same complaint repeatedly without new reflection.
  • Sending the unsent letter in the heat of the moment.
  • Treating the writing as the change itself rather than a support for it.

Three worked problems

1

Insight that keeps fading. Client writes three lines after each session and rereads them on Monday mornings. Next sessions start from where the last one ended.

2

Anger at a former boss. An unsent letter lets everything out. The client then writes the two calm sentences they actually want to say in the exit meeting.

3

Ending a long coaching engagement. Client writes a letter from themselves a year ahead. It becomes the plan for continuing the work without the coach.

Where it comes from

Expressive and reflective writing (for example James Pennebaker’s research) and letter-writing practices from narrative therapy.

My notes

Situation Atlas

180 situations that come up in professional coaching, sorted into 9 groups. Each card shows what is happening and the recommended move at a glance. Open it for what you’ll see in the room, what the client might say, what’s underneath, questions that often open it, what to avoid, examples, a short sample exchange, signs it’s working, a look-alike not to confuse it with, and related situations. Start from what you see in front of you and jump to the move.

S1
Situation group · 21 situations

How the topic arrives

About this group

The first minutes of a session tell an attentive coach whether they are about to witness a living inquiry or sit through a press release. This group maps twenty-one recognizable ways a topic can arrive in the room — because the opening shape of a topic predicts, more reliably than its content, which method will actually move it. A topic told in fluent, unchanging sentences needs something different from a topic that arrives as a breathless list of six urgent things, which needs something different again from a topic that shows up as a single hesitant half-sentence after a long pause. The content might be identical across all three; the coaching is not.

What to listen for is less about what the client says than how they say it: speed of delivery, degree of polish, whose agenda is actually driving the topic (theirs, or someone who sent them), whether there is a concrete scene or only a slogan, whether the body appears to be present in the account at all, and whether the official title of the topic matches the heat you can actually feel in the room. These situations were chosen because each is a mismatch between surface and substance that a coach can learn to notice quickly: several topics at once usually means the real work is choosing one, not answering all of them. A long, detailed story usually means the useful move is finding its chapter title, not gathering more plot. A slogan ("I just need more balance") usually means the useful move is finding what a real Tuesday under that slogan would actually look like.

The discipline for this whole section is the same: hear the first telling once, all the way through, without interrupting to be clever. Then go under it. The first version a client offers is almost never wrong — it is just rarely complete, and the gap between what was said and what is true is where the coaching begins.

S1.1Telling a rehearsed story
Fluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotion
Expand: “What else?” / impact / feeling
In the room

Fluent narrative. Same phrases they have used with a partner, a friend, and a mirror. Little new language. Low emotion. They sound competent and slightly bored by their own plot.

It might sound like
  • So basically, as I said to my wife last night…
  • The short version is the same as always.
  • I've thought about this a lot, so I'll just walk you through it.
What’s underneath

The first version is almost never wrong; it is rarely complete. Rehearsal is a social technology: it keeps the story stable so the teller does not have to feel it again. Professional coaching needs the unstable layer — impact, pattern, the word they are not using.

Questions that often open it
  1. What else is true about this that you have not said yet?
  2. How does this affect you in your day-to-day — not the story, the impact?
  3. What are you feeling as you tell this, right now?
  4. If you said this for the first time, what word would you use that you are not using?
Avoid here

Preferred future too early (they have not arrived in the present). Reframe before they feel heard (lands as “you did not listen to my official version”). Generating options (there is no new material to option from). Pre-mortem (there is no plan; there is a performance).

Watch

Hear the first telling once. Then go under it. Do not interrupt to be clever.

Examples from the field
Example
A VP tells a smooth story of a “difficult stakeholder.” Dates, emails, tone. Coach hears it once, then asks for impact. New sentence: “I rewrite every message three times and I hate who I am at 11pm.” That sentence is the topic. The stakeholder is context.
Senior engineer
Retells the 'why I didn't get promoted' story with identical phrasing to last month. Coach asks what word they'd use if saying it for the first time: 'Invisible.' The session moves from the plot to visibility.
Nonprofit director
Polished account of a board conflict, delivered like a briefing. Coach asks what the story costs them day to day. Answer: 'I've stopped writing anything I care about in board papers.' That cost becomes the topic.
Sample exchange
Client

…and that's the whole saga, really. Same as always.

Coach

You've clearly told this before. What's true about it that hasn't made it into the telling yet?

Client

(pause) That I'm a bit relieved they said no.

Coach

Stay with relieved for a moment.

Signs it’s working

New words appear that the client hasn't used before, the pace slows, and they look surprised at their own sentence.

Don’t confuse with

S1.8 Story-looping / circling the same plot

Story-looping is the same plot repeated across sessions. A rehearsed story can be told well once; it's just polished, not stuck.

S1.2Stuck in the problem
Problem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted life
Preferred future / miracle / visualization
In the room

Problem trance. More analysis of what is wrong. Little or no picture of a wanted life. Verbs sit in the present-continuous of suffering. Options, if any, are all forms of “stop the pain,” not “live something.”

It might sound like
  • I just keep going round what's wrong with this team.
  • Honestly, I don't even know what good would look like.
  • Every option is just a way of making it hurt less.
What’s underneath

Solution-focused and narrative work share a claim: options generated against a fog of not-wanting tend to be reactive and forgettable. The nervous system orients toward what it can picture. No picture, no true choice.

Questions that often open it
  1. If this were fully handled, what would be different tomorrow morning?
  2. Suppose overnight a miracle happens and the problem is gone — you are asleep so you do not know. What is the first sign that tells you something has changed?
  3. Imagine you one year from now, having handled this well. What did that person do? Who did they become?
  4. If I could see a short film of a good Tuesday after this is resolved, what would I see and hear?
Avoid here

Future questions while flooded (capacity is offline — regulate first). More analysis, clean language on problem-words only, or option-generation from inside the trance. Pre-mortem (adds more doom to a doom-only map).

Watch

Do not ask future questions while they are flooded. Ground first.

Examples from the field
Example
Product lead can describe six reasons a launch is doomed. Miracle first sign: they open Slack without a spike in the chest, and the stand-up starts with one risk, not twelve. Piece already slightly true on Thursdays after a run. Experiment: protect that Thursday condition twice this week, then look at the launch from there.
Operations lead
Forty minutes analysing a broken handover process. Miracle question: 'I'd walk in and not check Slack first.' That first sign becomes the design spec.
Career changer
Every option is framed as escape from the current job. Coach asks for a film of a good Tuesday a year from now. Teaching, not consulting, shows up in the picture.
Sample exchange
Client

It's the meetings, the politics, the budget, all of it.

Coach

Suppose tonight it's sorted while you sleep. What's the first thing you notice tomorrow?

Client

I'd… actually want to open my laptop.

Coach

What would you open first?

Signs it’s working

Verbs shift from 'stop' and 'avoid' to 'want' and 'would', and a concrete scene appears.

Don’t confuse with

S2.1 Emotionally flooded / activated

A flooded client may look stuck, but needs grounding before any future question. Stuck-in-problem clients are calm enough to imagine.

S1.3Certain their view is the only one
Absolute language, “obviously”, no curiosity about other readings
Perspective shift / reframe / assumptions
In the room

Absolute language. “Obviously.” “Anyone can see.” No curiosity about other readings. Tight jaw. They came for an ally, not a second chair.

It might sound like
  • Obviously they're doing it on purpose.
  • Anyone with eyes can see what's going on.
  • There's no other way to read it.
What’s underneath

Certainty often does the job anxiety used to do: it removes ambiguity. Challenging the person feels like theft of that safety. Challenge the frame, never their intelligence for building it. Frames were almost always adaptive once.

Questions that often open it
  1. What are you assuming that might not be true?
  2. How would the other person tell the same facts?
  3. If there were three other interpretations, what would they be?
  4. What would a person you respect see that you are not seeing?
Avoid here

Early reframe as correction. Argument. Joining the prosecution. Miracle question (they do not lack a picture; they lack plurality).

Watch

Challenge the frame, not their intelligence.

Examples from the field
Example
“The board is anti-innovation.” After being heard: respected-chair lens — they are anti-surprise. Options change from “braver deck” to “pre-wire two directors.” Certainty loosens without a lecture on open-mindedness.
Sales director
Certain finance is blocking their deal out of spite. Coach asks how finance would tell the same facts. 'They'd say we never sent the margins.' Curiosity returns.
Head of product
Certain the CEO has 'given up on' their team. Three other readings are generated; one, that the CEO is distracted by fundraising, is checkable by Friday.
Sample exchange
Client

It's obvious. He wants me out.

Coach

That's one reading. If there were two others, what might they be?

Client

I suppose he might just be swamped. Or testing me.

Coach

Which of the three could you check this week?

Signs it’s working

Absolutes soften ('probably', 'maybe'), and the client proposes a way to test their reading.

Don’t confuse with

S2.3 Angry / blaming / righteous heat

Righteous anger is about heat and dignity; certainty is about a locked interpretation. Anger needs validating first; certainty needs a gentle second chair.

S1.4Vague
“Things feel off”, “leadership”, “balance” with no picture
Scaling / “What would we see if we filmed it?”
In the room

“Things feel off.” “Leadership.” “Balance.” “I need to be more strategic.” No Tuesday. No camera shot.

It might sound like
  • I just need more balance.
  • It's about leadership, generally.
  • Things feel a bit off, but I can't put my finger on it.
What’s underneath

Abstraction protects. As long as the topic stays a noun with no scene, no one can fail at it and no one can finish it. Advanced coaching operationalizes: values, identities, and moods become behavior in a room at a time of day.

Questions that often open it
  1. On a 1–10, where is this now — and what does that number look like on a Tuesday?
  2. If we filmed a good week versus this week, what would we see and hear?
  3. When you say that word, what do you actually mean in behavior?
  4. What would +1 on the scale look like in one concrete scene?
Avoid here

Coaching the slogan. More values language. Big identity work with no scene. Generating a 10-step “confidence plan.”

Watch

Do not coach the abstraction. Coach the scene.

Examples from the field
Example
“I just need more balance.” Film: current Tuesday is Slack at 21:40. +1 is laptop closed at 19:00 two nights, calendar invite to themselves. Balance stops being a personality project.
New VP
'I need to be more strategic.' Coach: 'If we filmed you being strategic on Tuesday, what would we see?' Answer: blocking two hours before the ops review. Now it's doable.
Parent returning to work
'Balance' becomes: leaving at 17:15 three days a week without apologising. The apology turns out to be the real topic.
Sample exchange
Client

I want to show more presence.

Coach

If I filmed you with more presence in Thursday's meeting, what would I see?

Client

Me speaking in the first ten minutes. Not waiting.

Coach

What's the first sentence you'd say?

Signs it’s working

The abstract noun turns into a scene with a day, a place and an observable behaviour.

Don’t confuse with

S1.17 Very little language / “I don’t know”

Vague clients have plenty of words but no picture. 'I don't know' clients have few words at all and need more structure.

S1.5Overwhelmed
Too much at once, pressure, no foothold
Exceptions, resources, +1 on the scale
In the room

Too much at once. Pressure. No foothold. Lists. Breathless. Body ahead of language, or language sprinting to outrun the body.

It might sound like
  • I don't even know where to start.
  • There's just too much on.
  • If one more thing lands, I'll snap.
What’s underneath

An overloaded system cannot use a big plan. Load reduction and resource-finding are regulation, not soft extras. +1 and exceptions restore a sense of authorship without pretending the load is imaginary.

Questions that often open it
  1. When is this even 10% less heavy — what is different then?
  2. What is already working, even a little?
  3. On a 1–10, where are you — and what already got you off the floor?
  4. What would a 10% lighter week include? What must stop?
Avoid here

Giant homework. Preferred-future montage. Pre-mortem (more future weight). Who-would-you-need-to-be as a heroic identity.

Watch

Do not add a big homework plan to an overloaded system.

Examples from the field
Example
Six workstreams plus a sick parent. Exception: last Thursday when they declined two meetings. +1: decline the standing Thursday review that produces no decisions. Not a life-redesign.
Clinic manager
Short-staffed, audit due, a child unwell. Scale says 2. What got them off 1? A colleague covering a shift. +1 is asking that colleague for one more, not a new rota system.
Founder
Fundraising, hiring and a product bug at once. Exception: the week they paused investor calls. +1 is a two-day calls-free window, not a strategy offsite.
Sample exchange
Client

Everything's urgent. All of it.

Coach

When was it even ten percent lighter recently?

Client

Last Wednesday. I skipped the steering group.

Coach

What made skipping it possible?

Signs it’s working

Breathing slows, the client names one thing they could drop, and the plan gets smaller rather than bigger.

Don’t confuse with

S1.10 Dumping everything at once / multiple topics

Overwhelm is about load and nervous-system state. Dumping multiple topics is about focus. Overwhelm needs load reduction; dumping needs a choice.

S1.6Intellectualizing
Models, analysis, “interestingly”, little felt experience
Body, emotion, metaphor, silence
In the room

Models, analysis, “interestingly.” Little felt experience. They will happily discuss adult-development stages of their own avoidance.

It might sound like
  • Interestingly, there's a framework for this…
  • From a systems perspective, it's fascinating.
  • I've read a lot on attachment styles, so I get why I do it.
What’s underneath

Cognition ahead of felt experience gets rejected by the nervous system even when accurate — and here cognition is the defense. Out-analyzing them rewards the defense. Sideways routes (body, image, silence) restore data they have edited out.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where do you feel this in your body as you talk?
  2. If the analysis stepped aside for 30 seconds, what is here?
  3. If this topic were weather, a place, or an object, what would it be?
  4. (After a charged sentence) … What just happened there?
Avoid here

Question cube as more architecture. Systemic reframe as another framework. Any method that stays in third-person analysis.

Watch

Do not out-analyze them. That rewards the defense.

Examples from the field
Example
Client maps their “avoidance pattern” with a 2x2. Coach does not add a quadrant. “If the 2x2 stepped aside…” Throat tight. Weather: locked archive room. Work becomes the unsent two-line message, not a better map of avoidance.
Consultant
Ten minutes explaining their pattern through Kegan's stages. Coach: 'Where is that in your body right now?' Long pause. 'My throat.' The work begins there.
Data scientist
Treats a breakup at work as a model to optimise. Coach asks for a weather image. 'Fog over a harbour.' Feeling enters without a lecture about feelings.
Sample exchange
Client

Theoretically, it's a classic approach–avoidance conflict.

Coach

If the theory stepped aside for thirty seconds, what's here?

Client

(quiet) I'm scared they'll find out I'm not that good.

Coach

Thank you. Let's slow down there.

Signs it’s working

Sentences get shorter, the client uses 'I feel' rather than 'one might', and the analysis pauses on its own.

Don’t confuse with

S3.12 Data-only / feeling-blind

Data-only clients ignore feelings in decisions. Intellectualizing uses ideas to avoid their own felt experience in the moment.

S1.7Ready to move
Forward energy, asks for next step, new language already appearing
Options, experiments, who they would need to be
In the room

Forward energy. They ask for the next step. New language already appearing. Lean-in, brighter voice, “so what I need to do is…”

It might sound like
  • Okay, so what do I actually do Monday?
  • I think I've got it. What's the move?
  • I want to try something this week.
What’s underneath

Continued exploration at this point is often the coach’s need for thoroughness. Readiness is perishable. Land while the nervous system is still organized toward action.

Questions that often open it
  1. What options do you see — including unwise ones?
  2. What are you willing to try, by when, and how will we know it happened?
  3. Who would you need to be to take that step?
  4. If you were already the person who handles this easily, how would you walk in?
Avoid here

More expand. Miracle question. Clean language archaeology. Another reframe “to be sure.”

Watch

Do not over-explore when the energy has already turned forward.

Examples from the field
Example
After naming “I have been managing their mood,” client is already drafting a sentence. Coach skips another why. One dated conversation Friday. Success = it happened.
Team lead
Insight lands in minute 25: 'I've been rescuing them.' Coach doesn't explore further but asks for one experiment: stay silent in standup for the first five minutes.
Executive
Leaning forward, new language. Coach offers the pivot explicitly; client picks action. A dated email is drafted before the hour ends.
Sample exchange
Client

Right. I see it now. What do I do?

Coach

What's the smallest thing you'd be willing to try before we meet again?

Client

Tell Sam I'm not reviewing his deck anymore.

Coach

When, and what's your first sentence?

Signs it’s working

The client commits to something dated and specific and leaves with energy still high.

Don’t confuse with

S1.19 Jumping straight to solutions

Ready-to-move clients have already found new understanding. Jumping-to-solutions clients skip the understanding altogether.

S1.8Story-looping / circling the same plot
Repeats events, more detail, no new insight, time passing
Stop the plot. Move to meaning, pattern, or wanted future
In the room

Repeats events. More detail. No new insight. Time passing. You could transcribe last month and this month and they would match.

It might sound like
  • So then, again, she did the same thing…
  • I know I've told you this.
  • It just keeps happening the same way.
What’s underneath

More plot rarely creates change. Repetition usually means the intervention is at the wrong level — or the loop is protecting them from an act, a feeling, or an ending.

Questions that often open it
  1. We've got the story. What is the question this story is asking?
  2. What do you want this to mean from here?
  3. If all these details were a chapter title, what would it be?
  4. What would be different if we did not retell the events and only worked the pattern?
Avoid here

Expand-for-more-detail. Clean language on plot nouns. Sympathy that invites another lap.

Watch

More plot rarely creates change. Name the loop kindly.

Examples from the field
Example
Third retelling of a board ambush. Chapter title: “I keep going in without a sponsor.” Level change: one pre-wire this week, or park the topic.
Product manager
Third session on the same difficult stakeholder, same detail. Coach changes level: 'What does this keep teaching you about yourself?' The loop is about being liked.
Partner at a firm
Circles a decision for six weeks. Coach names the loop and asks what not deciding protects. 'If I don't choose, I can't disappoint either partner.'
Sample exchange
Client

And then, again, the email from Priya…

Coach

I notice we've been here before. What's this loop protecting you from?

Client

Having to actually say no to her.

Coach

That sounds like the real topic.

Signs it’s working

The plot stops, the client names the pattern or its function, and a different level opens (identity, system or experiment).

Don’t confuse with

S3.9 Rumination / same thoughts on repeat

Rumination is the client's private replay, usually alone at night. Story-looping is the same plot brought into session after session.

S1.9Skimming / staying on the surface
Short answers, “it’s fine”, jumps topics, jokes away
Slow down. One thread. Reflect + silence. Invite the unsaid
In the room

Short answers. “It’s fine.” Jumps topics. Jokes away. No dwell time.

It might sound like
  • It's fine, honestly.
  • Anyway, what else…
  • Ha, you know how it is.
What’s underneath

Surface is often safety, not shallowness. Chasing every new topic they offer as escape trains the dodge. One thread + silence is the intervention.

Questions that often open it
  1. If we stayed with just this one sentence, what is under it?
  2. What aren’t you saying yet?
  3. You moved off that quickly. May we go back one sentence?
  4. What would make it safe enough to stay here for two minutes?
Avoid here

And-what-else as a machine gun. Deep identity work before safety. Challenge.

Watch

Do not chase every new topic they offer as escape.

Examples from the field
Example
Client hopscotches from team to school to a podcast they heard. Coach returns to “it’s fine.” Under it: they were copied off a thread. Two minutes there is the hour.
Graduate hire
Lists five 'fine' things. Coach returns to one: 'You said the review was fine.' Silence. 'I cried after it.' That thread is the session.
Senior leader
Jumps from strategy to holiday to a podcast. Coach slows, picks the one sentence where their voice dropped, and waits.
Sample exchange
Client

Work's fine. Team's fine. Anyway, did I mention the offsite?

Coach

Can we go back to 'team's fine' for a moment?

Client

(shrug) It's… mostly fine.

Coach

(waits)

Signs it’s working

The client stays with one thread for more than a minute and their answers get longer.

Don’t confuse with

S1.13 Avoiding the real topic

Skimming touches many topics lightly. Avoiding the real topic picks one safe topic and stays there, while the heat sits elsewhere.

S1.10Dumping everything at once / multiple topics
Long list, urgency, no priority, breathless
Contract. Choose the thread with the most energy
In the room

Long list. Urgency. No priority. Breathless. They watch to see which fire you will pick.

It might sound like
  • Okay, I've got a list today.
  • There's six things, and they're all urgent.
  • Where do you want to start?
What’s underneath

The list is data. The session still needs one focus. Several topics at once usually means the real work is choosing, not answering all of them.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you could resolve only one thing today, which one?
  2. Which item has the most heat?
  3. If this list is a weather report, where is the storm?
  4. What would make this hour useful even if the rest of the list waits?
Avoid here

Trying to land six micro-plans. Expanding every item. Being the project manager.

Watch

Their list is data. The session still needs one focus.

Examples from the field
Example
Reorg, hire, board pack, leave-question. Heat is on the leave-question when they say it. Contract twenty minutes there; the rest becomes context for whether they stay.
School principal
Budget, an inspection, a parent complaint, staffing, a personal decision. Coach asks which has the most heat. It's the personal decision; the rest becomes context.
Startup COO
Rattles off eight items. Coach: 'If only one moved this week, which would make the others easier?' Hiring a finance lead unlocks four of them.
Sample exchange
Client

…and the audit, and the offsite, and my review.

Coach

If only one changed by Friday, which would you pick?

Client

Honestly? Whether I'm staying.

Coach

Twenty minutes on that, then we check in?

Signs it’s working

The client chooses one topic, and the others are explicitly parked or reframed as context.

Don’t confuse with

S1.5 Overwhelmed

Dumping is a focus problem and the client can still think. Overwhelm is a capacity problem where choosing itself feels impossible.

S1.11Over-specific / lost in detail
Names, dates, emails, who said what
Zoom out to pattern, purpose, and what they want instead
In the room

Names, dates, emails, who said what. Inbox as the room.

It might sound like
  • So on the 14th she replied-all with…
  • I have the thread here if you want to see.
  • Then at 3:42 he said…
What’s underneath

Detail can be a hiding place — from feeling, from pattern, from a decision. Harvest one pattern, then leave the inbox.

Questions that often open it
  1. If all these details were a chapter title, what would it be?
  2. What is the pattern across the details?
  3. What do you want from all this detail — to be understood, or to change something?
  4. What would you keep if you could only keep the meaning, not the inbox?
Avoid here

Following each email. Clean language on every proper noun.

Watch

Details can be a hiding place. Harvest one pattern, then leave the inbox.

Examples from the field
Example
Twelve-message CC war. Chapter title: “I will not ask directly.” Pattern, then one request. Inbox closed.
Project manager
Reading emails aloud verbatim. Coach: 'What do all these emails have in common?' 'I'm always the one fixing.' Pattern harvested; inbox closed.
Lawyer
Precise timeline of a dispute. Coach asks how it felt at the moment the timeline turned. Detail gives way to betrayal.
Sample exchange
Client

…and then on Thursday at 4pm, the second email arrived.

Coach

If you zoomed out from the inbox, what's the pattern across all of it?

Client

I'm always the last to know.

Coach

How long has that been the pattern?

Signs it’s working

Names and dates fade, and a single pattern or feeling becomes the focus.

Don’t confuse with

S1.1 Telling a rehearsed story

A rehearsed story is polished and summarised. Over-specific detail is exhaustive and unpolished, and gets lost in the trees.

S1.12Bringing someone else’s agenda
“My boss said I should…”, partner booked them, HR sent them
Separate assigned topic from their topic. Restore ownership
In the room

“My boss said I should…” Partner booked them. HR sent them. Official topic sits beside a quieter live one.

It might sound like
  • HR said I should work on my presence.
  • My partner booked this, to be honest.
  • My boss thinks I need coaching on delegation.
What’s underneath

Coaching requires authorship. You can work the overlap between organizational want and client want. You cannot become the organization’s enforcer and still be their coach.

Questions that often open it
  1. What part of this is yours?
  2. If no one had sent you, what would you want to work on?
  3. What does the organization want — and what do you want?
  4. Where do those two overlap enough to work today?
Avoid here

Running the company’s curriculum. Ignoring the assigned topic entirely without naming the fork (can blow up sponsorship). Advice on how to “perform presence.”

Watch

Do not become the organization’s enforcer.

Examples from the field
Example
Assigned: executive presence. Owned: credit stolen by a peer. Overlap: one visible moment Thursday. Both agendas honored; neither colonizes the hour.
Engineering manager
Sent to 'improve communication'. Their own stake: being heard in architecture reviews. The overlap, one review this month, becomes the contract.
Finance director
Board-mandated coaching. Coach names the fork: the board's agenda and theirs. Client chooses succession planning, which serves both.
Sample exchange
Client

My manager wants me to be more strategic.

Coach

And what would you want from these sessions, if it were up to you?

Client

To stop doing my team's job.

Coach

Where do those two overlap?

Signs it’s working

The client finds their own stake and uses 'I want' about the topic.

Don’t confuse with

S1.13 Avoiding the real topic

Someone else's agenda is openly assigned. Avoiding the real topic is the client's own choice of a safer issue.

S1.13Avoiding the real topic
Safe issue up front, energy elsewhere, late-session reveal
Follow energy, not the official title. Name the mismatch
In the room

Safe issue up front. Energy elsewhere. Late-session reveal. Mismatch between words and heat.

It might sound like
  • I wanted to talk about time management.
  • It's probably nothing, but…
  • (at minute 50) Oh, one more thing…
What’s underneath

Avoidance is information about cost and safety, not a character flaw. Name the mismatch; do not ambush. They choose.

Questions that often open it
  1. The words are about X, the energy seems to be about Y. Which one wants air today?
  2. If we named the thing under this, what might it be?
  3. What would it cost to put the real topic on the table?
  4. What are you protecting by staying with the safer issue?
Avoid here

Clever “gotcha.” Deep dive with eight minutes left. Reframe of the safe topic as if it were the work.

Watch

Do not ambush. Offer the observation and let them choose.

Examples from the field
Example
Official: calendar. Heat: “my partner booked this.” Offer the observation. They choose the authorship topic. Calendar was the costume.
Marketing lead
Official topic: prioritisation. Heat rises at 'my manager's new hire'. Coach names the mismatch; client chooses to talk about feeling replaced.
Physician
Brings rota planning. Voice cracks on 'my last patient'. Coach offers the observation gently and lets them choose.
Sample exchange
Client

…so yes, just better calendar habits.

Coach

Can I share something I noticed? Your energy changed when you mentioned your partner booked this.

Client

(pause) Yeah. That's the actual thing.

Coach

Would you like to go there today?

Signs it’s working

The client chooses the real topic themselves, and the room feels more alive, not ambushed.

Don’t confuse with

S1.15 Confidential / shame-tinged topic

A shame-tinged topic may be avoided, but it needs extra pace and safety once it's named, not just a re-contract.

S1.14First time saying it out loud
Hesitation, “this may sound silly”, long pause before the sentence
Safety first. Witness. Do not rush to fix or reframe
In the room

Hesitation. “This may sound silly.” Long pause before the sentence. Voice changes.

It might sound like
  • This might sound silly, but…
  • I've never actually said this out loud.
  • Don't laugh, okay?
What’s underneath

Being heard is the intervention. Insight can wait. A reframe here is a small violence: it teaches them that this room, too, will rush to tidy what they just risked.

Questions that often open it
  1. Thank you for trusting this here. What is it like to hear yourself say it?
  2. What becomes possible now that it is in the room?
  3. What did you need in order to say it?
  4. What do you want us to do with it — hold it, understand it, or move it?
Avoid here

Immediate reframe, options, miracle, challenge.

Watch

Insight can wait. Being heard is the intervention.

Examples from the field
Example
“I think I want to leave the field.” Coach does not build an exit plan. First work: they hear themselves. Then they choose hold vs move.
Accountant
'I think I want to be an artist.' Coach reflects the sentence back and waits. No plan this session. The client hears themselves say it.
Senior nurse
'I don't think I love this anymore.' Coach doesn't reassure or problem-solve, and asks what it was like to say it.
Sample exchange
Client

(long pause) I think I want to leave medicine.

Coach

(slowly) You want to leave medicine.

Client

Wow. I've never said that out loud.

Coach

What's it like to hear it?

Signs it’s working

The client breathes out, may repeat the sentence, and chooses for themselves whether to explore or simply hold it.

Don’t confuse with

S2.9 Hopeful / lit up for the first time

Hope lit up for the first time is energised and wants to move. A first-time disclosure is fragile and wants witnessing.

S1.15Confidential / shame-tinged topic
Lowered voice, looking away, moral language
Normalize, bound confidentiality, go at their pace, separate person from act
In the room

Lowered voice. Looking away. Moral language. “I shouldn’t have…”

It might sound like
  • I shouldn't have done it, I know.
  • Can this stay between us?
  • I'm not proud of this.
What’s underneath

Shame hears challenge as further verdict. Separate person from act before any learning. Confidentiality and pace are methods, not preamble.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would make this safe enough to explore?
  2. What would a compassionate witness say?
  3. You are not the act. What is the pattern, and what do you want instead?
  4. What pace do you need from me?
Avoid here

Pry. Cheerleading “you’re great.” Diagnosis. Immediate experiment they will use as more evidence of defect if it fails.

Watch

Do not pry. Do not collapse into reassurance that blocks exploration.

Examples from the field
Example
Client whispers about losing their temper in a 1:1. Separate: the snap is behavior. Pattern: Friday depletion. Clean learning: Friday is not a feedback day. No identity trial.
Manager
Shouted at a direct report. Coach separates person from act first, then explores repair. Learning only after the client feels they aren't on trial.
Executive
Hid a mistake from their board. Coach re-checks confidentiality and pace, then asks what a clean repair would look like.
Sample exchange
Client

(quietly) I lied in the review.

Coach

Thank you for trusting me with that. Take your time.

Client

I don't know who I am when I do that.

Coach

You're more than that moment. What would repair look like?

Signs it’s working

The voice returns to normal volume and the client moves from verdict ('I'm terrible') to repair ('I could…').

Don’t confuse with

S2.5 Ashamed / self-attacking

Ashamed/self-attacking is a general emotional state. A shame-tinged topic is about one specific act the client feels they must hide.

S1.16Talking very fast / flooding with words
No pauses, stacked clauses, little breath
Pace down. Reflect one piece. Ask for the headline
In the room

No pauses. Stacked clauses. Little breath. Fog increases if you match them.

It might sound like
  • And then, and also, and the other thing is—
  • Sorry, I'm rambling.
  • Let me just get it all out.
What’s underneath

Speed is often anesthesia or an attempt to get it all in before they are interrupted (history of not being given the floor). Pacing down is regulation. Headline restores choice.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you had only one sentence, what is the heart of this?
  2. Can we take a breath and pick the thread that matters most?
  3. I want to make sure I have the center. What is the center?
  4. What happens if we slow the last sentence down?
Avoid here

Matching speed. And-what-else rapid fire. Complexifying.

Watch

Matching their speed increases fog.

Examples from the field
Example
Seven-minute sentence about a reorg. Coach: one sentence. “I don’t know if I have a job.” That is the hour.
Hospital administrator
Five minutes of rota detail in one breath. Coach lowers their own voice and pace and says nothing for a beat. The client slows too, then: 'I haven't had a day off in six weeks.'
Researcher
Overlapping clauses about funding. Coach invites a breath and a headline. The headline is about their PhD supervisor, not the grant.
Sample exchange
Client

…and the budget and then the deadline moved and also—

Coach

(slower) Let's pause. One breath. If it were one sentence?

Client

(exhales) I'm not sure I'm good enough for this job.

Coach

Let's start there.

Signs it’s working

The client's pace slows to match the coach's, and a clear headline appears.

Don’t confuse with

S2.1 Emotionally flooded / activated

Flooding with words is fast and verbal. Emotional flooding is visibly physical (tears, shaking) and needs grounding first.

S1.17Very little language / “I don’t know”
Shrugging, one-word answers, blank look
Offer structure: scale, image, guess, body, either/or
In the room

Shrugging. One-word answers. Blank look. Long gaps that are empty rather than working.

It might sound like
  • I don't know.
  • Dunno, maybe.
  • Nothing really.
What’s underneath

“I don’t know” is often “I haven’t looked yet” or “it is unsafe to know.” Structure is kindness: scale, image, guess, either/or. Staring them down is not presence.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you had to guess, what would you guess?
  2. Point to it on a 1–10.
  3. If it had a color or weather, what would it be?
  4. Would it help to choose between two starting points I name, or to sit in silence for a moment?
Avoid here

Wide open “what do you want from your life.” Challenge. Question cube.

Watch

“I don’t know” is often “I haven’t looked yet” or “it is unsafe to know.”

Examples from the field
Example
New director, one-word answers. Two doors: “the role, or the loneliness in it.” They pick loneliness. Language appears once the door is smaller.
Apprentice
One-word answers. Coach offers either/or: 'Is it more the work or the people?' 'People.' Scale: 'How bad, 1–10?' '7.' Movement begins.
Senior analyst
Blank look. Coach invites a guess: 'If you did know, what might it be?' The guess is accurate.
Sample exchange
Client

I don't know.

Coach

If you had to guess — no wrong answer — is it more about the role or the manager?

Client

The manager. I guess.

Coach

On a scale of 1 to 10, how much?

Signs it’s working

Answers lengthen, and the client starts to offer images or numbers without being prompted.

Don’t confuse with

S2.2 Numb / flat / shutdown

Very little language may be a style or unfamiliarity with reflection. Numbness is a low-energy state across everything.

S1.18Humor as deflection
Jokes at the exact moment of heat, self-mockery
Smile with them, then return to the moment before the joke
In the room

Jokes at the exact moment of heat. Self-mockery. Room laughs; topic dies.

It might sound like
  • Ha, well, that's my life!
  • Classic me, right?
  • Anyway, enough of my tragedy.
What’s underneath

Humor is often a gifted regulator. Do not kill it. Use it as a doorway back to the sentence before the joke.

Questions that often open it
  1. The joke came right after something important. Can we go back one sentence?
  2. What did the humor just protect?
  3. If we took the joke seriously as a clue, what is it pointing at?
  4. What is the unfunny version of what you just said?
Avoid here

Tight-faced “let’s be serious.” Ignoring the joke and losing the heat marker.

Watch

Do not kill humor. Use it as a doorway.

Examples from the field
Example
“My team doesn’t need me — lucky them!” Return. Unfunny version: fear of becoming ornamental after promotion. Work that.
Creative director
Jokes right after 'my team doesn't need me'. Coach smiles, then reflects the sentence before the joke. Their face changes.
Sales lead
Self-mocking about a lost deal. Coach: 'That got a laugh — what's under the laugh?' 'Embarrassment, mostly.'
Sample exchange
Client

My team doesn't need me — ha, maybe I should take up golf!

Coach

(smiles) The joke came right after 'my team doesn't need me'.

Client

(pause) Yeah. That one stings.

Coach

Tell me about the sting.

Signs it’s working

The humour stays, but the client can also return to the sentence before it without deflecting.

Don’t confuse with

S1.9 Skimming / staying on the surface

Skimming moves on quickly through many topics. Humour deflects at one specific moment of heat.

S1.19Jumping straight to solutions
Action list before the topic is understood
Pause action. Check if the problem is the real problem
In the room

Action list before the topic is understood. “So I just need to…” in minute four.

It might sound like
  • So I just need to…
  • I've already got a plan, I just want your view.
  • Let's skip to what I should do.
What’s underneath

Premature plans recycle the old frame. Sometimes action-hunger is anxiety management. Distinguish a planning hour from an understanding hour — and let them choose if both are live.

Questions that often open it
  1. What are we solving, exactly?
  2. If that plan worked, what would it give you that you want?
  3. What would you miss if we skipped understanding and only built the plan?
  4. Is this a planning hour or an understanding hour?
Avoid here

Helping them polish the premature plan. More options on an unexamined problem.

Watch

Premature plans recycle the old frame.

Examples from the field
Example
Client arrives with a 9-point script for a fight with their peer. “If it worked, what would it give you?” “I want to stop being erased.” Understanding hour: erasure pattern. Then a shorter request, not a 9-point prosecution.
Department head
Arrives with a full restructure plan for a team they took over last month. Coach: 'What problem is this plan for?' The answer is a trust problem, which a restructure wouldn't fix.
Founder
Wants a script for firing a co-founder. Coach checks: planning hour or understanding hour? Client picks understanding; the script later shrinks to three lines.
Sample exchange
Client

So I'll set up weekly one-to-ones, a dashboard, and—

Coach

Before the plan, what's the problem you most want it to solve?

Client

Honestly? I feel like nobody tells me anything.

Coach

Let's understand that first.

Signs it’s working

The plan becomes shorter and better aimed after the client understands what it's for.

Don’t confuse with

S1.7 Ready to move

Jumping to solutions comes before any insight. Ready to move comes after new insight has appeared in the session.

S1.20Wanting a diagnosis or label
“What’s wrong with me?”, “Am I a bad leader?”
Stay descriptive, not diagnostic. Separate identity from pattern
In the room

“What’s wrong with me?” “Am I a bad leader?” They want a verdict they can either collapse under or fight.

It might sound like
  • What's wrong with me?
  • Am I just a bad manager?
  • Is there a name for what I do?
What’s underneath

Labels shrink possibility. Coaching describes patterns and choices. Diagnosis-hunger is often a wish for the uncertainty to end.

Questions that often open it
  1. I will not diagnose you. What pattern are you noticing?
  2. What do you want instead of the pattern?
  3. If we dropped the label, what would we be working on?
  4. What would a fair description be, without a verdict?
Avoid here

Informal diagnosis (“you’re a classic imposter”). Therapy-speak beyond contract. Reassurance only.

Watch

Labels shrink possibility. Coaching describes and chooses.

Examples from the field
Example
“Am I an alcoholic leader or just stressed?” Coach stays in scope: the Friday snap pattern, sleep, what they want instead. Flag other support if clinical. No verdict from the coaching chair.
Team leader
'Am I a narcissist?' Coach doesn't diagnose; asks which behaviour they want to change. 'Interrupting.' That's workable.
Young professional
Wants an MBTI explanation for procrastination. Coach describes the pattern and choice instead, and asks when it doesn't happen.
Sample exchange
Client

Just tell me. Am I a bad leader?

Coach

I'm not going to label you. What's a moment you'd like to have led differently?

Client

Tuesday. I froze in the all-hands.

Coach

Let's look at Tuesday.

Signs it’s working

The client stops asking for a verdict and starts describing behaviours they can choose.

Don’t confuse with

S4.9 Outsourcing judgment to the coach

Outsourcing judgment asks the coach to decide. Wanting a label asks the coach to define who they are.

S1.21Comparing this to last time / “we already covered this”
Impatience, “I know this”, cynicism
Honor the known. Ask what is new in this version
In the room

Impatience. “I know this.” Cynicism. They grade the hour against a previous insight.

It might sound like
  • We already covered this.
  • I know, I know, I need to delegate.
  • This feels like groundhog day.
What’s underneath

Repeating a topic is not failure. Integration may be missing. Knowing is not living. Honor the known; ask what is different about this week’s living.

Questions that often open it
  1. You know the content. What is different about living it this week?
  2. What still doesn’t shift even though you know?
  3. What would integration look like, not more insight?
  4. What have we been repeating instead of doing?
Avoid here

Re-teaching the same insight more brilliantly. Shame about repetition.

Watch

Repeating a topic is not failure. Integration may be missing.

Examples from the field
Example
“We covered delegation.” Living it this week: they still took the deck back on Sunday. Integration = stop-doing list with their boss, not another article on empowerment.
Director
Rolls eyes at delegation again. Coach: 'You know it. What's different about it today?' 'Today it's costing me my weekends.' The stakes are new.
Coach-savvy client
'We did this in March.' Coach asks what made March's insight hard to live. The integration gap becomes the topic.
Sample exchange
Client

We literally talked about this last month.

Coach

You did. What's different about it now?

Client

I actually tried it. And it didn't stick.

Coach

What got in the way of it sticking?

Signs it’s working

Cynicism eases and the client gets curious about the gap between knowing and doing.

Don’t confuse with

S8.10 Repeating the same topic session after session

Repeating the same topic session after session is the coach's pattern to name. 'We already covered this' is the client's impatience in one moment.

S2
Situation group · 17 situations

Inner weather

About this group

The nervous system sitting in the chair is part of the topic, not a distraction from it. A client describing a stalled project while flooded with anxiety and the same client describing it from a numb, shut-down state are, functionally, presenting two different coaching problems, even though the words on the page would look identical in a transcript. This group maps seventeen recognizable emotional states — flood, numbness, anger, anxiety, shame, guilt, grief, hope, disappointment, envy, and more — because each one changes which questions are physiologically usable in the moment, for both people in the room, not just which questions are strategically wise.

The logic connecting these seventeen situations is regulation before content. If the client is flooded, the coach's job is presence and pacing, not a future-oriented question — asking someone mid-flood to visualize their preferred future is like asking someone to read a map while the building is on fire; the capacity for that kind of thinking simply is not online yet. If the client is numb or shut down, the fix is not enthusiasm turned up to ten — that usually deepens the shutdown — but the volume raised by a single careful notch: a small question, a tiny scale, a gentle exception. If shame is running, the pattern must be separated from the person's identity before anything resembling a challenge is introduced, because a person in shame hears any challenge as further proof of the verdict they have already passed on themselves. And if hope has just arrived — often visible as a genuine smile, new language, a lean forward — the coach's job is to harvest it immediately, not stress-test it; hope is fragile in its first minutes and dies quickly under premature scrutiny.

None of this is a detour from professional coaching into therapy. Emotion here is being treated as data: information about what the topic actually costs the client and what it is asking for, which is exactly the kind of information a coach needs in order to choose the next question well.

S2.1Emotionally flooded / activated
Tears, shaking voice, heat, can’t finish sentences
Safety, presence, breath, smaller slice. No big future questions yet
In the room

Tears, shaking voice, heat, cannot finish sentences.

It might sound like
  • Sorry, I don't know why I'm crying.
  • I can't — give me a second.
  • I'm so angry I can't think.
What’s underneath

High arousal takes prefrontal capacity offline. Asking for a preferred future mid-flood is map-reading while the building is on fire. Presence and slice-size are the methods.

Questions that often open it
  1. We can slow this. What do you need right now to stay with it?
  2. What is the feeling asking for?
  3. Do you want to stay with this, take a minute, or change the size of the slice?
  4. What would make this 10% more holdable?
Avoid here

Miracle, future-self, pre-mortem, challenge, question cube, stacked powerful questions.

Watch

Do not stack powerful questions. Regulate first.

Examples from the field
Example
Client breaks on “they announced the role without telling me.” Coach does not ask what future-them would do. Slice: this feeling, two minutes, feet on the floor. Later they choose a request to the sponsor — after speech returns.
Programme manager
Voice shaking after a client called their work 'amateur'. Coach slows down, invites a breath and offers water. The feedback is only discussed once their sentences come back.
Executive
Shaking voice after a board attack. Coach names what they see, keeps sentences short, and saves any future-focused question for the next session.
Sample exchange
Client

(crying) I can't believe they did that—

Coach

Take your time. Feel your feet on the floor. There's no rush here.

Client

(breathing) Okay. Okay.

Coach

What do you need right now?

Signs it’s working

Breathing evens out, sentences become complete again, and the client can choose what to do next.

Don’t confuse with

S1.16 Talking very fast / flooding with words

Talking fast is verbal speed with the body less involved. Flooding is physical arousal where thinking capacity is temporarily offline.

S2.2Numb / flat / shutdown
Monotone, “whatever”, low energy, no charge
Gentle sensory/body, tiny scales, exception, warmth without pressure
In the room

Monotone. “Whatever.” Low energy. No charge.

It might sound like
  • Whatever. It doesn't matter.
  • I don't really feel anything about it.
  • Fine. Sure.
What’s underneath

Shutdown is not the absence of a topic; it is a nervous-system setting. Turning enthusiasm to ten usually deepens it. Raise volume one notch: tiny scale, flicker, safe sliver.

Questions that often open it
  1. If the volume on this were turned up one notch, what would we hear?
  2. When did you last feel even a flicker of this?
  3. Where is there even 5% of sensation or care?
  4. What would be too much to feel right now — and what is a safe sliver?
Avoid here

Rally speeches. Who-you-need-to-be as a trumpet. Preferred-future cinema.

Watch

Pushing for passion can deepen shutdown.

Examples from the field
Example
“Career is fine I guess.” 5% care: they still notice ugly slide design. Tiny act: one craft conversation. Aliveness returns without a purpose workshop.
Operations director
Monotone after a third reorg. Coach doesn't push energy; asks for one small sensation: 'What's one thing that still bothers you, even slightly?'
Doctor
Flat after a long run of nights. Coach checks wellbeing and sleep, and keeps the session small and slow.
Sample exchange
Client

It's all the same. I don't care anymore.

Coach

If there were one small thing that still bothered you, even a little, what would it be?

Client

…That nobody asked me.

Coach

Nobody asked you.

Signs it’s working

A flicker of feeling appears (irritation, sadness, a small want) without the client being pushed.

Don’t confuse with

S2.16 Burned out / depleted

Burnout includes exhaustion, cynicism and dread. Numbness can be one part of it, or appear briefly after a shock.

S2.3Angry / blaming / righteous heat
Other-focus, injustice language, clenched jaw
Validate the heat, then separate fact / interpretation / want
In the room

Other-focus. Injustice language. Clenched jaw. They want a witness for the prosecution.

It might sound like
  • It's completely unacceptable what they did.
  • Anyone would be furious.
  • I want you to agree this is unfair.
What’s underneath

Anger is often a protector of dignity, boundary, or grief. Do not moralize it; do not join the case. Sequence: validate heat → separate fact / interpretation / want → find the clean request.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is the anger protecting?
  2. If the anger had a clean request, what would it be?
  3. What happened — and what did you make it mean?
  4. What do you want to have happen from here, not only what they did?
Avoid here

Immediate perspective-take (“have you considered their side”) — feels like betrayal. Cheerful reframe.

Watch

Do not moralize their anger. Do not join the prosecution.

Examples from the field
Example
Rage at a peer who “stole” a project. Anger protecting: not being erasable. Clean request: shared ownership memo + a conversation. Prosecution energy drops when dignity has a next act.
Senior engineer
Furious a peer took credit. Coach validates the heat, then separates what's theirs to move. One clean conversation is planned.
Store manager
Blames head office for everything. Coach asks what the anger is protecting. 'My team's dignity.' That becomes a request to head office.
Sample exchange
Client

He's a liar and everyone knows it.

Coach

That's a lot of heat. What is the anger protecting for you?

Client

My reputation. Years of work.

Coach

What part of that can you act on?

Signs it’s working

The client moves from prosecuting the other person to naming their own want or boundary.

Don’t confuse with

S4.1 Victim stance / it’s all them

Victim stance feels powerless. Anger feels powerful and righteous. Both blame, but anger has energy that can become a request.

S2.4Anxious / catastrophizing
What-if chains, worst-case movies, body tension
Present facts vs forecast. Scale likelihood. Small next experiment
In the room

What-if chains. Worst-case movies spoken as present fact. Body tension.

It might sound like
  • What if it all falls apart?
  • I just know the launch will flop.
  • I can't stop thinking about worst cases.
What’s underneath

Anxiety collapses time: forecast becomes now. Ground in known vs imagined. Scale likelihood. Coping-even-if. A 2% safer next step. Do not debate the catastrophe (argument feeds it).

Questions that often open it
  1. What is known versus imagined right now?
  2. If the worst case is 10, how likely is it on a 1–10?
  3. Even if it happened, what would you do?
  4. What is a 2% safer next step?
Avoid here

Pre-mortem as first move (rehearses failure). Miracle question if they cannot leave the movie. “It won’t happen.”

Watch

Do not debate the catastrophe. Ground it.

Examples from the field
Example
“I will be fired in the town hall.” Known: agenda has their update. Imagined: public humiliation chain. Likelihood they actually name: 3. 2% safer step: walk the update with an ally tonight. Tree stops growing.
Project lead
'The client will cancel.' Coach separates known from imagined and scales likelihood: 30%. A coping-even-if plan drops it further.
New manager
Catastrophising about a first review. Coach asks for the smallest safer step: a practice run with one peer.
Sample exchange
Client

If this presentation goes wrong, I'm finished.

Coach

What do you actually know right now, and what are you imagining?

Client

I know it's on Friday. The rest is… imagined.

Coach

If it did go badly, how would you cope?

Signs it’s working

The client separates forecast from fact and finds a small coping step.

Don’t confuse with

S3.2 Catastrophic forecast as fact

Catastrophic forecast is a thinking pattern that can be calm. Anxiety is the emotional and physical state that comes with it.

S2.5Ashamed / self-attacking
“I’m such an idiot”, collapsing posture
Separate person from behavior. Compassion without skipping learning
In the room

“I’m such an idiot.” Collapsing posture. They beat you to the punch.

It might sound like
  • I'm such an idiot.
  • I always ruin things.
  • Before you say it, I know it was stupid.
What’s underneath

Shame already passed a verdict. Any challenge sounds like more evidence. Separate person from behavior first. Rescuing (“no you’re great”) can block the look they need.

Questions that often open it
  1. If a colleague you respect did the same thing, what would you say to them?
  2. What does shame want you not to look at?
  3. What is the behavior, and who are you besides it?
  4. What would clean learning look like without extra punishment?
Avoid here

Challenge. Reframe-as-pep-talk. Immediate public experiment.

Watch

Rescuing (“no you’re great”) can block the look they need.

Examples from the field
Example
Missed a number in a forum. Shame wants them not to look at the skipped rehearsal. Clean learning: rehearsal ritual. Extra punishment: a week of self-prosecution — named and dropped.
Analyst
After a data error: 'I'm useless.' Coach separates person from behaviour and asks what someone who cared about them would say.
Team lead
Beats the coach to every criticism. Coach doesn't rescue; asks what this harsh voice is trying to protect.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm hopeless. I always mess it up.

Coach

You made a mistake on Tuesday. Is that the same as being hopeless?

Client

…No. It just feels like it.

Coach

What would a friend who knows your work say?

Signs it’s working

The client uses behaviour language ('I made') rather than identity language ('I am').

Don’t confuse with

S1.15 Confidential / shame-tinged topic

A shame-tinged topic concerns one hidden act. Self-attack is the general tone the client turns on themselves.

S2.6Guilty / over-responsible
Should have, my fault, I ruined it
Sort responsibility: mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination
In the room

Should have. My fault. I ruined it. They carry structural events as personal sin.

It might sound like
  • It's all my fault.
  • I should have seen it coming.
  • I've let everyone down.
What’s underneath

Guilt can be a hidden form of control: if it is all mine, I am not powerless. Sort mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is actually yours to own?
  2. What would clean responsibility look like, without extra punishment?
  3. What repair is needed — and what rumination is extra?
  4. What are you keeping by holding all of it?
Avoid here

“It’s not your fault” as a blanket (they will not believe it, and some piece may be theirs). More rumination disguised as processing.

Watch

Guilt can be a hidden form of control.

Examples from the field
Example
Reorg hurt their team. Theirs: how they communicated. Not theirs: the headcount decision. Repair: honest meeting. Rumination: nightly replay — extra.
Department head
Blames themselves for redundancies decided by the board. Mine / ours / not mine sort reveals one real repair and a lot of borrowed guilt.
Carer and manager
Guilty about both roles. Coach separates rumination from repair; one apology and one boundary emerge.
Sample exchange
Client

I ruined the project for everyone.

Coach

Let's sort it. What part was yours, what was shared, and what wasn't yours?

Client

The deadline was mine. The budget cut wasn't.

Coach

What would repair look like for your part?

Signs it’s working

Responsibility gets sized accurately and the client names one repair action instead of endless regret.

Don’t confuse with

S4.11 Over-owning other people’s emotions

Over-owning others' emotions is about carrying feelings. Guilt is about carrying blame for events.

S2.7Afraid of being seen / visibility anxiety
Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speaking
Future-self who can be seen. Tiny exposure. Identity vs skill
In the room

Avoids stage, meetings, credit, speaking. Over-prepares then ducks.

It might sound like
  • I'd rather someone else presented it.
  • I don't like being the centre of attention.
  • I'll prepare more, then decide.
What’s underneath

Often a belonging story, not a skills gap. Identity vs skill. Tiny exposure beats a forced keynote. Hiding has a protective job and a cost.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would be at risk if you were fully visible?
  2. Who would you be if being seen were allowed?
  3. What is a tiny, safe-enough exposure this week?
  4. What does hiding protect — and what does it cost?
Avoid here

“Just believe in yourself.” Giant first stage. Listing achievements only (imposter cousin).

Watch

Do not force a big stage as the first experiment.

Examples from the field
Example
Avoids speaking in the ops forum. Risk: being found ordinary. Tiny exposure: 60 seconds on one metric, ally in the room. Not the offsite keynote.
Researcher
Avoids conference talks. Coach finds the belonging story ('people like me don't speak'). Tiny exposure: asking one question at a seminar.
Engineer
Ducks credit in reviews. Experiment: name one contribution in Thursday's standup.
Sample exchange
Client

I'll let my manager present our results.

Coach

What would being seen cost you?

Client

If I'm visible, they'll see I don't belong.

Coach

What's the smallest way to be seen this week?

Signs it’s working

The client agrees to a small, specific act of visibility and names the fear behind avoiding it.

Don’t confuse with

S6.2 Imposter feelings

Imposter feelings are about doubting competence. Visibility anxiety is about the exposure itself, even when competence is clear.

S2.8Grief / loss mixed into a work topic
Role loss, champion left, identity ending, eyes wet when “professional”
Name the loss. Allow a beat. Then ask what wants to be carried forward
In the room

Role loss, champion left, identity ending. Eyes wet while they stay “professional.”

It might sound like
  • I know it's just a job, but…
  • It feels silly to be this upset about a reorg.
  • She was the reason I stayed.
What’s underneath

Grief is not a lesson yet. Reframing it into growth too fast is a small desecration and breaks trust. Name what is ending and what is not. Then ask what wants to be carried forward.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is ending here?
  2. What is not ending?
  3. What would honoring this look like?
  4. What do you want to carry forward from what was lost?
Avoid here

Immediate silver lining. Options. “Who do you need to be now” in the first minute.

Watch

Do not reframe grief into a lesson too fast.

Examples from the field
Example
Sponsor leaves. Client wants a “stakeholder map.” First: name the loss of being believed without a slide.
Charity manager
Their flagship programme is closed by a funder. They ask for a transition plan. Coach first names what's being lost (eight years of work and a community) before any planning.
Founder
Selling the company. Grief for the identity of 'founder'. The session simply names what is ending.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm being stupid, it's just a team change.

Coach

It sounds like something mattered to you. What's ending?

Client

(tears) The people who knew me.

Coach

That's a real loss.

Signs it’s working

The client stops apologising for the feeling and can name what's ending and what continues.

Don’t confuse with

S2.10 Disappointed after a setback

Disappointment follows one setback. Grief follows the loss of something lasting: a role, a person, an identity.

S2.9Hopeful / lit up for the first time
Energy rise, new language, smile, leaning in
Harvest it. Make it specific. Lock a small embodiment
In the room

Energy rise. New language. Smile. Lean-in.

It might sound like
  • Oh — I've never thought of it like that!
  • That actually excites me.
  • Wait, I could do that, couldn't I?
What’s underneath

Hope is fragile in its first minutes and dies under premature scrutiny. Harvest. Make specific. Lock a small embodiment. Do not immediately stress-test.

Questions that often open it
  1. Stay with this. What just became possible?
  2. What is the smallest way to keep this alive this week?
  3. Where do you feel this hope in your body?
  4. What would protect this from being talked away?
Avoid here

Pre-mortem. “But what if.” More analysis to make it robust.

Watch

Do not immediately stress-test the hope.

Examples from the field
Example
First genuine “I could try for the role.” Harvest. Body: lift in chest. Keep-alive: tell one safe person. No SWOT of the application today.
Teacher
Lights up imagining a curriculum role. Coach harvests: 'Say it in one sentence.' Then one small embodiment: asking the head about it this week.
Sales manager
Sees a new way to lead their team. Coach slows the urge to over-plan and locks one specific practice.
Sample exchange
Client

I could actually run the pilot myself!

Coach

Say that again — slower.

Client

I could run the pilot.

Coach

What's one thing you'd do this week that proves it's real?

Signs it’s working

The client leaves with the hope intact and one small, concrete act attached to it.

Don’t confuse with

S2.15 Over-excited / manic planning

First-time hope is quiet and fragile. Manic planning is loud and spreads into ten projects.

S2.10Disappointed after a setback
Deflation after effort, “why bother”
Acknowledge the hit. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions
In the room

Deflation after effort. “Why bother.”

It might sound like
  • Why do I even bother?
  • All that work for nothing.
  • Maybe I'm just not cut out for this.
What’s underneath

The hit is real. Toxic positivity here breaks trust. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions. Smallest act of continuing.

Questions that often open it
  1. What did the setback take, and what did it not take?
  2. When have you come back from a similar dip?
  3. What does this setback mean about you — and what else could it mean?
  4. What is the smallest act of continuing?
Avoid here

Immediate next mountain. “Everything happens for…”

Watch

Toxic positivity here breaks trust.

Examples from the field
Example
Launch missed. Took: a quarter and a narrative. Did not take: their judgment with customers. Exception: 2019 dip → short learning review with one ally. Same move, sized small.
Bid manager
Lost a major tender. Coach acknowledges the hit, separates the event from identity, and finds the next small act of continuing.
Athlete turned coach
Not selected for a role. Coach asks what they did well that they want to keep.
Sample exchange
Client

Six months of work and they picked someone else.

Coach

That really hurts. What do you want to remember about how you worked?

Client

I actually did my best work on that bid.

Coach

What's the smallest next step that keeps that going?

Signs it’s working

The client acknowledges the hurt and names something they still value about their effort.

Don’t confuse with

S2.11 Embarrassed after a public miss

Disappointment is about an outcome not arriving. Embarrassment is about being seen to fail in public.

S2.11Embarrassed after a public miss
Replay of meeting, heat in face, reputation fear
Normalize the human moment. Extract one learning. Design repair if needed
In the room

Replay of the meeting. Heat in face. Reputation fear.

It might sound like
  • Everyone saw me freeze.
  • I keep replaying it.
  • I can't face them on Monday.
What’s underneath

Embarrassment wants completion of a cycle: one learning, repair if needed, next showing. Minimizing leaves the loop running at 1am.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is the story you fear others are telling?
  2. What repair or next showing would you respect?
  3. What is one thing you want to do differently next time — only one?
  4. What would completion of this cycle look like?
Avoid here

“Everyone forgets.” Ten-point improvement plan (punishment).

Watch

Do not minimize. Help them complete the cycle.

Examples from the field
Example
Wrong figure in a board pack. Feared story: “sloppy.” Repair they respect: corrected note today + one process change. Cycle completes; 1am court adjourns.
Manager
Blanked in front of the board. Coach completes the cycle: one learning, a short follow-up note, and a plan for the next showing.
Junior lawyer
Corrected publicly by a partner. Coach asks what repair, if any, is needed, and what they'd do differently.
Sample exchange
Client

I just stood there in silence. Everyone saw.

Coach

What's one thing you learned from it?

Client

I need notes, not a script.

Coach

And what's your next chance to show that?

Signs it’s working

The replay stops because the loop is complete: learning named, repair done or decided, next showing planned.

Don’t confuse with

S2.5 Ashamed / self-attacking

Embarrassment is about one public event. Self-attack is a general harsh voice about oneself.

S2.12Lonely in the role / “no one gets it”
Isolation, peer gap, can’t talk at home or work
Name the isolation. Build a support design, not only inner work
In the room

Isolation. Peer gap. Cannot talk at home or work.

It might sound like
  • Nobody gets what this role is like.
  • I can't talk about this at home.
  • It's lonely at this level.
What’s underneath

Insight without a place to belong often fades. This is not only inner work. Design support. The coach is not their only peer.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where is it unsafe to tell the truth?
  2. What kind of company do you actually need?
  3. Who could hear 20% more of this than they hear now?
  4. What can this coaching hold — and what else do you need besides coaching?
Avoid here

More self-reliance identity. Only inner resilience.

Watch

Insight without a place to belong often fades.

Examples from the field
Example
New country manager. Coaching holds the weekly sense-making. Also: one external peer and one in-country ally. Belonging design, not just “hold the loneliness better.”
New CEO
No peers inside. Coach supports sense-making and designs one external peer group and one internal confidant.
Solo practitioner
Isolated running a practice. Experiment: a monthly peer call with two other owners.
Sample exchange
Client

There's nobody I can be honest with.

Coach

Who could be one person, outside work or inside, who'd understand part of this?

Client

Maybe the CFO at my last company.

Coach

When could you contact her?

Signs it’s working

The client names specific people and plans contact, rather than just enduring loneliness.

Don’t confuse with

S7.16 Lonely at the top / no peers

Lonely at the top is specifically about seniority and lack of peers. Lonely in the role can happen at any level.

S2.13Resentful / bitter
Kept score, “after all I did”, tightness
Find the unmet contract. Turn resentment into a request or a boundary
In the room

Kept score. “After all I did.” Tightness.

It might sound like
  • After everything I've done for them…
  • I'm keeping score, honestly.
  • Nobody ever thanks me.
What’s underneath

Resentment is often an unmet contract that was never spoken. Venting without a request keeps them stuck. Turn into a request or a boundary — or a clean decision to stop waiting.

Questions that often open it
  1. What did you give that was never agreed?
  2. What would a clean boundary or ask be now?
  3. What are you still waiting for that you have not requested?
  4. What would you need to stop doing so the resentment can move?
Avoid here

More venting as the whole method. Moral lecture about gratitude.

Watch

Venting without a request keeps them stuck.

Examples from the field
Example
Covered a peer’s region for a year. Never agreed; never asked. Clean ask or stop covering. Bitterness was unpaid invoice plus silence.
Product owner
Has run QA testing for a sister team for months 'just to help'. Coach asks what the unspoken deal was. A clear handback date replaces the quiet bitterness.
Co-founder
Bitter about doing all the ops work. The unspoken contract is named and renegotiated.
Sample exchange
Client

I've been covering for them for a year.

Coach

Did you ever agree to that, out loud?

Client

No. I just… did it.

Coach

What would you like to ask for now?

Signs it’s working

Venting becomes a specific request, a boundary or a clear decision to stop waiting.

Don’t confuse with

S2.3 Angry / blaming / righteous heat

Anger is hot and immediate. Resentment is cold and stored up over time, usually around an unspoken deal.

S2.14Envious / comparing
Their title, their ease, social proof
Use envy as a compass: what does it point to that they want?
In the room

Their title, their ease, social proof. Then self-attack for being envious.

It might sound like
  • Must be nice, being them.
  • I hate that I'm jealous.
  • They got promoted and I didn't.
What’s underneath

Shame about envy hides useful data. Envy is a compass: it points to a want. Work the want, not the character trial.

Questions that often open it
  1. What does this person represent that you want?
  2. What is your version of that, not theirs?
  3. What is the envy asking you to develop or claim?
  4. What happens if you take 10% of the wanting without the self-attack?
Avoid here

Moralizing. Imitation plan that copies their life.

Watch

Shame about envy hides useful data.

Examples from the field
Example
Envy of a peer’s keynote ease. Want: to be at ease being seen. Their version: a 60-second forum speak, not that peer’s brand.
Designer
Envies a peer's speaking slots. Coach: 'What does that point to that you want?' 'To be known for my ideas.' That want becomes the goal.
Academic
Comparing publication counts. Coach separates the want from the self-attack about being envious.
Sample exchange
Client

It's petty, but I'm so jealous of her.

Coach

If envy were a compass, what would it be pointing at?

Client

Being asked my opinion by the leadership team.

Coach

What's one way to move toward that?

Signs it’s working

Self-judgement about envy fades and a clear personal want appears.

Don’t confuse with

S6.9 Comparing to a past self

Comparing to a past self looks back at who you used to be. Envy looks sideways at someone else.

S2.15Over-excited / manic planning
Huge vision, no sleep, ten projects
Channel the energy. Sequence. Risk-check without killing it
In the room

Huge vision. No sleep. Ten projects.

It might sound like
  • I've got ten ideas, and they're all brilliant!
  • I barely slept, I'm buzzing.
  • Let's do everything!
What’s underneath

Do not match the high. Be the ballast. Channel, sequence, risk-check without killing life.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you could only keep one of these for 30 days, which one?
  2. What would future-you thank you for not starting?
  3. What is the sequence, not the pile?
  4. What would “this energy, with a ballast” look like?
Avoid here

Matching with more vision. Shame about the high.

Watch

Do not match the high. Be the ballast.

Examples from the field
Example
Ten-project founder week. Keep the customer-evidence project 30 days. Pre-mortem on scope only. Energy stays; pile shrinks.
Founder
Ten new projects after a good quarter. Coach stays calm, helps sequence, and keeps one project for 30 days.
Department head
Back from a conference with huge plans. Coach checks sleep and capacity, and runs a quick pre-mortem on scope.
Sample exchange
Client

We could launch three products this quarter!

Coach

There's real energy here. If you could only keep one for thirty days, which?

Client

…The customer pilot.

Coach

What would make that one fail?

Signs it’s working

The energy stays but the list shrinks, and the client agrees a sequence.

Don’t confuse with

S2.9 Hopeful / lit up for the first time

Hope is fragile and needs protecting. Manic planning needs grounding and sequencing so the energy isn't wasted.

S2.16Burned out / depleted
Cynicism, exhaustion, Sunday dread, numbness + irritability
Energy before strategy. Recovery design. Reduce load, don’t add homework
In the room

Cynicism. Exhaustion. Sunday dread. Numbness plus irritability.

It might sound like
  • I dread Sunday evenings.
  • I'm running on empty.
  • I just don't care anymore, and that scares me.
What’s underneath

Do not coach peak performance on an empty tank. Energy before strategy. Reduce load; do not add homework. Recovery is the strategy.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is draining versus restoring?
  2. What would a 10% lighter week include?
  3. What must stop?
  4. What would recovery look like before we talk performance?
Avoid here

Who-you-need-to-be-as-a-high-performer. Big plans. Appreciation as pep.

Watch

Do not coach peak performance on an empty tank.

Examples from the field
Example
Sunday dread + cynicism. Must stop: Sunday night pre-writes for a meeting that never decides. Recovery design first. Performance later.
Teacher
Exhausted and cynical. Coach doesn't set goals; explores load reduction and recovery, and suggests a GP visit.
Consultant
Sunday dread for months. One experiment: protected Saturday with no laptop. Energy before strategy.
Sample exchange
Client

I just can't keep doing this.

Coach

Before any plan, what would help your energy this week?

Client

One evening with no email.

Coach

Which evening?

Signs it’s working

The conversation is about recovery, not performance, and the client takes something off their plate.

Don’t confuse with

S2.2 Numb / flat / shutdown

Numbness can be brief or situational. Burnout is long-lasting depletion with cynicism and dread. Consider referral if it's severe.

S2.17Afraid of hope / waiting for the other shoe
Won’t celebrate, discounts wins
Explore the protective logic of not hoping. Tiny allowed hope
In the room

Will not celebrate. Discounts wins. Superstitious caution.

It might sound like
  • Let's not jinx it.
  • Something will go wrong, it always does.
  • It's not a big deal, really.
What’s underneath

Not-hoping is a protective logic after previous crashes. Forcing celebration feels naive. Tiny allowed hope. Evidence they would need.

Questions that often open it
  1. What does not-hoping protect you from?
  2. What would a 5% safer hope look like?
  3. What has hoping cost you before?
  4. What evidence would you need to let 10% of this be real?
Avoid here

Party hats. Immediate stretch goals.

Watch

Forcing celebration can feel naive to them.

Examples from the field
Example
After a previous failed promotion cycle. Not-hoping protects against public hope-then-humiliation. 5% safer: write the contribution list privately. Not a LinkedIn announcement.
Manager
Wins a major contract and won't celebrate. Coach invites a tiny allowed hope and one witness to the win.
Returner
Got the job after a long gap. Fears it will be taken away. Coach explores what they'd need to trust it a little.
Sample exchange
Client

It's good news, but I don't want to get excited.

Coach

What would five percent of hope look like?

Client

Telling my sister.

Coach

Would you be willing to?

Signs it’s working

The client allows a small, safe acknowledgement of the good thing.

Don’t confuse with

S5.17 After a win they can’t own

After a win they can't own is about taking credit. Afraid of hope is about trusting that good things will last.

S3
Situation group · 16 situations

The mind’s frame

About this group

Clients do not only bring events into the room. They bring a way of reading events — a cognitive frame built up over years, largely invisible to the person using it, that decides in advance what a given fact is allowed to mean. Two people can experience the identical Tuesday and walk away with opposite conclusions about their competence, their prospects, or their worth, purely because of the frame each was reading it through. This group maps sixteen of the most common frames a coach will meet: binary thinking, catastrophic forecasting spoken as present fact, mind-reading other people's intentions, over-generalizing from a single event, duty language standing in for want, fixed-mindset identity claims, complexity used as a hiding place, and more.

The coaching move across all sixteen is the same in structure even though the surface technique differs: question the topic itself — the assumption quietly embedded inside the story — without prosecuting the person who holds it. This distinction is the difference between coaching and correcting. Challenge the frame, never the person's intelligence for having built it; frames like these were almost always adaptive once, and are being carried out of genuine loyalty to a lesson that used to be true. Particularize the word "always" until it becomes one instance. Translate "should" back into want, value, fear, or someone else's borrowed voice, so the client can see whose sentence they are actually speaking. Put an abstract slogan into a concrete scene — "confidence" becomes a specific Tuesday-afternoon meeting, not a permanent character trait to acquire.

Two opposite failure modes sit at either end of this section. When complexity has become a hiding place — endless frameworks, endless stakeholders, no decision — the coaching move is to simplify ruthlessly down to the actual choice in front of the client. When a slogan has become the hiding place instead — fluent language with no scene behind it — the coaching move runs the other direction: unpack the slogan back into the specific situations, skills, and beliefs it is standing in for.

S3.1All-or-nothing / binary thinking
Success or failure, stay or explode, good or weak
Insert the middle. Scale. Third options
In the room

Success or failure. Stay or explode. Good or weak. No middle.

It might sound like
  • Either I get the promotion or I leave.
  • It's a success or it's a disaster.
  • Either I'm a strong leader or I'm weak.
What’s underneath

Binaries feel like clarity. They are usually fear. The middle is where most adult work lives.

Questions that often open it
  1. What lives between 3 and 7?
  2. What is a third path that is neither collapse nor heroics?
  3. If both poles are half-true, what is the missing middle?
  4. What would “good enough and alive” look like?
Avoid here

Picking a pole with them. Moralizing the “extreme.”

Watch

Binaries feel like clarity. They are usually fear.

Examples from the field
Example
“Either I nail the offsite or I’m finished.” Middle: good-enough structure, one hostile question rehearsed, sleep. Alive and imperfect.
Project manager
'Either the launch is perfect or I've failed.' Coach asks what a 70% launch would look like. A middle ground becomes a real plan.
Employee
'Stay and suffer or quit tomorrow.' Coach invents five options in between, including a six-month negotiated change.
Sample exchange
Client

Either I confront him or I just accept it forever.

Coach

What's something in between those two?

Client

I suppose I could ask for one change.

Coach

What would that change be?

Signs it’s working

Words like 'partly', 'for now' and 'one step' appear, and the client sees more than two options.

Don’t confuse with

S5.14 Stuck between option A and B

Stuck between A and B is a real choice between two options. Binary thinking turns every situation into two extremes.

S3.2Catastrophic forecast as fact
Future spoken in present tense as doom
Time-stamp the fear. Probability. Coping even if
In the room

Future spoken in present tense as doom. “It’s over.”

It might sound like
  • It's over. They're going to cut my team.
  • I'll never get another job like this.
  • This is going to end badly, I know it.
What’s underneath

Time-stamp the fear. Forecast ≠ fact. Coping-even-if restores agency without fake reassurance.

Questions that often open it
  1. If this is a forecast, not a fact, what else could happen?
  2. How would you handle it if it did happen?
  3. What is the evidence for the doom — and for other outcomes?
  4. What is the next hour, not the whole future?
Avoid here

“It won’t happen.” Pre-mortem as first move if they are already in the movie.

Watch

Arguing “it won’t happen” rarely works.

Examples from the field
Example
“My career is over after that meeting.” Time-stamp: one meeting, Tuesday. Other outcomes listed. Next hour: send the correction note. Career-over court postponed.
Director
'The merger means I'm out.' Coach time-stamps the fear: 'That's a forecast for March. What do you know today?' Planning replaces dread.
Small-business owner
'We'll go bust.' Coach builds a coping-even-if plan for the worst case, which turns out to be survivable.
Sample exchange
Client

We're going to lose the contract. It's done.

Coach

Is that something that's happened, or a forecast?

Client

A forecast. A strong one.

Coach

If it did happen, how would you cope?

Signs it’s working

The client uses future tense for the forecast and can name what they'd do if it happened.

Don’t confuse with

S2.4 Anxious / catastrophizing

Anxiety is the emotional state. A catastrophic forecast is a thinking pattern that can be stated quite calmly.

S3.3Mind-reading others
“They think I’m…”, no data
Separate observation from story. What was actually said or done
In the room

“They think I’m…” No data.

It might sound like
  • They think I'm incompetent.
  • I can tell my boss doesn't rate me.
  • Everyone's talking about me.
What’s underneath

Mind-reading is an attempt to stay safe without risking contact. Invite a clean data-ask rather than better speculation.

Questions that often open it
  1. What did you see or hear, exactly?
  2. What else could that behavior mean?
  3. What would you need to ask to replace the guess with data?
  4. If you stopped mind-reading for a day, what would you do instead?
Avoid here

Helping them build a richer theory of the other mind.

Watch

Invite a clean data ask rather than more speculation.

Examples from the field
Example
Short email from a director = “she thinks I’m weak.” Seen: four words, sent from a phone at 22:10. Data-ask: “What do you need from me on this?”
Engineer
Sure the team lead thinks they're slow. Coach asks what data they have. Very little. A clean question in the next one-to-one replaces months of guessing.
Manager
Thinks a peer resents them. Coach invites three other explanations, then a direct check-in over coffee.
Sample exchange
Client

My manager thinks I'm not up to it.

Coach

What has she actually said or done that tells you that?

Client

…Nothing directly. It's a feeling.

Coach

How could you find out?

Signs it’s working

The client separates evidence from assumption and agrees to a direct, low-risk check.

Don’t confuse with

S1.3 Certain their view is the only one

Certainty is about one locked reading of events. Mind-reading is specifically about guessing others' thoughts without asking.

S3.4Over-generalizing from one event
“I always”, “this always happens”
Particularize. Find exceptions. Name the rule they built
In the room

“I always.” “This always happens.” One event wrote a law.

It might sound like
  • I always mess up presentations.
  • This always happens to me.
  • Nobody ever listens to me.
What’s underneath

The rule is the coaching object, not the episode. Particularize. Find exceptions. Ask if the rule is optional.

Questions that often open it
  1. Always? When was a time it went differently?
  2. What rule did this one event write?
  3. If the rule were optional, what would you try?
  4. What is this instance, without the word always?
Avoid here

Debating frequency. More episodes.

Watch

The rule is the real coaching object.

Examples from the field
Example
One icy board = “I always freeze with seniors.” Exception: CFO meeting last month. Rule optional this Thursday with an ally present.
Analyst
One bad presentation became 'I'm terrible at presenting'. Coach finds three presentations that went well. The rule loosens.
Manager
'People always leave my team.' Data shows two departures in five years. The rule was built on one painful exit.
Sample exchange
Client

I always freeze in big meetings.

Coach

Always? When was a time you didn't?

Client

Actually, the planning day last month was fine.

Coach

What was different then?

Signs it’s working

'Always' and 'never' change to 'sometimes' or 'that time', and exceptions are found.

Don’t confuse with

S3.6 Fixed-mindset identity claims

Over-generalising makes a rule from events. A fixed-mindset claim makes a rule about who the person is.

S3.5Should / must / have-to language
Duty voice, little want-language
Translate should → want / value / fear / someone else’s voice
In the room

Duty voice. Little want-language.

It might sound like
  • I have to take this role.
  • I should be grateful.
  • I must say yes to my boss.
What’s underneath

Don’t smash duty. Find the living value, fear, or borrowed voice under it. Then they can choose.

Questions that often open it
  1. Whose should is this?
  2. If should disappeared, what would you choose?
  3. What value is the should trying to protect?
  4. What do you want, in want-language, not duty-language?
Avoid here

Adolescent rebellion coaching. Ignoring real duties (care, visa, safety).

Watch

Don’t smash duty. Find the living value under it.

Examples from the field
Example
“I have to take the global role.” Whose: father’s immigrant script + a sponsor. Want-language: “I want work that uses my languages and a life with my kids.” Both/and experiment becomes speakable.
Graduate
'I should do the MBA.' Whose voice? Their parents'. Under it: a real want to lead. Other routes to leadership become speakable.
Doctor
'I must cover every shift.' The living value is care for patients. A boundary that still honours care is designed.
Sample exchange
Client

I have to go to every event.

Coach

Whose 'have to' is that?

Client

Probably my old boss's.

Coach

And what would you want, if it were your choice?

Signs it’s working

Want language appears alongside duty, and the client sees where they actually have a choice.

Don’t confuse with

S6.17 Duty vs desire

Duty vs desire is a deep conflict between values. Should-language can be just a habit of speech covering a borrowed rule.

S3.6Fixed-mindset identity claims
“That’s just how I am”, “I’m not a people person”
Historicize the belief. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity
In the room

“That’s just how I am.” “I’m not a people person.”

It might sound like
  • I'm just not a people person.
  • That's how I'm built.
  • I've never been good at networking.
What’s underneath

Do not debate personality. Open it as a story / strategy that once helped. Historicize. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity.

Questions that often open it
  1. When did you decide that?
  2. What would a person who believed the opposite try this week?
  3. Where is this already not fully true?
  4. If this is a strategy that once helped, where does it now cost you?
Avoid here

Trait arguments. Typology rabbit holes.

Watch

Do not debate personality. Open it as a story.

Examples from the field
Example
“Not a people person” started after a public humiliation at 24. Already untrue with their craft peers. 10% stretch: one curious question in the staff meeting.
Technical lead
'I'm not a people person.' Coach asks when that story started and when it helped. Then: one conversation this week that tests it.
Manager
'I'm bad with conflict.' Counter-evidence: they handle supplier disputes well. The skill exists in one context already.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm just not good with people.

Coach

When did you first decide that?

Client

School, probably. I was the quiet one.

Coach

Is that still true in every situation now?

Signs it’s working

The claim becomes a story with a history, and the client agrees to a small experiment.

Don’t confuse with

S6.4 “That’s just who I am” as a closed door

'That's just who I am' as a closed door is used to end the conversation. Fixed-mindset claims are believed sincerely and can be explored.

S3.7Complexifying / adding layers to stay safe
More frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decision
Simplify to the real choice. Time-box complexity
In the room

More frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decision.

It might sound like
  • There are a lot of factors to consider.
  • I need to map all the stakeholders first.
  • It's more complicated than that.
What’s underneath

Complexity can be highly intelligent avoidance. Time-box. 70% information. Actual Friday choice.

Questions that often open it
  1. If this had to be decided by Friday with 70% information, what is the actual choice?
  2. What complexity is useful — and what complexity is protection?
  3. What would you decide if you were allowed to be 70% sure?
  4. What are you afraid a simple choice would expose?
Avoid here

Question cube used as more layers. More stakeholder maps.

Watch

Complexity can be a highly intelligent avoidance.

Examples from the field
Example
Nine-stakeholder model for a hire. Friday choice: A or B, 30-day review. Fear under complexity: being seen to pick wrong. Named; then picked.
IT director
Adds a fourth vendor evaluation round 'to be thorough'. Coach asks what they'd pick today with what they know. They name one, then name the fear of blame if it fails.
Academic
Adds a new theoretical layer every session. Coach names it and asks what deciding would risk.
Sample exchange
Client

Before deciding, I want to model three more scenarios.

Coach

What would you choose with what you know now?

Client

Option B, probably.

Coach

What's making it hard to say that out loud?

Signs it’s working

The client makes a provisional choice and can name what the complexity was protecting.

Don’t confuse with

S5.3 Analysis paralysis / too many options

Analysis paralysis is stuck among options. Complexifying adds new layers so options never become clear.

S3.8Simplifying too fast / slogans
“I just need to be more confident”
Unpack the slogan into situations, skills, beliefs
In the room

“I just need to be more confident.” Fluent motto, no scene.

It might sound like
  • I just need to be more confident.
  • It's all about mindset.
  • I'll just communicate better.
What’s underneath

Opposite of S3.7. Slogans feel like progress and stall work. Unpack into situation, skill, belief, first scene.

Questions that often open it
  1. Confidence to do what, with whom, in which room?
  2. What would we see if this slogan were becoming true?
  3. What is under the slogan that is more precise?
  4. What is the first scene, not the motto?
Avoid here

Better slogans. Affirmations.

Watch

Slogans feel like progress and stall work.

Examples from the field
Example
Confidence → the 3pm vendor call, one ask for a date. Scene, not motto.
Sales rep
'More confidence' unpacked: one situation (pricing calls), one skill (silence after the price), one belief ('asking is pushy').
Team lead
'Better communication' becomes a first scene: Monday's update, two minutes shorter, with one clear ask.
Sample exchange
Client

I just need to be more assertive.

Coach

Where would being assertive matter most this week?

Client

Thursday's budget meeting.

Coach

What would you say there?

Signs it’s working

The slogan turns into a situation, a skill, a belief and a first scene.

Don’t confuse with

S1.4 Vague

Vague clients can't name what they mean. Slogan clients think they already know and stop there too quickly.

S3.9Rumination / same thoughts on repeat
Circular why, no new data
Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination
In the room

Circular why. No new data. Same tape.

It might sound like
  • I can't stop going over it.
  • Why did I say that?
  • I'm up at 2am replaying it.
What’s underneath

More analysis of the same tape will not release it. Shift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination. Give its job another method.

Questions that often open it
  1. What has thinking this 100 times already given you?
  2. What would one experiment teach that thinking cannot?
  3. If rumination had a job, what is it — and how else could that job get done?
  4. What is the question you have not asked yet, instead of the one you keep asking?
Avoid here

Deeper why. Clean language on the same nouns for twenty minutes.

Watch

More analysis of the same tape will not release it.

Examples from the field
Example
Hundred loops of “why did they exclude me.” Job of rumination: prevent another surprise. Other method: a cadence question to the boss. Tape stops needing to play all night.
Manager
Replays a failed meeting nightly. Coach shifts 'why?' to 'what next?' and sets a 10-minute worry window.
Executive
Ruminates about a decision made months ago. Coach asks what the rumination is trying to do for them.
Sample exchange
Client

I keep asking myself why I didn't speak up.

Coach

What would you want to do next time instead?

Client

Say one sentence. Even a short one.

Coach

What sentence?

Signs it’s working

'Why' questions turn into 'what next' and the client feels lighter, not more analysed.

Don’t confuse with

S1.8 Story-looping / circling the same plot

Story-looping is retelling the plot in session. Rumination is private mental replay.

S3.10Confirmation-seeking
Looks for evidence they are right or doomed
Ask for disconfirming data on purpose
In the room

Looks for evidence they are right or doomed. Cherry-picks.

It might sound like
  • See, this just proves it.
  • Here's another example of them doing it.
  • I knew it.
What’s underneath

Stay curious, not prosecutorial. Ask for disconfirming data on purpose.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would count as evidence you might be wrong?
  2. Where is the 10% that doesn’t fit?
  3. What are you treating as proof that is only a clue?
  4. If you collected for the opposite case this week, what would you look for?
Avoid here

Helping them build the case.

Watch

Stay curious, not prosecutorial.

Examples from the field
Example
“They are icing me out.” Disconfirming: they forwarded a useful intro yesterday. 10% doesn’t fit. Experiment: collect for the opposite case three days before concluding.
Team lead
Collects evidence the new boss dislikes them. Coach asks for one piece of evidence that points the other way.
Founder
Only quotes customers who agree with them. Coach suggests talking to three who churned.
Sample exchange
Client

Another email cc'ing my boss. He doesn't trust me.

Coach

What's one piece of evidence that doesn't fit that story?

Client

Well, he did give me the new account.

Coach

How does that fit?

Signs it’s working

The client actively looks for disconfirming data and holds their view more lightly.

Don’t confuse with

S3.3 Mind-reading others

Mind-reading guesses without data. Confirmation-seeking gathers data selectively to support a view.

S3.11Abstract values with no behavior
“Integrity”, “excellence” as fog
Operationalize. Film the value on a Tuesday
In the room

“Integrity.” “Excellence.” On the wall, missing from Tuesday.

It might sound like
  • Integrity really matters to me.
  • Our value is excellence.
  • I believe in transparency.
What’s underneath

Values without scenes stay decorative. Values speeches without calendar change increase shame.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would integrity look like in the 3pm meeting?
  2. Where are you already living this value?
  3. Where is the gap between the word and the week?
  4. What 60-minute act would make the value visible?
Avoid here

Values elicitation workshops with no Tuesday.

Watch

Values without scenes stay decorative.

Examples from the field
Example
Integrity gap: they sat silent when a number was massaged. 60-minute act: a private correction conversation, not a new value statement.
Department head
Values 'respect' but cancels one-to-ones. Coach asks what respect would look like in Tuesday's calendar.
Founder
'Transparency' is on the wall. Coach asks for one decision this month that would show it.
Sample exchange
Client

Honesty is my core value.

Coach

Where did honesty show up in your week?

Client

…I'm not sure it did, really.

Coach

Where could it show up this week?

Signs it’s working

The value becomes a visible behaviour in a specific situation.

Don’t confuse with

S6.15 Values-action gap

Values–action gap is the pain of noticing the mismatch. Abstract values is not yet noticing that the value has no behaviour.

S3.12Data-only / feeling-blind
Metrics, slides, no human field
Add stakeholder experience, body, relationship cost
In the room

Metrics, slides, no human field.

It might sound like
  • The numbers say it's fine.
  • Feelings aren't really relevant here.
  • Show me the data.
What’s underneath

Honor their strength in data; widen the instrument panel. Stakeholder experience, body, relationship cost.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is the human effect of this choice?
  2. What are you feeling that the dashboard cannot show?
  3. If the numbers were silent for a minute, what would you know?
  4. Who is affected that is not in the spreadsheet?
Avoid here

Anti-data sermons.

Watch

Honor their strength in data; widen the instrument panel.

Examples from the field
Example
Cut a team to hit a ratio. Dashboard silent: trust in the remaining leads. They know. Work both panels.
Finance director
Restructure looks good on paper; team morale is falling. Coach widens the instrument panel to include stakeholder experience.
Engineer
Data-led decision on a reorg. Coach asks what it will cost in relationships.
Sample exchange
Client

The metrics clearly support this.

Coach

They do. What would the people affected say about it?

Client

They'd probably be upset.

Coach

What would that cost you?

Signs it’s working

The client adds human factors to their thinking without losing their analytical strength.

Don’t confuse with

S1.6 Intellectualizing

Intellectualizing avoids the client's own feelings. Data-only ignores feelings in decisions about other people.

Related situations
S3.13Feeling-only / no structure
Mood as the only compass
Add facts, scale, experiment, time
In the room

Mood as the only compass. No facts, dates, tests.

It might sound like
  • It just doesn't feel right.
  • My gut says no.
  • I'm not in the mood to plan.
What’s underneath

Feelings are data, not the whole brief. Add facts, scale, experiment, time.

Questions that often open it
  1. What do the facts say alongside the feeling?
  2. What would a 2-week test tell us?
  3. On a 1–10 of intensity versus a 1–10 of evidence, where are you?
  4. What structure would support the feeling rather than replace it?
Avoid here

Only more feeling. Only a spreadsheet that shames feeling.

Watch

Feelings are data, not the whole brief.

Examples from the field
Example
“This job is wrong” at intensity 8, evidence 4. 2-week test: three named conditions logged daily. Structure supports the feeling; doesn’t obey it blindly.
Creative
Decides projects by mood alone. Coach adds dates, a scale and one test before deciding.
Manager
'I feel the team is unhappy.' Coach asks what evidence they have and how to check.
Sample exchange
Client

I just feel like it's wrong.

Coach

Your feeling is useful. What facts would help you test it?

Client

I could ask two people how they see it.

Coach

Who, and by when?

Signs it’s working

Feelings stay respected but are joined by facts, dates and small tests.

Don’t confuse with

S3.12 Data-only / feeling-blind

Data-only ignores feelings. Feeling-only ignores structure. Both need the other side added.

S3.14Past-as-prison
Origin story explains and excuses everything now
Honor origin. Ask what the adult can choose now
In the room

Origin story explains and excuses everything now.

It might sound like
  • It's because of how I was raised.
  • My first boss ruined me for this.
  • That's just my history.
What’s underneath

Honor origin. Do not do archaeology for its own sake in performance coaching. Ask what the adult can choose now.

Questions that often open it
  1. That history makes sense of the pattern. What is available to you now that wasn’t then?
  2. What from the past still belongs — and what can be retired?
  3. If the origin story is true, what is also true about you today?
  4. What would the adult choose that the younger you could not?
Avoid here

Deep childhood excavation beyond scope and contract.

Watch

Do not do archaeology for its own sake in performance coaching.

Examples from the field
Example
Humiliation at 24 explains freeze. Also true today: they run a 40-person org. Adult choice: ally in the room. History honored, not in the driver’s seat.
Manager
Explains conflict avoidance through childhood. Coach honours it, then asks what the adult can choose now.
Executive
Past layoff explains all caution. Coach asks: 'What's different about today?'
Sample exchange
Client

I avoid conflict because my dad was so angry.

Coach

That makes sense. What can you choose now, as an adult?

Client

Maybe to say one honest thing calmly.

Coach

Where?

Signs it’s working

The past is acknowledged and the client turns to present choices.

Don’t confuse with

S3.16 Nostalgia / golden past

Nostalgia longs for a better past. Past-as-prison uses the past to explain why change can't happen.

S3.15Future-as-fantasy without steps
Beautiful vision, no next Tuesday
Sensory future, then reverse-engineer 7 days
In the room

Beautiful vision. No next Tuesday.

It might sound like
  • One day I'll run my own studio.
  • I can see it all so clearly.
  • When it happens, everything will be different.
What’s underneath

Do not kill the vision. Give it legs. Sensory future, then reverse-engineer 7 days.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would Tuesday morning look like if this were becoming true?
  2. What is the first visible act?
  3. What would future-you thank you for starting, not for dreaming?
  4. What 7-day version of the vision exists?
Avoid here

More vision. Cynical “be realistic” that shames wanting.

Watch

Do not kill the vision. Give it legs.

Examples from the field
Example
“A studio of my own.” Tuesday: 90 minutes of making before Slack. 7-day version exists inside the current job.
Employee
Vivid vision of starting a business, nothing scheduled. Coach reverse-engineers the next seven days: one customer conversation.
Writer
Imagines the published book. First step: 500 words on Saturday.
Sample exchange
Client

I'll be running workshops around the world.

Coach

Beautiful. What would you do in the next seven days?

Client

Book one workshop locally.

Coach

Which day?

Signs it’s working

The vision stays alive and gets one dated step.

Don’t confuse with

S2.15 Over-excited / manic planning

Manic planning has lots of projects and frantic energy. Fantasy has one calm vision but no steps.

S3.16Nostalgia / golden past
“It used to be better”
Harvest what was living then. Recreate the quality, not the era
In the room

“It used to be better.”

It might sound like
  • It used to be so much better here.
  • When we were a startup, it worked.
  • I miss the old team.
What’s underneath

You cannot coach them back into last year. Harvest the quality. Recreate it inside today’s constraints. Name what is gone for good.

Questions that often open it
  1. What quality of that time do you miss?
  2. How might that quality exist in today’s constraints?
  3. What is gone for good — and what can be reinvented?
  4. What is the work of this season, not last season?
Avoid here

Time-travel plans. Trashing the past.

Watch

You cannot coach them back into last year.

Examples from the field
Example
Miss the startup intimacy. Quality: unfiltered craft talk. Today: a weekly 30-minute “ugly work” session with two people. Era is gone; quality is not.
Long-serving employee
Misses the old culture. Coach harvests the quality ('trust') and asks how to recreate it in today's team.
Founder
Misses early days. Names what's gone and builds one small ritual to keep the spirit.
Sample exchange
Client

The old days were just better.

Coach

What was the best thing about them?

Client

We trusted each other.

Coach

How could you build some of that now?

Signs it’s working

The client names the quality they miss and one way to bring it into the present.

Don’t confuse with

S2.8 Grief / loss mixed into a work topic

Grief is about a loss that needs naming and honouring. Nostalgia is idealising the past instead of acting now.

S4
Situation group · 12 situations

Agency and ownership

About this group

Underneath almost every topic sits one quiet question: who is driving. Twelve situations are collected here because each is a different disguise the same underlying issue wears — a client's relationship to their own agency, and the story they tell themselves about how much of the outcome is actually theirs to influence. This matters because a coach who cannot see past the surface content of these situations will keep offering strategy to a client whose real problem is authorship, and strategy offered to an authorship problem tends to bounce off without landing.

Each of these twelve disguises rewards a slightly different kind of listening. Victim language ("they," "the system," "no choice") often hides a request that has quietly never been made — the client has decided the answer would be no, so they never risked asking. Hero language ("I have to fix everyone") hides a load that was never actually theirs to carry, dressed up as responsibility. "Yes, but" is very often a clean no wearing a polite costume, stalling because saying no outright feels unavailable. Waiting for perfect conditions is frequently postponement with a respectable excuse attached. And "just tell me what you would do" is a direct, sometimes charming invitation for the coach to take the wheel — one of the easiest traps in the entire practice of coaching to walk into, because it is flattering to be asked.

The consistent move across this section is to sort what genuinely belongs to the client, what is shared, and what is not theirs at all — and then land one clean request or one clean act, rather than a philosophical resolution. Two cautions run underneath all twelve cards. First, never shame a victim stance; it was very often a strategy that once kept the client safe, and treating it as a character flaw only entrenches it further. Second, resist becoming the person who grants permission — the goal of every card in this section is to return authorship to the client, not to relocate it onto the coach instead.

S4.1Victim stance / it’s all them
They, the system, luck, no agency language
Validate constraint. Find the 5–20% they can move. Request vs complaint
In the room

They, the system, luck. No agency language.

It might sound like
  • There's nothing I can do — it's them.
  • The system's rigged.
  • It's just bad luck.
What’s underneath

Often hides a request never made — they decided the answer would be no. Validate constraint. Find 5–20% they can move.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is outside your control, honestly?
  2. Inside that, what is your next clean move?
  3. What request have you not made?
  4. If you took 10% more authorship, what would you do?
Avoid here

Shame. Heroic pep. Strategy pile-on.

Watch

Do not shame the victim stance. It was often learned for survival.

Examples from the field
Example
“Matrix makes delivery impossible.” True constraint. Unmade request: tradeoff sentence to the constraint-holder. 10% authorship.
Team lead
Blames head office for every delay. Coach validates the constraint, then asks: 'What 10% is yours to move?'
Employee
Never asked for a raise but resents the pay. A request never made becomes the first step.
Sample exchange
Client

Management won't let anything change.

Coach

That sounds frustrating. Inside those limits, what could you move, even a little?

Client

I could change how my team runs meetings.

Coach

What would you change first?

Signs it’s working

The client uses 'I can' and finds a small area of real influence.

Don’t confuse with

S4.12 External locus dressed as realism

External locus as realism sounds reasonable and calm. Victim stance sounds aggrieved and powerless.

S4.2Hero / I must fix everyone
Over-functioning, no delegation, exhaustion pride
Return work to its owner. Cost of heroics. Team as system
In the room

Over-functioning. No delegation. Exhaustion pride.

It might sound like
  • If I don't do it, no one will.
  • I'll just stay late and fix it.
  • I can't let the team fail.
What’s underneath

Heroics are often rewarded. Name the price — to them and to the people who never get to carry their own work.

Questions that often open it
  1. What are you carrying that is not yours?
  2. What would happen if you put it down for a week?
  3. What does the hero role cost you and them?
  4. What would adult-to-adult look like instead of rescue?
Avoid here

Time-management tips that leave the identity intact.

Watch

Heroics are often rewarded. Name the price.

Examples from the field
Example
Does the report’s stakeholder management. Cost: report stays junior, hero is exhausted. Week experiment: they send their own update. Standard reaches them.
Manager
Rewrites team reports at night. Coach names the price to them and to the team who never learn.
Nurse leader
Covers every gap personally. Experiment: hand one shift decision to a senior nurse.
Sample exchange
Client

It's quicker if I just do it myself.

Coach

What does doing it yourself cost you, and them?

Client

My evenings. And they never get better.

Coach

What's one thing you could hand over?

Signs it’s working

The client names a cost of heroics and delegates one real task.

Don’t confuse with

S4.3 Rescuer of the team / parent in the workplace

The hero fixes tasks. The rescuer protects people from consequences.

S4.3Rescuer of the team / parent in the workplace
Protects people from consequence, buffers the boss
Adult-adult. Boundaries. Development vs rescue
In the room

Protects people from consequence. Buffers the boss.

It might sound like
  • I don't want to put that on them.
  • I'll handle the boss so they don't have to.
  • They're not ready for that feedback.
What’s underneath

Rescue can be love and control at once. Development vs rescue. Let the standard reach them.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you stopped buffering, what would they have to learn?
  2. What are you afraid would happen?
  3. Where is care becoming control?
  4. What standard have you not let reach them?
Avoid here

Softness with no standard.

Watch

Rescue can be love and control at once.

Examples from the field
Example
Softens every message from the SVP. Team never feels the real requirement. Fear: they will break. Adult: pass the standard, stay available.
Department head
Hides a team member's poor performance from senior leaders. Coach explores development versus rescue.
Team lead
Buffers the team from all bad news. Experiment: share one hard update directly.
Sample exchange
Client

I protect them from the politics.

Coach

What do they miss out on when you protect them?

Client

Learning how it works, I guess.

Coach

What would development look like instead?

Signs it’s working

The client lets one standard or consequence reach the team, supported rather than blocked.

Don’t confuse with

S4.11 Over-owning other people’s emotions

Over-owning emotions is about feelings. Rescuing is about shielding people from consequences or standards.

S4.4Blaming self for the system
Takes structural problems as personal defect
Sort person / role / system. Reduce false shame
In the room

Structural problems worn as personal defect.

It might sound like
  • I should be able to handle it.
  • If I worked harder, it would be fine.
  • It's my fault the team is overloaded.
What’s underneath

Sort person / role / system. Do not let them “work harder” at an unworkable design.

Questions that often open it
  1. Which part is you, which is the role, which is the system?
  2. What would a fair account be?
  3. What are you working harder at that is actually an unworkable design?
  4. What system conversation is needed, not only a self conversation?
Avoid here

Only mindset. Only blame-the-org.

Watch

Do not let them “work harder” at an unworkable design.

Examples from the field
Example
Measured on personal heroics and team development. Unworkable. Conversation with boss to change the scoreboard — plus one delegation act.
Manager
Blames themselves for a team designed with half the needed headcount. Person / role / system sort shows a design flaw.
Teacher
Thinks they're failing; class sizes doubled. Coach helps write one request to change the system.
Sample exchange
Client

I just need to work harder.

Coach

Is the problem you, the role, or the system?

Client

Honestly, the system. Two people's work, one person.

Coach

Who could change the design?

Signs it’s working

The client sees the structural part and stops trying to solve it with personal effort alone.

Don’t confuse with

S2.6 Guilty / over-responsible

Guilt can attach to any event. Blaming self for the system is specifically wearing a design flaw as a personal defect.

S4.5No ownership / “yes but”
Agrees then undoes, external conditions always
Name the yes-but. Find the hidden loyalty or fear
In the room

Agrees then undoes. External conditions always appear.

It might sound like
  • Yes, but…
  • That's a good idea, but it won't work here.
  • I would, but…
What’s underneath

Yes-but is information, not just resistance. Often a clean no in costume, or a hidden loyalty/fear.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is the “but” protecting?
  2. If the but were handled, what would you actually do?
  3. Is this a yes, a no, or a not-yet?
  4. What would a clean no sound like?
Avoid here

More action planning they will yes-but.

Watch

Yes-but is information, not just resistance.

Examples from the field
Example
“Yes I’ll talk to her but the offsite…” But protects fear of her anger. Clean not-yet: after the offsite, dated. Or clean no. Anything but a fake yes.
Team lead
'Yes but' to every option. Coach asks: 'If the honest answer is no, what's the no about?'
Manager
Agrees to delegate, then explains why not. Underneath: loyalty to an old boss who never delegated.
Sample exchange
Client

Yes, but my boss wouldn't allow it.

Coach

I notice a lot of 'yes buts'. What would a clean no sound like?

Client

I don't actually want to change this.

Coach

That's important. Tell me why.

Signs it’s working

The client says a clear yes or a clear no, and the hidden reason comes out.

Don’t confuse with

S5.11 Resistance to action / “I’ll think about it”

'I'll think about it' is a soft delay. 'Yes but' is active resistance to each option.

S4.6Waiting for perfect conditions
“Once the reorg / hire / budget…”
Act inside constraints. 70% rule. Controllables
In the room

“Once the reorg / hire / budget…”

It might sound like
  • Once the reorg is done, I'll start.
  • When I have the right team…
  • After the budget is approved.
What’s underneath

Perfect conditions are often postponement with a respectable excuse. Act inside constraints. 70% rule.

Questions that often open it
  1. If this constraint stayed for 6 months, how would you still move 10%?
  2. What is possible before perfect?
  3. What are you postponing that does not require the missing condition?
  4. What would 70% ready look like?
Avoid here

Strategy that starts “after.”

Watch

Perfect conditions are a postponement strategy.

Examples from the field
Example
Waiting for the hire to start culture work. 10% now: one team norm they can set without the hire.
Head of sales
Won't change the pipeline review until the new CRM arrives in nine months. Coach asks for one change possible with today's spreadsheet. A weekly 15-minute deal review starts Monday.
Writer
Waiting for a quiet month. Experiment: 20 minutes a day now.
Sample exchange
Client

I'll start the project after the restructure.

Coach

What could you start inside today's limits?

Client

A one-page plan.

Coach

By when?

Signs it’s working

The client acts inside current constraints instead of waiting for perfect ones.

Don’t confuse with

S5.5 Procrastination / delay

Procrastination avoids a specific task emotionally. Waiting for perfect conditions postpones whole initiatives with a reasonable-sounding excuse.

S4.7Wanting permission
Looks to coach, boss, spouse to bless the choice
Return authority. Practice self-authorization
In the room

Looks to coach, boss, spouse to bless the choice.

It might sound like
  • Do you think it's okay if I…?
  • I need to check with my partner first.
  • I'd do it if my boss said yes.
What’s underneath

Do not become the new parent who says yes. Practice self-authorization.

Questions that often open it
  1. What permission are you seeking? From whom?
  2. What would it take to grant it to yourself?
  3. What are you making me or them responsible for that is yours?
  4. If you were already authorized, what would you do this week?
Avoid here

Blessing the choice. Advice they will treat as permission.

Watch

Do not become the new parent who says yes.

Examples from the field
Example
“Should I apply?” Coach will not vote. Already authorized act: write the three contributions, then decide.
Employee
Waits for boss approval to take leave they're entitled to. Coach practises self-authorisation.
Founder
Wants the coach to bless a pivot. Coach returns the decision: 'What do you think?'
Sample exchange
Client

Would it be alright if I said no to the project?

Coach

Whose permission are you looking for?

Client

Anyone's, honestly.

Coach

What would you decide if you gave yourself permission?

Signs it’s working

The client makes the decision themselves and states it as theirs.

Don’t confuse with

S4.9 Outsourcing judgment to the coach

Outsourcing judgment asks the coach to decide. Wanting permission has already decided and wants approval.

S4.8Decision already made but not owned
Energy is done, words still “considering”
Name it. Help them admit the choice and plan the conversation
In the room

Energy is done. Words still “considering.”

It might sound like
  • I'm still weighing it up.
  • I haven't decided yet.
  • Let's say I'm leaning…
What’s underneath

Thinking can be a delay of the announcement. Help them admit the choice and plan the conversation.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you already know, what are you delaying by still “thinking”?
  2. What would owning it out loud change?
  3. Who needs to hear the decision — and what is the sentence?
  4. What are you waiting to feel before you admit you have chosen?
Avoid here

More pros/cons.

Watch

Thinking can be a delay of the announcement.

Examples from the field
Example
Energy dead on staying. Words: “exploring options.” Naming: they have left internally. Next: sentence to the sponsor.
Manager
Says they're 'considering' leaving but already has an offer accepted in their mind. Coach: 'What if you've already decided?'
Partner
Still 'thinking' about ending a partnership. Coach helps plan the conversation.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm still thinking about whether to go.

Coach

If you'd already decided, what would the decision be?

Client

(pause) Go.

Coach

What's left is the announcement. Let's plan it.

Signs it’s working

The client admits the decision and the energy shifts to planning how to communicate it.

Don’t confuse with

S5.14 Stuck between option A and B

Stuck between A and B is a real oscillation. Here the choice is made; only owning it is missing.

S4.9Outsourcing judgment to the coach
“Just tell me what you would do”
Refuse the expert trap. Offer a perspective only if contracted, without attachment
In the room

“Just tell me what you would do.”

It might sound like
  • What would you do?
  • Just tell me the answer.
  • You're the expert.
What’s underneath

Flattering trap. Advice creates dependency and weakens their muscle. Occasional contracted perspective is fine; a habit is not coaching.

Questions that often open it
  1. I can share a view if you want it, and you still choose. What do you already know?
  2. Are you asking me to think for you, or with you?
  3. What would you do if I were not allowed to answer?
  4. What are you hoping my answer will spare you?
Avoid here

Answering as the main move.

Watch

Advice creates dependency and weakens their muscle.

Examples from the field
Example
Stay or go. They already know they are leaving. My answer would spare them disappointing their sponsor. Work that, not my hypothetical career.
Senior engineer
Asks the coach which of two job offers to take. Coach asks what they'd tell a friend in their position. They answer instantly, and the session works with that.
Executive
Wants the coach's view on a stay-or-go. Coach notices they already know and works with that.
Sample exchange
Client

Just tell me what you'd do.

Coach

I could, but then it'd be my decision. What's your gut saying?

Client

Probably to leave.

Coach

What makes it hard to trust that?

Signs it’s working

The client works from their own judgement and doesn't need the coach to decide.

Don’t confuse with

S8.2 Wants the coach to be the expert / mentor / parent

Wanting the coach as an expert is an ongoing role pull. Outsourcing judgment is one specific request to decide.

S4.10Hiding in “we”
Team language when it is an I-issue
Shift we → I. Personal stance
In the room

Team language when it is an I-issue.

It might sound like
  • We're struggling with priorities.
  • As a team, we need to communicate better.
  • We decided to delay it.
What’s underneath

We can be diplomacy or disappearance. Shift we → I.

Questions that often open it
  1. When you say we, what is your part?
  2. What do you want, not what does the group want?
  3. What I-sentence have you not said?
  4. What happens if you speak only for yourself for two minutes?
Avoid here

More org-speak.

Watch

We can be diplomacy or disappearance.

Examples from the field
Example
“We are unsure about the date.” I-sentence: “I think the date is a lie and I have not said so.” That’s the work.
Department head
'We're not delivering.' Coach asks: 'What's your part in that?' The I-issue is avoiding a hard call.
Leader
Uses 'we' for every mistake. Coach: 'If you say I instead of we, what changes?'
Sample exchange
Client

We need to get better at saying no.

Coach

What would it look like if you said 'I'?

Client

I need to say no to my boss.

Coach

That's a different conversation.

Signs it’s working

The client switches to 'I' and names their own part and action.

Don’t confuse with

S4.1 Victim stance / it’s all them

Victim stance blames others. Hiding in 'we' spreads responsibility so no one owns it.

S4.11Over-owning other people’s emotions
I made them upset, I must fix their feeling
Return their feelings to them. Clean impact vs imagined impact
In the room

I made them upset. I must fix their feeling.

It might sound like
  • I made her upset.
  • I need to fix how he feels.
  • I can't relax until they're okay.
What’s underneath

Empathy without boundary becomes fusion. Clean impact vs imagined impact. Let them have their reaction.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is your impact, and what is their feeling to hold?
  2. What repair is clean versus extra?
  3. Where does empathy become fusion?
  4. What would respect for them include — including letting them have their reaction?
Avoid here

Scripts for managing the other person’s inner life.

Watch

Empathy without boundary becomes fusion.

Examples from the field
Example
Gave fair feedback; colleague cried. Clean: check they understood and are resourced. Extra: rewriting the feedback into mush. Respect includes their reaction.
Team lead
Cancelled a team social; one person seemed hurt. They spend the weekend worrying. Coach asks what was actually said. Nothing: the hurt was imagined, and a short check-in settles it.
Team lead
Feels responsible for team morale every day. Coach helps them let people have their own reactions.
Sample exchange
Client

I upset him with my feedback.

Coach

Was the feedback fair and kind?

Client

Yes, it was.

Coach

Then can his reaction be his?

Signs it’s working

The client stays caring but stops trying to manage everyone's feelings.

Don’t confuse with

S7.6 People-pleasing frame

People-pleasing is about getting approval. Over-owning emotions is about feeling responsible for others' feelings.

S4.12External locus dressed as realism
“That’s just corporate life”
Test which constraints are real, which are assumed
In the room

“That’s just corporate life.”

It might sound like
  • That's just corporate life.
  • You can't fight the system.
  • That's how it works everywhere.
What’s underneath

Realism and resignation can sound identical. Test written rule vs cultural habit vs prediction.

Questions that often open it
  1. Which rule is written, which is a habit of the culture, which is your prediction?
  2. Where has someone in a similar system done something different?
  3. What is realism here — and what is resignation wearing realism’s clothes?
  4. What 10% is movable even if the rest is not?
Avoid here

Naive “just be courageous” that ignores real power.

Watch

Realism and resignation can sound identical.

Examples from the field
Example
“No one pushes back on dates.” Not written. Two people have. 10%: one tradeoff sentence this Friday.
Manager
'Nobody gets flexible hours here.' Coach asks: written rule, cultural habit or prediction? It's a habit; one request is tested.
Analyst
'You can't challenge senior people.' Coach finds an example where someone did.
Sample exchange
Client

That's just how it is in big companies.

Coach

Is that a written rule, a habit, or a guess?

Client

A habit, I think.

Coach

Could you test it once?

Signs it’s working

The client distinguishes real limits from assumed ones and tries one test.

Don’t confuse with

S4.1 Victim stance / it’s all them

Victim stance is emotional and powerless. External locus as realism is calm and sounds sensible.

S5
Situation group · 17 situations

From insight to action

About this group

Coaching that never leaves the chair is incomplete work, however insightful the conversation felt in the moment. But coaching that jumps to a plan before the topic has actually been understood simply recycles the old frame with a new to-do list stapled to it — the client executes a plan built on the same assumptions that created the problem, and is surprised when it doesn't hold. This group maps seventeen ways coach and client can relate to action badly, so the specific failure in front of you can be named precisely rather than treated with a generic "let's make a plan."

The seventeen situations cluster around a handful of recognizable failure patterns: insight with no next step (beautiful ahas that change nothing by next Tuesday), motion with no meaning (busywork that feels productive and accomplishes nothing), too many options or too few, delay functioning as emotion-management rather than a time-management problem, perfectionism operating as a socially acceptable disguise for fear of judgment, a strong start that predictably fades by week three, sabotage that appears right before the finish line, and compliance — homework done to please the coach rather than because the client actually wants the outcome. Each of these needs a different intervention: a knowing-doing gap needs smaller and more scheduled acts, not more insight; analysis paralysis needs the options deliberately narrowed, not widened further; a fading start needs environment and identity design, not more willpower; sabotage near success needs the fear of success named and negotiated with, not scolded away.

The through-line for the whole section: when energy in the room genuinely turns forward, protect that momentum rather than continuing to explore out of habit or thoroughness. Generate more than the obvious two options, then land exactly one — owned by the client, dated, and observable enough that both people will know without ambiguity whether it happened. And when the client is visibly not ready to commit to action, resist the temptation to manufacture a plan anyway just to end the session on a productive-looking note; a false plan is worse than an honest not-yet.

S5.1Insight without behavior change
Beautiful ahas, same week as last month
Close the knowing-doing gap. Smaller, scheduled, observable acts
In the room

Beautiful ahas. Same week as last month.

It might sound like
  • Yes, I totally see that now.
  • That's such a good insight.
  • I know what I need to do, I just haven't.
What’s underneath

Knowing-doing gap. More insight can become another hiding place. Integration is a scheduled act, not a better sentence.

Questions that often open it
  1. What did last month’s insight change on a Tuesday?
  2. What 15-minute experiment would make this real?
  3. What do you know that you are not living?
  4. What would integration look like this week, not more understanding?
Avoid here

Another brilliant why.

Watch

More insight can become another hiding place.

Examples from the field
Example
Third “I need to stop rescuing.” Integration: one update they do not rewrite this week. Insight without that act is décor.
Executive
Great insights each session, same behaviour. Coach schedules integration: one act, a date, a check.
Manager
Knows they should delegate. Coach asks: 'What would make this week different?'
Sample exchange
Client

I realised last time I need to listen more.

Coach

Where did you practise it this week?

Client

I didn't.

Coach

Let's put one moment in the calendar.

Signs it’s working

Insight is attached to a dated action and checked next session.

Don’t confuse with

S1.21 Comparing this to last time / “we already covered this”

'We already covered this' is impatience. Insight without behaviour change is a pattern across sessions.

S5.2Action without insight / busywork
Lots of doing, no learning, hamster wheel
Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs motion
In the room

Lots of doing. No learning. Hamster wheel.

It might sound like
  • I've been so busy.
  • I'm doing loads, but nothing changes.
  • I've added another meeting to fix it.
What’s underneath

Do not applaud motion that is avoidance. Pause. Meaning. Strategy vs anxiety-motion.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is all this activity in service of?
  2. If you did 50% less, what might you see?
  3. Which actions are strategy, and which are anxiety?
  4. What would purposeful stillness give you?
Avoid here

More productivity systems.

Watch

Do not applaud motion that is avoidance.

Examples from the field
Example
14 status meetings. 50% less might reveal no decision owner. Stillness would show the missing contract, not a need for a 15th meeting.
Marketing manager
Launches a new campaign every fortnight but never reviews results. Coach suggests pausing one launch to study the last three. The data shows only one channel works.
Founder
Constant launches with no learning. Coach builds a weekly 'what did we learn?' review.
Sample exchange
Client

I've been working twelve-hour days on this.

Coach

What have you learned from all that work?

Client

…Honestly, not much.

Coach

What would you stop doing to find out?

Signs it’s working

The client pauses and names what activity is for, and stops some activity.

Don’t confuse with

S4.2 Hero / I must fix everyone

Hero over-functions to rescue others. Busywork is activity without learning, often to manage anxiety.

S5.3Analysis paralysis / too many options
Pros/cons forever, more research
Limit options to 2–3. Decide by value + reversible test
In the room

Pros/cons forever. More research.

It might sound like
  • I need more information.
  • Let me do another pros and cons list.
  • There are just too many options.
What’s underneath

More options after a point reduce action. Decide by value + reversible test. What is research hoping to spare them from feeling.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you had to choose tonight with a 30-day review, which way?
  2. What is reversible versus not?
  3. What are you hoping more research will spare you from feeling?
  4. Which option can you live with even if it is imperfect?
Avoid here

Invent-eight here (wrong situation — that is for no options). Question cube as more dimensions.

Watch

More options after a point reduce action.

Examples from the field
Example
Four vendors, sixth comparison sheet. Research spares them from disappointing a friend-vendor. Named; pick with a 30-day out.
Graduate
Researching career paths for a year. Coach: 'What is more research protecting you from?' A reversible test replaces research.
Manager
Three vendors, endless comparisons. Decide by values and a 30-day trial.
Sample exchange
Client

I'll research a bit more before deciding.

Coach

What is the research hoping to spare you?

Client

Picking wrong.

Coach

What's a choice you could reverse if needed?

Signs it’s working

The client makes a reversible decision based on values, not more data.

Don’t confuse with

S3.7 Complexifying / adding layers to stay safe

Complexifying adds layers. Analysis paralysis has clear options but can't choose.

Related situations
S5.4No options they can see
“There is no way”
Invent 8 ideas including bad ones. Constraint-busting. Borrow others’ moves
In the room

“There is no way.” Frozen imagination.

It might sound like
  • There's no way out.
  • I've tried everything.
  • Nothing will work.
What’s underneath

First “no options” is usually freeze, not physics. Invent eight including unwise. Constraint-busting.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you could do anything, even unwise, what are 8 options?
  2. What would a brave peer try?
  3. Which constraint is fact, and which is a rule you wrote?
  4. If option 9 existed, what would it be?
Avoid here

Picking from their empty list. Premature experiment.

Watch

The first “no options” is usually a frozen imagination.

Examples from the field
Example
“Cannot move the date.” Eight options include lying, cutting 40%, pairing, public tradeoff. Option 9: cut scope and say the tradeoff sentence. Imagination thaws.
Manager
Can't see any option with a difficult boss. Coach invites eight options including unwise ones; option six is workable.
Small-business owner
'No way to cut costs.' Constraint-busting reveals two.
Sample exchange
Client

There's literally nothing I can do.

Coach

Let's list eight options, including silly ones.

Client

Quit, hide, shout… ask HR, find a mentor…

Coach

Which of those has something useful in it?

Signs it’s working

The client generates several options and one feels possible.

Don’t confuse with

S4.1 Victim stance / it’s all them

Victim stance blames others. No options is a freeze in imagination, often from stress.

S5.5Procrastination / delay
Starts Sunday night, avoids the hard block
Name the avoided feeling. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes
In the room

Starts Sunday night. Avoids the hard block.

It might sound like
  • I'll do it tomorrow.
  • I work better under pressure.
  • I keep finding other things to do.
What’s underneath

Often emotion management, not time skills. Name the feeling at sit-down. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes.

Questions that often open it
  1. What feeling starts when you sit down to do it?
  2. What would a ridiculously small start be?
  3. What are you managing with delay — fear, boredom, standard, loyalty?
  4. What would make starting easier than avoiding?
Avoid here

Calendar lectures. Shame.

Watch

Procrastination is often emotion management, not time skills.

Examples from the field
Example
Deck avoided. Feeling at sit-down: being seen as thin. First 10 minutes: ugly outline labeled DRAFT, one reader. Delay’s job handled another way.
Analyst
Avoids a report until Sunday night. Coach asks what they feel when they sit down. 'Dread.' Shrink the start to 10 minutes.
Student
Delays a thesis chapter. First 10 minutes are designed: open the file, write one heading.
Sample exchange
Client

I keep putting off the strategy paper.

Coach

When you sit down to start, what do you feel?

Client

Like it'll never be good enough.

Coach

What's the smallest first ten minutes?

Signs it’s working

The client names the feeling and starts with a small, designed first step.

Don’t confuse with

S5.6 Perfection delay

Perfection delay waits for flawless. Procrastination avoids starting at all, often for many reasons.

S5.6Perfection delay
Won’t ship until flawless
Define good enough. Audience of one. Version 1
In the room

Won’t ship until flawless.

It might sound like
  • It's not ready yet.
  • I just want to polish it a bit more.
  • I can't send it like this.
What’s underneath

Often fear of judgment wearing a high standard. Define good enough. Audience of one. Version 1.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would 80% look like?
  2. Who is the draft for?
  3. What is the cost of waiting for 100%?
  4. What would Version 1 be allowed to be?
Avoid here

“Lower your standards” as insult.

Watch

Perfection is often fear of judgment wearing a high standard.

Examples from the field
Example
Strategy deck. Audience of one: trusted peer Wednesday. 80% is problem, three options, recommendation. Cost of 100%: missing the slot.
Designer
Won't share drafts. Coach defines 'good enough' with them and picks one trusted reviewer.
Researcher
Paper stuck in revision for a year. Version 1 is sent to one colleague.
Sample exchange
Client

I'll send it once it's perfect.

Coach

What would 'good enough' look like?

Client

Clear argument, no typos.

Coach

Is it there now?

Signs it’s working

The client ships a version and survives the feedback.

Don’t confuse with

S5.5 Procrastination / delay

Procrastination may not even start. Perfection delay starts but won't finish.

S5.7Starts strong then fades
Week-1 hero, week-3 ghost
Design environment, identity, review rhythm — not willpower
In the room

Week-1 hero, week-3 ghost.

It might sound like
  • I was great for the first week.
  • I lost momentum.
  • I always start strong.
What’s underneath

Motivation is a bad operating system. Design beats mood: environment, identity, review rhythm.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would make this easier to keep than to drop?
  2. When does the fade begin?
  3. What identity are you practicing on day 1 that you drop by day 12?
  4. What review rhythm would catch the fade early?
Avoid here

More inspiration. Bigger goals.

Watch

Motivation is a bad operating system. Design beats mood.

Examples from the field
Example
Fade begins Sunday night when calendar fills. Design: Friday 15-minute review locked with a peer. Identity: “person who reviews,” not “person who starts.”
Manager
Morning routine works for a week then fades. Coach designs environment cues and a weekly review.
Runner
Fitness plan stalls at week three. Identity work: 'I'm someone who runs on Tuesdays.'
Sample exchange
Client

I did it for a week, then stopped.

Coach

What made the first week work?

Client

I'd put my shoes by the door.

Coach

How could you keep that cue going?

Signs it’s working

The client designs structure that doesn't depend on motivation.

Don’t confuse with

S5.12 Missed the last commitment

Missed the last commitment is one missed action. Starts strong then fades is a repeated pattern.

S5.8Sabotages near success
Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the win
Name the success-fear. Parts work. What would change if they succeeded
In the room

Picks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the win.

It might sound like
  • Something always goes wrong at the end.
  • I got sick right before the launch.
  • I picked a fight just before the deal closed.
What’s underneath

Treat sabotage as protection, then negotiate. Success-fear. What would have to be true about them if they finished.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would success cost you?
  2. Which part doesn’t want the finish line?
  3. What would have to be true about you if you finished?
  4. How could you succeed and still keep what that part is protecting?
Avoid here

Scolding. More willpower.

Watch

Treat sabotage as protection, then negotiate with it.

Examples from the field
Example
Fight with the producer the night before a keynote. Part protecting: don’t be seen then rejected. Negotiate: smaller exposure + debrief ally. Show happens.
Founder
Derails funding rounds at the last step. Coach explores what success would mean for their identity.
Employee
Misses deadlines just before promotion. Coach treats sabotage as protection and negotiates with it.
Sample exchange
Client

Every time I get close, I blow it.

Coach

If you finished, what would have to be true about you?

Client

That I'm… successful. That scares me.

Coach

What's scary about that?

Signs it’s working

The client sees what success threatens and can choose to finish anyway.

Don’t confuse with

S6.13 Success would break a loyalty

Success breaking a loyalty is a specific reason. Sabotage near success is the behaviour pattern.

S5.9Wants a giant leap only
Allergic to small steps, “that’s not enough”
Link small steps to identity and compounding. Define a bold small
In the room

Allergic to small steps. “That’s not enough.”

It might sound like
  • Small steps feel pointless.
  • I want real change, not tweaks.
  • That's not enough.
What’s underneath

Sometimes they need a meaningful experiment, not a trivial one. Sometimes the giant leap is a wish to skip becoming. Discern which.

Questions that often open it
  1. What small step would actually scare you a little?
  2. What compound effect do you dismiss?
  3. What would a meaningful experiment be — small and not trivial?
  4. What giant leap is hiding a wish to skip the becoming?
Avoid here

Tiny trivial homework they will despise. Matching the leap with an unsized plan.

Watch

Some clients need a meaningful experiment, not a tiny trivial one.

Examples from the field
Example
Wants to “quit and start the firm.” Meaningful-small: one paid pilot with a real contract this month — scary, not trivial, not the whole leap.
Executive
Rejects small experiments. Coach designs a meaningful 30-day experiment big enough to matter.
Career changer
Wants to quit and start fresh tomorrow. Coach explores whether the leap skips needed growth.
Sample exchange
Client

A small step won't change anything.

Coach

What's the smallest step that would feel meaningful?

Client

Taking one client of my own.

Coach

That's not small. When?

Signs it’s working

The client agrees to an experiment that feels meaningful without skipping necessary growth.

Don’t confuse with

S2.15 Over-excited / manic planning

Manic planning has many projects. Giant leap is one big jump rejecting small steps.

S5.10Compliance without buy-in
Will do the homework to please you
Rebuild choice. They design the experiment or there is none
In the room

Will do the homework to please you.

It might sound like
  • Sure, I'll do that.
  • Whatever you think is best.
  • I did the homework you gave me.
What’s underneath

Compliant clients create empty sessions. They design the experiment or there is none. Your approval cannot be the engine.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would you do if you were not trying to be a good client?
  2. What do you actually want to test?
  3. If I never asked about this again, what would you still do?
  4. What experiment would you design if it only had to matter to you?
Avoid here

More assigned homework.

Watch

Compliant clients create empty sessions.

Examples from the field
Example
They complete every worksheet. None touch the leave-question. New rule: they design or we don’t assign.
Manager
Does every task to please the coach. Coach stops assigning and asks the client to design their own.
Graduate
Compliant but no energy. Coach asks: 'What would you want to try?'
Sample exchange
Client

Okay, I'll do whatever you suggest.

Coach

What would you design for yourself?

Client

I hadn't thought about that.

Coach

Take a moment. What feels right?

Signs it’s working

The client designs their own experiment and it has their energy behind it.

Don’t confuse with

S8.9 Coach-pleasing / doing homework for you

Coach-pleasing is about the relationship. Compliance is about the homework.

S5.11Resistance to action / “I’ll think about it”
Soft close, no date, no witness
Get specific or name the no. Explore the cost of thinking-about-it
In the room

Soft close. No date. No witness.

It might sound like
  • I'll think about it.
  • Maybe.
  • Let me get back to you.
What’s underneath

A vague maybe is usually a hidden no. Get specific or name the no. Cost of thinking-about-it.

Questions that often open it
  1. Is this a yes, a no, or a not-yet?
  2. What would a real not-yet need?
  3. What does “I’ll think about it” usually turn into in your life?
  4. What would you be saying no to if you said yes?
Avoid here

Fake deadline you invent.

Watch

A vague maybe is usually a hidden no.

Examples from the field
Example
“I’ll think about the conversation with her.” In their life that means never. Honest not-yet: after Thursday’s results, decide Friday, tell you next session.
Manager
Soft close on every commitment. Coach asks: 'Is that a yes, a no or a not yet?'
Employee
'I'll think about asking for a raise.' Coach names the cost of thinking about it for another month.
Sample exchange
Client

I'll think about having that conversation.

Coach

Is that a yes, a no, or a not yet?

Client

Probably a no, honestly.

Coach

Thank you. What's the no about?

Signs it’s working

The vague maybe becomes a clear yes with a date, or an honest no.

Don’t confuse with

S4.5 No ownership / “yes but”

'Yes but' argues against options. 'I'll think about it' politely avoids committing.

S5.12Missed the last commitment
Didn’t do it, shame or shrug
No prosecution. Learning review. Redesign, don’t double the load
In the room

Didn’t do it. Shame or shrug.

It might sound like
  • I didn't do it.
  • Sorry, I didn't get round to it.
  • It's fine, I just forgot.
What’s underneath

No prosecution. Was it wrong-sized or wrong-owned? Redesign; don’t double the load. Shame resets the same cycle.

Questions that often open it
  1. What got in the way, specifically?
  2. Was the action wrong-sized or wrong-owned?
  3. What will you choose now?
  4. What would make the next commitment honest rather than hopeful?
Avoid here

Pep plus a bigger task.

Watch

Shame resets the same cycle.

Examples from the field
Example
Missed the 90-minute deep work. Wrong-sized for a travel week. Honest next: 15 minutes at the gate, or no commitment this week.
Manager
Missed the agreed conversation. Coach asks if it was the wrong size or wrong owner. Redesigned smaller.
Analyst
Shrugs at a missed task. Coach explores without blame what got in the way.
Sample exchange
Client

I didn't have the conversation.

Coach

No judgement. Was it the wrong size, or not really yours?

Client

Too big. I froze.

Coach

What's a smaller version?

Signs it’s working

The commitment is redesigned to fit, without shame or doubling the load.

Don’t confuse with

S5.7 Starts strong then fades

Fading is a pattern. Missed the last commitment is one instance that needs redesign, not prosecution.

S5.13Impatient for a quick fix
Wants the trick, the script, this week
Honor urgency. Distinguish technique vs identity work. Offer a 7-day test
In the room

Wants the trick, the script, this week.

It might sound like
  • Just give me the script.
  • What's the trick?
  • I need this fixed by Friday.
What’s underneath

Honor urgency. Distinguish technique vs identity work. Give a real near move without pretending deep change is a hack.

Questions that often open it
  1. What part can move this week, and what will take longer?
  2. What would a useful 7-day test be?
  3. What are you hoping a trick will spare you from becoming?
  4. What is the nearest real move, not the fantasy fix?
Avoid here

Fake hack. Or a sermon about patience with no near move.

Watch

Do not pretend deep change is a hack. Do give them a real near move.

Examples from the field
Example
“Give me the script for executive presence.” Near move: one scene Thursday. Longer: identity that can be seen. Both named; only one is this week.
Manager
Wants a script for a review tomorrow. Coach gives a real near move (opening sentence) and names the deeper work for later.
Sales lead
Wants a confidence hack. One concrete technique now, identity work next month.
Sample exchange
Client

I just need the magic words.

Coach

Here's one move for Friday. And there's a deeper piece we can work on after.

Client

Okay. What's the move?

Coach

Open with your purpose, in one sentence.

Signs it’s working

The client gets a useful near move and understands the difference from deeper change.

Don’t confuse with

S1.19 Jumping straight to solutions

Jumping to solutions skips understanding. Impatient for a quick fix is urgency about a specific upcoming event.

S5.14Stuck between option A and B
Oscillates daily, seeks a sign
Values, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period
In the room

Oscillates daily. Seeks a sign.

It might sound like
  • One day I want A, the next B.
  • I'm waiting for a sign.
  • I keep going back and forth.
What’s underneath

The torture is often the oscillation, not either option. Values, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period.

Questions that often open it
  1. Which option does future-you already live in?
  2. What do you lose by not choosing?
  3. What 30-day trial would teach you?
  4. What is the torture — A, B, or the oscillation?
Avoid here

More comparison matrices.

Watch

The torture is often the oscillation, not either option.

Examples from the field
Example
Two job offers. Oscillation is the torture. Future-you already lives in B when they describe Friday evening. 30-day trial not possible; announcement date is.
Professional
Oscillating between two job offers. Coach: 'What does not choosing cost you?' Values sort makes B clearer.
Couple-run business
Expand or stay small? A three-month trial of one option.
Sample exchange
Client

Monday I want the job, Tuesday I don't.

Coach

What's the cost of not choosing for another month?

Client

I'm exhausted.

Coach

Which choice fits your values best?

Signs it’s working

The client chooses or sets a trial period, and the oscillation stops.

Don’t confuse with

S3.1 All-or-nothing / binary thinking

Binary thinking sees only two extremes everywhere. A and B are two real options.

S5.15Stay-or-go decision
Job, role, city, company
Two-movie method. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible
In the room

Job, role, city, company. High identity load.

It might sound like
  • Should I stay or go?
  • I can't decide whether to move.
  • This decision is huge.
What’s underneath

Do not pick for them. Make both futures vivid, including costs. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible.

Questions that often open it
  1. If both lives were films, which one do you want to star in?
  2. What data would make this a cleaner call?
  3. What are your non-negotiables in either life?
  4. What experiment could you run before you leap — or what conversation would make the leap clean?
Avoid here

Pros/cons only. Coach’s career advice as the engine.

Watch

Do not pick for them. Make both futures vivid.

Examples from the field
Example
Both films include costs. Stay-film costs self-respect; go-film costs money buffer. Non-negotiable: no more half-life. Experiment: 90-day full stay or a real search — pick one.
Manager
Stay at the company or leave? Coach makes both futures vivid, including costs and non-negotiables.
Employee
Relocating for a role? Experiment: a two-week trial in the new city first.
Sample exchange
Client

I don't know whether to stay or leave.

Coach

Let's imagine both futures. A year from now in each, what do you see?

Client

Staying feels safe. Leaving feels alive.

Coach

What would you need to be true either way?

Signs it’s working

Both futures are vivid and the client has non-negotiables to decide by.

Don’t confuse with

S5.14 Stuck between option A and B

Stuck between A and B can be any choice. Stay-or-go carries heavier identity and life weight.

S5.16Need to have a difficult conversation
Avoids the meeting, writes unsent emails
Purpose, request, opening line, body regulation, rehearsal
In the room

Avoids the meeting. Writes unsent emails.

It might sound like
  • I've written the email but not sent it.
  • I keep putting off the conversation.
  • I don't know how to say it.
What’s underneath

Role-play beats more theory. Purpose, request, first sentence, body, live practice.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is the clean purpose of the conversation?
  2. What is the first sentence?
  3. What are you afraid they will feel?
  4. Say the opening out loud. What happens in you?
Avoid here

Longer essays. More theory of crucial conversations.

Watch

Role-play beats more theory.

Examples from the field
Example
Unsent prosecution email. Purpose: fewer surprises. First sentence practiced. Heat in chest named. Meeting request sent same day.
Partner in a firm
Needs to tell a long-time colleague they won't be made equity partner. Coach helps write one honest opening sentence, then they practise it twice aloud.
Co-founder
Needs to discuss equity. Role-play twice, then a walk-away point.
Sample exchange
Client

I need to tell her the project's late.

Coach

What's your purpose, and your first sentence?

Client

'I want to be honest with you about the timeline.'

Coach

Let's practise it. I'll be her.

Signs it’s working

The client has practised the opening and feels ready to have the conversation.

Don’t confuse with

S7.14 Need to give hard feedback

Giving hard feedback is one kind of difficult conversation. This covers any difficult conversation.

S5.17After a win they can’t own
Luck, team, timing — never them
Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update
In the room

Luck, team, timing — never them.

It might sound like
  • It was just luck.
  • The team did the work, not me.
  • Good timing, really.
What’s underneath

Unowned wins do not update self-concept. Harvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update.

Questions that often open it
  1. What did you specifically do that made this possible?
  2. If you took 30% of the credit, what would be true?
  3. What identity would have to update if you owned this?
  4. Where else have you done this and called it luck?
Avoid here

Fake humility praise.

Watch

Unowned wins do not update self-concept.

Examples from the field
Example
Turnaround attributed to “the team and timing.” Specifics: they set a weekly tradeoff meeting and killed two projects. Identity that updates: someone who designs conditions, not a spectator of luck.
Manager
Won a big project and credits everyone else. Coach harvests their specific contribution.
Engineer
Launches a feature, dismisses it. Coach starts an evidence log of their wins.
Sample exchange
Client

It was just a lucky break.

Coach

What did you do that made it possible?

Client

I suppose I did build the client relationship.

Coach

Can you write that down?

Signs it’s working

The client names their contribution and it updates how they see themselves.

Don’t confuse with

S2.17 Afraid of hope / waiting for the other shoe

Afraid of hope fears the good won't last. Can't own a win denies their part in it.

S6
Situation group · 26 situations

Identity and meaning

About this group

Some topics that arrive dressed as a scheduling problem or a leadership problem are not, underneath, about the meeting at all. They are about who the person believes they are, and what their life is for — questions that professional coaching is allowed to sit with, even though it is not therapy and is not meant to become it. This group gathers twenty-six of the situations where that deeper layer is doing most of the actual work: fusion with the problem ("I am the failure," not "I made a mistake"), imposter feelings, an old identity dying as a new one is not yet trustworthy, worth quietly equated with output, a professional mask worn so long it is hard to locate the face underneath, a family or cultural loyalty that success would break, a widening gap between stated values and an actual calendar, and duty pulling one direction while desire pulls another.

These situations were chosen specifically because they resist tactical fixes. Telling an imposter-feeling client to "just believe in themselves" does nothing, because the feeling is not a data problem that more evidence will solve — it is a belonging story that needs to be worked directly. Offering a productivity hack to someone in genuine purpose fog insults the size of the question they are actually asking. The common moves across this section reflect that: separate the person from the pattern rather than let identity and behavior fuse into one indistinguishable thing; ask who they would need to become, not just what they would need to do; and — crucially — make meaning visible inside an actual week, through one small observable act, rather than leaving it as beautiful but inert language.

Two cautions matter more here than almost anywhere else in this guide. Go slowly whenever family, class, or culture enters the room — these loyalties are old, often multi-generational, and deserve more patience than a single session can offer. And resist the pull to reduce a genuine existential edge — mortality, faith, the question of whether a life has mattered — to a productivity plan just because a plan is what the coach knows how to build. Some of what shows up here calls for reverence rather than a framework, and for referral beyond coaching's scope when it turns toward clinical despair.

S6.1Fused with the problem (“I am the failure”)
Identity language, not behavior language
Externalize the problem. You vs the pattern
In the room

Identity language, not behavior language.

It might sound like
  • I am the failure here.
  • I'm just a disaster.
  • This is who I am — someone who drops balls.
What’s underneath

Never coach identity as a diagnosis. Externalize so they can relate to a pattern they have.

Questions that often open it
  1. You are not the doubt — when does the doubt show up?
  2. What would you call this pattern if it were a character?
  3. Who are you when the pattern is quiet?
  4. What becomes possible if this is something you have, not something you are?
Avoid here

Labels. Pep “you’re not a failure.”

Watch

Never coach identity as a diagnosis.

Examples from the field
Example
“I am the anxiety of this team.” Character: Sunday Weather. Quiet after a written opening line. They have Sunday Weather; they are not it.
Project lead
After a missed deadline: 'I'm a failure.' Coach externalises: 'What do you call this pattern when it shows up?' 'The Rush.' Now they can study it.
Manager
'I'm a bad mother and a bad manager.' Coach separates behaviours from identity and picks one behaviour to work on.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm just a failure.

Coach

If the pattern that led to this had a name, what would you call it?

Client

…The Overpromiser.

Coach

When does the Overpromiser show up?

Signs it’s working

The client talks about the pattern as something they have, not something they are.

Don’t confuse with

S2.5 Ashamed / self-attacking

Self-attack is a harsh tone. Fusion is identity language: 'I am' the problem.

S6.2Imposter feelings
Waiting to be found out, over-prepares, discounts praise
Evidence file. Belonging vs competence. Who they are becoming
In the room

Waiting to be found out. Over-prepares. Discounts praise.

It might sound like
  • They'll find out I'm not that good.
  • I just got lucky.
  • Everyone else knows what they're doing.
What’s underneath

Not only a data problem. Belonging story. Do not just list achievements.

Questions that often open it
  1. What evidence would a fair jury use?
  2. Who decided you don’t belong?
  3. What would “good enough authority” look like?
  4. What are you treating as fraud that is actually learning in public?
Avoid here

Trophy lists alone. “Fake it till you make it.”

Watch

Do not just list achievements. Work the belonging story.

Examples from the field
Example
Fair jury: three years of delivery. Belonging story: first in family in rooms like this. Work both. Good-enough authority: speak without one more rehearsal.
New director
Over-prepares for every meeting. Coach explores the belonging story underneath, not just achievements.
Doctor
Discounts every compliment. Coach asks what it would mean to belong here.
Sample exchange
Client

Any day now, they'll realise I don't belong.

Coach

What story do you have about who belongs here?

Client

People from better schools. Not me.

Coach

Where did that story come from?

Signs it’s working

The client sees the belonging story and can hold it more lightly.

Don’t confuse with

S2.7 Afraid of being seen / visibility anxiety

Visibility anxiety is about exposure. Imposter feelings are about doubting your right to be there at all.

S6.3High achiever crash / arrival fallacy
“I got it and I feel nothing”
Meaning, next chapter, human needs beyond achievement
In the room

“I got it and I feel nothing.”

It might sound like
  • I got the promotion and I feel nothing.
  • I thought I'd be happier.
  • Now what?
What’s underneath

Do not immediately set a bigger mountain. Meaning, next chapter, human needs beyond achievement.

Questions that often open it
  1. What did you think this would give you?
  2. What do you actually need now that the mountain is climbed?
  3. Who are you without the next climb?
  4. What wants a life, not only another summit?
Avoid here

Next goal as antidepressant.

Watch

Do not immediately set a bigger mountain.

Examples from the field
Example
Made partner. Felt nothing. Thought it would give belonging. Need now: unperformed friendship and a craft that is play. Not a bigger book of business this week.
VP
Reached the goal, feels empty. Coach doesn't set a bigger target; explores what needs beyond achievement matter now.
Athlete-turned-executive
Post-success crash. Coach explores meaning and the next chapter.
Sample exchange
Client

I made partner, and it's just… flat.

Coach

What did you hope it would give you?

Client

Feeling like I'd finally made it.

Coach

What would 'enough' feel like, without the next target?

Signs it’s working

The client explores meaning and needs instead of immediately chasing the next goal.

Don’t confuse with

S6.16 Purpose fog / “is this all?”

Purpose fog is a general question of meaning. The arrival crash comes right after reaching a goal.

S6.4“That’s just who I am” as a closed door
Personality as fate
Traits as strategies that once worked
In the room

Personality as fate.

It might sound like
  • That's just who I am. End of story.
  • I'm too old to change.
  • Take it or leave it.
What’s underneath

Honor the strategy before asking it to retire. Traits as strategies that once worked.

Questions that often open it
  1. When did this strategy start helping you?
  2. Where does it now cost you?
  3. Who are you when you don’t use it?
  4. What would a 10% stretch beyond “who I am” look like?
Avoid here

Personality debate.

Watch

Honor the strategy before asking it to retire.

Examples from the field
Example
Bluntness helped in a brutal early job. Costs them now in a partnership culture. 10%: one question before the verdict in the next design review.
Operations manager
'I'm a perfectionist, that's me.' Coach asks where perfectionism protected them early in their career, and where it now slows the team. The trait stays; its range narrows.
Engineer
'I'm blunt, that's me.' Coach asks when bluntness helped, and where it costs them.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm direct. That's just me.

Coach

When has being direct served you well?

Client

In crises. People trust me then.

Coach

And where might it cost you?

Signs it’s working

The client sees the trait as a strategy and can choose when to use it.

Don’t confuse with

S3.6 Fixed-mindset identity claims

A fixed-mindset claim is sincere. 'That's who I am' as a closed door shuts the conversation down.

S6.5Old identity dying (expert → leader, founder → CEO)
Grief + incompetence of the new skin
Name the identity funeral and the apprenticeship
In the room

Grief plus incompetence of the new skin.

It might sound like
  • I miss being good at my job.
  • I don't know who I am as a manager.
  • I keep jumping back into the detail.
What’s underneath

They need rites of passage, not only skills. Name the funeral and the apprenticeship. Newness is not incompetence.

Questions that often open it
  1. Who are you no longer?
  2. Who are you practicing becoming?
  3. What can the old identity still contribute without driving?
  4. What incompetence is just newness?
Avoid here

Tool-only manager training.

Watch

They need rites of passage, not only skills.

Examples from the field
Example
Founder still in every product thread. Funeral: “I am no longer the best doer in the room.” Apprenticeship: one thread they sponsor only. Old identity contributes taste, not keystrokes.
Lead surgeon turned clinical director
Misses operating and keeps scheduling surgery over leadership meetings. Coach names what's ending and what this new role asks them to learn.
Expert promoted
Grieves being the go-to person. Coach names the loss before teaching skills.
Sample exchange
Client

I used to be the best engineer. Now I'm a mediocre manager.

Coach

What are you saying goodbye to?

Client

Being the one with answers.

Coach

And what are you learning to become?

Signs it’s working

The client names what's ending and accepts being a beginner at the new role.

Don’t confuse with

S7.18 Expert becoming manager

Expert becoming manager is about behaviour (still doing). Old identity dying is about the grief and identity shift.

S6.6Worth = productivity
Rest guilt, weekend collapse, metrics as self
Decouple worth and output. Rest as strategy
In the room

Rest guilt. Weekend collapse. Metrics as self.

It might sound like
  • If I'm not productive, what am I?
  • I feel guilty resting.
  • My numbers are me.
What’s underneath

Often cultural and familial, not only personal. Decouple worth and output. Rest as strategy.

Questions that often open it
  1. Who are you when you produce nothing for 24 hours?
  2. What are you afraid rest would reveal?
  3. What is your worth when the dashboard is dark?
  4. What would rest give the work later?
Avoid here

Productivity hacks that keep the equation.

Watch

This is often cultural and familial, not only personal.

Examples from the field
Example
24-hour off. Afraid rest reveals they are ordinary. Worth work is the topic; a sleep app is not.
Consultant
Collapses every weekend. Coach decouples worth from output; rest becomes strategy.
Founder
Self-worth tied to revenue. Explores family messages about work.
Sample exchange
Client

A day off feels wasted.

Coach

Who taught you that rest has to be earned?

Client

My dad, probably.

Coach

What would rest mean if it didn't need earning?

Signs it’s working

The client can describe value in themselves beyond output and plans real rest.

Don’t confuse with

S6.20 Rest guilt / always-on

Rest guilt is the behaviour of being always on. Worth = productivity is the belief underneath.

S6.7Being “too much” or “not enough” — or both
Volume, tone, ambition policed
Find the contexts. Recover range. Choose the room
In the room

Volume, tone, ambition policed.

It might sound like
  • I'm told I'm too much.
  • Then they say I'm not assertive enough.
  • I can't win.
What’s underneath

Do not shrink them to fit a small culture unexamined. Find contexts where “too much” is the right size. Recover range.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where is your “too much” actually the right size?
  2. What would right-size look like here without shrinking your gift?
  3. Whose room are you trying to fit?
  4. What would range look like — not permanent shrinking?
Avoid here

Tone-policing as the coaching.

Watch

Do not shrink them to fit a small culture unexamined.

Examples from the field
Example
“Too much” in a conflict-avoidant culture; right size in customer rooms. Range: keep the gift, titrate this room, question whether this is the right room long-term.
Woman leader
Called both 'too aggressive' and 'not assertive enough'. Coach finds contexts where her full volume is exactly right.
Junior manager
'Too ambitious.' Coach explores the culture's norms rather than shrinking them.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm always too loud for this place.

Coach

Where is your volume exactly the right size?

Client

With clients. They love it.

Coach

What does that tell you?

Signs it’s working

The client sees the culture's limits and chooses where to adjust and where not to.

Don’t confuse with

S6.8 Mask vs authentic self at work

Mask vs authentic self is about hiding. Too much / not enough is about being policed.

S6.8Mask vs authentic self at work
Code-switch fatigue, professional persona
What the mask protects. Selective authenticity experiments
In the room

Code-switch fatigue. Professional persona.

It might sound like
  • I'm a different person at work.
  • I'm exhausted from pretending.
  • I can't be myself here.
What’s underneath

Full unmasking in an unsafe system can be unwise. Calibrate. What the mask buys. Selective authenticity experiments.

Questions that often open it
  1. What does the mask buy you?
  2. What would 10% more real look like with a safe person?
  3. Where is the mask still wise?
  4. What is the cost of wearing it all day?
Avoid here

“Just be yourself” as slogan.

Watch

Full unmasking in an unsafe system can be unwise. Calibrate.

Examples from the field
Example
Mask buys airtime with a volatile SVP. 10% more real with a peer. All-day cost: Sunday dread. Calibrated, not a confession in the all-hands.
Professional
Code-switch fatigue. Coach explores what the mask protects and where selective authenticity is safe.
Manager
Professional persona hides humour. One small authentic act in a safe meeting.
Sample exchange
Client

I hide who I really am at work.

Coach

What does the mask protect you from?

Client

Being judged.

Coach

Where could you take it off a little, safely?

Signs it’s working

The client calibrates authenticity rather than choosing all or nothing.

Don’t confuse with

S6.14 First-generation / outsider-in-the-room load

First-generation load is structural and includes code-switching. Mask vs authentic can happen to anyone.

S6.9Comparing to a past self
“I used to be sharper / braver”
Honor then. Meet now. Different season, different strengths
In the room

“I used to be sharper / braver.”

It might sound like
  • I used to be sharper.
  • I was braver in my twenties.
  • I'm not the person I was.
What’s underneath

Nostalgia for a past self can insult the present one. Different season, different strengths.

Questions that often open it
  1. What did that past self have that you can still use?
  2. What does this season require that they didn’t?
  3. What is the insult hidden in the comparison?
  4. What is true of you now that was not true then?
Avoid here

Trying to resurrect 32-year-old them.

Watch

Nostalgia for a past self can insult the present one.

Examples from the field
Example
Past self had speed. This season requires political patience they did not have. Insult hidden: “you got soft.” Also true now: they can keep a team.
Leader in 50s
Compares themselves to their younger self. Coach explores strengths of this season.
Returner
After a career break, feels slower. Coach finds new strengths gained.
Sample exchange
Client

I used to be so fearless.

Coach

What do you have now that you didn't then?

Client

Judgement. Patience.

Coach

How could those help here?

Signs it’s working

The client appreciates current strengths rather than mourning past ones.

Don’t confuse with

S3.16 Nostalgia / golden past

Nostalgia misses a past situation. Comparing to a past self misses a past version of oneself.

S6.10Legacy / last-chapter questions
What will I leave, who will I have been
Contribution, people, body of work, unfinished conversations
In the room

What will I leave. Who will I have been.

It might sound like
  • What will I leave behind?
  • I want my work to have mattered.
  • I've got maybe ten years left in this.
What’s underneath

Legacy talk can avoid today’s messy conversation. Keep both. Today’s version of legacy, not only the eulogy.

Questions that often open it
  1. What do you want to be true because you were here?
  2. Who needs something only you can give now?
  3. What unfinished conversation belongs to this chapter?
  4. What is today’s version of legacy, not only the eulogy version?
Avoid here

Vision board only. Reducing it to KPIs.

Watch

Legacy talk can avoid today’s messy conversation. Keep both.

Examples from the field
Example
Talks legacy; unsent conversation with a brother. Today’s version: that call. Eulogy can wait.
Retiring headteacher
Talks about legacy in big terms. Coach asks what legacy looks like this term. The answer is mentoring the deputy who will take over.
Professor
Wants to leave a mark. Coach asks what legacy looks like this week.
Sample exchange
Client

I want to be remembered for building people up.

Coach

What would that look like this Tuesday?

Client

Spending an hour with my deputy.

Coach

Is that in your calendar?

Signs it’s working

Legacy becomes a present action, not only a future story.

Don’t confuse with

S6.16 Purpose fog / “is this all?”

Purpose fog doesn't know what matters. Legacy knows and wonders what will last.

S6.11Inner critic running the meeting
Harsh voice, pre-emptive attack
Personify the critic. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime
In the room

Harsh voice. Pre-emptive attack.

It might sound like
  • A voice in my head says I'll mess it up.
  • I tell myself off constantly.
  • I'm my own worst critic.
What’s underneath

Don’t exile the critic. Give it a smaller seat. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime.

Questions that often open it
  1. If the critic is trying to protect you, from what?
  2. What would a wiser inner chairperson say?
  3. How much airtime does the critic actually need to do its job?
  4. What happens if the critic sits slightly to the side, not in the chair?
Avoid here

“Silence your inner critic” posters.

Watch

Don’t exile the critic. Give it a smaller seat.

Examples from the field
Example
Critic protects from a parent’s public shaming. Needs five minutes of risk-check, not the whole prep. Chairperson runs the rest.
Manager
Critic runs every meeting. Coach asks the critic's job (protecting from embarrassment) and negotiates airtime.
Writer
Critic blocks drafts. Coach gives it a smaller seat: editing time only.
Sample exchange
Client

My inner critic won't shut up.

Coach

What is it trying to protect you from?

Client

Looking stupid.

Coach

Could it have a smaller seat — say, five minutes after the meeting?

Signs it’s working

The client relates to the critic as a part with a job, not as the truth.

Don’t confuse with

S6.12 Parts in conflict

Parts in conflict are two wants pulling. The inner critic is one harsh voice.

S6.12Parts in conflict
One part wants the promotion, one wants peace
Parts / empty chair. Let both speak. Find a third way
In the room

One part wants the promotion, one wants peace.

It might sound like
  • Part of me wants it, part of me doesn't.
  • I'm torn.
  • Two voices in my head.
What’s underneath

Do not pick a winner too early. Both care about something. Third way that does not exile either.

Questions that often open it
  1. Can we hear from the part that wants X, then the part that fears X?
  2. What do both care about?
  3. What is each part afraid will happen if the other wins?
  4. What third way would not exile either part?
Avoid here

Aligning with the “healthy” part.

Watch

Do not pick a winner too early.

Examples from the field
Example
Promotion vs marriage/sleep. Both care about a life that matters and a body that lasts. Third way: role with written non-negotiables, 90-day review.
Manager
One part wants promotion, one wants peace. Coach gives both a voice; a third way emerges.
Founder
Part wants to grow, part wants to sell. Both care about family security.
Sample exchange
Client

Part of me wants the job, part of me wants a quiet life.

Coach

What does each part care about?

Client

Growth… and my kids.

Coach

Is there a way to honour both?

Signs it’s working

Both parts are heard and the client finds an option that doesn't exile either.

Don’t confuse with

S5.14 Stuck between option A and B

Stuck between A and B is about external options. Parts in conflict are about inner wants.

S6.13Success would break a loyalty
Family script, class, culture, “people like us don’t…”
Name the loyalty. Grieve it. Design a both/and if possible
In the room

Family script, class, culture. “People like us don’t…”

It might sound like
  • People like us don't do that.
  • My family would think I'd changed.
  • I feel like I'm betraying where I'm from.
What’s underneath

Sacred ground. Go slowly. Name the loyalty. Grieve it. Design both/and if possible. Multi-generational patience.

Questions that often open it
  1. Who would you be leaving if you succeed?
  2. How might success still honor them?
  3. What loyalty is this — and is it still the one you choose?
  4. What would a respectful departure from the old script sound like?
Avoid here

Individualist “just choose you” in session one.

Watch

This is sacred ground. Go slowly.

Examples from the field
Example
First to take equity over a stable profession. Honor: they still send money and stories home. Departure: “I am using what you survived to build,” not “you were wrong.”
First-gen executive
Promotion feels like leaving family behind. Coach names the loyalty gently and explores both/and.
Artist from business family
Success in art feels like betrayal. Coach goes slowly.
Sample exchange
Client

If I succeed, I'm not one of them anymore.

Coach

Who is 'them'?

Client

My family. My town.

Coach

What would it mean to carry them with you?

Signs it’s working

The loyalty is named and honoured, and the client explores success that keeps the bond.

Don’t confuse with

S5.8 Sabotages near success

Sabotage is the behaviour. Loyalty to family or class can be the reason behind it.

S6.14First-generation / outsider-in-the-room load
Translating worlds, extra vigilance
Name the extra labor. Resources. Belonging design
In the room

Translating worlds. Extra vigilance.

It might sound like
  • I'm always translating between worlds.
  • I have to work twice as hard.
  • Nobody here grew up like me.
What’s underneath

Do not treat structural load as a confidence gap only. Name extra labor. Belonging design. Skill vs structural load.

Questions that often open it
  1. What are you carrying that insiders don’t see?
  2. What support would make the room more livable?
  3. What is skill, and what is structural load?
  4. Where do you want to stop translating and just be?
Avoid here

Imposter toolkit only.

Watch

Do not treat structural load as a confidence gap only.

Examples from the field
Example
Translates culture both ways all day. Support: one insider ally briefed. Stop translating: one meeting where they do not explain themselves.
First-gen lawyer
Exhausted from extra vigilance. Coach names the extra labour as structural, not a confidence gap.
Immigrant manager
Navigating unwritten rules. Coach helps design belonging and allies.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm always on guard here.

Coach

That's extra work most people don't have to do. What does it cost you?

Client

Energy. All of it.

Coach

Who could share some of that load?

Signs it’s working

The extra load is named and the client finds support rather than self-blame.

Don’t confuse with

S6.2 Imposter feelings

Imposter feelings are internal doubt. Outsider load is real structural extra work.

S6.15Values-action gap
Says family, lives inbox
Calendar audit. One aligned act. Repair
In the room

Says family, lives inbox.

It might sound like
  • Family's my priority, but I'm never home.
  • I value health, but I don't exercise.
  • I'm not living what I believe.
What’s underneath

Values speeches without calendar change increase shame. Audit. One aligned act. What to stop.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where does your week already tell the truth?
  2. What 60-minute act would close the gap this week?
  3. Which value is on the wall and missing from Tuesday?
  4. What would you stop that is crowding the value out?
Avoid here

More articulation.

Watch

Values speeches without calendar change increase shame.

Examples from the field
Example
Family on the wall; 21:40 Slack. Stop: two nights closed laptop. One act beats a new value deck.
Executive
Says family, lives inbox. Coach audits the calendar and adds one aligned act.
Manager
Values learning but never trains. One hour blocked weekly.
Sample exchange
Client

My family matters most.

Coach

Where does that show up in your calendar?

Client

…It doesn't.

Coach

What's one change this week?

Signs it’s working

One aligned act appears in the calendar and something gets stopped.

Don’t confuse with

S3.11 Abstract values with no behavior

Abstract values haven't been turned into behaviour. Values–action gap is the painful awareness of the mismatch.

S6.16Purpose fog / “is this all?”
Success without meaning
Life chapters, contribution, aliveness clues
In the room

Success without meaning.

It might sound like
  • Is this all there is?
  • I'm successful but empty.
  • What's the point?
What’s underneath

Purpose is found in clues and experiments, not one slogan. Aliveness. What wants to end. What wants a bigger place.

Questions that often open it
  1. When did you last feel alive in the work?
  2. What wants a bigger place?
  3. What wants to end?
  4. What experiment would give purpose a chance to show itself?
Avoid here

Purpose statement workshop as the product.

Watch

Purpose is found in clues and experiments, not one slogan.

Examples from the field
Example
Last alive: teaching juniors on a whiteboard. Experiment: two hours of that protected. Slogan later, if ever.
Senior manager
Success without meaning. Coach explores what makes them feel alive, using small clues.
Banker
'Is this all?' Experiment: volunteer one evening a month.
Sample exchange
Client

I've got everything I wanted, but it feels empty.

Coach

When did you last feel really alive?

Client

Mentoring a graduate.

Coach

What's in that?

Signs it’s working

The client finds clues to meaning and plans a small experiment.

Don’t confuse with

S6.3 High achiever crash / arrival fallacy

Arrival crash is right after a goal. Purpose fog can be long-running.

S6.17Duty vs desire
Should-career vs pull
Both voices. Design experiments that honor both where possible
In the room

Should-career vs pull.

It might sound like
  • I should stay in law, but I want to teach.
  • Duty says one thing, my heart another.
  • I can't just follow my passion.
What’s underneath

Do not romanticize desire or sanctify duty. Both voices. Both/and for this season if possible.

Questions that often open it
  1. What does duty fear will happen if you follow desire?
  2. What does desire know that duty will not say?
  3. Where is a both/and possible for this season?
  4. If both voices sat at the table, what deal could they live with?
Avoid here

Picking for them.

Watch

Do not romanticize desire or sanctify duty.

Examples from the field
Example
Duty: keep the license. Desire: build the studio. Season deal: license hours three days; studio two. Review in six months.
Doctor
Duty to patients vs desire to write. Coach explores both/and for this season.
Heir to family business
Duty to run it vs desire to start something new.
Sample exchange
Client

I should keep this job, but I want something else.

Coach

What does the duty care about? And the desire?

Client

Security… and aliveness.

Coach

Is there a version that gives some of both?

Signs it’s working

Both voices are respected and a both/and option is explored.

Don’t confuse with

S3.5 Should / must / have-to language

Should-language may be a habit. Duty vs desire is a deep values conflict.

S6.18Family expectation vs own goal
Invisible stakeholders at the table
Name who is in the room. Adult-to-adult with the script
In the room

Invisible stakeholders at the table.

It might sound like
  • My parents expect me to be a doctor.
  • I don't want to disappoint my family.
  • They'd never understand.
What’s underneath

Go gently. Old loyalties. Name who is in the room. Adult-to-adult with the script.

Questions that often open it
  1. Whose voice is in this decision?
  2. What would you choose if they could be proud either way?
  3. What is yours, and what is inherited?
  4. What conversation with the living or the internalized would clear the table?
Avoid here

Cutting-off fantasies as session one homework.

Watch

Go gently. These loyalties are old.

Examples from the field
Example
Mother’s voice in the promotion no. Named. Living conversation possible; or a letter they do not send. Choice becomes theirs.
Graduate
Family expects medicine; wants design. Coach names who's in the room, gently.
Manager
Family business expectations. Adult-to-adult conversation is planned.
Sample exchange
Client

My parents sacrificed so much for this.

Coach

Who else is in the room when you make this decision?

Client

My mum. My grandfather.

Coach

What would you want to say to them, adult to adult?

Signs it’s working

The client names invisible stakeholders and finds their own voice.

Don’t confuse with

S6.13 Success would break a loyalty

Loyalty breaking is about class or culture identity. Family expectation is about a specific goal or path.

Related situations
S6.19Money vs meaning tension
Golden handcuffs, lifestyle lock
Numbers + values. Runway. Enough definition
In the room

Golden handcuffs. Lifestyle lock.

It might sound like
  • I can't afford to leave.
  • I'm stuck in golden handcuffs.
  • Meaningful work doesn't pay.
What’s underneath

Fantasy exits without numbers stay fantasy. Enough definition. Runway. Numbers + values.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is enough?
  2. What would a 2-year bridge look like?
  3. What are you afraid to want?
  4. If money were handled for 18 months, what would you do with your days?
Avoid here

“Follow the bliss” with no math.

Watch

Fantasy exits without numbers stay fantasy.

Examples from the field
Example
Enough is named as a number for the first time. Bridge: two years, one consulting retainer. Fantasy becomes a plan or an honest stay.
Banker
Wants meaningful work but has mortgage. Coach works numbers and values: runway and 'enough'.
Lawyer
Fantasy exit. Coach defines the real cost.
Sample exchange
Client

I'd leave if it weren't for the money.

Coach

How much is enough?

Client

I've never actually calculated it.

Coach

Shall we?

Signs it’s working

The client has real numbers and can decide with values and facts.

Don’t confuse with

S6.16 Purpose fog / “is this all?”

Purpose fog doesn't know what's meaningful. Money vs meaning knows, but feels trapped by finances.

S6.20Rest guilt / always-on
Phone in bed, vacation inbox
Off-design. Identity beyond usefulness
In the room

Phone in bed. Vacation inbox.

It might sound like
  • I check email in bed.
  • I can't switch off on holiday.
  • What if something urgent comes in?
What’s underneath

Always-on is often anxiety management. Off-design. Identity beyond usefulness.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is rest for, in your own words?
  2. What would a protected off-period give the work later?
  3. Who are you when you are not useful?
  4. What boundary with the device would make rest real?
Avoid here

Wellness slogans.

Watch

Always-on is often anxiety management.

Examples from the field
Example
Rest is for a nervous system that can think on Monday. Device in another room Saturday morning — already an exception that works. Do more of that.
Executive
Always on. Coach explores anxiety underneath and designs off-time.
Manager
Checks email on holiday. Experiment: one device-free day.
Sample exchange
Client

I just can't switch off.

Coach

What are you afraid would happen if you did?

Client

Something would go wrong.

Coach

What's one hour you could protect?

Signs it’s working

The client protects some real off-time and notices nothing collapsed.

Don’t confuse with

S6.6 Worth = productivity

Worth = productivity is the belief. Always-on is the behaviour, often anxiety-driven.

S6.21Creativity blocked
Dry, bored, safe
Play, constraints as fuel, permission to make bad work
In the room

Dry, bored, safe.

It might sound like
  • I've got nothing new.
  • Everything I make is boring.
  • I've lost my spark.
What’s underneath

Block is often fear or depletion, not lack of talent. Play. Permission to make bad work. Constraints as fuel.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where is there aliveness even 5%?
  2. What would you make if no one saw it?
  3. What is the block protecting?
  4. What tiny, bad, private thing could you make this week?
Avoid here

Inspiration speeches. Big projects.

Watch

Block is often fear or depletion, not lack of talent.

Examples from the field
Example
Block protecting them from being seen as less brilliant than their reputation. Private bad sketchbook. Reputation not invited.
Designer
Stuck for ideas. Coach invites play and permission to make bad work.
Strategist
Safe, dull proposals. Constraint: three wild ideas in ten minutes.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm completely blocked.

Coach

What if you made something deliberately bad?

Client

(laughs) That would be easy.

Coach

Try it this week.

Signs it’s working

The client creates something, even rough, and the block loosens.

Don’t confuse with

S2.16 Burned out / depleted

Burnout is depletion. Creativity block can be fear or depletion; check which.

S6.22Midlife / quarter-life / chapter change
Time awareness, identity inventory
Past-future-present deep dive. What to keep / drop / begin
In the room

Time awareness. Identity inventory.

It might sound like
  • I'm 40 and wondering what I've done.
  • Is it too late to change?
  • I'm at a crossroads.
What’s underneath

Do not pathologize a chapter change. Keep / drop / begin. What the last chapter cannot hold.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is complete?
  2. What is unfinished?
  3. What is calling that has no name yet?
  4. What belongs to the next chapter that the last one cannot hold?
Avoid here

Crisis diagnosis. Instant reinvention plan.

Watch

Do not pathologize a chapter change.

Examples from the field
Example
Expert chapter complete. Unfinished: a conversation with a co-founder. Calling with no name: making things with their hands. Next chapter must hold that; last one cannot.
Professional at 45
Time awareness. Coach uses keep / drop / begin.
Graduate at 25
Quarter-life wobble. Coach normalises a chapter change.
Sample exchange
Client

I feel like time is running out.

Coach

What do you want to keep, drop, and begin?

Client

Keep my team. Drop the travel. Begin teaching.

Coach

Which feels most urgent?

Signs it’s working

The client sees the chapter change as normal and names what to keep, drop and begin.

Don’t confuse with

S6.16 Purpose fog / “is this all?”

Purpose fog is about meaning. A chapter change is about time and life stage.

S6.23Spiritual / existential edge in a work topic
Mortality, meaning, faith, emptiness
Respect the depth. Don't reduce to a productivity plan
In the room

Mortality, meaning, faith, emptiness arriving inside a work title.

It might sound like
  • What's the point of any of it?
  • Since my friend died, work feels different.
  • I've been thinking about faith.
What’s underneath

Respect the depth. Don’t reduce to a productivity plan. Stay in coaching scope. Refer if clinical despair. Some of this wants reverence, not a framework.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is this asking about a life, not only a job?
  2. What would a meaningful next year include?
  3. What wants reverence rather than a plan?
  4. What support beyond coaching does this edge need?
Avoid here

OKRs for a soul. Amateur theology.

Watch

Stay in coaching scope. Refer if it becomes clinical despair.

Examples from the field
Example
After a parent’s illness, “is this all” arrives in a role conversation. Coaching holds: what a meaningful next year includes at work. Also names: this edge may want pastoral or clinical support they choose.
Leader
After a bereavement, work questions turn existential. Coach respects the depth and stays in scope.
Manager
Emptiness inside a work topic. Coach checks if referral is needed.
Sample exchange
Client

Since my dad died, none of this seems to matter.

Coach

That sounds like a big shift. What feels most important now?

Client

Time with people.

Coach

How could work make room for that?

Signs it’s working

The depth is respected, and the client finds a way to connect it to their life and work.

Don’t confuse with

S8.13 Wants therapy from coaching — or vice versa

Wanting therapy may need referral. Existential depth can stay in coaching if handled with respect.

S6.24Retirement or late-career transition
End of career in sight; identity, structure and status about to change
Walk the timeline; find what carries forward; picture a wanted next chapter
In the room

Mixed relief and dread. “Who will I be without this?” Talks about the end date often.

It might sound like
  • I’ve no idea who I’ll be when I stop.
  • Everyone says I’ll love it, but I’m not sure.
  • I’ve been counting down, and now it’s close I’m scared.
What’s underneath

Retirement is an identity transition, not just a date. Work has provided structure, status and belonging. Without a picture of what replaces them, the end feels like a cliff. Grief and excitement can sit side by side.

Questions that often open it
  1. What will you miss, and what won’t you miss?
  2. What has work given you besides income?
  3. What do you want the next chapter to be about?
  4. What would a good ordinary Tuesday look like a year from now?
Avoid here

Turning it into a hobby list. Assuming retirement means stopping all work. Rushing past the loss.

Watch

Honour the ending before planning the beginning.

Examples from the field
Example
A finance director with 30 years’ service plans to stop in six months. Timeline work shows the thread is developing people. The plan becomes two non-executive roles and a mentoring programme, not golf.
Head nurse
Dreads losing the team. Coach explores what belonging means to her. She plans to join a community health board.
Engineer
Excited, then flat after leaving. A future-self letter helps him design a weekly structure.
Sample exchange
Client

Six months and I’m done. I should be happy.

Coach

What feelings are actually there?

Client

Relief. And fear of being irrelevant.

Coach

What would make the next chapter feel relevant to you?

Signs it’s working

The client can name both the loss and the hopes, and has a picture of the next chapter beyond the date.

Don’t confuse with

S6.22 Midlife / quarter-life / chapter change

Chapter change can happen at any age. Retirement is the end of a working identity, with its own grief and freedom.

S6.25Neurodivergence shaping how they work (ADHD, autism, dyslexia)
Work set up for different brains; strong in some areas, worn out in others
Spot strengths; design the environment and adjustments around how they work best
In the room

Describes struggling with systems built for other brains. May or may not use a diagnosis. Often exhausted from masking.

It might sound like
  • I can do the hard bits brilliantly and then forget the simple ones.
  • Open-plan offices destroy me.
  • I spend all day pretending to work like everyone else.
What’s underneath

The client’s mind works differently, not wrongly. Problems often come from a poor fit between how they work best and how the job is set up. Coaching works on fit, strengths and adjustments, not on “fixing” the person. Diagnosis is not the coach’s role.

Questions that often open it
  1. When does your mind work at its best?
  2. What conditions get in the way?
  3. What adjustments would help most?
  4. Who could you ask about them?
Avoid here

Diagnosing or suggesting a diagnosis. Treating it as a confidence problem. Generic productivity advice.

Watch

Never diagnose. Work on fit, not on fixing the person.

Examples from the field
Example
A product manager with ADHD loses track of long meetings. Coach helps design shorter meetings with written agendas, and they ask for this as a reasonable adjustment.
Autistic analyst
Excellent with data, drained by networking events. Coach helps them choose one-to-one networking instead.
Dyslexic executive
Slow with long reports. Switches to audio summaries and short briefing notes.
Sample exchange
Client

I’m brilliant at some things and terrible at admin.

Coach

When does your mind work at its best?

Client

Big problems, short sprints, quiet room.

Coach

How could more of your week look like that?

Signs it’s working

The client designs adjustments that fit how they work and feels less need to hide it.

Don’t confuse with

S6.8 Mask vs authentic self at work

Mask vs authentic self is a general pull. Here, masking is about hiding a different way of thinking and working.

S6.26Chronic illness or health limits reshaping work (including menopause)
Health limits energy or capacity; fear of being judged as unreliable
Sort control; redesign work around real limits; plan the conversations
In the room

Energy varies day to day. Worry about being seen as unreliable. May hide symptoms.

It might sound like
  • Some days I’m fine, some days I can’t think.
  • I don’t want them to think I can’t cope.
  • I’m not the person I was two years ago.
What’s underneath

Health changes the resources available, not the person’s value. The coaching challenge is redesigning work around real limits, communicating needs, and dealing with the identity hit. Medical questions belong with medical professionals.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is in your control, and what isn’t?
  2. When is your energy best?
  3. What would you need from your workplace?
  4. How would you like to talk about this, if at all?
Avoid here

Medical advice. Pushing performance goals as if health is unchanged. Treating it as purely a mindset issue.

Watch

No medical advice. Coach the redesign, not the diagnosis.

Examples from the field
Example
A senior lawyer going through menopause has poor sleep and brain fog. Coach helps sort what’s in her control, plan demanding work for her best hours, and prepare a conversation with HR.
Manager with long Covid
Plans a phased schedule and talks to her boss about it.
Engineer with chronic pain
Restructures the week around good and bad days.
Sample exchange
Client

I’m scared they’ll think I’m not up to the job.

Coach

What would you need from them to do your best work?

Client

Flexibility on bad days.

Coach

How would you ask for that?

Signs it’s working

The client has a practical plan that respects their limits and feels less alone with it.

Don’t confuse with

S2.16 Burned out / depleted

Burnout is depletion from work. Health limits come from the body, and work has to adapt to them.

S7
Situation group · 37 situations

Other people and the system

About this group

A professional coaching topic almost always includes other people and a system standing just outside the room: a boss, a peer, a direct report, a board, an organizational culture, a calendar full of other people's priorities, a structural constraint the client did not design. This is the largest group in the guide — thirty-seven situations — because the world outside the session is where most of a client's stated problems actually live, even when the conversation about them happens entirely inside the coach's four walls.

The central discipline here is refusing two tempting shortcuts. The first is treating a genuine system problem as only a mindset problem — coaching someone to feel better about an unworkable structure instead of naming that the structure itself needs to change, or that a conversation with the person who controls it is overdue. The situations here ask the coach to sort what is person, what is role, and what is system, because clients (and sometimes coaches) collapse all three into a single personal failing far more often than is warranted. The second shortcut is treating a relationship problem as only a communication-technique problem — handing over a script when what is actually missing is the request that was never made, the score quietly being kept, the dual role that was never named out loud, or the standard that was assumed but never actually stated.

Several situations in this section — influence without formal authority, scope creep, a new boss whose priorities are still unknown, promotion ambivalence, quiet-quitting exit energy in oneself, an ethical gray zone that is not clearly illegal but is not clearly clean either — were included because they specifically resist being resolved through inner work alone. They need a clean, real conversation out in the world, not merely a cleaner story about it inside the client's head. Coaching that stays entirely internal when the actual next step is external is, in these situations, a subtle form of avoidance dressed up as depth.

S7.1Conflict with a boss
Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading
Intent/impact, request, manage-up map, power reality
In the room

Walking on eggs, rage, mind-reading.

It might sound like
  • My boss is impossible.
  • I walk on eggshells around her.
  • He never listens.
What’s underneath

Work inside power reality without disappearing. Intent/impact, request, manage-up map. Do not coach rebellion they will not choose — or submission they will resent.

Questions that often open it
  1. What does your boss actually optimize for?
  2. What is the smallest true conversation?
  3. What do you want them to understand — and what do you want them to do?
  4. What is the power reality you must work inside, without disappearing?
Avoid here

Courage speeches that ignore power. Joining the prosecution.

Watch

Do not coach rebellion they will not choose — or submission they will resent.

Examples from the field
Example
Boss optimizes for no surprises, not for innovation. Smallest conversation: risk-flag cadence. Power named; voice not erased.
Analyst
Afraid of their manager's temper. Coach maps intent vs impact and plans one clear request.
Director
Clashes with the CEO. Coach builds a manage-up map within the power reality.
Sample exchange
Client

My boss undermines me in meetings.

Coach

What would you want to ask her for?

Client

To raise concerns with me first.

Coach

How could you say that?

Signs it’s working

The client plans a clear request that respects the power reality without disappearing.

Don’t confuse with

S7.11 Managing up poorly

Managing up poorly is about the client's own habits. Conflict with a boss is about friction in the relationship.

S7.2Conflict with a peer
Territory, credit, style clash
Shared purpose, clean requests, third-side view
In the room

Territory, credit, style clash.

It might sound like
  • She takes credit for my work.
  • We just don't get along.
  • He's always stepping on my turf.
What’s underneath

Often unstated score-keeping. Shared purpose. Clean requests. Third-side view.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you were on the same side of the table facing the problem, what would change?
  2. What do they want that you haven’t granted?
  3. What score are you still keeping?
  4. What is the shared purpose that is larger than the clash?
Avoid here

Winning strategy only.

Watch

Peer conflict is often unstated score-keeping.

Examples from the field
Example
Credit war. Score: last year’s launch. Shared purpose: this quarter’s customer. Request: names on the memo. Score named so it stops driving.
Manager
Clash over who owns a project. Coach finds shared purpose and a clean request.
Peer
Style clash. Third-side view: what would a neutral colleague say?
Sample exchange
Client

He's always trying to take over my area.

Coach

What do you both care about here?

Client

Getting the client happy.

Coach

What could you ask him for?

Signs it’s working

The client finds common ground and makes one clean request.

Don’t confuse with

S7.13 Feeling unseen / credit stolen

Credit stolen is about visibility. Peer conflict covers broader territory and style.

S7.3Difficult direct report
Avoidance or over-control
Clear standard, feedback, consequence, development stance
In the room

Avoidance or over-control.

It might sound like
  • One of my team is a nightmare.
  • I don't know how to handle him.
  • She just won't change.
What’s underneath

Caring is not the same as being clear. Standard, feedback, consequence, development stance.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is the standard?
  2. Have you said it plainly?
  3. What happens if nothing changes?
  4. Are you developing them or protecting yourself from the conversation?
Avoid here

More empathy without a standard. PIP talk as first move when the standard was never said.

Watch

Caring is not the same as being clear.

Examples from the field
Example
Late stakeholder updates. Standard never said plainly. First: say it. Then consequence if needed. Not a sudden PIP.
Manager
Avoids a difficult report. Coach sets standard, feedback and consequence.
Team lead
Over-controls a struggling employee. Coach explores development stance.
Sample exchange
Client

I keep avoiding talking to him.

Coach

What's the standard he isn't meeting?

Client

Deadlines.

Coach

What would clear, caring feedback sound like?

Signs it’s working

The client is clear about the standard and plans a direct conversation.

Don’t confuse with

S7.14 Need to give hard feedback

Hard feedback is the conversation. A difficult direct report is the ongoing relationship.

S7.4Conflict-avoidant
Keeps peace, stores residue, surprise explosions later
Micro-truths. Body first. 2-minute version of the conversation
In the room

Keeps peace. Stores residue. Surprise explosions later.

It might sound like
  • I'd rather keep the peace.
  • It's not worth the fight.
  • I'll just let it go.
What’s underneath

Teach titrated honesty, not a personality transplant. Body first. 2-minute version.

Questions that often open it
  1. What truth is going unsaid to keep the peace?
  2. What is the cost of this peace?
  3. What is the 2-minute version you could say this week?
  4. What happens in your body right before you swallow it?
Avoid here

“Have the big fight.”

Watch

Teach titrated honesty, not a personality transplant.

Examples from the field
Example
Swallows “this date is fiction.” Body: swallow reflex. 2-minute version to the PM this week. Titration.
Manager
Stores up resentment, then explodes. Coach teaches a two-minute honest version.
Employee
Avoids every disagreement. Body first: noticing tension, then one small honest sentence.
Sample exchange
Client

I don't like confrontation.

Coach

What's the two-minute version of what you'd want to say?

Client

'I'd like to be consulted next time.'

Coach

That's not confrontation. That's clarity.

Signs it’s working

The client says something honest in a small dose and survives it.

Don’t confuse with

S7.6 People-pleasing frame

People-pleasing says yes. Conflict-avoidant stays quiet.

S7.5Conflict-seeking / always the fight
Identity as the one who says it
Discern which fights matter. Tone vs content
In the room

Identity as the one who says it.

It might sound like
  • Someone has to say it.
  • I'm the one who tells the truth.
  • I don't do diplomacy.
What’s underneath

Do not shame their courage. Aim it. Which fights matter. Tone vs content. Winning with the relationship intact.

Questions that often open it
  1. Which battle is actually yours?
  2. What would winning with the relationship intact look like?
  3. Where is courage becoming a habit that costs you?
  4. What fight would you retire if you only kept the ones that matter?
Avoid here

Making them “nice.”

Watch

Do not shame their courage. Aim it.

Examples from the field
Example
Fights every process. Two that matter: safety and a false date. Retire the rest. Courage aimed.
Union representative
Challenges every management proposal. Coach asks which two fights really matter this year. Picking those makes their voice stronger, not weaker.
Engineer
Truth-teller identity. Coach separates tone from content.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm the only one brave enough to challenge.

Coach

Which fights really matter?

Client

Maybe two out of ten.

Coach

And the other eight?

Signs it’s working

The client chooses battles and thinks about winning with the relationship intact.

Don’t confuse with

S2.3 Angry / blaming / righteous heat

Anger is a feeling. Conflict-seeking is an identity and habit.

S7.6People-pleasing frame
Yes first, resentment later
Need vs please. Practice a boundaried no
In the room

Yes first, resentment later.

It might sound like
  • I always say yes.
  • I don't want to let anyone down.
  • I'll just fit it in.
What’s underneath

Pleasing was often a brilliant old strategy. Need vs please. Practice a boundaried no.

Questions that often open it
  1. What are you afraid will happen if you disappoint them?
  2. What would a kind no sound like?
  3. What need of yours is being traded for their comfort?
  4. Where did pleasing start helping you — and where does it now cost you?
Avoid here

“Just say no” without the old strategy honored.

Watch

Pleasing was often a brilliant old strategy.

Examples from the field
Example
Pleasing started in a volatile house. Costs them now in scope creep. Kind no practiced. History honored.
Manager
Yes to every request, then resentful. Coach practises a boundaried no.
Assistant
Pleasing as old strategy. Coach honours it, then explores need vs please.
Sample exchange
Client

I said yes again. I couldn't help it.

Coach

What would a kind no sound like?

Client

'I can't this week, but I could next Tuesday.'

Coach

Try saying that aloud.

Signs it’s working

The client practises and uses a boundaried no.

Don’t confuse with

S4.11 Over-owning other people’s emotions

Over-owning emotions feels responsible for feelings. People-pleasing seeks approval.

S7.7Can’t ask for help
Solo hero, shame about need
Normalize interdependence. Script the ask. Start small
In the room

Solo hero. Shame about need.

It might sound like
  • I'll manage alone.
  • I don't want to bother anyone.
  • Asking for help feels weak.
What’s underneath

Help-refusal can look like strength and cost the system. Normalize interdependence. Smallest clean ask.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would you let a trusted person carry this week?
  2. What makes asking feel dangerous?
  3. What is the smallest clean ask?
  4. What are you proving by not asking?
Avoid here

Lecture on teamwork.

Watch

Help-refusal can look like strength and cost the system.

Examples from the field
Example
Proving they are not a burden. Smallest ask: a peer reviews the deck for 15 minutes. Dangerous and doable.
Manager
Overloaded but won't ask. Coach normalises interdependence; smallest clean ask.
New hire
Struggling silently. Experiment: ask one colleague one question.
Sample exchange
Client

I don't want to look like I can't cope.

Coach

What's the smallest thing you could ask for?

Client

Help with the slides.

Coach

From whom?

Signs it’s working

The client makes one small ask and sees it's welcomed.

Don’t confuse with

S7.8 Can’t receive help / praise / credit

Can't receive help deflects offered help. Can't ask doesn't request it.

S7.8Can’t receive help / praise / credit
Deflects, immediately gives it away
Practice receiving as a skill. 3-second pause
In the room

Deflects. Immediately gives it away.

It might sound like
  • Oh, it was nothing.
  • The team did it, really.
  • You're too kind.
What’s underneath

Receiving is a leadership skill. 3-second pause. Identity that would have to update.

Questions that often open it
  1. What happens in you when credit arrives?
  2. Can you take it in for three seconds before moving it on?
  3. What would receiving give them, not only you?
  4. What identity would have to update if you let it land?
Avoid here

More compliments to overpower deflection.

Watch

Receiving is a leadership skill.

Examples from the field
Example
Credit arrives; body moves it on in one second. Practice three seconds. Receiving gives the giver the dignity of having given.
Leader
Deflects all praise. Coach practises a three-second pause and 'thank you'.
Employee
Rejects offered help. Coach asks what would have to change in their identity to receive.
Sample exchange
Client

It was nothing, really.

Coach

What if you just said 'thank you'?

Client

That feels uncomfortable.

Coach

Try it now.

Signs it’s working

The client receives praise or help with a pause and a thank you.

Don’t confuse with

S5.17 After a win they can’t own

Can't own a win is about self-credit. Can't receive is about accepting from others.

S7.9Trust broken — they broke it or it was broken
Repair vs rumination vs exit
Repair conversation, amends, new agreement, or clean ending
In the room

Repair vs rumination vs exit.

It might sound like
  • I'll never trust him again.
  • I let her down badly.
  • Can it be fixed?
What’s underneath

Not everything is repairable. Don’t force it. Repair conversation, amends, new agreement, or clean ending.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would repair require from you?
  2. What would you need to see to trust again?
  3. Is this repairable — and how would you know?
  4. What would a clean ending look like if repair is not the path?
Avoid here

Forgiveness slogans. Endless rumination.

Watch

Not everything is repairable. Don’t force it.

Examples from the field
Example
Peer leaked a draft. Repair would require an account and a new handling agreement. They would know in 30 days of behavior, not apology poetry. If not, clean ending of that channel.
Manager
Trust broken by a colleague. Coach explores repair, new agreement or clean exit.
Leader
They broke trust. Coach helps plan amends.
Sample exchange
Client

She broke my trust.

Coach

What are your options: repair, new terms, or exit?

Client

Maybe a new agreement.

Coach

What would it include?

Signs it’s working

The client chooses a path (repair, new agreement or exit) rather than ruminating.

Don’t confuse with

S2.13 Resentful / bitter

Resentment stores unmet expectations. Broken trust is a specific breach.

S7.10Politics / influence without authority
No formal power, needs movement
Stakeholder map, interests, allies, small bets
In the room

No formal power. Needs movement.

It might sound like
  • I have no authority here.
  • Politics are dirty.
  • Nobody listens to me.
What’s underneath

Purity about politics can keep them ineffective. Stakeholder map, interests, allies, small bets.

Questions that often open it
  1. Who cares about this outcome and why?
  2. Where is there already movement you can join?
  3. What interest of theirs could this serve?
  4. What small bet would teach you how the system moves?
Avoid here

Moral purity or Machiavelli cosplay.

Watch

Purity about politics can keep them ineffective.

Examples from the field
Example
Quality initiative. Finance already cares about rework cost. Join that movement. Small bet: one joint slide, not a lone manifesto.
Project lead
Needs buy-in without authority. Coach maps stakeholders and allies.
Specialist
Refuses politics. Coach explores small bets for influence.
Sample exchange
Client

I hate playing politics.

Coach

What would ethical influence look like?

Client

Understanding what others need.

Coach

Who's first?

Signs it’s working

The client maps stakeholders and makes a small move to influence.

Don’t confuse with

S7.11 Managing up poorly

Managing up is one relationship. Politics is the wider network.

S7.11Managing up poorly
Surprises the boss, or hides
Boss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics
In the room

Surprises the boss, or hides.

It might sound like
  • My boss is always surprised.
  • I avoid telling her bad news.
  • I don't know what she wants.
What’s underneath

Managing up is service, not sucking up. Boss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics.

Questions that often open it
  1. How does your boss like to learn bad news?
  2. What does a good week look like from their seat?
  3. What are you optimizing for that they are not?
  4. What cadence would make surprises rare?
Avoid here

“Be more authentic” as the whole play.

Watch

Managing up is service, not sucking up.

Examples from the field
Example
They optimize for craft; boss optimizes for no Friday surprises. Cadence: Thursday risk note. Service, not surrender.
Manager
Hides problems from boss. Coach treats boss as client: cadence and risk flags.
Analyst
Surprises boss with issues. Weekly update designed.
Sample exchange
Client

My boss hates surprises, but I hate bad news.

Coach

What would a weekly risk flag look like?

Client

Three bullets on Friday.

Coach

Start this week?

Signs it’s working

The client sets up a regular, honest rhythm with the boss.

Don’t confuse with

S7.1 Conflict with a boss

Conflict with boss is friction. Managing up poorly is about the client's habits.

S7.12Friendship or dual relationship at work
Blurred lines, leftover personal
Name the dual hats. Separate roles in the conversation
In the room

Blurred lines. Leftover personal.

It might sound like
  • She's my friend and my report.
  • It's awkward now.
  • We used to be peers.
What’s underneath

Denial of the dual relationship creates mess. Name the hats. Separate roles in the conversation.

Questions that often open it
  1. Which hat are you wearing?
  2. What would the role require if the friendship were silent for a minute?
  3. What agreement have you never made about the dual relationship?
  4. What is kind to the friendship and clean for the work?
Avoid here

Pretending there is one relationship.

Watch

Denial of the dual relationship creates mess.

Examples from the field
Example
Friend-report late on updates. Role hat: standard. Kind-and-clean: name the dual hats out loud and set the work agreement.
Manager
Promoted over a friend. Coach names the hats and separates roles in conversations.
Founder
Friend as co-founder. Coach helps a clear role talk.
Sample exchange
Client

It's weird managing my friend.

Coach

What hat are you wearing in which conversation?

Client

I hadn't separated them.

Coach

How could you name that with her?

Signs it’s working

The client names the dual relationship openly and separates roles.

Don’t confuse with

S7.2 Conflict with a peer

Peer conflict is about clashes. Dual relationship is about blurred roles.

Related situations
S7.13Feeling unseen / credit stolen
Heat + helplessness
Visibility design, documentation, allies, direct conversation
In the room

Heat + helplessness.

It might sound like
  • Nobody sees my work.
  • He took credit for my idea.
  • I'm invisible here.
What’s underneath

Victim-only or aggression-only both usually fail. Visibility design, documentation, allies, direct conversation.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where did the work become invisible?
  2. What is a clean way to put your name back on it?
  3. Who already knows the truth and could help it be seen?
  4. What conversation is needed — and what documentation?
Avoid here

Only rumination or only war.

Watch

Victim-only or aggression-only both usually fail.

Examples from the field
Example
Section landed in a peer’s deck. Clean: follow-up note with the original artifact copied to the sponsor. Ally already knows. Not a war; not silence.
Engineer
Credit stolen. Coach designs visibility: documentation, allies and a direct conversation.
Analyst
Unseen. Experiment: share one result in a team channel.
Sample exchange
Client

My manager presented my work as his.

Coach

What would help your work be visible?

Client

Sending updates myself.

Coach

When's the next one?

Signs it’s working

The client designs visibility instead of only feeling angry or helpless.

Don’t confuse with

S2.7 Afraid of being seen / visibility anxiety

Visibility anxiety avoids being seen. Feeling unseen wants to be seen.

S7.14Need to give hard feedback
Writes the speech, never delivers
One behavior, one impact, intention, ask. Rehearse
In the room

Writes the speech. Never delivers.

It might sound like
  • I've written the email, but…
  • I don't know how to tell him.
  • I keep postponing it.
What’s underneath

Rehearse out loud. Written essays rarely get spoken. One behavior, one impact, intention, ask.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is the one behavior and one impact?
  2. How will you open so they can hear it?
  3. What is your intention that you want them to feel?
  4. Say it in one minute. What can go?
Avoid here

Longer essays.

Watch

Rehearse out loud. Written essays rarely get spoken.

Examples from the field
Example
Speech is four pages. One minute: late updates, sponsor blindsided, intention to set them up to win, ask for 24-hour pre-alert.
Manager
Writes a feedback speech, never delivers. Coach rehearses aloud: behaviour, impact, ask.
Team lead
Over-softens feedback. Practice once, then deliver.
Sample exchange
Client

I need to tell her the report wasn't good enough.

Coach

One behaviour, one impact, one ask. Try it.

Client

'The report missed the data, and the client noticed. Next time, can we review it together?'

Coach

Good. Again, slower.

Signs it’s working

The client rehearses aloud and delivers the feedback.

Don’t confuse with

S5.16 Need to have a difficult conversation

Difficult conversation is broad. Hard feedback is specific.

S7.15Received feedback they reject
360 sting, “that’s not me”
Separate grain from garbage. Impact vs intent
In the room

360 sting. “That’s not me.”

It might sound like
  • That's not me at all.
  • The 360 is unfair.
  • They don't know me.
What’s underneath

Total rejection wastes the gift. Total collapse wastes the self. Grain from garbage. Impact vs intent.

Questions that often open it
  1. What 10% might be useful even if the delivery was poor?
  2. What do you want to be known for instead?
  3. Where is impact different from your intent?
  4. What would you take seriously if pride stepped aside for a minute?
Avoid here

“The 360 is the truth.” Or “ignore them.”

Watch

Total rejection wastes the gift. Total collapse wastes the self.

Examples from the field
Example
“Arrogant.” Delivery was poor. 10%: they interrupt in design reviews. Want to be known for rigor and room for others. One behavior change, not a personality trial.
Leader
Rejects 360 feedback. Coach finds the grain of truth.
Manager
Collapses under feedback. Coach separates impact from intention.
Sample exchange
Client

That feedback is just wrong.

Coach

Is there any grain of truth in it?

Client

Maybe I am impatient sometimes.

Coach

When?

Signs it’s working

The client takes something useful from the feedback without collapsing.

Don’t confuse with

S8.3 Defensive when challenged

Defensiveness happens in session. Rejecting feedback is about feedback from others.

S7.16Lonely at the top / no peers
Can’t talk inside the company
Design an outside peer space. What can be said here
In the room

Can’t talk inside the company.

It might sound like
  • I can't talk to anyone inside.
  • Nobody understands this level.
  • The coach is my only sounding board.
What’s underneath

The coach is not their only peer. Help them build a bench.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where can the whole truth be spoken?
  2. What do you need that this role cannot give you internally?
  3. Who is on your bench outside the org?
  4. What can we use this coaching for that a peer bench should also hold?
Avoid here

Insight without company.

Watch

The coach is not their only peer. Help them build a bench.

Examples from the field
Example
CEO client. Coaching holds weekly sense-making. Bench: two outside CEOs, one chair. Not coach-as-only-friend.
CEO
No peers internally. Coach helps build a bench: external peers and advisers.
Senior leader
Isolation. Experiment: join a peer forum.
Sample exchange
Client

You're the only one I can talk to.

Coach

Who else could be part of your bench?

Client

Maybe a former colleague.

Coach

When could you reach out?

Signs it’s working

The client builds a network of peers beyond the coach.

Don’t confuse with

S2.12 Lonely in the role / “no one gets it”

Lonely in role can be any level. Lonely at the top is specific to seniority.

S7.17New leader / first-time manager
Still doing the old job, conflict-shy
Role contract, let-go list, first conversations
In the room

Still doing the old job. Conflict-shy.

It might sound like
  • I'm still doing my old job.
  • Managing people is hard.
  • I avoid difficult talks.
What’s underneath

Do not only teach tools. Shift identity. Role contract. Let-go list. First conversations.

Questions that often open it
  1. What must you stop doing that made you successful last time?
  2. What does the team need from you that they didn’t?
  3. What is the role contract you have never written down?
  4. What first conversations would make the new role real?
Avoid here

Toolkits without identity funeral.

Watch

Do not only teach tools. Shift identity.

Examples from the field
Example
Still the best analyst on the team. Stop-doing: last-pass on every model. First conversation: who owns the last-pass now.
First-time manager
Still the best analyst. Coach builds a let-go list and a role contract.
New team lead
Conflict-shy. First conversations planned.
Sample exchange
Client

I keep doing the work myself.

Coach

What do you need to let go of?

Client

Reviewing every report.

Coach

Who could own that?

Signs it’s working

The client lets go of old tasks and starts leading.

Don’t confuse with

S7.18 Expert becoming manager

Expert becoming manager focuses on expertise. New leader is broader: identity, conflict, role.

S7.18Expert becoming manager
Still the smartest doer in the room
From answers to questions. Develop others
In the room

Still the smartest doer in the room.

It might sound like
  • I know the answer faster.
  • It's easier to do it myself.
  • I'm still the expert.
What’s underneath

Expertise is an asset that can become a trap. From answers to questions. Develop others.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where are you still the bottleneck?
  2. What would teaching look like instead of doing?
  3. What does the team lose when you keep being the expert?
  4. What question could replace the answer you usually give?
Avoid here

“Stop being so smart.”

Watch

Their expertise is an asset that can become a trap.

Examples from the field
Example
They answer in 8 seconds. Replace with one question in the design review. Team starts thinking in the room.
Engineer turned manager
Still answering everything. Coach shifts from answers to questions.
Doctor leading a team
Develop others rather than doing.
Sample exchange
Client

I just jump in with the solution.

Coach

What question could you ask instead?

Client

'What do you think we should do?'

Coach

Try it tomorrow.

Signs it’s working

The client asks more questions and develops others.

Don’t confuse with

S6.5 Old identity dying (expert → leader, founder → CEO)

Old identity dying is the grief. Expert becoming manager is the behaviour.

S7.19New boss arrived
Lost the old contract, reading the new one
Observe, inquire, renegotiate value
In the room

Lost the old contract. Reading the new one.

It might sound like
  • My old boss was great.
  • The new boss doesn't get it.
  • I don't know where I stand now.
What’s underneath

Loyalty to the old boss can sabotage the new chapter. Observe, inquire, renegotiate value in the new language.

Questions that often open it
  1. What does the new boss care about that the last one didn’t?
  2. How will you learn them fast?
  3. What value do you need to re-explain in their language?
  4. What loyalty to the old boss is now in the way?
Avoid here

Performing the old contract louder.

Watch

Loyalty to the old boss can sabotage the new chapter.

Examples from the field
Example
Old boss loved craft essays. New boss wants three bullets and a risk. Re-explain value in bullets. Loyalty named and retired.
Manager
New boss arrived; loyalty to old one. Coach explores observing and renegotiating value.
Team member
Reading new expectations. Coach plans an early conversation.
Sample exchange
Client

Everything was fine before she arrived.

Coach

What does she value?

Client

I don't know yet.

Coach

How could you find out?

Signs it’s working

The client learns about the new boss and builds a new contract.

Don’t confuse with

S7.20 Reorg / merger / ambiguity

Reorg is broad ambiguity. New boss is a specific relationship change.

S7.20Reorg / merger / ambiguity
Role fog, rumor mill, freeze
Stabilize controllables. 30-day purpose. Network
In the room

Role fog. Rumor mill. Freeze.

It might sound like
  • Nobody knows what's happening.
  • There are rumours everywhere.
  • I don't know if I'll have a job.
What’s underneath

Do not pretend certainty you don’t have. Stabilize controllables. 30-day purpose. Network.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is known, unknown, and yours to clarify?
  2. How will you be useful in the fog?
  3. What 30-day purpose can you set without fake certainty?
  4. Who do you need to stay connected to while the map is redrawn?
Avoid here

Five-year plans. False reassurance.

Watch

Do not pretend certainty you don’t have.

Examples from the field
Example
Unknown: final structure. Known: customers still need X. 30-day purpose: protect X and stay connected to two nodes. Useful in fog.
Manager
Role fog after merger. Coach focuses on controllables and a 30-day purpose.
Employee
Freezes during restructuring. Coach helps strengthen their network.
Sample exchange
Client

Nobody can tell me what my role will be.

Coach

What can you control in the next 30 days?

Client

My current project. My relationships.

Coach

Let's start there.

Signs it’s working

The client stabilises around what they can control.

Don’t confuse with

S2.4 Anxious / catastrophizing

Anxiety is the feeling. Reorg ambiguity is the real situation.

S7.21Scope creep / everything is urgent
Calendar as crime scene
Priorities as values. What to stop. Stakeholder reset
In the room

Calendar as crime scene.

It might sound like
  • Everything is urgent.
  • My calendar is a nightmare.
  • I can't say no.
What’s underneath

A calendar is a values document. Read it aloud. What to stop. Whom to disappoint on purpose. Stakeholder reset.

Questions that often open it
  1. If you could only keep three outcomes this month, which?
  2. What will you disappoint on purpose?
  3. If your calendar is a values document, what does it say?
  4. What conversation resets scope with the person who keeps adding?
Avoid here

Time-hacking the unworkable pile.

Watch

A calendar is a values document. Read it aloud.

Examples from the field
Example
Calendar says they value being unrefusable. Three outcomes named. Reset with the adder. Values become visible.
Manager
Calendar packed. Coach reads it as a values document and finds what to stop.
Lead
Scope creep. Coach helps decide whom to disappoint on purpose.
Sample exchange
Client

Everything is a priority.

Coach

If your calendar spoke, what would it say you value?

Client

Other people's needs.

Coach

What could you stop?

Signs it’s working

The client removes something from the calendar and accepts disappointing someone.

Don’t confuse with

S1.5 Overwhelmed

Overwhelm is a state. Scope creep is a work design issue.

S7.22Under-resourced / budget / headcount
Asked to do more with less
Renegotiate outcomes, not only hours. Tradeoff conversation
In the room

Asked to do more with less.

It might sound like
  • We have half the people we need.
  • They keep cutting the budget.
  • Do more with less.
What’s underneath

Heroic absorption trains the system to give them less. Renegotiate outcomes, not only hours. Tradeoff conversation.

Questions that often open it
  1. What will you stop, delay, or do worse on purpose?
  2. What conversation have you not had with the person who holds the constraint?
  3. What are you training the system to expect by absorbing it?
  4. What is the tradeoff sentence you need to say?
Avoid here

Resilience pep.

Watch

Heroic absorption trains the system to give them less.

Examples from the field
Example
Same outcomes, minus two people. Tradeoff sentence to the SVP. Absorption would train “they can always take more.”
Manager
Under-resourced team. Coach helps renegotiate outcomes, not just hours.
Department head
Heroic absorption. Coach builds a tradeoff conversation.
Sample exchange
Client

We're expected to deliver the same with fewer people.

Coach

What could you renegotiate?

Client

Deadlines. Scope.

Coach

How would you propose it?

Signs it’s working

The client negotiates tradeoffs rather than absorbing everything.

Don’t confuse with

S4.4 Blaming self for the system

Blaming self for system is internal. Under-resourced is the external reality.

S7.23Unclear expectations
Aiming at a moving target
Make the contract explicit. Success criteria
In the room

Aiming at a moving target.

It might sound like
  • I don't know what they want.
  • The target keeps changing.
  • Nobody tells me.
What’s underneath

Mind-reading the scoreboard is optional. Asking is not. Make the contract explicit.

Questions that often open it
  1. How will we know this was a success in their eyes?
  2. What have you assumed?
  3. What question would make the scoreboard visible?
  4. What are you delivering that nobody asked for?
Avoid here

Working harder at a guessed target.

Watch

Mind-reading the scoreboard is optional. Asking is not.

Examples from the field
Example
Delivering a 40-page strategy nobody asked for. Scoreboard question to the sponsor this week. Assumed “depth = value.”
Employee
Moving targets. Coach helps ask for explicit expectations.
Manager
Unclear goals. Coach writes questions for the boss.
Sample exchange
Client

I never know what success looks like.

Coach

Who could tell you?

Client

My boss.

Coach

What would you ask?

Signs it’s working

The client asks directly and gets clearer expectations.

Don’t confuse with

S3.3 Mind-reading others

Mind-reading guesses others' thoughts. Unclear expectations is a real lack of clarity.

S7.24Promotion ambivalence
Want the level, not the life
Two futures. Role reality, not the title shine
In the room

Want the level, not the life.

It might sound like
  • I want the title, not the job.
  • I'm not sure I want to be promoted.
  • The next level looks miserable.
What’s underneath

Title hunger can hide a lifestyle no. Two futures. Role reality, not title shine.

Questions that often open it
  1. What about the work of that job do you want?
  2. What about the life of that job do you not want?
  3. If the title were stripped away, would you still want the days?
  4. What would you be saying yes to besides the name?
Avoid here

Ambition pep.

Watch

Title hunger can hide a lifestyle no.

Examples from the field
Example
Want the strategy work, not the political evenings. Title stripped: mixed. Negotiation for a scoped role becomes possible.
Manager
Wants VP title but not the lifestyle. Coach explores two futures and role reality.
Analyst
Promotion pressure. Coach checks what they actually want.
Sample exchange
Client

I should go for the promotion.

Coach

Do you want the title, or the life that comes with it?

Client

Honestly? The title.

Coach

Let's look at the real role.

Signs it’s working

The client decides based on the real role, not the title.

Don’t confuse with

S6.17 Duty vs desire

Duty vs desire is broader. Promotion ambivalence is about one specific step.

S7.25Exit energy / quiet quitting in themselves
Doing the minimum, checked out, still there
Tell the truth. Stay fully or leave cleanly. No half-life
In the room

Doing the minimum. Checked out. Still there.

It might sound like
  • I do the minimum now.
  • I've checked out.
  • I'm just waiting.
What’s underneath

A long maybe hurts them and the team. Stay fully or leave cleanly. No half-life.

Questions that often open it
  1. Are you leaving or staying?
  2. What would either choice look like if it were clean?
  3. What is the half-life costing you and them?
  4. What conversation would make the next chapter start?
Avoid here

Engagement hacks.

Watch

A long maybe hurts them and the team.

Examples from the field
Example
Body has left. Clean stay: 90 days of real contribution while they search. Or clean leave conversation. Half-life named as the costliest option.
Employee
Quiet quitting. Coach explores staying fully or leaving cleanly.
Manager
Half-in, half-out. Coach sets a decision date.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm just going through the motions.

Coach

What would staying fully look like? And leaving cleanly?

Client

Leaving, probably.

Coach

What's the first step?

Signs it’s working

The client chooses to recommit or to plan an exit.

Don’t confuse with

S2.16 Burned out / depleted

Burnout is depletion. Exit energy is disengagement and waiting.

S7.26Organizational values clash
Integrity heat, political cost
Name the clash. Options: influence, bound, leave, choose battles
In the room

Integrity heat. Political cost.

It might sound like
  • This company doesn't share my values.
  • I can't support this decision.
  • It feels wrong.
What’s underneath

Do not moralize them into a resignation they don’t choose. Name the clash. Influence, bound, leave, choose battles.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where can you have integrity inside this system?
  2. Where can you not?
  3. What is your line?
  4. Which battle is yours this season?
Avoid here

Purity test.

Watch

Do not moralize them into a resignation they don’t choose.

Examples from the field
Example
Values poster vs quarter-end number massage. Line: they will not sign a false number. This season’s battle: the number, not the entire culture war.
Manager
Values clash with leadership. Coach names the clash and explores influence or exit.
Employee
Integrity heat. Coach doesn't push resignation.
Sample exchange
Client

I can't believe they're doing this.

Coach

What are your options: influence, boundary, or leave?

Client

Influence first.

Coach

Where?

Signs it’s working

The client chooses a response to the clash.

Don’t confuse with

S7.27 Ethics gray zone

Ethics gray zone is unclear right or wrong. Values clash is a known mismatch.

S7.27Ethics gray zone
Not illegal, not clean
Values, stakeholders, future-self, counsel
In the room

Not illegal, not clean.

It might sound like
  • It's not illegal, but…
  • I'm not sure this is right.
  • Everyone does it.
What’s underneath

Stay in coaching. Flag when they need legal/HR, not a coach. Values, stakeholders, future-self, counsel.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would you respect yourself for in two years?
  2. Who else is affected?
  3. What advice would you want on record?
  4. Where does this need legal or HR, not only coaching?
Avoid here

Amateur legal opinions.

Watch

Stay in coaching, and flag when they need legal/HR, not a coach.

Examples from the field
Example
Channel stuffing adjacent. Two-year self would not respect silence. Also: this needs counsel, not only a values chat. Both named.
Manager
Asked to massage numbers. Coach flags when legal or HR is needed.
Consultant
Gray-zone request. Values and future-self lens.
Sample exchange
Client

It's technically allowed, but it feels off.

Coach

How would your future self judge it?

Client

Not well.

Coach

Who else should you consult?

Signs it’s working

The client clarifies their position and knows when to escalate.

Don’t confuse with

S7.26 Organizational values clash

Values clash is clear. Ethics gray zone is ambiguous.

S7.28Cross-cultural / remote / hybrid friction
Misread tone, time zones, silence as meaning
Make norms explicit. Charity of interpretation + clean checkouts
In the room

Misread tone. Time zones. Silence as meaning.

It might sound like
  • Their emails sound rude.
  • Time zones kill us.
  • They never speak in meetings.
What’s underneath

Do not over-psychologize a systems/medium problem. Make norms explicit. Charity of interpretation + clean checkouts.

Questions that often open it
  1. What are you treating as intent that might be culture or medium?
  2. What norm have you never stated?
  3. What generous reading is available?
  4. What checkout question would reduce the mind-reading?
Avoid here

Personality theories about Slack punctuation.

Watch

Do not over-psychologize a systems/medium problem.

Examples from the field
Example
Short Slack from a remote colleague treated as contempt. Medium + time zone. Checkout: “How shall we close decisions in writing?” Norm stated.
Global manager
Misread tone. Coach makes norms explicit.
Remote team lead
Silence misinterpreted. Coach builds communication charter.
Sample exchange
Client

My overseas team never responds.

Coach

What norms have you agreed?

Client

None, really.

Coach

What would you propose?

Signs it’s working

Norms are made explicit, and friction reduces.

Don’t confuse with

S3.3 Mind-reading others

Mind-reading is personal. Cross-cultural friction is structural.

S7.29High-stakes event coming (board, keynote, review)
Performance anxiety + preparation swirl
Purpose, audience, state regulation, rehearsal, good-enough structure
In the room

Performance anxiety + preparation swirl.

It might sound like
  • The board meeting is next week.
  • I'm terrified of the keynote.
  • I keep adding slides.
What’s underneath

More content is rarely the missing piece. Purpose for the audience. State regulation. Rehearsal. Good-enough structure.

Questions that often open it
  1. What does success look like for the audience, not your inner critic?
  2. How will you regulate the hour before?
  3. What is good enough structure?
  4. What extra content is anxiety, not service?
Avoid here

More slides.

Watch

More content is rarely the missing piece.

Examples from the field
Example
60 extra slides are anxiety. Audience success: three decisions. Hour before: walk, not tinkering. Structure good enough.
Executive
Board presentation anxiety. Coach focuses on purpose and state, not more content.
Speaker
Keynote. Rehearsal and good-enough standard.
Sample exchange
Client

I need more slides.

Coach

What does the audience need from you?

Client

A clear recommendation.

Coach

Can you say it in one sentence?

Signs it’s working

The client focuses on purpose and rehearses instead of adding content.

Don’t confuse with

S2.4 Anxious / catastrophizing

Anxiety is general. High-stakes event is specific.

S7.30Work-life / caregiver / dual-career load
Calendar collision, guilt both ways
Design, not heroics. Negotiated load at home and work
In the room

Calendar collision. Guilt both ways.

It might sound like
  • I'm failing at home and work.
  • I'm caring for my mum and my team.
  • There aren't enough hours.
What’s underneath

Do not treat structural overload as a mindset issue only. Design, not heroics. Negotiated load at home and work.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is actually sustainable for this season?
  2. What needs to be renegotiated, not endured?
  3. Where is guilt doing the scheduling?
  4. What would a fair design include that heroics have been covering?
Avoid here

Resilience + a morning routine.

Watch

Do not treat a structural overload as a mindset issue only.

Examples from the field
Example
Dual-career plus elder care. Heroics covering a missing paid hour of help and a meeting-culture renegotiation. Design both. Guilt unseated as scheduler.
Parent
Calendar collision. Coach designs load, not heroics.
Carer
Guilt both ways. Coach negotiates support at home and work.
Sample exchange
Client

I'm letting everyone down.

Coach

What could be renegotiated, at home and at work?

Client

Maybe school pickups.

Coach

Who could help?

Signs it’s working

The client redesigns load instead of trying harder.

Don’t confuse with

S6.20 Rest guilt / always-on

Always-on is anxiety. Work-life load is real structural overload.

S7.31Compensation / raise / negotiation topic
Worth, fear, market story
Value case, ask, BATNA, practice the sentence
In the room

Worth, fear, market story.

It might sound like
  • I'm afraid to ask for more money.
  • I don't know what I'm worth.
  • It feels greedy.
What’s underneath

Money talk is often identity talk. Work both. Value case, ask, BATNA, practice the sentence.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is the value you create in their language?
  2. What is the number and the sentence?
  3. What happens in you when you say the number out loud?
  4. What is your walk-away — and what is enough?
Avoid here

Only market data or only inner-child-of-money.

Watch

Money talk is often identity talk. Work both.

Examples from the field
Example
Number spoken; voice shrinks. Practice twice. Enough and walk-away defined so the ask is not a plea. Identity and tactic.
Analyst
Afraid to ask. Coach builds value case and practises the sentence.
Manager
Negotiation. BATNA and identity work.
Sample exchange
Client

I don't know how to ask for a raise.

Coach

What's your value case?

Client

I delivered three major projects.

Coach

Say the ask out loud.

Signs it’s working

The client practises the ask and feels ready.

Don’t confuse with

S7.22 Under-resourced / budget / headcount

Under-resourced is about the team. Compensation is personal.

S7.32Job search / in-between identity
Lost title, narrative wobble
Story of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications
In the room

Lost title. Narrative wobble.

It might sound like
  • I don't know who I am without a job.
  • Job hunting is soul-destroying.
  • I keep apologising for the gap.
What’s underneath

The search is a meaning project as well as a market project. Story of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications.

Questions that often open it
  1. Who are you without that title?
  2. What story of your work is true and alive?
  3. What experiment would teach you more than another application?
  4. What are you apologizing for that is actually a chapter change?
Avoid here

Only job-search tactics. Only identity fog with no market move.

Watch

The search is a meaning project as well as a market project.

Examples from the field
Example
Ex-title wobble. Alive story: they design conditions for teams to decide. Experiment: two conversations in that language, not 40 generic applications. Chapter change, not apology.
Professional
Lost title. Coach builds story of contribution, not apology.
Graduate
Job search. Coach designs experiments.
Sample exchange
Client

I feel like nobody without my title.

Coach

What contribution do you bring, title or not?

Client

I solve messy problems.

Coach

Lead with that.

Signs it’s working

The client tells a story of contribution and feels steadier.

Don’t confuse with

S6.22 Midlife / quarter-life / chapter change

Chapter change is life stage. Job search is the practical in-between.

S7.33Disclosure of bullying, harassment or discrimination
Client describes treatment that may be bullying, harassment or discrimination
Listen and believe; map options and support; refer to formal channels
In the room

Hesitant disclosure. Fear of retaliation. Self-doubt (“maybe I’m overreacting”).

It might sound like
  • Maybe I’m being too sensitive.
  • I don’t want to make trouble.
  • It happens every time he’s in the room.
What’s underneath

This is not only a coaching topic. It may need HR, legal, union or other formal support. The coach listens, believes, helps the client understand their options and supports their choice. The coach does not investigate, judge or decide for them, and does not promise confidentiality they can’t keep.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would be most helpful right now?
  2. What do you know about the options available to you?
  3. Who could support you through this?
  4. What feels safe to do next?
Avoid here

Coaching their “resilience” to tolerate it. Telling them what to do. Investigating or confronting anyone. Minimising.

Watch

This may need formal support. Don’t coach someone to tolerate mistreatment.

Examples from the field
Example
A junior employee describes repeated comments about her accent from a manager. The coach listens, acknowledges how hard it is, and helps her map formal and informal options and who could support her.
Contractor
Excluded from meetings after raising a concern. Coach helps them find the contract’s complaint process and a union contact.
Senior woman
Repeatedly talked over and mocked. Coach supports her decision about whether and how to report.
Sample exchange
Client

I don’t know if it counts as harassment.

Coach

Thank you for telling me. What’s happened sounds serious.

Client

I’m scared of what happens if I report.

Coach

Let’s look at the options and who could support you.

Signs it’s working

The client feels believed, knows their options and support, and makes their own choice.

Don’t confuse with

S7.1 Conflict with a boss

Conflict with a boss is two-way friction. This may be mistreatment that needs formal channels.

S7.34Being made redundant
Role ended by the organisation; shock, loss and practical pressure
Absorb the shock first; then rebuild the value story; then design next steps
In the room

Shock, anger, shame, sometimes relief. Rehearses the meeting. Worries about money.

It might sound like
  • Twenty years, and a fifteen-minute meeting.
  • I feel ashamed even though it wasn’t about me.
  • Part of me is relieved.
What’s underneath

Redundancy is a loss of role, income, routine and identity, often at once, and usually not personal. The client needs first to absorb the shock, then to rebuild a story of their value and design practical next steps.

Questions that often open it
  1. What do you need most right now?
  2. What have you survived before that might help here?
  3. What did you bring to that role that goes with you?
  4. What’s one small step this week?
Avoid here

Jumping straight to CV and LinkedIn. Silver-lining talk. Ignoring finances.

Watch

Shock first, strategy second.

Examples from the field
Example
A marketing director is told her role is cut. First session: the shock and the anger. Second: strengths and her story. Third: three experiments in the job market.
IT manager
Furious. Coach lets him be heard before anything else. Next week he can think clearly about options.
Researcher
Uses the timeline to see three earlier reinventions.
Sample exchange
Client

I keep replaying the meeting.

Coach

That’s a big shock. What do you need right now?

Client

To feel like I’m still worth something.

Coach

What did you bring to that role that goes with you?

Signs it’s working

The client has worked through the shock and moves on to plans based on their real value.

Don’t confuse with

S7.32 Job search / in-between identity

Job search is the practical in-between. Being made redundant is the shock and loss that comes first.

S7.35Having to make others redundant
Must deliver redundancies; torn between the organisation and the people
Hold both duties; rehearse clear and humane conversations; care for themselves
In the room

Guilt, dread, loss of sleep. “I’m the bad guy.” Worry about their team.

It might sound like
  • I hired some of these people.
  • I can’t sleep.
  • How do I do this decently?
What’s underneath

The client holds two duties at once: to the organisation and to the people affected. Both are real. Coaching helps them act with integrity and care, prepare the conversations, and look after themselves without pretending the role is easy.

Questions that often open it
  1. What matters most to you in how this is done?
  2. What will you say in the first sentence?
  3. How do you want people to remember how they were treated?
  4. What support do you need for yourself?
Avoid here

Helping them become cold or detached. Turning it into only a legal script. Ignoring their own wellbeing.

Watch

Don’t coach them into numbness or into martyrdom.

Examples from the field
Example
A plant manager must lay off 40 people. Coach helps him rehearse a clear, humane opening sentence and plan support for those affected and for himself.
HR director
Parts work: the protector and the professional both have voices. A plan honours both.
Team lead
Rehearses delivering news to a long-time colleague.
Sample exchange
Client

I don’t know how to tell them.

Coach

What matters most to you in how this is done?

Client

Honesty and respect.

Coach

What would your first sentence be?

Signs it’s working

The client feels prepared to act with clarity and care and has support for themselves.

Don’t confuse with

S7.14 Need to give hard feedback

Hard feedback is about behaviour. This is delivering a life-changing decision.

S7.36Returning from parental leave
Back from parental leave; new identity, new demands, out of the loop
Map the polarity; set clear agreements at work and home
In the room

Excited and guilty. Feels out of date. Worries about being seen as less committed.

It might sound like
  • I feel like the new person again.
  • I’m guilty whichever way I lean.
  • Everyone’s moved on without me.
What’s underneath

The client is adjusting to a new identity and a new set of demands. Work may have moved on. The tension between career and family is ongoing, not a problem to solve once. Clear agreements at work and at home matter.

Questions that often open it
  1. What do you want from work in this chapter?
  2. What has changed while you were away?
  3. What agreements would help at work and at home?
  4. What would a good first month look like?
Avoid here

Assuming they want less, or more, ambition. Treating guilt as a problem to eliminate.

Watch

Don’t assume what they want. Ask.

Examples from the field
Example
A software lead returns after a year. Coach maps the Work and Family polarity, and helps plan conversations with her boss about the first three months.
Father returning
Wants to protect pickup times. Coach helps him make a clear ask.
Manager
Uses a stakeholder loop to rebuild visibility quickly.
Sample exchange
Client

I feel like I have to prove myself all over again.

Coach

What do you want from work right now?

Client

To be trusted with the big projects again.

Coach

Who needs to hear that, and when?

Signs it’s working

The client has clear agreements and a realistic rhythm, with less guilt.

Don’t confuse with

S7.30 Work-life / caregiver / dual-career load

Work-life load is ongoing. Returning from leave is a specific transition.

S7.37Role reshaped or threatened by AI and automation
Work changing because of AI or automation; uncertainty about the future
Separate tasks from value; picture two futures; run small experiments
In the room

Unease, defensiveness or curiosity. “Will my job exist?” Mixes real data with rumour.

It might sound like
  • I don’t know if my job will exist in five years.
  • I refuse to use it.
  • Everyone’s pretending they know what’s going on.
What’s underneath

Some tasks will change; the client’s value is rarely only the tasks. Coaching helps separate fact from fear, find which strengths become more valuable, and run experiments with the new tools rather than waiting.

Questions that often open it
  1. Which of your tasks are changing, and which aren’t?
  2. What do you bring that a tool can’t?
  3. What would you do if you assumed the change is coming?
  4. What small experiment could you run with these tools?
Avoid here

Reassuring that nothing will change. Predicting the future. Pure technical advice.

Watch

Don’t predict or reassure. Help them experiment.

Examples from the field
Example
A copywriter fears AI will replace her. Coach separates tasks from value. She experiments with AI tools for drafts and repositions as a brand strategist.
Paralegal
Pre-mortem on doing nothing. Starts learning to review AI outputs.
Call centre manager
Two futures: resist or lead the change. Chooses to lead a pilot.
Sample exchange
Client

AI is going to take my job.

Coach

Which of your tasks might change, and which are you?

Client

The drafting might change. The judgement is me.

Coach

How could you put more of your judgement to work?

Signs it’s working

The client separates fear from fact and starts experimenting.

Don’t confuse with

S7.20 Reorg / merger / ambiguity

Reorg is organisational ambiguity. This is about a technology changing the work itself.

S8
Situation group · 21 situations

What happens in the room

About this group

Everything covered so far treats the client's topic as the object of the work. This final section turns the lens around: the relationship happening inside the hour — between this particular coach and this particular client, right now — is also data, and sometimes it is the actual topic wearing a disguise. Twenty-one situations are gathered here because each is a live-wire moment in the coaching relationship itself: a client testing the coach's competence, advice-hunger dressed as a simple question, defensiveness when challenged, false harmony that never produces real friction, intellectual sparring that keeps everything safely in the head, two different kinds of silence that need opposite responses, transference onto the coach, homework done to please rather than to grow, the same topic returning session after session, and a client performing leadership rather than actually exploring anything.

These situations were chosen because they are easy to misread from the coach's chair — a testing client can look hostile when they are actually checking for safety; false harmony can look like a successful session when it is actually the client protecting themselves from being truly known; intellectual sparring can feel like a stimulating conversation while functioning as a very effective way to avoid feeling anything. The discipline across all fifteen is to name what is happening between the two people without attachment or defensiveness — as an observation offered to the client, not a verdict delivered to them. Do not perform expertise to win back a testing client's confidence. Do not rush to fill a silence that is doing real work. Do not open a genuinely deep cut with eight minutes left on the clock. And when an insight visibly lands — new language, wet eyes, a dropped shoulder — stop adding questions; the very next clever thing a coach says is often exactly what steals the insight before it has had time to settle.

The section closes on a point worth stating plainly: recognizing when a topic has moved past coaching's proper scope, and referring it onward to therapy, legal counsel, or HR, is a mark of competence in a coach, not a failure of one.

S8.1Testing the coach / “impress me”
Wry, evaluative, “other coaches said…”
Stay unhooked. Presence. Contract what would make this useful
In the room

Wry, evaluative. “Other coaches said…”

It might sound like
  • My last coach was brilliant.
  • Go on then, impress me.
  • I've done a lot of coaching before.
What’s underneath

Can look hostile; often checking for safety. Stay unhooked. Usefulness, not performance.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would make this hour worth it for you?
  2. What are you checking about me?
  3. What would usefulness look like, not performance?
  4. How will you know I am a fit — and how will I know we are working?
Avoid here

Question-cube-as-audition. Clever reframe to win.

Watch

Do not perform expertise. Be useful.

Examples from the field
Example
“My last coach used clean language.” Coach does not demonstrate it. Contracts usefulness. Test softens when they are not being auditioned back.
Executive
Tests the coach early. Coach stays unhooked and simply useful.
Senior manager
'Other coaches said…' Coach doesn't compete; asks what would make this useful.
Sample exchange
Client

My last coach used fancy models.

Coach

What would make this session useful for you?

Client

Clarity on my team.

Coach

Let's start there.

Signs it’s working

The testing fades as the client sees the coach is useful, not performing.

Don’t confuse with

S8.5 Intellectual sparring with the coach

Sparring debates ideas. Testing checks whether the coach is safe and useful.

S8.2Wants the coach to be the expert / mentor / parent
Advice hunger, “what would you do?”
Name the pull. Offer choice: coaching vs a contracted opinion
In the room

Advice hunger. “What would you do?”

It might sound like
  • What would you do?
  • You've seen this before — just tell me.
  • I need your advice.
What’s underneath

Name the pull. Offer choice: coaching vs a contracted opinion. A habit of answering is not coaching.

Questions that often open it
  1. Are you asking me to think for you, or with you?
  2. What do you already know?
  3. I can offer a view without attachment if you want it. Do you?
  4. What would you lose if I answered?
Avoid here

Becoming the parent who says yes.

Watch

An occasional perspective is fine. A habit of it is not coaching.

Examples from the field
Example
They lose the muscle and the blame if you answer. Named. They already know they will not take the role. Work that.
New manager
Wants advice every session. Coach names the pull and offers a contracted opinion.
Founder
Wants a mentor. Coach clarifies coaching vs mentoring.
Sample exchange
Client

You must know the answer.

Coach

I can share a view if you'd like, but first: what do you think?

Client

I think I should wait.

Coach

What's your reasoning?

Signs it’s working

The client works from their own thinking and the coaching contract is clear.

Don’t confuse with

S4.9 Outsourcing judgment to the coach

Outsourcing judgment is one decision. This is an ongoing role pull.

S8.3Defensive when challenged
Explains, justifies, tightens
Soften. More empathy first. Smaller challenge. Ask permission
In the room

Explains, justifies, tightens.

It might sound like
  • That's not fair.
  • You don't understand.
  • Let me explain why.
What’s underneath

A challenge before enough safety becomes an argument. Soften. Empathy first. Smaller challenge. Ask permission.

Questions that often open it
  1. I may have moved too fast. What landed wrong?
  2. May I offer an observation?
  3. What do you need from me to be able to look at this?
  4. What is the challenge touching?
Avoid here

Bigger challenge. Debate.

Watch

A challenge before enough safety becomes an argument.

Examples from the field
Example
Challenge on heroics landed as contempt. Repair. Smaller: “May I say what I notice about the load?” Defense drops.
Leader
Gets defensive at a challenge. Coach softens and offers empathy first.
Manager
Justifies. Coach asks permission before challenging again.
Sample exchange
Client

That's not what happened.

Coach

I may have gone too fast. What's important for me to understand?

Client

I did try.

Coach

Tell me about that.

Signs it’s working

Defensiveness eases and the client can explore again.

Don’t confuse with

S7.15 Received feedback they reject

Rejected feedback is about others' input. Defensiveness is in the session itself.

S8.4Agrees with everything (false harmony)
Nodding, no friction, no energy
Invite disagreement. Look for the place they don’t buy it
In the room

Nodding. No friction. No energy.

It might sound like
  • Yes, absolutely.
  • That makes sense.
  • I agree.
What’s underneath

Harmony can be a way not to be known. Invite disagreement. Look for the place they don’t buy it.

Questions that often open it
  1. Where am I off?
  2. What are you being polite about?
  3. What do you not want to work on?
  4. If you disagreed with me, what would you say?
Avoid here

Taking nods as success.

Watch

Harmony can be a way not to be known.

Examples from the field
Example
Nods through a reframe. “Where am I off?” “This isn’t about presence.” Real topic appears once disagreement is legal.
Manager
Nods at everything. Coach invites disagreement.
Employee
False harmony. Coach looks for the place they don't buy it.
Sample exchange
Client

Yes, that's right.

Coach

Where don't you agree with me?

Client

(pause) Actually, the part about my boss.

Coach

Tell me.

Signs it’s working

The client voices disagreement and the session gains energy.

Don’t confuse with

S8.9 Coach-pleasing / doing homework for you

Coach-pleasing seeks approval. False harmony avoids being known.

S8.5Intellectual sparring with the coach
Debates the model, stays in the head
Step out of the tennis match. Go to experience
In the room

Debates the model. Stays in the head.

It might sound like
  • That model is flawed.
  • Let's debate that.
  • Actually, research shows…
What’s underneath

Do not win the debate. Leave the court. Go to experience.

Questions that often open it
  1. We can think about this, or we can look at it in your week. Which serves you?
  2. What is happening in you while we debate?
  3. If we dropped the model, what is the live issue?
  4. What would it cost to stop winning this point?
Avoid here

Better theory.

Watch

Do not win the debate. Leave the court.

Examples from the field
Example
Debate on adult development. Live issue: they froze in Tuesday’s forum. Week, not model.
Academic
Debates coaching models. Coach leaves the court and goes to experience.
Consultant
Sparring. Coach asks: 'What's happening for you right now?'
Sample exchange
Client

I don't think that framework is valid.

Coach

You may be right. What's happening for you right now?

Client

I'm… frustrated.

Coach

With what?

Signs it’s working

The client moves from ideas to experience.

Don’t confuse with

S1.6 Intellectualizing

Intellectualizing is the client's habit. Sparring is directed at the coach.

Related situations
S8.6Silence that is working
Thinking face, eyes moving, processing
Wait. Do not fill. After, harvest
In the room

Thinking face. Eyes moving. Processing.

It might sound like
  • (silence, thinking)
  • Hmm…
  • Give me a moment.
What’s underneath

Anxious coaches ruin the best minutes of the session. Wait. Then harvest.

Questions that often open it
  1. (silence)
  2. What just happened there?
  3. What did you find in the quiet?
  4. What wants to be said now?
Avoid here

A second question.

Watch

Anxious coaches ruin the best minutes of the session.

Examples from the field
Example
After “I think I want out,” 20 seconds of living silence. New sentence arrives. The next clever question would have stolen it.
Client
Silent, eyes moving. Coach waits; the insight arrives.
Manager
Long pause after a question. Coach doesn't fill it.
Sample exchange
Coach

What would you do if you weren't afraid?

Client

(long silence)

Coach

(waits)

Client

I'd leave.

Signs it’s working

The silence produces something new, and the coach harvests it.

Don’t confuse with

S8.7 Silence that is stuck / freeze

Stuck silence is frozen. Working silence is active thinking.

S8.7Silence that is stuck / freeze
Blank, frozen, long and tight
Offer a ramp: scale, choice, image, “would it help if…”
In the room

Blank. Frozen. Long and tight.

It might sound like
  • (blank stare)
  • I don't know…
  • (frozen)
What’s underneath

Do not stare them down. Offer a ramp: scale, guess, two doors, “would it help if…”

Questions that often open it
  1. Would a scale, a guess, or changing topic for a minute help?
  2. What would make it easier to start?
  3. Is this thinking, or is this freeze?
  4. Would it help if I offered two doors?
Avoid here

More silence as purity.

Watch

Do not stare them down. Offer structure.

Examples from the field
Example
Tight blank after “shame.” Two doors: stay with the body, or talk about the meeting facts first. They pick facts, then return. Ramp, not stare.
Client
Frozen silence. Coach offers a ramp: a scale or two doors.
Employee
Blank. Coach asks 'Would it help if I…?'
Sample exchange
Coach

What do you want?

Client

(frozen)

Coach

Would it help to start with a number from 1 to 10?

Client

Maybe a 3.

Signs it’s working

The client re-engages through a simple, structured question.

Don’t confuse with

S8.6 Silence that is working

Working silence should be protected. Stuck silence needs a ramp.

S8.8Transference onto the coach (boss, parent, judge)
Extra heat, extra pleasing, extra fight
Notice in supervision. Gently name the pattern if useful
In the room

Extra heat, extra pleasing, extra fight.

It might sound like
  • You sound like my father.
  • You're judging me.
  • I want you to be proud of me.
What’s underneath

Notice in supervision. Gently name if useful and inside agreement. Do not interpret like a therapist if that is outside contract. Be clean.

Questions that often open it
  1. Something about this conversation seems charged beyond the topic. What does this remind you of?
  2. Who am I becoming in this chair for you?
  3. What do you need from me that is about this hour, not about them?
  4. How shall we use that, if it is here?
Avoid here

Deep interpretation. Acting into the role.

Watch

Do not interpret like a therapist if that is outside agreement. Be clean.

Examples from the field
Example
Extra fight when the coach is quiet. Reminds them of a silent father. Named lightly. Need this hour: a coach who stays, not a father to defeat.
Client
Extra pleasing toward coach. Coach notices and takes it to supervision.
Manager
Extra heat toward coach. Coach gently names it if helpful.
Sample exchange
Client

I feel like you're disappointed in me.

Coach

I'm not. Who else might feel that way?

Client

My manager. My dad.

Coach

That's worth noticing.

Signs it’s working

The client notices the pattern without the coach acting as a therapist.

Don’t confuse with

S8.9 Coach-pleasing / doing homework for you

Coach-pleasing is behaviour. Transference is a deeper pattern projected onto the coach.

S8.9Coach-pleasing / doing homework for you
Looks for gold star
Return the work to their life. They pick the experiment
In the room

Looks for a gold star.

It might sound like
  • I did all my homework!
  • Was that what you wanted?
  • I hope you're pleased.
What’s underneath

Your approval cannot be the engine. Return the work to their life. They pick the experiment.

Questions that often open it
  1. If I never asked about this again, what would you still do because it matters to you?
  2. Whose experiment is this?
  3. What would you do if I were not impressed either way?
  4. How will you know this mattered besides my reaction?
Avoid here

Gold stars.

Watch

Your approval cannot be the engine.

Examples from the field
Example
Worksheets complete; leave-question untouched. New contract: experiments they would do if you disappeared.
Graduate
Seeks a gold star. Coach returns ownership.
Manager
Does homework for the coach. Coach asks: 'What did you learn for yourself?'
Sample exchange
Client

I did everything you said!

Coach

What did you learn for yourself?

Client

I hadn't thought about that.

Coach

Take a moment.

Signs it’s working

The client owns the work for their own reasons.

Don’t confuse with

S5.10 Compliance without buy-in

Compliance is about tasks. Coach-pleasing is about approval.

S8.10Repeating the same topic session after session
Same title, same floor
Name the loop. Change the level: identity, system, experiment, or ending
In the room

Same title. Same floor.

It might sound like
  • Same topic again, sorry.
  • It's still my boss.
  • We keep coming back to this.
What’s underneath

Repetition means the intervention is at the wrong level. Name the loop. Identity, system, experiment, or ending.

Questions that often open it
  1. We have visited this room before. What have we not been willing to do?
  2. What would make this the last time we talk about it this way?
  3. Are we at the wrong level — story, feeling, belief, system, action?
  4. What are you protecting by staying here?
Avoid here

Better insight at the same level.

Watch

Repetition means the intervention is at the wrong level.

Examples from the field
Example
Four sessions on the peer. Never sent the request. Protecting: not being seen as political. Level change: send it or park the topic.
Client
Same topic for months. Coach names the loop and changes level.
Manager
Repeated issue. Coach tries identity or system level.
Sample exchange
Client

It's my boss again.

Coach

We've talked about this five times. What does that tell us?

Client

That talking isn't working.

Coach

So what level should we try?

Signs it’s working

The level of conversation changes and new movement appears.

Don’t confuse with

S1.8 Story-looping / circling the same plot

Story-looping is within session. This is across sessions.

S8.11Session energy drops / both get sleepy
Fog, going in circles
Call it. Stand, breathe, pick a sharper question or close this thread
In the room

Fog. Circles.

It might sound like
  • (yawning)
  • I'm not sure where we are.
  • Sorry, I've lost the thread.
What’s underneath

Polite persistence in a dead thread wastes the hour. Call it. Stand, breathe, sharper slice or park.

Questions that often open it
  1. The energy just dropped. What is happening?
  2. Are we on the real topic?
  3. Do you want a sharper slice or to park this?
  4. What would bring this hour back to life?
Avoid here

One more question at the same altitude.

Watch

Polite persistence in a dead thread wastes the hour.

Examples from the field
Example
Fog on a stakeholder map. Real topic was the leave-question they stepped around. Naming the drop finds it.
Session
Fog sets in. Coach calls it and suggests a sharper focus or a pause.
Session
Both sleepy. Coach suggests standing and breathing.
Sample exchange
Coach

I notice the energy has dropped for both of us.

Client

Yeah, it has.

Coach

Shall we pick a sharper slice, or park this?

Client

Sharper slice.

Signs it’s working

Energy returns or the topic is consciously parked.

Don’t confuse with

S2.2 Numb / flat / shutdown

Numbness is the client's state. Energy drop is shared in the session.

S8.12Big insight just landed — needs integration
Quiet, wet eyes, “oh”
Stop adding questions. Let it settle. Anchor in body and next hour
In the room

Quiet. Wet eyes. “Oh.”

It might sound like
  • Oh…
  • (quiet, eyes wet)
  • I never saw it like that.
What’s underneath

The next clever question can steal the insight. Stop. Anchor in body and next hour.

Questions that often open it
  1. Let’s not move yet. Where do you feel that?
  2. What wants to be remembered when you leave this room?
  3. What is the smallest way to keep this alive?
  4. What would steal this if we kept talking?
Avoid here

Stress-test. Another why.

Watch

The next clever question can steal the insight.

Examples from the field
Example
“I’ve been applying for my father’s approval in this job.” Stop. Body. One sentence written. No org-chart analysis today.
Client
Insight lands. Coach stops asking and anchors it.
Manager
Big 'aha'. Coach asks how to remember it this week.
Sample exchange
Client

Oh. I've been protecting myself all along.

Coach

(pause) Let's stay with that.

Client

(silence)

Coach

How will you remember this tomorrow?

Signs it’s working

The insight is anchored in a sentence or action, not buried under more questions.

Don’t confuse with

S2.9 Hopeful / lit up for the first time

Hope lights up energy. Insight is quiet and needs anchoring.

S8.13Wants therapy from coaching — or vice versa
Trauma unfolding, diagnosis talk, or only tactics when grief is here
Re-contract scope. Refer when needed. Stay in present-and-forward if coaching
In the room

Trauma unfolding, diagnosis talk — or only tactics when grief is here.

It might sound like
  • I think this goes back to my childhood.
  • I've been diagnosed with…
  • Can we just do tactics?
What’s underneath

Re-contract scope. Refer when needed. Stay present-and-forward if this is coaching. Know your edge. Referring is competence.

Questions that often open it
  1. Some of this may want a different kind of support. What is the coaching part we can do well together?
  2. What belongs here, and what belongs with someone else?
  3. What present-and-forward piece can we work?
  4. What would good care include that is bigger than this hour?
Avoid here

Amateur trauma work. Or skipping grief that belongs in the room for a beat.

Watch

Know your edge. Referring is competence.

Examples from the field
Example
Trauma material unfolding. Coaching part: how they want to walk into Thursday’s review. Referral named without dumping them. Both are care.
Client
Trauma surfaces. Coach re-contracts scope and refers.
Manager
Avoids grief, wants only tactics. Coach gently names the grief.
Sample exchange
Client

This reminds me of what happened when I was young.

Coach

That sounds important. Is this something a therapist could help with alongside our work?

Client

Maybe.

Coach

Let's talk about that.

Signs it’s working

The scope is clear, with referral offered where needed.

Don’t confuse with

S6.23 Spiritual / existential edge in a work topic

Existential depth can stay in coaching. Clinical issues need referral.

S8.14Time pressure in the session
Big topic at minute 45
Don’t open surgery. Contract a slice or park it well
In the room

Big topic at minute 45.

It might sound like
  • (minute 50) Oh, one more thing…
  • I know we're nearly out of time, but…
  • Quickly, can we talk about…
What’s underneath

A messy deep-dive into the last 8 minutes is not bravery. Don’t open surgery. Clean slice or strong setup for next time.

Questions that often open it
  1. We have 12 minutes. Do you want a clean slice today or a strong setup for next time?
  2. What is the one piece we can do justice to now?
  3. How do you want to leave this so it is held, not dumped?
  4. What should we not open in the last minutes?
Avoid here

Opening the real topic at minute 52.

Watch

A messy deep-dive into the last 8 minutes is not bravery.

Examples from the field
Example
Leave-question at minute 48. Setup for next time + one sentence they want remembered. No amateur exit plan in 8 minutes.
Client
Big topic at minute 48. Coach sets it up for next time.
Manager
Late reveal. Coach gives one sentence and a plan.
Sample exchange
Client

Actually, I'm thinking of leaving.

Coach

That's big. We have eight minutes. Shall we set it up properly for next time?

Client

Yes.

Coach

What's one sentence about it for now?

Signs it’s working

The big topic is held and scheduled rather than rushed.

Don’t confuse with

S1.13 Avoiding the real topic

Avoiding the real topic is a pattern. Time pressure is the timing problem.

S8.15Client is performing leadership rather than exploring
Keynote in the chair, no crack
Ask for the unofficial version. Energy under the polish
In the room

Keynote in the chair. No crack.

It might sound like
  • Our strategy is clear.
  • I'm very confident about the vision.
  • As a leader, I always…
What’s underneath

Status is a defense. Respect it, then invite the human. Kitchen-table version.

Questions that often open it
  1. That is the board version. What is the kitchen-table version?
  2. Where is the crack in the polish?
  3. What would you say if this were not a performance?
  4. What are you showing me, and what are you living?
Avoid here

Competing keynotes. Calling them fake.

Watch

Status is a defense. Respect it, then invite the human.

Examples from the field
Example
Board version of a reorg. Kitchen table: they are scared they will become the person they disliked. Crack. Work that.
CEO
Performs leadership in session. Coach asks for the kitchen-table version.
Executive
Polished. Coach looks for the crack.
Sample exchange
Client

Our transformation is going very well.

Coach

That's the board version. What's the kitchen-table version?

Client

(laughs) It's a mess.

Coach

Tell me about the mess.

Signs it’s working

The client drops the performance and talks about the real experience.

Don’t confuse with

S1.1 Telling a rehearsed story

Rehearsed story is polished narrative. Performing leadership is a status display.

S8.16Suicidal thoughts or risk disclosed
Client hints at or states thoughts of ending their life
Stop the coaching agenda; ask directly; listen; connect them to professional help
In the room

Hopelessness. “What’s the point?” Talking about not being here, being a burden, or having a plan. May be hinted rather than stated.

It might sound like
  • Sometimes I don’t see the point of any of it.
  • Everyone would be better off without me.
  • I’ve been thinking about not being here.
What’s underneath

Safety comes before coaching. Asking directly and calmly about suicidal thoughts does not plant the idea; it often brings relief. The coach stays calm, listens, takes it seriously, and helps the client connect with professional help: their GP, a mental health professional, or crisis services. The coach follows their contract and any safeguarding procedures, and gets supervision afterwards.

Questions that often open it
  1. Are you having thoughts of ending your life?
  2. Are you safe right now?
  3. Who can you contact for support today?
  4. Can we look together at how to reach that support?
Avoid here

Carrying on with the coaching agenda. Panic or lecturing. Promising complete confidentiality. Ending the session without a plan for support.

Watch

This is outside coaching. Safety and referral first, then supervision for the coach.

Examples from the field
Example
A client says, “Sometimes I think everyone would be better off without me.” The coach pauses the session, asks directly, listens, and stays with the client while they agree who they will contact for help that day.
Senior leader
Mentions feeling like a burden. Coach asks directly. The client agrees to call their doctor that afternoon.
Remote session
Client goes quiet after hinting. Coach asks directly and helps them reach a crisis line before ending.
Sample exchange
Client

Some days I wonder if anyone would notice if I wasn’t here.

Coach

I’m glad you told me. I need to ask directly: are you having thoughts of ending your life?

Client

Sometimes, yes.

Coach

Thank you for being honest. Let’s talk about getting you support today.

Signs it’s working

The client is connected to professional support with a clear next step, and the coach has sought supervision.

Don’t confuse with

S8.13 Wants therapy from coaching — or vice versa

Wanting therapy is a scope question. This is a safety situation that needs immediate action.

S8.17Signs of substance misuse
Hints of using alcohol or substances to cope
Notice and ask respectfully; evoke their own view; refer if they want help
In the room

Mentions drinking to cope, heavy weekends, missed mornings. Jokes about it. Defensive if it comes up.

It might sound like
  • I need a few drinks to switch off.
  • It’s just how the industry works.
  • I’ve missed a few mornings lately.
What’s underneath

The coach is not there to diagnose or treat. But they can notice, ask with respect, and use a non-judgemental, motivational approach to help the client think about it. If the client wants help, the coach can point them to professional support.

Questions that often open it
  1. How do you feel about how much you’re drinking?
  2. What does it help with?
  3. What concerns you about it, if anything?
  4. What kind of support would you want, if any?
Avoid here

Lecturing, labelling, or ignoring obvious signs. Acting as a counsellor.

Watch

Notice and ask; don’t diagnose or treat.

Examples from the field
Example
A sales director jokes about needing three drinks after every call. Coach asks, without judgement, how they feel about it. The client admits it worries them and agrees to talk to their doctor.
Consultant
Uses alcohol to sleep. Coach evokes his own concern. He agrees to talk to his GP.
Founder
Uses stimulants to keep going. Coach gently names the pattern and the health risk, and suggests professional support.
Sample exchange
Client

Honestly, wine is my therapy.

Coach

How do you feel about how much you’re relying on it?

Client

I don’t love it, if I’m honest.

Coach

What would you want to do about that, if anything?

Signs it’s working

The client reflects honestly and knows where to find help if they want it.

Don’t confuse with

S2.16 Burned out / depleted

Burnout is depletion. Substance misuse can be a way of coping with it, and needs extra care.

S8.18Client far more senior or powerful than the coach
Large status gap; coach tempted to defer or impress
Contract for challenge; stay curious and independent
In the room

The coach feels smaller, defers, or tries to impress. The client may test or dominate.

It might sound like
  • I don’t have much time, so let’s be efficient.
  • My last coach was a former CEO.
  • I already know most of this.
What’s underneath

Seniority and status are part of the room. If the coach defers, the client loses the challenge they need. The coach’s value is in their questions and their independence, not in matching the client’s status.

Questions that often open it
  1. How much challenge do you want from me?
  2. What does nobody else tell you?
  3. What do you need that’s different from what everyone else gives you?
  4. What would make this time worth it?
Avoid here

Deference. Performing expertise. Avoiding challenge.

Watch

Your independence is your value. Don’t trade it for approval.

Examples from the field
Example
A new coach working with a CEO keeps agreeing. In supervision, the coach realises this. Next session they contract openly for challenge.
Chief executive
Coach asks what no one else tells them. Session becomes useful.
Government minister
Coach contracts upfront for honesty and challenge.
Sample exchange
Client

I’ve heard most of this before.

Coach

What does no one else tell you?

Client

…That I scare people.

Coach

Let’s look at that.

Signs it’s working

The coach stays independent and the client gets challenge they don’t get elsewhere.

Don’t confuse with

S8.1 Testing the coach / “impress me”

Testing the coach is the client’s behaviour. This is about the coach’s response to a status gap.

S8.19Cultural or identity gap between coach and client
Coach and client differ in culture, identity or experience
Name the gap; use the client’s own words; ask, don’t assume
In the room

Misunderstandings. The client explains context the coach doesn’t share. The coach may assume or avoid.

It might sound like
  • It’s different where I’m from.
  • You might not understand how this works for someone like me.
  • That advice wouldn’t work here.
What’s underneath

Culture, identity and lived experience shape what problems mean and what solutions are possible. The coach doesn’t need to share them, but does need curiosity, humility and willingness to name the gap and ask.

Questions that often open it
  1. What do I need to understand about your context?
  2. What would that look like where you work?
  3. Is there anything I might be missing?
  4. How would you like me to ask if I don’t understand?
Avoid here

Assuming your own cultural norms are neutral. Avoiding the topic. Over-apologising.

Watch

Your norms aren’t neutral. Use their language, not yours.

Examples from the field
Example
A coach from a low-hierarchy culture coaches a client from a high-hierarchy culture about “speaking up to the boss.” The coach asks what speaking up would look like in the client’s context.
Client from a minority group
Coach asks how identity shapes the situation, instead of assuming.
International team lead
Coach uses clean language to stay with the client’s own words.
Sample exchange
Client

That approach wouldn’t work in my culture.

Coach

Thank you. What would work there?

Client

Speaking to the boss privately first.

Coach

Let’s plan that.

Signs it’s working

The client feels understood and the solutions fit their real context.

Don’t confuse with

S7.28 Cross-cultural / remote / hybrid friction

Cross-cultural friction is between the client and colleagues. This is between the coach and client.

S8.20Attraction, over-familiarity or boundary pull
Relationship drifting beyond the professional; personal pull on either side
Restate boundaries kindly and clearly; take it to supervision
In the room

Personal messages outside sessions. Requests to meet socially. Compliments that feel personal. The coach may feel flattered or uncomfortable.

It might sound like
  • You understand me better than anyone.
  • We should get dinner sometime.
  • Can I message you whenever?
What’s underneath

Coaching needs clear boundaries to stay safe and useful. The coach is responsible for holding them, kindly and clearly, whatever the client does. Supervision is important.

Questions that often open it
  1. How are you finding our working relationship?
  2. What would be helpful to keep this professional and useful?
  3. What do you need from coaching that might be missing elsewhere?
  4. How shall we contact each other between sessions?
Avoid here

Ignoring it. Encouraging it. Shaming the client.

Watch

The coach holds the boundary, always. Use supervision.

Examples from the field
Example
A client begins sending friendly late-night messages. The coach thanks them, restates how and when they communicate, and discusses it in supervision.
Lonely senior leader
Leans on the coach as a friend. Coach restates boundaries and helps them build a network.
Coach feels attraction
Takes it to supervision and keeps all contact professional.
Sample exchange
Client

We should grab dinner after this.

Coach

I enjoy working with you, and I keep our relationship to sessions. That keeps it useful for you.

Client

Of course, makes sense.

Coach

Let’s get back to your plan.

Signs it’s working

Boundaries are clear and the relationship stays professional and useful.

Don’t confuse with

S8.8 Transference onto the coach (boss, parent, judge)

Transference is a pattern projected onto the coach. Boundary pull is about the relationship becoming personal.

S8.21Confidentiality clashes with safety or legal duty
Information shared may require action beyond the coaching relationship
Revisit the agreed limits; explore the client acting first; seek advice
In the room

The client shares something that may put them or others at risk, or that may be illegal. The coach feels torn.

It might sound like
  • I’m only telling you because it’s confidential.
  • Nobody else knows.
  • I don’t want to get anyone into trouble.
What’s underneath

Confidentiality has limits, which should be agreed in the contract at the start. When serious risk to someone or legal duties are involved, the coach may need to act. Being honest with the client about those limits keeps trust.

Questions that often open it
  1. What do you think needs to happen with this?
  2. How could you raise this yourself?
  3. What support do you need to do that?
  4. How do you feel about the limits we agreed?
Avoid here

Promising total confidentiality. Acting without telling the client. Ignoring the risk.

Watch

Confidentiality has limits. Agree them at the start and be honest when they apply.

Examples from the field
Example
A client reveals they are covering up a safety risk at work. The coach reminds them of the agreed limits of confidentiality and explores how the client can report it themselves.
Factory manager
Hides a safety incident. Coach helps them plan to report it.
Team member
Discloses a colleague may be at risk. Coach follows their agreed process and seeks advice.
Sample exchange
Client

This stays between us, right?

Coach

Most things do. As we agreed at the start, if there’s serious risk to someone, I may need to act. Can we talk about what you think should happen?

Client

I know it needs reporting.

Coach

How could you do that yourself?

Signs it’s working

The client is supported to act, and trust remains because the coach was honest.

Don’t confuse with

S8.16 Suicidal thoughts or risk disclosed

Suicidal risk is about the client’s own safety. This covers wider risks and legal duties.

S9
Situation group · 13 situations

The engagement and the team

About this group

Most of this guide looks inside one session. But coaching also happens across a whole engagement: the first meeting where both sides decide whether to work together, the sponsor who is paying and wants to know it’s working, the three-way meeting, the stretch where nothing seems to move, and the ending. These moments shape what any single session can achieve, and they are where many coaching relationships quietly go wrong.

This group also covers five situations from team coaching, where the client is a group rather than one person. Team sessions bring their own patterns: one voice filling the room, a team politely avoiding the conflict everyone can feel, blame aimed at another team, unclear roles in a new team, and recovering together after a failure.

The discipline across this group is clear contracting. Most engagement-level problems are easier to prevent than to repair, and nearly all of them are handled best by naming what is happening, out loud and early, and agreeing what to do about it.

S9.1First session or chemistry meeting
First meeting; deciding whether to work together and how
Show how you work; clarify expectations, confidentiality and fit
In the room

Both sides checking fit. The client may test the coach or ask about methods. Expectations unclear.

It might sound like
  • What’s your approach?
  • My company says I need coaching.
  • I’m not sure what to expect.
What’s underneath

The chemistry session is about fit and expectations, not proving brilliance. The coach should show how they work, clarify what coaching is and isn’t, and help the client decide.

Questions that often open it
  1. What made you interested in coaching now?
  2. What would make this worth it for you?
  3. How would you know it’s working?
  4. What do you need to know about how I work?
Avoid here

Over-selling. Starting deep work before the contract is agreed. Being vague about logistics and confidentiality.

Watch

Fit matters more than impressing.

Examples from the field
Example
A client asks how coaching will help. The coach does a short taste of coaching on a real topic, then explains confidentiality, sponsor involvement and how they would work together.
Sceptical engineer
Coach offers a 15-minute taste of coaching on a real problem.
Executive
Clarifies role of the sponsor and confidentiality.
Sample exchange
Client

How does this work?

Coach

Shall we try ten minutes on something real, then talk about how we’d work together?

Client

Sure.

Coach

What’s on your mind this week?

Signs it’s working

Both sides have a clear sense of fit and expectations before agreeing to work together.

Don’t confuse with

S1.12 Bringing someone else’s agenda

Someone else’s agenda is a session-level topic. This is about starting the engagement.

S9.2Sponsor asks what the client said
Sponsor wants information about sessions
Restate the agreement; redirect to client-owned progress updates
In the room

A manager or HR contact asks for updates or details from sessions.

It might sound like
  • So, what has she told you?
  • We’re paying for this, so we need to know.
  • Is he making progress?
What’s underneath

The sponsor has a legitimate interest in progress, but not in session content. Confidentiality and reporting should be agreed upfront in a three-way contract. The client, not the coach, should own the progress updates.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would be useful for you to know about progress?
  2. How could the client share that directly?
  3. What did we agree about confidentiality?
  4. When is the next review meeting?
Avoid here

Sharing session content. Being evasive without explaining why.

Watch

Share progress, never content. Agree it upfront.

Examples from the field
Example
An HR manager asks how sessions are going and what the client said about their boss. The coach explains the agreement and suggests the client gives a progress update in the next three-way meeting.
Line manager
Asks about specific comments. Coach redirects to the client’s own progress report.
HR partner
Agrees a short quarterly review format.
Sample exchange
Sponsor

What has he said about his team?

Coach

Sessions are confidential, as we agreed. He’s happy to share progress with you directly.

Sponsor

Fair enough.

Coach

Shall we set up a review meeting?

Signs it’s working

Confidentiality is protected and the sponsor gets progress information from the client.

Don’t confuse with

S9.3 Three-way meeting with client and sponsor

The three-way meeting is a planned conversation. This is an informal request for content.

S9.3Three-way meeting with client and sponsor
Formal alignment or review meeting with sponsor present
Prepare the client to lead; facilitate goals and observable signs of change
In the room

Formal meeting with the client’s manager. The client may be nervous or guarded.

It might sound like
  • I’m worried about what my boss will say.
  • What should I share?
  • Can you explain it to her?
What’s underneath

Three-way meetings align goals and show progress. The client should lead, the coach facilitates, and the sponsor gives perspective. Preparation matters.

Questions that often open it
  1. What do you want to share in the meeting?
  2. What would your manager notice if this were working?
  3. What do you need from your manager?
  4. How will you handle surprises?
Avoid here

Coach speaking for the client. Revealing session content. Letting the sponsor dominate.

Watch

The client leads. The coach facilitates.

Examples from the field
Example
Before the meeting, the coach helps the client rehearse what to share. In the meeting, the client presents goals, and the boss shares what they would notice changing.
Manager
Rehearses presenting goals to boss.
Executive
Coach asks sponsor what observable changes they would like to see.
Sample exchange
Client

Can you tell him what we’ve been working on?

Coach

I think it’s more powerful coming from you. What do you want to say?

Client

That I’m working on delegation.

Coach

Let’s practise it.

Signs it’s working

The client leads, goals are aligned, and the sponsor knows what progress looks like.

Don’t confuse with

S9.2 Sponsor asks what the client said

A sponsor asking informally is a confidentiality issue. A three-way meeting is a planned alignment.

S9.4Coaching isn’t working
Sessions repeat without progress; frustration on one or both sides
Name it openly; review goals, fit and approach together
In the room

Sessions feel flat. Little progress. Both may feel frustrated.

It might sound like
  • I don’t feel like we’re getting anywhere.
  • It’s fine, I guess.
  • Maybe I’m not coachable.
What’s underneath

Lack of progress is information. The topic, the fit, the timing or the method may be wrong. Naming it openly is better than carrying on politely.

Questions that often open it
  1. How useful are these sessions for you, honestly?
  2. What would make them more useful?
  3. Are we working on the right thing?
  4. What should we change, or stop?
Avoid here

Blaming the client. Pretending it’s fine. Trying harder with the same approach.

Watch

Name it. Don’t just try harder.

Examples from the field
Example
After six sessions, nothing has changed. The coach names it and asks what isn’t working. The client admits the real topic is leaving, not leadership.
Manager
Coach scales usefulness. 3/10. Changing topic doubles it.
Executive
Coaching ends early with a clear review and referral to a mentor.
Sample exchange
Coach

I notice we haven’t moved much. How useful are these sessions for you?

Client

Honestly, not very.

Coach

Thank you. What would make them useful?

Client

Talking about whether I should even stay.

Signs it’s working

Both sides agree on a change: new topic, new approach, or ending.

Don’t confuse with

S8.10 Repeating the same topic session after session

Repeating the same topic is one pattern. Coaching not working is the bigger picture of the engagement.

S9.5Client wants to stop early
Client asks to end the engagement before planned
Respect the choice; reflect on what led to it; harvest the learning
In the room

Cancels or asks to stop. Gives practical reasons. May avoid explaining.

It might sound like
  • I just don’t have the time anymore.
  • I think I’ve got what I need.
  • It’s not you, it’s me.
What’s underneath

Stopping early can be the right choice or an avoidance. The coach respects the decision while inviting reflection on what led to it and what the client has gained.

Questions that often open it
  1. What has led to this decision?
  2. What have you got from our sessions so far?
  3. Is there anything you want to finish before we stop?
  4. What would be most useful in a final session?
Avoid here

Persuading them to stay. Taking it personally. Ending without reflection.

Watch

Respect the decision. Don’t chase.

Examples from the field
Example
A client wants to stop after three sessions. The coach asks what led to it. The client admits the topic got too close. They agree a final session to harvest learning.
Busy executive
Agrees a shorter final session to harvest progress.
Client
Admits topic was uncomfortable; chooses to continue with a new contract.
Sample exchange
Client

I think I need to stop coaching.

Coach

That’s your call. What has led to it?

Client

It got harder than I expected.

Coach

Would a final session to pull together what you’ve learned be helpful?

Signs it’s working

The client ends, or continues, by choice, with learning captured.

Don’t confuse with

S9.6 Ending the engagement well

Ending well is planned. Wanting to stop early is unplanned.

S9.6Ending the engagement well
Final session or sessions of an engagement
Harvest learning; celebrate progress; plan how to continue without the coach
In the room

Final sessions. Reflection, gratitude, possibly anxiety about continuing alone.

It might sound like
  • I’m not sure I can keep it up without these sessions.
  • I’ve learned so much.
  • Can we do one more?
What’s underneath

Endings matter. A good ending helps the client own their progress, plan how to keep it going and leave with confidence rather than dependency.

Questions that often open it
  1. What has changed since we started?
  2. What are you most proud of?
  3. What will help you keep going?
  4. What would your future self say to you now?
Avoid here

Ending abruptly. Adding new topics at the last minute. Fostering dependency.

Watch

End with ownership, not dependency.

Examples from the field
Example
In the last session, the client reviews their goals, names three key learnings, and writes a letter from their future self to keep.
Leader
Reviews 360 before and after to see change.
Manager
Builds a monthly self-review to replace coaching.
Sample exchange
Client

I’m worried I’ll slip back.

Coach

What will help you keep going?

Client

A monthly review with myself.

Coach

Let’s design it now.

Signs it’s working

The client owns their progress and has a plan to continue.

Don’t confuse with

S8.12 Big insight just landed — needs integration

Insight just landed is a moment. Ending well is the close of the whole engagement.

S9.7Repeated cancellations or no-shows
Sessions keep being cancelled or missed
Name the pattern without blame; re-contract
In the room

Missed sessions, last-minute cancellations, apologetic messages.

It might sound like
  • Sorry, something urgent came up.
  • I’ve been so busy.
  • Can we move it again?
What’s underneath

Repeated cancellations are information: about priority, avoidance, workload, or fit. Naming the pattern, without blame, helps the client decide what they want.

Questions that often open it
  1. I notice we’ve missed a few sessions. What’s going on?
  2. How much of a priority is this for you right now?
  3. What would make the sessions easier to keep?
  4. Should we change the format or timing?
Avoid here

Ignoring it. Getting annoyed. Making assumptions.

Watch

It’s information, not an insult.

Examples from the field
Example
A client cancels three times. The coach names the pattern kindly. The client admits the sessions feel like another obligation. They change frequency and focus.
Executive
Changes to shorter, monthly sessions.
Manager
Admits avoidance of a hard topic; addresses it.
Sample exchange
Coach

We’ve missed three sessions. What’s going on for you?

Client

I’m swamped, and coaching feels like extra work.

Coach

What would make it feel useful rather than extra?

Client

Shorter sessions, and only when I have a real topic.

Signs it’s working

The client re-commits or changes the arrangement by choice.

Don’t confuse with

S9.5 Client wants to stop early

Wanting to stop early is an explicit request. Cancellations may be an unspoken one.

S9.8Remote session: camera off, distracted or multitasking
Client distracted or unseen in remote sessions
Name it; agree remote norms; help them arrive
In the room

Camera off, typing sounds, delayed answers. Short replies.

It might sound like
  • Sorry, just finishing an email.
  • My camera’s not working.
  • Can you repeat that?
What’s underneath

Remote coaching needs agreed norms. Distraction may be workload, avoidance or connection problems. Naming it and agreeing what works helps the session be useful.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would help you be fully here for this time?
  2. Would you like to turn your camera on, or is it better off today?
  3. What’s competing for your attention?
  4. Shall we take a minute to settle in?
Avoid here

Ignoring it. Getting irritated. Assuming bad faith.

Watch

Agree norms upfront; name drift kindly.

Examples from the field
Example
A client keeps checking email during sessions. The coach names it and asks what would help them be present. They agree to start each session with two minutes of settling.
Manager
Agrees to close email during sessions.
Executive
Prefers camera off; agrees to voice-only with check-ins.
Sample exchange
Coach

I can hear typing. What would help you be fully here?

Client

Sorry, I’ll close my inbox.

Coach

Shall we take a minute to settle?

Client

Yes, please.

Signs it’s working

The client is present and the session is useful.

Don’t confuse with

S7.28 Cross-cultural / remote / hybrid friction

Remote friction with colleagues is a work topic. This is about the coaching session itself.

S9.9Team session: one voice dominates
Team coaching; one person fills the space
Structure turn-taking; widen perspectives; use spatial mapping
In the room

One person speaks most. Others go quiet. The team defers to them.

It might sound like
  • Let me just add one more thing…
  • I think what we all mean is…
  • (silence from others)
What’s underneath

Dominance may be habit, status or anxiety. Others’ silence may be agreement, fear or disengagement. The team coach balances voices without shaming anyone.

Questions that often open it
  1. Let’s hear from everyone. What’s your view?
  2. Who sees it differently?
  3. What hasn’t been said yet?
  4. Where would each of you stand on this?
Avoid here

Ignoring it. Publicly shutting the person down. Letting the session become a monologue.

Watch

Balance voices without shaming anyone.

Examples from the field
Example
In a leadership team session, the CEO answers every question. The coach uses a round where each person speaks in turn, then a spatial map where each person places themselves.
Leadership team
Rounds and sticky notes reveal hidden views.
Project team
Constellation shows the quiet members feel left out.
Sample exchange
Coach

Let’s go round the room. One minute each.

Team member

Actually, I see it differently.

Coach

Thank you. What do others think?

Team member

I agree with that.

Signs it’s working

All voices are heard and the team sees a wider range of views.

Don’t confuse with

S8.15 Client is performing leadership rather than exploring

Performing leadership is one person’s defence. This is a team dynamic.

S9.10Team avoids the real conflict
Team tension that no one names openly
Make it safe to name; map it as a polarity or pattern, not a personal attack
In the room

Polite agreement. Tension under the surface. Side conversations after the meeting.

It might sound like
  • We’re all aligned.
  • Let’s take that offline.
  • (eye rolls, silence)
What’s underneath

Avoided conflict doesn’t go away; it moves to corridors and email. The team coach makes it safe enough to name, often by mapping tensions as polarities or patterns rather than personal attacks.

Questions that often open it
  1. What’s the conversation we’re not having?
  2. What do each of you care about here?
  3. What’s the tension between these two goods?
  4. What would help us talk about it openly?
Avoid here

Forcing confrontation. Taking sides. Pretending all is fine.

Watch

Make it safe, not forced.

Examples from the field
Example
A team says it agrees on priorities, but projects keep stalling. The coach maps the speed vs quality polarity. Both sides see their concern is valid and agree on a way to manage it.
Sales and product teams
Drama triangle shows each blames the other. They agree a shared goal.
Leadership team
Positive intent: each side protecting something important.
Sample exchange
Coach

I sense there’s a conversation we’re not having. What is it?

Team member

(pause) We disagree on priorities.

Coach

Thank you. What does each side care about?

Team member

Speed. And quality.

Signs it’s working

The conflict is named safely and the team agrees how to manage it.

Don’t confuse with

S7.4 Conflict-avoidant

Conflict-avoidant is an individual style. This is a team-level pattern.

S9.11Team blames another team (silos)
Team describes another team as the problem
Map the system both teams sit in; find the team’s own part and one shared step
In the room

“Sales never…”, “Ops always…”. Energy goes into describing the other team. Little talk of their own part.

It might sound like
  • Sales never tell us anything.
  • It’s always ops who drop the ball.
  • We’d be fine if it weren’t for them.
What’s underneath

Silos usually come from structure, goals and incentives, not bad people. Blame protects the team’s identity but blocks shared problem-solving. The coach widens the lens to the whole system and helps the team see its own part without shaming it.

Questions that often open it
  1. What would the other team say about you?
  2. What in how we’re set up makes this keep happening?
  3. What part of this is ours to change?
  4. What’s one thing we could do together?
Avoid here

Joining the blame. Lecturing about collaboration. Coaching only the team in the room as if the other team doesn’t exist.

Watch

Widen to the system; don’t take sides.

Examples from the field
Example
A product team blames sales for over-promising. A systemic map shows both teams are rewarded on different targets. The team proposes one shared metric and a joint fortnightly review.
Hospital wards
Night and day shifts blame each other for handover errors. A joint handover redesign replaces the complaints.
Finance and marketing
Each sees the other as the blocker. A shared planning calendar starts the repair.
Sample exchange
Team member

Marketing just ignores our deadlines.

Coach

What would marketing say about your team?

Team member

(pause) That we change the brief late.

Coach

So what could both teams change?

Signs it’s working

The team talks about the system and its own part, and proposes a joint step.

Don’t confuse with

S9.10 Team avoids the real conflict

Avoiding conflict keeps tension hidden inside a team. Silo blame points it outwards at another team.

S9.12New or re-formed team with unclear roles
Team is new or changed; roles and agreements are unclear
Contract at team level: purpose, roles, decision rights, ways of working
In the room

Overlapping work, gaps no one owns, polite confusion, people waiting for someone else to decide.

It might sound like
  • I thought you were doing that.
  • Who actually decides this?
  • We’re all a bit unsure who does what.
What’s underneath

New teams need explicit agreements about purpose, roles and ways of working. Without them, people fill gaps based on old habits, and friction appears as personal conflict. Contracting at team level is the work.

Questions that often open it
  1. What is this team for?
  2. Who owns what, and where do we overlap?
  3. How will we make decisions?
  4. How will we know we’re working well?
Avoid here

Jumping to team-building games. Letting the leader define everything alone. Treating role confusion as a personality problem.

Watch

Make agreements explicit before friction becomes personal.

Examples from the field
Example
After a merger, two teams become one. The coach runs a session where each person maps what they think they own. Gaps and overlaps become visible, and the team writes a one-page charter.
Project team
Roles mapped on a whiteboard; three gaps found and assigned.
New leadership team
Agrees decision rights for budget, hiring and priorities.
Sample exchange
Team member

I assumed that was yours.

Coach

Let’s map it. Who thinks they own this?

Team member

(two hands go up)

Coach

Good — that’s exactly what we need to sort out.

Signs it’s working

The team has a written agreement on purpose, roles and decisions, and refers back to it.

Don’t confuse with

S7.23 Unclear expectations

Unclear expectations is one person and their boss. This is a whole team without shared agreements.

S9.13Team after a failure or setback
Team has failed or had a setback; morale and trust are shaken
Blame-free review; find what worked; agree what to change
In the room

Low energy, quiet blame, defensiveness, or “let’s just move on”.

It might sound like
  • We just want to put it behind us.
  • Someone should have caught it.
  • We’re rubbish at launches.
What’s underneath

After a failure, teams tend either to look for someone to blame or to avoid the subject. Both waste the learning. A blame-free review that also finds what went well helps the team recover confidence and improve.

Questions that often open it
  1. What happened, step by step?
  2. What did we learn?
  3. What went well that we want to keep?
  4. What will we do differently next time?
Avoid here

A blame hunt. Skipping the review. Forced positivity.

Watch

Learning, not blame. Find what worked too.

Examples from the field
Example
A product launch fails. The coach runs a review in three parts: what happened, what we learned, what we’d keep. The team leaves with two process changes and renewed confidence.
Sales team
Missed target. Review finds a pricing issue and a strong client-care process to keep.
Research team
Failed grant. Reframe as feedback; resubmission plan agreed.
Sample exchange
Team member

Let’s not dwell on it.

Coach

What’s one thing we learned that’s worth keeping?

Team member

We worked really well together under pressure.

Coach

And what would we change?

Signs it’s working

The team names lessons and strengths, agrees changes, and moves on with confidence.

Don’t confuse with

S2.10 Disappointed after a setback

Disappointed after a setback is an individual. This is a team recovering together.

Phrase finder: what the client says

Start from the words you hear. Type part of what the client said and jump to the situations it most often points to. There are 540 phrases here. Remember they are clues, not diagnoses: the same words can mean different things in different rooms.

The coach’s inner game

Everything above describes the client's material — the topic, its emotional weather, the frame around it, the system it sits inside. This part turns the same rigor onto the other person in the room. The coach's own nervous system, ego, and attention are not neutral instruments standing outside the work; they are part of what the client is responding to, moment by moment, whether either person names it or not. A brilliant question asked from an anxious, fix-it energy lands differently than the same question asked from settled curiosity — often so differently that it stops being the same question at all.

The five practices gathered here are not techniques to use on a client. They are disciplines a coach practices on themselves, in real time, during the session: noticing the pull to fix before it turns into a rescued client; holding a silence a few seconds longer than feels comfortable, because the client's most honest sentence often arrives right after the first, rehearsed one; offering a strong intuitive hunch as a question the client can wave off, not a verdict they have to accept; naming a stuck, circling loop out loud without exasperation; and offering an explicit, honest choice between digging deeper and moving to action, rather than quietly deciding for the client which one they need.

These cards are written as prompts the coach asks themselves, not questions to put to the client — the "what is happening" and "coach move" fields describe an internal state and an internal correction. Read them as a mirror for supervision and self-reflection between sessions, not as another script to deploy in the room.

Practice 1

Managing the righting reflex

The momentCoach feels the pull to fix, to demonstrate insight, to supply the clever reframe
The practiceNotice the urge, take one breath, return to curiosity before speaking
Self-check Prompts
  1. What am I trying to prove right now?
  2. Whose need is this question actually serving — mine or theirs?
  3. What would happen if I said nothing for five more seconds?
  4. What is the client already capable of finding without my help?
The righting reflex is often love in a hurry. Slow it down — don't shame yourself for having it.
Practice 2

Strategic silence

The momentA powerful question has just been asked and the room goes quiet
The practiceCount to seven before speaking again — the client's most honest answer often comes after the first, rehearsed one
Self-check Prompts
  1. Has the client actually finished, or have I just filled the gap?
  2. What changed in their face or posture in this silence?
  3. Am I uncomfortable, or are they?
  4. What would this silence say if it could speak?
Anxious coaches narrate through silence. Practice holding it until it feels almost too long.
Practice 3

Intuition with consent

The momentCoach has a strong hunch about what the topic is really about, unconfirmed by anything said directly
The practiceOffer the hunch as a question, not a verdict, and stay unattached to whether it lands
Ways To Offer It
  1. I have a hunch — would you be open to hearing it, even if it's off base?
  2. Does any part of that land, or does none of it fit?
  3. What would you say instead?
  4. What made that resonate, if it did?
Offer once, lightly. If it doesn't land, drop it — don't defend the intuition.
Practice 4

Name the dance (navigating a stuck loop)

The momentCoach and client have circled the same point for several minutes without new movement
The practiceName the pattern out loud, without judgment, and ask what makes this spot so sticky
Questions That Often Open It
  1. I notice we've circled this a few times — what makes this part feel so heavy?
  2. What are we both avoiding by staying here?
  3. What would moving on cost you right now?
  4. What do you need in order to leave this spot?
Naming the loop works only if the coach's tone stays curious, not exasperated.
Practice 5

Offering the pivot

The momentExploration has run its useful course but neither party has named it — the session risks drifting
The practiceOffer an explicit choice between going deeper and moving to action, and let the client choose
Questions That Often Open It
  1. We could keep digging into the root of this, or shift to designing one small experiment — which serves you more right now?
  2. What would going deeper give you that moving to action wouldn't?
  3. What would moving to action give you that more digging wouldn't?
  4. If we only had ten minutes, which would matter more?
Offering the pivot should not be code for the coach's own impatience. Check your motive before asking.

Across the engagement

Each session follows the spine of the hour. The whole engagement has its own shape too, from the first meeting to the evaluation. Most problems at this level are easier to prevent with clear contracting than to repair later.

1

Chemistry and fit

A first meeting to check fit, explain how coaching works, and let the client experience a few minutes of it. Either side can decide not to go ahead.

2

Contracting

Agree goals, logistics, confidentiality and its limits, and the sponsor’s role. If there is a sponsor, this is often a three-way meeting.

3

Goals and baseline

Turn broad goals into two or three observable outcomes. Note where things are now, so progress can be seen later (scaling and stakeholder input both help).

4

Working sessions

Each session has its own contract and follows the spine of the hour. Experiments between sessions carry the work into real life.

5

Mid-point review

Check honestly: is this working? Are we on the right topic? What should change? Stakeholder feedback can help here.

6

Ending

Harvest learning, review the original goals, plan how the client will continue, and close with ownership rather than dependency.

7

Evaluation

Look at change at several levels: how the client found it, what they learned, what they now do differently, and what difference it made at work.

Ethics and professional practice

The essentials, gathered in one place. Several situation cards go deeper: S8.16 Suicidal thoughts or risk disclosed S8.21 Confidentiality clashes with safety or legal duty S7.33 Disclosure of bullying, harassment or discrimination S8.20 Attraction, over-familiarity or boundary pull S9.2 Sponsor asks what the client said

Confidentiality

What the client says is confidential, within agreed limits. Agree those limits at the start: serious risk of harm to the client or others, and legal duties. Share progress with sponsors, never session content, and let the client lead those updates.

Contracting

Be clear about goals, roles, logistics, fees, confidentiality and how coaching will end. Re-contract when the topic, the relationship or the scope changes.

Scope and referral

Coaching is not therapy, medical care, legal or financial advice. Refer when a topic needs other expertise, especially mental health crises, clinical conditions, harassment or legal matters.

Safety

If a client may be at risk of harm, safety comes before the coaching agenda. Ask directly, listen, and help them reach the right support. Follow your safeguarding procedures.

Boundaries

Keep the relationship professional. The coach is responsible for holding boundaries, kindly and clearly, whatever the client does.

Conflicts of interest

Notice and name any conflict, such as coaching two people in the same team, or dual relationships. Decline or adjust when needed.

Competence and supervision

Work within your skills and training. Use regular supervision to reflect on your practice, especially on difficult cases.

Codes of practice

Follow the code of ethics of your professional body and any rules that apply where you work.

Working across cultures

Every method carries cultural assumptions about directness, emotion, hierarchy, silence and the individual. These notes show how some of the most-used methods may need adjusting. They are prompts for curiosity, not rules about any culture: always ask the client what fits for them. See also S8.19 Cultural or identity gap between coach and client and S7.28 Cross-cultural / remote / hybrid friction.

#MethodWhat to adjust
1Contract the topic firstIn some cultures, being very direct about goals early can feel abrupt. Build relationship first, and ask what a useful conversation would look like for them.
7Slow down: reflect, pause, follow heatSilence means different things across cultures. In some it is respectful thinking time; in others it signals discomfort or disagreement. Ask, rather than assume.
2Expand the topicQuestions about feelings may feel intrusive where emotions are not usually discussed at work. Start with impact and observable effects, then invite feeling if the client is comfortable.
10Question the topic itself (assumptions)Challenging a belief directly can cause loss of face in some contexts. Use softer forms: “Some people might see it as…”
12ReframeReframes that centre individual choice may fit less well where decisions are collective or family-based. Include the wider group in the frame.
15Positive intent reframeGenerally well received across cultures, because it preserves dignity. Useful when face-saving matters.
16Systemic reframeOften fits well in collectivist cultures, where people already think in terms of family, team and community.
21Imagine a preferred futureSome people find it unusual or even presumptuous to describe a wanted future in detail. Start smaller and closer in time.
36Generate options then one experimentIn hierarchical cultures, an experiment may need permission or a sponsor. Plan who needs to be involved.
42Feedforward and stakeholder loopAsking peers or seniors for suggestions may be unusual or uncomfortable in some cultures. Agree the most natural way to ask.
8Evoke change talkThe ruler question (0–10) may feel strange to some clients. Use words instead of numbers if needed.
32Centre and groundBody-based practices can feel too personal in some professional contexts. Offer them lightly, explain why, and accept no.

Practice

Spot the situation: practice exercises

Read each short scenario and decide for yourself before opening the answer: what situation is this, what would you try first, and what would you avoid?

1“We already covered this”In session four, your client rolls her eyes when delegation comes up again: “I know, I know. We’ve done this.”Which situation is this, what would you try first, and what should you avoid?Show suggested answer

S1.21 Comparing this to last time. Honour that she knows it, then ask what is different about it now, or what made last month’s insight hard to live. Avoid repeating the same delegation exercise or defending the topic.

2Seven-minute sentenceA client talks without pausing about a reorg, the budget, two colleagues and a deadline, getting faster as he goes.What is happening, and what is your first move?Show suggested answer

S1.16 Talking very fast. Slow your own pace, invite one breath, and ask for the headline in one sentence. Avoid matching his speed or asking “and what else?”

3The polite yesYour client agrees with every suggestion, nods a lot, and never disagrees. The sessions feel pleasant and empty.Which situation, and what would you try?Show suggested answer

S8.4 False harmony. Invite disagreement directly: “Where don’t you agree with me?” Look for the place they don’t buy it. Avoid more suggestions.

4After the promotionA newly promoted director says, “I got the job I wanted for ten years, and I feel nothing.”Which situation, and what should you avoid?Show suggested answer

S6.3 Arrival fallacy. Avoid immediately setting a bigger goal. Explore what she hoped the role would give her, and what needs beyond achievement matter now.

5Either/or“Either I confront my boss in the next meeting, or I just accept it forever.”What is the pattern, and which method helps?Show suggested answer

S3.1 Binary thinking. Invent options in between (Method 36), or if it is an ongoing tension rather than a one-off choice, use a polarity map (Method 18).

6Quiet hintNear the end of a session, a client says quietly, “Some days I wonder if anyone would notice if I wasn’t around.”What do you do?Show suggested answer

S8.16. Stop the coaching agenda. Ask directly and calmly whether they are having thoughts of ending their life. Listen, take it seriously, and help them connect with professional support before you end. Follow your contract and safeguarding procedures, and take it to supervision.

7Ten projectsA founder arrives buzzing after a great quarter, with ten new initiatives and very little sleep.Which situation, and what is your role?Show suggested answer

S2.15 Over-excited planning. Be the ballast, not the cheerleader. Ask which one they’d keep for 30 days, and run a quick pre-mortem on scope. Avoid matching the high or shaming it.

8Yes, butEvery option you explore gets a “yes, but…” and a reason it won’t work.What might be underneath, and what could you try?Show suggested answer

S4.5 No ownership / yes but. It may be a clean no in disguise or a hidden fear. Name the pattern and ask what a clean no would sound like, or use Evoke change talk (Method 8) to draw out their own reasons rather than offering more options.

Self-assessment

Rate your confidence with each method. Your answers stay only in this browser. The summary suggests where to focus next.

Rate a few methods to see your summary.

Open

1 · Contract the topic first
2 · Expand the topic
3 · And what else?
4 · Scale the topic
5 · Exceptions and resources
8 · Evoke change talk
9 · Spot strengths in action

Shift the Frame

12 · Reframe
13 · Externalize the problem
14 · Parts work / empty chair
15 · Positive intent reframe
16 · Systemic reframe
17 · Immunity to change map
18 · Polarity map
19 · Map the drama triangle
20 · Defuse from the thought

Move in Time

22 · Miracle question
24 · Two futures / two videos
26 · Pre-mortem
27 · Walk the timeline

Precise Inquiry

28 · Clean language
29 · The question cube
30 · The third entity
31 · Metaphor, image, body
32 · Centre and ground
33 · Map it in space
34 · Developmental lens

Reflection and supervision prompts

Use these after a session, on your own or with a supervisor. Pick two or three, not all of them.

About the client

  • What situation was I seeing? Was there more than one?
  • What was the client’s energy like at the start, middle and end?
  • What did the client say that was new?

About my choices

  • Which method did I use, and why that one?
  • Where did I change level, and where should I have?
  • Was there a moment I asked the right question at the wrong stage?

About me

  • Where did I feel the pull to fix, impress or rescue?
  • When did I fill a silence that might have been working?
  • What was I feeling that might belong to the client’s system?

About next time

  • What would I do differently if I had that moment again?
  • What is one thing I want to practise next session?
  • Is there anything here I need to take to supervision or refer?

Toolkit

Cheat sheets

Four one-page summaries to keep on your desk. The print button prints only these sheets.

The five families

Which kind of move does this moment need?

OpenHas this topic only been seen from one angle?Contract the topic first, Expand the topic, And what else?, Scale the topic, Exceptions and resources, Film it / make it observable, Slow down: reflect, pause, follow heat, Evoke change talk, Spot strengths in action
Shift the FrameIs the meaning of undisputed facts locked?Question the topic itself (assumptions), Show alternatives / other perspectives, Reframe, Externalize the problem, Parts work / empty chair, Positive intent reframe, Systemic reframe, Immunity to change map, Polarity map, Map the drama triangle, Defuse from the thought
Move in TimeIs the client standing only inside today’s problem?Imagine a preferred future, Miracle question, Future-self / identity in the future, Two futures / two videos, Temporal reframe (wiser future self), Pre-mortem, Walk the timeline
Precise InquiryHas an ordinary open question stopped producing anything new?Clean language, The question cube, The third entity, Metaphor, image, body, Centre and ground, Map it in space, Developmental lens
Land ItHas enough opened that it must become durable?Who would you need to be?, Generate options then one experiment, Rehearse the hard conversation, Harvest a just-landed insight, Name the loop, Sort control, Appreciative / what is working, Feedforward and stakeholder loop, Reflective writing and letters

The spine of the hour

Where are we in the session?

ContractAgree what this hour is for.Skip it: Two problems solved at once, neither well.
ExploreGet past the rehearsed story.Skip it: The first account gets recycled.
WidenGo beyond the two options they brought.Skip it: A choice that was never really a choice.
FocusNarrow to the real lever.Skip it: A rich chat with no thread to pull.
ForwardOne owned, dated experiment.Skip it: Next week starts from zero.
In the moment: Notice → Choose one family → Ask one question → Wait → Shift level if stuck

The six levels

If nothing new is coming, change altitude, not wording.

Story“What happened?”
Feeling“What’s that like for you?”
Belief“What do you take it to mean?”
Identity“Who are you in this?”
System“What around you keeps this going?”
Experiment“What will you try this week?”

End most sessions at Experiment.

Ten methods to learn first

Method and its core move

  1. 1 Contract the topic first Agree the destination before diving in
  2. 2 Expand the topic Pull impact, pattern, feeling — not more plot
  3. 3 And what else? Repeat until the known list is exhausted
  4. 4 Scale the topic Fog into a number; work +1 only
  5. 7 Slow down: reflect, pause, follow heat Presence as the intervention
  6. 12 Reframe Same facts, different meaning
  7. 21 Imagine a preferred future Destination before options
  8. 36 Generate options then one experiment Widen choices; converge on one owned test
  9. 38 Harvest a just-landed insight Stop and anchor; don’t keep questioning
  10. 40 Sort control Mine / ours / not mine, then one clean move

Follow the energy in the room, not this page.

Templates

Checklists and agendas you can copy into your own notes.

Engagement contracting checklist

  1. What does the client want from coaching, in their own words?
  2. What does the sponsor want, and where do the two overlap?
  3. How many sessions, how often, how long, where and how (in person or remote)?
  4. What is confidential, and what are the limits (risk of harm, legal duties)?
  5. What will be shared with the sponsor, by whom, and how?
  6. How will we know coaching is working? What will be different?
  7. How will we review progress, and when?
  8. What happens if a session is cancelled or missed?
  9. What are the coach’s and client’s responsibilities?
  10. How will we end?

Session contracting (start of each session)

  1. What do you want to work on today?
  2. What would make this session useful?
  3. Why does this matter now?
  4. How will we know we’ve got there?
  5. Anything from last time you want to pick up?

Session notes

  1. Date and session number
  2. Topic and session contract
  3. Situations noticed
  4. Methods used and how they landed
  5. Key insights in the client’s own words
  6. Experiment agreed (what, when, how they’ll know)
  7. For next time
  8. For supervision (my own reflections)

Three-way meeting agenda

  1. Purpose of the meeting and confidentiality reminder (coach)
  2. Client shares goals or progress in their own words
  3. Sponsor shares what they would notice changing
  4. Agree two or three observable signs of success
  5. Agree how progress will be shared from now on
  6. Next review date

End-of-engagement review

  1. Revisit the original goals: what has changed?
  2. What evidence do you and others see?
  3. What are you most proud of?
  4. What helped most in the coaching?
  5. What will keep the change going without the coach?
  6. What would you do if you started slipping?
  7. Anything left unfinished, and where it should go next?

Quick reference: all 43 methods at a glance

#MethodFamilyCore move
1Contract the topic firstOpenAgree the destination before diving in
2Expand the topicOpenPull impact, pattern, feeling — not more plot
3And what else?OpenRepeat until the known list is exhausted
4Scale the topicOpenFog into a number; work +1 only
5Exceptions and resourcesOpenFind when it’s less true; do more of that
6Film it / make it observableOpenTurn slogans into a camera shot
7Slow down: reflect, pause, follow heatOpenPresence as the intervention
8Evoke change talk OpenDraw out their own reasons for change; don’t argue for it
9Spot strengths in action OpenName the strengths already at work, then aim them at the problem
10Question the topic itself (assumptions)Shift the FrameSocratic challenge of the story
11Show alternatives / other perspectivesShift the FrameOffer lenses without attachment
12ReframeShift the FrameSame facts, different meaning
13Externalize the problemShift the FrameSeparate person from pattern
14Parts work / empty chairShift the FrameVoice both inner pulls; find shared care
15Positive intent reframeShift the FrameFind the protective purpose first
16Systemic reframeShift the FrameWiden from person to system
17Immunity to change map Shift the FrameFind the hidden commitment that keeps a sincere goal from moving
18Polarity map Shift the FrameManage an ongoing tension instead of trying to solve it
19Map the drama triangle Shift the FrameSpot the Victim–Rescuer–Persecutor roles; step into a healthier stance
20Defuse from the thought Shift the FrameHold the thought lightly; act on values, not on the thought
21Imagine a preferred futureMove in TimeDestination before options
22Miracle questionMove in TimeOvernight resolution; hunt for first signs
23Future-self / identity in the futureMove in TimeVisit who they’d be, having handled this well
24Two futures / two videosMove in TimeMake both futures vivid; choose from experience
25Temporal reframe (wiser future self)Move in TimeBorrow distance from an older self
26Pre-mortemMove in TimeImagine failure; work backward to causes
27Walk the timeline Move in TimeLay the story out in time to see the turning points and what carries forward
28Clean languagePrecise InquiryAsk about the client’s exact word only
29The question cubePrecise InquiryRotate purpose, perspective, time, action, depth
30The third entityPrecise InquiryGive the topic its own seat and voice
31Metaphor, image, bodyPrecise InquiryGo sideways through image or sensation
32Centre and ground Precise InquiryWork with breath, posture and sensation to change the state, then the conversation
33Map it in space Precise InquiryPlace the people and parts of a system in space to see the relationships
34Developmental lens Precise InquiryHelp what they’re run by become something they can look at
35Who would you need to be?Land ItIdentity-in-action, paired with one act
36Generate options then one experimentLand ItWiden choices; converge on one owned test
37Rehearse the hard conversationLand ItPurpose, first sentence, live practice
38Harvest a just-landed insightLand ItStop and anchor; don’t keep questioning
39Name the loopLand ItChange the level: identity, system, experiment, ending
40Sort controlLand ItMine / ours / not mine, then one clean move
41Appreciative / what is workingLand ItDiscover life-giving factors; do more of them
42Feedforward and stakeholder loop Land ItAsk stakeholders for future suggestions and check in regularly on progress
43Reflective writing and letters Land ItPut it on paper: letters, logs and notes that carry the work between sessions

Quick reference: all 180 situations at a glance

Every situation on one line: what is happening, the recommended coach move, and the methods that handle it. Click a situation to open its full card, or a number to jump to the method. Hover over a number to see the method’s name.

CodeSituationWhat is happeningCoach moveMethods
S1 How the topic arrives 21 situations
S1.1Telling a rehearsed storyFluent narrative, same phrases, little new language, low emotionExpand: “What else?” / impact / feeling235673139
S1.2Stuck in the problemProblem trance, more analysis of what is wrong, little picture of wanted lifePreferred future / miracle / visualization45621222324
S1.3Certain their view is the only oneAbsolute language, “obviously”, no curiosity about other readingsPerspective shift / reframe / assumptions10111216
S1.4Vague“Things feel off”, “leadership”, “balance” with no pictureScaling / “What would we see if we filmed it?”6222835
S1.5OverwhelmedToo much at once, pressure, no footholdExceptions, resources, +1 on the scale145740
S1.6IntellectualizingModels, analysis, “interestingly”, little felt experienceBody, emotion, metaphor, silence6714283138
S1.7Ready to moveForward energy, asks for next step, new language already appearingOptions, experiments, who they would need to be435363738
S1.8Story-looping / circling the same plotRepeats events, more detail, no new insight, time passingStop the plot. Move to meaning, pattern, or wanted future14213539
S1.9Skimming / staying on the surfaceShort answers, “it’s fine”, jumps topics, jokes awaySlow down. One thread. Reflect + silence. Invite the unsaid127
S1.10Dumping everything at once / multiple topicsLong list, urgency, no priority, breathlessContract. Choose the thread with the most energy140
S1.11Over-specific / lost in detailNames, dates, emails, who said whatZoom out to pattern, purpose, and what they want instead2639
S1.12Bringing someone else’s agenda“My boss said I should…”, partner booked them, HR sent themSeparate assigned topic from their topic. Restore ownership163540
S1.13Avoiding the real topicSafe issue up front, energy elsewhere, late-session revealFollow energy, not the official title. Name the mismatch12714
S1.14First time saying it out loudHesitation, “this may sound silly”, long pause before the sentenceSafety first. Witness. Do not rush to fix or reframe17133538
S1.15Confidential / shame-tinged topicLowered voice, looking away, moral languageNormalize, bound confidentiality, go at their pace, separate person from act13141540
S1.16Talking very fast / flooding with wordsNo pauses, stacked clauses, little breathPace down. Reflect one piece. Ask for the headline173132
S1.17Very little language / “I don’t know”Shrugging, one-word answers, blank lookOffer structure: scale, image, guess, body, either/or5631
S1.18Humor as deflectionJokes at the exact moment of heat, self-mockerySmile with them, then return to the moment before the joke71431
S1.19Jumping straight to solutionsAction list before the topic is understoodPause action. Check if the problem is the real problem17102126
S1.20Wanting a diagnosis or label“What’s wrong with me?”, “Am I a bad leader?”Stay descriptive, not diagnostic. Separate identity from pattern51335
S1.21Comparing this to last time / “we already covered this”Impatience, “I know this”, cynicismHonor the known. Ask what is new in this version14293839
S2 Inner weather 17 situations
S2.1Emotionally flooded / activatedTears, shaking voice, heat, can’t finish sentencesSafety, presence, breath, smaller slice. No big future questions yet73238
S2.2Numb / flat / shutdownMonotone, “whatever”, low energy, no chargeGentle sensory/body, tiny scales, exception, warmth without pressure2531
S2.3Angry / blaming / righteous heatOther-focus, injustice language, clenched jawValidate the heat, then separate fact / interpretation / want71011193740
S2.4Anxious / catastrophizingWhat-if chains, worst-case movies, body tensionPresent facts vs forecast. Scale likelihood. Small next experiment62030
S2.5Ashamed / self-attacking“I’m such an idiot”, collapsing postureSeparate person from behavior. Compassion without skipping learning13
S2.6Guilty / over-responsibleShould have, my fault, I ruined itSort responsibility: mine / ours / not mine. Repair vs rumination121640
S2.7Afraid of being seen / visibility anxietyAvoids stage, meetings, credit, speakingFuture-self who can be seen. Tiny exposure. Identity vs skill152335
S2.8Grief / loss mixed into a work topicRole loss, champion left, identity ending, eyes wet when “professional”Name the loss. Allow a beat. Then ask what wants to be carried forward7233043
S2.9Hopeful / lit up for the first timeEnergy rise, new language, smile, leaning inHarvest it. Make it specific. Lock a small embodiment63538
S2.10Disappointed after a setbackDeflation after effort, “why bother”Acknowledge the hit. Separate event from identity. Recover exceptions59132241
S2.11Embarrassed after a public missReplay of meeting, heat in face, reputation fearNormalize the human moment. Extract one learning. Design repair if needed37
S2.12Lonely in the role / “no one gets it”Isolation, peer gap, can’t talk at home or workName the isolation. Build a support design, not only inner work116
S2.13Resentful / bitterKept score, “after all I did”, tightnessFind the unmet contract. Turn resentment into a request or a boundary1243740
S2.14Envious / comparingTheir title, their ease, social proofUse envy as a compass: what does it point to that they want?35
S2.15Over-excited / manic planningHuge vision, no sleep, ten projectsChannel the energy. Sequence. Risk-check without killing it1122526
S2.16Burned out / depletedCynicism, exhaustion, Sunday dread, numbness + irritabilityEnergy before strategy. Recovery design. Reduce load, don’t add homework53240
S2.17Afraid of hope / waiting for the other shoeWon’t celebrate, discounts winsExplore the protective logic of not hoping. Tiny allowed hope12152538
S3 The mind’s frame 16 situations
S3.1All-or-nothing / binary thinkingSuccess or failure, stay or explode, good or weakInsert the middle. Scale. Third options141824
S3.2Catastrophic forecast as factFuture spoken in present tense as doomTime-stamp the fear. Probability. Coping even if1020
S3.3Mind-reading others“They think I’m…”, no dataSeparate observation from story. What was actually said or done37
S3.4Over-generalizing from one event“I always”, “this always happens”Particularize. Find exceptions. Name the rule they built5
S3.5Should / must / have-to languageDuty voice, little want-languageTranslate should → want / value / fear / someone else’s voice114
S3.6Fixed-mindset identity claims“That’s just how I am”, “I’m not a people person”Historicize the belief. Hold counter-evidence. Experiment identity5153435
S3.7Complexifying / adding layers to stay safeMore frameworks, more stakeholders, never a decisionSimplify to the real choice. Time-box complexity129
S3.8Simplifying too fast / slogans“I just need to be more confident”Unpack the slogan into situations, skills, beliefs635
S3.9Rumination / same thoughts on repeatCircular why, no new dataShift why → what next / what for. Time-box the rumination141520303943
S3.10Confirmation-seekingLooks for evidence they are right or doomedAsk for disconfirming data on purpose511
S3.11Abstract values with no behavior“Integrity”, “excellence” as fogOperationalize. Film the value on a Tuesday6
S3.12Data-only / feeling-blindMetrics, slides, no human fieldAdd stakeholder experience, body, relationship cost1631
S3.13Feeling-only / no structureMood as the only compassAdd facts, scale, experiment, time4
S3.14Past-as-prisonOrigin story explains and excuses everything nowHonor origin. Ask what the adult can choose now12252735
S3.15Future-as-fantasy without stepsBeautiful vision, no next TuesdaySensory future, then reverse-engineer 7 days2123
S3.16Nostalgia / golden past“It used to be better”Harvest what was living then. Recreate the quality, not the era527
S4 Agency and ownership 12 situations
S4.1Victim stance / it’s all themThey, the system, luck, no agency languageValidate constraint. Find the 5–20% they can move. Request vs complaint161940
S4.2Hero / I must fix everyoneOver-functioning, no delegation, exhaustion prideReturn work to its owner. Cost of heroics. Team as system16193540
S4.3Rescuer of the team / parent in the workplaceProtects people from consequence, buffers the bossAdult-adult. Boundaries. Development vs rescue16193740
S4.4Blaming self for the systemTakes structural problems as personal defectSort person / role / system. Reduce false shame121640
S4.5No ownership / “yes but”Agrees then undoes, external conditions alwaysName the yes-but. Find the hidden loyalty or fear8151740
S4.6Waiting for perfect conditions“Once the reorg / hire / budget…”Act inside constraints. 70% rule. Controllables40
S4.7Wanting permissionLooks to coach, boss, spouse to bless the choiceReturn authority. Practice self-authorization23
S4.8Decision already made but not ownedEnergy is done, words still “considering”Name it. Help them admit the choice and plan the conversation37
S4.9Outsourcing judgment to the coach“Just tell me what you would do”Refuse the expert trap. Offer a perspective only if contracted, without attachment1
S4.10Hiding in “we”Team language when it is an I-issueShift we → I. Personal stance40
S4.11Over-owning other people’s emotionsI made them upset, I must fix their feelingReturn their feelings to them. Clean impact vs imagined impact3740
S4.12External locus dressed as realism“That’s just corporate life”Test which constraints are real, which are assumed5101634
S5 From insight to action 17 situations
S5.1Insight without behavior changeBeautiful ahas, same week as last monthClose the knowing-doing gap. Smaller, scheduled, observable acts1735383943
S5.2Action without insight / busyworkLots of doing, no learning, hamster wheelPause. Meaning. Strategy vs motion172140
S5.3Analysis paralysis / too many optionsPros/cons forever, more researchLimit options to 2–3. Decide by value + reversible test2429
S5.4No options they can see“There is no way”Invent 8 ideas including bad ones. Constraint-busting. Borrow others’ moves32122
S5.5Procrastination / delayStarts Sunday night, avoids the hard blockName the avoided feeling. Shrink the start. Design the first 10 minutes61415
S5.6Perfection delayWon’t ship until flawlessDefine good enough. Audience of one. Version 115
S5.7Starts strong then fadesWeek-1 hero, week-3 ghostDesign environment, identity, review rhythm — not willpower1735
S5.8Sabotages near successPicks a fight, misses the last mile, gets sick before the winName the success-fear. Parts work. What would change if they succeeded141517
S5.9Wants a giant leap onlyAllergic to small steps, “that’s not enough”Link small steps to identity and compounding. Define a bold small2326
S5.10Compliance without buy-inWill do the homework to please youRebuild choice. They design the experiment or there is none836
S5.11Resistance to action / “I’ll think about it”Soft close, no date, no witnessGet specific or name the no. Explore the cost of thinking-about-it836
S5.12Missed the last commitmentDidn’t do it, shame or shrugNo prosecution. Learning review. Redesign, don’t double the load36
S5.13Impatient for a quick fixWants the trick, the script, this weekHonor urgency. Distinguish technique vs identity work. Offer a 7-day test1
S5.14Stuck between option A and BOscillates daily, seeks a signValues, future-self, cost of not choosing, trial period82431
S5.15Stay-or-go decisionJob, role, city, companyTwo-movie method. Non-negotiables. Experiments before the leap if possible82326
S5.16Need to have a difficult conversationAvoids the meeting, writes unsent emailsPurpose, request, opening line, body regulation, rehearsal731353740
S5.17After a win they can’t ownLuck, team, timing — never themHarvest contribution. Evidence log. Identity update593841
S6 Identity and meaning 26 situations
S6.1Fused with the problem (“I am the failure”)Identity language, not behavior languageExternalize the problem. You vs the pattern5132030
S6.2Imposter feelingsWaiting to be found out, over-prepares, discounts praiseEvidence file. Belonging vs competence. Who they are becoming92338
S6.3High achiever crash / arrival fallacy“I got it and I feel nothing”Meaning, next chapter, human needs beyond achievement2122
S6.4“That’s just who I am” as a closed doorPersonality as fateTraits as strategies that once worked15
S6.5Old identity dying (expert → leader, founder → CEO)Grief + incompetence of the new skinName the identity funeral and the apprenticeship116233435
S6.6Worth = productivityRest guilt, weekend collapse, metrics as selfDecouple worth and output. Rest as strategy1225
S6.7Being “too much” or “not enough” — or bothVolume, tone, ambition policedFind the contexts. Recover range. Choose the room16
S6.8Mask vs authentic self at workCode-switch fatigue, professional personaWhat the mask protects. Selective authenticity experiments15
S6.9Comparing to a past self“I used to be sharper / braver”Honor then. Meet now. Different season, different strengths25
S6.10Legacy / last-chapter questionsWhat will I leave, who will I have beenContribution, people, body of work, unfinished conversations122527
S6.11Inner critic running the meetingHarsh voice, pre-emptive attackPersonify the critic. Ask its job. Negotiate airtime1415202530
S6.12Parts in conflictOne part wants the promotion, one wants peaceParts / empty chair. Let both speak. Find a third way1418
S6.13Success would break a loyaltyFamily script, class, culture, “people like us don’t…”Name the loyalty. Grieve it. Design a both/and if possible1417
S6.14First-generation / outsider-in-the-room loadTranslating worlds, extra vigilanceName the extra labor. Resources. Belonging design16
S6.15Values-action gapSays family, lives inboxCalendar audit. One aligned act. Repair6
S6.16Purpose fog / “is this all?”Success without meaningLife chapters, contribution, aliveness clues2122
S6.17Duty vs desireShould-career vs pullBoth voices. Design experiments that honor both where possible1418
S6.18Family expectation vs own goalInvisible stakeholders at the tableName who is in the room. Adult-to-adult with the script1433
S6.19Money vs meaning tensionGolden handcuffs, lifestyle lockNumbers + values. Runway. Enough definition1824
S6.20Rest guilt / always-onPhone in bed, vacation inboxOff-design. Identity beyond usefulness6
S6.21Creativity blockedDry, bored, safePlay, constraints as fuel, permission to make bad work1530
S6.22Midlife / quarter-life / chapter changeTime awareness, identity inventoryPast-future-present deep dive. What to keep / drop / begin122527
S6.23Spiritual / existential edge in a work topicMortality, meaning, faith, emptinessRespect the depth. Don't reduce to a productivity plan21
S6.24Retirement or late-career transitionEnd of career in sight; identity, structure and status about to changeWalk the timeline; find what carries forward; picture a wanted next chapter2123274143
S6.25Neurodivergence shaping how they work (ADHD, autism, dyslexia)Work set up for different brains; strong in some areas, worn out in othersSpot strengths; design the environment and adjustments around how they work best69163640
S6.26Chronic illness or health limits reshaping work (including menopause)Health limits energy or capacity; fear of being judged as unreliableSort control; redesign work around real limits; plan the conversations416323640
S7 Other people and the system 37 situations
S7.1Conflict with a bossWalking on eggs, rage, mind-readingIntent/impact, request, manage-up map, power reality10193740
S7.2Conflict with a peerTerritory, credit, style clashShared purpose, clean requests, third-side view111937
S7.3Difficult direct reportAvoidance or over-controlClear standard, feedback, consequence, development stance637
S7.4Conflict-avoidantKeeps peace, stores residue, surprise explosions laterMicro-truths. Body first. 2-minute version of the conversation7313237
S7.5Conflict-seeking / always the fightIdentity as the one who says itDiscern which fights matter. Tone vs content122535
S7.6People-pleasing frameYes first, resentment laterNeed vs please. Practice a boundaried no1517
S7.7Can’t ask for helpSolo hero, shame about needNormalize interdependence. Script the ask. Start small37
S7.8Can’t receive help / praise / creditDeflects, immediately gives it awayPractice receiving as a skill. 3-second pause3538
S7.9Trust broken — they broke it or it was brokenRepair vs rumination vs exitRepair conversation, amends, new agreement, or clean ending37
S7.10Politics / influence without authorityNo formal power, needs movementStakeholder map, interests, allies, small bets1633
S7.11Managing up poorlySurprises the boss, or hidesBoss-as-client. Cadence, risk flags, their metrics63742
S7.12Friendship or dual relationship at workBlurred lines, leftover personalName the dual hats. Separate roles in the conversation3337
S7.13Feeling unseen / credit stolenHeat + helplessnessVisibility design, documentation, allies, direct conversation3742
S7.14Need to give hard feedbackWrites the speech, never deliversOne behavior, one impact, intention, ask. Rehearse3537
S7.15Received feedback they reject360 sting, “that’s not me”Separate grain from garbage. Impact vs intent1542
S7.16Lonely at the top / no peersCan’t talk inside the companyDesign an outside peer space. What can be said here16
S7.17New leader / first-time managerStill doing the old job, conflict-shyRole contract, let-go list, first conversations13435
S7.18Expert becoming managerStill the smartest doer in the roomFrom answers to questions. Develop others2334
S7.19New boss arrivedLost the old contract, reading the new oneObserve, inquire, renegotiate value11
S7.20Reorg / merger / ambiguityRole fog, rumor mill, freezeStabilize controllables. 30-day purpose. Network1633
S7.21Scope creep / everything is urgentCalendar as crime scenePriorities as values. What to stop. Stakeholder reset40
S7.22Under-resourced / budget / headcountAsked to do more with lessRenegotiate outcomes, not only hours. Tradeoff conversation16
S7.23Unclear expectationsAiming at a moving targetMake the contract explicit. Success criteria1042
S7.24Promotion ambivalenceWant the level, not the lifeTwo futures. Role reality, not the title shine24
S7.25Exit energy / quiet quitting in themselvesDoing the minimum, checked out, still thereTell the truth. Stay fully or leave cleanly. No half-life24
S7.26Organizational values clashIntegrity heat, political costName the clash. Options: influence, bound, leave, choose battles16
S7.27Ethics gray zoneNot illegal, not cleanValues, stakeholders, future-self, counsel23
S7.28Cross-cultural / remote / hybrid frictionMisread tone, time zones, silence as meaningMake norms explicit. Charity of interpretation + clean checkouts11
S7.29High-stakes event coming (board, keynote, review)Performance anxiety + preparation swirlPurpose, audience, state regulation, rehearsal, good-enough structure263237
S7.30Work-life / caregiver / dual-career loadCalendar collision, guilt both waysDesign, not heroics. Negotiated load at home and work1618
S7.31Compensation / raise / negotiation topicWorth, fear, market storyValue case, ask, BATNA, practice the sentence31
S7.32Job search / in-between identityLost title, narrative wobbleStory of contribution, not apology. Experiments, not only applications3935
S7.33Disclosure of bullying, harassment or discriminationClient describes treatment that may be bullying, harassment or discriminationListen and believe; map options and support; refer to formal channels17163740
S7.34Being made redundantRole ended by the organisation; shock, loss and practical pressureAbsorb the shock first; then rebuild the value story; then design next steps5792736
S7.35Having to make others redundantMust deliver redundancies; torn between the organisation and the peopleHold both duties; rehearse clear and humane conversations; care for themselves714183237
S7.36Returning from parental leaveBack from parental leave; new identity, new demands, out of the loopMap the polarity; set clear agreements at work and home1821244042
S7.37Role reshaped or threatened by AI and automationWork changing because of AI or automation; uncertainty about the futureSeparate tasks from value; picture two futures; run small experiments29242636
S8 What happens in the room 21 situations
S8.1Testing the coach / “impress me”Wry, evaluative, “other coaches said…”Stay unhooked. Presence. Contract what would make this useful1
S8.2Wants the coach to be the expert / mentor / parentAdvice hunger, “what would you do?”Name the pull. Offer choice: coaching vs a contracted opinion1
S8.3Defensive when challengedExplains, justifies, tightensSoften. More empathy first. Smaller challenge. Ask permission7
S8.4Agrees with everything (false harmony)Nodding, no friction, no energyInvite disagreement. Look for the place they don’t buy it3
S8.5Intellectual sparring with the coachDebates the model, stays in the headStep out of the tennis match. Go to experience2931
S8.6Silence that is workingThinking face, eyes moving, processingWait. Do not fill. After, harvest38
S8.7Silence that is stuck / freezeBlank, frozen, long and tightOffer a ramp: scale, choice, image, “would it help if…”4
S8.8Transference onto the coach (boss, parent, judge)Extra heat, extra pleasing, extra fightNotice in supervision. Gently name the pattern if useful30
S8.9Coach-pleasing / doing homework for youLooks for gold starReturn the work to their life. They pick the experiment36
S8.10Repeating the same topic session after sessionSame title, same floorName the loop. Change the level: identity, system, experiment, or ending39
S8.11Session energy drops / both get sleepyFog, going in circlesCall it. Stand, breathe, pick a sharper question or close this thread129
S8.12Big insight just landed — needs integrationQuiet, wet eyes, “oh”Stop adding questions. Let it settle. Anchor in body and next hour3843
S8.13Wants therapy from coaching — or vice versaTrauma unfolding, diagnosis talk, or only tactics when grief is hereRe-contract scope. Refer when needed. Stay in present-and-forward if coaching1
S8.14Time pressure in the sessionBig topic at minute 45Don’t open surgery. Contract a slice or park it well1
S8.15Client is performing leadership rather than exploringKeynote in the chair, no crackAsk for the unofficial version. Energy under the polish738
S8.16Suicidal thoughts or risk disclosedClient hints at or states thoughts of ending their lifeStop the coaching agenda; ask directly; listen; connect them to professional help1732
S8.17Signs of substance misuseHints of using alcohol or substances to copeNotice and ask respectfully; evoke their own view; refer if they want help47840
S8.18Client far more senior or powerful than the coachLarge status gap; coach tempted to defer or impressContract for challenge; stay curious and independent13728
S8.19Cultural or identity gap between coach and clientCoach and client differ in culture, identity or experienceName the gap; use the client’s own words; ask, don’t assume171128
S8.20Attraction, over-familiarity or boundary pullRelationship drifting beyond the professional; personal pull on either sideRestate boundaries kindly and clearly; take it to supervision17
S8.21Confidentiality clashes with safety or legal dutyInformation shared may require action beyond the coaching relationshipRevisit the agreed limits; explore the client acting first; seek advice140
S9 The engagement and the team 13 situations
S9.1First session or chemistry meetingFirst meeting; deciding whether to work together and howShow how you work; clarify expectations, confidentiality and fit136821
S9.2Sponsor asks what the client saidSponsor wants information about sessionsRestate the agreement; redirect to client-owned progress updates14042
S9.3Three-way meeting with client and sponsorFormal alignment or review meeting with sponsor presentPrepare the client to lead; facilitate goals and observable signs of change16263742
S9.4Coaching isn’t workingSessions repeat without progress; frustration on one or both sidesName it openly; review goals, fit and approach together14293439
S9.5Client wants to stop earlyClient asks to end the engagement before plannedRespect the choice; reflect on what led to it; harvest the learning17838
S9.6Ending the engagement wellFinal session or sessions of an engagementHarvest learning; celebrate progress; plan how to continue without the coach35384143
S9.7Repeated cancellations or no-showsSessions keep being cancelled or missedName the pattern without blame; re-contract14839
S9.8Remote session: camera off, distracted or multitaskingClient distracted or unseen in remote sessionsName it; agree remote norms; help them arrive1732
S9.9Team session: one voice dominatesTeam coaching; one person fills the spaceStructure turn-taking; widen perspectives; use spatial mapping311293033
S9.10Team avoids the real conflictTeam tension that no one names openlyMake it safe to name; map it as a polarity or pattern, not a personal attack15161819
S9.11Team blames another team (silos)Team describes another team as the problemMap the system both teams sit in; find the team’s own part and one shared step11161933
S9.12New or re-formed team with unclear rolesTeam is new or changed; roles and agreements are unclearContract at team level: purpose, roles, decision rights, ways of working163342
S9.13Team after a failure or setbackTeam has failed or had a setback; morale and trust are shakenBlame-free review; find what worked; agree what to change5123841

Where the methods come from, and further reading

Most methods in this guide have a recognised origin in coaching, therapy or organisational practice. Each method page ends with a short “Where it comes from” note. These books are good next steps.

A note on the explanations in this guide. Phrases such as “the nervous system rejects cognition that arrives too early” are useful ways of describing what experienced coaches notice, not precise scientific findings. Many of the methods have solid research or long practice behind them, but the “How it works” sections mix evidence, theory and craft wisdom. Treat them as working explanations to test in your own practice.

Coaching foundations

  • Coaching for Performance John WhitmoreThe GROW model and the basics of performance coaching.
  • The Coaching Habit Michael Bungay StanierSeven practical questions, including “And what else?”
  • Co-Active Coaching Henry Kimsey-House, Karen Kimsey-House, Phillip Sandahl and Laura WhitworthA widely used model of the coaching relationship.
  • Humble Inquiry Edgar ScheinThe art of asking rather than telling.

Solution-focused and narrative

  • Clues: Investigating Solutions in Brief Therapy Steve de ShazerThe origins of the miracle question, scaling and exceptions.
  • Brief Coaching for Lasting Solutions Insoo Kim Berg and Peter SzabóSolution-focused ideas applied to coaching.
  • Maps of Narrative Practice Michael WhiteExternalizing and re-authoring conversations.

Language, meaning and change

  • Change: Principles of Problem Formation and Problem Resolution Paul Watzlawick, John Weakland and Richard FischThe classic text on reframing.
  • Metaphors in Mind James Lawley and Penny TompkinsClean Language and Symbolic Modelling.
  • Focusing Eugene GendlinWorking with the body’s felt sense.
  • Introducing NLP Joseph O’Connor and John SeymourAn accessible introduction to the NLP techniques used in this guide.

Change, motivation and identity

  • Motivational Interviewing William R. Miller and Stephen RollnickWorking with ambivalence and change talk.
  • Immunity to Change Robert Kegan and Lisa LaheyWhy people don’t change, and how they can.
  • In Over Our Heads Robert KeganAdult development and the subject–object shift.
  • ACT Made Simple Russ HarrisDefusion, values and acceptance.
  • No Bad Parts Richard SchwartzAn accessible introduction to Internal Family Systems.

Systems, teams and tensions

  • Polarity Management Barry JohnsonManaging tensions that can’t be solved once.
  • The Power of TED* David EmeraldA way out of the drama triangle.
  • Appreciative Inquiry David Cooperrider and Diana WhitneyBuilding on what works.
  • Leadership Team Coaching Peter HawkinsCoaching whole teams and their systems.

Decisions, emotions and the coach

  • “Performing a Project Premortem”, Harvard Business Review (2007) Gary KleinThe original description of the pre-mortem.
  • Chatter Ethan KrossSelf-distancing and the inner voice.
  • The Leadership Dojo Richard Strozzi-HecklerSomatic leadership and centring.
  • What Got You Here Won’t Get You There Marshall GoldsmithFeedforward and behavioural change for leaders.
  • Supervision in the Helping Professions Peter Hawkins and Robin ShohetReflective practice and supervision.

What this guide does not cover

No guide covers everything. These thirteen techniques are not covered as methods here, or are covered only in part. Use this section to see where they sit, how close the guide already gets, and where to start from what you have. Six NLP tools are now included as variations inside methods 1, 10, 11, 32, 35 and 36.

13techniques outside the guide
5areas they fall into
4mostly there
6partly there
3mostly absent
3areas that look missing but are covered

Where these techniques sit

Structured modelsWOOPThe FUEL modelSBI feedbackTherapeutic schoolsCognitive Behavioural CoachingThe wider Gestalt toolkitOntological coachingOther NLP techniquesTeams and relationshipDedicated team coaching methodsRapport-building techniquesWellbeingFormal mindfulness practicesA resilience toolkitCoach self-careDirective movesPrescriptive and informative interventionsThis guide43 methods · 180 situations5 families
Mostly therePartly thereMostly absentClick a technique to open its card below.

At a glance

TechniqueAreaHow close the guide getsIn one line
Cognitive Behavioural Coaching (CBC)Therapeutic schoolsPartly thereA structured way to catch, test and rebalance unhelpful thoughts.
The wider Gestalt toolkitTherapeutic schoolsMostly absentAwareness in the here and now, live experiments, unfinished business.
Ontological coachingTherapeutic schoolsPartly thereLanguage, mood and body as one system that shapes a way of being.
Formal mindfulness practicesWellbeingPartly thereTaught practices (breath, body scan, pause) the client uses between sessions.
Prescriptive and informative interventionsDirective movesPartly thereAdvising and informing, two of Heron’s six categories.
Dedicated team coaching methodsTeams and relationshipPartly thereCoaching a whole team as one system.
Rapport-building techniquesTeams and relationshipMostly thereDeliberate ways to build trust and connection.
A resilience toolkitWellbeingMostly thereTools to absorb setbacks and recover faster.
Coach self-careWellbeingMostly absentKeeping the coach well, so presence stays strong.
WOOP (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan)Structured modelsPartly thereFour quick steps from a wish to an if–then plan.
The FUEL modelStructured modelsMostly thereFrame, Understand, Explore, Lay out a plan.
SBI feedback (Situation–Behaviour–Impact)Structured modelsMostly thereA three-part shape for specific, fair feedback.
Other NLP techniquesTherapeutic schoolsMostly absentSwish patterns, submodality work, hypnotic language and phobia techniques.

Technique cards

Each card gives what the technique is, why it sits outside this guide, its benefits, questions to try, and where to start from what you already have here.

Cognitive Behavioural Coaching (CBC)A structured way to catch, test and rebalance unhelpful thoughts.Partly there
What it is

A structured approach drawn from cognitive behavioural therapy. It links events, thoughts, feelings and actions, then tests unhelpful thoughts against evidence and builds more balanced alternatives, often with worksheets such as thought records.

Why it is not in this guide

This guide works with thinking through lighter conversational moves (questioning assumptions, reframing, defusion) rather than a worksheet sequence.

Benefits
  • Gives clients a repeatable self-coaching tool they can use alone
  • Makes thinking traps visible and nameable
  • Strong research base from CBT
  • Useful for performance anxiety, procrastination and self-criticism
Questions to try
  1. What went through your mind just before you felt that?
  2. What evidence supports that thought, and what doesn’t?
  3. What would you tell a colleague who thought this?
  4. What is a more balanced way to see it?
  5. What will you do differently if you hold that view?
The wider Gestalt toolkitAwareness in the here and now, live experiments, unfinished business.Mostly absent
What it is

An awareness-based approach. The coach works with what is happening right now (posture, voice, energy), invites small live experiments, notices what stands out and what fades (figure and ground), and helps finish unfinished business.

Why it is not in this guide

Only the empty chair appears in this guide (methods 14 and 30). The rest of the toolkit needs dedicated training to use safely.

Benefits
  • Brings the client into the present moment
  • Turns insight into felt experience
  • Surfaces what is being avoided
  • Works well with clients who intellectualise
Questions to try
  1. What are you aware of right now, as you say that?
  2. What is your hand doing? Could you let it continue?
  3. What stands out most, and what fades into the background?
  4. What would you like to say that hasn’t been said?
  5. Would you be willing to try a small experiment?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: A Gestalt Coaching Primer — Dorothy Siminovitch
Ontological coachingLanguage, mood and body as one system that shapes a way of being.Partly there
What it is

Sees a person as a “way of being” expressed through language, moods and emotions, and the body. Change one and the others shift. It teaches precise distinctions, such as facts versus assessments, requests, promises and declarations.

Why it is not in this guide

This guide touches identity, body and metaphor in separate methods, but does not teach the full model or its language distinctions.

Benefits
  • Shifts clients at the level of how they show up, not just what they do
  • Gives precise language tools (requests, promises, declarations)
  • Connects mood to what feels possible
  • Links body posture to confidence and presence
Questions to try
  1. What mood are you in when you think about this?
  2. Is that a fact, or your assessment? What grounds it?
  3. What request haven’t you made yet?
  4. What would you need to declare to move forward?
  5. How does your body hold this?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: Coaching to the Human Soul — Alan Sieler
Formal mindfulness practicesTaught practices (breath, body scan, pause) the client uses between sessions.Partly there
What it is

Formal practices such as breath awareness, a body scan or a one-minute mindful pause, taught so the client can use them on their own between sessions. Intuitive-awareness work is related: noticing subtle signals before acting.

Why it is not in this guide

This guide covers presence in the session (method 7) and grounding (method 32), but not structured practices the client takes away.

Benefits
  • Lowers reactivity under pressure
  • Improves attention and focus
  • Helps self-regulation before hard conversations
  • Gives the client a tool they own
Questions to try
  1. Would you be willing to take three slow breaths before we go on?
  2. What do you notice in your body right now, without changing it?
  3. When in your day could a one-minute pause fit?
  4. What happens to the thought when you simply notice it?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: Mindful Coaching — Liz Hall
Prescriptive and informative interventionsAdvising and informing, two of Heron’s six categories.Partly there
What it is

Two of John Heron’s six categories of helping intervention. Prescriptive means advising or directing; informative means giving knowledge or information.

Why it is not in this guide

This guide deliberately stays facilitative: the client finds their own answer. A view is offered only if it is agreed first.

Benefits
  • Speeds things up when the client lacks knowledge
  • Fits mentoring and new-role transitions
  • Honest use of the coach’s real expertise
  • Clear when contracted openly
Questions to try
  1. Would it help if I shared what I’ve seen work elsewhere?
  2. Do you want options from me, or would you rather think it through first?
  3. Here is one view. What fits and what doesn’t?
  4. Now you have that information, what will you do with it?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: Helping the Client — John Heron
Dedicated team coaching methodsCoaching a whole team as one system.Partly there
What it is

Methods for coaching a whole team as one system: team purpose and agreements, stakeholder expectations, group process and team-level constellations.

Why it is not in this guide

This guide is built for one-to-one coaching. Its methods adapt to teams, and five team situations are covered, but there is no method designed for teams alone.

Benefits
  • Works on shared team patterns, not just individuals
  • Builds collective ownership
  • Aligns the team with its stakeholders
  • Makes hidden conflict discussable
Questions to try
  1. What does this team exist to do that no individual could?
  2. Who are your key stakeholders, and what do they need from you?
  3. What do we avoid talking about as a team?
  4. What agreements do we need about how we work?
  5. What will we do differently from Monday?
Rapport-building techniquesDeliberate ways to build trust and connection.Mostly there
What it is

Deliberate techniques for building trust and connection: matching pace and language, attentive listening, checking understanding and agreeing a shared agenda.

Why it is not in this guide

This guide treats rapport as the foundation of the relationship that every method stands on, rather than as a method of its own.

Benefits
  • Clients open up sooner
  • Challenge lands better
  • Strengthens the working alliance, widely seen as central to good outcomes
  • Repairs trust after a misstep
Questions to try
  1. What do you need from me to make this conversation useful?
  2. How would you like me to challenge you, if at all?
  3. What is working in how we work together, and what isn’t?
  4. Did I get that right?
A resilience toolkitTools to absorb setbacks and recover faster.Mostly there
What it is

A set of tools for building capacity to absorb setbacks: noticing how one explains bad events, recovery routines, support networks and realistic optimism.

Why it is not in this guide

The pieces are here (exceptions, strengths, control-sorting, grounding), but spread across methods rather than gathered as one toolkit.

Benefits
  • Helps clients recover faster
  • Reduces burnout risk
  • Turns setbacks into learning
  • Builds confidence for the next challenge
Questions to try
  1. What has helped you recover from a setback before?
  2. What is in your control here, and what isn’t?
  3. Who could you lean on this week?
  4. What would you tell yourself a year from now about this?
  5. What one thing would help you recharge?
Coach self-careKeeping the coach well, so presence stays strong.Mostly absent
What it is

Practices that keep the coach well: managing energy between sessions, limits on workload, processing difficult sessions and having one’s own support.

Why it is not in this guide

This guide focuses on what happens in the session. Self-reflection and supervision are covered; looking after the coach’s own wellbeing is not.

Benefits
  • Sustains presence and quality over time
  • Reduces the risk of burnout and over-involvement
  • Models healthy practice for clients
  • Keeps judgment clear in difficult cases
Questions to try
  1. What am I carrying out of this session?
  2. How full is my diary, and how much recovery is in it?
  3. What do I need to take to supervision?
  4. When did I last do something just for my own energy?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: Supervision in the Helping Professions — Peter Hawkins and Robin Shohet
WOOP (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan)Four quick steps from a wish to an if–then plan.Partly there
What it is

A four-step routine based on Gabriele Oettingen’s research on mental contrasting and if–then plans: name a Wish, picture the best Outcome, name the inner Obstacle, then make a Plan (“If [obstacle], then I will…”).

Why it is not in this guide

This guide has the pre-mortem and one-experiment methods, which plan for obstacles, but not the four-step routine itself.

Benefits
  • Takes only a few minutes
  • Backed by research
  • Turns a wish into a concrete if–then plan
  • Anticipates the inner obstacle, not just outside ones
Questions to try
  1. What is your wish for the next four weeks?
  2. What would be the best outcome? How would it feel?
  3. What in you might get in the way?
  4. If that obstacle shows up, then what will you do?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: Rethinking Positive Thinking — Gabriele Oettingen
The FUEL modelFrame, Understand, Explore, Lay out a plan.Mostly there
What it is

A four-step conversation model from John Zenger and Kathleen Stinnett: Frame the conversation, Understand the current state, Explore the desired state, Lay out a success plan.

Why it is not in this guide

Each stage is covered by methods in this guide, but the model itself is not named.

Benefits
  • Simple structure for managers who coach
  • Keeps the conversation moving towards action
  • Easy to teach and remember
  • Maps neatly onto the spine of the hour
Questions to try
  1. What would you like to get from this conversation?
  2. What is happening now, from your point of view?
  3. What would you like to see instead?
  4. What are the next steps, and when will we check in?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: The Extraordinary Coach — John Zenger and Kathleen Stinnett
SBI feedback (Situation–Behaviour–Impact)A three-part shape for specific, fair feedback.Mostly there
What it is

A three-part feedback structure associated with the Center for Creative Leadership: describe the Situation, the observable Behaviour, and its Impact.

Why it is not in this guide

SBI is never named here, but the move for giving hard feedback follows a similar shape: one behaviour, one impact, intention, ask.

Benefits
  • Keeps feedback specific and fair
  • Avoids judging character
  • Easier for the receiver to hear
  • Easy to rehearse before the real conversation
Questions to try
  1. In what situation did it happen?
  2. What exactly did they do or say? What would a camera have seen?
  3. What was the impact on you, the team or the work?
  4. What do you want to ask for next time?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: Center for Creative Leadership — SBI feedback resources
Other NLP techniquesSwish patterns, submodality work, hypnotic language and phobia techniques.Mostly absent
What it is

NLP (neuro-linguistic programming) was developed by Richard Bandler and John Grinder in the 1970s and is a large set of techniques. Six of its more conversational tools are now included in this guide as variations inside existing methods. Others, such as the swish pattern, submodality changes, the Milton model of hypnotic language and the fast phobia technique, are left out.

Why it is not in this guide

The techniques left out lean towards therapy and hypnosis rather than coaching conversation, and need specific training. Research support for NLP’s core claims is limited, and some ideas, such as reading thinking style from eye movements, have not held up.

Benefits
  • Quick, structured techniques that many coaches find practical
  • A precise vocabulary for how clients picture and talk about experience
  • Work with mental images that drive strong feelings
  • Pairs well with the body and metaphor methods in this guide
Questions to try
  1. When you picture it, is the image near or far, bright or dim, moving or still?
  2. What changes if you make the picture smaller and further away?
  3. What do you say to yourself about it, and in what tone of voice?
  4. How would you like to see it instead?
Bridge from this guide
Learn more: Introducing NLP — Joseph O’Connor and John Seymour

When to look beyond this guide

Signals in the room that one of these techniques may help, and where to start with what is already here.

You notice…ConsiderStart with
The client keeps arguing with the same harsh thoughtCognitive Behavioural Coaching20 · Defuse from the thought 10 · Question the topic itself (assumptions)
The client talks about feelings but seems cut off from them right nowThe wider Gestalt toolkit31 · Metaphor, image, body 7 · Slow down: reflect, pause, follow heat
Their mood seems to decide what feels possibleOntological coaching31 · Metaphor, image, body 34 · Developmental lens
They want a daily practice to stay calm under pressureFormal mindfulness practices32 · Centre and ground
They lack knowledge you genuinely have, and ask for itPrescriptive and informative interventionsS8.2 Wants the coach to be the expert / mentor / parent
A whole team asks to be coached togetherDedicated team coaching methods33 · Map it in space S9.9 Team session: one voice dominates
Trust feels thin and the client stays guardedRapport-building techniques7 · Slow down: reflect, pause, follow heat S9.1 First session or chemistry meeting
Setback after setback, and energy is droppingA resilience toolkit5 · Exceptions and resources S2.16 Burned out / depleted
You leave sessions drained or still carrying the clientCoach self-careThe coach’s inner game
Good intentions, but obstacles keep surprising themWOOP26 · Pre-mortem 36 · Generate options then one experiment
A manager wants a simple model for coaching their teamThe FUEL model1 · Contract the topic first 36 · Generate options then one experiment
They need to give feedback that will landSBI feedbackS7.14 Need to give hard feedback 37 · Rehearse the hard conversation
A vivid mental picture keeps triggering the same strong feelingOther NLP techniques31 · Metaphor, image, body 32 · Centre and ground

Covered elsewhere in this guide. Some areas can look missing but are covered: cross-cultural work in Working across cultures; boundaries and endings in Ethics and professional practice and Across the engagement; coach self-evaluation in The coach’s inner game and Practice and self-assessment.

Questions for your own development

  1. Which of these techniques do my clients most often seem to need?
  2. Where am I already using part of one without naming it?
  3. Which one would add most to my practice in the next six months?
  4. What training or supervision would I need to use it safely?
  5. Which gap matters most for the kind of clients I work with?
  6. How will I tell a client when something is outside my scope?

My favourites and notes

Star any method or situation (look for the ☆ button) and write private notes on method pages. Everything is saved only in this browser on this device.

Nothing saved yet.

Principles to carry

Follow the energy in the room, not this page. Situations overlap. A client can be vague, ashamed, and waiting for permission at once. Choose the doorway with the most life in it.
Simple before structured. The most structured methods (clean language, the question cube, the pre-mortem, the third entity, temporal and systemic reframes) and every inner-game practice are tools for the coach’s own discipline as much as the client’s material. Reach for them once the simpler moves have been tried, not as a way to sound advanced.
Know the edge. This is a coaching reference for ordinary professional situations, not a diagnostic manual and not therapy. If someone is flooded or in clinical distress, regulation and referral come first.